@SecureSignals's banner p

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

				

User ID: 853

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 853

The case for a right-of-conquest is seriously undermined by the fact that Israel owes its existence - its entire conquest as such - to foreign powers and continued foreign aid in its defense, and foreign intervention in destabilizing or outright destroying its adversaries. The subsequent ethnic cleansing is not a conquest, it's just the spoils of the Western conquest on behalf of the Jews.

Israel has been unable to resolve the Palestinian question, and the failure for any peace is another blow to acknowledging any sort of conquest. They are pursuing a longer-term solution of resettlement but they simply have not been able to solve the problem with any resolution that could rightfully be called a conquest.

Independence is a privilege, not a right.

Agreed- if the Zionists want their state in the middle of hostile territory surrounded by enemies on all sides, they can defend it themselves, and they have no right to demand the rest of the world works towards the security of their state. All it has earned the United States is the enmity of the Arab world, foreign entanglement in Middle East wars that are not in its interests, and general destabilization of the Middle East which has been a strong contributing factor to refugee crises which are saddled on the European sphere due in no small part to international NGOs and lobbying efforts.

Israel hasn't exercised right-by-conquest, it's exercised right-by-political-influence-in-the-West, and that's why there's been no resolution to these decades of problems.

There are a lot of constraints to your question, like assuming you are talking to a moderate/reasonable woke person and you don't want to credibly be accused of being a bigot. That doesn't leave a lot of options, but your best bet would be along the lines of advocating for an MLK color-blind ideal followed by your reasoning for why conservatism or Republicans have a better strategy for realizing this vision. You could say that race isn't essential, and the emphasis on race threatens to stoke racial tensions indefinitely and have blowback effects on progressive advocacy which is, in important ways, keeping racial distinction alive in public consciousness- whereas we should be trying to move past it. In this way, you could try to make the argument that progressivism does more harm than good on that front.

But on the other hand, I of course do not buy any of those arguments and all arguments I would give would credibly be accused of bigotry, so I would avoid any conversation like that unless I were willing to face the accusation. If I were really in that situation and couldn't avoid conversation, I would probably try to find some middle ground where I genuinely agree with them without tipping them off to my actual beliefs.

For example, I do think that there are many reasonable woke people who are more empathetic than the average conservative. I think the "MLK conservative" type of counterargument laid out above (vocally advocated for by some here) does genuinely lack empathy and sensitivity to lived experience by demanding that all cast aside their racial and ethnic identities and ignore the systematic issues that do indeed break along racial lines. And this appears to be an intractable problem that won't go away by being ignored. In the same ways, the conservative "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" mentality genuinely does lack empathy. So I might agree with the woke interlocutor on the need for empathy and identity without conceding to broader oppression narratives that are usually associated with those premises.

I also think it's a mistake to consider woke positions, especially the more "reasonable" or steel-manned form of those positions, to be idiotic. It follows from centuries of Christian and liberal thinking. The MLK idea which conservatives are desperately trying to hijack as a kosher opposition to wokeness is clearly a failure, it does lack empathy and is self-serving, and I would feel like a fraud if I tried to advance those arguments to score some debate points against someone who is woke. The MLK idea is a failure because of reasons that wokes are sensitive to - oblivious they may be to the causes of the problems they identify.

I've seen that video. It would be comparable if there was a wealth of testimonies from people who had personally spoken with these phantom Cossacks, and testimony from the Cossacks themselves.

Even better, there were witnesses to snow being shoveled out of the passenger wagons which were allegedly transporting the Russians. A very Holocaust-esque detail. There seems to be something about a passenger train with the shades drawn that excites the imagination of passersby in the right conditions and state of rumor.

Closed goods wagons do a lot of work in the Holocaust narrative as well. The British civilians thought they were witnessing mass transports of Russians when they saw random trains with the shades drawn. No doubt similar errors would be made with transports consisting of closed goods wagons and unknown cargo.

there is German documentation to support the arrival of very many mass transports of Polish Jews to Treblinka, as I outlined earlier in the thread.

There is no German documentation to support the arrival of mass transports of Jews to T-II. The only surviving train records denote "Treblinka" as the destination, but even the mainstream acknowledges that this did not refer to T-II, and they allege that there was some (undocumented) shunting operation from Malkinia that is not recorded anywhere. Those same records also specify lengthy stops at other locations known to be connected to labor camps.

The Hoefle Telegram says "T", and it shouldn't be assumed that this referred to T-II. We know the train schedules documented "Treblinka" as the transport destination but that did not actually denote or indicated T-II as the destination of the transport. The Korherr report is even more vague and describes the settlers as "sifted through the camps of General Government", which does not provide any sort of statement on how many Jews set foot in T-II either. Of course neither document makes the slightest mention of extermination, and Korherr himself claimed after the war to believe that it referred to actual resettlement.

Huge quantities of human ash and remains found on the premises in 1944.

Soviet investigators concluded that they found no mass graves and none likely existed in the camp. You have even acknowledged that a complete cremation cover-up to make the graves "spotlessly clean" was not possible. That makes the lack of discovery of mass graves, by the own conclusion of the Soviet investigation, much more unlikely given your recognition that a complete cover-up was impossible.

So there's no documentation of mass transports to T-II, investigators have never discovered any mass graves on the site by their own stated conclusions- you entirely rely on the testimony of witnesses.

The remains of the place(s) where these people were "concentrated"? The people themselves?

As far as I have seen, there is nothing of the sort.

Yes, there are. It turns out that there were many tens of thousands of camps in the East that historians were not aware of, and those camps have only recently been studied with very limited information available.

Researchers at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum have been documenting all of the Nazi concentration camps, ghettos, slave labour sites and killing factories which had been set up across Europe.

When they first started the project, the team expected to find about 7,000 camps and ghettos.

Shockingly, they discovered 42,500 camps across large swathes of German-controlled Europe.

Speaking to the New York Times, Hartmut Berghoff, director of the institute, said: 'The numbers are so much higher than what we originally thought...

When the project first started, the researchers expected to find about 7,000 Nazi camps and ghettos. But as the project has gone on, the numbers constantly increased to the current figure of 42,500.

It's pretty awkward of them to find 6x the number of camps that they previously thought existed. Obviously the greater number of camps than expected implies a greater operation of resettlement rather than mass extermination.

So historians missed tens of thousands of camps that existed in these areas. This revelation certainly gives more context to Korherr's interpretation of settlers "sifted through the camps of General Government" as opposed to documenting some exact number brought to T-II for extermination. It turns out there were many more camps than historians had ever imagined. Likely there are many more that have not been found.

You have said that the story of Treblinka is absurd. I think it is absurd to claim that the Germans carried out a massive action larger than any single Soviet deportation, and pulled it off without leaving a shred of evidence behind, but this is the revisionist claim.

You realize that your entire case relies on the reliability of Soviet investigation right? Because it is also possible (indeed likely) that exculpatory evidence would not have been investigated, retained, or presented by Soviet investigators. The Soviets denied access to Western observers during these investigations, which further reduces their credibility. You can't say that it didn't leave behind "a shred of evidence" unless you trust Soviet investigators to find and preserve the exculpatory evidence that would have been left behind. I certainly do not.

And of course, 40,000+ camps can only be interpreted as evidence for resettlement, as those camps would not have been necessary given the assumption of an extermination policy.

On the other hand, I do trust that if there had been mass graves of 800,000 people in Treblinka, the Soviet investigators would have found them and conducted a propaganda campaign with 10x the fanfare of the German exhumation of the Katyn Mass Graves. The fact that they concluded in their own report that no mass graves were found and never bothered to excavate any of them with international observers and the whole nine yards should be interpreted as evidence that the mass graves are not there.

They weren't able to actually do a grand mass grave exhumation like the Katyn Forest massacre because they weren't able to find any mass graves! That fact has been attributed to the magical cover-up by the magical cremations, but you and I know that's a lie.

Edit: One more point, which is that Majdanek had many, many witnesses to mass gassings in facilities which are now admitted to have not been gas chambers. I would daresay that there were more Majdanek gas chamber witnesses than Treblinka witnesses based on some thread I saw awhile back where a bunch of witness testimony was compiled from former Majdanek inmates who had identified the (real) shower facility as the center of gas chamber extermination.

The unreliability of witness testimony is legendary. I've already explained to you why the historical validity of the subsequent trials - decades after the fact - has low historical trustworthiness but you continue to just appeal to the witnesses anyway. Witnesses in a show trial are not good historical evidence, period. But that's all you really have to work with.

I'm not a diehard NFL fan, I've seen a lot of games end with winding down the clock but it's the first time I remember seeing someone intentionally dive in front of the open end-zone to avoid a touchdown.

Can you show any comparable historical event where every single witness lied about every detail of what what happened?

Ryan Faulk presents an interesting case study in how rumor can lead to systematically false testimony, even false testimony that confounds both sides of a conflict. People even claimed to first-hand witness the details of "Russians mobilizing in England" but it never happened. Take something like a delousing procedure, and it's trivial to see how this could form the basis for some murder-shower propaganda rumor that takes on a life of its own.

The proportion of "Holocaust witnesses" to the main alleged extermination operation is an extremely low percentage of all witnesses, certainly a very small fraction of a single percent. Even at Auschwitz, over 99% of witnesses did not report any direct knowledge of gas chamber extermination and only a very few number of witnesses interviewed by the Soviets claimed to be Sonderkommando for example.

The vast majority of witnesses were likely telling the truth to the best of their recollection and it's only a very small number of testimonies proportionally that are identified by Revisionists as deceitful.

Your question should ask instead if there are comparable tribunals where witnesses lied about what happened, but you know the bar for that is absurdly low. All 9 Treblinka "witnesses" false-positively identified John Demjanjuk as a Treblinka guard in that Israeli show trial. At the original Nuremberg trial, the entire Treblinka narrative was substantiated by a single witness testimony that lasted no longer than 15 minutes, and that witness was not even cross-examined. This behavior doesn't just apply to witnesses with a bone to pick, it also applies to defendants as well, probably most famously in the Salem Witch trials:

Historically, a confession was the single best way for the court to gain a conviction and an execution for charges of witchcraft. The irony is that none of the accused Salem witches who confessed were convicted or executed but all 19 people who refused to confess were found guilty and executed.

The accused witches quickly figured out by watching the early trials that a confession could spare you from the gallows.

At the Nuremberg Trials, the former commandant of Auschwitz Josef Kramer flatly denied the Auschwitz extermination narrative in his opening defense:

I have heard of the allegations of former prisoners in Auschwitz referring to a gas chamber there, the mass executions and whippings, the cruelty of the guards employed, and that all this took place either in my presence or with my knowledge. All I can say to all this is that it is untrue from beginning to end.

But as the trial unfolded he understood that the only permissible defense was to admit knowledge but downplay responsibility for the same reasons as above.

And of course there were many Soviet show trials where people confessed to ridiculous and false things. The chief Soviet prosecutor in the Nuremberg Trials was heavily involved in those Stalinist show-trials as well.

There is also the fact that the WWI German "corpse-factory" atrocity hoax is eerily similar to the WWII Holocaust atrocity claims, so there is even precedent for specifically allegations of "corpse factories" being intentionally created but widely-believed atrocity lies.

The entire Treblinka narrative was established in a sham trial based on no evidence. That doesn't lend credibility to the subsequent trials decades after the fact, where the extermination narrative had already been "proven" decades before those trials even happened. Although at Nuremberg, the alleged murder weapon used at Treblinka was still steam chamber.

I have never seen anybody other than a Revisionist recognize that the Treblinka narrative presented in the "standard work" on Treblinka is impossible. To_Mandalay is the only one in the mainstream camp I have ever seen concede that. It is entirely fair to attribute that position to Revisionism because Revisionists, at great personal risk and costs, have been the only ones who have done the research and published those criticisms that he is now acknowledging are true.

If you can show me any published work from the mainstream camp that is critical of Arad's narrative along the same line of argument, you would have a good point, but the logistical impossibility of Arad's claims is a position that is indeed 100% owned by Revisionists and acknowledged by no mainstream historians.

Arad didn't entirely make up those claims out of the blue. Those historical claims were made based on witness testimony. As has been stressed in this argument, there is no documentary or physical proof establishing the murder of millions of people in these "extermination camps". The case is based on the testimony of witnesses. For example, someone in this thread cited Chil Rajchman as providing a compelling witness testimony for the cremation operation at Treblinka. But Rajchman stressed that the cremation work was completed early:

It is July 1. We were supposed to have worked also in the afternoon, but at the last moment there was a counter-order.

We are locked inside our barrack.

Through a small window we see that a large number of guards have been posted all around the place. A few minutes later Himmler arrives with his convoy. He inspects the gas chambers and then walks to the place where the graves once were and where now everything is spotlessly clean. Himmler looks very satisfied. He laughs, and his underlings, who are standing some meters away, are beaming with pleasure.

Rajchman states that the work was completed by July. Arad cites Rajchman and heavily relies on his account of the cremation operations. The implication of Arad formulating an impossible historical narrative is that the evidence used to substantiate the narrative was unreliable.

If Rajchman's account of cremation work being done and the mass graves being "spotlessly" cleaned by July is wrong, and he even describes Himmler visiting and laughing at the completely cleaned out mass graves, how does that impact your assessment of his credibility? To_Mandalay's position constitutes an inherent criticism of Rajchman's account, which does have implications for the broader narrative and is not a minor issue.

Revisionists contend that the entire mass cremation narrative was formulated by lying witnesses in order to provide an explanation for a lack of evidence for what they claimed to witness. After all, if you are lying about someone committing a crime you may also lie about how you witnessed them cover up the evidence for their crime, thereby providing an explanation for why investigators would not be able to find evidence for your allegation. So acknowledging Arad's narrative as unworkable is not just a minor historical disagreement, it's a justification of the Revisionist criticism of the evidence used by mainstream historians that formulates the foundation for the entire narrative.

'More research' is always a good thing but the broad thrust of a narrative can still remain intact even if some tweaking of it might be needed.

The thrust of the narrative does not remain intact because the evidence which was used to formulate the discredited narrative is the same body of evidence used to prop up the other parts of the narrative.

The way I have approached this is that the evidence is co-related. If holocaust historians cite 3 witnesses that claim something, and Revisionists show beyond doubt that one of the witnesses is wrong or lying, that increases my suspicion that the other witnesses are unreliable. Revisionists have proven beyond doubt that the mainstream historical narrative was wrong about Majdanek as an extermination camp with homicidal gas chambers, and that increased my suspicion that it was also wrong about other alleged "extermination camps."

People have nothing better to do than to chain NPCs to a cave and give them an indonesian muppet show all day long?

What do you think Hollywood, art, mass media, religion, and culture essentially are? If you are the one putting on the show you guide the reality-perception of the masses. That's the stuff that builds (or destroys) civilization. The cave allegory is lame because it supposes some duty for philosophers to liberate the NPCs. But that's not possible or desirable. The vast majority of people are probably not capable of living without some sort of structure defined by the puppet show put on by the elites.

The cave allegory should be properly understood as recognizing the power of mass media and culture over the masses. Plato understood the psychological power of light projection thousands of years before the creation of cinema. That should be the real takeaway from the allegory.

So what? 'Mainstream historiography' evolves constantly in any case. Arad's book was written forty years ago...

I read Arad's book a while ago, but if he indeed claims that 800,000 people were fully cremated between March 1943 and August 1943 using nothing but dry branches then yes he is wrong, you win.

Yitzhak Arad served as the director of Yad Vashem, Israel's official Holocaust museum, for over twenty years. It's fair to say that this is the most important academic position in Holocaust historiography. Arad's work, despite being originally published 40 years ago, is still the standard work on the so-called Operation Reinhardt Death Camps.

The Operation Reinhard Death Camps, Revised and Expanded Edition, authored by Arad with Yad Vashem as contributor, was published only in 2018. Are these claims still in the "Revised and expanded edition?" Yes, they are. From Chapter 23 of my copy:

IN LATE FEBRUARY OR EARLY March 1943, Heinrich Himmler visited Operation Reinhard headquarters and the death camps of Sobibor and Treblinka. Himmler had already paid a visit to Operation Reinhard headquarters in the first stage of the extermination action, in the middle of July 1942. The second visit also included the death camps, places he had not inspected on his first tour. The February 1943 visit was in the closing stage of Operation Reinhard, which, according to Himmler’s order of July 19, 1942, had to be accomplished by December 31, 1942.

Needless, to say there's no documentary evidence whatsoever that Himmler visited Treblinka. But Arad goes on:

Himmler learned from his visit to Treblinka that, in spite of his orders, the corpses of the Jews who had been exterminated in this camp had not been cremated, but buried. Immediately after this visit, the big cremating operation began in the camp. This was the main task imposed on Treblinka during the last months of the camp’s existence...

After Himmler’s visit, the date for closing and liquidating the camps of Belzec, Sobibor, and Treblinka became dependent on the completion of the cremation of the victims’ corpses and the erasure of all traces of the crimes that had been carried out in these camps. The timetable for carrying out this decision lay mainly in the hands of the camp commanders and in their ability and desire to accomplish the erasure of the crimes as quickly as possible.

From Chapter Twenty-Four: "The Erasure of the Crimes"

In Treblinka, the camp command faced the most difficult task—unearthing over 700,000 corpses and cremating them while at the same time continuing to receive new transports with Jews for extermination. In this camp the entire cremation operation lasted about four months, from April to the end of July 1943. To accomplish the task, the cremating took place simultaneously in a number of sites and the largest number of Jewish prisoner-workers were put to work in the various required stages.

What are the implications of acknowledging Arad's claims are impossible? For one, Arad's account does not permit you peg the start of mass cremation earlier than Himmler's alleged visit to Treblinka in February/March 1943. Secondly, you can't make the cremation operation end later because of the camp revolt. Thirdly, leaving a bunch of corpses uncremated would contradict the claimed orders and objective of the alleged cremation operation- to erase the crime. So you can't really massage Arad's account into a workable narrative without dispensing with the historical continuity that he is presenting.

In any case, the persistence of these impossible claims in the most important standard works of the Holocaust proves that Revisionism is necessary. You don't seem to mind conceding that Arad's account is impossible, but there is no mainstream historian that challenges those claims on their impossibilities. Only Revisionists do that.

Arad's claims demonstrate a systematic failure of mainstream historiography. If impossible claims have been made and believed for so many decades, that is proof that additional evidence is required to truly understand what transpired. In other words, you can't just say "Oh they must have cremated 200,000 people instead of 800,000 then because that is more plausible." The proper conclusion is that more research is needed if any of the claims attached to the discredited narrative are true to any extent.

And given the systematic failure of witnesses, courts, and historians to ascertain the truth of these allegations, they should not be believed without a large amount of physical evidence. Physical evidence that would still be right there in the ground in massive quantities for the mainstream to uncover - if they wanted to. But they don't want to- why complicate these fantastical narratives, which are already widely believed, with real excavations?

Contemporaneous reports to who?

To anyone anywhere!

Any sort of document or report about anybody in the area noticing a daily forest-fire size inferno from the camp which was well known among the locals. Somehow reports of a "Treblinka extermination camp" reached London before Treblinka was even open! But during the height of the extermination with the most publicly visible impossible-to-hide massive fires 24/7, there's nobody who noticed anything? Nobody who noticed hundreds of cords of wood being delivered every single day? None of the witnesses noticed or appreciated the massive amount of fuel that would be required for what they were claiming to witness? They kind of forgot about the thousands of cords of wood that would have had to have been burned?

It's possible that either knowledge of the intended function of TII linked before the start of operations (since Belzec and Sobibor had been open for months at this time) or that there were 'test gassings' carried out there as at Belzec and Sobibor. I consider either of these plausible.

More speculation without evidence or support in mainstream historiography. It's not plausible that the TII "extermination camp" would be outed in the international press before it was even opened by shrewd spies operating in the area, but then the impossible-to-hide daily mass cremation fires were not apparently noticed by anybody.

Is there any documentation referencing or establish the delivery of anything to Treblinka during the entire period of its operation? No, there is not.

That is an excellent point, which also raises the point that the alleged arrival of 800,000+ Jews to the camp, T-II, is not documented. So that should be added as another premise to these grand claims that does not have documentary support. The claim that ~800,000 people step foot in T-II specifically is based solely on witness testimony and has no documentary support. So there's another assumption added to the pile needed to make the story work.

I find it extremely difficult to take revisionists seriously when they complain about a lack of documentation, considering your thesis is that the Nazis shipped and resettled millions of Polish Jews to the Russian east without leaving any evidence of the mass operation whatsoever in the historical record.

I know you don't take the revisionist complaint about lack of documentation seriously, it's why I'm a revisionist. The mainstream makes these fantastical assertions and then tires to absolve themselves of having documentary support for what they are claiming actually happened. That was a big hint to me that Revisionists are right.

Yitzhak Arad is not holy scripture.

Another very good point! But if you doubt Arad's claims strongly enough you will be thrown in jail in much of Europe. On the other hand, you can deny holy scripture without anybody raising an eyebrow, which makes Holocaust historiography holier-than-holy scripture. The main point is that these claims made in mainstream historiography were not based on strong evidence, and instead of Holocaust bloggers saying "Arad and mainstream historians got it right, look at all this evidence that shows their conclusions", the bloggers will retreat from the claims that are being challenged by Revisionists to try to make them more reasonable than what was originally asserted.

Eyeballing Jannson's photo, the area of the Birkshaw pits is not in fact significantly larger than the yellow areas identified by Colls+the area under the cement of the memorial.

You maybe should get your eyeballs checked, as the area is significantly larger than the yellow areas. The shape of the yellow areas also do not resemble the shape of a well-constructed huge mass graves which would have been required to achieve the shape and dimensions of the graves alleged. Caroline Colls did not find a single pit that resembled the very large pits you are referencing, and of course she did not excavate any mass graves in the camp at all.

You're right that it's infeasible to completely cremate several hundred thousand corpses on open air pyres in the space of a few months. Which is why it is unsurprising that it didn't work, and the place was found by the Soviets and the Poles covered in ash and bone and bits of intact human corpses .

That's a vague concession. Can you instead concede specifically that the cremation operation claimed by Yitzhak Arad: Late February/March 1943 - August 1943 cremation of 800,000 people, was not possible as described? That would be a more meaningful concession but I have a feeling you won't be willing to make it.

You also know as well as I do that the Soviet investigation concluded that no mass graves were found and none likely remained in the camp. And since then no excavation of alleged mass graves has ever been done, and it's specifically forbidden by Jewish authorities.

This is also a good demonstration of the Revisionist versus the Holocaust blogger approach. The Revisionist approach is "Yitzahk Arad is making impossible claims, so the foundation of this entire narrative is very weak and more physical evidence is therefore required." And Holocaust blogger approach is "Yitzahk Arad is making impossible claims, so what actually happened must have been half of what he claimed." That is the pattern I've observed and it's another reason I'm a revisionist.

The point is that ChatGPT is useless for this purpose, unless you want to agree with the bot that the Great Purge is "highly unlikely" to have happened.

I think ChatGPT gave a reasonable response. Such a mass execution is highly unlikely in general in that it's a rare event. But you didn't ask it specifically about the Great Purge. ChatGPT gave specific criticisms of the evidence for the Treblinka narrative. Does it give similar criticisms of the evidence for the Great Purge?

A key takeaway from the Holocaust blogger's analysis is that even they, using the most generous (and wrong) assumptions possible in order to reduce hypothetical fuel requirements, still estimate it would have required 30,450 kg of dry wood to cremate 2,500 bodies. With a daily cremation rate of 5,000 - 7,000 bodies attested to by witnesses and claimed by mainstream historiography, that would be an average daily fuel requirement of over 60-85+ cords of wood to be delivered, hauled, used for construction, and burned on a daily basis for 150 days straight. That is a daily requirement of over three to four times the amount of wood as in this video.

The burning of this wood according to Jansonn's estimate would produce the daily equivalent to a 150m x 150m forest fire that looks like this. Again, this is assuming the Holocaust blogger's stated fuel requirements rather than an estimate closer to Carlo Mattogno's analysis which would multiply the scale of these allegations.

These raging infernos were only about 500 meters from a busy rail line connecting Malkinia to Siedlce Poland. The camp was also in the area of several villages and hamlets. The Treblinka camp was well known among the locals and there were even reports in the international press about a Treblinka "extermination camp" before the alleged extermination camp was even open.

With all the attention and rumor surrounding this camp, were there any contemporaneous reports of these daily raging infernos? No, there weren't, despite the fact that local villagers would go to the camp perimeter to trade embezzled property. Is there any documentation referencing or establishing the daily mass deliveries of huge quantities of dry wood? No, there is not. Is there any witness account for how this wood was delivered or hauled to the cremation aera despite the huge logistical problem it posed? No, there is not. There is nothing.

Witnesses claim little or no fuel was required because the story-tellers had no conception for the amount of fuel that would be required to actually do what they were claiming (and neither do many people here, apparently). So they didn't think it was a problem to claim that only dry branches were used, or no fuel was used at all.

What is the absolute best way to defend the claims? The best way to defend the claims is to abandon them, as To_Mandalay has. He, contra authoritative historians like Arad, suggests that mass cremations began much earlier. Also contra mainstream historiography, claims that some unspecified portion of the victims did not get cremated and that complete cremation was probably not attained. So he defends mainstream historiography by abandoning it, and it's telling that the "best defense" from the Revisionist argument is to retreat from the claims when pressed.

The problem with his retreat is that he further contradicts the "logic" in the entire operation. Why didn't Treblinka have state-of-the-art crematoria like other concentration camps? Because the plan was to bury the bodies, and the order to exhume and cremate them was a last-minute decision to hide the evidence after the Katyn Forest mass graves were discovered by the Germans and Himmler supposedly got spooked by his own mass graves being found in the same way.

Likewise, it is said that the motive for the gargantuan task to exhume and cremate millions of corpses was to hide evidence of the crime. If not all the cremations were done, or the cremation was not complete with a high state of destruction, that also flies in the face of the logic which is claimed to have motivated the orders.

Here revisionist Friedrich Jansson, who ran this blog, tells about the "495,000 sheep-equivalent carcasses" that were buried in about "1.3467 hectares" of burial space at Birkshaw.

Jannson's analysis strongly supports the Revisionist argument. Look at the diagram of Birkshaw pits scaled to the Treblinka-required-equivalent shows how large of an area would have been required and how Caroline Coll's GPR results identified 0 pits with the dimensions resembling the Birkshaw pits in size, shape, or volume. Again I'll emphasize that Colls did not excavate any of the pits suggested to contain mass graves, so we're left in a familiar situation....

I don't really see the purpose of digging up places like Treblinka. It's naturally more sensitive than massacres from hundreds or tens of thousands of years ago. The only real purpose would be to placate Holocaust deniers and I don't blame the people in charge of these sites for not being prioritizing that.

"Not prioritizing" that is not an accurate description. The authorities responsible for the site hired a team of archaeologists, and produced TV shows and exhibits based on that work. They forbade the excavation of any mass graves. So it's not just "not prioritized", it's forbidden.

"The only real purpose would be to placate Holocaust deniers and I don't blame the people in charge of these sites for not being prioritizing that" sounds familiar...

Genocide deniers ask: Where are the bodies of the residential schoolchildren?

But. Where. Are. The. Bodies?

They are where they were buried — in those secret or official graves. At this point, nobody is going to be digging up those children to satisfy a bunch of white settlers’ points of view as to what we should be doing with our tragically deceased little ones.

Currently, we don’t have protocols in place yet (that I’m aware of) on how to sensitively deal with the graves. However, we are taking our cultural beliefs into consideration, which go against unsettling rest spaces. This call for bodies is nothing more than a racist rant bordering on genocide denial.

How far will a denier go? When no longer able to refute the absurdly massive physical evidence, Holocaust deniers started to appeal to more “scientific” data. For example, they claimed that the chemical analysis of hydrogen cyanide compounds showed the amounts were not sufficient enough to kill people in gas chambers. Posing as tourists, these “scientists” would gouge chunks of plaster from the walls of gas chambers to send them for analysis.

What happened in residential schools is not about the evidence. This kind of trolling is part of genocide, as are the actual crimes. Gregory H. Stanton, an expert on crimes against humanity, described 10 stages of genocide; extermination is not the final step. Rather, its final stage is denial that it happened — such as high-profile commentators’ demands to see bodies.

We see To_Mandalay pull a very familiar script. This is the script that Revisionists have had to contend with for decades. And now the Kamloops allegations provide another example that should hopefully wake people up to the tactics used by actors maliciously engaging in atrocity propaganda for political purposes.

As another aside, with regards to ChatGPT's ability to evaluate the reality of historical atrocities

Well the most pertinent claim from ChatGPT was on cremation requirements in a context that wasn't related to historical atrocities. So you have to assume that Revisionist literature polluted ChatGPT's understanding of the science of cremation even in a non-atrocity context, and that's why it estimated fuel requirements in line with Mattogno and not in line with the Holocaust bloggers. You can say ChatGPT is wrong but it's highly unlikely that Revisionist literature has influenced its understanding of cremation so heavily.

The furnaces used were huge, thus kept the heat of the bodies that have already burned before in their brickwork.

There was no brickwork. The bodies were piled on outdoor fires because Treblinka like the other two camps did not have a crematorium with modern ovens. The plan was to bury the bodies and the plan changed only in 1943, but no crematoria were built. This was not an "industrial process", it was allegedly done with the most crude methods and none of the modern technology that were used for cremation in the concentration camp. All experience shows that these cremations require a huge amount of energy, and I continue to be surprised that so many people are claiming that the Treblinka cremations were the only cremations in human history that required no fuel. Why? "Industrial processes" or something.

Whether or not you can perform a cremation without additional fuel will depend on how much heat is lost to the environment

So you are not saying one way or another whether a cremation requires fuel? Can you cite me any case or example where the cremation of a carcass (livestock for example) did not require fuel to be cremated to ash?

Here's an example by the way of a cremation of a pig with a large amount of wood fuel. It did not achieve complete cremation.

So that's now 3 people who have claimed it takes no fuel to cremate bodies, just for the record.

I have provided empirical evidence in the form of historical mass cremation, where massive amounts of fuel were used to cremate livestock:

According to a USDA veterinarian who helped during the U.K. outbreak, a 200-meter funeral pyre was used to incinerate 400 cows or 1,200 sheep or 1,600 pigs. Such a pyre required 1,000 railway ties, 8 tons of kindling, 400 wooden pallets, 4 tons of straw, 200 tons of coal, and 1,000 liters of diesel fuel.

I've also cited modern cremation practices, which are universally known and acknowledged to require huge amounts of energy.

Too bad the workers didn't know that the cremation could have been accomplished with only a match and a little kindling. Too bad modern crematoriums are operated by such stupid people that they don't understand how easy cremation is.

I literally can't believe that we now have 3 people who believe that the cremation of 5,000 to 7,000 people could be accomplished without fuel beyond a little kindling. Such a lack of critical thinking and devotion to a cult-like belief in absurd claims.

So your contention is that it takes no fuel beyond body mass to perform a cremation?

Why would the Nazis want to hide the evidence of something they did not consider a crime?

According to official historiography, the discovery of the Katyn Forest mass graves by the Germans led Himmler to be concerned about the Holocaust mass graves being discovered in the same way. The story goes, he therefore ordered the extermination camps to exhume the corpses of the millions of murdered Jews and for them to be cremated.

Hiding the evidence is cited by mainstream historiography as the motive for the Germans exhuming the millions bodies they had just buried and burning them on open-air pyres.

There were even allegations that the Germans went further and mixed the cremated ashes of the gas chamber victims with concrete and used it to pave roads. The road that was constructed near Treblinka from around this time was forensically tested but no human remains were found in the material. There were also allegations that the cremains were manufactured into fertilizer and used for German crops. However, cremated remains are toxic to plant life largely due to the high concentration of sodium.

This is to say, hiding the evidence is the alleged motive motive for the gargantuan task of cremating 5,000-7,000 people every single day on open-air pyres in Treblinka. It therefore would have required cremation with a very high state of destruction.

Contrary to a layperson's perception of cremains, even state-of-the-art cremation furnaces do not reduce a body to pure ash. There are still many thousands of identifiable bone fragments and many large identifiable bone fragments. Needless to say, an open-air pyre is far less efficient than a state-of-the-art cremation furnace and would have extreme difficulty in reaching even this state of destruction.

There would be many hundreds of millions of identifiable teeth and bone fragments in the ground of Treblinka if the story were true, and it would be trivial to excavate huge masses of cremains at Treblinka and disprove Revisionism forever. But that is never going to happen, because the authorities know that those masses of remains are not there.

I repeat, reading "The Holocaust: a Nazi Perspective"

I've read it, it's typical Moldbug. Very provocative title, but makes no effort at a genuine Nazi perspective. He just cites a witness and says "good enough for me!"

You are just speaking pure nonsense, but I'll point out that the standard of cremation for hiding the evidence of a crime requires a much higher state of destruction than cremating a carcass for sanitary or biohazard reasons.

But why should this one claim, which is apparently likely false, entirely discredit the account?

You are asking why a witness claiming something that did not happen discredits the account? It increases the probability that the witness is lying. You suggest that the witness maybe just heard a false rumor, but you don't consider the possibility that the witness lied in order to increase the stakes of what he claimed to witness. There were other aspects of this happening, it's a pattern. Revisionists don't have to prove the witness is lying about everying, they just have to show the witness accounts are not sufficient evidence to establish what is being claimed.

All it shows is that eyewitness accounts should be interpreted critically and shouldn't be taken at face value, which is something we already knew.

That is good for you to acknowledge, but you are not interpreting the eyewitness accounts critically. For example, you take it for granted for granted that the entire 2 hectares of area conceivably had burial pits of 10 meters deep. No pits of 10 meters have been identified nor excavated, but apparently you do not require any physical investigation of these 10 meter pits in order to be sure they existed. The area burial density is unlike any other grave in human history, not even close. It is not plausible absent concrete, physical evidence which does not exist. Of those 2 hectares, 0% has been shown to actually cover mass graves of any depth, much less mass graves 10 meters deep for the entire area.

A million people buried in 2 hectares would be by far the most dense grave of carcasses in human history. It's not a plausible claim unless there is significant physical evidence to support it, and there is not. You rely on witness testimony to assert the plausibility of the claims.

Edit: A Revisionist has also compared burial density of other (real) concentration camp mass graves to the alleged Treblinka mass graves. Again, the real concentration camp graves resemble other known mass graves and the Treblinka mass graves you are alleging resemble nothing in history.

Furthermore, the historical position is not that these claims are plausible, it's that they are certain and there is no doubt the claims are true. Your assertion that "if 100% of 2 hectares was one giant pit that was 10 meters deep then it would be plausible" is a weak position in the face of official historiography, which has a much stronger position than "plausible."

Do you also think it's "plausible" that 5,000-7,000 people were cremated on outdoor pyres every single day? Do you think the truth of that claim is as certain as it is claimed by mainstream historiography? Do you also think it's plausible that these cremations were done without fuel?

What is the motive to lie?

The motive to lie is that a political prisoner detained and subject to harsh conditions has a reason to want to exact revenge against the defeated adversary. He might exaggerate the crimes committed by his captors or entirely make up claims that would be used against them in court and subject them to punishment.

In the trial of John Demjanjuk, Reichmann was one of 9 "Treblinka witnesses" who misidentified Demjanjuk as "Ivan the Terrible" in court. Do you think this was random circumstance, or do you think the misidentification was motivated by other factors? "Other factors" would include fame for participating in the Israeli show-trial and political clout- being celebrated by the global media for being a witness who identified "Ivan the Terrible." There is also a nationalistic motive, as Jewish nationalism is closely tied to Holocaust lore, having a conviction for a Treblinka guard in Israel would be a propaganda win for Jewish nationalism write large.

It even turned out that one of the witnesses who identified Demjanjuk as "Ivan the Terrible", Eliahu Rosenberg had testified in 1947 that "Ivan the Terrible" was killed in the Treblinka revolt. So that witness, Rosenberg, who made a big scene when he asked to "look into the eyes of Demjanjuk" to identify him, testified decades earlier that Ivan the Terrible was dead only to testify in the trial that it was John Demjanjuk. This cannot be said to be a case of mistaken identity. Why would Rosenberg testify that Ivan the Terrible was killed, and then identify him in a trial decades later?

The motives for false testimony are numerous, and systematically false testimony is not unusual either. It was a common features in witch trials and Soviet show-trials.

Just saw your edit. Revisionists have already studied the UK foot and mouth outbreak as a case study for mass burial and cremation.

Here is a source showing the mass burial specifications for the UK foot and mouth mass graves. It shows 1,262,000 worth of sheep that weighed 50kg on average (close to an average human) were buried in about 1000 hectares of mass grave space.

There is no more than 2 hectares of possible mass grave space in Treblinka based on mainstream research. Arad claims those 2 hectares held 800,000 human corpses.

The revisionist also analyzes the UK foot and mouth livestock mass grave at Great Orton. About 575,077 sheep-equivalent carcasses were buried in mass graves covering no less than 55 hectares.

If Treblinka achieved similar density as that livestock grave then that would imply 72 hectares of space would have been required to bury 760,000 people, but there is only 2 hectares of possible space where those bodies could have been buried in Treblinka, and 0% of those 2 hectares have ever been showed to cover mass graves.

The Revisionist put together the to-scale results from recent GPR investigation of Trebklina (in yellow) next to the Great Orton grave space (orange). So the orange space (at the very least) was required to bury 575,000 animal carcasses weighing an average of 50kg. But the yellow spots are supposed to account for the burial of 700,000-800,000 people in this small space in Treblinka. He also inlaid the GPR hits in a 1-hectare space to scale. Mainstream historians claim that 700,000-800,000 people were buried within that white square (plus maybe one more of those squares but there's no evidence for that). Those little pits supposedly held more carcasses than all of Great Orton.

Here's the to-scale comparison with Belzec, where the number of alleged burials in Belzec is 75.6% of the number of sheep-equivalent carcasses buried at Great Orton (orange).

There's also a brief analysis of the UK foot and mouth graves on cubic volume to show that what was observed was perfectly inline with Revisionist estimates.

Lastly, the UK foot and mouth case study allows us to dispense with the absurd claim from @official_techsupport that humans are self-cremating.

According to a USDA veterinarian who helped during the U.K. outbreak, a 200-meter funeral pyre was used to incinerate 400 cows or 1,200 sheep or 1,600 pigs. Such a pyre required 1,000 railway ties, 8 tons of kindling, 400 wooden pallets, 4 tons of straw, 200 tons of coal, and 1,000 liters of diesel fuel.

A 200-meter pyre for 1,200 sheep doesn't stand against the magical pyres at Treblinka that could cremate 7,000 people using a "few dry branches" or no fuel at all! So it goes.

You consider it plausible that the Germans built a large incinerator in Treblinka for British Jews who would be deported there after Hitler captured Great Britain? It's not plausible at all. There's no documentation for such a nonsensical plan. Such a device as described by Reichmann is not described in any documents or other witness testimonies, and you won't find a single mainstream historian who makes this claim today. There are multiple "mini-legends" within the Treblinka narrative that try to gave the British/Americans more stake in the Treblinka narrative, and that was one of them that didn't make its way into mainstream historiography. You have outed yourself as being incapable of assessing the plausibility of claims made by witnesses. Your judgement is obviously too clouded by your biases on the issue.

There's a difference between planning for victory and "you know what, let's just go ahead and build a large incinerator for British Jews for when Hitler gets around to conquering Great Britain, so they can be sent here to Treblinka." I can't begin to describe how asinine the assertion is. Needless to say, it did not happen, and it discredits Reichmann's account along with all of his other assertions.

It is not nearly as preposterous as you are claiming that a giant pile of corpses that had been decaying for a long time could burst into flames and burn for a day.

Decomposing/decomposed bodies are not flammable. The methane gases would escape in the open pit, and blood is not flammable. Bodies cannot sustain a fire for a day, and the decomposition would reduce the body mass that would provide energy. Even during a short cremation, the body mass cannot sustain a cremation and external heat has to be added to maintain temperatures. 250,000 bodies bursting into flames, with flammable blood seeping to the surface and burning for an entire day is a propaganda hoax. It did not happen, and it's unbelievable to me that you would think that this actually happened.

Reichmann says that over a million corpses were buried in Treblinka before being unburied and burned, and that particular mass grave with 250,000 bodies was only on grave of eleven mass graves. Do you think it's possible to bury a million people in 5 football fields?

It's astounding how much nonsense you are willing to believe without any concrete physical evidence or without the claims even being remotely possible. But believing this story requires belief in the impossible, because the official narrative makes impossible claims only supported by witnesses who lack credibility and have an obvious motive to lie.

That's rich coming from someone who is arguing that bodies are flammable and cremation is an energy-positive process, and that the cremations would have required no fuel. Even the informed anti-deniers do not make that argument, they would be embarrassed by your display. But you are so committed to believing witnesses you will believe them even when they make completely impossible claims.

Here are some other gems from Yechiel Reichmann including claims of:

The Germans building a special incinerator in Treblinka to exterminate British Jews after Hitler conquered Great Britain:

“Reichman also said the Nazis had prepared a special incinerator in Treblinka for British Jews, who were to be deported under Adolf Hitler's masterplan for a Jewish-free Europe.

‘This was the incinerator for the British Jews,’ he said, pointing to a diagram of Treblinka. ‘The Germans planned to bring them there when they captured Britain. It was built in a very solid manner and could not be moved. It remained there until the end.’

The mere notion that the Germans three months after Stalingrad would entertain hopes of defeating Great Britain and have all Jews of the island nation shipped over to Europe to be gassed is nothing else than laughable.

And blood that burst into flames like fuel:

At one time we put up a roast beside a large grave, into which more than 250.000 corpses had been thrown. The roast was loaded as usual and lit in the evening. There was a strong wind, and the fire burned so intensely, that it spread to the large opened grave. The blood from a quarter of a million human beings went up in flame and burned until the evening of the following day.

All of the leading camp staff came to take a look at this wonder. They marveled at this fantastic fire. The blood rose to the surface of the ground and ignited like fuel.” (p. 119)

Reichmann also falsely identified the American-Ukrainian citizen John Demjanjuk as a Treblinka guard known as "Ivan the Terrible." Demjanjuk was convicted and sentenced to death, but the conviction was overturned because it turned out all the Jewish witnesses which had identified him were "mistaken."

An elderly Jewish survivor of the Holocaust recalled today that a Ukrainian named Ivan was ''the biggest devil'' among the guards he knew at the Nazi death camp in Poland called Treblinka.

Sixty-six-year-old Chil Rajchman, now living in Uruguay, picked out a visa application photo of a suburban autoworker, John Demjanjuk, shown him by Government attorneys.

He said that ''in my opinion'' it was the Treblinka guard.

Mr. Rajchman was the first of nine Treblinka survivors to testify at Mr. Demjanjuk's denaturalization trial in Federal District Court here. The prosecution says the 60-year-old Mr. Demjanjuk herded trainloads of Polish Jews to gas chambers at two death camps in 1942 and 1943.

Things to keep it mind when you are trying to gauge the credibility of Rajchman's claim that thousands of people were cremated with "dry branches", or that blood seeped from the earth and burst into flames.

Your argument is that since a proper cremation of a single body requires a lot of energy, a mass cremation of 5000 bodies requires a proportionally prohibitive amount of energy.

If the cremation of a single body requires a lot of external energy, then why wouldn't that scale with the cremation of 5000 bodies? It absolutely would. The external energy must have a source to sustain hours of cremation.

Your claims are literally absurd. But it's why witnesses thought it wasn't too big of a problem to say that little or no fuel was used, or particularly fat women were used as fuel. There are also witnesses who say that blood was flammable and used as fuel, but I think even you wouldn't fall for that one.

@johnfabian cited Rajchman's Treblinka memoirs. Here is what Rajchman claims in his memoirs:

“At one time we put up a roast beside a large grave, into which more than 250.000 corpses had been thrown. The roast was loaded as usual and lit in the evening. There was a strong wind, and the fire burned so intensely, that it spread to the large opened grave. The blood from a quarter of a million human beings went up in flame and burned until the evening of the following day.

All of the leading camp staff came to take a look at this wonder. They marveled at this fantastic fire. The blood rose to the surface of the ground and ignited like fuel.” (p. 119)

Pure fantasy. Just think that he witnessed these things but the OSI didn't get around to interviewing him until 1980, and his first memoir wasn't published until 2009.

Edit: There's also this laughable account from Rajchman showing the propaganda-motive for these tall tales:

“Reichman also said the Nazis had prepared a special incinerator in Treblinka for British Jews, who were to be deported under Adolf Hitler's masterplan for a Jewish-free Europe.

‘This was the incinerator for the British Jews,’ he said, pointing to a diagram of Treblinka. ‘The Germans planned to bring them there when they captured Britain. It was built in a very solid manner and could not be moved. It remained there until the end.’”

The mere notion that the Germans three months after Stalingrad would entertain hopes of defeating Great Britain and have all Jews of the island nation shipped over to Europe to be gassed is nothing else than laughable.

That's a "jet fuel can't melt steel beams" kind of argument.

It's pretty unbelievable that you make the claim that thousands of people could be cremated simultaneously without fuel (except to start the fire), and that the cremation would be net energy-positive. Then you accuse me of making a "jet fuel can't melt steel beams" argument. You are literally saying that the cremations were magical and the bodies were self-cremating.

Humanity has practiced cremation for millennia. Cremation is not net-energy positive. There are many studies and case studies, especially pertaining to the cremation of livestock during pandemics, and what you are claiming is a fairy tale. Revisionists have also studied cases where extremely hot house or car fires failed to cremate a body, the notion that a body is self-cremating once a temperature threshold is reached is completely asinine.

But just because I asked ChatGPT to weigh in since people are more likely to trust an AI to say the sky is blue than a Holocaust denier:

Is cremation net energy-positive?

The cremation process itself consumes energy, typically in the form of natural gas or propane, to heat the cremation chamber to the high temperatures required for cremation. The energy required to cremate a body can vary depending on the size of the body, the type of equipment used, and the efficiency of the cremation process. Some sources suggest that cremation can be energy-intensive, particularly if the equipment used is not well-maintained or operated efficiently. In general, cremation is considered to be an energy-intensive process, and it is not considered to be net energy-positive.

But doesn't the body-mass give off energy when it cremates? So couldn't it be cremated with its own stored energy?

The energy released during cremation is not sufficient to sustain the process. Cremation requires a significant external energy source, typically in the form of gas, propane, or coal, to reach the high temperatures necessary for complete combustion of human remains. The energy released by the body is consumed in the initial stages of the cremation process and is not enough to continue the process on its own.

How much additional external energy would be necessary for complete combustion of human remains?

The amount of external energy required for complete combustion of human remains depends on several factors, such as the size and weight of the body, the temperature of the cremation chamber, and the efficiency of the cremation equipment. On average, it takes about two to three hours to cremate a human body using a modern cremation furnace. The furnace typically operates at a temperature of about 1400-1800°C and requires a significant amount of fuel, such as propane or natural gas, to maintain these high temperatures. The total energy requirement will depend on the specific conditions and equipment used, but it is safe to say that a significant amount of external energy is necessary for complete combustion of human remains.

You have not provided an explanation for how 5,000 could have been cremated every single day, you are providing evidence of how completely absurd the official story is and how detached it is from reality.

The suggestion that cremations were burned in the open-air without fuel is of course completely absurd, but so it goes in Holocaust lore. You are not just burning the meat, you are trying to cremate the skeleton to ashes, which requires a prolonged period of extremely high heat. Cremation is not an energy-positive process.

By means of a special process which Wirth had invented, they were burned in the open air without the use of fuel.

Is a perfect example of Holocaust mysticism. The statement "By means of a special process which Wirth had invented" is supposed to give credibility to the absurd claim. The "special process" was laying corpses on makeshift grates made with railroad rails and burned on open-air pyres.

But you can notice there is already a contradiction in the witness testimony. One says that the cremations were performed without the use of fuel (!) and the other just mentions that "dry branches" were used. Of course none of the methods attested to are remotely possible.

Here's another quick-and-dirty source:

Here's the morbid math: Cremating one corpse requires two to three hours and more than 1,800 degrees of heat

The energy from that is not coming from the body. It is a completely absurd claim but it's part-and-parcel for the sort of "witness testimony" you get when you try to account for the logistics for what is claimed.

I am aware of that point being raised by anti-Revisionists and I actually brought it up with ChatGPT in the original convo:

What if they were stacked together?

Stacking bodies to be cremated would not significantly reduce the amount of fuel required for cremation.

Cremation requires a substantial amount of fuel, typically in the form of wood, in order to reach the high temperatures needed to reduce a body to ash. The amount of fuel required is not dependent on the physical arrangement of the bodies, but rather on the number of bodies and the size of the bodies being cremated.

While stacking bodies may help to conserve space, it would not significantly reduce the amount of fuel required for cremation. In addition, stacking bodies in this manner would raise complex ethical, logistical, and practical challenges, and would likely be viewed as disrespectful and undignified by many people.

It makes sense, there's no free lunch. You might reduce heat escape (which would be a big problem with open-air pyres lol) but on the flip side the unevenness of the heating of the stacks would reduce efficiency. In any case we aren't talking about magic, even say a 25% improvement in efficiency isn't bringing this operation closer to the realm of reality.