@Mewis's banner p

Mewis


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 10 02:05:33 UTC

				

User ID: 1091

Mewis


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 10 02:05:33 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1091

My understanding is that the issues with the British economy are structural and go back to the Blair government, which mostly rode a boom in financial services while sowing the seeds of our current issues. Britain is by this point, highly deindustrialized and heavily indebted, with poor infrastructure and an aging population, an economy built on cheap labour and a harsh regulatory environment. This is the result of decades of overconsumption and underinvestment by both the private industry, average people, and government. The longer the fall, the harder the landing, and Liz Truss is simply reaping the result, as much due to animal spirits as any particular decision. Her tax cuts are not particularly radical - they're more or less a return to the taxation levels of Blair. But fiddling with tax levels is only going to shift money between the UK population and the government. It is not going to make the country as a whole (population+government) any richer or poorer, it's pure redistribution.

I think the mindset idea has some value - innate talent might be important, but for practical purposes, you can't change the genes you were born with, whereas you can practice hard. At the same time, it might be that people are better off trying to identify their talents and disposition and act in a way that matches them, rather than trying to shove their square self into a round hole.

Yes, I think that 1% chance of a nuclear war tomorrow is high - I am using the word 'tomorrow' figuratively, to mean 'in the foreseeable future'.

Anything political that doesn't directly and immediately affect you on a personal level is something that you should be concerned about only to a limited degree.

If white replacement ends in the destruction of your society and perhaps the deaths of you and your descendants in 50 years, as many replacement theory believers perceive, that would be a larger threat than the maybe 1% chance of a nuclear exchange tomorrow.

More broadly I don't think that this kind of 'I should only think about my personal and immediate interests and not give a shit about the broader society I live in or the long-term future' attitude actually holds up that well. It's a recipe for extreme short-termist thinking, a politics that is incapable of solving problems on any kind of significant time-scale. Coming from a country that I believe has been totally ruined by this kind of attitude, I am much more worried about what the country will look like in thirty years than whether someone might randomly invade us tomorrow.

If the war were somehow to stop now, it would be Russia which would take a few years to re-arm and re-group and then take the rest of Ukraine.

That seems highly unlikely given how poorly the war has gone so far, and could be prevented simply by inviting Ukraine into NATO.

Russia has made it clear that Ukraine is not a legitimate entity to them.

What does that have to do with anything?

But you might ask, at what point does this Pollyanna-Putin outlook begin to crumble? When does the filter bubble burst, and Putin has his Downfall-style meltdown? When Ukraine liberates Kherson? Lysychansk? Donetsk? Sevastopol? I think the only answer we can give here is that people in general are very bad at facing up to uncomfortable realities, and can keep themselves from accepting painful truths for their entire lives if necessary. Or think of psychologist's Leon Festinger's now famous work on cognitive dissonance on doomsday cults: when the doomsday prophecy fails, people will go to great lengths to avoid accepting that they've been duped. I expect Putin to go out the same way, with his final thoughts being confidence that Russia can still be victorious, even as he has an unfortunate fall from a window.

I don't find this kind of psychological analysis to be that convincing. It's compelling to imagine Putin ranting at his generals in some palace and to pull out all sorts of diagnoses - he's a megalomaniac, he's a psychopath, he's delusional, he's paranoid, etc. But these kinds of assertions are made without evidence, and are constructed to support desired conclusions. The claim that Putin is insane or Hitleresque is made to justify war with Russia, and what Americans think of as the good kind of war - total war that doesn't stop until the entire country and government is destroyed. It is made to rule out the possibility of negotiation or normalizing relations.

In any case, Putin's interior psychology is not really that important. Russia is in a very bad place right now, but they really have no choice but to continue to believe that victory is possible. People can believe anything if they have to!

Reading abstruse political theory penned over a hundred years ago is much more an act of obedience than it is of independence. Slavish Marxist-Leninists are just as intellectually incurious as Ayn Rand cultists or fundamentalist Christians or modern antiracists. I think what you actually like is just people who are an intellectual match for you, which I agree is probably more important than how you prefer to waste that intellect.

If anything, being on the brink would make a nuclear exchange more likely. People are more likely to resort to violence or extreme measures when they feel their back is against the wall and they don't have any options. If Russia does not believe it could defend itself in a conventional war, and that the United States intends to destroy their country (which are both true, btw), they will look to non-conventional means of defense.

Escalation in Ukraine makes nuclear war substantially more likely, not less likely. Russia is more likely to resort to nuclear warfare if other options are not available to it. This is not to say that we should be willing to sacrifice all our interests in order to reduce the risk of a nuclear exchange. However, I do not think that humiliating Russia is actually in our interests, and if it increases the chance of nuclear war, we should avoid doing it. Your personal desire to see others degraded and humbled means nothing to me. Go kill ants if that's what gives you pleasure.

They've been bold enough to push their luck, I don't see why we shouldn't be too.

I don't think that the invasion of Ukraine is anything about Russia pushing their luck (beyond the more general principle that war is inherently unpredictable).

Appeasement, in other words?

In other words, I oppose invading Russia and launching ICBMs at Moscow.

Every war is clearly good versus evil for the first few months/years. It's only later that people begin to take a more nuanced view. Who, at the time, did not view WWI, II, the Korean War, the Vietnam War, the War in Iraq, the War in Afghanistan the same way? I recall the same quivering righteousness over Syria.

You'd have to be very much a quokka indeed to be so anti-war as to oppose bleeding out someone who you're still in a nuclear stalemate with. As an American, every day I open my eyes with a Russian warhead pointed me, ready to slaughter my family. So pardon me if I cheer on Ukraine's humiliation of Russia's armed forces.

You do realize that things can always get worse? A humiliation of Russia might make you feel better about having a sword over your head, but you might be safer to try and keep the guy holding the sword feeling calm and secure rather than goading him. This isn't a game - if Americans really believe they're on the brink, they're not acting like it.

It sounds like you can write, you just find it very difficult and unpleasant. Which is not unusual, since I have heard this comment from many people.

The circumstance that every so often, this problem briefly just goes away and I can in fact vomit out several pages that do in fact hold up even if I look at them again later, just makes my problem all the more frustrating - it feels like it's not like there is something I just lack (and therefore could obtain, making the problem go away), but rather that the necessary circuitry is there but defective.

That sounds more like that your circuitry is functional, but you have problems with environment or mood that interfere. That's good because you can control your environment and your mood (to an extent). Think back to those times when you succeeded in writing and think about whether your situation was different, or maybe you did something immediately beforehand that put you in the right state. Having a pre-writing ritual can help deal with procrastination and also put you in the writing mood, even if it's as simple as taking a walk or talking to a particular person.

That will not begin to ameliorate the damage this idiotic war has caused to Russia and Ukraine, but at this point it is the least bad option. The only question now is how Russia can best ensure a relatively fast recovery from the self-inflicted harm it has created.

That more or less explains why it can't happen. If the goal of the West is to weaken or destroy Russia, then it benefits them to drag the war out as long as possible.