You're cherrypicking examples. I can think of people to whom applying this standard would have made us better off.
Also, yes I am, but isn’t that the point of examples? If you can name some leaders society would have been better throwing out over moral reasons I would be interested to hear the counter-case. That is, business leaders or tech CEOs or something equivalent, not merely political leaders who had scandals.
The spy thing is a deeper wrinkle that requires some more nuance here — although again I would point out that now the news is saying we’re not really sure if she was a spy or not. But I’m not trying to make this about the spy as such: I want to reject the argument that we get some kind of moral busybody veto on who gets to be a tech CEO.
I mean, well, we already do have such a veto, it’s the law, and we elect representatives to decide it. I would be fine with Jensen Huang being punished if he killed a kid because that’s illegal, everybody knew that going in. If people think he should be punished for having an affair, we have mechanisms for that, someone can campaign on putting people in jail for cheating on a spouse. Nobody seems to be saying that though.
Have you been jacking off to porn? Said the r-slur? Had a girl say you raped her? This is highly unethical, as everybody knows, and society cannot allow you to continue working if you engage in unethical behavior.
Oh, you want me to make an exception for you? I can’t do that without logically condoning murder. So we have to condemn Jensen Huang, he had an affair.
The most important industrialists in the world absolutely have spies and watchers tracking them. You don’t need paparazzi: it just takes someone who knows making a phone call to the NYT. Discretion doesn’t save anybody either, in a post-privacy world.
Maybe I’m being imprecise. Arnold Murray was apparently 19 when they met — Turing would have been about 39. I would have guessed he’d had relations with someone 16-17 but perhaps I’m confusing him with someone else — it’s fairly common in gayworld.
Maybe this makes a better argument anyways: you can’t impose a Neo-Puritan moral sex code on the tech CEOs when we made it up five minutes ago. Look at Alan Turing, his life was ruined over what today would be totally unobjectionable.
Chinese spy is a bigger deal yeah. I’m chiming in because the standard being claimed here is inching closer towards crabs in a bucket.
We’re building superintelligences that could solve cancer and math and eliminate work, and we’re worried that the guys building it aren’t saints? Respectfully I worry this is literal slave morality, the social contract actually falls apart if we imagine that we all get to exercise a veto on the superproductive whenever they violate some Neo-Puritan code.
Jensen Huang jumped through many more hoops than anyone on this forum. Probably more than almost anyone on the planet. The question isn’t whether elites have to jump through hoops, but whether one of those hoops should be the arbitrary veto of small-minded public morality.
A veto which, may I remind the reader, would have condemned this forum.
Jensen Huang isn’t elite because he passed the 2rafa morality test. There was no election. He didn’t ascend the cursus honorum. Nobody in the general public had even heard of this guy until Nvidia’s stock surge in 2023 made it valuable. That is, he didn’t rise because of a formal process that you can veto. He rose in fact through a system that does not ask for your approval and in fact could not exist if it did.
What would happen if we applied this standard backwards in history? I think it’s fair to ask:
-
Alan Turing was a homosexual who committed sexual acts with young boys. Is it good that he was prosecuted, stripped of his security clearance, and ultimately driven out?
-
Weather Von Braun was the chief architect of Saturn V. Should he have been? Do you agree with giving Nazis power and influence?
-
Oppenheimer hung out with Communists and carried on affairs: would you have put him in charge of the Manhattan Project?
-
Jeff Bezos and Bill Gates have committed very public affairs, at what point would you have taken their companies from them?
You said that elites should “sleep around quietly”. But that’s an impossible standard if elites sleeping around is inherently newsworthy.
Not caring about the personal ethics of elites is degenerate behavior
Caring about the personal ethics of people you see on TV is parasocial behavior. Jensen Huang cheats on wife, user 2rafa hardest hit?
Why do you think you get a vote? Tech companies have to cater to your sense of ethics? One of the great virtues of capitalism has been the opposite, actually -- that the productive and artistic and great are given power beyond the ability of prudes to veto them. Or else, why stop with Jensen Huang? Peter Thiel and Sam Altman are degenerate gays, Elon Musk is fathering children out of wedlock, Jeff Bezos and Bill Gates are philanderers, do we need to take their jobs?
the tech right makes itself look repulsive when it loudly does so in Jensen’s defense.
Well, the important thing about Jensen Huang cheating on his wife is that we found a way where it's somehow Republican's fault. Did Republicans lose the midterms because of their weak stance on no-fault divorce?
Then they can sleep around quietly
Do you think it's Jensen Huang's fault that the NYT published pieces about him?
Yeah that's right but that's entailed by running a company. Jensen Huang's judgment isn't exercised by preventing harm to the wider world, it's exercised by making Nvidia profitable. It's not his job to worry about the wider world. And I'm not going to argue that dating a Chinese spy represents good judgment. (Although it's now in dispute if Jensen has really done that.) But in a strange way it's totally possible for Jensen's lax attitude toward Chinese exports to represent good judgement as CEO of Nvidia in a way that represents bad judgment if he were President of the United States.
After all, good judgment is fairly lateral. Good leadership is fairly independent of the thing being lead. If you were to create a superposition called "CEO of preventing harm to the wider world," ironically, one of the best candidates for it would be Jensen Huang. Sure, the bad judgment of dating a Chinese spy is fairly damning. But most people make mistakes like that all the time, and in fact would never exercise the good judgment to rise that high in the first place.
Yeah I think any phenomenal success like Nvidia probably requires a lot of luck, but excellent judgment is still also required. There are lots of ways Jensen Huang could have screwed it up or lost leadership to some other company, look at all the other manufacturers of chips.
The causality probably runs the other way: The breakdown of the institution of marriage created gay marriage. Gay marriage didn't degrade marriage, at least, not any more than it had already been degraded.
However, gay marriage is also a part of that decline. The redefinition of an institution as old as marriage resulted from a weaker definition of what marriage is. God, family, community, progeny, church -- all that is lost when marriage is defined as simply a relationship between two people. It's fundamentally selfish and even narcissistic, in the sense that the only reference point for marriage is the self, society and other people don't even enter into it at all. The cultural shift that produced this new idea of marriage is so profound that even calling it "selfish" probably sounds prudish and harsh to the average person. "Marriage, it's about love, what's selfish about that?"
But contra /u/porkpiehat I think you can't pick and choose your vices. I mean, I agree that gay orgies and polycules are more degenerate in some sense than man having affair. But it's really all the same thing. Emile Durkheim called this anomie, the breakdown of social norms, the breakdown of all social bonds that keep man from degenerating into mere individuals. It's like acid dissolving flesh. You can't dissolve one tissue only, the acid eats everything. Perhaps historically it happens that first man cheats on woman, then gay men marry, then you get trans kids and polycules. But the order is somewhat incidental because each descent isn't causing the next. The social organism as a whole is breaking down, it's the same cause of everything.
Durkheim called the original social cohesion "organic solidarity". He identified the cause of it as the division of labor, which is to say, work gives people social roles, and those roles naturally produce social cohesion. It isn't caused by policy or belief. You can't simply take everyone to church and make social conservatives who don't have children out of wedlock. (This can produce what Durkheim calls "mechanical solidarity," which is what happens when people are all fundamentally alike and society is homogenous. But something like the habit of going to church is itself a product of social solidarity, and you can't just go to church and grind out Church EXP until you Virtue Level Up.)
Anyways I wrote all this to get out something I've been thinking lately, which is that "you can't pick and choose your vices".
Or, rather, AI is going to dramatically increase every kind of "degeneracy". They are all going to go up together, because they all came in together in the first place. You can't pick and choose.
AI is changing the means of production, and very few people are going to be truly productive in any meaningful sense. Who is going to write code or design bridges or draft text when intelligence is cheap-to-free? You can still do these things if you want, but they're not meaningful, they're museum pieces. There are still people driving horse-drawn carriages, but not really for transportation. And you can still always make clay pots or tend a garden. Get good at hosting dinner parties. Swim laps. Kaczynski called these "surrogate activities" and called them ways of coping with the neurosis of not working for one's bread. John C. Calhoun called these "grooming activities" when he saw it in his rats he kept in post-scarcity conditions, and he called those rats "The Beautiful Ones". BAP would call this world "owned space," or, if you prefer, the Longhouse. Whatever you call it, it becomes increasingly difficult for people to find a sense of purpose when their work is fundamentally meaningless. And if Durkheim is right this would produce anomie, in all its forms, together, all its forms together, because they're all the same thing.
I've been thinking like this in response to some based friends of mine who support based abortion, which is when you support abortion for based reasons. Such as, "Planned Parenthood is good because it keeps certain people from breeding". Margaret Sanger thought the same. But you can't have just a little flesh-eating acid -- when you have abortion you will get divorce, fatherlessness, gay marriage, polyamory, trans kids, furry generals, mass immigration, DEI, etc. I have a premonition that soon we'll have Based Trans Rights, which is when you support genital reconstruction surgery because it's based if Liberals can't reproduce. The idea is interesting to me because I think there are rich depths to cynicism we haven't plunged yet as a body politic. Imagine it for a moment.
I don't think I'm in favor of any of this, I think the social conservatives were right about everything, but I'm not a social conservative, I'm gay. I'm not sure if there are many social conservatives around anyways. A lot of them are doing it for social credit, which is to say, it's a surrogate activity, it's a fun costume to wear at parties. It gives them the credibility to say that they support abortion but based. Or they want e.g. the part where the man works and makes a big salary and the woman stays at home, but they don't want the part where the woman still can't have a career or an education. I have an aunt and uncle who go to church and mean it and had a family and kids. They didn't used to be the exception.
Anyways forgive me for monologuing because this doesn't have much to do with your post, which turned out to be a good place for me to jump-off and write out some thoughts I've been having. What I'm thinking is that birthrate collapse will probably continue, and that AI could actually accelerate the collapse right as it seems to be flattening out. What I'm thinking is that "degeneracy" will increase as AI renders most people economically useless, although they might vote for some kind of horse-drawn carriage economic makework platform if Democrats offer one, what I'm thinking is that it doesn't really make much of a difference.
Sleeping around (allegedly) with two Nvidia subordinates raises questions as to his judgement
Questions mostly answered by, "judgment that built the most valuable company in the world". Or is it not accepted that Nvidia would not be where it is without Jensen Huang? Because to me it's fairly obvious that Jensen Huang with a scandal about his affairs still on net has demonstrably better judgment than basically everyone else in the world. Jensen Huang with a pegleg and an eyepatch has better judgment than basically everyone else in the world.
It's pretty extraordinary to create the most valuable company in the world, and fairly solid proof positive of very good judgment, even with massive mistakes or scandals thrown in. Who has a better track record than Jensen Huang? The competition here includes Steve Jobs trying to cure his cancer with fruit juice, Mark Zuckerberg calling his customers "dumb fucks," Jeff Bezos and Bill Gates each getting divorced for their own affairs, and Elon, poor Elon, I love Elon but come on.
Or maybe a 63 year old guy who dresses like he's still 30 has bad judgement all round.
I'm always baffled by comments like this. Jensen Huang took a niche technical product and turned it into one of the most valuable companies of all time. That, facially, requires phenomenal judgment. It requires extreme business savvy and technical knowledge and social skill. The null hypothesis here is that Jensen Huang has such good judgment that it is better than anybody on this forum criticizing his judgment. Almost anybody in the world, frankly. Even if you view his affairs as showing catastrophically bad judgment, he's still up $151 Billion overall. And he has bad judgment because he wears leather jackets?
The number of peers who can really render judgment on Jensen Huang here is exceedingly small. There are very few CEOs operating at this level of importance to the global economy. Very few people have the ability and temperament to operate in an environment like that. Elon Musk could criticize Jensen, but his conduct isn't all that much better either.
Imagine you are operating at the top of the corporate world. Every decision you make is potentially important. You have to switch context rapidly across technical fields, social environments, business requirements, legal criteria, shareholder meetings, etc. etc. You spend years cultivating snap-second judgment because there are hundreds of things that need your decision within a given day. Those decisions have to make sense in their own right and as part of a broader vision about the future of one of the most important companies on the planet. For your success in this endeavor you acquire tremendous wealth and influence, you can satisfy basically any physical desire you might have and people will do almost anything you ask of them. And in this environment, beautiful women come up to you and make you all sorts of offers.
It's part-and-parcel of being a top executive. And it's not that all of them do it. But, off the top of my head -- Napoleon, Trump, Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk, Eric Schmidt, JFK, LBJ, Clinton -- it's pretty common after all.
A few posts ago you were declaring that Superintelligence has a specific meaning in the AI field and now you’re saying that it’s not a useful term and can have no useful meaning and the only reason I could be using it is because I’m a cultist following Trump.
You want to have it both ways so you can feel righteous indignation and get upvotes.
“Superintelligence” is very useful as a term to describe the coming better-than-human intelligence. This is the sense in which I used it and I’m glad that Trump popularized this term, even if for non-technical reasons.
Your frustration is not an argument.
I will continue to use it without caving to demands that I recite the technical researcher’s definition at every utterance, recognizing that I might be subjected to emotional episodes from people who want me to be a stand-in for their frustrations with Donald Trump.
“Superintelligence” is a more useful term in several contexts than “AI” was. If every time now you hear the term “Superintelligence” you freak out about Trump, that is actually the definition of TDS.
You're referring to hypothetical technologies that don't actually exist yet and saying when they exist we should call them superintelligence.
Try again.
You clearly aren’t reading what I’m writing because I have to repeat the exact point I just made: I am using the word “superintelligence” in exactly the sense you describe. I said that all the compute being built would be used because the possible uses of superintelligence are infinite.
Yeah, Trump started using “Superintelligence” and I thought “that is better in certain contexts”. Such as the one in which I used it. You yourself were arguing that SI has a distinct meaning from AI — would you not use SI at all now even when it’s the better term?
I am speaking in the hypothetical. Yet-to-be-built compute will be used because demand for Superintelligence approaches infinity.
This is not really the thread or the moment in which I want to have this debate. But for the sake of mutual understanding I will say: your position reads to me as, “Yeah we won militarily but we don’t like the war and want to surrender, therefore, we did lose.”
Hm. Maybe you and I have gotten off on the wrong foot too many times or something. And I apologize if I’ve been rude to you. So you’re welcome to get your licks in.
But I’m also not a dumb or mean guy and we’ve had this argument many times now and I think you know what I think. And I hope that in the new year, let’s say, we can have more productive conversations.
Is it still a military success if Congress defunds the war Vietnam style?
That’s a military victory and a political loss. Neither invalidates the other.
- Prev
- Next

I agree with this up to a point, but it’s also clear that anyone can be tempted at any time. Who’s to say you wouldn’t cheat on your wife? You haven’t had the opportunities that Jensen has.
We don’t pick tech CEOs for their moral virtue. “We” don’t even pick tech CEOs at all. They generally pick themselves because it is extremely hard to do what Jensen Huang did and build a successful company. You and I are just watching this on TV. But the option is always there for you to try and join the ruling class yourself.
More options
Context Copy link