SecureSignals
Ere the Sun rises
No bio...
User ID: 853
The Wannsee Conference was organized after Goering gave a famous order to Reinhard Heydrich “to submit to me as soon as possible a general plan of the administrative material and financial measures necessary for carrying out the desired final solution of the Jewish question.” Reinhard Heydrich was killed by ;artisans during the war.
But after the war Goering flatly denied the exterminationist interpretation of the "final solution" in the above context:
SIR DAVID MAXWELL-FYFE: Do you still say neither Hitler nor you knew of the policy to exterminate the Jews?
GOERING: As far as Hitler is concerned, I have said I do not think so. As far as I am concerned, I have said that I did not know, even approximately, to what extent these things were taking place.
SIR DAVID MAXWELL-FYFE: You did not know to what degree, but you knew there was a policy that aimed at the extermination of the Jews?
GOERING: No, a policy of emigration, not liquidation of the Jews. I knew only that there had been isolated cases of such perpetrations.
The Wannsee Protocol explicitly establishes that this was the planned proposal:
Chief of the Security Police and of the SD, SS-Obergruppenfuehrer Heydrich, reported that the Reich Marshal [Goering] had appointed him delegate for the preparations for the final solution of the Jewish question in Europe"
The Reichsfuhrer-SS [Himmler] and the Chief of the German Police (Chief of the Security Police and the SD) [Heydrich] was entrusted with the official central handling of the final solution of the Jewish question without regard to geographic borders.
The Chief of the Security Police and the SD then gave a short report of the struggle which has been carried on thus far against this enemy, the essential points being the following:
a) the expulsion of the Jews from every sphere of life of the German people,
b) the expulsion of the Jews from the living space of the German people.
In carrying out these efforts, an increased and planned acceleration of the emigration of the Jews from Reich territory was started, as the only possible present solution.
By order of the Reich Marshal [Goering], a Reich Central Office for Jewish Emigration was set up in January 1939 and the Chief of the Security Police and SD was entrusted with the management. Its most important tasks were
a) to make all necessary arrangements for the preparation for an increased emigration of the Jews,
b) to direct the flow of emigration,
c) to speed the procedure of emigration in each individual case.
[...]
In the meantime the Reichsfuehrer-SS and Chief of the German Police had prohibited emigration of Jews due to the dangers of an emigration in wartime and due to the possibilities of the East.
III. Another possible solution of the problem has now taken the place of emigration, i.e. the evacuation of the Jews to the East, provided that the Fuehrer gives the appropriate approval in advance.
Here, the protocols explicitly identify the "evacuation of the Jews to the East" as the planned proposal. This is also how Goering describes the plan. This is also how Lina Heydrich, Reinhard Heydrich's wife (the one who organized the Wannsee Conference and appointed by Goering) denied the Holocaust and said the plan was to implement a 'territorial solution’ as described in the protocols.
The Wannsee Conference makes no mention of a gas chamber extermination policy whatsoever. A direct reading supports the Revisionist case, and historians have to rely on the accusation of camouflaged language and euphemism.
Josef Bühler, the deputy governor of the General Government and attendee of the Wannsee Conference testified at the IMT as a defence witness for Hans Frank, and claimed that the purpose of Wannsee was to discuss the forced resettlement of Jews in the northeast of Europe:
I ask you now, did the Governor General send you to Berlin for that conference; and if so, what was the subject of the conference?
BUEHLER: Yes, I was sent to the conference and the subject of the conference was the Jewish problem. I might say in advance that from the beginning Jewish questions in the Government General were considered as coming under the jurisdiction of the Higher SS and Police Leader and handled accordingly. The handling of Jewish matters by the state administration was supervised and merely tolerated by the Police.
During the years 1940 and 1941 incredible numbers of people, mostly Jews, were brought into the Government General in spite of the objections and protests of the Governor General and his administration. This completely unexpected, unprepared for, and undesired bringing in of the Jewish population from other territories put the administration of the Government General in an extremely difficult position.
Accommodating these masses, feeding them, and caring for their health-combating epidemics for instance-almost, or rather, definitely overtaxed the capacity of the territory. Particularly threatening was the spread of typhus, not only in the ghettos but also among the Polish population and the Germans in the Government General. It appeared as if that epidemic would spread even to the Reich and to the Eastern Front.
At that moment Heydrich's invitation to the Governor General was received. The conference was originally supposed to take place in November 1941, but it was frequently postponed and it may have taken place in February 1942.
Because of the special problems of the Government General I had asked Heydrich for a personal interview and he received me. On that occasion, among many other things, I described in particular the catastrophic conditions which had resulted from the arbitrary bringing of Jews into the Government General. He replied that for this very reason he had invited the Governor General to the conference. The Reichsfuehrer SS, so he said, had received an order from the Fuehrer to round up all the Jews of Europe and to settle them in the Northeast of Europe, in Russia. I asked him whether this meant that the further arrival of Jews in the Government General would cease, and whether the hundreds of thousands of Jews who had been brought into the Government General without the permission of the Governor General would be moved out again. Heydrich promised me both these things. Heydrich said furthermore that the Fuehrer had given an order that Theresienstadt, a town in the Protectorate, would become a reservation in which old and sick Jews, and weak Jews who could not stand the strains of resettlement, were to be accommodated in the future. This information left me definitely convinced that the resettlement of the Jews, if not for the sake of the Jews, then for the sake of the reputation and prestige of the German people, would be carried out in a humane fashion. The removal of the Jews from the Government General was subsequently carried out exclusively by the Police....
In internal NKVD documents that no one but Soviet officials were ever supposed to see?
The majority of the documents pertaining to Jewish transports are said to have been destroyed by the SS to hide their crimes, and only a few remain. So you accuse the SS of a coverup of deportation documentation right before you say the NKVD would never do such a thing. You are ultimately relying on data from the NKVD, and the fact is there is uncertainty that comes with relying so heavily on that source, especially given the fact that it's confirmed the NKVD was used in the manipulation of population data for propaganda purposes.
You are also assuming a "hard break" between the NKVD and Russian intelligence. Russia let go of the Katyn Forest lie, that doesn't mean they would let go of the Holocaust lie and air the dirty laundry of the NKVD on that front.
The total emigration from Poland in total from 1931 to 1938 was about 500,000.
Sanning cites a different mainstream source with a higher estimate. There's variance and uncertainty, that's the entire point.
Mainstream historiography argues there was much secrecy about the Holocaust even within internal top-secret documents in the SS. Globocnik's direct, top-secret report to Himmler on Aktion Reinhardt makes no mention or allusion whatsoever to any extermination in the General Government, and only mentions resettlement.
If Germany won the war, and the SS archives were eventually opened up, would you take all the surviving documents at face value? Would you assume the SS would faithfully retain the documentation of their crimes? Particularly if they were involved in crimes they had successfully pinned on the Soviets? Historians refuse to take SS documents at face-value as-is, saying that they used "coded language" in their own top-secret communication to each other.
There is also a clear motivation hiding the toll of famine and repression on the Soviet population, and no such obvious motivation for drastically downsizing the numbers of Jewish deportees into the Soviet interior.
I had to read this a couple of times because... of course I agree that there is a clear motivation for hiding the toll of famine and repression. But if there was famine and repression experienced by the large numbers of Jews who fled Poland to the Soviet Union ahead of the German advance (very reasonable to assume and widely reported by mainstream sources), there would be a motivation to transfigure those people to be victims of Nazi gas chambers instead of dead in camps in Siberia. Particularly if numbers of those people were, as reported, forcefully deported.
Sanning doesn't rely on this assumption of NKVD data mainpulation, but he's proven motive and opportunity for the NKVD to lie (if you can't trust the NKVD, who can you trust?!). There was a motivation for NKVD to downplay the number of Jews deported to the Soviet Interior- foremast because they were claiming that the Germans murdered millions of Jews in "factories of death" in Majdanek and Auschwitz. Downplaying the number of Jews that fled to their custody would support those allegations and avert attention from the treatment of those Jews who fled to the Soviet Union.
The mainstream openly sidesteps this issue by saying, even if large numbers of Jews were deported to Siberia and died there, those should still count as Holocaust victims. You can make a moral argument for that, but it still hurts the case for the presumed extermination of 3 million Jews in gas chambers disguised as shower rooms.
From the 1958 publication of “Opinion of the Institute for Contemporary History”:
The wave of emigration of German Jews was only a part – and not even the largest one at that – of a general Jewish emigration from central, eastern and southeastern Europe. In the years following 1933 about 100,000 Jews left Poland every year, partly because of the increasingly anti-Semitic policies of the Polish government, but also because of the progressively worsening pauperization of the Polish Jews. Similar tendencies existed in Latvia, Lithuania, Rumania and, to a lesser degree, in Hungary.
This is a mainstream source. You can cite other sources but you are just affirming the uncertainty of the problem...
The heavily-urbanized Hungarian Jewish population also experienced considerable excess deaths over births after 1927, reaching 0.5% annual decrease in 1938 (Sanning p. 33). On the other hand, the Mainstream source extrapolates the excess births over deaths of Polish Jews from the 1931 census as a constant through 1939, despite the sharp demographic decline which was measured within these heavily urbanized Hungarian Jews during the same period. It would also be unusual to assume constant high-fertility during a period of high emigration due to the push factors described above. Sanning's estimation tracks with data in Hungary, whereas the Mainstream study assumes no decline at all in fertility during this period. Sanning's methodology is clearly superior on this front.
Finally, Sanning and Revisionsits do not claim that these numbers or the sources provided are definitive. The entire purpose is to demonstrate the variance and uncertainty, and Revisionists are able to do so using entirely mainstream sources.
It's also worth recognizing here the controversial 1939 Soviet census:
On 25 September 1937, there was a special Sovnarkom decision proclaiming the census invalid and setting a new one for January 1939. A Pravda editorial stated that the "enemies of the people gave the census counters invalid instructions that led to the gross under-counting of the population, but the brave NKVD under the leadership of Nikolai Yezhov destroyed the snake's nest in the statistical bodies".
Stalin had to agree with the lower numbers of population growth. In his report to the 18th Congress of the All-Union Communist Party (bolsheviks) he said:
"Some workers of the old Gosplan thought that during the second five-year plan (1933–1938) the annual growth of population was three to four million people. It was a fantasy or worse."
The new Soviet Census (1939) showed a population figure of 170.6 million people, manipulated so as to match exactly the numbers stated by Stalin in his report to the 18th Congress of the All-Union Communist Party. No other censuses were conducted until 1959.
Today there is a consensus that the results of the 1939 census were adjusted (0.5 to 1.5 million persons were added to the reported population). Some historians consider the 1937 census the only more or less reliable source of demographic data for the period 1926–1959. However, demographers do not consider it as such[citation needed]. The data became influential for evaluating the number of victims of the Great Purge, World War I, and the 1930s famines, including the Holodomor."
During the 17th Congress of the All-Union Communist Party, Stalin reported that one of the main achievements of the Soviet system was "Growth of population from 160.5 millions in the end of 1930 to the 168 millions in the end of 1933."
...
Official statistics based on the registered birth and death rates implied that the 1937 census should show a population of 170–172 million
So the Soviets said that "officially" the 1937 population should have been 170-172 million, so the real 1937 census that showed a population of 162,000,000 was a conspiracy by "enemies of the people" which was squashed by the "brave NKVD" in the statistical bodies. Of course these adjustments are considered to be false and motivated by propaganda purposes.
This is proof of Soviet manipulation of population data. It's desperate that anyone would treat population numbers coming from the NKVD post-war, even internal numbers, as beyond reproach.
Lastly, The Alternative Hypothesis - who you may know as one of the more popular (and high-quality) HBD YouTube channels back in the pre-censorship days recently dove into this issue and produced this document. I looked through it and it seemed to pretty closely follow Sanning, but I'll mention it here because it's very interesting to note Alt Hype is breaking towards the Revisionist side of the debate.
return to the territory the revisionists prefer to debate.
It is absolutely true that the strongest territory of the Revisionists follows from - is there evidence that what mainstream historiography claims happened actually happened? - and that speaks volumes... You will not enter that territory because you clearly know enough about the debate to know that mainstream historiography cannot answer the Revisionist case. So you will prefer the comfortable corner of relying on some data points from the NKVD on a tumultuous demographic question, in order to handwave the large body of Revisionist scholarly work and a suspicious lack of evidence for what is being claimed.
The most recent edition of Sanning's work is 2015. The "Holocaust Handbooks" are meant to provide a definitive Revisionist position on various issues, so updating Sanning's work is entirely appropriate especially since his core arguments were not addressed in the mainstream response. For example, whereas Sanning spent 20 pages explaining the problem of the demographic development of Polish Jewry in the years 1931-1939, the mainstream response only deals with it in two sentences:
“[…] if we extrapolate the census figures [of 1931], taking into account natural increase and emigration, we arrive at a 1939 total population of 35,100,000 persons for the Polish nation as a whole, of which the Jewish component is estimated at 3,446,000. We repeat: these figures are not certain [….]
The mainstream response does not engage or acknowledge Sanning's argument, it just makes the extrapolation that Sanning argued is invalid.
Likewise the mainstream response overtly made no effort to distinguish between Jews who died in the Soviet Union outside the German sphere of occupation:
It [the number of Jewish Holocaust victims in the USSR] also includes the casualties among Jewish soldiers and civilians [partisans] as well as those who succumbed to the strain of flight and to starvation. This is justified. They too were victims of violent National Socialist policies
You can make a moral case for this catch-all approach, even including Red Army soldiers or those who perished in Stalin's custody as "Holocaust victims", but the mainstream methodology further confounds the issue in determining German policy and an alleged mass gas chamber extermination based on their study. The mainstream study makes no effort quantify these various categories.
Sanning's observations regarding the evacuation of Polish Jews into the Soviet Union relies on entirely mainstream sources, and was widely reported within Zionist circles. Per the mainstream response to Sanning, any of those Jews that died for any reason, even those that never came under German occupation, are counted as "Holocaust victims" which confounds the controversies under discussion.
The mainstream response to Sanning also did not contain a single section on the problem of Jewish post-war emigration from Europe. It doesn't mention the large-scale migration after the war which has become known as a modern Exodus.
This is to say, a new volume would be largely a restatement of Sanning since his work has withstood the mainstream response.
Revisionists were the first ones to enter the demographic debate. Meanwhile, mainstream historians, like you, maintain a policy of categorically refusing to acknowledge or engage Revisionist technical arguments which have been proven correct in many important cases.
The Soviet census data that seems to mostly inform your position on this topic existed during a time when the Soviet-reported death toll at Asuchwitz was 4 million, and over 1 million at Majdanek. Presumably you would have dismissed Revisionist criticisms of those claims because, after all, there's the census data, right?
The Soviets claimed there were 7 gas chambers in Majdanek for many decades. This was disproven by Revisionists long before those "gas chambers" at that camp were officially revised at the Majdanek museum.
In other words, your narrow interest would have prevented you from accepting Revisionist arguments that have now been proven true. It seems that your acceptance of the mainstream historiography surrounding the operation of the alleged extermination camps is narrowly predicated on demographic analysis. I would never accept that as a reasonable position. Regardless of census data, we can and should critically analyze claims, like the claim of 7 gas chambers at Majdanek, because there is an interdependency of these issues.
Revisionists have proven beyond doubt that the Soviet Union:
-
Fabricated structures post-war to frame them as "homicidal gas chambers"
-
Misidentified crematorium and hygienic facilities as gas chambers after official investigation as early as 1944, before the liberation of Auschwitz- where identical claims were later made in 1945
-
Exaggerated death tolls by the order of millions and millions of people
-
Accused Germany of war crimes that it itself had committed. The lead investigators of Extraordinary State Commission report USSR-54 submitted to Nuremberg, blaming Germany for the Katyn Massacre (with eyewitnesses to support the accusation!) were the very same as the USSR-8 report on the "Auschwitz Death Camp" (with the addition of that biological quack Lysenko)
Therefore your narrow reliance on Soviet-provided data on the number of Jews in the Soviet Union post-war is putting far too much weight on an unreliable source. Even taking away the unknown variable of "intentional deception", there are many confounders that make any demographic study extremely difficult, and this is thoroughly analyzed by Sanning. There is more than enough uncertainty in that data to raise questions surrounding the official German policy with respect to the Jews, and whether this policy actually was "extermination" as claimed by historians.
it's a historiographical debate, one with many different varying facets, one of which seemingly is one that revisionists wish to avoid (apart from saying "Look, Sanning!")
You say that there are "various facets" to the historical debate, but Revisionists are the ones engaging all those facets while your interests are admittedly narrow. Revisionists were the first ones to publish a manuscript solely dedicated to the demographic problem in question. The mainstream response did not come until 8 years later. To repeat: Sanning came before any detailed demographic analysis from the mainstream camp, and of course the 6 million lore as "established history" preceded all study of it by many years. So to say that Revisionists "are not interested" in this issue is a complete inversion of reality- Revisionists were the ones who pressed the issue whereas the "6 million" number was never based on any such study in the first place.
Revisionists engage the demographic debate, but they also emphasize the technical debate which is ignored by you and mainstream historians. They say 900,000 people were murdered, buried, unburied, cremated on makeshift open-air pyres, and reburied in a small camp in Poland in a matter of months.... How did that happen? What is the evidence for it? What would such an operation have required? Is it even possible it happened?
But those questions do not capture your interest, which is fine, as nobody can force you to be interested in anything. But a historiographical debate cannot ignore these questions- these questions are only ignored because they cannot be answered in mainstream historiography. I believe you know this too, which is why you explain you are not interested in technical issues surrounding the operation of the alleged extermination camps. I will again repeat that these technical arguments were proven true at Majdanek, and so they are worthy of consideration in the other alleged extermination camps where identical claims are made.
It is unusual but certainly possible to be interested in the Holocaust debate and not be interested in the details surrounding alleged gas chambers and extermination camps, but if you are not interested in the latter then you are not going to be able to engage or appraise the Revisionist position on these issues.
The minutes are explicitly stating that the expulsion approach is lacking, expulsion has been banned, and that a different path is to be taken.
The different path was evacuation to the East. This is what is explicitly described in documents and this is what Revisionists claim the plan was. Historians say that "evacuation to the East" was coded language for gassed in gas chambers. But a direct reading of the document supports the Revisionist case for the German plan.
In the same way, Himmler will refer to a camp, like Sobibor, as a "Transit Camp", which is what Revisionists claim it was, while historians will say "Transit camp" was "coded language" for death camp. The historians rely on assumptions of euphemism and coded language while the documents supports the Revisionist case.
It's full of euphemisms
This is what historians say to hand-wave the fact that the minutes of the Wannsee Conference, a direct reading, supports the Revisionist case for the "final solution." Revisionists claim the "final solution" was the expulsion of the Jews from the European sphere, and the minutes from the Wannsee Conference are evidence of that interpretation. The plan was to concentrate them in the East and then resettle them out of Europe, Madagascar was the most serious proposal as that territory would be negotiated from France, after the war. Although there is evidence that a reservation in (planned to be conquered) Russian territory was also considered.
It is historians who say that the minutes are full of "camouflage and euphemism" because a direct reading of the documents simply does not support their case.
Here and here. I linked to Sanning, who among other things, concludes an over-estimate of the 1939 Polish Jewish population due to fertility decline and emigration in the interwar period, an under-estimate of the post-war Jewish population in the Soviet Union. Mainstream studies have also neglected the large scale deportations of Polish Jews, and their subsequent mortality, into the Soviet interior and Siberia.
On the other side, the "six million" number was ordained when the official Soviet-reported death tolls at Auschwitz and Majdanek were 4 million and 1.5 million, respectively. Today those official numbers are 1.1 million and 68,000, but despite these mutli-million reductions in death tolls over the decades the sacred number remains unchanged. Demographic studies are not a substitute for the historical burden of proof to show where and how these six million died, so we have to rely on other evidence to investigate these claims.
It speaks volumes to me if the crucial question of "well, what happened to the Jews then?" is treated by revisionists in such a cavalier manner.
Imagine we are standing in a field in Poland. It has grass, trees, flowers- otherwise it just looks like any other field. Now imagine that you tell me - "900,000 people were gassed, cremated, and buried directly underneath where we are standing."
And then I ask, "really? That sounds extremely unusual and unlikely, what's the evidence for that?"
And then imagine after an exchange debating the evidence for the claim, you ultimately force a "stalemate" by saying "if they weren't murdered, cremated, and buried right here then where did they go?"
It's not treated by revisionists in a cavalier manner, it's just acknowledged as an extraordinary attempt to reverse the burden of proof for an extraordinary claim that lacks evidence. It's also acknowledged as a "reversal" that would not be necessary if you had sufficient evidence to establish what you are claiming in the first place.
Now imagine it's the Revisionist who says, "ok, well if you insist this is what happened, let's excavate the area so we can better understand what happened," and then you say "no, you have to tell me where these 900,000 Jews went if they weren't murdered right on this spot. We can't excavate this area because it would disturb the souls of the 900,000 people who were murdered here."
This is the "state of the debate", and Revisionists have the far better case.
You are correct that "then where did they go?" is the best retort against Revisionist critique of mainstream historiography... but it proves how weak the evidence is that the "best counter-argument" consists of a blatant reversal of the burden of proof. You are the one claiming they were murdered and buried in a precisely known location...
One thing that has impressed me in the Revisionist space, unlike a lot of heterodox spaces where everyone has their own cockamamie theory, is that there's 100% consensus on the core claims. The claims are:
-
There was no German plan for the physical extermination of world Jewry
-
There were no gas chambers disguised as shower rooms used to exterminate millions of Jews
-
The "six million" number is a propaganda/symbolic figure that has no relation to actual Jewish population losses
I would say the high-end of Jewish population losses among Revisionist estimates is 1.5-2 million, but most estimates are lower than that. The question of whether or not these events count as genocidal is a semantic question that I have not seen treated by Revisionists.
I don't have a problem with, even if you take those 3 claims away, still calling the real parts a "genocide." It really is all about the three claims above- no more and no less.
I’d be interested to listen to a good-faith debate between, say, @SecureSignals and an actually well-respected PhD Holocaust historian, but between me and him I’m at an insurmountable disadvantage because he’s spent a lot more time thinking about this than me.
I would agree to this.
The main takeaway from Sanning is that it's an intractable problem. Demographic study is hard in the best of times, and the political circumstances combined with significant changes during the interwar period, massive population movements during the war (including the large scale deportation of Polish Jews to the Soviet interior), floods of refugees after the war, and the fact that the Soviet Union was waging a propaganda war about a German extermination policy, and so it had a motive to lie about these things- as it lied about many other things during its various investigations (i.e. the Katyn Massacre and a "factory of death" in Majdanek where the Germans murdered 2 million people), makes it an impossible problem to solve.
None of the "big-ticket" items of the Holocaust were based on demographic study. The earliest of such studies came well after the establishment of the main components of the narrative that Revisionists challenge. If historians are claiming that a million people were murdered and buried in a known location, then any reasonable person should scrutinize the evidence that was used to "prove" that claim.
Revisionists acknowledge the inherent interdependency of the evidence. By that I mean- the Soviets falsely claimed that the Germans murdered 2 million people at Majdanek, murdered 4 million people at Auschwitz, that Majdanek had 7 gas chambers and a special crematorium with a gas chamber... but none of this was true. Any reasonable person should update his priors on the reliability of Soviet investigation since it has been proven by hard evidence beyond doubt that their investigations have been systematically wrong in service to a campaign of propaganda warfare.
It demonstrates a weak case that you need to rely so heavily on the accuracy and integrity of the number of Jews the Soviet Union said it had after the war when there is an extremely long list of reasons for why these studies are confounded. It's ultimately an attempt to reverse the burden of proof. You want to claim that a million people were gassed and buried in a known location, but for some reason you cannot rely on the evidence for it, you have to demand that Revisionists solve the impossible problem of post-war demographic study behind the Iron Curtain.
Revisionists don't claim to be able to do that, they do claim to be able to show, with the evidence, that what is claimed did not happen.
Unless you claim that for example demographic statistics before (or after) war were falsified and demographics of Polish Jews were falsified before war and so on.
The post-war demographic data entirely comes from Soviet authorities, who had a track record of lying about census data and fudging the ethnic distribution their citizens before the war. They also had a motive to downplay the number of Jewish survivors under their control, particularly the large number of Jews who were deported deep into the Soviet interior and never came under German occupation. The work of Sanning in The Dissolution of Eastern European Jewry suggests that the pre-war population of Jewish Poles was over-estimated due to underestimates of interwar emigration and overestimations of fertility of the Jewish population, which had declined in the interwar years.
But in any case, the "Holocaust" narrative as such absolutely preceded any demographic study of Jewish post-war populations. The Six Million number, the gas chamber, the narrative surrounding the "final solution", these were all established in the historical record before any demographic study.
The "six million" number was not derived from any demographic sources, it first emerged from Zionist sources in January 1944, more than a year and a half before the end of the war.
“In early April 1943, on the clandestine radio, we heard about the outcry of Rabbi Stephen Wise [one of the leaders of U.S. Jewry] about 2 million Jews who were exterminated in Poland. We heard and were surprised: Didn’t the world know as yet that the number of the nation’s dead has already reached 6 million?” he said.
Several hours after his first speech, Unger also spoke at the convention of Hakibbutz Hameuhad kibbutz movement, which convened at Kibbutz Givat Brenner. There he cried out that “Six million martyrs are gone.” Two days later, his words made it to the front page of Haaretz...
About 15 years later, during Eichmann’s trial, chief prosecutor Gideon Hausner said that “In the consciousness of the nation the number 6 million has become sanctified.” But he added: “It’s not so simple to prove that. We did not use this number in any official document, but it became sanctified.” Now, thanks to Rappel, historical research had added another layer for understanding the context for the number.
It's also worth mentioning that the number six has special significance in the Jewish religion, i.e. six-pointed star. It is also said that there were 600,000 Israelite men in the Exodus according to Jewish myth.
Ultimately, historians are claiming that millions of people were killed in specific time and place, with a specific motive and murder weapon. The fact that there are constant appeals to demographic numbers that had nothing to do with the creation of this historical narrative in the first place only shows how little evidence there is. i.e., you cannot say "look at this unambiguous documentary and physical proof for a million people being gassed at Auschwitz," so you have to say "look at this Soviet census data."
Jewish identity was also suppressed in the post-war period in the Soviet Union. A drop in self-identification would likely follow from restrictions on other forms of identification like speaking Yiddish. In the last US census we saw a precipitous decline in the number of white people in the country, and the leading theory is that white Americans are increasingly identifying as mixed due to cultural pressures.
To follow-up my comment below, and after now having read Mattogno's work on the topic, the problems with Mandelbaum's testimony are insurmountable. To answer your question:
What's the specific reason for a neutral observer to doubt the specific testimony from these accounts?
Mattogno analyzes pages and pages of contradictions, inaccuracies, and obvious exaggerations, but I'll cite the single most damaging aspect of Mandelbaum's testimonies, which comes from his 2003 interview with Igor Bartosik and Adam Willma:
Q. When working at the crematorium did you come across the corpses of children?
A. No.
Q. Mr. Mandelbaum, the records clearly indicate that there were children in the transports.
A. But I didn’t see it! You are speaking with a serious man, and I have lived through a great deal. I didn’t come here to lie to the two of you. If I don’t know something, I say I don’t know. I did not see children. Maybe there weren’t any on my shift.
Q. Or perhaps your memory has erased these painful images.
A. There were women. But children? After all, I would remember children going to the gas, how they are burned.” (pp. 49/45)
To justify this unique affirmation by Mandelbaum, the interviewers refer in a footnote to psychological studies of ex-inmates from which it appears that “in eyewitnesses, memory was highly selective” (pp. 49/45, Note 65).
Q. When you began working in the crematorium, the transports of Hungarian Jews were still arriving, and there were a lot of children among them.
A. When we were working three shifts, two other transports could arrive on the other shifts. And have you heard about the destruction of the Gypsies in Auschwitz?
Q. Of course.
A. So, a multitude of people were murdered, and I never saw a single Gypsy on the pyre. I only heard from the other guys that there was some kind of fighting with them. They were obviously burned on another shift. I repeat that, when I was working, there were only childless transports.” (pp. 50/48)
According to the official narrative, children, being unable to work, were automatically selected and among the most numerous victims of the gas chambers. Mandelbaum would have cremated hundreds of thousands of children, and his adamancy that he never saw or cremated children is completely irreconcilable with the historical narrative, which his why his interviewers press him so hard on this question and make a futile effort to "jog his memory".
"Selective memory" due to trauma is the best the interviewers can do. But this is demonstrative of how historians will selectively pick the details from these testimonies to piece together a somewhat-coherent broader narrative and handwave the major problems, but when you take a comprehensive view of a witness the credibility doesn't withstand basic scrutiny.
There are of course a lot of other problems that Mattogno describes, but this part of his testimony completely sinks his credibility as it is not reconcilable with the historical narrative without relying on dubious theories of selective memory.
The paper at least mentions Mandelbaum, except for some strange reason without a separate analysis or even mentioning much of his specific testimony
There is an entire trilogy solely dedicated to the various testimonies of the Sonderkommando of Auschwitz.
Here is a PDF of Sonderkommando Auschwitz I: Nine Eyewitness Testimonies Analyzed. Henryk Mandelbaum's various testimonies (including testimony unknown in mainstream historiography and translated by Mattogno) are presented and criticized in a 37-page section in Section 10, starting at page 179.
I am not even aware of Dario Gabbai testimony in the 1940s. AFAIK Gabbai entered the scene along with his brother and cousins, the Venezias, no earlier than 1987. The earliest reference I find on Dario's wikipedia page only goes to 1991.
But the Gabbai's and their cousins are featured along with the other "late testimony" witnesses in Sonderkommando Auschwitz III: They Wept Crocodile Tears. A Critical Analysis of Late Witness Testimonies:
Most of the main and secondary witnesses of the Sonderkommando that I have already analyzed, as many as 17, testified for the first time between 1945 and 1947, and this is perfectly understandable; some waited two or three decades: Paisikovic made his first statements in 1963, Rosenblum in 1970. Inexplicably, a small group of self-proclaimed Sonderkommando members, united by origin – they were all Jews deported to Auschwitz from Greece (Josef Sackar, Jaacov Gabai, Shaul Chasan and Leon Cohen) – decided to tell their stories only between 1987 and 1993, in the form of interviews conducted by Israeli historian Gideon Greif, who then published them in 1995 in German (Greif 1995), and ten years later also in an English translation titled We Wept without Tears: Testimonies of the Jewish Sonderkommando from Auschwitz (Greif 2005). The statements of these late “eyewitnesses” constitute the main subject of this present study.
Since the beginning of the 1990s other Greek “survivors” of the Sonderkommando, who until then had remained silent, suddenly felt the imperative “duty to testify”: Daniel Bennahmias in 1993 (Camhi Fromer), and Leon Cohen, already interviewed by Gideon Greif, in 1996 (Cohen).
The crown of laggards, however, unquestionably belongs to Shlomo Venezia (my emphasis: Dario Gabai's (the actor's) cousin), a Jew with Italian citizenship who was deported to Auschwitz from Thessaloniki. After an insignificant media excursion in 1992, he officially entered the Auschwitz martyrology on 3 December 2000, thanks to three German scholars, Eric Friedler, Barbara Siebert and Andreas Kilian, who interviewed him. But it was only after the 2007 publication of his memoirs – in French and then in Italian – that he rose to a prestigious position in Holocaust memoiology as the last “eyewitness” of the “gas chambers” of Auschwitz. In practice, he waited 55 years to “testify,” if we start counting from the end of the Second World War.
Witness testimony is notoriously considered one of the weaker forms of evidence. This is why the Revisionists emphasize historical examples, like Congressman Tom Lantos procuring an "escapee direct eyewitness" to the Iraqi soldiers removing babies from incubators and killing them, direct eyewitnesses to mass graves of babies, and this story probably tipped the scales of public opinion for waging war on Iraq. Likewise, there were eyewitness testimony to gassings at Dachau and Buchenwald, which are no longer claimed to have happened... although the Dachau museum used to have a sign that bizarrely read GAS CHAMBER disguised as a "shower room" - never used as a gas chamber. That Dachau "gas chamber - never used as a gas chamber" was prominently featured in the Nuremberg Trials by the way.
There were also many eyewitnesses to mass homicidal gassings at Majdanek who testified in 1944 (before the liberation of Auschwitz), in facilities which have been revised to have been real hygienic facilities and shower rooms. Soviet investigators claimed in 1944 that Majdanek featured a crematorium with a built-in gas chamber, which was revised recently and admitted to have never been a gas chamber, before Auschwitz was even liberated.
The suspicious over-reliance on the testimony of witnesses also obscures the evidence of which there is too little, which is why I linked the other book. Most people probably do not know that the British intercepted and decoded the secret communication between Auschwitz and SS throughout the war and period of alleged extermination, but even historians admit "The decoded messages contain no references to gassings."
Likewise, the blueprints and construction documents discovered in the archives by Revisionists show non-homicidal functions for these structures. Revisionists, for example, showed that all the blueprints throughout multiple years of one of the Krematorium shows a swinging door connecting the alleged "gas chamber", which is identified as a morgue in the blueprints, with the ovens. The best Believers can do is just argue that the "swinging door" must have been an error in all the blueprints, because a gas chamber obviously would have required a sturdy air-tight door.
Relying so much on the witness testimony, which has its own major problems, ignores a lot of problems with the documentary and physical evidence, or lack thereof.
My point was that the case relies on the credibility of witness testimony, and your counterargument simply lists a few names of such testimony, without explaining why you find them to be credible or sufficient to establish the murder of a million people. You are even relying on scrolls which were allegedly written by eyewitnesses, buried, and discovered decades after the war (mostly not until the 1960s or 1970s). I think most people assume that the certainty for the Holocaust at Auschwitz is established beyond doubt by contemporary, hard documentary and physical evidence. They would be surprised to realize how important the testimony is of a few witnesses, or scrolls remarkably found buried in the ground in the 1970s.
Needless to say, Revisionists are aware of all the sources you have listed and have studied them all in great detail across many volumes of work and do not find them to be credible in lieu of contemporary documentary or physical evidence.
I don't think it requires some vast conspiracy to explain why communist eastern Europe did not place great cultural relevance upon the Holocaust, given that the Soviets very much wanted to downplay crimes specifically against Jews
You say it "doesn't require a conspiracy" right before you propose a conspiracy for why this major event was not talked about or even widely known among the people the event is supposed to have actually happened to. That is the opposite of the way major historical catastrophes impact public consciousness, where they are most talked about in the immediate aftermath and then the saliency of that event in the cultural consciousness fades over time.
"The Holocaust" was virtually unknown in the public, including in the West, until Holocaust remembrance took off in the 1960s and probably peaked in the public consciousness in the 1990s.
No matter how you spin this, it's a very strange course of events. You would expect 1. The event to be most salient in public consciousness in the immediate aftermath, which did not happen, 2. The event to be most salient in the consciousness the people closest to the events, which also did not happen.
And public opinion is always formed more of pop culture than academic history
Nobody understands this better than Jews, who have done more than anyone to blur the line between pop culture and academic history on this issue.
The chief historical consultant for Spielberg's award-winning documentary The Last Days was Dr. Michael Berenbaum. He was the Deputy Director of the President's Commission on the Holocaust, Project Director of the USHMM, Director of the USHMM's Holocaust Research Institute, President and CEO of the Survivors of the Shoah Visual History Foundation, and currently a Professor of Jewish studies. Here he is storyboarding The Last Days.
Berenbaum is also an ordained Orthodox Rabbi.
This is from an interview of Rabbi Berenbaum:
"I was ordained because of Vietnam, but it proved to be one of the most important things in my life. It imposed upon me a responsibility to the Jewish past -- and the Jewish future -- and to become a producer of Torah and not just a consumer."
The content designer for the Washington Holocaust Museum, and director of the Shoah Oral History project established by Stephen Spielberg, Dr. Berenbaum is a Holocaust scholar (and part-time professor at the University of Judaism).
This is the "conspiracy" that Revisionists accuse Jews like Berenbaum of admitting to here- producing Torah, creating a new chapter in the long history of Jewish religious myth. In the interpretation of Gentiles who lack the capacity to truly understand this impulse, if revealed, would just come across as shameless lying.
Berenbaum's role in The Last Days and as content designer for the US Holocaust Museum reveals the, frankly, dirty tricks that Revisionists have to contend with. The historical establishment colludes with Hollywood to produce utter tripe that manipulates the American public with shameless lies like The Last Days. Revisionists, often at great personal risk of political suppression and persecution, expose those lies.
After the Revisionists expose the pop culture manipulations as systematically featuring indefensible lies, people like you try to say "well The Last Days was just a pop culture sensation, its indefensible lies do not reflect on academic historians." I do not buy it.
The Last Days is absolutely a product of academic historians, and the quality of that work is undeniably a reflection of the quality and integrity of academic study of the Holocaust.
I did not bring it up as an argument for eugenics, I am citing it to prove eugenic thinking in ancient time. I am not familiar with Chinese history except that it's a long history of being conquered and subjugated, making their genetic lineage not very straightforward. I seriously doubt there were no elements of eugenic societal organizations there, i.e. inherited priestly or chieftain function, but I don't know nearly as much about that ancient history and there is already a huge wealth of examples in ancient Aryan civilizations to prove the point I was making.
Saying that the Indian caste system is not a central example of eugenic thinking... again, I just have to scratch my head wondering what you are smoking to not see this tradition as a central example of eugenic thinking. Not necessarily something to emulate, but to disprove the point he was making "oh, it's better the ancients invented writing than eugenics." They did invent eugenics, and it was central to their religions and civic society.
We could do much better with technology and knowledge of the biology of inheritance. But eugenic thinking is at least as old as writing.
Dario Gabbai and his fellow Sonderkommando are featured in the film I linked, I would encourage anyone to view their accounts captured on film right here and decide for themselves if their various stories seem credible. They are indeed very important witnesses, so much hinges on their credibility and historians rely heavily on their accounts.
That is a stretch, there is simply no comparison between the Soviet Atrocities and the Holocaust in the influence on American Culture and foreign policy. So far in this discussion I've touched on many bestselling and hugely influential Holocaust memoirs, academy-award winning films directed by Steven Spielberg, instances of Jews in our government invoking the Holocaust to manipulate the American public into supporting war in the Middle East with fabricated atrocity propaganda, Holocaust education in public schools, the Memorial Museums with hundreds of millions in funding, the weight of the "Nazi" epithet...
There simply is no similar cultural force that is based on the authenticity of Stalin's crimes or "Judeo-Bolshevism." I am not even aware of what the atrocity claims are beyond questions over the extent to which famine was planned versus unplanned. I don't think those questions have nearly the same saliency to Western culture and politics as questions surrounding the Holocaust.
Let's say the Holodomar was unplanned and not an intentional genocide. How much would that theoretical revelation impact the American public versus the revelation of the Holocaust- the extermination camps and gas chambers, not being real?
The former would somewhat weaken tired conservative talking points against socialism. I don't think it would at all change the American foreign policy apparatus posture against Russia. The latter would inspire a lot of controversy, introspection, and ideally scrutiny over our political, academic, and cultural institutions that aggressively perpetuated the falsehoods for so long.
The Holocaust is truly a mishmash of myth and reality divided between the East and the West. On the one hand you have @johnfabian mentioning that the experience of Western Jews colors public perception of the Holocaust in the West, whereas the greatest parts of the Holocaust and gas chamber extermination actually happened in areas which were conquered and fell behind the Iron Curtain- where Western investigators were denied access to key evidence. And after the Nuremberg Trials, in which the Soviets provided most of the evidence and interrogations of witnesses that have informed the academic "Holocaust" narrative, the Holocaust did not become a part of Soviet culture in the way the Holocaust has become central to Western culture.
So you have a weird scenario where the East had the custody of most of the key evidence, but the Holocaust did not become part of cultural consciousness (where it actually happened (!)), but in the West, which did not have custody of most of the key evidence, the Holocaust became central to the culture. This was accomplished with the memoirs and Hollywood productions that @johnfabian accuses Revisionists of opportunistically using for their agenda. Just pause to appreciate the inversion of reality he is trying to pull, by accusing Revisionists of exploiting memoirs and Hollywood blockbusters which have formulated mass public perception of the Holocaust in the West.
Holocaust awareness has become a bigger part of the political narrative in Russia since the fall of the Soviet Union. It was the Great Patriotic War, and was therefore a Soviet accomplishment that could transition to being a Russian accomplishment. The Putin regime is leaning on the Holocaust narrative to justify aggression against Ukraine. Both Zelensky and Putin have used the Holocaust to frame the conflict and appeal to Israel. It would not be productive for Russian apologists or Soviet revisionists to entertain Holocaust denial.
Why not? Why attempt to revise only one genocide?
Revisionists place special important on the Holocaust due to its influence in our culture and our foreign policy. The Revisionist film I linked earlier includes a section on the alleged atrocities of the Iraqis and Sadam Hussein in Kuwait, and how atrocity tales like babies being removed from incubators and killed were fabricated to manipulate public opinion towards war with Iraq. Not just that, but they were fabricated specifically by Congressman Tom Lantos, who was a Holocaust survivor and one of the 5 witnesses featured in Spielberg's film.
They place specific importance on this genocide because our culture does so. That doesn't mean Revisionists buy whole-cloth into all the witness testimony of all Soviet atrocities as implied in a different comment.
I have not seen Revisionists beleaguer the conditions in the Gulags based on witness testimony. The Gulags are used by Revisionists as a counterpart, an attempt to draw an equivalency, to the German concentration camps. If you take away the 4 or 5 alleged "extermination camps" with homicidal gas chambers in Poland, and are the left with the German concentration camp system as described in documents, then there is an easy comparison with the Gulags of the Soviets (who were an ally), and the American concentration camps to a lesser extent.
Gulag revisionists tend to be sympathetic to the Soviet Union in a similar way that Revisionists also tend to be sympathetic to Germany. But any Russian or Soviet sympathizers are going to rightfully be proud of probably the greatest accomplishment of the Soviet Union which earns it universal praise among the criticism- defeating Nazi Germany.
The Holocaust narrative adds a lot of moral weight and credibility to that accomplishment, and if you take it away, the "victory" and costs of that devastating conflict become a lot more ambiguous- particularly for the Western Allies. I think that's why I am not aware of any dual-Gulag/Holocaust Revisionists, and the conditions of the gulags is not something I have looked into so I cannot say.

To_Mandalay claims that "Operation Reinhardt" was the code-name for the German plan to exterminate the Jews in gas chambers. He claims Globocnik was put in charge of this operation by Himmler.
But Globocnik's top-secret report to Himmler on this initiative makes no reference or allusion to the extermination of the Jews. The report describes resettlement as claimed by Revisionists. So To_Mandalay is accusing the SS of deception in internal, top-secret documentation during a period when they were not expecting to lose the war.
Globocnik also suggested destroying the receipts of confiscated property, showing the obvious conclusion that the participants in secret operations will destroy the paper trail of their crimes after-the-fact. Historians claim this happened in spades within the SS, but the FSB releases from the NKVD must be taken at face value according to him - even though they have a track record and motive to lie about these very questions.
The Korherr report also describes an evacuation and resettlement and not an extermination. This is yet another case where the mainstream is alleging deception and camouflage in top-secret, internal reporting. The author of that report even wrote a letter to Der Spiegel in the 1970s saying that he sought clarification and understood the reporting to refer to evacuation/resettlement and not extermination, so To_Mandalay would have you believe that even the statistician who created the report was deceived! So much for the "no deception in internal communications" assumption he relies on so heavily to bolster his trust in NKVD sources.
More options
Context Copy link