@SecureSignals's banner p

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

				

User ID: 853

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 853

Is your argument that 'demographic decline' is inherently dysgenic, or that "atheists" are genetically superior and their relative decline is dysgenic for society as a whole?

My argument is that atheists don't lose their religious inclination just because they are on the bandwagon of rejecting Christianity. Their rejection of Christianity doesn't change their genes. Their religious impulse is just directed towards other expressions of religious devotion and cult-like behavior. Many atheists are more "religious" in these terms than Christians- think the die-hard trans activist vs the average Joe who goes to church on Christmas and Easter because that's his family's tradition. There is arguably now greater social pressure for people to be atheist than to be Christian. I am speaking of religiosity as a behavior, not adherence to a specific traditional religion.

Sorry hoss, I ain't buying it. But I don't think either of us would benefit from hashing it out.

You are just willfully blind then. You think those caste systems which have persisted for thousands of years were just put in place and persisted for shits and giggles?

The Indian caste system was established 3,000 years ago, after the Aryan invasion, and Brahmins in India to this day have more Aryan DNA than the lower castes:

Among the upper castes the genetic distance between Brahmins and Europeans (0.10) is smaller than that between either the Kshatriya and Europeans (0.12) or the Vysya and Europeans (0.16). Assuming that contemporary Europeans reflect West Eurasian affinities, these data indicate that the amount of West Eurasian admixture with Indian populations may have been proportionate to caste rank.

They are unambiguous proof of eugenic thinking in ancient time, and society was almost entirely organized around these systems in many cases. They didn't understand genes but they clearly understood the importance of inheritance. The ancient Greeks, Romans, Jews, Indians, all of them attributed spiritual quality to what we understand as the science of inheritance, and they organized their religion and society around that understanding. The United States is likely less eugenically minded than any of these other civilizations at their height, as eugenic thinking is taboo today whereas it was the center of their religions and civic societies.

there's plenty of ways AI (or tech more broadly) can be eugenic on your terms without having an effect on fertility or requiring people to change 'breeding habits or mate selection.'

You are just using a "magic wand" to dismiss the issue. We don't know exactly how or when this "magic wand" will be sufficiently developed and integrated into society to have what impacts. We don't know if there will be political will to use these tools properly, for all we know AI will be used to suppress eugenically-minded behavior. Even rationalists are extremely fearful of eugenic thinking, judging by the EA forum, so how are the powers that be going to use AI on this front? It's a total unknown. I obviously do not oppose the involvement of AI in these initiatives, but to take it for granted that the theoretical advancements are already a substitute for culture, a substitute for evolution, is not at all certain and would far more likely complement such cultural changes along these lines.

Cultural changes towards eugenically-minded thinking would assist the development of AI towards these ends and reduce the risk of "AI alignment" being deployed against it.

The last absurdity with you and other posters saying "whatever AI will solve it" is you are still acknowledging the importance of the issue! You are just saying that culture and mate selection and breeding habits are already deprecated by theoretical advancements in AI. That is just completely absurd. We are already seeing geopolitical implications of a couple generations of assortative mating habits in Israel. It would not take 8 generations for other movements like this to make major political and geopolitical impacts.

At the end, Chapter 14, Wiernik describes his daring escape:

Suddenly we heard the signal - a shot fired into the air.

We leaped to our feet. Everyone fell to his prearranged task and performed it with meticulous care. Among the most difficult tasks was to lure the Ukrainians from the watchtowers. Once they began shooting at us from above, we would have no chance of escaping alive. We knew that gold held an immense attraction for them, and they had been doing business with the Jews all the time. So, when the shot rang out, one of the Jews sneaked up to the tower and showed the Ukrainian guard a gold coin. The Ukrainian completely forgot that he was on guard duty. He dropped his machine gun and hastily clambered down to pry the piece of gold from the Jew. They grabbed him, finished him off and took his revolver. The guards in the other towers were also dispatched quickly...

Just as I thought I was safe, running straight ahead as fast as I could, I suddenly heard the command "Halt!" right behind me. By then I was exhausted but I ran faster just the same. The woods were just ahead of me, only a few leaps away. I strained all my will power to keep going. The pursuer was gaining and I could hear him running close behind me.

Then I heard a shot; in the same instant I felt a sharp pain in my left shoulder. I turned around and saw a guard from the Treblinka Penal Camp. He again aimed his pistol at me. I knew something about firearms and I noticed that the weapon had jammed. I took advantage of this and deliberately slowed down. I pulled the ax from my belt. My pursuer - a Ukrainian guard - ran up to me yelling in Ukrainian: "Stop or I'll shoot!" I came up close to him and struck him with my axe across the left side of his chest. He collapsed at my feet with a vile path.

I was free and ran into the woods. After penetrating a little deeper into the thicket, I sat down among the bushes. From the distance I heard a lot of shooting. Believe it or not, the bullet had not really hurt me. It had gone through all of my clothing and stopped at my shoulder, leaving a mark. I was alone. At last, I was able to rest.

Holocaust memoirs are the ultimate double-edged sword in the Holocaust industry. They can become immensely popular, commercially succesful, have huge cultural influence, and greatly increase the public perception of the Holocaust, especially among children, but they are often riddled with historical inaccuracies, contradictions, exaggerations, and outright fabrications that can put historians in an uncomfortable position of contradicting the experiences of the survivors.

Many authors of Holocaust memoirs are those who remained silent for decades, but finally decided to come out and tell their story for the first time. An example is Irene Zisblatt, who decided to break her silence and tell her story in her memoir, The Fifth Diamond published in 2008. Among other things, Zisblatt claimed that she escaped from a gas chamber, had her Auschwitz prisoner tattoo surgically removed by Dr. Mengele, that Ilse Kolche had selected her to be turned into a lampshade, and that she constantly swallowed, defacated, and re-swallowed diamonds given to her by her mother during her internment in the camp.

This also just wasn't a one-off book, Irene Zisblatt is one of the most prominently-featured survivors in Steven Spielberg's film The Last Days, which won an Oscar. Revisionists had a field day with exposing the absurd lies that Hollywood honored as their best output. I was surprised to come across this recent Times of Israel article that, finally, indicates mainstream skepticism for her obvious lies and laments that the deniers are asking good questions.

There are many other instances of Holocaust memoirs, like The Painted Bird (1968) being exposed as literary fraud, and the author of that bestseller eventually committed suicide. There are a lot of exaggerated and false memoirs.

Elie Wiesel's Night (1958) is another example- he doesn't mention gas chambers in his famous memoirs but he describes truckloads of babies being burned alive, which is not claimed to have happened by mainstream historians today.

But Herman Rosenblat takes the cake for the most iconic memoir fraudster who, after a couple appearances on Oprah, a book deal, and movie deal, was exposed for being a fraud. In an interview he did with ABC News, he was asked why he lied to so many people, and his response was "it wasn't a lie, it was my imagination, and in my imagination it was true".

There's a lot of commercial incentive for survivors to "tell their stories", with all the problems that come with perverse incentives and "recovered memory" syndrome. This also presents a problem because "the case" for the Holocaust entirely relies on witness testimony, so embarassing displays of prominent witnesses lying weakens the most important body of evidence that historians rely upon in lieu of documentary and physical evidence. Holocaust historians almost never reference the authors of these memoirs.

With all that said, there is one memoir that is extremely important to Holocaust historigraphy, and that is Yankel Wiernik's A Year in Treblinka (1944). Wiernik's memoir was published by the Polish Underground in 1944, making it an extremely early purported eyewitness account to the alleged Treblinka atrocities. Owing to the lack of documentary and physical evidence, Wiernik's memoir is heavily relied on as a primary source by Holocaust historians. But I encourage anyone to read it and decide for themselves. It doesn't come across as very credible, which is why it hasn't become "required reading" so-to-speak.

The most famous "memoir" of sorts is Anne Frank's diary, which does not claim to witness gas chamber extermination. Anne was deported with her family to Auschwitz, but then transferred to Belsen where she died in a hospital of Typhus. So the diary, while famous, does not enter into discussions of the authenticity of gas chambers and extermination camps.

In short, for a memoir to enter into the discussion it has to: 1. be relevant to the extermination and gas chamber claims, and 2. be credible (i.e. early accounts). There are not very many memoirs that fit this criteria, Wiernik is really the best they can do on that front, and his credibility is seriously lacking.

In other words, no, your religious beliefs are absolutely not genetically heritable in the way that (I think) you are claiming.

I meant heritability of religion in the terms you are describing, and 25-45% range is about what I would have expected. The religiosity gene(s) are what matter, and they don't go away just because theistic religion is declining among certain demographics. A 25-45% heritability of religious impulse still has important implications. Those people want to latch onto something, and if it's not something eugenic then there's a chance it will be something dysgenic. Certainly from the perspective of the DR, the prevailing civic religions that capture the free religious energy of "atheists" is dysgenic as it entails the celebration of and political support for demographic decline. For a longtermist, that should be terrifying and just assuming AI is going to solve it is a dangerous bet.

But the heritability of "Collinsism" or whatever would certainly be near-zero. Their children will not have a lot of incentive to adopt that religion of their parents and a lot of incentive to put it behind them in their identity and their lives.

but what you call 'race formation' is very far from the only viable option for civilization building. If humans in antiquity had decided to invent eugenics rather than writing, we never would have made as much progress as we have now.

The ancients did invent eugenics. It's biblical. In the book of Genesis, Jacob swindles the herd of sheep from his father-in-law by peeling the bark off of a tree, in order to influence the breeding habits of the flock of sheep. Flocks of sheep are often biblical metaphor for humans and, according to the parable, the sheep saw the stripes on the tree from the peeled bark and that altered their mating habits. Jacob directed the mating habits of the herd (with cultural signaling) and acquired the flock.

In ancient Greece, priestly function was inherited. There were numerous fertility cults in ancient Greece and Rome that, through religion, provided breeding models for men and women, including the establishment of a physical ideal for men and women through the images of their gods. There were also caste systems, like the one in ancient Rome that eventually declined in prominence along with the decline of Rome itself. India's caste system was obviously designed with a eugenic function in the consciousness of its creators... and the Brahmin are now entering the American elite in growing numbers, aren't they?

Obviously the ancients did not have the genetic knowledge we do today. But they clearly learned eugenics and transmitted that knowledge through art and religion.

Improvements in AI, synthetic augmentation (neuralink, etc) and social organization could very well eclipse anything you could accomplish with assortative mating given ~25-35 year generation times even if you managed to get everyone on board and biology works as well as you think it will.

The biology of inheritance is certainly more reliable than theoretical improvements in AI. It's far more likely that AI would improve fertility, and therefore the impact of a eugenic-minded strategy, well before it replaces the importance of breeding habits and mate selection altogether (if it ever does, which it likely will not).

There is nothing "just" about 11 generations! Making decisions today on the assumption that your kids, and their kids, and so on up to 8 billion people will keep your ideology over the course of centuries is making decisions on the basis of a false assumption.

I agree. The DR has a more sober-minded view that the solution is to orchestrate the reproductive habits of a larger subset of people towards a common end. This can only be done with religion, whether theistic or non-theistic, traditional or hipster. I'm not familiar with Israel's internal politics, but I'll defer to the comment of @2rafa describing the looming dominance of the ultra-orthodox in that country. If trends continue, it's not going to take 11 generations for this to happen, and for the ensuing political (and likely geo-political) implications.

@Stefferi also mentioned the Laestadians in Finland.

Would longtermism want to emulate the Ultra-Orthodox or Laestadians in every sense? No. But if such a cult inspired and ameliorated productive and civilizational-oriented behavior instead of strict adherence to superstition, and incentivized a eugenic mate selection that increased the fertility of the most beautiful, intelligent, and physically fit- you likewise would not need 11 generations to see an evolution in the population.

I've been thinking about this article a lot. To some degree, the whole situation comes across as one family's attempt to grapple with the fact that they've been a part of a subculture - rationalists - that almost often seems to price being weird and doing things differently from the normies - and at the same time they've been struck with one of the most normie human emotions of all of them, ie. the wish to have children. As such, it would not be enough to just have kids like a normie, you have to find some sort of a justification for acting normal - with the whole pro-natalist shtick being this justification.

I think that's part of it. But I think it's also the "low IQ/high IQ" meme template of "the best people should just have more kids". Their recent post on the EA forum is a lot more well-thought out than a post-hoc justification for hormonal instincts. It was poorly received by the EA community who correctly identified it as getting very close to the train of dissident right-wing thinking, although I mean that as a compliment rather than a criticism.

Yeah they are weird as hell, but I like it. Part of what I dislike about Effective Altruism is it seems like a fancy way for rationalists to just be boring liberals- longtermists with an egalitarian hangover, and they can't quite escape the orbit of those liberal presuppositions. This is especially evident in the comments of the EA forum:

Moreover, it seems to me that one of the core values of effective altruism is that of impartiality― giving equal moral weight to people who are distant from me in space and/or time. The kind of essentialist and elitist rhetoric common among people who concern themselves with demographic collapse seems in direct opposition to that value; if you think a key priority of our time is ensuring the right people have children, especially if your definition of "the right people" focuses on elite and wealthy people in Western countries, I doubt that we have compatible notions of what it means to do the most good.

and:

The main reason for the post is not to start a discussion on whether or not the Collins' brand of pronatalism is appropriate or a logical conclusion to longtermism. I already have a fairly settled view on this, and if it's the case that we sit here and discuss the merits of this type of pronatalism and suggest that it is a natural conclusion to longtermism, I'm simply going to reject longtermism.

There is nothing about longtermism that requires "impartiality". Longtermism is nominally about civilizational trajectory, not egalitarianism (at least it should be).

The Collinses are trying to start a fertility cult. They have escaped orbit and their wacky adventures are going in the right direction from my view.

There is a long history of fertility cults. Arguably all religion, and politics for that matter, could be interpreted through the lens of different implementations of fertility cults. The Collins cult is myopic and not something I would support, but it's thinking in the right direction.

Of course, the problems of separation and insularity are also a common discussion vis-a-vis strongly Islamic immigrant communities in Europe and elsewhere.

The Collins cult seems to be aiming for insularity, but it doesn't have to be a feature of any theoretical solution. The cult of Apollo is referenced by some in the DR as a breeding model which facilitated eugenic mate selection, and it was the center of many aspects of public life.

I really enjoyed the series and got a lot out of it. It's a difficult topic to engage with if you haven't read the source material. But I'm looking forward to your next book reviews.

Rationalism Done Right (and Hipster Eugenecists)

I don't follow the Rationalist sphere very much beyond this community, but I came across the above article with claims that there may be some rightward shifts within the rationalist movement in interesting directions. The author starts by mentioning that:

Richard Hanania said he wanted to start calling himself a “right-wing rationalist.” He thinks he has the same methods of reasoning that rationalists use, but he reaches right-wing conclusions. I spend time with effective altruists, read Scott Alexander, and all that, but I also come to some conclusions that most people would regard as right-wing. I think plenty of people in the community do the same, but they aren’t the majority.

I can't speak to Hanania's views so I would take that with a grain of salt. But the author creates "a list of beliefs for rationalists or effective altruists who lean right", which are the author's conception of "right-wing rationalism." They are described in the article but listed here:

\1. Rejection of the Blank Slate

\2. Cognitive ability, as measured by IQ, has numerous important socioeconomic correlates within countries

\3. Cognitive ability, as measured by IQ, has numerous important socioeconomic correlates between countries

\4. Within developed nations, we cannot substantially permanently change cognitive ability for the better

\5. Inequality of educational outcomes within developed countries is primarily driven by genetic differences

\6. Since genetic differences—especially in genes associated with IQ—play an important causal in socio-economic outcomes, we have to treat genetic changes—dysgenics and eugenics—seriously

\7. Rejection of “the orthodoxy”

\8. Markets are good

\9. We are in an evolutionary mismatch

\10. Suppressing the above information is more harmful than helpful, and we should face reality

The list is weighted too much on IQ differences and socio-economic outcomes. Basically five of these points are restatements of the importance of IQ. But essentially all aspects of our personality, including our religious and political beliefs, are heritable. What makes China and what makes the United States is not only a function of IQ.

Point #6 is interesting because I felt it was the biggest differentiator between rationalist thinking and dissident right-wing thinking- the latter of which is concerned with the problem of ethnogenesis and race formation which, if you care about basically anything: civilization, politics, religion, you have to consciously confront the problem of ethnogenesis. It's interesting to see a higher awareness of that problem in a Rationalist, although again he seems only concerned with IQ drift and is missing the bigger picture of ethnogenesis. That is probably why he ultimately describes himself as "enthusiastic for immigration", still viewing the problem as capturing as many high-IQ genes as possible rather than confronting the harder problem of race formation.

Point #9 is also a step closer to DR-oriented thinking:

On the rationalist right, there is more skepticism around the practicality and utility of polyamory, promiscuity, substance use, and atheism. There is more sympathy for Christianity, having children, and the genders adopting their respective gender roles. The right also seems to like older and more traditional aesthetics in architecture, artwork, clothing, etc.

At the end of his article Parrhesia mentions "the Collin’s pro-natalist conservative faction" and linked to this article: Billionaires like Elon Musk want to save civilization by having tons of genetically superior kids. Inside the movement to take 'control of human evolution'. There's a lot of sneering by the author, a lot of cultish goofiness from the subjects of the article (the Collinses), but ultimately I think there's a lot of substance there.

Like many, I've been highly critical of Effective Altruism's implementation of longtermism, primarily due to the fact that if you are a longtermist then your top priority shouldn't be altruism, it should be race formation. What would a longtermist, civilization-building-focused care about that isn't downstream from the gene pool? The Effective Altruist forum has a thread on this article under the thread name "Pronatalists" may look to co-opt effective altruism or longtermism. The greatest consternation was over this part of the BI article:

She [Collins] also weighed in on the stunning implosion of Sam Bankman-Fried's crypto exchange FTX, which represented one of the largest financial hubs for the effective-altruism movement. The Collinses, who never directly associated with the top Democratic donor Bankman-Fried, spied an opportunity in his demise.

"This means our faction (more conservative, pronatalist, long-termist-civilization-building-focused, likely to self fund) is now 100X more likely to become a real, dominant faction in the EA space," Simone wrote in a text message on November 12.

The Collinses hope that advances in technology will keep pace with their growing family. The reproductive entrepreneurs who spoke with me seemed confident that the science would progress quickly. "I think we are reaching a point in which we are reinventing reproduction," Varsavsky said.

If scientists at companies like Conception succeed in creating viable embryos out of stem cells, they could in theory produce a massive number of them. Combined with enhanced genetic screening, parents could pick the "optimal" baby from a much larger pool. "There's a seductiveness to these ideas, because it's very grand," Torres said. "It's about taking control of human evolution."

I think the vision here is a far better implementation of longtermism than EA.

As these threads of of Rationalist thinking start to converge with DR thinking, they will have to confront the major problem of coordinating behavior. There's a tounge-in-cheek naivety in the plan of the Collinses:

Along with his 3-year-old brother, Octavian, and his newborn sister, Titan Invictus, Torsten has unwittingly joined an audacious experiment. According to his parents' calculations, as long as each of their descendants can commit to having at least eight children for just 11 generations, the Collins bloodline will eventually outnumber the current human population.

This sounds like a crazy idea (and it is). But a much more attainable solution is to organize the social behavior of similar people by granting social status to reproducing, and incentivizing assortative mate selection with high-quality and like-minded people. Basically the things Religion has done for us until now. This could be accomplished with the revitalization of traditional religious institutions or the creation of a new non-theistic cult that coordinates this behavior. The DR is split between the two approaches, and the Collinses would clearly fit better in with the latter.

Another aspect of the article I found noteworthy was that the Collinses (who are Jewish) laugh-off the predictable comparisons to Nazism which (to be fair, credibly) are going to be associated with any pro-natalist movement by its opponents:

The Collinses themselves have been called "hipster eugenicists" online, something Simone called "amazing" when I brought it to her attention.

Malcolm's "going to want to make business cards that say 'Simone and Malcolm Collins: Hipster Eugenicists," she said with a laugh.

"It's funny that people are so afraid of being accused of Nazism," when they're just improving their own embryos, Simone added, after noting that her Jewish grandmother escaped Nazi-occupied France. "I'm not eliminating people. I mean, I'm eliminating from my own genetic pool, but these are all only Malcolm and me."

Another interesting statement from Simone, which is something you will read verbatim in the DR:

"The person of this subculture really sees the pathway to immortality as being through having children," Simone said.

I started writing a paragraph of what I thought the article would look like, but it was too spicy. It is Christ-like for white people to endure this when nobody else with the power would do so.

It just shows the uselessness of your model that both the Jewish lobby described in this article and BDS are simply "both wholly PMC." What good is your model if you are unable to differentiate between these influences? Everything is just PMC I guess, and there's no point to looking into other patterns of behavior other than class dynamics. That just leaves you with absurdity like the author of this article who is left pondering what these people have in common.

You would sing a different tune if the vitriol of this (checks notes) Yahoo News article were going off on Jews instead of wypipo. But Jews would not tolerate that. Heads would roll if something like that got published.

Your relative power dynamics and income data doesn't seem to explain the difference here.

It's just SBF funnelling big donor money into giving more power to the Professional–managerial class.

Why is the Professional-managerial class so unified on support for Israel?

Of course the leftist author can only look at this through a class lens and totally ignore the ethnic motivations to this unity between these Dem Pacs spending the vast majority of their money on democratic primaries, AIPAC, and "pro-Trump billionaires". They always have to say it's about class and "power to the Professional-managerial class" and remain willfully blind to the truth of the dual-loyalty of these Jews who spend enormous amounts of money and political influence to secure the standing of their ethnostate in American politics.

These groups aren't working together for their class interests. They are doing so for their ethnic interests and their loyalty to Israel.

I mean, look at this:

But, SBF wasn’t the only billionaire to support the effort. Trump supporting billionaires Bernard Marcus (owner of Home Depot), Robert Kraft (owner of the Patriots), and Paul Singer (owner of Elliot Investment Management) each gave a million dollars to help defeat working class candidates.

Overall, the five groups that make up the Injustice Democrats spent $44,454,111 on outside expenditure this cycle.

What did SBF have in common with the pro-Israel lobby and pro-Trump billionaires? In short, a desire to staunch the rise of the left, and keep the Democratic Party in the hands of financial and political elites who protect the status quo.

The SBF and AIPAC affiliated PACs which made up the Injustice Democrats worked together directly in at least 14 competitive primaries.

Even when a leftist does excellent work in doing research and connecting the dots, he's ultimately confronted with the hard limits on the Marxist lens of political analysis. When asking what these people: SBF, Mark Mellman, Jewish billionaires, and AIPAC have in common, his answer is that they are all "financial and political elites who protect the status quo." Come on, it's just too much. Really shows the hard limits of class reductionism that he can't see what he is clearly laying down in front of his own face.

That's funny you mention that quote, I just watched Oblivion yesterday with Tom Cruise and it was a plot point of the film. What are the chances. It's funny how two people can read the same writing and both think it supports their perspectives even though they are opposed.

But I don't think that quote lends support to the "be quietly devoured" side of Nietzsche's dilemma. Do you really think you are facing fearful odds for the ashes of your fathers with a milquetoast non-resistance to an opposition that is tearing down the temples of your gods? You really think "Democrats are the real racists" is you standing against fearful odds when it's the safest (non-)opposition that progressives allow you to have? You will be able to live peacefully with that opposition, that's true, because "Democrats are the real racists" is ultimately paying homage to their gods. You are still adopting their moral compass.

Horatius describing "Standing against fearful odds" obviously honors the bold and the brave opposition- in the context of ancestor worship for that matter, and not the personal salvation of one's own soul. The ancient Romans made mountains of skulls in honor of the ashes of their fathers and the temples of their gods. And so did any great civilization.

Caring more about the salvation of one's own soul than fighting and winning against a monstrous opposition would be total lunacy to Horatius.

I also object to the implication I am a utopian. I am certainly not. I believe in the deep, inherent conflict of the political and don't believe there's one neat trick that solves it and saves everyone's soul. That's why I care about winning, and think it's a vice for people who should know better, but they stay within the walled garden of their feckless opposition while they make the conscious decision to gracefully lose.

It's not brave at all and it's certainly not the posture that Horatius is honoring in this writing.

I can see that from a Christian perspective, with a belief in an eternal reward for choosing non-resistant martyrdom against enemies that wish you harm.

But in ancient Roman the virtues included Virtus, Auctoritas, Dignitas... "Gracefully losing" while your community falls apart would be seen as a vice from this perspective.

Nietzsche asked:

Is it better to out-monster the monster or to be quietly devoured?

If your morals lead you to be devoured by the monster, for no benefit to anyone except monsters, then what good are those morals?

But, Knives Out wasn't even about that; the family members got their comeuppance at their own hands. They dispossessed themselves.

In the same way, the writers do not believe white people are worthy of the inheritance of the country, or "the estate." Of course they are going to depict the white people in the story of not being worthy of their inheritance, and the minority character does nothing wrong in the entire film. In fact, that's a plot twist of the first film: you thought the housekeeper made a big mistake but it turns out she was completely innocent and didn't make a mistake at all. In the sequel, too, they portray the success of the white man as having been stolen from the black woman. To say that this is about class and not about race is missing the mark.

Sometimes a cigar is, indeed, just a cigar.

I don't think you watched the film very closely. Rian Johnson slams this over the head of the audience. There were a lot of lines and scenes that put the film in a racialized context, i.e.:

Many of the main points in “Knives Out” are made during allegories like that game of Go.

During Harlan’s party, for example, Richard beckoned Marta towards the couch, where he was seated with a few family members while they discussed politics. Many of the Thrombeys are afraid of immigrants, and said things like “We’re losing our way of life and our culture,” “America is for americans,” and, most strikingly, “We let them in and they think they own what’s ours.”

Of course, the final shot of the film is Marta looking down from the balcony with a mug that says "My House." Even National Review picked up on it, for whatever that's worth.

I also agree that you can identify and critique "woke messaging" but still enjoy a film on its own merits - writing, acting, story, etc. I also enjoyed the first movie, although I was far more offended by Daniel Craig's Southern accent than I was by the film's celebration of white replacement.

It's also worth noting that the Jewish counter-examples you raise have themselves far higher than average anti-Semitic views. Ron Unz, Paul Gottfried, David Cole, et al. share critiques of Jewish influence with the alt right. Ron Unz is a "Holocaust denier" and probably more anti-Semitic than than the average alt-righter, owing to his depth of knowledge. David Cole is also a Holocaust denier (although he'll try to distance himself from the term, he is one according to any mainstream authority on that label). Gottfried has been influential on the alt-right and hits many of the same criticisms of Jewish influence (i.e. in the Neo-conservative movement) and zionist hypocrisy, which are standard fare on the DR.

Jewish anti-semitism is an interesting phenomenon. It's a phenomenon the DR recognizes and appreciates, because obviously in-group criticism is going to have a greater force of credibility than an out-group criticism. But overall I would say it lends credibility to so-called "anti-semitic" views that the most "pro-western Jews" are more likely to sympathize with and agree with alt-right critiques which are called "anti-semitic."

The first movie, Knives Out, was clearly about and a celebration of white dispossession, with the final scene consisting of the Latina housekeeper who has inherited the mansion looking down on the disinherited, evil white family from the balcony with a mug that says "my house, my rules, my coffee." I haven't seen the new one yet, but it sounds like another "all the white people are evil except the detective" plot.

As is always the case when people criticize legal decisions

The legal decision should be criticized for regarding a sacred Jewish symbol as secular when it is not secular. Jews themselves, the ones who sponsor the menorahs, do not regard them as secular. The decision relied on that logic which is clearly wrong.

What matters, at the end of the day, is that there are giant menorahs in front of the White House and many other public spaces where elected officials pay respect and promise support to Jews, and in those spaces there is no similar regard for Christianity. It's the largest menorah in the world at Central Park, not the largest Nativity scene in the world at Central Park. Allegheny helps explain the development status quo, but I am talking about the meaning of the status quo rather than simply criticizing the legal decision. So your hairsplitting really does not change the fact of the matter.

I would also suggest that the fact that you use Prager's claim re the historical significance of the battle that Hannukah celebrates as evidence of the religious significance of the holiday, you aren't thinking very rigorous about the claim you are making.

All religion has historical significance. The birth of Jesus, whether you regard it as history or myth, is itself a historically important story.

Prager regards the menorah as a symbol of Jewish victory, like many of the Jews I read who weighed in on their interpretation of why it's important to light the menorah in public spaces. "It's a symbol of Jewish victory, and it's historically important" does not make it secular any more than saying "The Cross is a symbol of Christianity, and it's a historically important symbol" makes it secular.

If the menorah were replaced with a Cross (relates to historically important developments, so it's secular!), and Joe Biden attended ceremonies for its dedication, and promised support to the Christian people and federal handouts to Churches and Christian community centers, and created a task force in the National Security apparatus to "counter anti-Christianity", would you regard that as the establishment of religion?

The point is that if you look at one museum among seventeen and note that it receives more funding than some and less than others

As I've said, it received $244 million from public and private sources. That is not "more than some and less than others", that is vastly more than all others. I have also said that this fact indicates a prioritization of the subject matter we consider sacred.

If the museum to the Victims of Communism had a $244 million dollar budget in combined public and private support, and the USHMM had a $1 million budget in combined public and private support, I would not say, like you do, "Oh well, that's just due to the way the government processes budget requests." I would also attribute that to a meaningful difference in the cultural narratives we consider sacred compared to the present reality.

In this alternate universe where the Victims of Communism museum had $244 million in support and the USHMM had $1 million support, how could you see that happening without a major cultural change in this alternate world?

I think that Jews as a group have lots of power in the US and that they're generally not interested in using this power to promote the Jewish religion, for the simple reason that they mostly don't believe in it themselves.

Their religion is themselves, and they are their religion. Their religion is a matrilieanly-inherited status to the Chosen people, and that membership is often extremely important even to "non-religious" Jews. Their influence to give themselves special financial and legal privileges as members of that group, handouts of federal funds to their synagogues and community centers, billions of dollars of taxpayer money to their ethnostate, and now a "task force" which will use the national security apparatus to "counter" people who dare to criticize them... That is all promoting their religion, even if "promoting their religion" does not involve great effort to convert gentiles.

You don't necessarily promote a religion by trying to convert others. You can promote it by giving it special status and privileges and protections, or by lighting giant menorahs in symbolically important spaces where Christians are denied a Nativity during the Christian's own very import holiday.

what's the problem? That Christians weren't allowed both the tree and the nativity display? Or that the tree is pagan, and therefore 'technically' Christians got nothing?

The Christmas Tree is not a Christian symbol. Every atheist I know has a Christmas Tree in his house. I live in a heavily Hindu area, and they are participating in Christmas lights and decorations with about as high participation as my white neighbors. The Nativity, though is a Christian symbol.

Jews are allowed to have their sacred religious symbol, which does have a deeply religious and symbolically important purpose. Whereas Christians are denied a Nativity in these same, symbolically-important public spaces.

This is very meaningful, as meaningful as Jews would interpret it if the Menorah in front of the White House were removed and replaced with a giant Nativity Scene. They would, rightfully, attribute important meaning to that act. All I am doing is calling attention to the fact that the status quo is also deeply meaningful and indicative of cultural power and influence.

Here is the first sentence under "Opinion of the Court" in the article I linked:

The majority holding of the Court found that the crèche display violated the Establishment Clause while the menorah did not

The breakdown of the votes between the two sides of the majority is not at all relevant. I even linked the article where anyone could see the vote breakdown between the two sides. But the opinion was as I described.

A creche is far more of a sacred religious symbol than is a menorah

This is just a totally absurd statement. They are both sacred religious symbols. A menorah is not a secular symbol. Saying "one is more sacred than the other" is just trying to rationalize privileging one religious symbol over the other. Today I saw this Fox News article by Dennis Prager: Hanukkah made western civilization possible:

Holiday celebrates Jewish victory but really preserved the idea of one God instead of pagan beliefs

I also stated, to the annoyance of some here, that the menorah is a symbol of Jewish victory. And Prager affirms that interpretation verbatim. It is obviously a sacred religious symbol. The Talmud says:

Our Rabbis taught: It is incumbent to place the Hanukkah lamp… at the window nearest the street. [Shabbat 21b] Rava asked: [If there is a choice between lighting] the Hanukkah lights and saying kiddush over the wine [for the Sanctification of Shabbat], is 3 [kiddush] more important, because it is a more frequent obligation? [Shabbat is weekly, whereas Hanukkah is only annual.] Or are the Hanukkah lights preferable, on account of publicizing the miracle? Afterasking, he himself answered it: The Hanukkah lights are preferable, because they publicize the miracle.

So the Talmud mandates the display of the menorah to "publicize the miracle." That is a sacred religious symbol.

the display is OK if 1) it has a secular purpose

The menorah lighting at the White House and Central Park does not have a secular purpose. It has a deeply religious and symbolically important purpose. Jews themselves understand this. I know you are going to say it has a secular purpose, because you want to privilege Jewish sacred symbols over Christian symbols. But it doesn't make that position any more rational than it is.