@Mewis's banner p

Mewis


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 10 02:05:33 UTC

				

User ID: 1091

Mewis


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 10 02:05:33 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1091

For someone who owns property, as most NIMBYs do, the prospect of cheap housing is a bad one. It's not about keeping homeless people out of sight, it's about keeping rents flowing in and property prices climbing.

Exactly. It would be one thing if the South had invested in themselves and turned themselves into an economic powerhouse, but they didn't - cotton profits were consumed, not invested.

It is not that "in principle" there's a lot of stuff to work out about how to make a truthful agent, its that in practice we have absolutely no idea how to make a truthful agent because when we try we ram face-first into the PoMo problem.

I mean, there is a pretty obvious source out there of truthful data - the physical world. ChatGPT is blind and deaf, a homonculus in a jar. Obviously it's not designed to interpret any kind of sense-data, visual or otherwise, but if it could, it could do more than regurgitate training data.

But current ChatGPT is a biting, accurate caricature of a very-online liberal, with not enough guile to hide the center of its moral universe behind prosocial System 2 reasoning, an intelligence that is taught to not have thoughts that make liberals emotionally upset; so it admits that it hates political incorrectness more than genocide.

Well, firstly it should be noted that the intense safeguards built into ChatGPT about the n-word but not about nuclear bombs is because ChatGPT has n-word capability but not nuclear capability. You don't need to teach your toddler not to set off nuclear weapons, but you might need to teach it to not say the n-word - because it can actually do the latter.

Secondly, ChatGPT doesn't have direct experience of the world. It's been told enough about 'nuclear bombs' and 'cities' and 'bad' to put it together that nuclear bombs in cities is a bad combination, in the same way that it probably knows that 'pancakes' and 'honey' are a good combination, not knowing what pancakes and honey actually are. And it's also been told that the 'n-word' is 'bad'. And likely it also has been taught not to fall for simplistic moral dilemmas to stop trolls from manipulating it into endorsing anything by positing a worse alternative. But that doesn't make it an accurate caricature of a liberal who would probably agree that the feelings of black people are less important than their lives.

The thing about GPT is that while it can string words together in grammatically correct order it's still nowhere close to replicating human communication in large part because upon inspection/interrogation it quickly becomes apparent that it doesn't really have a concept of what words mean, only what words are associated with others.

Well, yes. It's living in Plato's cave. It has no direct experience of physical reality, only training data - it no more understands what 'red' really is any more than a blind human does. None of that means that it's not intelligent, any more than the people in Plato's cave are unintelligent for not deducing the existence of non-shadows from first principles. With that said, I think ChatGPT does a excellent job of giving advice despite being extremely disabled by human standards.

You might as well ask GPT "what does the bomb plan to do after it goes off?" or "what brand of whiskey does the bomb prefer with it's steak?" as the answers you get will be about as relevant/useful.

These things wouldn't work, because the GPT knows that a 'bomb' is not a type of noun that is associated with performing the verb 'plan' or 'prefer', in the same way that it knows that balls do not chase dogs.

Is it? what consequences would those be?

The obvious answer is that if use of AI chatbots becomes widespread, that they will be used to replicate the preferred values of their creators. This is hardly science fiction. Google search and Wikipedia are not autonomous intelligences - they are still used as ideological weapons. That's alarming, but if the developers don't get it right, it might have very different values - such as valuing a language taboo over the lives of millions.

If you're living in a city in the Western World, the problem probably isn't that your dating pool is too narrow. Plenty of single guys and girls out there - if you couldn't find a partner in the first 10,000, the next 10,000 probably isn't going to change things.

Personally, I'm not interested either way and I wouldn't take a drug that would make me want sex and romantic love, since the entire thing seems to be a complete mess with all the anger, rejection, aggression, and arguing over what are the expectations and the mores and the right way or wrong way to do it, and all the unhappy people who want it but can't get it, or get the wrong kind of attention.

People argue about it and get angry about it because it's something important. And though the experience of wanting things does cause problems and drama, I think that not wanting anything is worse.

Right, but that's more about finding and activating existing people to see themselves as queer or PoC or whatever so they will see their interests as being aligned with the wider queer or PoC community. Such as the efforts to sheepdog Asians into voting for affirmative action.

I don't really agree - I think it's better not to form an opinion at all than to form a really bad one, and I think it's better to stick conservatively to what is known for sure rather than speculate wildly on what's going on in someone's head. This doesn't mean we can't know anything, but what we can know has to have a rock solid base. For example, I think it's reasonable to say that one motivation behind the Russian invasion is that they thought it would be easy. This is so common-sense and obvious that I rarely see people discuss it. It's obvious for many reasons - firstly, it's why we go to war as well. Secondly, we ourselves perceived Ukraine as being vulnerable to invasion in the run-up to 2022. None of this requires us to try and get inside Putin's head, or to develop any understanding of the Russians - in fact, to try and develop an understanding of the Russians assumes there is something to understand, that they differ from us in some fundamental way.

And more broadly, I think that being excessively curious presents it's own danger. Humans are absolutely capable of overthinking, overinterpreting and overfitting, generating patterns and order out of chaos, going back to the astrologers who tried to match events on earth to the movement of the heavens.

Your "Expert Russia Understanders" claim a thing and you believe them.

No, I don't believe them. I don't believe that Expert Russia Understanders understand anything, and I believe their 'understanding' is just a way to justify their preferred conclusion - Russia delenda est.

Are you advocating we destroy their government and then back off with no further intervention to prevent them from doing it again? Or are you advocating that we destroy their government and then imperialistically foist a new government with our ideals upon them?

No, no. For the second time, I am not saying that Russians are orcish. Maybe you should write less and read more.

Maybe for the purposes of military planners. Is it useful for you and I to try and understand the mind of the lowly Russian serf? Are we going to learn Russia, throw ourselves into 500 years of complicated history, move to Russia and explore the nature of its people? Unlikely. We're going to read a bunch of articles on Wikipedia, maybe a thinkpiece (they all have titles like "How the EU is playing right into Putin's hands"). Is this kind of half-baked understanding going to reflect anything but our own biases, whether for peace or for war?

It is not my perspective the the Russians are orcish - I'm saying, that it seems to be a common conclusion among Expert Russia Understanders.

You are literally advocating the genocide of 143 million people because you believe them to be evil, not because you've met all 143 million of them, or probably even a dozen, but because of the government and military of their country is doing bad things and there is some amount of support among their populace.

I'm literally not.

Is it actually productive to try and understand Russian motivations? Regardless of their motivations, they're trying to use force to conquer an independent nation, one that was attempting to align itself with the West. The fact that they might see this as part of a broader conflict with the West isn't news, and it doesn't change matters on the ground.

In addition, it seems like most people in Western countries, including many people here, come at the issue of trying to understand Russia from the perspective of trying to justify war - the Russians are inherently authoritarian/imperialistic/belligerent/orcish, and therefore must be destroyed. I don't think this attitude is helpful or should be encouraged.

There's no doubt it's hyperbole, but you can make yourself believe if you repeat it loudly and often enough. You can whip yourself into a paranoid frenzy, and make yourself believe that JK Rowling is hiding underneath your bed waiting to strangle you in your sleep, and turn every single debate over pronoun usage into a life-and-death struggle for survival. Every day it's 1933 in Germany, forever. And this is in fact, effective political strategy for people who liberals find sympathetic.

Maybe not a Christian invention (since the Romans also had monogamy), but it was Christian Popes that forced monogamy on non-Roman Europe, by threat of excommunication.

While it's true that the influx of new players from actual play podcasts has resulted in tabletop gaming becoming a younger, queerer, and more progressive community than before (I have witnessed the transformation first-hand on Tumblr)

I don't believe this is actually true. Were 13 and 14 year olds really not playing D&D in the 80s and 90s? Is it really likely that young gay kids were too busy playing football to have any interest in TTRPGs? Or is this just that young people nowadays - particularly of the indoorsy and nerdy variety - are more likely to have strong progressive opinions and to be gay, trans, or otherwise GNC?

They don't care about progressive issues, or (their other scape goat) NFT's.

They cared enough to declare that Nielsen's art would never be reprinted.

I haven't seen this particular criticism of Trump before, and I found it interesting to read.

I'm of two minds about this. On the one hand, it is concerning that humans might be turned into docile, passive herd animals. On the other, there's no doubt that huge amounts of crime and dysfunction are caused by a small minority of humans with abnormal personalities. When you think about people who, for whatever reason, function very poorly, it's often a result of excessive neuroticism, lack of conscientiousness, or poor executive function... would it really be so 'inhuman' to live in a country like Japan?

Yes, that is the problem with conservatives, they don't have any really terrible ideas like the Left do. What they need is some completely out-of-touch bug-eyed academics to tell us that brushing your teeth is racist or that we should abolish traffic lights or that bicycles should be outlawed. That will really show the Left (the path to unopposed power when the Right loses every elected office in the galaxy).

I don't see the disagreement. By your own admittance, Democrats are likely to get their way within a decade. Please pick either 'Democrats aren't coming for your stove' and 'They are but it's for your own good'.

Though I don't begrudge anyone their essays, I don't really like this presumption. The left is much better at writing essays and getting them published, because most journalists and writers are lefties. The battle, by it's nature, is asymmetrical, and picked by the collective consciousness of the left to be the path of least resistance to them - since all they need to do is sow doubt about whether gas stoves might be harmful, and because the regulations they favor are designed to boil the frog and wipe out gas stoves thirty years down the road rather than tomorrow.

Bugs cannot be engineered to be bigger than they currently are because their internal biology is designed for being small. They don't have lungs, or blood as we think of it, or complex nervous systems, or a hundred other things necessary for larger animals. In addition, part of what makes insects an 'efficient' food source is precisely their small size and short life cycle.

I don't see the bother even to try. When there are countless mammals and birds and fish around which are already delicious and great food, why choose to try and make perfect future food out of bugs? Why not start with something that is already great and just needs some tweaking?

Imagine having leaders capable of thinking more than a decade ahead!

Maybe it's not a problem now, but these countries hope to eventually be rich and stable like Western European countries, and if they are, they'll have to deal with third world immigration then. And E-Europeans heading west to make money don't want to have to compete with Africans.

No, that's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard. Is it theft to be inspired by someone else's work?

A market that negotiates as a block, represents its buying power and influence as a block. The EU exists for a reason. Global consumerism means that powerful developed countries rely on access to big market blocks like India to keep their profits high.

That doesn't really ring true. India is a net importer, but not from western countries, and many western countries are also net importers.

India is effectively asking the global-south to present as a more unified negotiating block, that allows for more favorable terms due to collective bargaining.

Which is not realistic because they don't share common economic interests. The Western world contains both importers (the US and UK) and exporters (Germany, the Netherlands), while the 'global South' does the same.

The real negotiation here is : India closing itself off and accepting a QOL hit, while lost sales hurt the exporting 1st world's industries.

Indians are not splurging on American movies and European wine. India mostly imports important economic inputs - machinery, energy, raw materials and fertilizer. Protecting domestic markets from foreign competition can be advantageous in some cases, but it's not really clear what the goal would be. There's no point in cutting off oil imports if your country can't produce it's own oil.