when 4chan failed to successfully splinter because of moot's mishandling of Gamergate.
I disagree with this, 8chan was a very successful splinter. It was an active site with a large, culturally-unique community and ongoing influence on the internet's zeitgeist. My time on 8chan was 'peak internet', for me, in that there was no censorship and a big enough, developed enough community to talk about things beyond what we'd talk about in everyday life.
It had little communities with a few hundred live users here and there that I still think about. I think any of those communities, alone, would count as an abnormally successful splinter site today.
You can see this in StackOverflow too, where the site remained strong until AI got good at which point it deserted completely, because it is faster and more efficient (and far less rudely nitpicky) at answering the average coding question than the collective of human beings.
This is something that worries me about the dead internet. There's a lot less motivation to reach out and make connections if you can just ask Claude and get a satisfactory answer on whatever obscure technical thing you want to know. I've encountered this myself - reaching out to people on the fringes on the internet is a lot harder than it was; people put much less effort into networking and community-building. So much could be done if the top dozen or so dissident techfags all logged into the same IRC server now and again and talked.
I disagree. Federation [in the sense that you mean it] is already accomplished at the web browser (or the app store) layer
Federation's value is that it solves the coordination problem. There are (or were) a whole bunch of individually-dead reddit clones out there that were meant to be 'free reddit'. Some of them had communities of a dozen increasingly-inactive users, who stopped coming because there wasn't really anything new to say. The "Network Effect" is how large social media sites stay on top even if nobody likes their leadership, and why upstarts generally fall flat.
With federation, you automatically get an active community of thousands of people that your users can talk to even if only one guy has signed up to start with.
I'm working on replacing a recently-dead BBS forum of historical significance. Rather than putting it onto an isolated website, I'm setting it up so that it seamlessly talks to Nostr and hopefully the rest of the Fediverse.
Screenshot so far: This is a normal, twitter-like Nostr client behind the scenes, and replies from other servers are automatically treated as forum posts and put in the proper places.
IMO brigading was an overstated problem. Local moderators could handle it, and it was mainly used as justification to ban subreddits on very shaky grounds. Woke sub says something unpopular, gets downvotes and hostile comments, blames whichever non-woke sub was most active at the time, admins ban it. This was before they just explicitly banned anything not left-of-center.
Moreover, comment-brigading is relatively harmless. Brigaded comments get downvoted and hidden. We don't have to accept other sites' votes, only their comments - and any node that hosts a bunch of spammers can be defederated.
I'll also say that you shouldn't worry about "radical lemmy instances". These are hugboxes for redditors who want to consider themselves special even as the main site is politically indistinguishable from theirs. They'll blacklist us immediately, and we'll never hear from them.
The long-term goal is to set things up to allow more subcommunities, similar to how subreddits work.
I think you are trying to solve a real problem - it's entirely true that a website that exists only to host a single discussion topic will vitrify, and will feel a lot less like a community besides. Part of what made Old Reddit special was that everyone was a "real person", with their entire set of interests collected in one account. The guy talking about immigration rates with you was also a welder, and a hobbyist C programmer. In contrast, everyone on each of the various offshoot forums is there because a banned community was one of their primary interests, and their activity there is distinct from their activity anywhere else.
However, I don't think adding subreddits will help. It's a small and cohesive enough community that anything any of us would want to post here is probably of interest to anyone reading the main feed. There's no influx of people that will let a really good moderator turn themotte.org/gardening into a thriving gardening community. Other Reddit offshoots have tried this and never really had much success, aside from the massive exodus around Voat that had people convinced that it could really be Reddit's successor back in the '10s. Communities.win, for example, is anchored by The_Donald, which still has thousands of active users, and its set of communities amounts to a couple of fairly inactive replacements for other subreddits that got banned.
I know it's a bit of a buzzword, but Federation is the only thing that really works here. Code is cheap nowadays; have Claude Opus 5.5 (or one of the Fable models, if you've got the $100 a month) tie Plemora into the forum, letting users talk to people from the other servers out there and letting the other servers comment in threads here. The Fediverse is full of the sort of tech-savvy, contrarian, erudite people that are our core demographic, and being able to engage with this community using a client they're already comfortable with eliminates a big source of onboarding friction. Nostr in particular has a bunch of smart-but-fanatical tech guys who will use the social media service with the best whitepaper come hell or high water.
I'm working on something of exactly this nature - a Fedi-enabled replacement for a historically-significant BBS forum that recently died, and I'd be glad to talk to site devs about it.
The internet pioneers definitely thought that "open internet" meant "interpret censorship as damage and route around it", not "the corporate censor is in a generous mood today".
In the era of pre-Pao Reddit, there was no notion of a corporate (really, government wearing the term 'private company' as a skinsuit) censor being able to do what it did. The assumption when Voat was created was that Reddit would meet the same fate as Digg, and one or more successors would inherit the entire userbase. The idea of e.g. ISPs and DDOS mitigators suddenly becoming political actors was as unthinkable as the Pentagon declaring that everyone using ARPANET had to swear allegiance to Richard Nixon or be booted.
As for Musk, I don't think he has any real 'intentions', or a master plan of any kind. He's vaguely right-libertarian, and he saw something wrong, and he tried to do something he thought would help. Same deal as Trump, really. Musk's issue as far as curation is that he has a tendency to "trust the experts" more than he should, and the "experts" told him that having a team of people trying to manually curate the algorithm was better than the pre-2016 system in which you took a pair of neural networks and taught them to map posts to users likely to enjoy them with no other restrictions.
Eliza is quick script in a language that has nothing to do with logic programming. I'm talking about things like Eurisko.
If you're genuinely interested in learning about this sort of thing, I'd encourage you to google Logic Programming, and follow a few quick tutorials on e.g. Prolog. Introducing a contradiction in the set of lemmas you give a system will indeed break it.
Do you think TheMotte has enough of a hacker community to prototype stuff like this? I'd love a browser extension that e.g. filters imageboards for posts I might find interesting or enjoyable, and it wouldn't be that hard to jury-rig. If a few other users agree, or want to build something in a vaguely similar vein, I'd be game for setting something up so we could pool our efforts.
No, if you put a paradox in one of the old logic engines, it will break. It wasn't just invented from whole cloth by Star Trek.
I think we're using different definitions of "closed". Giant platforms gobbling up small web forums is unaesthetic, but survivable as long as they have the principles that pre-Pao Reddit had. Each subreddit really was its own community, and plenty of unique cultures survived and thrived there.
In contrast, the total abandonment of impartiality on every service from social media websites to ISPs was closure. The physical world's power structure got together and decided that the internet had to die. This was hardly cheap - the internet of 2012 was a major engine of American soft power, and was directly responsible for making Western liberalism aspirational in the eyes of countless second- and third-worlders - but it was the point at which the inevitability of cyberpunk freedom broke, and it became clear that, if information is to be free, it will be because agentic 'great men' made it so by fighting against the forces that would prevent it from being so.
I think there's a strong future for imageboards provided that a few people have the agency to take the old regex filter system to its logical conclusion. I've been thinking about an extension that scrapes 4chan posts when you have a thread open, feeds them into a shared server, and has a cheap-but-decent LLM assign tags for various things users might or might not want to see, then filters the thread accordingly.
The idea is that individual users could write up their own filters, sharing popular servers and caching results, and essentially letting their custom LLMs 'curate' their feed for posts that are worth reading.
The minimum viable product is something that lets you specify a few kinds of spam you don't want to see with a sentence each, pipes posts in any thread you open to a Qwen instance running on a cheap server somewhere, and collapses anything you said you didn't want.
Gamergate was a intratribal skirmish amongst of Blues arguing about "ethics in games journalism" while what Reds who were paying attention watched on in bemusement. Imagine believing that Journalists have ethics
I don't think this is true. A lot of latent political energy was unleashed when all the little communities of discontent young men suddenly had a rallying cry. There were years of high-energy, optimistic culture on e.g. /pol/ from the influx of guys who suddenly knew they had a tribe.
Maybe it's an age thing. You felt it if you were 15-22 at the time, and it looked like kids playing around if you were 30+. the 23-29 year olds were the cool older brothers showing people the ropes and making OC.
IMO it's a good filter on whether an author is worth reading, as is the "no commenting unless you give me money" thing.
If someone sincerely believed they had a brilliant take, they'd shout it from the rooftops; they'd pay to make people see it. When I see people trying to LARP as a secret club with their subscribers, they generally have no interesting views or insights.
I do miss the regular influx of new users that we had when we were on Reddit. I understand why Zorba moved us, as I'm sure it was only a matter of time before the Admins found some pretext to ban the subreddit. Still, I do hope that if activity on this forum declines too much we give Reddit another go. I don't see any other option for attracting fresh blood.
It'd be a neat test case for something I'd been thinking about for a while - integrating a free website and a censored platform via a browser extension, such that users of the extension can post on the latter and have their posts mirrored to the former, while seeing others' posts from the former whenever they browse the latter.
With reddit bots/automod, you could take it further. Mirror posts from reddit to themotte.org, and have automod post any themotte.org replies that wouldn't be banned on reddit onto the subreddit.
I think SSC's author has changed similarly. He's unrecognizable. Went from being as open-minded as anyone to being a generic redditor who claims that cancelling elections and jailing opposition parties is far less severe than some nebulous "threat to democracy" imposed by Trump speeches.
Still, wouldn't hurt to ask the SSC mods. Maybe some still fly the old colors.
Well, "smarter" isn't really right. The whole "defeat AI with a paradox" trope comes from the previous epoch of AI, in which we thought we'd be able to feed a bunch of logical truths into something like Prolog and get a machine that could reason its way through extremely complex problems. It's an interesting history, look up "symbolic AI vs machine learning" and "eurisko".
Basically, we thought AI would be ultra-logical because that's what had worked so far. The pivot to language models was sudden and completely reshaped our expectations.
Can't help but be reminded of my own post on the subject, and of the Arctotherium article that inspired it. Some interesting discussion in the comments, there.
Anyway, what do you think? What do you think about how TheMotte has evolved over the years, what do you like about it now, what do you want to see changed, etc.
I very much feel you on preserving the "middle internet", as you call it. I think you'd really like the article linked above, even if it's a bit depressing and not as prescriptive as I'd like it to be, simply because of the sheer detail and explanatory power it provides.
To answer the core question of your post, I think that preserving this culture entails solving two problems:
-
Gathering up the scattered peoples of the open internet, and letting them talk to each other. As it is, some of them are 'hiding their power levels' on normie social media, others are on Twitter dodging shadowbans and deboosting systems, and yet others are hiding out in little enclaves like this one with populations ranging from the dozens to the thousands. Scale is vital to a thriving community; lots of good things just can't get off the ground without enough eyes, collaborators, and feedback. There's a qualitative difference between a community with 100 people and a community with 1,000, or 10,000. The odds of finding a handful of guys with the same strain of autism to build something with skyrockets.
-
Onboarding new people. 2014-16 was amazing in large part because it involved previously apolitical people, untainted by years of news cycles and anger, coming onto the scene via GG and bringing lightheartedness, agency, and optimism with them. I think a fundamental part of a happy culture is having a sizable 18-25 demo coming in, and that this is instinctual - people avoid investing in dying institutions. The closure of the internet has made organic word of mouth pipelining a lot harder (there's no more 'meme on normie subreddit' -> 'vaguely edgy subreddit via Google search for meme' -> 'source of the meme' pipeline, even as youth are more radicalized than ever). Communities that want a future will need to invest in guerilla marketing.
As for actionable advice, I'd keep things tractable and suggest the following:
-
Add some Fediverse capabilities, since LLMs have made code incredibly cheap. There are plenty of tech-savvy contrarians on there that can be talked to, and linking little sites like this into a shared ecosystem helps solve the network effect problem.
-
Try some very basic guerilla marketing stuff. A monthly sitewide contest for promoting it, for example, with a small prize pool paid in XMR. People launch promotions like postering campaigns, viral videos, and substack articles from popular accounts, and some trustworthy figure picks the most effective ones and doles out awards. A $20 prize is probably workable through crowdfunding (I'd donate) and would at least get people interested - it's surprising how much people will do when the person asking them to do it demonstrates real investment in it getting done.
or another TracingWoodgrains
I don't think people like him are especially unique - the entire pre-Trump GOP establishment seemed to be made of them. In isolation, they present as interesting contrarians, but once you see enough of them, it just feels like cynical rage/engagement bait; hanging out on the edges of generally right-leaning parts of the internet and poking at them with the same tired "ahkshully the White working class deserves it" schtick that was played-out ten years ago. There used to be similar figures targeted at the Left, but they got purged (nobody would engage with them, at best, and at worst people actively harassed them).
Incidentally, this week marks a key point in internet history. "Gamer Uprising", the surviving forum component of the edgy news site Daily Stormer, which was once one of the big countercultural nexuses on the internet and had four million unique monthly viewers, went down two days ago, probably permanently and without warning. Countless memes have outlived the website, and its cultural impact will be felt and studied for decades to come, but the dispersion of its community, whether you agree with their particular strain of edginess, is also of note.
Years ago, people generally believed some tenets of the hacker creed with the same fanaticism as they believed in the laws of physics - information wants to be free, and free communities will always spring up. This is noble, but complacent - GU could have channeled its substantial human capital (much of its userbase was composed of programmers) into keeping the site relevant, but they let it languish as an old BBforums template, and it quietly faded away.
Last week I started writing an effort post that was in part a response to @SneedNibba's post on the closure of the internet and some of the replies to @Lizzardspawn's post on the French Freezer hack only to loose it to a negligent refresh.
The website really should auto-save WIP longposts as cookies. It's one of those QoL features that's really mandatory nowadays.
there are spaces where MAGA is the norm and any claim that "woke owns the discourse" would be met with derision and possibly a ban.
Is this really true? There are little enclaves here and there, but nothing like what I'd expect from a movement that amounts to a majority of young tech-savvy men and half the country. T_D's remnant on communities.win is the biggest one I can find. It was commensurately huge in 2016, MAGA was as big on the internet as in the collective subconscious, but the total censorship of the internet seems to have returned it to universally-known-but-never-spoken-of status on much of the user-facing internet.
I've been looking around on Tor, at the "darknet", and it feels surprisingly like a ghost town. "Dread", the oft-spoken of darknet forum, has top posts with upvotes in the low dozens. There's a huge potential audience for a leet uncensored darknet cyberpunk hacker forum, but as far as I can tell, it doesn't exist yet.
I’m of the position that what Yarvin does or says should basically have nothing to do with one’s evaluation of Urbit.
It's not a matter of him discrediting the core technology, it's a matter of there being thousands of bespoke anti-censorship social media technologies that have about three active users each and an onboarding process that would take a CS freshman a full afternoon. If he were a super-celebrity that could serve as a Schelling point that coordinated people around the platform, that might (partially) solve the network effect, but he isn't.
The barrier isn’t very high, and also this can be a feature, not a bug.
This is exactly the problem. There's an implicit barrier to entry for any uncensored platform that already excludes the people we don't want. Asking anything more of potential users feels like 'entitlement' - a platform that assumes that it's automatically going to be worth going through that for. In practice, all of these platforms are competing with both each other and with the option of staying on mainstream social media sites and dodging the censors as best they can.
The platform that wins is the one that acknowledges that users aren't going to be as passionate about a whitepaper as developers are, and realizes that UX makes a qualitative difference in whether a platform lives or dies.
what are they doing to influence the outcome of the elections?
Aside from all of the recent moves that can conceivably be dismissed as having some other motivation, they penned a 24 page "letter to the American public" in which they explicitly stated that they wanted to influence the midterm elections in favor of the Democrats and that voting for them was what they wanted Americans to do.
I'm not joking, by the way, you can Google this. It's utterly baffling that that's the message they'd write to the dozen or so Americans willing to read a 24 page letter from the Iranian government in full, but it is indeed what they wrote.
If Iran cared about the US midterm elections, what exactly would Iran be doing or not doing, in your view?
What? My position is that they do seem to care, and are wrong to care.
Well do you agree that anti-Israel sentiment has grown significantly in the Democratic party even in the last few years?
Sentiment and policy outcome are two very different things. In the GOP, the populists are strong and fighty enough to occasionally force an issue they care about. In the DNC, they're either too unagentic (in the case of migrant anti-Israelism) or too thoroughly 'buckbroken' (in the case of redditor anti-Israelism) to meaningfully contest the party establishment. AOC being made to vote in favor of an Israel aid bill that was already going to pass by a massive margin is a pretty useful case study.
perhaps they are more likely to have an accurate view.
This would be more compelling if it hadn't been tested and found wanting. Indeed, Obama II was more neoconservative by many standards than Trump 1, and Biden was unambiguously more neoconservative than Trump 1. The neocons who were chased out of the GOP in 2016 were largely successful in taking over the DNC instead.
I actually suspect that some of Trump's public signaling around the midterms, particularly his statements that "we're going to end the war after the midterms," reflected not a plan to escalate, but a plan to de-escalate and sign a deal, with the midterms acting as a signal to Iran: hey you just need to make it to November without rocking the boat and then we'll give you what you want, but we can't sign that deal now because it will cost us the election. Not that anything the Trump admin says to anyone, let alone to Iran, is reliable evidence of their intent to follow through, but it seemed to me that was the signal they were trying to send.
See, this is where I object. Trump definitely knows the war is unpopular and leaving it completely, even if it involves giving Iran a de facto victory, is much less politically costly than continuing it. For the first few months, up until the MoU, he was all about getting out of it, and was willing to push back against Israel and its assets to do so. He seemed to understand very acutely that the younger cadre of his base felt very strongly about the whole "mean tweets, world peace" thing.
For some reason, after the MoU fell through because Israel wouldn't stop causing issues in Palestine, Trump seemed to give up on that and completely fall in line.
As for the institutional memory thing, you might be onto something. A bunch of boomers remembering the Carter administration, and all. I'd have thought that the Biden administration's relatively total support of Israel would dissuade them from this, though.
I heard about Urbit a long time ago, but I think it falls into the category of "uncensored service too full of itself to realize that the barrier to entry is too enormous to attract a community with anything better to do".
It doesn't help things that Yarvin kind of backed down when the Eye of Sauron started looking at him, and ran off to insist that ahkshully the true edgy dissident position is "taking the clearpill" and completely capitulating. Like, if he were an edgy hackerman that never submitted, he might have the mystique to attract people to his thing.
- Prev
- Next

I finished my Nostr bulletin board project, and put it up via Nsite's decentralized hosting service. Basically, it lets users who enjoy the BBS format seamlessly talk to the rest of Nostr.
Lunar Uprising, a successor to the long-running Daily Stormer forum, which had spent years as a Tor service.
More options
Context Copy link