@SecureSignals's banner p

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

				

User ID: 853

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 853

Classical liberals had no problems integrating beliefs in race and HBD (far harder than even the most edgy 4channer today) with dedication to liberty.

Right off the bat, this is just extremely wrong. The contradiction of liberalism and HBD led to a Civil War, segregation, integration, and racial conflict that has never actually stopped, it's just changed form. Liberalism completely lost the plot on HBD, to the extent that HBD itself is radical and edgy, though true, and it is not accepted within our scientific or social institutions. Liberalism has led to a demographic replacement in the United States and Europe that is unprecedented in human history except in military conquests or war crimes. Classical liberalism in fact cannot integrate HBD, this has been proven by the fact that HBD denial became entrenched under its hegemony.

There is a niche that Hanania could have tried to fill by saying "HBD is true and it matters for policy, but classical liberalism provides the best policy taking into consideration the importance of HBD." But even he couldn't bring himself to say that, he just joined every other classical liberal in denying the importance of HBD to policy. So Hanania himself seems to think branding himself as a classical liberal means denying the importance of HBD to policy.

I can understand someone totally cynical and disilusioned, someone who freed himself from any delusions about "morals" "human rights" or "value of human life"

In my experience, the libertarian to dissident right pipeline is not motivated by people dropping concern for morals or rights, it's motivated by them realizing they have been completely duped into a sucker's game by embracing an individualist ethos while the rest of the world organizes collectively and along tribal lines, and in doing so crushes them politically and culturally. They then accept HBD and notice that all the libertarians they have known tend to be white or Jewish men, and reciting some Milton Friedman lectures is going to be unlikely to convert the masses to drop their own tribal identities. Their ideological commitment to Freedom and Liberalism in the English Tradition is just a figment of their own whiteness. They then notice that they are stopped from having any similar identity by forces which themselves heavily organize on tribal lines.

In Rationalist parlance you could say they go from mistake theorists to conflict theorists, which is not the same thing as dropping concern for morals or rights. It's when libertarians realize the claim that it's a "self-evident truth" that our rights come from God and our government is merely formed to protect them with minimal force is an outright Noble Lie. Our rights come from our government, our morals are framed by our culture.

"Caring about rights or morals", then, doesn't mean watching Milton Friedman lectures or trying to convince everyone to stop being collectivists while being crushed by the organizing power of those collectivists, it means competing for the reins of political power and cultural influence. This is understood by those who organize and identify on tribal lines, and who use that same collective group-behavior to deny white classical liberals the ability to do the same.

White people have to learn how to play identity politics, and to do so in a way that is positive, ambitious, affirmational, civilizational-oriented, and ultimately eugenic.

Telling everybody else that they are wrong for not being individualists, while the individualists get crushed by identity-oriented group behavior politically, culturally, demographically, is no real solution.

Advocating mass involuntary sterilization and mass deportation of every Hispanic who arrived after 1965 is far more radical than blaming Jews for wars in the Middle East or decline in institutional trust (although I ultimately think he is more doomed for his anti-semitism than he is for those other things).

You could say his anti-semitism was more understated compared to the other writings you find on OO, sure, but that is just comical. He contributed to the publication. It's one thing to read Kevin MacDonald's work, it's another to endorse it, it's another entirely to contribute to his publication... How can you do that and then remain in good standing in the mainstream center/right elite?

Nothing about what I said in this comment here is speaking to the sincerity of Hanania's beliefs, my comment is talking about Hanania being potentially useful to establishment thinking by providing an outlet for HBD acceptance within a classical liberal subculture.

I take Hanania at his word, I don't question his sincerity. Just because he's sincere doesn't mean he's not running from one bad idea to another on a poor intellectual foundation.

The other possibility is that Hanania is used as a sort of sanctioned dissident to divert the libertarian to dissident right pipeline back to "individualist libertarianism" but with more racism.

HBD denial among libertarians is probably the leading cause for that pipeline, Hanania could be useful for the establishment by integrating it with libertarianism. I think it's his Occidental Observer associations that are a bridge too far, though.

And you have to admit, by OO standards, Hanania’s writing is pretty mild.

No it's not, his emerged writings on sterilization and anti-feminism are more extreme than anything I've read in the DR in memory, although I was not around for the Dionysian 2016 "Alt-Right": the blind transgressionism did not appeal to me as it seemed to appeal to Hanania. I clung to the "racist libertarian" sensibilities to which Hanania has now retreated until having to face the reality that begging for everyone to be individualists does not work, and I became more influenced by the DR as it moved away from that sort of rhetoric that Hanania contributed to.

And I do believe he has changed his mind, I just don't think he's changed his mind for the right reasons. I don't think he's been influenced by arguments, I think he's been influenced by the incentives that could reward him or punish him based on what he says.

My guess is he’s still in the bottom quartile of antisemitism for Palestinians.

But that's not the population group we care about, it's elite or elite-adjacent influencers we should care about, and if Hanania is able to retain some status in that population that is significant. How many in that population group have gone on the record endorsing The Culture of Critique?

I would be interested in Hanania explaining the arguments that he may have formerly found in The Culture of Critique to be compelling, but now he does not think so. Given that he has retreated to "HBD doesn't matter for policy" I doubt he would give an honest answer for why his opinion on that work changed (if it has, technically nothing he wrote in his apology indicated a shift in view on this particular topic). He's just going to say whatever maximizes his chances of retaining his status, and he'll retcon it as a sort of moral enlightenment.

It may not cancel the publication of his book, but it's going to limit his ascendency. It would be remarkable if it did not. The biggest issues aren't even the edgy things he has said about sterilizing black people. He wrote for Counter-Currents and The Occidental Observer, which is Kevin MacDonald's publication. Here is one of his articles on The Occidental Quarterly:

I’m not one to be suspicious of an intellectual just because he happens to be Jewish. But Emory University’s Melvin Konner seems to be a character straight out of The Culture of Critique...

In another context, Konner called MacDonald “worrisome.” He must be. His work hits too close to home.

Either he gets cancelled, which he deserves for such an intellectually dishonest groveling (i.e. saying it doesn't matter for policy whether social outcomes are driven by racial differences), or he doesn't get cancelled and it's a big step towards the normalization of Dissident Right thinking.

Greg Johnson at Counter-Currents apparently did not know that Hoste was Hanania:

It turns out, though, that Richard Hanania and I go way back, and I didn’t even know it. From 2009 to 2011, I published Hanania under the pen name Richard Hoste, first at TOQ Online and then at Counter-Currents. Hoste was a joy to work with. He was intelligent, versatile, prolific, wrote well, had interesting insights, and was enthusiastic about exploring ideas. He was also a prompt correspondent and never threw diva fits over editing.

Hanania characterizes the views he published at Counter-Currents and similar platforms as “repugnant” and renounces them. Beyond that, he says that he was not entirely in earnest. He was “trolling.”

Sorry, but I am not buying it. Trolls post one-liners on social media. They do not read thousands of pages of densely-written academic works and write carefully-crafted multi-thousand-word reviews.

Richard Hanania is asking us to believe that the things he wrote under a pen name at White Nationalist and human biodiversity sites, including endorsing ideas from Kevin MacDonald’s The Culture of Critique, were not entirely in earnest, but that the more moderate and socially acceptable things he wrote under his own name — when he was both subject to cancellation and rewarded with money and status — are actually honest and sincere. Only a fool would believe that.

The most charitable interpretation of Richard Hanania’s career trajectory is that he remained race-wise and Jew-wise, but edged up to the mainstream to inject good ideas and shift the Overton window.

He was wildly successful. Hanania is not just an intelligent and energetic writer. He’s also an entrepreneur. He had a good thing going. So, when his real views were revealed, he panicked, cucked, and doubled down on the classical liberal, color-blind meritocracy cover.

It is a depressingly old pattern: smart libertarian and conservative nerds start noticing collectives, especially Jews and blacks, but as soon as there is a hint of pushback, they say, “But I treat everyone as an individual.” Basically, they realize that this a world of clashing tribes, in which individualism is a sucker’s game. Then they get scared — because they have no tribe to protect them — and signal to the enemy tribes (almost always Jews), “I’m an individualist, so even though I notice collectives, I won’t act on that knowledge. So you don’t have to destroy me. You can just play me for a sucker.”

It balances out if you are mentally deranged- maybe you would be happy to trade your child or friend or neighbor being killed for no good reason, so long as a random African is saved from AIDs, then you can consider "the ledger balanced". That's due to a derangement in your value system and not mine.

"Personal motives" include "being pressured by your own cabinet and Media apparatus", of which there is monumental evidence, whereas you just mentioned the "daddy revenge" theory which has no historical evidence. Indeed, the decision to invade Iraq and depose Saddam was not based on WMDs, it was predetermined by the written agenda of Zionists deeply embedded in the American foreign policy apparatus and the WMDs just became the last part of the narrative to tie a bow on the casus belli. Of course that same policy apparatus insisted that failing to institute regime change in Iraq in the Gulf War was HW's biggest mistake.

BTW, as for Bush, if we are counting lives lost and lost saved, he is probably on the positive side of the ledger.

American troops die for Israel alone in the desert, thousands of miles from their families, but hey Bush saved some Africans from AIDs so it all balances out.

his reasons were primarily that he wanted to avenge his father and secondarily that as a born-again Evangelical he had some weird eschatological views about war in the Middle East in general.

This is such a self-serving narrative, the blueprint for regime change in Iraq was written down by Zionists embedded in the American government for years before Bush II's invasion of Iraq, with the fabricated intelligence on WMDs likewise coming from Zionists in key positions in the highest places in American government. The last ingredient was 9/11, which created the American public demand for reprisal against the Arab world.

A Clean Break: A New Strategy for Securing the Realm (commonly known as the "Clean Break" report) is a policy document that was prepared in 1996 by a study group led by Richard Perle for Benjamin Netanyahu, the then Prime Minister of Israel.[1] The report explained a new approach to solving Israel's security problems in the Middle East with an emphasis on "Western values." It has since been criticized for advocating an aggressive new policy including the removal of Saddam Hussein from power in Iraq and the containment of Syria by engaging in proxy warfare and highlighting its possession of "weapons of mass destruction".

I remember reading the "Bush invaded Iraq as revenge for his father" in high school, and looking back it is astonishing those textbooks do not mention Zionists influence as playing any role whatsoever in the war, and likewise the Wikipedia article on PNAC makes not a single mention of Zionism or Israel. How long can that charade last, and can you ignore the elephant in the room?

There's an interesting discussion to be had about how Oppenheimer and many of his colleagues were Western Jews whose favorable opinions of communism came from academic hobnobbing and philosophical flirtation, and who were thus not keen on the idea of nuclear brinksmanship against the Soviets, versus other Jewish figures of the era like Teller, von Neumann and Ulam, whose native countries were under communist occupation.

One wonders how much of Oppenheimer's remorse was driven by the fact the bomb was used against Japan rather than Germany.

Testing my thinking, that's really it. If there is a better space on the internet for me to do so where would it be? Nowhere, it's either an echo chamber or an execution chamber everywhere else on the internet. It's really the only place where I can actually test my thinking.

This is certainly a solution, but the massive failures, predicted by Nietszche actually, tend to end in massive waves of blood drenching the world. It's happened twice already, and I think most modern leaders are understandable highly cautious when it comes to any sort of 'non-theistic Religion.'

It has happened many, many times, not just twice- the dividing lines between Ideology and Religion are more of an illusion than a reality.

I think most modern leaders are understandable highly cautious when it comes to any sort of 'non-theistic Religion.'

No they are not, they are highly cautious about defending their own non-theistic Religion, which we call "wokeness". Their core narrative is that their own non-theistic Religion is the One and True Just morality, and heretics have only ever covered the world in blood while their own ideology has liberated the masses. It's a highly convenient narrative, but it isn't true and their bloodlust against heretics is not driven by caution against non-theistic Religion, it's driven by fanaticism towards their own non-theistic Religion.

Religion and true Gods are supposed to give us something to map onto concepts that are difficult for humans to wrap their minds around. A worthy God (or pantheon) must embody concepts like bargaining with the future, cleansing the people of sin, helping people work together, and as you say steer people towards good values. (or a eugenic direction in your desacralized wording.)

I agree, but isn't this exactly what Marvel Comics does? Heroes in that canon achieve this same influence without demanding the audience believes the literal truth of the myths they portray. This was also similar to the Roman system, where there was certainly superstition among the laity but the essence of the Religion itself was civic ritual rather than a personal salvation cult based on belief in the literal truth of the myth of a dying-and-rising god. Abrahamic religion is is fairly unique in this regard in terms of demanding belief in the literal truth of the claimed miracles, and it did not appear to be a feature of European religious practice pre-Christianity.

The European gods were like tribal mascots, held dearly, but more like Comic-con on steroids than mass belief in the actual, literal resurrection of Jesus Christ.

Right now your main contention is that religion 'demands belief in miracles.' What if we could separate our understanding of religion from science, and see it through an experiential lense.

Yahwehism demands belief in the literal truth of the miracles it claims, but that is not a necessary feature of a religion per se. That is my point. If I were to "design a religion" and somehow use AI or something to meme it into existence, I wouldn't choose to make that a feature of my religion because it has proven to be vulnerable/killed by rationalism and enlightenment thinking.

There of course is the prospect, the likelihood, that all religion has always been consciously designed by a cultural elite in order to invoke a psychological effect in intended flocks. This is how Plato saw the Greek religion, and how Nietzsche saw Christian religion as well.

Nietzsche viewed the Death of God as an existential crisis, certainly, but he still welcomed it because he viewed it as a sink or swim moment for humanity. It's a moral crisis but it's also an opportunity for transcendence.

Religiosity is a personality trait like agreeableness or conscientiousness, and adopting atheism doesn't actually change your personality in that dimension, it just channels it through other causes, like atheism itself or communism or nationalism. Although I now reject Yahweh-ism, I don't feel I have become less religious in character. That inclination for religiosity is channeled through other causes. I also don't think "religiosity" is a personality defect that can or should be entirely crowded out by rationalism, it inspires people to do great things often manifests as self-sacrifice for a group cause.

I also don't think Nietzsche's intention was for all men to ascend to godhood, but for an extremely small number of worthy to do so and for the rest to be good followers. The former interpretation leads to the chaotic incompetence of everyone wanting to be a leader but nobody a follower, which is what you see today with Online Influencers fostering their own small communities but otherwise not cohering men together in a broader Religion. This also manifests in "Beta-male" being universally interpreted as an insult, whereas great men are nothing without worthy Beta-males. What would Napoleon have achieved if all of his followers fancied themselves as Alpha and thought it was some humiliation to be a loyal follower?

I think the solution is to consciously develop a new non-theistic Religion that doesn't rely on superstition or demand belief in miracles. Adherence to this religion should sacralize civilizational achievement, the Faustian spirit, and social conventions that steer society in a eugenic direction. It should oppose those who compromise these objectives with false gods and a false morality.

When you're on your deathbed, where will you look for comfort? What force or being or god will let you face your own death without flinching? What water will purify you?

Although I no longer believe in spiritual afterlife, I believe in more than ever a physical afterlife. I will look towards my children, who are my life after my death, a physical projection of my blood and spirit. Any successor-religion to Yahweh-ism should likewise elevate eternal life not as a matter of personal salvation, but group survival and thriving.

I disagree that Jewish American and gentile white American interests must be fundamentally hostile toward each other. But, of course, if gentile WNs are openly hostile toward Jews then Jews will continue to be hostile towards you

This is just a chicken and egg question. It's notable here that the entirety of Jewish recorded history is traced by conflict with various hegemons and civilizations: Egypt, Babylon, Assyria, Rome... Come 20th century America, I think White America naively expected the Jews to assimilate to the degree that, say, the Italians assimilated. That didn't happen, and you cannot blame White Nationalists for that. If Jews had assimilated to the degree of Italians, then you would have a point, but that did not happen. Jews retained a strong ethnocentrism, including a strong ethnonationalism towards a foreign country and hysterical opposition to anti-Semitism that doesn't resemble the ethnic struggle of any other European group which was folded into white culture. And that ethnic identity influenced the development of critical cultural and political institutions, to the determinant of the station of White Americans.

I will grant you that there are WNs more hellbent on revenge and score-settling, who hate Jews more than they love their own people, the National Justice Party comes to mind. But I will not grant you that the behavior of Jews was driven by these WNs, America accepted them with open arms and they retained strong loyalty to their own particular ethnos which they had internalized as fundamentally oppositional to White Gentiles (understandable given their religion is defined by struggle against Gentiles). That ethnocentricism systematically took the form of radical critique of White culture and morality throughout the 20th century and today.

WNs justify, for example, hostility towards black people with crime statistics, so why can't Jews justify hostility towards WNs with the 'crime statistics' of the Holocaust which - even under revionist interpretations - are still rather grim reading (huge expropriation, stripping of professional titles, imprisonment, deportation, mass shootings, impromptu pogroms etc.)?

Who says they can't? I'm not saying they can't, the even more pessimistic outlook is that Jews are justified in being hostile towards White identity. I am merely observing that they are hostile and that they will always be so. Isn't it even worse for you to admit, that because of WWII, Jews can never accept advocacy for white ethnic identity? If I were you, I would want to convince WNs that there is still a pathway for Jews to accept white ethnic advocacy, but I think we both know that is not the case precisely for the reason you have described right here.

Lastly, I think the smartest WNs are more open to practical relations on more equal terms with Jews than you would acknowledge. There are influential writers like Ron Unz, Gottfried, David Cole, who are appreciated broadly by WNs... the difference is those figures will grant that there is an unacceptable dynamic at play between the assertion of Jewish identity and white identity, whereas people like you take the position that the Jews are the eternal blameless victims, and this conflict is solely due to the deficiencies of non-Jews forcing them to be on the defensive. Given the experience of 20th century America, I cannot buy that, and you are just another example of someone who can't bring herself to attribute any sort of culpability to the behavior of Jews for the conflict we are talking about right now.

If WNs drop their anti-Semitism, you think Jews are going to all of a sudden start supporting white identity? I don't think so, and 20th century America is my evidence for my confidence in that conclusion.

https://cdapress.com/news/2023/jul/21/patriot-front-members-jailed-banned-cd/

Prosecutors had recommended the maximum fine of $5,000, as well as the maximum sentence of a year in jail, with 10 days of actual jail time and 40 hours of community service.

Wes Somerton, chief criminal deputy city attorney for Coeur d’Alene, suggested the Patriot Front members could be made to volunteer at a human rights organization in order to show them other viewpoints.

“Other people’s rights and voices do have a place in the fabric of America,” Somerton said.

In court Friday, the defendants each addressed the court, saying they respected the jury’s decision but maintained that their intent was to peacefully protest in Coeur d’Alene, not incite a riot.

When they recently attempted to crash a MAGA rally they got their asses kicked by the attendees. Not a particularly popular bunch even among the demographic they're trying to target for recruiting and persuasion.

Well, that's not Patriot Front in that video...

They had written plans showing that this is what they were going to do. They've done many protests with the same U-haul, uniforms, and shields and that is exactly what they have done every time. There was no evidence presented that they planned to riot this time in contradiction with every single other protest they have done in the past few years. A jury can get things wrong, you know, especially if the prosecutors and courts are biased against a defendant.

Rousseau's attorney claims that one of the phones which was handed to the FBI (without anybody having seen a warrant apparently) contained footage of the dress rehearsal of the march the day before... you have written plans showing an organized protest, a history of organized protest with the exact same uniform and materials, potential footage of the dress rehearsal of an organized protest... yes, I can say I know they they were not planning to riot and the jury got it wrong.

They were arrested for trying to protest a drag event, which has become popular in conservative circles. I'm not sure that a judge would be more sympathetic than an average person.

You made a claim that the convictions are legally dubious.

They are legally dubious because the evidence is that they were going to protest in the exact same way they have protested in many other cases with the exact same uniform, shields, flag poles... I didn't say the arrests were dubious because police have to wait for a crime to happen before making an arrest. You are responding to an argument nobody has made.

This amounts to a claim that, when police have evidence that people are conspiring to commit a crime, they must wait for them to actually commit the crime before arresting them, in case the police are mistaken

We are not talking about an arrest, we are at the point where it has supposedly been proven beyond reasonable doubt that they were conspiring to riot. I am saying it would have been harder to have made that case if they had started the march before being arrested.

I know exactly what PF was going to do when they got to the event. They were going to leave the U-haul, form a column with flags, march and chant and then leave. That's what they have done in every single case. They don't even let the rank-and-file talk or interact with counter-protestors during the march precisely for these reasons. Arresting them before they even started made the job of the prosecution much easier, that was my point.

If the situation had unfolded, the prosecution would have had a harder time making case.

Saying it's "NOT notable" is just flatly wrong, it is a notable fact of the case, even if it is technically true that a conspiracy doesn't require waiting until the act is carried out.

It's notable because, in an alternative universe where they did arrive at the park and marched as they had planned to and exactly in the manner they have been documented to march in every single other case, it would have been harder to allege a conspiracy to riot. So it's notable that the case is easier given that they did not have an opportunity to demonstrate that they were there to protest. It seems unlikely to me they would have been arrested for marching if they had made it that far, only stopping them before they could start gave the prosecution a case here.

I'm not familiar with formatting standards here it seems pretty case-by-case. It's a long post with 2 issues, the jury trial and the Idaho Tribune article, so I used a Markdown header to separate them.

Edit: Changed to a smaller header format.

I recommend watching this brief video from the PF leader published yesterday as a response to the convictions if you want to get a sense... they are true believers in Americana and they are betting on the average Joe rather than a Judge. I've wondered the same thing, as a Judge would be sticking his or her neck out there with a guilty verdict without a Jury to provide for cover.

But the Judge didn't dismiss the charges, and sentenced them to jail. Although the prosecutors were calling for the max 1-year sentence and mandatory volunteering at a Civil Rights NGO, and the judge actually provided a much lighter sentence than that.

Patriot Front's Conspiracy to Riot in Coeur d'Alene Idaho

This is another post in what has become a series covering widespread lawfare against dissident-right activists, previously I have covered:

The arrest of the Patriot Front men on their way to protest in Idaho (seen here from their perspective) became a big news story, with the dox and mugshots widely published and applauded, even as anti-hate NGOs admitted that rioting was not the M.O of the group. At the time, even I didn't think the charges stood a chance of going anywhere, even if police wanted to argue for probable cause there was no way a prosecutor would dig a little into the group, see quite clearly they intended to protest in the exact way that have been documented to protest over a dozen times, and then claim that these men came to riot. But I was wrong, and charges were pursued on a single count of "conspiracy to riot."

30 out of 31 members pled Not Guilty and opted for jury trials, 1 member pled guilty to a lesser charge of disturbing the peace and was sentenced to 180 days in jail with 179 days suspended. The first jury trial of 5 members who pled not-guilty to conspiracy charges was concluded last week, where a jury of 6 unanimously found them guilty of conspiracy to riot. They were sentenced to 5 days in jail with 2 days served and banned from downtown for a year.

Having followed the trial in various news stories, the evidence provided by the prosecution seemed to solely entail potentiality, as in "these shields could be used to bash people, and the flagpoles could have been used to hit people from behind the shields." It was noted that the shields the men were carrying had scratches on them and the flagpoles were longer than normal as suspicious, even while the testifying officers admitted that other protestors were open carrying, and it is not illegal to have a shield.

It's notable here that the members were arrested on their way to protest, they did not even have the opportunity to leave the vehicle. All indications are that they planned to march in the exact manner they have done many times before. My confusion, even after following the coverage, is whether or not the prosecution is alleging that this behavior would have constituted a riot, or if they solely relied on speculation for how the shield and flag poles and such could have been used to riot. If the Patriot Front had made it to the park and marched, would they have been arrested for rioting? I don't think so, somehow stopping them before they even had the opportunity gave the prosecution more leeway to plant in the minds of the jury all the things they could have done when they got to the park. It's not clear how this conviction will impact the other trials.

Needless to say, civil rights organizations are not lining up to defend these men (in contrast, the "civil rights conspiracy" Charlottesville lawsuit was concocted in a Manhattan office with a multimillion, NGO-funded war chest, with a lead attorney who compared the lawsuit to the Warsaw ghetto resistance). The PF men have relied on public defenders and faith in the jury process.

FBI Whistleblower Reveals Malfeasance In Patriot Front Trial (?)

The one form of institutional opposition to this prosecution has come from an article published last week by the Idaho Tribune. This trial is only the tip of the iceberg. Not only were PF men arrested, doxed, and charged with conspiracy to riot, but their phones were handed over to the FBI by the State for data extraction. The prosecution claims it cannot present the phones to the defendants in their conspiracy cases, as the State no longer as possession of the evidence. It turns out, nobody from the State ever saw a warrant for those phones before, or since, handing them over to the FBI. Not only that, but according to a whistleblower an FBI SSRA in Idaho was removed from his position because he refused to a sign a warrant for the phones due to lack of probable cause:

“I have friends who are in Couer D'alene who refused to write a Search Warrant for PF [Patriot Front] phones because the PC [probable cause] didn't exist. FBI HQ removed the supervisor from his position.” ...

A second source that will remain anonymous confirmed to the Tribune that Shoffstall was asked to write a warrant to procure data in the phones of the detained Patriot Front members.

After Shoffstall refused, he was punished. Sources tell the Tribune that he was sent on a “special assignment” to work at the FBI’s National Threat Operation Center, which is essentially a call center, where Schoffstall would ride a desk, instead of continuing his work in the field.

The Idaho Tribune was able to speak with Special Agent Schoffstall, who confirmed that he is no longer assigned to the Coeur d’Alene office because he is on a “temporary assignment,” and that he cannot disclose any further information...

In a court proceeding held on Tuesday July 18th, Thomas Rousseau’s public defender Kinzo Mihara vigorously argued that his client should be able to get data from his phone that depicts “the dress rehearsal from the day before” the events of June 11th.

However, the prosecution in all of these cases has not made these phones, nor the warrant that allowed the FBI to perform data extractions on the phones, available to the defense.

Mihara argued saying:

"We want media files from that phone… We have no evidence from the state of what was done, who did it when they did it, why they did it…

“Where is this search warrant? What search warrant? Which judge signed the search warrant? What was the material to be seized, the information to be looked for? Why don't we have it back? In a recent case I have search warrant from here signed by your Honor. It's to seize a black box out of a truck. They seized the black box, they left the copy of the warrant. If you're gonna grab physical items, our constitution demands it being pursuant to a warrant. And the criminal rules, both federal and state, cited to the court demand as copy of the warrant be turned over. We had no warrant from the state and we have no, we have no communications from law enforcement, which another judge in this court, judge Randalls expressly ruled to that. That's fair game. We asked for it. We want it, your Honor. We asked for it way back in February and it hasn’t been turned over.”

IANAL, so I cannot tell how serious this issue is, but reading through this brief it seems Rousseau's attorney is claiming the phones contain potentially-exculpatory evidence and that the State has "parked" the evidence with an FBI based on a warrant that nobody has ever seen and has not been provided to the defense.

The State's argument in this case is dangerous. Any time it wishes to shield exculpatory evidence from a criminal defendant, the State merely needs to have a law enforcement officer "park" the evidence with a federal law enforcement colleague and claim that it cannot produce such evidence ... taking it out of reach of a criminally-accused defendant. This is antithetical to due process and embodies the very tyranny our forefathers saw in their British masters.

In these cases, from what I can tell the public defenders have done a good job and they are receiving a good defense, though maybe not the best money could buy. But I'm not sure what exculpatory evidence could be on the phone: it seems the prosecution wasn't even denying that they planned to march in the way they've done every other time, they were just arguing that their actual plans constituted a plan to riot.

Lessons Learned

So you're right wing, but anonymously shit-posting online isn't enough for you, you want to organize IRL. Maybe you want to march with your friends against a Pride event. Well you better be prepared to be arrested, doxed with your face plastered in national news, charged with a conspiracy, and have your phone be handed to the FBI. Some people on the DR argue that it's an "overly online" movement, but this case shows that IRL activism is at the moment not worth the risk.

Patriot Front has some cringe optics, Rousseau's speeches are really cringe, but if their activism is accomplishing anything, it's exploring the boundaries of legal right-wing expression, which is not where you would expect it to be based on 1A protections.