@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

Many norms are being broken, but almost never by Trump

Come off it. You can argue that invoking war powers in peacetime is technically legal, but it is definitely unprecedented.

Impounding spending, while not unprecedented, is a clear breach of norms about separation of powers (and the law, assuming that the Impoundment Control Act is constitutional).

Obfuscating the org chart of a powerful office within the EOP, for example by issuing a press release saying that Elon Musk is head of DOGE and then saying in a court filing that it is actually Amy Gleason, is a breach of norms about basic honesty (and possibly also perjury).

On the other hand, district court judges issuing nationwide injunctions against executive policies that appear to be facially illegal is now, unfortunately, entirely normal.

The class is members of Tren de Aragua. Not all aliens from Venezuela - Trump isn't claiming that the US is at war with Venezuela. Under the WW2-era jurisprudence whether any given alien is a member of the class is justiciable, including via habeas corpus. That is why Trump had to ship the detainees out of the jurisdiction before a court could rule on what is going on - if he has to litigate each detainee's membership of Tren de Aragua individually then the policy goal of the whole scheme is not achieved.

And obviously here there's the factual question of whether the "senior staffer" who allegedly hijacked Biden's autopen" fills the relevant criteria of 301.

He clearly doesn't because EOP staffers are not Senate-confirmed. Either Biden ordered the pardon or it is illegal.

Mooting a case by voluntarily ceasing to do the thing litigated against is legally dubious, but it is very different from doing the thing before (or, in this case, during) the hearing and claiming the case is moot because it can't be undone.

The formal peace treaty with Germany legally ending WW2 wasn't signed until German Reunification in 1990. The Allies withdrew from most of Germany voluntarily in 1949, but remained in belligerent occupation of Berlin. West Germany never claimed sovereignty over West Berlin. East Germany's claim to East Berlin was not recognised by the UK, France or the USA, and the Soviet Union agreed not to press the issue and that the four occupying powers' troops could behave as if Berlin was still under joint occupation.

So "The US was still legally at war with Germany in 1948" was uncomplicatedly correct. The SCOUTS verdict was that if a legal state of war exists, the question of whether or not it is a real war allowing the invocation of Presidential war powers is non-justiciable.

It all seems like a very shallow dispute.

The core dispute here - is a determination by the President that an "invasion" exists under the Enemy Aliens Act justiciable - is not shallow. It is as fundamental as constitutional disputes get. Either legal immigrants enjoy the rights that the Constitution grants to "persons" (as opposed to "citizens of the United States") or they do not. And if the administration's interpretation of the Enemy Aliens Act is correct, then they don't - because the President has the right to grab any non-citizen they want and ship them off to a foreign prison without meaningful judicial review.

Ignoring the merits for a moment (and you shouldn't - it is probably the most important constitutional case since the War on Terror), the procedural issues are not shallow. The problem of cases of national significance being heard by forum-shopped district court judges has been getting worse for a long time and has hurt both sides (nothing being done to Trump is fundamentally different from what Judge Kacsmaryk did to Biden), and probably requires Congressional action to fix - a process for enjoining facially illegal executive policies is necessary, and right now that process is to file suit in any district court with jurisdiction. If district courts just stop hearing this type of case then there are a whole load of illegal or unconstitutional policies that can't be litigated. (Including, among others, the Biden student loan scheme - these issues are profoundly bipartisan). And the procedural moves taken by the administration are utterly outrageous to the point where a private litigant who tried it would go to jail without passing Go - the administration moved the subject matter of litigation out of the jurisdiction while the hearing was going on in the courtroom and the government lawyer claimed not to know what was going on.

So the issues we have at stake are:

  • Do legal immigrants (including green card holders - if there is an legal "invasion" then they are exempted from the Tren de Aragua proclamation as a matter of grace and not obligation on the part of the administration) have rights, like at all?
  • What is the procedure for judicial review of an executive policy which may be facially illegal and cannot or should not be litigated piecemeal by individual litigants with standing?
  • Can the administration circumvent court processes (including habeas corpus) by flying detainees out of the country to a foreign prison before the judge has time to finalise an order?

Given that the whole point of the increased borrowing is to re-arm against Russia, and the AfD is fairly reliably pro-Russian, I don't think the AfD would want a deal on any sane terms.

What is the significance of October 6, 1973? Googling gives me the Yom Kippur war, which is irrelevant to what was largely a US domestic phenomenon.

I think the "fifties" end with the rise of large-scale resistance to the Vietnam draft, which was somewhat earlier. The "sixties" are generally accepted to have begun in 1968 and continued into the 1970's, and 1968 is also about the right date for the end of the "fifties" by my definition.

The Pax Romana is traditionally defined from the ascension Augustus in 27 BC to the death of Marcus Aurelius in 180 AD, 206 years.

This period includes a major civil war in AD 69. I agree that you could argue for Domitian as a sixth small-g good Emperor on top of the five capital-G Good Emperors.

Regardless of the colour, the buzz cut is unattractive to heterosexual men in the vast majority of times and places.

I think the distinction between "cool/hot alt-girl", "fun" and "slutty" is one without a difference. I mean this girl is in her mid-twenties and has already had seven messy breakups.

Movie Ramona is mid by the standards of female characters in Hollywood movies. I assume this is deliberate on the part of the filmmakers.

This is a large part of why Prince Andrew was not prosecuted - Virginia Guiffre was 17 when they had sex, which makes her legal in London (16) and NYC (17). So for there to be a crime they would have to prove they had sex specifically on Epstein's island (age of consent is 18 in the US Virgin Islands).

That Epstein transported teenage girls from jurisdictions where they were legal to the USVI where they were jailbait is one of the great absurdities of the whole affair, and a point in favour of the "planned blackmail op" hypothesis.

Both Einstein and Gauss were tracked into the top track (Gymnasium) of the heavily tracked German school system, and accelerated further within it.

The classic example of a genius-tier mathematician who failed out of school due to poor performance in non-maths subjects is Ramanujan.

It's certainly a distinction used by academic anthropologists, which given the epistemic standards of anthropology is only weak evidence that it is useful. Yudkowskian rationalists who read books by antrhopologists have said that this particular concept is non-BS, which is rather stronger evidence.

The broader point - that some, but not a majority of, sub-Saharan African cultures fit a pattern where farming is considered pink-collar work, men do very little useful work for the tribe, and women enjoy more sexual freedom than they did in almost any other premodern culture is well-attested by a wide range of Western commentators including journalists, travel memoirists, British imperialists, aid workers etc. as well as academic anthropologists .

As I understand it, livestock on the hoof is a lot easier to steal than the types of wealth you see in crop-growing societies. This means that men are a lot more valuable to the tribe, because they can guard cattle or steal the other tribe's cattle. But I'm not an expert.

And 1500 years later, the leading Saxon polity is ruled by a Senate that meets on Capitol Hill in a building decorated in the Corinthian Order. I don't think the Saxons are entirely un-Romanized.

They’re not mutually exclusive. Romulus, notably, was both a mythical father figure of the Romans and the Latins were a real ethnicity.

I was thinking of the period when the Roman Empire was explicitly multiethnic, during which the deified Emperor was the mythopoetic father figure. The growth of the Roman empire (small 'e' as the process begins under the late Republic) involves a series of extensions of increasing levels of political inclusion (socii, then Latini, then full cives Romani) to people who were increasingly obviously not ethnic Latins.

I don't care. Given the way that take was punctuated, it was asking for it.

There used to be a whole genre of fiction praising men who choose plain moral women over femmes fatales, and this general wisdom is so hard to kill that it even bubbles up in modern fiction (to wit, Knives Chau's obvious moral superiority over Ramona Flowers).

Although in the movie Knives Chau gets tossed and the Good Ending involves Scott getting Ramona. My take on the movie (I haven't read the comic) is that the screenwriters want to, but don't explicitly, condemn the Scott-Knives relationship as inappropriate because she is still in school and he isn't.

Also, I don't think Ramona is supposed to hotter than Knives in the movie - her most prominent feature apart from being taller than Knives (who IIRC is tiny) is her electric pink buzz-cut hair - this is not something that is attractive to most hetrosexual men. Ramona is supposed to fun (unspoken subtext - slutty) in a way which an Asian-Canadian middle class teenager is not.

And of course the word "virtue" has the Latin root of "vir", meaning "man" in the sense of "adult male displaying the classical masculine virtues" (as opposed to "homo", meaning "man" as in "person assumed male because that's the default").

The Latin word virtu translates into modern English as "manliness" if you want a literal translation, but I would translate it as "prowess" - when applied to an adult human male it is approximately synonymous with the Greek Arete. (Arete could also be applied to inanimate objects which were exceptionally fit for their purpose - when applied to a bladed weapon it gets translated as "sharpness".)

It's the gold standard for all of human history

Nationalism of any kind (including ethno-nationalism) can't be the gold standard for all of human history because nations don't exist until mass literacy and the printing press. Tribalism, based on loyalty to Dunbar-sized groups of actual kin and larger facsimiles thereof was the gold standard for most of human history. But the most successful large tribes - including the Roman Empire and Christian Church, and therefore Western Civilisation, were based on fictive kinship through a shared mythopoetic father-figure, not realish kinship determined by ethnicity.

Ethno-nationalism as a political idea begins as a 19th century small-l liberal project, replacing loyalty to dynastic states. Bismarck comes up with a right-wing version of it which works in the context of Protestant Germany. But in Catholic countries ethno-nationalism is directly opposed to throne-and-altar conservatism, which was the gold standard in early modern Europe.

Fair, I questioned it wrong; which successful modern civilizations that also police their population's sexual activity exist today?

Mormons. Modern Orthodox Jews. Per some other discussions in this thread, possibly the less strict Mennonite sects. Ethnic Chinese Blue Tribers in the US. European traditional elite families still do it, although they don't (and never did) stop their sons banging lower-class chicks on holiday.

And of course the dirty little secret of the Blue Tribe PMC (see for example Charles Murray's Coming Apart) is that they police their own sexual activity much more than they are able to admit to.

All successful civilizations controlled female sexuality heavily,

CisHajnal Europe (from about 1000 AD) less than most*, and we are the most successful civilisation by far. The socially optimal amount of male control over female sexuality may well be higher than what we have now, but it is lower than what arises by default in the vast majority of societies.

One of the sources of confusion here is that people misunderstand the 1950's social model as a free-market outcome. Women working outside the home was and is fundamental to modernity (the first factory jobs were pink-collar) and the societies that better accommodated it outcompeted the ones that did not - notably on the battlefield in the World Wars. The 1950's housewife - i.e. the idea that respectable working class married women should not work outside the home - is a result of post-war America (and post-war Europe once it had repaired the war damage) deciding that is both rich enough relative to historical expectations and egalitarian enough to prioritise leisure over wealth accumulation. The whole point of the social model was to give each respectable family access to 40 hours a week of paid work at above-market wages, but not the ability to get ahead by working harder than that. Because if families can compete for social status by sending mum to work, empirically they will. Famously, this is what drove Elizabeth Warren to anti-feminist heresy in The Two Income Trap.

* Hoe-based agriculture produces the least patriarchal societies, plow-based agriculture produces more patriarchal societies, and animal herding produces even more patriarchal societies. Hunter-gatherer societies are all over the place. Premodern cisHajnal Europe is comfortably the least patriarchal plow-based society.

Government welfare schemes do do all those things. Unless you are too disabled to work, I am not aware of any countries where you are officially allowed to live for more than a few months as a welfare bum, or more than a few years as a welfare mother. (Unless you count able-bodied retirees in their 60's and 70's as welfare bums, which I do but a supermajority of the electorate don't). In every country I have looked at,

The US has no cash or cash-equivalent welfare at all for able-bodied, childless paupers. In the UK assistance is gated by a fortnightly interview where you have to show receipts for your job search. I don't know much about Continental Europe, but the generous benefits in those countries are limited to people who have already paid into the system. I do know that Italy has no means-tested benefit for people without a contribution history and explicitly expects them to sponge off their parents.

The problem is that chivvying the undeserving poor into work doesn't work well at the best of times, and doesn't work at all when done by large centralised bureaucracies. Victorian England was already rich enough that you couldn't whip effort out of idlers without paying the man with the whip more than the value extracted - the workhouses cost more than just paying people outdoor relief, and were deliberately and consciously maintained as an expensive tool of social control similar to the prisons. Conventional wisdom among British Jobcentre workers is that the signing on process is completely useless for genuinely unemployed people and the only reason for retaining it is that it preferentially inconveniences people with a cash-in-hand job to supplement their benefits.

The other problem is that when you go looking for people who could get a job with ordinary effort but choose not to, you don't find as many as you expect. You find single mothers who can't fit the available jobs around their childcare arrangements, you find disabled people who haven't managed to get a diagnosis through the bureaucracy, you find people who don't have a diagnosable disability but are clearly unemployable basket cases, you find people living in unemployment blackspots without the resources to move, and you find people who had a job when the economy was better and will get another job when the economy improves.

However, you also had things like the English poor laws, which were secular, state-provided relief (of a sort) for the desperately poor.

The first Poor Law was introduced in 1601 to fill a gap in society that had been created (according to schoolboy history) by the dissolution of the monasteries or (according to revisionist histories of the Reformation) by Protestant spiritual coercion being less effective than Catholic spiritual coercion at getting the money in, so secular coercion was required instead.

I use the term "spiritual coercion" literally - in a society where people actually believed in their religion, "pay up or go to hell" is directly coercive in the same way which "pay up or go to jail" is today.

Hanson says a lot of things about creative uses of markets which make me want to facepalm because based on my own professional experience he clearly doesn't understand how financial markets work, so I assume Gell-Mann amnesia applies when he writes about technical topics I don't understand. But even if he is mostly wrong, he certainly never fails to be interesting.