@SecureSignals's banner p

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

				

User ID: 853

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 853

Here's a link on the Indian caste system being Harappan.

https://www.gnxp.com/WordPress/tag/india-genetics/

I noticed the article makes similar claims that steppe ancestry wasn't related to social class in ancient Greece:

In the near future the ancient DNA group led by David Reich will publish a bunch of stuff, and one paper will note that the variation in steppe ancestry in the Bronze Age Greeks did not have class implications. In other words, the ancient Greeks did not have a caste system as you might find in India

Who was the god among the Greco-Romans venerated as embodying the highest degree of power and beauty- worshipped as "The Most Greek" of the gods? It was Apollo the Hyperborean. Apollo was likewise known as Archegetes, meaning Apollo was a founder of civilizations and a colonizer, who "took pleasure" in the creation of cities and contrived their existence. The god embodies a race of civilizational founders who emerged from a northern realm. In the 4th century AD, the physician Adamantius described the "true Greek" - or where the "Hellenic race has been kept pure" as:

Wherever the Hellenic and Ionic race has been kept pure, we see proper tall men of fairly broad and straight build, neatly made, of fairly light skin and blond...

The Ionians in particular were understood as directly descended from Apollo.

Apollo was described as the most beautiful and perfect of the gods, establishing a breeding model and aspirational model for men. Here we see the Indo-European, Nordic type posited as a physical ideal among the ancient Greeks. Apollo is the unequivocal embodiment of the Indo-European gene worshipped by the Greco-Romans. The basis for your assertion that the Indian Caste system has non-IE origins is rationalized in your article with:

India is different. It has jati-varna, with varna being caste as you would understand, but jati being one of thousands of endogamous “communities” in the subcontinent. At first, like many, I assumed this had something to do with the Indo-Aryan migration into the subcontinent, but I noticed a few things early on... jati is peculiarly India, even if varna is not.

But caste subdivision was a fact of Greco-Roman civilization. In Ancient Greece the Phratry controlled access to civic society and citizenship. Phratry was itself considered a subdivision of Phyle- tribe, or clan. There were subdivisions within the Phratry known as Genos, from which we derive the modern words gene or genetics.

Unequivocally, in Greco-Roman society we see an identical concern with genetics as religion, including castes and their subdivisions, in the amelioration of an Indo-European gene. This is to say, the caste system in India is Indo-European, and after all both jati and varna are words of Indo-European origin.

Never heard of this author, but if you're looking for reactionary interpretation of ancient history you should check out Survive the Jive who produces popular content in those circles.

This is absurd, I am not evading the question. One of the best aspects of the American project is the formation of a pan-European ethnic identity, which has entailed the mixing of distinguishable European groups into a "white" identity. That is a political project, and ethnogenesis, that I support.

I don't support the political project of Sweden becoming Middle Eastern. I doubt Jews would support the project of racially integrating with the Palestinians.

I answered your question: I am not against it in principle, but I am concerned with the political motives and outcomes of that social organization, which everyone always has been throughout all of human history, and this concern took the form of religion.

My tongue-in-cheek answer was meant to demonstrate the hostility of encouraging endogamy for your ingroup and exogamy for your outgroup. Seems pretty hostile, doesn't it? It's only tongue-in-cheek, I have an unreciprocated respect for Jewish ethnic identity and I wouldn't seriously demand that they race-mix with the Palestinians to smooth racial tension.

Again, can you explain your point with respect to my claim? Are you claiming the caste system in India has non-Indo European origins? Is it not an example of a genetic strategy as a religion as I have said? Hinduism is the expression of the unique combination of genes and environment on the continent, I wouldn't expect it to be identical to all IE civilizations. But caste endogamy is absolutely a common feature in IE civilization and that feature in Indian civilization has IE origins.

The Roman Republic certainly experienced genetic change as it expanded, and the prominence of the Patrician class waned as the empire decayed (isn't there a lesson there if we contrast Rome with the longevity of Indian civilization?) But we still see an IE civilization with a caste system that correlated with steppe ancestry, conquering nations with lower steppe ancestry until it itself was conquered by barbarians with greater steppe ancestry.

I get the feeling you don't understand how extreme endogamy has to be to maintain genetic differences over long periods of time.

According to David Reich, "the population that contributed genetic material to South Asia was (roughly) 60% Yamnaya [my note: European steppe ancestry], ~30% European farmer-like ancestry".

Even with the particularly endogamous features of Indian civilization, modern day Northern Europeans bear far greater genetic similarity to the bronze age migrants, including the Aryans, than any peoples in India. I would likewise say the Bell Beaker-derived Patricians of Rome bore far greater genetic similarity to these Aryans than any modern population in India, with that similarity decaying as the Roman Empire integrated other nations into civic society.

Endogamy is a greater concern in IE civilizations with greater diversity including: South Africa, Latin America, Colonial America, the British Empire. Granted none of those are like the Hindu caste system, and those are all examples of post-Christianization European civilizations which would again support my argument for religious changes being synonymous with changes in genetic strategy (the Catholic church outlawing cousin marriage is significant here). Still, those civilizations had caste system with high levels of endogamy including in America, where the colonials resisted mixing with the natives.

How can you not tell you can see it on their faces.

Well we have more precise ways for understanding genetic similarities. I would be interested to know the Yamnayan ancestry for different sub-populations in Iran, including the sub-populations you claim are more genetically similar to the Aryans than the Brahmin. I don't necessarily doubt it I'm just not aware of that data. I see this guy on Reddit, that's significant Yamnaya ancestry but not that close to the Brahmin.

The level of endogamy in India is more likely due to natural pressures of a small ruling class in a highly diverse, increasingly urbanized continent. There are high levels of endogamy among Afrikaners, Québécois, and ruling elite like the Habsburg family. There is ample precedent. Are you saying that the level of endogamy among the Brahmin caste is not motivated by perpetuating the ancestry of a ruling class, it's motivated coincidentally by an unrelated indigenous tradition? I don't quite understand the point you are making here.

because in Mycenean Greece there was absolutely no correlation between steppe ancestry and social status.

That's a strong statement based on a small number of samples... The societal organizations which are most relevant to our discussion, the phratry, the phyle appeared to emerge in the 1st century B.C. Asserting that these organizations were unrelated to steppe ancestry is premature and most likely incorrect given the likely indo-european origin of these social organizations. Granted there is a lack of ancient DNA from Greece and the small number of samples we do have from Mycenean Greeks shows lower steppe ancestry than other Southern Europeans, and in particular their northern Macedonian neighbors. And it's worth pointing out Alexander the Great was Macedonian.

The non-Indo-European Etruscans were genetically identical to their Itallic neighbors.

My understanding is that Etruscans derived slightly over 50% from Bell Beaker-derived peoples who migrated there during the Bronze Age. Of course the Bell Beakers did not have pure steppe ancestry, but there is still a significant base of Steppe ancestry in Italy before Roman conquest of the peninsula. The Romans who conquered the Etruscans and became ruling class almost certainly had greater Bell Beaker admixture than the Etruscans and therefore more steppe ancestry. The Etruscans did not speak an Indo-European language so the Roman conquerors certainly had more steppe ancestry as IE speakers.

The linked study found the Etruscans derived [their] entire ancestry from other European populations such as the earlier Bell Beaker group from northern Italy and Iron Age populations from southern Europe so the Roman empire is absolutely inseparable from IE ancestry and culture:

This analysis demonstrated around 25% ancestry from such a distal steppe-related source, which reached around 50% when comparative populations were reduced to those more proximate in time and space than the Yamnaya, e.g., central European Bell Beakers

Of course as Rome conquered foreign nations (with less IE ancestry), we again see the emergence of a caste system correlated with European steppe ancestry in a sprawling empire. Notably, Rome never conquered Germania and was itself conquered by foreign barbarians with more steppe ancestry than the increasingly-admixed Roman ruling class.

Eastern Iranians are more Aryan than Brahmins

I'm aware that Y-haplogroups highly correlate with urban centers in Iran like Tehran, and therefore social and political class, but I'm not aware of Eastern Iranians having more European steppe ancestry than Brahmins. I'll take a look later.

Propensity for genetic disease is only one dimension of fitness for some objective like maintaining a ruling class or group survival as a diaspora with strong loyalties to an ancient, foreign religion. There are tradeoffs, but propensity for genetic disease isn't strictly inferior to other traits like IQ or religious zealousness in realizing these group-level objectives.

I'm not sure where the attribution of the caste system to the Harappans comes from, if you have anything to read about that I would be interested. The earliest description of the caste system comes from the Sanskrit (Aryan language) Rigveda. All indications are that the caste system was created to preserve the genes of a conquering ruling class in the framework of a religion with inherited priestly function.

You don't see anything like it from the Iranian branch of the Aryans.

Persia was conquered by the Arab Muslim jihad- and jihad, it should be noted, is another stark example of group-level genetic strategy as religion along with Hinduism and Judaism. The Jihad is the reason for the ethnic composition of Iran today, and a quick search shows < 9% frequency of R1a in Iran compared to a 57% frequency among Rajasthan Brahmin.

So we see persistence of a caste system where Aryan genes have been preserved, and no caste system where they were conquered. All Indo-European civilizations have had some form of a caste system, with the Phratry in Ancient Greece, which also contained elements of inherited priestly function, attributed to Indo-European origins. And of course the Patrician class in ancient Rome emerged with the Italian conquest by the Indo-European derived peoples who became the founders of Rome. This is not to deny by any means that the caste system and Hinduism in India is heavily influenced by contributions from all its indigenous populations, it's to say that this is a common a feature of Indo-European civilizations, and we don't see it where those genes no longer exist.

Edit: As an aside, here's a really interesting comparison of Sanskrit with Lithuanian that puts the cultural similarity in perspective:

Sanskrit: Kas tvam asi? Asmi svapnas tava tamase nakte. Agniṃ dadau te śradi tada viśpatir devas tvam asi.

Lithuanian: Kas tu esi? Esmi sapnas tavo tamsioje naktyje. Ugnį daviau tau širdy, tada viešpatis dievas tu esi.

English: Who are you? A dream in your dark night. I gave you the fire in your heart, so you are god our lord.

And

Sanskrit: Kas tava sūnus?

Lithuanian: Kas tavo sūnus?

English: Who is your son?

Not necessarily, I think the Israeli-Palestinian conflict could be resolved if they all just loved and married each-other and became one peoples. The Jewish religion is passed matrilineally, so there could be TV campaigns in Israel promoting Jewish women to take Palestinian men and I wouldn't have a principled opposition to that.

Yeah, that was the article I saw and I realized the interviewee was a different person working on a similar project:

I saw an Israeli television campaign that showed faces on trees and bus stops, like missing children ads. A voice-over said, “Have you seen these people? Fifty percent of young Jewish people outside of Israel marry non-Jews. We are losing them.”

It's interesting to contrast the description of that television campaign with the campaigns we see in the United States, which would be a good example of what the article you linked is identifying.

Also, as @2rafa has pointed out before, a lot of Jews and Jewish NGOs, including George Soros, advocate for increased non-Jewish immigration to Israel.

The "both-sidesing" is so tiresome, we are allowed to take stock of the net impact while recognizing there is a distribution of advocacy and influence among Jews. The net impact is that we see Jewish influence hostile to European race consciousness and heavily affine to Jewish race consciousness. Even assuming an exogamy rate of 50% in the United States, given the small proportion of Jews among the population in America that implies an enormous endogamous influence from Jewish identity.

I'm not sure there's a paradox here so much as there are Jews on both sides of the issue... Conservative and religious Jewish advocacy for an increase in fertility is no different than Mormon advocacy; incidently, the latter rate is higher than the former, and even secular Jews in Israel are below replacement level. This isn't evidence of some "hypocrisy" or scheming among Jews.

The key point is that religion and culture manipulates breeding behavior towards eugenic or dysgenic ends. Is the Brahmin being a hypocrite when he comes to America and joins the chorus of anti-racism and denounces eugenic-minded thinking for white people? It's his religion! There is, in fact, nothing hypocritical or paradoxical about preaching eugenics for your people and preaching dysgenics for your outgroup. If you are in competition with other tribes, this is going to be a powerful strategy, particularly if you can convince your outgroup that dysgenic behavior is the realization of a universal moral good, and eugenic behavior is the ultimate evil. It's ultimately tribalistic, not conspiratorial or hypocritical or paradoxical.

Religion, culture, and eugenics are one. This fact is understood foremost by the Jews, who have carried this knowledge through the millennia within their myths. Take the Book of Genesis: Jacob, the Patriarch of the Jewish people, swindles a herd of sheep from his father-in-law by peeling the bark off the tree. Seeing the striped tree, the white and black sheep interbreed and Jacob the Deceiver wins the flock of speckled sheep. This myth portrays ancient knowledge of the use of media for eugenic purposes, and it's important to recognize here that sheep are symbolic for people in biblical myth.

Of course Judaism is not the only religion that transmits an ancient knowledge of eugenics through the medium of religion, the Hindu caste system could be regarded as one of the most successful eugenic programs in human history, with most Brahmin to this day possessing the Aryan haplogroup R1a1 that has been inherited unbroken from the paternal line. It would be inaccurate to call this a conspiracy or eugenics with the veneer of religion, the religion is eugenics and eugenics is the religion.

There are of course some instances of outright hypocrisy, like LessWrong advocates for polygenic embryo screening falling over themselves trying to explain why it's not eugenics:

In my view, the term “eugenics” should not be used to describe embryo screening. In most people’s minds “eugenics” conjures images of government-sponsored sterilization efforts, genocide, and racist pseudoscience. I understand the technical definition is just “good for genes”, but this is not what comes to mind for most people when they hear this word.

Even worse, most of the horrible things done in the name of “eugenics” in the past were in fact not eugenic at all! The entire Nazi theory of genes was based on a fundamental misunderstanding of how genes worked. They believed that non-aryan peoples were “contaminating” the “pure aryan bloodline”, and that only by purging those who were unpure could they make a perfect master race. Which is of course not just a morally repugnant theory, but also wrong.

If you want to have a productive conversation, I would suggest using the term “epilogenics” to describe non-coercive means of improving genes that are in line with what we expect those affected would want. There are of course still some concerns with epilogenics (increasing inequality for example), but they are decidedly NOT the same concerns that people have about eugenics.

Here is a case where we see a sheer hypocrisy, but I don't even know if the author of this LW article is Jewish- although I suspect many Jews will make a similar argument as they use polygenic embryo screening. The more profound behavior we see in this article is the familiar use of the Holocaust to denounce eugenic thinking for white people, which is actually the crux of the issue.

With the understanding that religion, culture, and eugenics are inseparable, then we must relate the genetic trajectory of the nation and Europe to its sacred myths, and there is no myth more sacred today than the Holocaust. Understanding the Holocaust as the body of myth that formulates the prevailing civic religion, the issue becomes much deeper than merely a question of hypocrisy. It's a religion that denounces European race consciousness as the ultimate evil and all behaviors against European race consciousness as the ultimate good. It's the anti-caste system, where the civic religion is used to deconstruct and destroy rather than moralize a race consciousness that would be required for eugenic-minded behavior and culture.

The article you link traces the use of this civic religion to derail eugenic-minded thinking within the Academy and culture writ large. There is a full knowledge and recognition of where this breeding program is headed, best illustrated by Lise Funderburg's National Geographic feature, The Changing Face of America: We've become a country where race is no longer so black or white.

Certainly, race still matters in this country, despite claims that the election of Barack Obama heralded a post-racial world. We may be a pluralist nation by 2060, when the Census Bureau predicts that non-Hispanic whites will no longer be the majority. But head counts don’t guarantee opportunity or wipe out the legacy of Japanese-American internment camps or Jim Crow laws. Whites, on average, have twice the income and six times the wealth of blacks and Hispanics, and young black men are twice as likely as whites to be unemployed. Racial bias still figures into incarceration rates, health outcomes, and national news: A recent Cheerios commercial featuring an interracial family prompted a barrage of negative responses, including claims of white genocide and calls for “DIEversity.”

...

When people ask Celeste Seda, 26, what she is, she likes to let them guess before she explains her Dominican-Korean background. She points out that even then she has revealed only a fraction of her identity, which includes a Long Island childhood, a Puerto Rican adoptive family, an African American sister, and a nascent acting career. The attention she gets for her unusual looks can be both flattering and exhausting. “It’s a gift and a curse,” Seda says.

It’s also, for the rest of us, an opportunity. If we can’t slot people into familiar categories, perhaps we’ll be forced to reconsider existing definitions of race and identity, presumptions about who is us and who is them. Perhaps we’ll all end up less parsimonious about who we feel connected to as we increasingly come across people like Seda, whose faces seem to speak that resounding line from Walt Whitman’s “Song of Myself

“I am large, I contain multitudes.”

There's a recognition, celebration, that this is what Americans will look like in 2050, and this is absolutely downstream of the prevailing cultural and religio-political myth that defines the boundaries of our ways of thinking about race and eugenics. This is far more important than any individual-level hypocrisy, and after all pointing out a hypocrisy can be cathartic but it never motivates a rethinking of things and doesn't reach the crux of the issue in any case.

I mean race formation, checking the definition of "ethnogenesis" I see:

the formation and development of an ethnic group

Which is the sense in which I am using the term, by saying that this is far more important than secondary issues like taxes. If a Swede doesn't want his ethnic identity to become half Middle-Eastern, he shouldn't have to voice his objections in terms of some accountant analyzing a tax ledger.

You are inclined to learn Japanese and respect the local culture, my point is it's not reasonable to expect that same behavior from masses of third world economic migrants. If a Japanese person wanted to maintain Japanese culture, it would be a bad idea to import masses of people who are unlike the Japanese and expect they will adopt the "when in Rome" mentality that you have. Culture is more dynamic than people and their personalities, it's more likely the culture is going to change than a Paki is going to start acting like a Swede.

If mases of Turks or Syrians moved to Japan, how many Japanese people would say "oh well, being Japanese is an idea that has nothing to do with ethnicity so these are now fellow Japanese people"?

I'll trust your judgement on that question, but why would their response be so different than the Swede who feels compelled to voice his objection by couching it in terms of taxes?

I don’t see the point of trying to freeze the ethnic map of the world at any particular point in time, as these things are always in flux.

I completely agree with that, but that is also the point I am trying to get across to OP. This isn't really about crime or taxes, it's about ethnogenesis, which is monumentally more important than any of those issues.

I also don't see value in trying to freeze the ethnic map of the world, but being conscious of its direction is of extreme importance, and hiding those anxieties behind complaints about crime or taxes is the road to failure. Ideally, you would rationally and intelligently influence the ethnic map of the world to achieve some desirable outcomes.

I came close to berating several shopkeepers in my broken Swedish for their lack of respect towards their new home.

I'm not trying to be snarky when I say that this is just a lack of cultural sensitivity on your part. If you put a mouse in a barn do you berate it for not acting like a horse? They are not Swedish and they never will be, you either accept that along with the concurrent changes in Swedish language and culture or you get serious about the problem of ethnogenesis.

I second @2rafa's take. You know how most academics will heavily lean on "just-so" stories to explain social phenomena without recognizing HBD? And then on the other side HBD bloggers heavily rely on studies and data and plots to try to make the strongest case possible? Dutton is the guy who uses HBD to tell just-so stories: usually entertaining, probably some insights and elements of truth, but he's much less rigorous than any other HBD-type blogger I'm aware of.

So you would be fine with Denmark becoming significantly or even majority Chinese if it meant lower crime and higher tax income? I ask because so many conservatives try hard to convince themselves that it's not about race when they oppose illegal immigration, but they are just in denial.

"Being English has nothing to do with ethnicity", yes I would say that is the perspective of someone who has been brainwashed. How do you think such a prevailing opinion has come to be? Do you think if the culture were different then the public would have a different opinion?

Let's take this story from a few days ago: Anglo-Saxons aren’t real, Cambridge tells students in effort to fight ‘nationalism’

Cambridge is teaching students that Anglo-Saxons did not exist as a distinct ethnic group as part of efforts to undermine “myths of nationalism”...

Its teaching aims to “dismantle the basis of myths of nationalism” by explaining that the Anglo-Saxons were not a distinct ethnic group, according to information from the department.

The department’s approach also aims to show that there were never “coherent” Scottish, Irish and Welsh ethnic identities with ancient roots.

The increased focus on anti-racism comes amid a broader debate over the continued use of terms like “Anglo-Saxon”, with some in academia alleging that the ethnonym is used to support “racist” ideas of a native English identity.

Information provided by the Department of Anglo-Saxon, Norse and Celtic (ASNC) explains its approach to teaching, stating: “Several of the elements discussed above have been expanded to make ASNC teaching more anti-racist.

“One concern has been to address recent concerns over use of the term ‘Anglo-Saxon’ and its perceived connection to ethnic/racial English identity.

“Other aspects of ASNC’s historical modules approach race and ethnicity with reference to the Scandinavian settlement that began in the ninth century.

“In general, ASNC teaching seeks to dismantle the basis of myths of nationalism - that there ever was a ‘British’, ‘English’, ‘Scottish’, ‘Welsh’ or ‘Irish’ people with a coherent and ancient ethnic identity - by showing students just how constructed and contingent these identities are and always have been.”

...

However, the term Anglo-Saxon has recently become embroiled in controversy, with some academics claiming that the term Anglo-Saxon has been used by racists – particularly in the US – to support the idea of an ancient white English identity, and should therefore be dropped.

Cambridge teaching its students that there are no English, Scottish, Irish, or Welsh ethnic identities could be considered brainwashing or education depending on your perspective. But whatever term you choose, the fact remains is that public opinion is indeed trained by these institutions.

These students, as learning agents, are being trained to believe that "being English has nothing to do with ethnicity", which is a complete lie from any reasonable perspective that would acknowledge the biological reality of an English ethnic identity. LLMs are fine-tuned by similar people with similar methods and for similar motives.

If these cultures and institutions rallied around a real history of English ethnic heritage which recognizes the Anglo-Saxons, public opinion would be very different, and public opinion was different when the narrative described in that article was the popular narrative.

The LLM disagrees with me as well, and for basically the same reasons: it's been trained to think that.

Thanks for the links, one important point though is that this shouldn't matter for Denmark to not want to become Indian, Chinese, or MENAPT. I don't care if the Chinese have positive tax contributions and lower criminal behavior than Danes, I don't want Denmark to become Chinese. Opponents of immigration shouldn't fall into the trap of "it's not about race, it's about crime and tax dollars". That didn't work in the US, it's not going to work in Denmark. It is about race.

And so whatever Tarshish means, it means something convoluted involving wealth and opulence from far away, and perhaps this convolution is to a greater meaning.

Tarshish was a son of Javan, who is understood as descended from the Aryan figure Japheth. The meaning of Tarshish would indicate a city settled by Japhetites, and therefore Jonah fleeing the Jewish God's "presence" to an Aryan city.

Do you think in that situation with the exact same facts of the confrontation between the protestors/counter-protestors BLM protestors would face these charges as well? Or do you acknowledge that the political viewpoint is decisive here in how the case has been handled?

The fact that it is "politically motivated" has nothing to do with... whether this prosecution is a threat to freedom of speech

The fact the prosecution is politically motivated does mean it is a threat to free speech. It means if you want to participate in a protest with a political idea that is being persecuted, like protesting demographic change, there is a risk that the prosecutors will be politically motivated to cause as much legal trouble for you as possible, even stretching statutes that would be impossible to predict, like "burning an object with an intent to intimidate". That risk doesn't exist for protestors with other political viewpoints.

I just saw your edit, they circled the counter-protesters because the counter-protesters positioned themselves at the statue they were marching to... This is why the political motivation of the prosecution matters. If you are planning a protest, and it gets disrupted by counter-protestors who intentionally position themselves in the direction of your demonstration, then you run the risk of being charged with a felony for "intimidation" if you continue the demonstration?

If the situation were reversed, and White Nationalists gathered in the path of a BLM torch-lit march to counterprotest the BLM march, do you think the BLM protestors would have faced the same legal liability even if the facts were identical in every other respect? Or would you acknowledge that the political viewpoints are decisive in how this case has been prosecuted?

IF that is true, then that is obviously a problem. But, is it true? You have no idea, do you?

Yes, I do, because there have been calls for charges under this statute for years now by voices in the media and various interest groups.

The calls for the charges in the public space and on the campaign debate stage were predicated on the political content of the march and not whatever details may be in the indictment.

All the way back in 2017, Charges won't be filed over torch rally:

Virginia Code Sec. 18.2-423.01B says it is a Class 6 felony to burn an object on a highway or other public place in a way to make someone fearful of death or bodily injury. Chapman said that is true, but he has not been able to confirm whether the state judicial system has ever established burning a torch as a "true threat" under that statute.

On Saturday, City Councilor Wes Bellamy called for the ralliers to be prosecuted under the statute. He did not respond to a text message and a phone call seeking comment on Tuesday afternoon.

Chapman said the law could be amended by the state legislature to clarify whether the statute applies to using a torch in such a way.

"There is a threshold problem with the statute," he said Tuesday. "The statute refers to 'burn an object.' The question could arise — and would in criminal law — as to whether carrying a burning torch falls within the definitional scope of burning an object. That alone could prevent a prosecution.

"In criminal law, ambiguous terms are construed against the commonwealth to narrow their scope. If the law says 'burn an object,' we have to assume that's exactly what the law means. We can't broaden that with interpretation unless the intent that it be broader than that is very clear from the language. That's a threshold impediment."

You, on the other hand, are trying to tell everyone that this isn't new territory, it's the application of settled law. Even so, when I repeatedly ask you to present a case with similar laws/facts, you can only propose a hypothetical rather than point to any actual case where protestors were given similar charges for "burning an object" with the intent to intimidate. The fact that this prosecution has been politicized is proof it's politically motivated. It's been nearly six years, this is obviously politically motivated and I don't know who you think you are kidding by saying that I don't know that.

What do you think that new territory is

"Burning an object with the intent to intimidate" being applied to participants at a political protest holding tiki torches is new territory. If you don't think so, can you show me a single other case where a similar law has been applied to a similar situation?

hate speech with the intent to intimidate can be outlawed, but hate speech without the intent to intimidate cannot

What is unique here is that politically incorrect speech is being interpreted as having an intent to intimidate. Doing a political rally against, for example, demographic change is now legally risky and subject to a DA's interpretation of intent to intimidate. If you don't think so, please show me other cases where participants at a protest like the Charlottesville torch-light march were charged with similar "object burning" statutes. Or will you acknowledge that the "object burning" statute being applied in a protest like this is new territory? If not, then just show me a similar case.

I provided the exact text of 18.2.423.1 in my original comment, but why are you saying "no" when you are repeating what I said? Can you cite a case similar to this, if you don't think it's a novel application of the law?

They are using "intent to intimidate" as an avenue for outlawing hate speech, and punishment for participation in a political protest in a public space. You cannot even doubt that this was the motive of the prosecutors, as their prosecution under this statute was a campaign issue! It's clearly a novel case of these statutes being stretched into new territory.

Update on Felony Charges for Tiki Torch Marchers

A month ago I mentioned the announcement that several people from the Charlottesville 2017 torch-light march were indicted on felony charges for "burning an object with the intent to intimidate." There was a lot of skepticism that this would stick given that the statute is being stretched quite far from its incarnation as an anti-cross burning law. @netstack wrote "For the record, I don’t expect the Charlottesville tiki-torchers to be convicted."

Last Thursday it was reported that a South Carolina man entered a guilty plea, the second one to do so. He was sentenced to five years in prison / four and a half suspended:

A South Carolina man has pleaded guilty to a charge in connection with a torch march that occurred at the University of Virginia in 2017.

Tyler Bradley Dykes entered a guilty plea to burning an object with the intent to intimidate on Thursday.

He was sentenced to five years in prison, with four and a half years of that suspended.

Dykes is the second person to plead guilty.

Earlier this month, Will Zachary Smith of Texas also pleaded guilty to a charge of burning an object with the intent to intimidate.

As part of his plea deal, another charge associated with the Unite the Right rally was dropped.

Smith is scheduled to be sentenced in August.

The significance of this is that it's now precedent for "intent to intimidate" as an avenue for outlawing hate speech, which has traditionally had first amendment protections. I noted that Ron DeSantis's hate speech law signed in Jerusalem also contained verbiage surrounding an intent to intimidate, allowing for protestors to be asked to leave or be arrested/charged if they demonstrate on a university campus for the purposes of "intimidation." There was skepticism that "intimidation" could be stretched so far- but here we are, and it's already happened.

Why would these actions discourage the treatment of those platforms as a "public square"? They will continue to fulfill that function while they deplatform content that criticizes Jewish power or anything else deemed antisemitic by the IHR definition. Their purpose is to set the boundaries of acceptable speech within the public square, and the boundaries of acceptable speech will entail incessant criticism of white people with a zero-tolerance ban on criticizing Jews.