SecureSignals
Ere the Sun rises
No bio...
User ID: 853
If the identitarian right and the wider priestly caste are going to hold on to Identity Politics as an organizing principal/value they are going to have to have to confront the fact that the perception of Identity Politics in the popular zeitgeist is that of an ideology for losers. An ideology for people too stupid, degenerate, or incompetent to survive in an honest meritocracy.
That is certainly not the perception of Jewish Identity Politics, take Ben Shapiro for example. I doubt you feel that way about Jewish Identity Politics and the way it expresses itself in politics and culture. And even if you do feel that way about it, you are very far away from the Normie who perceives it as totally normal in the base case, but in many cases they view defense of Jewish Identity Politics as a moral impetus that falls even on non-Jews.
I do not believe the engagement of Jews with Identity Politics in how they socially, politically, and economically organize is because they are losers who are too stupid or degenerate or incompetent to survive in an honest meritocracy. Do you think that?
How is it we arrived at this point, where Jewish Identity Politics is a profound moral impetus, but White Identity Politics is just for people "too stupid, degenerate, or incompetent to survive in an honest meritocracy?"
I would say, however we arrived at this point, we use the same tools and levers to reverse this perception among normies. Normies, and people like yourself, have arrived at this bifurcated interpretation of Identity Politics based on the esoteric racial propaganda you have been exposed to since you were a child in various forms of your daily life. My opinion is not that we do normie outreach with political arguments, it's that we use the same tools to promote White identity as have been used to create your negative perception of White identity.
And maybe you think you arrived at your opinion of White Identity based only on rational argument and careful consideration. No you didn't- it's downstream of history you were taught, the stories you were told by your teacher, the material you were told to read in school, the movies you watch every time you go to the theater, the social causes taken up by Hollywood celebrities. If all of those things had conveyed a different cultural signal to you, you would also have a different opinion of White Identity, so it is for normies.
Yes, this is a Spencerian interpretation for how esoteric, racial moralization and demoralization signals in religion and culture are the key for directing the identities and behavior of the normies. Not going up to them and trying to convince them with arguments. That's certainly not how you or the normies became convinced that Identity Politics for Jews is great and Identity Politics for White people is degenerate.
I think it's time to admit that the famed Western creativity is mostly verbal tilt plus inflated self-esteem, not an advanced cognitive capability. I'm mildly surprised myself.
Trust me, I hope I'm wrong! But the fact is, as I go throughout my day 99% of the innovations I rely on and impact my daily life and our economy as a whole were invented in the West, and have been refined/manufactured/redesigned/made cheaper in China. Not the other way around, and if it were the other way around surely you would point to a HBD explanation. Yes, I do think there's an HBD basis for that and it would be absurd to deny that, a priori it would be silly to doubt there's an HBD basis for any sort of stark pattern like that one Murray observes. I don't think LLMs are a counterexample of that trend.
It would be like if China made a better and cheaper Tesla than Musk, OK that's great but it doesn't really contradict the observation that these innovations are born in the West and then get adopted and modified/improved in China.
The problem is that there haven't been substantial breakthroughs in LLMs in the West too.
Honestly this feels like a cope to me. There obviously was a breakthrough in LLMs in the West: politically, economically, technologically, culturally. It wasn't born in China, but they obviously have a significant part to play downstream of their undeniable talent pool.
It's hard to say Deepseek would have accomplished these things without drafting on OpenAI's introduction of LLMs to the world, and all of the downstream political, economic, geopolitical, cultural impact resulting from that disruption- and it was OpenAI that did the disrupting there is simply no denying. On the other hand we know OpenAI did not need Deepseek.
Yeah I've picked up on it from various Podcasts on movies and Bible Studies. They are doing a Podcast series on Genesis right now where they go through every single verse, but I think it's behind a paywall. They are close to releasing a book that will essentially be a debut for the theory. I'll probably read it and write a review when it comes out.
But in the meantime, Grok did a pretty stellar job providing a fair summary IMO:
REM Theory Overview:
REM Theory, as articulated by Mark Brahmin and Richard Spencer, primarily focuses on the concept of Racial Esoteric Moralization (REM) and Jewish Esoteric Moralization (JEM). The theory posits that myths, art, religion, and propaganda are not just cultural expressions but are deeply intertwined with the formation and moralization of racial identities. Here's a breakdown based on available sources:
- Racial Esoteric Moralization (REM): This aspect of the theory argues that there exists a symbolic language that has been passed down through centuries, influencing not only Western but global cultural narratives. REM suggests that this language serves to shape racial identity and moral conduct through symbols and stories that are often unconscious to the general populace but known to an elite or those versed in this symbolic language. The theory claims that these narratives in myths, religion, and art can either "moralize" or "demoralize" a populace, thereby serving as tools for social and political control.
- Jewish Esoteric Moralization (JEM): According to Brahmin, JEM is a subset of REM where Jewish mythology and cultural expressions have been used historically to shape not just Jewish identity but also to influence broader cultural narratives, particularly in Christianity. Brahmin's analysis suggests that JEM has contributed significantly to the development of Western culture in ways that might not be obvious to the lay observer.
- Apolloism: This is an extension of REM Theory where Brahmin and Spencer advocate for a return to or revival of a pre-Christian, classical, or "Aryan" ethic. Apolloism contrasts with what they perceive as the demoralizing effects of Judeo-Christian spirituality on what they term the "Aryan" race. The idea is to use the understanding of REM to construct a new cultural and religious framework (Apolloism) that would elevate and preserve the qualities they associate with ancient Aryan culture.
- Racial Esoteric Moralization (REM) in Film: Symbolism and Archetypes: Brahmin argues that films, like ancient myths, use archetypal characters and symbolic narratives to convey racial and moral messages. He interprets characters and plotlines in terms of their racial symbolism, suggesting that even mainstream movies are imbued with hidden messages that reinforce or challenge racial identities.
- Hollywood as a Moralizing Force: They see Hollywood as an institution that has historically served to shape the moral and racial consciousness of the audience. Through REM, Brahmin would analyze films to uncover how they might be promoting or undermining certain racial identities or moral values.
Insights from the Apollonian Transmission:
- Cultural and Myth Analysis: The Apollonian Transmission, a platform by Brahmin, delves into the decoding of ancient and contemporary texts through the lens of REM. It aims to uncover how these texts carry hidden messages that influence racial and moral identity. Brahmin and Spencer argue that by understanding these symbols, one can counteract or redirect the demoralization they believe has been inflicted upon Western civilization.
- Criticism and Controversy: The theory and its implications have stirred debate. Critics, like those referenced in "Once More Between Rome and Judea", challenge the methodology and conclusions of REM Theory, accusing it of sophistry and speculative pattern recognition, suggesting that it lacks rigorous evidential support and borders on pseudoscientific interpretation.
- Practical Application: Courses like those offered at ALEX university aim to apply REM Theory in understanding Hollywood cinema, suggesting that films serve not only entertainment but also as a medium for racial moralization or demoralization. This approach underscores Brahmin's belief in the power of culture as a tool for racial and moral shaping.
In summary, REM Theory by Mark Brahmin and Richard Spencer is a framework for interpreting cultural and religious narratives as mechanisms for racial identity formation and moral guidance, focusing on the symbolic language that they argue has shaped human history. Apolloism then proposes a cultural and spiritual revival based on these insights. However, this theoretical framework remains controversial and is subject to significant critique regarding its methods and conclusions.
One more followup:
Racial Esoteric Moralization (REM) in the Hebrew Bible:
- Symbolism and Allegory: Brahmin and Spencer argue that the Hebrew Bible, like other religious texts, contains layers of symbolic language intended to shape the racial identity and moral conduct of its adherents. They suggest that narratives within the Bible, such as those involving the Israelites, are not merely historical or moral tales but are imbued with racial significance.
- Creation of Jewish Identity: They posit that the Hebrew Bible has played a crucial role in the moralization (and thus, racialization) of Jewish identity, reinforcing a sense of chosenness and separation from other peoples. This is seen in stories like the Exodus, where the Israelites are depicted as a distinct, divinely selected nation.
- Influence on Western Culture: Brahmin extends this by suggesting that through Christianity (which he sees as heavily influenced by Judaism), these Jewish moral and racial narratives have permeated and shaped Western civilization, often in ways that are not overtly recognized.
The 4-word summary would be that "Myth influences racial formation."
I feel like Jeff Probst from Survivor has an awesome career. Imagine the rest of your career just be hosting Survivor, sounds fun.
They were always capable, they just needed to borrow the Silicon Valley move fast and break things culture in addition to the technical foundation.
They needed to borrow the Culture and they needed to borrow the technical foundation, so this still seems pretty much aligned with the HBD stans to me, who never doubted their intelligence or ability to adopt and improve upon Western innovations. Now if LLMs had had the OpenAI-tier breakthrough in China that would have been a challenge to the HBD stans, but this development basically aligns with the HBD take on the comparative advantage of Chinese talent in adopting Western stuff and then making marginal improvements with their own intelligence and grit.
99.99% of the Roman imperium were spectators, they got to bask in the Glory of Rome the same.
The most benevolent AI imaginable would do everything required to achieve these great works short of the marginal productivity of human struggle such that humans meaningfully participate in the project, even if that contribution itself could be automated.
Goethe said it best:
The Godhead is effective in the living and not in the dead, in the becoming and the changing, not in the become and the set-fast; and therefore, similarly, the reason is concerned only to strive towards the divine through the becoming and the living, and the understanding only to make use of the become and the set-fast.
Living is the act of becoming. Post-AGI economics should be geared towards great works; building the Tower of Babel, space colonization, Galactic Imperium. Something grows or it dies. Humans will need to participate in and identify with some grand project like this even if their individual contribution isn't meaningful.
Christianity is no more of a hoax than the myth of Jacob and Esau, or Moses, or Jupiter. I do not call any of those a hoax, they are something more powerful than that- a Hollywood movie is not a hoax. REM is about understanding the function of myth in directing the identity and ultimately genetic evolution of groups of people. I have explained this to you but you refuse to engage that argument so I think this conversation is pretty much done.
I've followed Richard's Substack and found the thesis very compelling, why is that so hard for you to understand? Do you know what Substack is? Do you know it lets other people read your stuff? No idea why you insist I am one of those people, you are delusional.
You are delusional if you think you have any idea who somebody is just because they share something they found interesting on Substack.
You are just taking a point-and-sputter approach where you don't engage with any of the arguments. Your comment is not an accurate characterization of REM Theory, but you can't actually engage the arguments it makes so instead you set up a really easy to tackle straw man.
Your entire bit has just been calling everything nonsense without engaging with the material. I really hate to burst your bubble- Christianity was invented by the Jews! Likewise Islam was derived from Judaism. Paul's project was explicitly to formulate a Judaism for Gentiles, and that effort yielded another extremely influential myth that is part of this long saga.
None of this is even controversial, what's controversial is the meaning behind these myths or the intention behind them. Notably, Christianity led to iconoclasm against the idols of traditional European religion in favor of sole worship of Yahweh above all else. That's not even disputable, you are just saying it was random development of history rather than an intelligent mythological influence. Kind of like how some people genuinely think Wokeness just popped out of the ground independent of the will of the people creating Culture everywhere they look.
Myth is a mechanism for control. That's the entire point of REM Theory. This applies to the Bible, and it applies to Marvel Comics and Schindler's List all equally. It's insightful and frankly derivative of insights from Plato's allegory of the Cave or Herbert's Dune.
REM Theory requires no gishgallop, just two simple premises which have quite a lot of support:
-
That some of the mythological figures in the Hebrew Bible were intended to symbolically represent an Indo-European type, like Esau and Goliath. This is a common feature of the pagan canon as well- mythological gods as symbolic representations of foreign people. It's not outlandish prima facie that Indo-Europeans are symbolically represented among figures in Hebrew myth. The reason it would be "new" to emphasize is because there has been a long-standing ignorance and denial of the extent of Indo-European migrations, and therefore a lack of appreciation for how these migrations could manifest in Hebrew myth developed during the time of these expansions.
-
That these myths were consciously designed by propagandists, and these myths direct the evolution of human races.
The texts have been interpreted countless ways over the centuries, so the idea Richard and Mark have found some novel way to interpret them is extremely implausible.
It's literally not novel as it aligns with the Early Rabbis who made the same relation... REM explains the reason for the existence of the myth.
Indo-European tribes invaded all of Europe, and down through India and Iran. Much about these invasions was not known for sure until very recently- in some cases, until the past couple decades, the invasions were regarded as racist myths and they never happened in the first place. The more we learn, the more plausible the suggestion is that Hebrew myth was, in significant part and in particular stories, inspired by contact with Indo-European tribes. Goliath being an example- an Indo-European name and a depiction of a physically tall man which of course is the most prominent phenotype of Indo-Europeans among everyone else in the world.
It perhaps even explains the reason the Hebrew Bible exists in the first place- propaganda to cohere a people in the face of an external threat. That part is more speculative, sure. REM would suggest that is the reason for the existence and importance of that myth body. I don't think anybody would deny the Jews have abided thanks to this body of myth.
But the Roman canon is likewise largely inspired by contact with external tribes, and there are Roman gods who esoterically depict Semitic peoples just the same. The notion that Indo-Europeans are not depicted in the Hebrew Bible becomes less likely the more we learn about how broad their migrations were across continents. Particularly given the early Rabbis themselves attributed a continuity between these mythological figures and the real-world Roman empire.
Spencer's interpretation isn't even novel as I've explained, what is novel is his combination of that interpretation with evolutionary psyschology and Race Formation. There has been scientific study of Race, there has been mythological study, but there hasn't been adequate analysis of the interplay between the two. REM fills a real gap in providing a synthesis of those studies.
I won't pretend to know that all Rabbis would agree on something, but I'm pretty sure they would at least mostly agree that the interpretation of the early Rabbis was that Rome was descended from Edom. The more controversial question would be why the early Rabbis had this interpretation of the myth.
The article I linked presents an interpretation of the reason the Rabbis associated Rome with Edom that does not agree with Richard's position.
However, the reason that article gives for why the early Rabbis associated Rome with Edom is basically the Transitive Property of Hate: the Rabbis hated Edom, the Rabbis hated Rome, therefore Rome is Edom. I don't find that convincing, but even that perspective supports REM Theory that these myths and their interpretation, and even their changing interpretations esoterically depict racial conflict.
Even the suggestion that the Rabbis associated Edom with Rome based on the conflict of Jews with Rome would only suggest that even the original influence of the story would have been inspired by proto-Jewish conflict with proto-Indo-European tribes as well! Did this conflict between Rome and Judea start with Rome and Judea? No it did not, the racial contact goes back further and the Hebrew bible provides a mythological depiction and interpretation of this conflict in stories like this...
That is REM Theory. It's highly plausible and I think it's a significant theory. It generalizes to art and myth that is depicted even today. It also generalizes to the Pagan canon. It's not just Jews that used Religion for this purpose, the Indo-European Pantheon is likewise an esoteric canon of racial conflict, moralization, and hierarchy. It's a very strong theory and you haven't really challenged it meaningfully IMO.
No, I said it's literary criticism, which means it should be engaged on its merits and there is a lot of merit to their interpretation. Especially since some of the most important parts align with the interpretation of the Rabbis.
This is just Richard’s interpretation and nothing more.
It is in fact not just Richard's interpretation:
Although the texts about Jacob and Esau are ostensibly speaking about individuals, each brother represents an ethnic and/or political group that resided in the Levant in biblical times.
Ok, so this is REM theory exactly. It's not some moral lesson from God, it's a myth representing race conflict and intended to moralize a race of people. And the article acknowledges the position of the Rabbis:
This basic sketch of the relationship between the polities of Israel/Judah/Judea and Edom/Idumea during the biblical and Second Temple periods indicates that Edom was a polity that ruled from the Mount Seir area, from Wadi al-Hasa (south-east of the Dead Sea) in modern day Jordan and southward, eventually extending westward to Ashkelon on the Mediterranean Coast, and northward up to Hebron, in the Second Temple period.
And yet, Rabbinic midrash associates Esau and Edom with a completely different geographical area—the city of Rome in the Italian Peninsula—and speaks as if Romans are all Edomites.
The Talmud clearly associates the Romans with the Edomites. And it's not just a Spencer idea that Jacob and Esau represent different races in ethnic conflict.
Even the Philistines, i.e. in the David and Goliath myth are considered to have been likely descended from the Sea Peoples, in particular the tribe with Greek origins:
Possible relations to Indo-European languages, even Mycenaean Greek, support the theory that immigrant Philistines originated among "sea peoples".
Goliath is not a semitic name, it's an Indo-European name and the Philistine language is not semitic in origin. Goliath's height and strength would support the theory from a phenotypical perspective as well.
The point of that being REM theory is both radical and plausible in proposing that these myths are portraying conflict between Jews and Indo-European tribes in many of the important cases. This theory is supported by the Rabbis and the Talmud. It's also supported by some archeological and linguistic evidence tying the Philistines to a tribe of Indo-European sea-farers.
So saying it's "unfalsifiable" is wrong, insofar you could prove it wrong if you could prove that Esau did not symbolically represent an Indo-European even though the Talmud supports the interpretation of Esau as representing an Indo-European type.
Even from purely a literary perspective, Esau seems to represent an Indo-European type with red hair- he is strong and physically fit. Famously, Jacob swindles Esau's birthright by putting on goat-skin and pretending to be Esau to his blind father Isaac, such that Jacob received the blessing meant for Esau. Very interesting stuff. The story harkens to even modern myth in which the "Nerd vs Jock" trope is racialized along the same lines, and the nerd uses his brains to beat the jock and get the chick in the end.
REM theory is only unfalsifiable insofar as all critical literary analysis is unfalsifiable. I agree Mark sometimes goes too far speculating on certain nuances, but the big picture items- Hebrew stores like Tower of Babel, Jacob and Esau, David and Goliath, esoterically depicting racial conflict and elevating a Jewish type is very obviously true and insightful. In the most important cases- i.e. Jacob and Esau representing a sibling rivalry between Jew and Aryan, this has always been acknowledged by the Rabbis who relate Esau to the progenitor of Edom, and therefore Rome and Rome's successor Europe. That's just an example for how REM aligns with the interpretation of the Rabbis in a very important case, maybe the most important case.
That analysis applied to modern filmography, i.e. Steven Spielberg is also only as "unfalsifiable" as all film criticism. But Spielberg films are unequivocally an example of REM theory generalizing to modern forms of art depiction, in which the Jewish identities of the art-creators is imbued in their mythological signals, which in turn influences the behavior of mass audiences of people.
The essence of REM Theory that Yahweh is a metaphor and synonym for Jews as a race is unequivocally true. Understanding that leads to a much deeper interpretation of these biblical stories, in particular understanding the stories in which Yahweh comes into conflict with Civilization (i.e. Tower of Babel).
The conclusion that the Hebrew Bible has influenced the creation of races of people, and therefore race-creation is downstream from myth-creation, is so obviously true that we should be shocked that nobody has made this observation before in the way REM has. Have to give it credit where due.
There's actually a lot of parallel between Spencer's theory and the e/acc actually, in particular how Culture is a complex interaction between memes and genes. e/acc seems to stop short of (at least exoterically) recognizing this as consequential and vital for Race Formation, whereas that's Spencer's primary concern. For example, how a piece of literary fiction like the Hebrew Bible can mold races of people over thousands of years.
On the other hand, e/acc is correct about the upheaval of AI and Spencer like most of the DR is basically blind to the fact that it is going to change everything.
I would say I think the truth is in between e/acc and Spencer. Spencer + AI Realism, or e/acc + Racial Esoteric Moralization.
Actually, his change toward this position is a result of the failures of political organizing. He has changed his approach significantly since the rise and fall of the Alt Right.
Right now his effort includes studying the aforementioned topic, in particular the Hebrew Bible as the ultimate keystone for understanding how esoteric, cryptic spiritual movements cohere races of people together and direct their behavior. And also how this practice extends to other forms of fictional art creation like film or comic books.
He has a book coming out on the theory he's been calling "Racial Esoteric Moralization", should be interesting. I do think he's correct that there has to be some sort of post-Christian Religion that organizes the behavior and identity of these disparate Right-Wing factions.
Spencer would tell you not to do anything to paint a target on yourself accelerate the collapse by furthering the more insane parts of the left so you can be the reasonable alternative to the communists when the Reichstag burns.
No, Spencer's much-vaunted "liberal turn" is just a misunderstanding of the fact he isn't an accelerationist and doesn't want to see prevailing institutions collapse. He wants to take them over using crypsis and esoteric group-signaling using the same tactics he perceives have been used by Jews.
He wants the institutions to survive, so the next Christian-successor spiritual movement is ready to take the helm and reorient them in the same way they were taken over and reoriented against us.
Whites have not had any good reason to assume a collective defensive identity, defined to exclude another more numerous group.
To be clear, this has already happened in the United States, and for the vast majority of the history of the United States until very, very recently. That unification was inspired by the project of empire-building itself, not being victims in some "pogrom", no good civilization was born over identifying as Eternal Victims, and likewise Jewish identification and ethnocentrism was a cause for such progroms as much as the pogroms inspired ethnocentrism.
Collective identity is based on myth and propaganda, as it was in the United States, Rome, the British Empire, Greece, any great civilization, and certainly how it is for the Jews as well. No great civilization was ever built by a race of whiney victim-mongers.
It's another of many liberal precepts you still low-key hold, that in order to form a collective identity you must be a victim to be inspired to act that way. You don't need to be a victim, although I agree you need pressures to motivate the change. The pressures are already here. War with Russia, which has directly motivated greater European military buildup and integration. You have demographic change which is evoking racial backlash all over Europe as well as Canada and the United States. You have the threat of China, the African population bomb, you have Indian migration which judging by the Canadian subreddit has turned the average Canadian into an actual Nazi.
There are plenty of pressures, the project of European integration into a white identity has already happened in the US, and it wasn't based on identifying as some whiney eternal victim, or long-over struggle against the Indians. It's only modern-day liberalism that grants value for identification based on being a victim.
The pressures faced by Europe today are far, far greater than they were during the integration of European immigrants into the United States "white identity". At the turn of the century the country was 85%+ White, with the 15% blacks concentrated in the south and largely segregated. At the turn of the century New York city was 93% White. It's just not true that European integration on the American continent was motivated by blacks or Indians as a common enemy.
Jews who identify less as Jews are less likely to be endogamous. This just illustrates how idealistic things like "identity" actually do influence the breeding behavior of people, and why promotion of identity among White people is not a dead-end to promoting endogamy among White people.
In addition I don’t think you can discount that it’s likely gentile white subgroups still marry endogamously at much higher than random rates, for religious and/or regional and local demographic reasons.
I think you misunderstood my point, I do think that gentile white subgroups are naturally endogamous and that was my point. It's not a "dead-end" when it's something they seem inclined to do anyway, even with the apparatus of propaganda being optimized to try to discredit the natural tendencies that are associated with the pattern of behavior.
My point was that I don't think promoting endogamy among white people is at all a dead end; even after decades of promoting exogamy White Women still prefer White Men. It's certainly not a dead end.
The disparity between "secular" and Orthodox Jews only illustrates the importance of ideology and identity to tuning the level of endogamy. How is it a dead end when the experience of Jews shows how important identity is to the practice?
Whites are not under attack as whites in Europe. There is nothing like the DEI edifice, the mass affirmative action disfavoring whites, etc. If current demographic trends persist in Europe, that could certainly change, but as of right now there is no strong external pressure compelling Europeans to defensively adopt a shared white identity.
Obviously it's aspirational. You have the EU- so you already have an ever-growing political and financial integration of European countries, including movement across borders. You have NATO so you have a level of military integration, including major recent developments like Germany remilitarizing and France advocating for closer military ties among European countries.
We are already quite close to Pan-Aryan Imperium simply with the current powers of EU, NATO and growing political and financial integration of Europe. And then you have demographic change which is spurring populist movements in Europe and a racial consciousness. The conditions are absolutely conducive for the fostering of a pan-European racial consciousness or a European unification. But a "White racial consciousness" would be required for European Unification. Unifying Europe is a glorious aspiration, and it's not as impossible as you think.
German Unification seemed impossible for thousands of years, until it happened. American unification was a pie-in-the-sky idea, until it wasn't.
I also reject your notion that whites are not under attack, the demographic changes themselves are ipso facto an attack on White people, and they are increasingly perceiving them as such in Europe. Are White people able to stop or reverse demographic change without racial consciousness? It seems to be required.
An aspirational White identity already exists in the US, so the idea that European people can't just federally integrate into a single country, and then very shortly identify as White is disproven by history. The concept is extremely relevant to Europe.
The comparison to reparations is instructive, I think, because it reveals the cracks in the “black” racial coalition.
And yet... there's still a Congressional Black Caucus. And the NAACP. And many, many, many other organizations dedicated to black advocacy. All of these arguments also apply to Jews who often disagree among themselves vehemently.... And yet....
You are just inventing these roadblocks for why White people can't advocate for themselves that do not exist. None of the reasons you are giving for why White people can't organize are unique to the challenges faced by White identity, they apply to all other identities exactly the same and yet those other identities succeed in organizing to project political power, even if it fails in certain silly cases like reparations.
Reparations as a policy fails on so many fronts it's useless to point to as an example of political advocacy being made impossible or impractical by ambiguous cases of group identity. As you noted, the controversy isn't even who is "black" it is who is owed reparations and who is not. All of those groups are considered black for the purposes of political advocacy, but when assessing damages to some perceived harm that is a different entirely question. It's also just not a popular policy, a lot of Americans do not like handouts. Also, if we made an attempt to objectively settle the financial costs of harms caused by social relations between blacks and whites, then certainly the reparations would be owed to White people and not the other way around.
Jews choosing to live among other Jews would be an endogenous factor, sure. But it's a factor that is itself explained by the phenomenon of Group Identity and ideology directing breeding behavior. And even if you adjusted that for certain communities the level of endogamy among Jews is impossible to explain by chance. I know you bemoan it is even as low as it is (!), but it's certainly not a dead-end issue.

That is the funniest thing you have ever said, European peoples are incredibly more monophyletic than Jews, who themselves are 50% European among Ashkenazis. Even the notion they are descended from the Hebrews is dubious, compared to the more likely possibility of converts in the Roman Empire.
People don't even understand how static European race has been racially for thousands of years. A Spaniard from the south of Spain is more closely related genetically to a Norwegian than to a Moroccan.
Edit: I would also suggest that the intra-European racial animosity among Whites in the US- while I acknowledge that does express itself in different ways even today, it's still lower than it is between Jewish subgroups in Israel. And in any case the perception of Jewish Identity Politics among normies is not at all a function of the supposed monophyletic-ness of Jews, it's a function of the propaganda that has been transmitted to them their entire lives.
More options
Context Copy link