@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

Banks are like power and water utilities. Its not something you cut off in a modern society without very good reasons.

Plenty of people get power or water cut off for non-payment, which falls a long way short of organised crime and terrorism. Plenty of people have credit bad enough that they can only get power with a prepayment meter. The equivalent is a basic bank account which can't be overdrawn (and therefore doesn't come with a cheque book, only a debit card - with the shift to zero floor limits the number of places that debit card can't be used is now quite low). You can't run a business with a basic bank account, and you can't run a business with electricity off a prepayment meter - in both cases this is both against the rules (the social contract that says regulated businesses can't shun dirty poors only extends to consumer services, not business ones) and impractical given the lack of credit.

The vast majority of business debankings are for credit control reasons, both of the "new information means this business is no longer considered creditworthy" and of the "new information means that this business is of a type which we do not bank because we lack the special skills needed to assess its creditworthiness" types.

The level of protection the banking system offers to normies who are victims of dodgy businesses (including but by no means limited to credit card chargebacks) is only possible because the system tries to keep dodgy businesses out.

This is too dank to believe, and I don't believe it, but it is what my Twitter feed wants me to believe, and I'm sharing it on that basis.

The combination of the messages on the cartridges is best explained by Robinson being deep into gamer culture

  • The sequence of arrows is a reference to Helldivers 2
  • "Ciao Bella" can be a number of things, but one of them is a HoI4 meme.
  • "If you read this you are gay" is general chan culture
  • "Notices, bulges what's this" is an online furry culture meme which has also spread into general chan culture

Where does this end up? If Robinson was deep into HoI4 online culture, his browser history will be full of both Wehraboo and Antifa material. And if he got into the chans or the other online cesspools where large number of gamers hang out, then they are going to find all the bad stuff. So the people who want to believe that he was a leftist will find enough evidence to believe that, the people who want to believe he was a groyper will find enough evidence to believe that, and the people (like me) who want to believe that he was just a Thomas Crooks-style very online loser who shot a politician because in the current year it is more memetically badass than shooting up a school will find enough evidence to believe that. So the assassination will become a super-scissor. And, to add insult to injury, a wholesome hobby that I and many other Motteposters enjoy a lot (namely Paradox grand strategy gaming) will become tied in the mind of normies to political violence.

If cancel culture was limited to firing people who celebrated political assassinations

The Deputy Secretary of State, on his official X account, said that "praising, rationalizing, or making light" of Kirk's death was grounds for visa revocation, and encouraged Karens to report wrongthinkers. That goes beyond "firing people who celebrated political assassinations" - it is a much broader category of prohibited wrongthink, as well as being a threat of government action. "Making light" would cover a lot of perfectly normal behaviour.

Wexner owned Victoria’s Secret before he met Epstein. He definitely wasn’t relying on Epstein to procure girls for him - the reverse seems more likely.

Churchill was technically fired for plagiarism and for falsely claiming to be a Native American. The fact that affirmative action fraudsters like Churchill and Warren only get caught and fired if they become politically controversial is an indictment of the system, but his firing was clearly legally justified.

Kirk opposed the civil rights act. Motteposters may not consider that a far-right political view, but normies do.

He was also all-in on Trump's attempt to remain in office despite losing the 2020 election. If you think (as Orwell did and you should, although most people don't) that the main danger of the far right is the same as the main danger of the far left - the threat to democracy and the rule of law - then that makes Kirk (and Trump, and most of MAGA) far-right in the way that matters. That is what I mean by Jan 6th being the ultimate scissor.

PS. If an American publisher were typesetting this post those hyphens would be rendered as em-dashes. (British style is to render parenthetic dashes as en-dashes between spaces, which is why I was so confused by the first few months of the em-dash discourse). Still not a bot.

The other claim is that his friends in the bank intervened when some transactions were flagged (for what, no one really explains) but this only deepens the original question: even if he was guilty of sex crimes, that doesn't imply that his financial dealings weren't in order.

If Epstein was as rich as he claimed to be without any of the wackier conspiracy conspiracies being true, he got the money by embezzling from Les Wexner. If any of the wackier conspiracies were true, he had a lot of foreign income he was being dishonest about the source of.

I personally think that Epstein's finances were above board and he simply wasn't as rich as he claimed to be (his lifestyle was consistent with the amount of money he could have made scummily but legally by charging Wexner 2-and-20 without providing alpha). But if I was the Feds I would have been going over his finances with a fine-tooth comb.

I can't say I've heard of an American movie getting grief for casting non-Americans

There was a fuss about black British actors playing characters who were ADOS blacks in American films - but it isn't clear to me if that was an actual thing or if it was just Samuel L Jackson and his sycophants.

Listen to American music, watch American shows, go see American films - obviously you're going to play American games as well

Games is the software sub-sector where the US is least dominant (Nintendo exists, for example), so this isn't the story.

If the killings are being done by psychos (which, to date, they mostly are) then that doesn't work.

real action basically never happens

I come from a Northern Irish family. I assure you that "real action" can happen if enough people want it to, and that you really shouldn't want it to.

I agree that (absent evidence that Kirk's killer was part of an organised political faction), "real action" is not happening in the USA in 2025

Big Tech now has high but not stupidly high PE ratios (except Tesla) - Apple/Google/Microsoft really are some the most profitable private-sector companies (sorry, Aramco) in history. Both that profit and the expenses (mostly pay and benefits) used to generate it count to US GDP. The fact that almost anyone with a raw IQ above 130 and a willingness to put up with corporate bullshit can learn to code and get a $250k tech job has driven up upper-middle class incomes in the US across the board. And the upper-middle class in California (and other Blue Tribe places which compete with California for mobile talent) pay a fuckton of taxes which secure the loans from the Red Chinese which allow normie-Americans to enjoy a comprehensive welfare state for the old without paying for it.

Software isn't the entirety of why America now has a higher GDP-per-hour-worked than Western Europe, but it is the biggest part of it. My tl;dr for why America won the early 21st century economically would be "America was already dominant in software by 2000, and software ate the world before anyone else could make a serious effort to catch up."

Think of all the sectors hollowed out by competition from Big Tech (most obviously newspapers and B&M retail). In Europe, those sectors have been hollowed out by foreign competition with the same kind of social impact (but on a smaller scale) as the China Shock hollowing out US manufacturing.

And so, goes this narrative, there really is a simple solution to these events: stop talking about them. Kill the meme and you kill the behavior. This obviously wouldn't be easy, between press incentives and an open internet, but I'm confident it would be easier than seizing hundreds of millions of guns.

I agree that this would work, and won't happen. The US has an unusually strong free speech culture as well as an unusually strong gun culture, so I don't think it is necessary easier than keeping guns away from crazies.

Switzerland and Canada both have broadly available long guns, but they don't seem to have many spree killings. I don't know if that this is because they are not exposed to the same mimetic contagion (unlikely in the case of Canada) or if their gun culture is healthier in some way which means that fewer guns are stored in ways where crazies have access to them. (Most school shooters use Dad's insecurely stored gun).

For the Taliban, no. Donald Trump surrendered in 2020 and Biden rather notoriously botched the implementation of the surrender agreement in 2021.

To the extent that Al-Qaeda still exists, the US is still at war with them.

The post-911 AUMF was (although it didn’t use the words, and probably should have done) a declaration of war against Al-Qaeda and the Taliban.

Hope, definitely. Bet, too. There is a reference class here - shootings of political figures by crazies with no participation in organised politics is now a several times per year event. As far as I can see, the only time in the internet news era a political figure in the US was shot at by an actual political opponent was Steve Scalise almost a decade ago.

I would put "Dems fumble an easily winnable election through poor candidate choice" and "Team Trump manage to steal the election" at about 20% and 10% respectively. And "The Trump administration gets less incompetent and thus more popular" has non-zero probability.

The President of the United States was involved in fundraising for the people who engaged in political violence on January 6th.

  • -10

As far as I can tell, there is no other way besides reducing one or more of guns, political polarization, and mental health issues.

If you reduce political polarization, the crazies will just go back to shooting up other targets.

To stop crazies killing people, you need to stop crazies having access to guns. Empirically you can't do this in a society where randos have access to guns - multiple countries have tried, some of them quite hard. This is the fundamental trade-off behind long gun control (handguns are different because they are used in orders of magnitude more homicides). Given how rare psychos shooting people actually is, I think the case for long guns being broadly legal is strong. But if the opponents of gun control are all "Yeah - it's a tradeoff. Thoughts and prayers" when other people's kids are the victims, and "We can't allow 'them' to carry on doing this - when do we start the purges?" when the victim is a sympathetic politician, then I am not going to take them seriously.

If the person who did this turns out to be a sane Democrat or someone with a history of organised far-left activity, then this is very bad news. But right now the way to bet is "psycho with a gun".

I don't think there was any indication the attacker was a conservative who hated them for being liberal. As I recall, it was more like some sort of dispute between friends or possibly lovers.

This was a dirty lie spread by Musk on Twitter. De Pape was delusional due to long-term drug use, but he was sane enough to stand trial, and at all times he continued to maintain that his target had been Nancy Pelosi and he had been trying to kidnap her as part of his delusional far-right political project. His other political activity at the time he did it was mostly watching Qanon and 2020-election-conspiracy material on social media. It looks like he had done an RFK-style left-conspiracy-theorist to right-conspiracy-theorist horseshoe turn at some point between 2014 (when he cancelled his Green Party voter registration) and 2020.

He was not affiliated with any Republican or far-right group, which is why I count him under "the school shooters started shooting politicians" category rather than right-wing political violence.

You're right that we don't know who the killer is or what the motive is. But you have to deliberately ignorant to not think an assassination at an open political event is not political motivated. This is not a passion killing. This is pre-meditated and cold and deliberate. If it was something like a personal grudge, wouldn't you rather shoot someone in a quiet place, such as at night? Why would you choose to assassinate someone in a place where there are thousands of people that could potentially spot you and stop you, unless there was some kind of goal in making a statement?

You could have said the same things about the Trump shooting, and many people did. But it turned out that the shooter was a disgruntled Red Triber with no discernable political motive.

You want to believe that "they" are engaged in a pattern of political violence, and you want it enough not to wait for confirmation where there is an obvious alternative theory that turned out to be correct last time. Why do you want to believe this? The world where the people who shoot politicians are crazies is a better, safer, happier one.

When we had actual large-scale political violence, like the troubles in Northern Ireland, or medium-scale political violence like the Days of Rage in the US, the people committing the violence looked very different to this lot - not least because they formed part of organised groups with standards. The Black Panthers or the IRA would have kicked out Thomas Crooks or Ryan Routh for being a liability.

I still thinks this looks more like "something memetic is making all the school shooters shoot politicians instead of schools"

Prediction: the man who shot Kirk has no history of political activism as part of the Democratic Party or any organised centre or far-left group.

As for actual newspapers, doing their own research and writing their own stories without political bias - there should be some. Surely they can't all be bad apples.

The existence of newspapers which seek to avoid political bias (except for the pro-establishment bias that comes from the need to cultivate sources and any bias which comes from seeking sensationalism) is the result of a temporary and somewhat unusual situation in the American advertising market in the second half of the twentieth century. Founding era newspapers wore their partisan bias on their sleeves, as did the Hearst era yellow press. So does the press in most other countries - the only British paper that isn't proud of its political slant is the Financial Times.

The truth-forming function of the press is best delivered by ideological diversity, not by hoping that a journalistic monoculture is unbiased. The problem here is that you need your partisan journalists to be journalists first and partisan second (as, for example, Rupert Murdoch and his news outlets always have been) or else you end up with Pravda and Infowars shouting at each other.

And of course it isn't technically a murder if the killer is legally insane - which is the scenario most likely to be relevant here.

Finally, did British rule actually cause India's economic growth to slow down? Because if so I was also not aware of that.

Population growth was faster under the Raj than under the Mughals (and faster under the Mughals than any other pre-Raj government). Given that mass living standards in India remain at bare subsistence (with negligible growth in GDP per capita) until India escapes the Malthusian trap in the 1990's, we can reasonably assume that most of GDP goes to keeping peasants alive, and that the faster population growth under the Raj corresponds to faster GDP growth.

The claim that India was a rich nation turned destitute by colonialism (Mughal + British or just British according to factional ID) is the Big Lie of Indian nationalism. India was dirt poor when the British arrived, and slightly less dirt poor when we left. Its just that if you go far back enough everyone was dirt poor, so the working definition of "rich country" was "dirt poor country where the elites can afford blinged-out throne rooms with big shiny diamonds". By that definition, Mughal India was the richest country in the world. And it is indeed the case that the biggest, shiniest diamond was no longer in India at independence.