@SecureSignals's banner p

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

				

User ID: 853

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 853

Sorry I think it was unclear, I don't think it was unfair I think it's how you win a culture war. You do it by changing the meaning of symbols and words, or stretching them here and there to suit the battle you are fighting at the time. People complain about the culture changing the meaning of words and symbols, they don't realize it's the reverse: you change the meaning of words and symbols in order to change the culture. I don't oppose that, I recognize the reality of it. It's why I would usually dismiss progressives as concern trolling when they break out a dictionary to test if it's really grooming. The correct response to that is "Ok, groomer" and I think that is going to work.

Moreover, you can 100% see rainbows w/o connotations of the LGBTQ+ movements, and that's in children's books and media.

That's a stretch. If you polled people with a rainbow color array and said "What does this mean?" 20 years ago, do you accept that would be radically different than the association people would have with it now? 50 years ago?

I've seen Richard Spencer consistently echo your exact concerns and counter-signal conservatives for chewing on a bone that doesn't really matter while they remain blind to the bigger picture. There's truth to that, I think it's fair to say that the conservatives are blind to the bigger picture, but I also think they are identifying something that is real when they describe "grooming." Does it fit the dictionary definition? Maybe, maybe not, but they are getting at something real.

I have also seen DR figures like you describe though. It falls along similar lines as the Klaus Schwab debate in the DR. Some on the DR pushed hard on the Schwab-posting since it was more adjacent to mainstream rhetoric and served as a potential gateway for conservatives whereas others opposed it for the simple fact that it isn't true, so you shouldn't sacrifice your credibility by pushing rhetoric that is fundamentally untrue.

I personally opposed the Klaus Schwab narrative because I didn't think it was getting at something real, but I will support the conservative rhetoric on this issue because I do think they are picking up on something real and opposing it in a way that may turn out to be effective.

I think your concerns are valid though, I am explaining why I fall on the side on supporting conservatives if they are picking up on something real.

There are some in the Dissident Right that counter-signal the conservative moral panic for the reasons you allude to. The DR is not conservative, so when and if it finds itself sharing the exact same rhetoric as the conservative boomerwaffen, some hesitancy is warranted. Especially because there is a bunch of Q-Anon nonsense among that demographic, which is adjacent to the "pedophilic elite" conspiracy, which is in turn adjacent to "groomer" rhetoric. Your enemies are going to use their full power to tie the "groomer" rhetoric to Q-Anon, and I've already seen that comparison made more than once.

Yesterday I found myself thinking about how tragic it is that the rainbow, a solar symbol with a rich history of meaning, is now appropriated for gay and trans activism and you can't see a rainbow without identifying with or against the movement. You could say "they shouldn't have done that, that's an unfair move to take a neutral symbol and use it to rally a cause", but they did and it's extremely effective. It's the work of the Symbol-Manipulators that Hlynka consistently underestimates. I think this is why the accusation of a conservative "moral panic" usually comes across as concern-trolling, because where and how exactly are conservatives supposed to provide pushback in similar measure?

One of the most effective and prolific tricks of the LGBTQ movement is to use the word "phobic" to denounce, insult, and shame their opponents by associating their beliefs, and themselves personally, as pathological. You're transphobic. You could write a post breaking out the dictionary definition of a 'phobia' and say "Ghee, you all on the LGBTQ+ community should stop accusing conservatives of transphobia, because their beliefs don't really describe the dictionary definition of a phobia." I think you would appreciate how feckless that would be, and if it's effective why would you expect them to not use the term? Or do you just accept that the LGBTQ movement will use such rhetoric to extreme effectiveness, but you think its opponents should be more principled and consult the dictionary before they engage with in-kind rhetoric?

I do endorse the groomer rhetoric because it's actually engaging in the debate on a symbolic level in the way progressives have only been able to since the conservative defeat on gay marriage. I don't think it's a moral panic for conservatives to appreciate the symbolic humiliation of drag queen story hour:

Children learn their lessons- their notion of reality and right and wrong, through stories. A story hour is a safe place for childen to learn through stories, and furthermore the storyteller is usually a trusted figure in the community like a teacher, mayor, or president. There is something symbolically revolutionary about children sitting in a circle around a flamboyant drag queen and being told a story. That symbolically matters. As hesitant as I am to endorse the rhetoric of the boomerwaffen, I can't fault them for picking this battle and I think it's gaslighting honestly to call their discernment of a sexually-charged augmentation to a symbolically important community ritual involving children a "moral panic."

The cynical bastard in me suspects that the reason "Symbol-Manipulators" seem to be so freaked out about GPT is that it represents a fully-automated-luxury-gay-reductio-ad-absurdum of everything that they think they know.

Based on your teaser last week I was expecting a revisit of Christianity and the Western Tradition. Isn't Christianity, in your model the foundation of civilization, the ultimate creation of Symbol-Manipulators?

Considering the vast bulk of the documentation relating to Reinhard was ordered "destroyed as soon as possible."

There are hundreds and hundreds of surviving documents pertaining to the Reinhardt operation. They point to the economic objective of the operation, even by the admission of the Majdanek Museum. Most importantly, the top-secret direct report from Globocnik to Himmler was preserved. If Himmler really did put Globocnik in charge of the extermination of the Jews, how could you possibly ask for a better source than a direct, top-secret final report from the man who did it to the man who ordered it?

But as it happens, the report just provides validation for the Revisionist position while the mainstream historians are left pointing to a passage here and there from a speech in Posen, rather than the actual direct report sent to Himmler on the operation a few months later. To me, that speaks volumes that one side is pointing to things like "what do you mean this people" and the other side is pointing to the actual top-secret document reporting exactly what the operation was and what its results were.

Himmler's Posen speech was two months before Globocnik submitted his final report on Operation Reinhardt to Himmler, which was by the end of 1943, two months after that speech. That report contains no mention of extermination, even euphemistically. It contains entirely information pertinent to the orders that Himmler describes in his Posen speech regarding the utilization of confiscated Jewish property.

You are saying that in a semi-public recorded speech, Himmler himself openly acknowledged a policy of extermination of all Jewish people in October 1943, but in the top-secret final report on that operation submitted two months later, there is no mention of extermination whatsoever. The lack of any mention of extermination in that top-secret report has been attributed to the enormous secrecy of the operation by the mainstream...

You would expect it to be backwards: the semi-public speech should be much more discreet than the top-secret, direct report which ought to have the highly sensitive but important details for high command.

But your interpretation has Himmler admitting to matters in a speech that were so secret they weren't even alluded to an in internal top-secret report on the operation only two months later.

The more reasonable interpretation is that in both passages he is referring to reprisals, which was topical due to recent events in Warsaw.

Not dramatically different. Very similar.

That is just absurd. Including families as acceptable targets for reprisals is tragic and should be criticized in its context, but it's also a common practice in history. The Germans were subject to it, and so were Iraqis. That is a very different matter than publicly announcing a policy to kill every person of a race. It is dramatically different.

Himmler isn't an idiot and when he wants to talk about partisan warfare he is perfectly capable of using the term 'partisan' or otherwise indicating that he is talking about partisan warfare.

There's a difference between being an idiot and considering that your enemies are going to decades later try to interpret every single word you say to assert the pre-concluded existence of a huge conspiracy that didn't exist. If there were no extermination policy, Himmler would not have been concerned with saying a phrase here or there that would be pounced on by people like you decades later to try to give credibility to the allegedly systematic use of code-words and euphemism across extant documentation.

This speech was in the recent aftermath of the Warsaw uprising which was big news (where the fighters were treated harshly as partisans), and partisans were already part of the earlier subject of his speech. You argue that Himmler says "enough about partisans," but the fact is if a speaker says "enough about X" then it's far more likely that X is going to be revisited later in the speech, particularly vaguely and in passing, because it is already established to be an important topic of the speech and will be fresh in the mind of the audience. This is basic logic that is only thrown out the window because your side really needs to selectively call unambiguous statements in documents "euphemism," and ambiguous statements as "direct confirmation" for your theory.

So no he's not using a euphemism, he's speaking about something specific

Good, so he's not using a euphemism here and he's talking about partisans and commissars, agreed. But you are saying he is using a euphemism earlier in that very speech when he describes the migration East of the Jews. The more likely solution than "inconsistent usage of euphemisms" is that he was trying to portray a convey similar idea in slightly different words across two speeches that were only two months apart.

Do you think the "Volk" he refers to is 'partisans'?

This is exactly what I mean, you pounce on words like "these people", I think he is identifying an enemy in a vague and essentialist sense, like partisans or Bolshevists. For example, in that passage, which you acknowledge was not a euphemism, on partisans and commissars he uses "subhumans". So the identification of "subhumans" with "this people" isn't nearly as unlikely as you are trying to let on. Again, if there is any ambiguity then there should be a bias towards interpreting very similar passages across two speeches two months apart to have a continuity in meaning, rather than assigning the nearly identical passages dramatically different meanings based on a few choice words like "this people."

It does make sense because Himmler explicitly says in several of these speeches that now he's speaking secretly and the "hard task" never be spoken of in public. Which makes absolutely no sense on the revisionist interpretation

He says he is speaking secretly and of a "hard task" in a passage where he explicitly mentions partisans and commissars. This passage is extremely similar to the passage where you are alleging that he was referring to every Jew:

Measures, gentlemen, which we are shirking today, will be welcomed by our grandchildren. If I was forced to take action against partisans and against Jewish commissars in a village - I am saying this in this circle, as it is only intended for this circle -, then I gave the basic order to have the wives and children of these partisans and commissars killed as well. I would be a weakling and a criminal of our descendants if I let the hateful sons of these subhumans, who were killed by us in the fight of man against subhuman, grow up.

Do you doubt he's referring to partisans and commissars here? Or are you going to deploy the "euphemism" card again?

What? Killing children to prevent avengers IS the extermination policy.

Your logic isn't new, it was brought up in the Nuremberg Trials as well and Otto Ohlendorf responded to your accusation:

Q. Will you agree that there was absolutely no rational basis for killing children except in genocide and the killing of race?

A. I believe that it is very simple to explain if one starts from the fact that this order did not only try to achieve security, but also permanent security because the children would grow up and surely, being the children of parents who had been killed, they would constitute a danger no smaller than that of the parents.

[...]

A. Mr. Prosecutor, I did not see the execution of children myself although I attended three mass executions.

Q. Are you saying they didn't kill children now?

A. I did not say that. May I finish? I attended three mass executions and did not see any children and no command ever search for children, but I have seen very many children killed in this war through air attacks, for the security of other nations, and orders were carried out to bomb, no matter whether many children were killed or not.

Q. Now, I think we are getting somewhere, Mr. Ohlendorf. You saw German children killed by Allied bombers and that is what you are referring to?

A. Yes, I have seen it.

Q. Do you attempt to draw a moral comparison between the bomber who drops bombs hoping that it will not kill children and yourself who shot children deliberately? Is that a fair moral comparison?

A. I cannot imagine that those planes which systematically covered a city that was a fortified city, square meter for square meter, with incendiaries and explosive bombs and again with phosphorus bombs, and this done from block to block, and then as I have seen it in Dresden likewise the squares where the civilian population had fled to - that these men could possibly hope not to kill any civilian population, and no children. And when you then read the announcements of the Allied leaders on this - and we are quite willing to submit them as document - you will read that these killings were accepted quite knowingly because one believed that only through this terror, as it was described, the people could be demoralised and under such blows the military power of the Germans would then also break down.

Q. Very well, let's concede - I think there is truth in what you say, though I never saw it. . .

So the prosecutor conceded that he wasn't making a very good argument, but you continue to present that argument as definitive because relying on a narrow interpretation of some speeches, while handwaving large amounts of other speeches and documents as "code" is what you have to work with.

The context of these speeches were in the aftermath the Warsaw uprising where the treatment of partisans was a salient issue. The issue of reprisals was a salient one internally during the war and after the war as well. You are saying that, on the one hand, Himmler made speeches about this controversy, but during this October 6 speech in Posen he was casually admitting to a policy of genocide in between his use of euphemisms, even though he was using identical terms to explain the partisan controversy in other speeches. It's just not a good argument, even the prosecutor had to admit it.

On more aspect of the Posen speeches is that Himmler describes a "strict order" he gave to Pohl to administer the utilization of confiscated property:

The riches they had, we've taken away from them. I have given a strict order, which SS Group Leader Pohl has carried out, that these riches shall, of course, be diverted to the Reich without exception.

Of course this was Operation Reinhardt, whereas Himmler alludes to no such grand orders to Globocnik for secret extermination even though he's ostensibly confessing to an extermination policy in your interpretation.

As I'm sure you know, Operation Reinhardt ended with Himmler ordering Globocnik to submit a report to Pohl on the operation, which reinforces the revisionist interpretation as well. That report has nothing to do with extermination as you know, the report was about the utilization of confiscated property with not even a "euphemistic" reference to extermination. It's amazing there would be so much secrecy and compliance in their own top-secret internal reporting on the operation, where even the final report on Operation Reinhardt contains no direct or even euphemistic reference to extermination, but then Himmler would just casually admit to it in a speech in between other speeches where he continues to use the euphemism. That just doesn't make any sense.

It's pretty clear because Himmler says things like:

The very first thing he said before the first two passages you posted was "Ich meine die Judenevakuierung": "I mean the evacuation of the Jews." So is he using a euphemism or is he being clear he means extermination? You are saying he is going back and forth, and then in Weimar two months later he's back to the euphemism.

Revisionists don't doubt the brutality of a forced resettlement/deportation operation which would have had a high mortality. Passages like:

Most of you know what it means when 100 bodies lie together, when 500 lie there, or if 1,000 lie there. To have gone through this, and at the same time, apart from exceptions caused by human weaknesses, to have remained decent, that has made us hard.

Sounds like a recognition of a bloody affair, which the evacuation undoubtedly was. It sounds like a speech a general could have given to troops justifying the firebombing of German or Japanese cities: "You all know what it's like to see mass death, and we know these actions are taking the lives of women and children but we have to be tough or the fascists will conquer the world blah blah". A general giving such a speech would not even consider the possibility of people later trying to infer a secret policy to exterminate all German people from a speech like that.

There is obviously tough talk and recognition of a bloody affair, but inferring a specific policy from such a speech would only be the act of desperation from someone who cannot rely on the documentation to definitively establish the policy being claimed. Especially when the very first sentence completely contradicts your interpretation of the policy inferred from these general words, and when later speeches continue to describe the policy as an evacuation.

Please explain how "the hard decision to wipe this people off of the face of the earth" can refer to either the killing of partisans or resettlement.

Because this:

I did not believe that I had the right to wipe out the men — rather I should say, kill them or have them killed — and let their children grow up to avenge themselves on our sons and grandsons. The hard decision to wipe this people off the face of the earth had to be made.

Sounds like it's trying to convey the same point made in a speech only two months later, where he also describes the policy as resettlement and it's obviously tough talk to rationalize reprisals against partisans and commissars:

Measures, gentlemen, which we are shirking today, will be welcomed by our grandchildren. If I was forced to take action against partisans and against Jewish commissars in a village - I am saying this in this circle, as it is only intended for this circle -, then I gave the basic order to have the wives and children of these partisans and commissars killed as well. I would be a weakling and a criminal of our descendants if I let the hateful sons of these subhumans, who were killed by us in the fight of man against subhuman, grow up.

I know you want to claim that there's no way these two passages from two different speeches were intended to convey the same idea, you are saying that these two passages had completely different meanings, but just reading them side by side it seems clear the point of this part of the speech is the same: it's tough talk to justify reprisals and the undoubtedly brutal forced resettlement.

Lastly, the dilemma presented in the passage you are leaning on doesn't make sense if you assume he is admitting to an extermination policy. Himmler justifies killing women and children so the children don't grow up and take revenge... but if the plan was to exterminate them all then this would never have entered into the decision calculus. The dilemma between killing children or having them grow up to take revenge (a dilemma also presented in the December speech which describes a policy of resettlement) only makes sense in the context of targeted killings and does not make sense in the context of a policy of extermination, in which case this would be a non-issue.

It's pretty clear the 4 October speech refers to physical annihilation as well

So much of your case rests on an extremely narrow interpretation of a few selected passages, while dismissing the much more extant documentation as "euphemism" and "coded language."

You say that the 4 October speech refers to physical annihilation because Himmler describes:

Ich meine jetzt die Judenevakuierung, die Ausrottung des jüdischen Volkes.

I am thinking now of the evacuation of the Jews, the extirpation of the Jewish people.

Your entire assumption is based on the assertion of what "Ausrottung" is supposed to denote. The meaning of this term was something of a mild controversy at the Nuremberg Trial and in the David Irving trial as well. It's misleading to call it "pretty clear" when it has been a controversy in court.

This question was brought to Alfred Rosenberg at Nuremberg:

MR. DODD: This is something you will be interested in. Will you look up and read out to the Tribunal what the definition of "Ausrottung" is?

ROSENBERG: I do not need a foreign dictionary in order to explain the various meanings "Ausrottung" may have in the German language. One can exterminate an idea, an economic system, a social order, and as a final consequence, also a group of human beings, certainly. Those are the many possibilities which are contained in that word. For that I do not need an English-German dictionary. Translations from German into English are so often wrong-and just as in that last document you have submitted to me, I heard again the translation of "Herrenrasse." In the document itself "Herrenrasse" is not even mentioned; however, there is the term "ein falsches Herrenmenschentum" (a false master mankind). Apparently everything is translated here in another sense.

MR. DODD: All right, I am not interested in that. Let us stay on this term of "Ausrottung." I take it then that you agree it does mean to "wipe out" or to "kill off," as it is understood, and that you did use the term in speaking to Hitler.

ROSENBERG: Here I heard again a different translation, which again used new German words, so I cannot determine what you wanted to express in English.

MR. DODD: Are you very serious in pressing this apparent inability of yours to agree with me about this ward or are you trying to kill time? Don't you know that there are plenty of people in this courtroom who speak German and who agree that that word does mean to "wipe out," to "extirpate?"

ROSENBERG: It means "to overcome" on one side and then it is to be used not with respect to individuals but rather to juridical entities, to certain historical traditions. On the other side this word has been used with respect to the German people and we have also not believed that in consequence thereof 60 millions of Germans would be shot.

Hitler warned of the "Ausrottung" of all European peoples (including the Allies) if Germany lost the war. Obviously this did not mean that every single European person would be killed, but something more like "an allied victory will lead to the Bolshevization of Europe," which he considered to be an Ausrottung.

So to say that it's pretty clear Himmler is referring here to physical annihilation rather than the sense used by Hitler and Rosenberg, which completely fits the evacuation policy, is grasping at straws.

In other speeches at Posen he uses the word "Judenevakuierung." In this speech he uses the word "umbringen," which unambiguously means "kill."

Yes, in speeches at Posen he describes the policy as evacuation. Two months after that October 1943 speech, in December, he also describes the policy as evacuation:

We are also too close to the development that is taking place in Europe. For the first time, as far as we can determine it historically since approximately 2 1/2 thousand years ago, we are at the point where the Germanic peoples have united, from a 65 million people in 1933 which has become 85 - 88 million people in 1941, which during the war some big migrations have taken place, a migration of 700,00 Germans who have immigrated, of 2 million foreigners who have emigrated, of such and such many Jews who have emigrated to the East; Movements of peoples, as we call them in history with infinite names, have taken place within the framework of this rapid development.

Although he mentions the killing of Jews in this December speech as well, in the context of partisans:

Measures, gentlemen, which we are shirking today, will be welcomed by our grandchildren. If I was forced to take action against partisans and against Jewish commissars in a village - I am saying this in this circle, as it is only intended for this circle -, then I gave the basic order to have the wives and children of these partisans and commissars killed as well. I would be a weakling and a criminal of our descendants if I let the hateful sons of these subhumans, who were killed by us in the fight of man against subhuman, grow up.

His defense of the decision to conduct reprisals against the families of partisans and commissars "If I was forced to take action" would not make any sense in the context of an extermination policy where extermination of all Jews would have been the policy. You are saying his statement here is just theater right? To provide cover for the fact he actually ordered the extermination of all Jews?

You are basically saying:

  • Posen October 4th <- evacuation euphemisms + partisans

  • Posen October 6th <- partisans + admitted the policy was to exterminate all Jews

  • Weimar December 15th <- evacuation euphemisms + partisans

Why did Himmler go "mask off" only in the October 6th speech but maintain the euphemisms in the other speeches? The Revisionist position is more sensible, that his statements about the hard decision to kill Jews in the October 6th speech resembles the same statements in the December speech which is unambiguously about partisans.

Hermann Goering- the one who actually gave the "Final Solution" order to Heydrich and would have been as aware as Himmler of its actual nature, maintained that it was a policy of evacuation for emigration and not a euphemism for extermination in the Nuremberg Trial. That stands as more significant than a narrow interpretation of a single passage which stands in contrast with other speeches before and after that single passage.

As I understand, you believe Operation Reinhardt was about resettling 2 million Jews

What Operation Reinhardt was about is an important issue.

It was one of my first topics of interest, because if Wikipedia had it right and this was the code-name for the secret plan to exterminate the Jews, then that would have settled the matter and satisfied my curiosity. But the mainstream consensus is clearly wrong.

Operation Reinhardt was an economic initiative for the utilization of Jewish labor and confiscated property in the General Government. One of the primary motivations for liquidating the Jewish ghettos was to confiscate and exploit Jewish movable and immovable property for the German economy and war effort. This required a significant amount of administration and labor, and all of this was organized under that operation. The Nuremberg Military Tribunal WVHA trial (1950), for what it's worth, also identified this as the purpose of the operation. From the court's finding of facts:

The purpose of the action [Reinhardt] was to gather into the Reich all the Jewish manpower and wealth which could be reached.

This can be compared with Wikipedia's description:

Operation Reinhard or Operation Reinhardt ... was the codename of the secretive World War II German plan to exterminate Poland's Jews in the General Government district of German-occupied Poland.

The NMT got it right. Mainstream historians have appropriated the "Reinhardt" code-name to claim it was code for extermination for the simple reason that they don't have other options for suggesting how the secret extermination plan was supposed to have been denoted in documents.

The difference between the data on the number of Jews at Princeton and the number of Jews recorded in a census is that at Princeton no one goes around asking everyone if they are Jewish, yet this is exactly what happens during a census.

The point was that counting people is not a politically-neutral act, neither is it for a census. The Alternative Hypothesis in his recent Revisionist work identified controversy surrounding the 1937 Soviet census:

"On 25 September 1937, there was a special Sovnarkom decision proclaiming the census invalid and setting a new one for January 1939. A Pravda editorial stated that the "enemies of the people gave the census counters invalid instructions that led to the gross under-counting of the population, but the brave NKVD under the leadership of Nikolai Yezhov destroyed the snake's nest in the statistical bodies".

The assumption is that thereafter Soviet population figures were inflated in the 1939 census, with the help of the "brave NKVD" destroying the "snake's nest in the statistical bodies." The assumption of political neutrality in the census is highly dubious. Keep in mind that historians accuse the Germans of manipulating their concentration camp inmate and death statistics by excluding the gas chamber victims in order to hide evidence of the crime. So they are accusing the Germans of manipulating internal statistics while taking Soviet statistics at face value.

This is pretty unambiguous: the number of Jews in Europe has decreased by 4 million.

It is actually pretty ambiguous, the estimated decrease is meant to take into consideration excess mortality and emigration since 1937, so asserting that this figure is some "unambiguous" admission to the murder of 4 million people is quite silly and not even the mainstream interprets this figure in that way. The most controversial figure is "Total Evacuations" which is 1.8 million. Historians say that was code for the number of Jews murdered in gas chambers on the pretext of taking a shower. Revisionists that this was the number of Jews deported into one of the many camps in General Government or deported further east. Korherr said he was told it referred to Jews deported into camps in Lublin, which fits the Revisionist claim.

Where are the testimonies of the more than one million Jews who were resettled?

Revisionists have proven beyond a doubt that the Soviet Union systematically inflated death tolls by orders of magnitude in their investigations, and modified structures to give them an apparent criminal intent, and accused the Germans of war crimes that the Soviets were responsible for... and you're asking why the Soviet Union didn't gather exculpatory testimonies and submit them as evidence? The Soviet Union did not allow Western investigators access to this entire body of evidence. Among the body of evidence that Western investigators had access to, the gas chamber extermination story was disproven.

At Nuremberg, Belzec, Sobibor and Treblinka were discussed in the trial for no more than 20 minutes. Electrocution floors were the alleged method of murder at Belzec at the time, and at Treblinka it was steam chambers. The alleged murder of millions at these camps was represented by a single witness who was examined for not more than 15 minutes and was not cross-examined by the defense. These camps were almost entirely ignored at Nuremberg, the Western camps were at the time more central to the gas chamber extermination claims, particularly Dachau.

The problem with all the evidence these eastern camps being behind the Iron Curtain is that you have to contend with the fact that this body of evidence was in Soviet Custody. So when you ask, for example "why weren't resettled Jews interviewed?" you don't seem to grasp the purpose of a show trial.

Edit: As a counterfactual, suppose the Nazis did murder millions of Jews and destroy the evidence by cremating the bodies and then destroying the crematoria and all the documents relating to the genocide.

The Katyn Forest massacre is an example of the counterfactual. The German's didn't have access to documents proving the Soviets did it, they had to scientifically investigate the crime scene to try and prove it. They didn't do it out of the goodness of their hearts, it was a very important propaganda opportunity. Your mistake is thinking that "cremating the bodies" is the same thing as "destroying the evidence", when they are not the same thing. A cremated body leaves behind a lot of evidence, 800,000 cremated bodies would leave an amount of evidence that is hard to fathom. But the Soviet Union would have had every motive to excavate those tens of millions of cremated bone fragments with international observers for all the same reasons as the Germans in their investigation of the Katyn massacre.

Imagine if the Germans interviewed a witness to the Katyn massacre, and the witness said the bodies were cremated and buried. And then the Germans covered the area of the mass graves in concrete and forbade anybody from excavating in order to protect the religious beliefs of the victims. Would that course of action at all make any sense if they were motivated to reveal Soviet crimes to the world? It would make sense in the case of a mass grave that wasn't actually there, and the world bought the story without the scientific investigation.

They can’t pick a single major point of disagreement, in fact invariably different revisionists contradict each other all the time.

This is not true at all... the points of disagreement are:

  • There was no plan for the physical extermination of Jewry, i.e. the "Final Solution" was not the plan to secretly exterminate Jews in gas chambers.

  • There were no gas chambers disguised as shower rooms used to carry out such a plan.

  • The 6 million number is a symbolic propaganda number that doesn't have a strong basis in reality.

There are no Revisionists who deny the existence of camps, or deaths by typhus and starvation especially near the end of the war. There is far more variation on the mainstream side of the camp, where they cannot even agree on where the "Final Solution" actually came from- who, when, or why...

In contrast, there are no Revisionists I am aware of who make claims that are stronger than the three above, and they all agree on these three claims. I disagree with Revisionists on some matters of interpretation, but the points of disagreement are summarized above and held by all Revisionists.

Here is Himmler talking openly about the extermination of European Jews without use of code-words in the Posen speech of October 6 1943:

In the Posen speeches Himmler describes the policy as "Judenevakuierung", which is alleged to have been a code-word. So he is still using the "code" at Posen. And months later he continues describing a policy of evacuation/resettlement/emigration to the East with the killing of Jews being in the context of partisan reprisals (which revisionists do not deny happened).

Revisionists have written many published works on the so-called "Operation Reinhardt" death camps, the most recent of which was published in 2021 and covers all three camps. But these technical studies aren't very approachable without a high level of background knowledge. My first exposure to the Revisionist position on those camps, which includes Treblinka, was in the well-known Revisionist documentary One Third of the Holocaust.

I wasn't a Revisionist when I first saw that and knew virtually nothing about these camps, so I took everything presented with a huge grain of salt. But there were some relatively straightforward claims presented in the documentary that seemed easy to verify, and if true, raised questions. For example, in the video the creator describes that the official historical narrative is that the Nazis buried about 1.5 million - 2 million Jews and then later dug them all back up and cremated them on grills to hide the evidence. I assumed that had to be some sort of straw man or misrepresentation but it turned out not to be- it's what historians actually claim. Or when he presents silly statements made by witnesses you are going to assume he is just cherry-picking, but it turns out those witnesses are as important to the whole story as he presents in the video.

Having learned that the story itself is simply pretty hard to believe, stranger than fiction even, I learned a lot more about these camps and the Holocaust in general, and the more I learned the more I realized that Revisionists have the stronger case. The evidence for these claims should be considered holistically. I would separate the categories of evidence in four parts:

Census data: Inconclusive, it's the most important evidence cited by anti-Deniers here due to the deficiencies in the other categories of evidence. But there are so many uncertainties and contradictions in the numbers. How many Jews are in the Princeton class of 2026? We couldn't figure that out, we could only conclude that the Jewish organizations presenting the estimates were fudging them based on political and economic incentives. But so many here stake the truth of this tall tale on some Jews that should exist on paper, by doing some simple additions and subtractions from many different demographic studies conducted before, during, and after the war in the Russian empire, Poland, and Soviet Union. It heavily relies on a level of precision (how many Polish Jews became "Soviet Citizens" on paper after the war?), accuracy and honesty that simply does not exist.

Physical evidence: Strongly favors the Revisionist side. Historians claim ~2 million were murdered in these camps, but the remains of approximately 0% of those two million victims have been identified in scientific excavations. This also includes technical arguments around things like burial density or cremation capacity, fuel requirements, etc. Although these arguments are usually not influential to non-Revisionists because they just assume that Revisionists are using math deceptively or not representing the mainstream position accurately (they are).

Documentary evidence: Strongly favors the Revisionist side, as the Revisionist case mostly takes the documents at face value whereas the mainstream narrative claims that there was systematic euphemism and coded language. For example, there are documents where both Himmler and Pohl, head of the concentration camp system, identify Sobibor as a transit camp (Durchgangslager). The Revisionist theory is this camp was what the document says it was, the mainstream theory is that in their own internal secret documents they used coded language to camouflage the extermination camp. There are some documents that Revisionists struggle to explain, which is to be expected given that there are millions and millions of them. There are documents that the mainstream struggles to explain. But most important of all are the documents that should be there but which are not.

Witness testimonies: The most strong aspect of the Revisionist case in my opinion. Witnesses are by far the most important part of the body of evidence for the mainstream narrative, so the Revisionist critique of that body of evidence is devastating.

The "Where did they Go?" trump card is the most popular retort against Revisionists as it's an attempt to reverse the burden of proof. The mainstream narrative makes these claims which are honestly pretty hard to believe, Revisionists build an extremely strong case against that narrative, so the ultimate strategy is to try to demand Revisionists track the population movements of Jews in the final years of the war, right before the Soviet Union conquered that half of the continent and the most important German officials involved had died or been killed.

The fact is, there are no surviving documents at all pertaining to transports to or from the alleged Treblinka extermination camp. The Korherr report does not mention Treblinka at all, and the author of that report wrote a letter to Der Spiegel in the 1970s stating that he interpreted those numbers in his report to mean what Revisionists say those numbers meant. The story is the same at Belzec, where the mainstream admits that unfortunately:

The railway documents were all destroyed on July 4 1944, when a lone Russian bomber dropped one solitary bomb over Belzec which just happened to hit an ammunition train standing in the station. The Belzec railway station was completely destroyed together with all the records.

So it's highly convenient to demand Revisionists answer questions that rely on evidence which has been destroyed in unlucky circumstances or otherwise fallen into Soviet Custody. But neither is there documentary evidence remaining for transports into those camps either.

In recent years it has been revealed, to the surprise of historians, that there were tens of thousands of labor and concentration camps which were previously unknown:

Researchers at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum have been documenting all of the Nazi concentration camps, ghettos, slave labour sites and killing factories which had been set up across Europe.

When they first started the project, the team expected to find about 7,000 camps and ghettos.

Shockingly, they discovered 42,500 camps across large swathes of German-controlled Europe.

Speaking to the New York Times, Hartmut Berghoff, director of the institute, said: 'The numbers are so much higher than what we originally thought...

When the project first started, the researchers expected to find about 7,000 Nazi camps and ghettos. But as the project has gone on, the numbers constantly increased to the current figure of 42,500.

So historians missed tens of thousands of camps that existed in these areas which happened to exist in a network around rail lines that were subject to the gas chamber extermination rumors. This revelation certainly gives more context to Korherr's interpretation of settlers "sifted through the camps of General Government", of which there were many more than historians had previously understood.

The retort "Where did the Jews go?" would not be necessary if there was strong evidence that they were murdered in the precise location where it is said they were murdered. When the Germans (NSFL) discovered the mass graves in the Katyn Forest, they invited international observers from all sides and released American POWs to observe the investigation. They exhumed the mass graves to conduct autopsies, investigate time and cause of death, and to identify victims. They were still accused of this crime by the Soviet prosecution at Nuremberg, and the Soviet authors of that Katyn report submitted into evidence (USSR-54) were the same as the authors of the Auschwitz report (USSR-8), with the addition of Trofim Lysenko as a signatory to the Auschwitz report.

No similar investigation was conducted for the alleged murder of about 2 million people at these three camps. While the Western Allies had conducted investigations disproving the allegations of gas chamber extermination in the camps liberated by the Western Allies, the Soviet Union denied access to outside observers and freely modified structures in Soviet-Occupied Poland, including most importantly the gas chamber at Auschwitz which has been shown to millions and millions of tourists.

A good summary of the Revisionist position is "the things that have always happened in human history and war: concentration and forced labor, conscription, property confiscation, forced resettlement, death by shooting, starvation, death by disease- actually happened. But the things that have never before happened in human history: herding millions of men, women, and children into bedroom-sized gas chambers on the pretense of taking a shower and being gassed by engine exhaust, after which they were buried, and then later unburied, cremated, and the ashes were scattered to hide evidence that this happened, did not actually happen."

Some people want to say that concentration and forced labor, conscription, shooting, starvation, and disease still constitutes a Holocaust. That's a fine perspective, but the ones with the delegated authority on that matter do not allow compromise on the gas chamber narrative or the extermination camps or the elusive extermination plan.

David Cole for example has long tried to distance himself from Holocaust Denial, but the establishment still does not allow his "Auschwitz was not an extermination camp, but Treblinka, Sobibor, Belzec, and Chelmno were" conclusion to acquit him from the crime Holocaust denial. His YouTube channel was very recently banned.

Cole has retreated to Substack to host his content, but alas, Substack has attracted the Eye of Sauron for its relatively lenient moderation policy and is now on the chopping block.

I would honestly prefer that. I absolutely stand by my original thread and think it's extremely CW-relevant even from a Revisionist-neutral perspective. But people want to discuss Revisionism itself in response, which I understand. I'm also hesitant to effortpost in response to OP with long back-and-forth threads that annoy the community, and I know that people who want to argue against Revisionism have to contend against that as well and it isn't fair for people who want to honestly discuss the issue.

I would be fine with a containment thread more suited for long-term discussion. If I responded to OP it would re-hash a lot of things I've already said, but like he mentioned, large parts of those discussions have been truncated by comment deletions and they are hard to follow.

So there's just not a great way for people who want to talk about it to do so without annoying the community, and frankly it's annoying that whenever people want to talk about it a bunch of others feel compelled to make comments about how much they don't care about the topic. Not sure what the solution is if not a containment thread.

Reading this post from SecureSignals, I was surprised that no asked asked what, concretely, is so harmful about Holocaust education.

I think I made it clear why that article presents what isn't just education curriculum like math, it's foundational to a hostile ideology:

  • I identify it as belonging to a Religious narrative that provides a center, and an anti-christ, of the moral universe and orients the boundaries of acceptable political thinking.

  • It's the implementation of ideas explicitly laid out by Jewish critical theorists, anthropologists, and psychoanalysts intended to cure what they consider to be embedded psychopathology in white people- what the author referred to as a "Western mind virus."

  • The motivation is to influence children to hold Jews in high regard while simultaneously hold their own ethnic heritage in low regard- or, more often, to be taught they have no ethnic heritage at all (many here make the same argument, by the way). More explicitly, the author is calling for children to be taught that Jews have a special quality and history while simultaneously white children will be taught they have no such thing, and for them to assert that would be the ultimate evil.

  • Technology is going to increase the effectiveness and impact of all of this, making it a lot harder to deny than the days where something like Schindler's List would fulfill the function which will now be fulfilled by mandated curriculum which will include visits to these mega-churches where students will be subject to visceral AI-powered AR/VR experiences which will be tailored to train the perception of those children of Jews- and their perception of themselves relative to Jews.

Otherwise I don't see why you wouldn't have just replied to my original comment and I could have responded to you there.

Again, you're just taking it for granted that the narrative is substantially untrue.

No I am not, I am saying that the motive for Holocaust remembrance is real, powerful, and valid even if the narrative is substantially untrue. The motive for Holocaust remembrance is not contingent on the historical truth of the narrative as challenged by Revisionists. I fully recognize that and always have, but that fact only uncovers a much deeper conflict and presents larger problems in ascertaining the truth of the matter.

but if AI-generated VR experiences become a standard delivery system for educational materials, this sounds a lot less scary than "High-tech dystopian Jew brainwashing." Then you're just complaining that we have too much Holocaust remembrance, and will go on insisting that the backlash will happen any day now.

The point I am trying to make, in the spirit of JTarrou's thought experiment, is that the line between culture/politics/religion or education/brain-washing is purely semantic. The critique I am making is not that it is brain-washing per se, it's that it is specifically brain-washing (or education, however you prefer) with a motive to influence children's perceptions of Jews in a particular direction. It's the religion I oppose, not religion itself or even its imminent technological innovations.

I am not grandstanding against VR brain-washing, I am saying to pay attention to the curriculum that gets mandated, the identities and narratives that get constructed into post-modern mega-churches, the messaging and content that is prioritized for adoption. What counts as education and what counts as brainwashing? The prevailing religion. Again, I'll reiterate that JTarrou suggests:

perhaps we should try to formalize it and create an Ecumenical Political Church, espousing a very vague and general set of principles to bound the acceptable limits of politics, that recognizes the fundamental tension of politics and is maximally inclusive.

And I am saying that we already have this, and it's the Holocaust narrative. You can call it education, but that's what it is all the same.

But if one supposes, just for the sake of argument, that there really was a concerted effort to exterminate them within living memory, one can surely see a motive for feeling this way that is not mere zeal to convert the heathens, no?

I don't question that the motive is sincere, similar to DasindustriesLtd's point. And although I do not believe the main big ticket items of the orthodox narrative are true, I do acknowledge it was a traumatic experience in which the Jews truly were at the complete mercy of non-Jews. They suffered for it and they do not want to be in that position again. I would go so far as to say even if some of them know the narrative is substantially false, they would still have that sincere motive to avoid what actually happened from ever happening again. As an example, Simon Wiesenthal is claimed to have been the progenitor of the deprecated claim that five million non-Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, but apparently Wiesenthal privately admitted that this was a lie to make non-Jews care about Jewish suffering. I don't doubt his motive, but I do acknowledge his willingness to lie in order to achieve his goals.

The entire problem is that the motivation for all this theater and religion is not contingent on historical truth. So your point only opens up the recognition of a genuine conflict of interest: Jews have a motive to propagate a message that promotes their own defense, even if parts of the narrative are substantially unture. An important part of the mechanism for ensuring their ethnic defense is weakening the ethnic defenses of non-Jews. You might consider that controversial, but this was basically the overt program of the critical theorists and psychoanalysts in their effort to cure Gentile psychopathology of the authoritarian personality. So we have a genuine conflict of interest in which historical truth is a lower priority than pursuit of cultural self-interest.

The problem with that sincere motivation, and the real reason anti-Semitism is so persistent- I would even say anti-fragile, is that the harder they fight against it the more they validate it and give it a greater force of truth and credibility. Let's say Dara Horn succeeds in mandating every child experiences some AI-powered VR/AR experience that is engineered to improve their perception of Jews. What rational person would deny at that point that the anti-Semites were right? Your average high-brow anti-Semite would blush to suggest that Jews will compel your children to consume AI-generated, Virtual Reality experiences to brainwash them into loving Jews. But this is being seriously proposed by Dara and some form of what she is suggesting will almost certainly be implemented as the lower-tech solutions are already being used on thousands of students every day.

Is Holocaust Education Making Anti-Semitism Worse?

With everything going on in the world, it's notable that this article from the upcoming May issue of The Atlantic is featured as the One Story to Read Today. It deserves to be closely studied- not just skimmed and written off as "progressivism gone amok."

Earlier in the thread, @JTarrou theorizes on politics replacing religion:

Given our emerging consensus that politics is replacing religion as the dividing line of society, and taking on many of the same functions, perhaps we should try to formalize it and create an Ecumenical Political Church, espousing a very vague and general set of principles to bound the acceptable limits of politics, that recognizes the fundamental tension of politics and is maximally inclusive.

I'm not shy about being a Holocaust Revisionist, and I'm aware that it seems to be a strange hobby horse to the vast majority of people including most here. Why dedicate so much time and credibility to this issue? It's not profitable, it's extremely low status, there's an extremely low chance of Revisionist criticisms of the narrative breaking through the mainstream in the near future. Ostensibly it's a controversy surrounding history rather than an immediately relevant cultural or technological issue. The reasoning is simple: the Holocaust already is the religion in the West that fulfills the function proposed by JTarrou. Long before I would cite any Revisionist or anti-Semite to make that case, I would plead for anybody who doubts that to closely read this Atlantic piece by Horn.

The Holocaust religion is growing and evolving with technology, and the motives have never been more transparent.

... well-meaning people everywhere from statehouses to your local middle school have responded to this surging anti-Semitism by doubling down on Holocaust education. Before 2016, only seven states required Holocaust education in schools. In the past seven years, 18 more have passed Holocaust-education mandates. Public figures who make anti-Semitic statements are invited to tour Holocaust museums; schools respond to anti-Semitic incidents by hosting Holocaust speakers and implementing Holocaust lesson plans...

If you read the article title maybe hoping for some nuance or self-reflection on the Holocaust Industry, you will be disappointed. According to Horn, Holocaust education is essential, but it doesn't go far enough in developing a positive public perception of Jews, particularly in young children.

One of Horn's chief complaints is that Holocaust education fails to impart on children the uniqueness of Jews. On the one hand, this is a fair criticism of Holocaust curriculum which is rife with the "Jews were completely normal and, one day for no reason at all, everybody hated them." On the other hand, it makes the political motivations of the Holocaust religion more transparent: the uniqueness and particularity of Jews should be explicitly taught and celebrated as curriculum. Jews aren't normal, they are special. If that sounds like an uncharitable interpretation, consider this exchange she had with a Holocaust educator:

“If you teach historical anti-Semitism, you have to teach contemporary anti-Semitism. A lot of teachers are fearful, because if you try to connect it to today, parents are going to call, or administrators are going to call, and say you’re pushing an agenda.”

But weren’t teachers supposed to “push an agenda” to stop hatred? Wasn’t that the entire hope of those survivors who built museums and lobbied for mandates and turned themselves into holograms? ...

I was baffled. Teachers who taught about industrialized mass murder were scared of teaching about … Judaism? Why?

“Because the teachers are afraid that the parents are going to say that they’re pushing their religion on the kids.”

But Jews don’t do that, I said. Judaism isn’t a proselytizing religion like Christianity or Islam; Jews don’t believe that anyone needs to become Jewish in order to be a good person, or to enjoy an afterlife, or to be “saved.” This seemed to be yet another basic fact of Jewish identity that no one had bothered to teach or learn.

Gas Chamber Simulacra

The Dallas Holocaust Museum was opened in 2019 and features prominently in her article: it covers an entire city block in the historical downtown district (Dara complains that it has almost two wings dedicated to the suffering of other minorities in a noble act of self-erasure). If this isn't a proselytizing religion then I do not know what is. Many thousands of children will be herded to these temples of tolerance to Learn their Lessons.

They will be taught the moral thesis of the world, Jews, and the moral antithesis, Hitler. They will sit in the pews learning from the saintly apparition about the Holocaust, using a conversational AI that is no doubt archaic compared to what will soon be displayed in Holocaust museums across the world. They will write down the lessons they have learned and make pledges (i.e. to "welcome and help new immigrants coming into Chicago").

The article covers the ways technology is used to teach the Holocaust to children in the form of holograms, AI, and VR. Dana describes a VR exhibit at one of the museums that takes the viewer on a first-person adventure from a boxcar to inside a gas chamber at Auschwitz.

A way Forward

Still, according to Dara, this doesn't achieve the primary objective of fighting anti-Semitism, which she dubs as a "Western mind virus" in the vein of the critical theorists, psychoanalysts, and anthropologists who preceded Holocaust remembrance in diagnosing the Gentile authoritarian personality. Dara emphasizes:

The study’s most disturbing finding was that even among those who studied the Holocaust, there was “a very common struggle among many students to credibly explain why Jews were targeted” in the Holocaust—that is, to cite anti-Semitism.

Dara's idea of a credible explanation for why Jews were targeted is revealed near the conclusion:

“If you don’t explain the ism,” she cautioned the teachers in the room, “you will need to explain to the kids ‘Why the Jews?’ Students are going to see Nazis as aliens who bring with them anti-Semitism when they come to power in ’33, and they take it back away at the end of the Holocaust in 1945.”

She asked the teachers, “What’s the first example of the persecution of the Jews in history?” ...

More blank stares. Finally, one woman said, “Are you talking about the Old Testament?”

“Think ancient Egypt,” Decoster said. “Does this sound familiar to any of you?”

“They’re enslaved by the Egyptian pharaoh,” a teacher said.

I wasn’t sure that the biblical Exodus narrative exactly qualified as “history,” but it quickly became clear that wasn’t Decoster’s point. “Why does the pharaoh pick on the Jews?” she asked. “Because they had one God.”

I was stunned. Rarely in my journey through American Holocaust education did I hear anyone mention a Jewish belief.

“The Jews worship one God, and that’s their moral structure. Egyptian society has multiple gods whose authority goes to the pharaoh. When things go wrong, you can see how Jews as outsiders were perceived by the pharaoh as the threat.”

This unexpected understanding of Jewish belief revealed a profound insight about Judaism: Its rejection of idolatry is identical to its rejection of tyranny. I could see how that might make people uncomfortable.

I wonder what Safe AI-powered simulacra will be used on my children when they become of age, scientifically optimized to train their perception of Jews - and their own identity. Horn has no shortage of ideas:

Back at home, I thought again about the Holocaust holograms and the Auschwitz VR, and realized what I wanted. I want a VR experience of the Strashun Library in Vilna, the now-destroyed research center full of Yiddish writers and historians documenting centuries of Jewish life. I want a VR of a night at the Yiddish theater in Warsaw—and a VR of a Yiddish theater in New York. I want holograms of the modern writers and scholars who revived the Hebrew language from the dead—and I definitely want an AI component, so I can ask them how they did it. I want a VR of the writing of a Torah scroll in 2023, and then of people chanting aloud from it through the year, until the year is out and it’s read all over again—because the book never changes, but its readers do. I want a VR about Jewish literacy: the letters, the languages, the paradoxical stories, the methods of education, the encouragement of questions. I want a VR tour of Jerusalem, and another of Tel Aviv. I want holograms of Hebrew poets and Ladino singers and Israeli artists and American Jewish chefs. I want a VR for the conclusion of Daf Yomi, the massive worldwide celebration for those who study a page a day of the Talmud and finally finish it after seven and a half years. I want a VR of Sabbath dinners. I want a VR...

I want to mandate this for every student in this fractured and siloed America, even if it makes them much, much more uncomfortable than seeing piles of dead Jews does. There is .. no other way to learn what Jews first taught the world: love your neighbor.

To defend Yudkowsky a bit, if his solution were predicated on international treaty when there are high economic and geopolitical incentives to defect, you would absolutely have to enforce it with an extreme amount violence or threat of violence. Airstrikes would probably not be good enough to stop nations from trying- although I look forward to the next Top Gun movie which will feature an airstrike on a data center instead of a nuclear research facility. Maverick will come out of retirement to deliver the killing blow to the grey goo after beating the AI-controlled bogeys in a dogfight. This will do much more to garner public support for Yudkowsky's proposal than his blog.

But there's too much pearl-clutching over the "advocating for violence" criticism. AI is going to be involved in violence, in many ways. Responses like:

There’s no such thing as lawful or legitimate aggression in int’l relations, because there’s no sovereign monopoly on its use which is the definition of legitimated force. It’s anarchy and it’s all illegitimate where aggressive.

Are just completely tedious. People are going to die because of AI, there's no question. It's only a question of when, how and why.

I don't think there's verification for signatures- Altman was added by someone but probably removed. FWIW I saw someone elsewhere mention that Altman was included but he wasn't there when I checked.

Here's a screenshot, he deleted the tweet, citing anti-Semitism and threats. Then he deleted the tweet with the complaint of anti-Semitism.

When people had the nerve to respond negatively to this, he of course pointed out to them that requesting he not dance on the graves of dead children is anti semitic.

To be fair, there was plenty of anti-Semitism in the replies. Even the Taliban PR twitter account (?) joined in.

Pakman could have said something edgy with more plausible deniability like "Sending thoughts and prayers", still in bad taste but could have been said to be a social critique. But "given that lack of prayer is often blamed for these horrible events" is just a WTF. You can say that sending condolences doesn't solve an underlying problem, but it is certainly not "often" that a lack of prayer is blamed. He let the mask slip.