@SecureSignals's banner p

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

				

User ID: 853

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 853

Let's say theoretically that Revisionists are correct, you would still say it's unnecessary to talk about in the context of the culture war? Revisionists being correct wouldn't change your opinion on any culture war topics? If so, then we can just agree to disagree, and you're free to avoid discussion of it as you please.

If you want to debate the what you see as the mainstream position with someone who supports the mainstream position, you need to go find someone who supports what you believe the mainstream position is, and then go debate them.

They do support the mainstream perspective, they are just defending the mainstream narrative with a non-mainstream framing. It's called a Motte and Bailey... the mainstream claims that the "Final Solution" was the German government's decision to exterminate the Jews in gas chambers, and that they exterminated millions of people in gas chambers and buried them in known locations. But they don't try to defend that narrative- they functionally concede the Revisionist position that the "Final Solution" denoted the deportation and concentration of the Jews East. They then try to say that the latter still counts as an "extermination plan" because of a single paragraph in a document that predicts high mortality from forced labor deployed East. Nobody except for Revisionists considers that to be the "Final Solution."

After the war, from 1944 to 1948 at least 12 million Germans were expelled and resettled from areas annexed by Poland and Czechoslovakia. It's estimated that between 10-30% of those expelled, about 2 million, died. Many others were deported to Soviet labor camps where the mortality rate (according to official statistics) was about 35%. Nobody would call the expulsion of the Germans an extermination plan, they would probably celebrate it as a reprisal. Likewise, the expulsion and concentration of the Palestinians by the Israelis could be criticized in its context, but it could not be regarded as a plan to physically exterminate the Palestinians using some absurd murder contraption.

Nobody established any plan for the extermination of the Jews. The Wannsee Conference - that 90 minute meeting with a bunch of mid-level nobodies was the best they could come up with to establish such a plan, although the document supports the Revisionist interpretation.

Let's just pause a moment to appreciate all the ink that's been spilled so far, with not one person raising any sort of physical or documentary evidence for the murder of three million people in gas chambers. It speaks volumes that they dance around the central myth of the entire Holocaust narrative .

I can do it to some extent, especially if I internally verbalize "one two three" over and over and just focusing on visually seeing the lines of text as a whole. But when I'm not actively trying I immediately revert to my old ways.

This is a tautology, isn't it? The Right's "big idea" is to be wary of big ideas

The "big idea" of being wary of big ideas loses to the people with big ideas. It's a feature not a bug to the extent that mainstream conservative thinking was consciously designed to keep a potential Right on the reservation.

EDIT/ADDENDUM: In the scope of history "Don't Tread on Me" is a pretty fucking big idea, and continues to be one.

Progressives have a far better claim on "Don't Tread on Me" than libertarians. Who the hell is scared of treading on a libertarian? People are genuinely afraid of repercussions for treading on progressivism, even the most red-tribe conservatives. Even faithful conservatives here will admit that it's a losing proposition, they just say they would rather accept a losing proposition than "become a bad person", and their conception of "being a bad person" suspiciously conforms to progressive demands on the boundaries of their way of thinking.

I've heard you can read faster and comprehend more when reading without internally verbalizing the words. I believe that but I haven't been able to train myself to do it consistently.

It's an affirmation of @Hoffmeister25's thread last week. The mainstream Right wing has no Will to Power, it has no big ideas. The Left wing is pushing forward major social upheavals at breakneck speed, and conservatives are trying to muster outrage and votes with gas stove flags. You are not conservative, so I think it's a bit concern-trolly to pat conservatives on the back for choosing such a comically non-threatening banner to rally behind.

This controversy really is a perfect embodiment for why conservatism delenda est. The mainstream Right wing is hardly more than an exhaust valve opposing all the big ideas that come from the left. In this day in age, 2023, with everything that is going on, "hands off our gas stoves" is the banner to rally the conservatives.

The left will force the LGBT flag into the pantheon of sacred banners, the right will make flags that say "don't mess with gas stoves".

Can you explain exactly what you think is unsupported? You don't think the Holocaust narrative is important to the Culture War? It would be hard to take that position. Or you agree it is important but it's just boring and unnecessary to talk about it critically?

When you're talking about a taboo topic you're held to an impossible standard. You are either accused of not providing enough evidence relative to the strength of your claim, or of Gish Galloping if you provide a lot of evidence, and I was accused of both in the very same discussion.

But I certainly didn't evade any of the topics of discussion. None of the people in that conversation, including yourself, even tried to defend the mainstream position, so there was no evasion on my end. I didn't even get into the minutiae since nobody even tried to defend the claims of mainstream historiography- because the people in that conversation who clearly know something about the debate know that it's the weakest part of the mainstream historiography. Maybe one day someone will try (or we can have that debate which was proposed in that thread) and you will see what minutiae really looks like in this topic.

We don't need to rehash the debate, as that is not the point of this thread. If you want to continue you can make a new thread somewhere, although I would ask that you actually try to defend the mainstream position that actually constitutes the mythos of the Holocaust narrative, rather than limit yourself to far less sensationalist but easier-to-prove claims that nobody contests.

And if I used the minus sign last week, I would have just minused out half the CW thread.

Again, I'm just not seeing it. What top-level threads from last week's CW thread are the witchy ramblings you are talking about? It seems well-rounded to me, with Christianity receiving more pointed criticism last week than Jews or the Holocaust.

Looking through the past CW threads, I'm not seeing it - "ONLY witchy ramblings." This is basically the only space of this kind that doesn't ban critical discussion on Jews or the Holocaust, which are very important topics in the Culture War, so when it does come up it is probably bothersome to a certain type... but:

I personally REALLY don't care about this topic... That topic makes the motte worse for me.

Does not follow. There are some topics that come up here frequently that I REALLY don't care about, and I click the '-' button within the 0.5 seconds it takes me to realize I'm not interested in the thread. You should just say that it's a topic that you do care about, and it bothers you when people discuss it with a critical perspective. That would be a more honest complaint, and it would ring true for the vast majority of people.

Allowing those topics (though I personally have posted 0 top-level threads on Holocaust denial (so far)) will lower the status of the community in adjacent spaces like SSC. I get the impression the mods are more committed to the purpose of the community than they are status signaling to other rationalists (and I don't mind the token denunciations from the mods here in that thread).

"Ancient tradition? You mean thousands of years of persecution, pogroms and genocide? Thanks, but no thanks."

Secular Jews seem no less inclined towards worshipping their own suffering and persecution. Their identity as the eternally, innocent persecuted is a pull factor rather than a push factor for secular Jews.

But I am far more certain that Germans murdered millions of people, many of them for being Jews.

Where did they kill them? How? When? What is the physical evidence for the crime you are alleging at those locations? Where are all the bodies?

I was surprisingly not able to find a PDF of the Protocols in German, but I found scans and this is the page.

entsprechend behan, clearly vague, but implies that the question was simply not dealt with in the conference and was a question for a later time- probably after the war. It is said that this entire conference only lasted 90 minutes, which doesn't exactly live up to the weight it's given in historiography.

When historians say that the Germans had a plan to exterminate the Jews, what they mean is that the Germans secretly decided that the final solution to the Jewish Question was to murder them all. It is claimed that this murder took place mostly with gas chambers disguised as shower rooms. These are the core claims that Revisionists contest.

It is strange to accuse Revisionists of "moving the goalposts" when you refuse to defend the core elements of the mainstream narrative. You are of course free to not take the mainstream position and propose your own historical interpretation, and that makes you a Revisionist. Congratulations.

You are trying to say "the concentration of Jews in labor camps is an extermination plan". You are free to say that but it has no relation to what the "Holocaust" actually is. The translation I am reading says:

The possible final remnant will, since it will undoubtedly consist of the most resistant portion, have to be treated accordingly, because it is the product of natural selection and would, if released, act as a the seed of a new Jewish revival (see the experience of history.)

This passage clearly means that they are not to be allowed back into Europe, but it is obviously vague on how this is supposed to happen. Given the continuity of the Wannsee Protocols with the Havaara Agreement and Madagascar Plan, it is clear that that "treated accordingly" would mean "moved away and not allowed back in." You are free to use your imagination for what "treated accordingly" is supposed to mean, but you are only proving how weak your case is for using the most vague parts of the document as the best evidence for your claims.

Obviously this question was not even in the scope of the conference.

You all rely on:

  • Desperately avoiding debate for the physical evidence of what you claim happened.

  • Assuming euphemism and coded language in hundreds of documents across a sprawling bureaucracy with an extremely impressive compliance... not to mention the confusion that would be caused by using "resettlement" as a code word when even historians admit there were all kinds of resettlements of people that were not euphemism.

  • Citing a few sentences from a document, where the document as a whole supports the Revisionist case, take something vague like the words "treated accordingly" and use that as the best evidence you can come up with for your interpretation of the document.

This is one of the reasons the mainstream has generally moved away from emphasizing Wannsee Protocols so much... when you actually read it and consider the context then you're just left desperately pointing to something like "look, it says 'treated accordingly'!" while the document as a whole is simply a verification of what Revisionists are claiming.

Elie Wiesel and his father were given the option to wait for the Russians or go with the Germans, and they chose the latter.

Oh wait, they were so terrible that people as result initially welcomed USSR as liberators (despite that things then went almost as bad as "liberation" by Third Reich). And put plenty of effort into sabotaging German war effort to help USSR.

This is hilariously backwards. Ukranians volunteered for the German War effort at such a rate that Germany had one of the largest foreign volunteer armies in history, composed mostly of slavs and Soviet citizens. IIRC it was something like a million Soviet citizens volunteered for the German war effort. The legacy of eager Ukranian support for Germany lingers to this day.

What happened was as the Soviets advanced an enormous number of people fled to west and caused overcrowding and catastrophic conditions as Germany was being destroyed from all sides. Then the Allies roll in and say "look at all the people the Germans murdered", which fine, if you want to say that they were under German custody so dying in any way counts as "murder", that is up to you. But that isn't the essence of the Holocaust lore, that essence are the matters that none of you want to talk about because you know the case for it is very weak.

It is well known that the Germans gave some prisoners at Auschwitz the option to either remain in the camp to be liberated by the Soviets or flee west with them. Many chose to go with the Germans, if you can believe that, with Elie Wiesel being among the prisoners who chose to go with the Germans rather than wait for the Russians.

Why would I address it when you aren't even trying to defend mainstream historiography?

Mainstream historiography states that "evacuation" was a euphemism for "one-way ticket to homicidal gas chambers", where millions were allegedly murdered and buried in known locations- and precisely 0 of the mass graves allegedly associated with this secret plan have ever been excavated. You refuse to engage in any sort of debate for the physical evidence for that claim, like everyone else who has argued with me so far. And you furthermore try to take the non-mainstream position that "evacuation" was a euphemism for "murdered with forced labor."

You are quite the Revisionist already, since your proposal for the denotation of the "euphemism" stands in contradiction to mainstream historiography!

The Germans predicted high mortality with evacuation and labor, that's true. You can call that murderous, that's no sweat off my back. Although forced labor in the Soviet Union would have to be regarded as murderous as well. You could also call being conscripted and sent to the front line "murderous." You don't think the German, or Allied governments for that matter, would be aware of high mortality for conscripts being sent to the front line? "We will deploy workers here and we expect high mortality" is less murderous than conscription for active combat?

Documents show that these workers were very important for the war effort, and the German government was desperate to reduce the mortality rate in the concentration camps. The head of the WVHA sent orders to all the concentration camps demanding reductions in the mortality rate of workers (during the period when the German government was allegedly murdering them in gas chambers).

Yes, the German government deported the Jews and concentrated them in camps where they were made to perform labor. That is very different from the allegations in mainstream historiography- of chemical slaughterhouses where millions were murdered in makeshift gas chambers disguised as shower rooms and buried on-site, which you aren't even bothering to defend in your comments.

The reason it's not a euphemism is because evacuation actually meant evacuation, it wasn't code for "murdered in gas chambers" as claimed in mainstream historiography.

The standard response is that Christianity has failed... delivered, generally, by people who willingly chose to abandon the faith of their fathers to embrace an alien and alienating worldview, and refuse to let it go.

The biggest flaw of Christianity, which sets it apart from many other religions- including the pagan traditions of the fathers of their father, is that Christianity requires a superstitious belief in the literal truth of claimed miracles. Is such a religion sustainable?

Paganism was about worshipping symbols and myths of the people, with collective public and familial rituals, to direct society in a positive direction. Other non-theistic religions like Buddhism also do not require the allegiance of faith in the truth of claimed miracles. Whereas there is no shortage of superstition in Judaism, especially among religious Jews, the Religion is ultimately about The Chosen People and so it coheres even non-religious Jews who internalize that sense in a non-theistic manner.

Christianity on the other hand... it's ultimately about belief in the truth of claimed miracles that emerged from the body of Jewish superstition. It's in fact historically unusual in this regard. If those claims are false then the religion is a farce, whereas the Jews exist as a coherent people even if you don't believe in a literal Yahweh. Yahweh as nothing more than a tribal mascot of the Jews is infinitely more real than Christianity if you take away the truth of the miracles. If you don't believe in the literal truth of those miracles, even if you were to support the religion in every other way, you are a heretic and in the outgroup.

You think Christianity is based? That it promotes good morals and is necessary to save Western Civilization? Too bad, you can't be a Christian if you don't believe in the literal truth of it. Or you can just pretend, and sit in the pews with a Religious experience that is totally discordant with everyone else sitting around you.

I've seen fairly large-sample Telegram polls in the DR and the polls were split exactly 50/50 on the Christian Question, making it highly divisive in that space. But the divisiveness is good, because it's a hard problem that has to be solved to move forward.

@Job mentioned he's seen people turn towards religious extremism. I've also seen the same, high-quality people (some previously atheist) who turn inwards towards their relationship with God and closely studying Christian doctrine. They avoid the alienation but what is that going to accomplish?

Good post, I mostly agree.

The Left does express a Will to Power. They have a vision for the way the world should be, and they are enforcing their will and changing the world. There is no Right wing "Will to Power" beyond complaints of authoritarianism or complaints of being oppressed by those with that will.

But why does the Right seem incapable of asserting a positive vision like the Left? Can it move beyond the conservative-libertarian synthesis? Why is it so challenging for the Right to move beyond this clearly losing proposition, this "meta-rule" of "you lose or you lose more slowly." Can you answer that question without an answer that is going to immediately take us to the boundaries of the JQ? When I ask that question, I know what everyone is thinking. I know you venture to answer that with analyzing a basic psychology of European people (an analysis that I agree with) but it's ultimately ignoring big parts of the picture.

Our prevailing political system permits a left-wing Will to Power while only allowing a moderate right-wing opposition. It simultaneously enforces a taboo, and in some cases in Europe an outright legal ban, on avant garde or post-liberal, right-wing political thinking.

You could accuse me right here of engaging in grievance politics or demoralization, but I don't think so. This is about soberly understanding the power dynamics you have to operate in, and why those dynamics exist. That's not to say the situation is hopeless, it's to understand the goal and the obstacles to achieving those goals.

With that said, there is definitely too much grievance porn on the Right... someone will post a story of a Swedish girl being raped by a migrant or something and I agree that offers nothing constructive except demoralization and useless outrage. There's also too much vindictiveness and too much ressentiment.

But there's a very fine line between grievance politics and the Schmittian friend-enemy distinction. A lot of conservatives want to write off Critical Theory as "grievance identity politics" but the DR is more likely to see it as something much more powerful, substantive, and subversive than that. There is a powerful force to cultural and historical critique that shouldn't be written off as pure grievance politics that doesn't accomplish anything. The Left has demonstrated the power of historical and cultural critique.

All successful "underdog" movements like liberalism, Bolshevism, Fascism, Zionism, Irish nationalism, etc. emerged from what could be simplified as grievance and victim narratives. But in reality those movements were all pushing a positive vision with a grave consciousness of the headwinds of the status quo.

I agree with the emphasis on a positive, affirmational worldview but it cannot win without consideration of the headwinds of the status quo. And it would be nice if "our only obstacle is ourselves" but that is just not true. The biggest obstacle is ourselves, but it isn't the only one. There are people rooting and working against your project for their own reasons, and that can't be ignored. It should be respected from an adversarial perspective.

You have misunderstood the documents. Voluntary emigration was banned for security reasons. Involuntary deportation was the final solution.

Is your contention that these documents are forged?

My contention is that the weakness of your case is demonstrated by your enormous reliance on handwritten modifications to a few documents that aren't even related in context to the resettlement actions in General Government under discussion. You are claiming that an enormous number of SS men in an enormous volume of documents across time and space were all in on the conspiracy to talk about "resettlement" instead of "gas chamber extermination" in secret internal communications, and that the highest-level officials with direct involvement in these initiatives all continued to insist on the "coded language" after the war. And you base that on very weak evidence. Someone in the comment section also objects to the reliability of your evidence that you place so much weight on:

I find it fascinating that the document the Judge Ad read before the "camo" document, orders on how to treat the Jews on the Eastern Front is based upon...hearsay and "doesn't help the court at all". Wow. Page 17. Hearsay admitted as evidence. Now, I wonder why the prosecution would do that?

Dr. Laternser asks to see the "camo" document? Why? Was he not allowed to see the "camo" document prior to the trial? Was the defense present during the forensic analysis? Nope.

  1. So no change of evidence for the document.
  1. Defense apparently didn't view the document prior to the trial as he asks to see it.
  1. Defense did not have representation during the forensic analysis.

There are according to the transcript, multiple copies, but only one presented as evidence. Can anyone obtain the original document for research or just the photostat? You realize it would be easily claimed the Prosecution manufactured the edit (replacement words in the margin instead of above the word???) , performed the forensic science, and then claim some official made the "rather clumsy precaution" with speculation as to the motivation...

You are basing so much on so little, but it's honestly par for the course in mainstream historiography.

The fact is, the direct reading of these documents, without your claim of remarkably consistent "coded language" supports the Revisionist case.

There are many, many, many documents describing resettlement in the General Government, but you base so much assumption on the impossible-to-verify authenticity of handwritten modifications to a few documents that aren't even contextually related to the resettlement actions in the General Government.

In these trials (the IMT) the prosecution also claimed:

An attempt was even made to manufacture soap from the fatty parts of the bodies, while the ashes remaining after cremation were used for fertilizer. This was indeed a gruesomely commercial exploitation of death on a mass basis.

It is not reasonable to base your assertion - that resettlement mentioned in dozens and dozens of documents was code for extermination- on a few handwritten modifications to documents that were submitted to these trials, especially in which the context was not related to these resettlement actions in General Government.

But you have to reach, because the direct reading of those documents affirms the Revisionist claims.

I bet that you would be really unhappy if you and your family would be "evacuated" in this way.

Of course I would be unhappy about it. I might be motivated to lie about my experiences in order to inflict maximum damage on my oppressors, and I'm sure the Soviet Union or Steven Spielberg would have been happy to use my eyewitness testimony in their investigation and show-trials and Oscar-winning films.

The "final solution" was the expulsion of Jews from Europe. So the Protocol's emphasis that Jews cannot be allowed to reestablish themselves in Europe after the war is 100% consistent with that interpretation. Why would they expel them just for them to come back after the war? That doesn't mean they are going to be exterminated. On the other hand, the long-standing Nazi support for the idea of a Jewish state as well as documents proving the Madagascar Plan was still under serious consideration by Hitler himself well into the war... these well-documented plans were fully compatible with the proclamation you are trying to claim is indicative of an extermination plan.

Letter by Franz Rademacher, Head of AA Referat D III (Jewish Affairs), to Harold Bielfeld, Head of AA Pol. X (Africa and Colonial Affairs), February 10, 1942.

In August 1940 I gave you for your files the plan for the final solution of the Jewish Problem, drafted by my office, for which purpose the Madagascar Island was to be demanded from France in the Peace Treaty, while the Reich Security Main Office was to be charged with the actual execution of the task. In accordance with the plan, Gruppenführer Heydrich has been ordered by the Führer to carry out the solution of the Jewish Problem in Europe.

In the meantime the war against the Soviet Union has offered the possibility of putting other territories at our disposal for the final solution. The Führer accordingly has decided that the Jews shall not be deported to Madagascar but to the East. Therefore it is no longer necessary that Madagascar be taken into consideration for the final solution.

Again, the direct reading is what Revisionists claim while historians rely on allegations of coded language.

Let's recap then. Historians claim that the "Final Solution" denoted the extermination of the Jews, using mostly gas chambers disguised as shower rooms. Historians furthermore claim that the Wannsee Conference stands head and shoulders above other documents in proving the intent of the "final solution."

But if you actually press the issue, you learn that there is no mention of gas chamber extermination whatsoever in any of the Protocols, and that the Protocols explicitly describe the "final solution" as the evacuation of the Jews to the East. This is what Revisionists say the "final solution" was, and this is what the document says. The best the mainstream can do to support the "Wannsee Conference" legend is cite a couple paragraphs in a 10-page document that predicts labor attrition but otherwise makes no reference to gas chamber extermination. Here they lean very heavily on the accusation of "euphemism and coded language", because the language itself supports the Revisionist case.

Even in the most comprehensive, top-secret direct report from Globocnik to Himmler after the major resettlement actions, there was no reference or allusion whatsoever to mass gas chamber extermination. The "so-called evacuation" was discussed as an evacuation. So To_Mandalay, who relies very heavily on the trustworthiness and accuracy of NKVD documents which were released decades after the fact by the FSB, accuses the SS of using deception to hide their treatment of the Jews in their own top-secret internal reports.

In addition to Globocnik's report, which identifies the "so-called evacuation" as an evacuation, there is also:

  • Hans Frank, the Governor General, who would have known without any doubt that the "so-called evacuation" was a euphemism but he denied any knowledge of that and testified to his understanding of a policy of resettlement and not extermination.

  • Josef Bühler, Frank's deputy, who attended the Wannsee Conference and testified to the fact that the conference was about the resettlement of the Jews and not the extermination of the Jews.

  • Goering himself, who gave the famous "final solution" order to Heydrich, but at Nuremberg flatly denied that this was a policy of extermination, and stated it was a policy of resettlement.

  • Oswald Pohl, who worked directly with Himmler and Globocnik on Operation Reinhardt, and also testified to his understanding of a policy of resettlement and not a secret policy of gas chamber extermination. And so did the rest of his organization that was involved in this initiative.

All of these high-level officials directly involved in these events and related documents would have known about the actual policy underneath the "so-called resettlement" but they all maintained that this was not euphemism, it was the actual plan. Historians rely on the confessions of lower-level officials extracted under torture or duress in show-trials after the war (in many cases, decades after the war), and the dubious testimony of Jewish eyewitnesses.

But the coup-de-grace is the debate on the physical evidence which you will notice none of my interlocutors want to touch with a 10 foot pole. They want to say that 900,000 people were gassed, buried, unburied, cremated, and reburied in a known location within a small camp in Poland. But they do not want to discuss the physical evidence for that claim, they are only interested in demographic studies and a paragraph here and there from the Wannsee Protocols.

They know that the biggest strength in the Revisionist critique lies in the technical arguments made by Revisionists, technical arguments which were proven true at the alleged Majdanek extermination camp and which mainstream historians will never acknowledge or try to answer.