site banner

Culture War Roundup for the week of October 5, 2026

This weekly roundup thread is intended for all culture war posts. 'Culture war' is vaguely defined, but it basically means controversial issues that fall along set tribal lines. Arguments over culture war issues generate a lot of heat and little light, and few deeply entrenched people ever change their minds. This thread is for voicing opinions and analyzing the state of the discussion while trying to optimize for light over heat.

Optimistically, we think that engaging with people you disagree with is worth your time, and so is being nice! Pessimistically, there are many dynamics that can lead discussions on Culture War topics to become unproductive. There's a human tendency to divide along tribal lines, praising your ingroup and vilifying your outgroup - and if you think you find it easy to criticize your ingroup, then it may be that your outgroup is not who you think it is. Extremists with opposing positions can feed off each other, highlighting each other's worst points to justify their own angry rhetoric, which becomes in turn a new example of bad behavior for the other side to highlight.

We would like to avoid these negative dynamics. Accordingly, we ask that you do not use this thread for waging the Culture War. Examples of waging the Culture War:

  • Shaming.

  • Attempting to 'build consensus' or enforce ideological conformity.

  • Making sweeping generalizations to vilify a group you dislike.

  • Recruiting for a cause.

  • Posting links that could be summarized as 'Boo outgroup!' Basically, if your content is 'Can you believe what Those People did this week?' then you should either refrain from posting, or do some very patient work to contextualize and/or steel-man the relevant viewpoint.

In general, you should argue to understand, not to win. This thread is not territory to be claimed by one group or another; indeed, the aim is to have many different viewpoints represented here. Thus, we also ask that you follow some guidelines:

  • Speak plainly. Avoid sarcasm and mockery. When disagreeing with someone, state your objections explicitly.

  • Be as precise and charitable as you can. Don't paraphrase unflatteringly.

  • Don't imply that someone said something they did not say, even if you think it follows from what they said.

  • Write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion.

On an ad hoc basis, the mods will try to compile a list of the best posts/comments from the previous week, posted in Quality Contribution threads and archived at /r/TheThread. You may nominate a comment for this list by clicking on 'report' at the bottom of the post and typing 'Actually a quality contribution' as the report reason.

2
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Something very strange is going on. Iran is negotiating its surrender. The war is over and Iran has lost.. I have been assured that the United States has destroyed Iran's ability of their proxies to project power in the Middle East.

Yet somehow, despite this war goal being accomplished and the war being over, Saudi Arabia is still being attacked by Iran's Proxies..

At least 12 people were killed and over 300 injured in a Houthi missile attack on King Khalid International Airport in Riyadh on Saturday, October 10, 2026. This marks the third strike on the facility in one week and the deadliest attack in a Gulf Arab country since the U.S.-Israeli war with Iran began in February.

In response, President Donald Trump stated the U.S. is considering joining Saudi Arabia’s military campaign against the Houthis, while the U.S. Embassy issued a security alert urging American citizens to avoid the Riyadh airport.

So to summarize, it looks like the war is expanding, Iran's proxies continue to be able to strike US allies, and Iran's proxies are escalating the conflict instead of backing down.

With early voting opening up soon for many states, what are the chances Iran has an October surprise in store for Trump? Trump has stated that the U.S. will not resume military strikes on Iran before the November 3, 2026 (midterm election). The U.S. military is deploying roughly 9,000 to 10,000 additional troops to the Middle East, including the USS Theodore Roosevelt carrier strike group and the USS Makin Island amphibious readiness group, which departed San Diego on October 4–5, 2026. This surge brings the total U.S. military presence in the region to over 60,000 personnel and establishes three aircraft carrier strike groups in the theater for the first time since April 2026.

So Iran knows that Trump wants the Iran War to quiet down before the Midterms, but he is preparing to escalate once it is over. Why would they play along with this? I believe there is a good chance they will escalate and cause Trump and Republicans political embarrassment soon. But maybe this doesn't matter, because for some reason, the Houthis don't count. So I guess everything is going according to plan. So this all could just be nothing.

With early voting opening up soon for many states, what are the chances Iran has an October surprise in store for Trump? Trump has stated that the U.S. will not resume military strikes on Iran before the November 3, 2026 (midterm election). The U.S. military is deploying roughly 9,000 to 10,000 additional troops to the Middle East, including the USS Theodore Roosevelt carrier strike group and the USS Makin Island amphibious readiness group, which departed San Diego on October 4–5, 2026. This surge brings the total U.S. military presence in the region to over 60,000 personnel and establishes three aircraft carrier strike groups in the theater for the first time since April 2026

I think it’s about zero. The people, for the most part, who oppose the war are already against Trump. They would have voted against Trump even before the war started. Democrats refusing to vote Republican is not the October surprise.

The pause is weird, because it betrays a lack of confidence in the war. If you think you can win, why wait? Why give Iran weeks to harden targets, plan counterattacks, coordinate with allies and move assets into position? If he’d never stopped, honestly Iran would be over by now because toe to toe, they cannot hope to defeat the USA militarily as we have the biggest military on the planet and well trained military forces using top military equipment. All Iran can do is mobilize terrorist militants and close the straits. Which is what will happen after the war resumes.

The pause is weird, because it betrays a lack of confidence in the war. If you think you can win, why wait?

Trump correctly believes a ground invasion is both unpopular and risky. He probably believes continued bombing will be unpopular if it doesn't win the war right away (which it won't). After the elections, he doesn't have to care.

So to summarize, it looks like the war is expanding, Iran's proxies continue to be able to strike US allies, and Iran's proxies are escalating the conflict instead of backing down.

Expanding a war is a pretty common tactic when slowly losing, historically speaking.

While the strikes between Saudi and Houthi territory are fairly well reported, what are the actual facts on the ground as far as dispossessing the Houthis of the territory gained a couple weeks back?

what are the actual facts on the ground as far as dispossessing the Houthis of the territory gained a couple weeks back?

Going very badly for the saudis by all accounts. Yemen government outlets are only publishing cope about how many kills saudi airstrikes are getting. They are claiming minor territorial gains along the coast but not any major settlements, and not making any significant advance in the mountains.

I believe there is a good chance they will escalate and cause Trump and Republicans political embarrassment soon.

I'm genuinely confused about why the Iranians (apparently) care about the midterms. Didn't we just get through four years of the Democrats letting Israel do whatever it pleased? Congressional dems have already shown that they have no intention of doing anything that might put a stop to the war, and see it as someone they don't like taking a hit to do something they wanted done anyways.

The Russians, in contrast, seem to understand now that the political establishment is pretty thoroughly neoconservative regardless of the sentiments of the American people, which is why they're willing to take cash to do something that helps the political fortunes of an administration that hasn't been very friendly with them.

I do think that either country could achieve a lot by pointing out that Lindsay Graham openly mocked Trump to the press while selling him on this war, presenting him as gullible and dismissing the voices of his supporters. Reminding him that the neoconservatives he's taking hits for despite him might make him less inclined to do as they say.

Consider that Iranian have an institutional memory of using American elections to their advantage.

Back in the early days of the Islamic Revolution, when the Mullahs had just thrown off the yoke of the Shah only to face invasion by Saddam, Jimmy Carter put an arms embargo on Iran, seeing the Islamic Revolution as a dangerous pathogen to be stopped. The Iran Hostage Crisis weakened the public's perception of Carter as president significantly during the last years of his presidency. Carter would successfully negotiate a deal for the release of the hostages during his presidency, but they would not actually be released until Reagan was inaugurated some months later. Reagan would, of course, then sell arms to Iran illegally during the Iran-Contra affair. Many have made the argument or presented some evidence that this was the result of back-channel negotiations between Reagan's foreign policy team and Iran: help us win the election by refusing to release the hostages while Carter is in office, and we'll deal kindly with you after we're in power.

Now the important thing is not whether we think that the Iranian's actions during the election were the proximate cause of Carter's electoral loss, or even whether Reagan sold arms to Iran because of some backroom deal. What matters is whether the Iranians themselves believe this version of events.

And it's not so crazy as a theory of foreign policy. Consider the famous 2012 open-mic incident in which Obama told Medvedev that he would have more flexibility to deal with some issues after the election.

As he was leaning toward Medvedev in Seoul, Obama was overheard asking for time - "particularly with missile defense" - until he is in a better position politically to resolve such issues. "I understand your message about space," replied Medvedev, who will hand over the presidency to Putin in May. "This is my last election ... After my election I have more flexibility," Obama said, expressing confidence that he would win a second term. "I will transmit this information to Vladimir," said Medvedev, Putin's protégé and long considered number two in Moscow's power structure.

It's probably fairly routine for American administrations to, sub rosa, tell international partners not to screw things up too badly before an election, after which they can take a freer hand.

I actually suspect that some of Trump's public signaling around the midterms, particularly his statements that "we're going to end the war after the midterms," reflected not a plan to escalate, but a plan to de-escalate and sign a deal, with the midterms acting as a signal to Iran: hey you just need to make it to November without rocking the boat and then we'll give you what you want, but we can't sign that deal now because it will cost us the election. Not that anything the Trump admin says to anyone, let alone to Iran, is reliable evidence of their intent to follow through, but it seemed to me that was the signal they were trying to send.

Anyway all of this is to say that the Iranians might believe, rightly or wrongly, that they can use the elections as leverage to negotiate with America on the war. They may be incorrect, but that doesn't mean they don't think it. If politiical actors were always right and never made incorrect strategic guesses, we wouldn't be in this war to begin with.

I actually suspect that some of Trump's public signaling around the midterms, particularly his statements that "we're going to end the war after the midterms," reflected not a plan to escalate, but a plan to de-escalate and sign a deal, with the midterms acting as a signal to Iran: hey you just need to make it to November without rocking the boat and then we'll give you what you want, but we can't sign that deal now because it will cost us the election. Not that anything the Trump admin says to anyone, let alone to Iran, is reliable evidence of their intent to follow through, but it seemed to me that was the signal they were trying to send.

See, this is where I object. Trump definitely knows the war is unpopular and leaving it completely, even if it involves giving Iran a de facto victory, is much less politically costly than continuing it. For the first few months, up until the MoU, he was all about getting out of it, and was willing to push back against Israel and its assets to do so. He seemed to understand very acutely that the younger cadre of his base felt very strongly about the whole "mean tweets, world peace" thing.

For some reason, after the MoU fell through because Israel wouldn't stop causing issues in Palestine, Trump seemed to give up on that and completely fall in line.


As for the institutional memory thing, you might be onto something. A bunch of boomers remembering the Carter administration, and all. I'd have thought that the Biden administration's relatively total support of Israel would dissuade them from this, though.

One view would be that Iran, Israel, and Russia all have intelligence agencies, an inside view on diplomatic processes, and a ton of skin in the game, whereas the average American media consumer is mostly interested in tribal signaling. So, if they are behaving as if there is more of a difference between the Democratic and Republican parties than you think there is, perhaps they are more likely to have an accurate view.

perhaps they are more likely to have an accurate view.

This would be more compelling if it hadn't been tested and found wanting. Indeed, Obama II was more neoconservative by many standards than Trump 1, and Biden was unambiguously more neoconservative than Trump 1. The neocons who were chased out of the GOP in 2016 were largely successful in taking over the DNC instead.

I'm genuinely confused about why the Iranians (apparently) care about the midterms.

The goal for Iran is to establish that attacking them is a mistake which will cost the ruling party their majority.

From where I stand, this is very sound reasoning with regard to their long-term interests. They correctly model both US parties as being more interested in clinging to power than following the long term interests of the US (whatever these may be) in foreign policy.

If Trump had known how messy his special military operation would get, he would not have attacked Iran. (Unless Bibi has way more dirt on him than I think.)

While it was psychologically important for Trump to negotiate a better deal with Iran than Obama's deal, he will not sacrifice his presidency on the alter of keeping Iran from having nukes. The plan was clearly to bomb Iran, hopefully get a regime change, or at least shock and awe them enough that they will agree to terms which Trump can easily sell as a victory. "Look at me, I am a decisive Republican president who gets shit done, not some pussyfoot Democrat who is too chickenshit to bomb our enemies in case the bombs have a disparate impact on minorities." Only it turned out that Obama had good reasons not to go to war with Iran -- squeamishness about bombing Muslims was certainly no fault of his.

It is also in the short-term interests of Iran to get the Democrats back into power. They do not own the war, and they can probably concede the strait to Iran without the Republicans making a stink. By contrast, Trump needs the war to continue until he gets out something which he can sell as a victory or he dies, whatever happens first.


Traditionally, both the Republicans and the Democrats have been against a Russian hegemony, but Trump was always lukewarm in his support of Ukraine. Presumably because he thought him negotiating a peace deal would win him the Nobel, but also MAGA is politically closer to Russia than to Western Europe. Besides, while the Western leaders treat him with disdain just because he threatened to end the Persian civilization, the non-democratic leaders take him as serious as anyone.

The goal for Iran is to establish that attacking them is a mistake which will cost the ruling party their majority.

In so far as psychoanalysing a regime with multiple decision-makers makes sense, I think there is a much simpler explanation. Trump presents his regime more generally as personal (whether or not you think it is), and in particular has presented the US decision to attack Iran as a decision that he took personally because the rest of the US elite was too weak. For Khamenei Jr or whoever else is making the decisions in Iran to treat the conflict as being with Trump personally makes sense, and in that case "We want to hurt Trump personally" is a good and sufficient reasons for adjusting tactics around the mid-terms.

While it was psychologically important for Trump to negotiate a better deal with Iran than Obama's deal, he will not sacrifice his presidency on the alter of keeping Iran from having nukes. The plan was clearly to bomb Iran, hopefully get a regime change, ...

I think Trump thought that Mossad had a cunning plan to make a regime change happen. I am struggling at work at the moment and we have also just acquired two rescue cats, so I don't know if my planned effortpost on this point will ever happen.

The goal for Iran is to establish that attacking them is a mistake which will cost the ruling party their majority.

This doesn't strike me as plausible. The GOP establishment doesn't care in the slightest about losing the midterms, and, even before the war, it seemed to be actively trying to throw them. They could've passed any number of bills, including voter ID, that would've motivated supporters and demoralized opponents, but instead they passed a left-leaning housing bill and blocked Trump from making recess appointments.

The neocons who convinced Trump to engage in this war are thrilled with the outcome. They plan to blame the midterms on immigration enforcement and see if they can get an amnesty on top of everything else.

While it was psychologically important for Trump to negotiate a better deal with Iran than Obama's deal, he will not sacrifice his presidency on the alter of keeping Iran from having nukes. The plan was clearly to bomb Iran, hopefully get a regime change, or at least shock and awe them enough that they will agree to terms which Trump can easily sell as a victory.

By contrast, Trump needs the war to continue until he gets out something which he can sell as a victory or he dies, whatever happens first.

I think it's pretty clear that he was talked into the war on that pretense, and then, up until the MoU, it seemed very clear that he was intent on getting out of it. I defended him quite a bit on that point; he'd made a bad decision and trusted people he shouldn't have, but he seemed appropriately upset with Israel and wanted to withdraw.

After Israel sabotaged the MoU, though, he doesn't seem to be trying anymore. As far as I can tell, he's just endlessly repeating the "Iran's weeks away from a nuke" line that AIPAC's been peddling since decades before I was born. The gasoline deal indicated that he does personally care about the midterms, but I think the neoconservative entryists are running the asylum at this point, and the beliefs of Trump himself don't appear to have any bearing on the Iran war's execution at all. Given what the Biden admin was like, I don't think the Dems would be any different, especially seeing as the odds of a competitive Republican candidate ever emerging again shrink by the day.

As the saying goes, congressional Republicans are openly pro-Israel and not-so-secretly gay, congressional Democrats are openly gay and not-so-secretly pro-Israel.

The GOP establishment doesn't care in the slightest about losing the midterms, and, even before the war, it seemed to be actively trying to throw them. They could've passed any number of bills, including voter ID, that would've motivated supporters and demoralized opponents, but instead they passed a left-leaning housing bill and blocked Trump from making recess appointments.

I think the marginal Republican senators not voting for Trump's policies are retiring senators who were successfully primaried by MAGA (Cassidy, Cornyn), too chicken to contest a primary against MAGA (Tillis), or undead (McConnell). All of these guys have reasons for their recalcitrance which do not apply to the GOPe as a whole. "I'm going to use my lame duck vote to push back against the guy who ended my political career" may be an ignoble motive, but it is not exactly a surprising one.

While it was psychologically important for Trump to negotiate a better deal with Iran than Obama's deal, he will not sacrifice his presidency on the alter of keeping Iran from having nukes.

I honestly think he would, under my "Boomer Common Sense" model of Trump. "Sacrificing the presidency" is talk for nerds writing papers in college. It's entirely the wrong framing. Do you, or do you not, act to stop an avowed mortal enemy that is currently much weaker than you from getting the city-destroying superweapon?

Yeah. Duh. Common fucking sense. Even arguing about it is the province of bloodless dorks and proof of why they should never have any real power.

I understand that framing may be difficult to process for someone who has contorted themselves into pretending that "Western leaders" have only come to disdain Trump since Iran, but I think it explains his actions much better than either the "8-D Chess" stuff MAGA used to argue or whatever iteration of "screaming chicken dumb dumb poopy pants" projection that the libs are on these days.

I honestly think he would, under my "Boomer Common Sense" model of Trump. "Sacrificing the presidency" is talk for nerds writing papers in college. It's entirely the wrong framing. Do you, or do you not, act to stop an avowed mortal enemy that is currently much weaker than you from getting the city-destroying superweapon?

This might hold up if Trump hadn't claimed to have obliterated the city-destroying superweapon program several months prior with Midnight Hammer.

I don't see how that counters my position at all. I didn't say Trump's Boomer Common Sense was infallible, just that it's a more reliable predictor his actions than "cartoon super genius" or "cartoon baby villain".

Why would this change anything? The Iranian regime obviously wants Nuclear weapons. Until they are completely destroyed or have changed their strategic calculus, every action to destroy or delay their nuclear capability is just mowing the grass.

I brush my teeth twice a day every day. The fact that I have to keep doing it doesn’t mean it’s not important or I don’t actually ‘mean it’.

Not every military action will be decisive. Not even a minority of them.

One of my favorite books on military strategy is “The Grand Strategy of the Byzantine Empire” by Luttwak and a running theme is the Byzantines dealing with the same nomadic tribes over and over again, bribing them to attack each other or annihilating one army while holding another one at bay.

There currently exist some permanent, existential enemies of the US and the Islamic Republic is certainly one of them, and they’ve proven themselves in the regard over and over again since 1979.

The fact that Israel benefits from this has acted basically just as a derangement of the plain, obvious truth the Islamic Republic is anti-American by nature.

Brushing your teeth every day, applied to Iran's nuclear ambitions, would mean that we have to go bomb a uranium deposit or something every few years. Fine, whatever.

Trump seems to be attempting to extract a single tooth in the belief that it will remove the chance of cavities in all our other Iranian teeth, which will not work and is a pretty deranged dental philosophy.

Destruction of the Iranian regime would be the tooth extraction in this analogy, yes. Or filling a cavity. This seems basically precise.

You still have to brush your teeth in this analogy.

Using America’s military resources to quash the plans and designs of America’s enemies on a regular basis is good military hygiene. If you have to repeat it multiple times it doesn’t mean you’ve failed, if you think that you’ve failed to understand a huge portion of the spectrum of military action.

This has happened basically since time immemorial.

As someone generally against nation building / neoconservatism, Iraq & Afghanistan really mind-raped a lot of westerners into thinking every military action in the greater Middle East is either some expression of goy-inservitude or some hopeless forever war secretly backed by corporations.

This, plus World War 2 has clouded the mind of many westerners to think that the only good use of military is 100% non ambiguous decisive victory against an aggressive peer opponent.

Sometimes you really can just kill a bunch of people and knock your enemies down a peg. It’s super Lindy.

Yes. Grandparent is espousing the extremely common fallacy that "anything which is not a permanent fix is not worth doing".

Most commonly seen in opponents of taking Ozempic.

"But if you stop taking it you'll gain the weight back".

"Okay, but what if I don't stop taking it".

ChatGPT tells me closest match is the Nirvana Fallacy.

Why would this change anything? The Iranian regime obviously wants Nuclear weapons. Until they are completely destroyed or have changed their strategic calculus, every action to destroy or delay their nuclear capability is just mowing the grass.

I brush my teeth twice a day every day. The fact that I have to keep doing it doesn’t mean it’s not important or I don’t actually ‘mean it’.

Not every military action will be decisive. Not even a minority of them.

The term Trump used for the Iranian nuclear program after Midnight Hammer was "obliterated". Not "damaged", "delayed" or "set back": "obliterated". Perhaps English is your second or third language but by using the term "obliterated" Trump indicated that he thought that Midnight Hammer was, in fact, decisive. Unfortunately he left no room for this brand of copium.

You’re telling me, at this point in your life you are surprised when a politician exaggerates for effect? How old are you?

Also. If I obliterate something, does that mean that it can never, ever be resumed in any way in another form, or another place? Or that obliteration removes even the desire that produced the action in the first place?

Is English not your first language?

This isn’t copium. A lot of people have deranged themselves into being unable to understand the simple reality of things, disguising their sophistry as sophistication.

You and @VIM have both been temp banned before for this kind of petty sniping. Stop it. Argue without the snide, condescending pot shots.

Also. If I obliterate something, does that mean that it can never, ever be resumed in any way in another form, or another place? Or that obliteration removes even the desire that produced the action in the first place?

I think it implies a setback much longer than the eight months between the 2025 and 2026 bombings. If it only took eight months between the nuclear program being obliterated and the Iranians needing to be bombed before they get nuclear ICBMs it sounds like the first bombing didn't work very well, it sounds like a minor setback to Iran at most. Maybe that makes the war a good idea! But it raises the question of what the 2025 attack actually did and how the 2026 one will be different.

More comments

You’re telling me, at this point in your life you are surprised when a politician exaggerates for effect? How old are you?

New levels of cynicism unlocked. You're upset that a politician lied? Psh.

More comments

You would want to punish whichever party started the war even if both parties were equally likely to have started the war; if you cause either party to lose then it will result in a “lesson” about instigating conflict even 50 or 100 years down the road. Unlike the Trump admin, I think the Iranian leaders actually care about the longterm good of their particular people / nation, so they consider how to secure benefits for their group long after they are individually gone, as opposed to falling into the nihilistic “we are all going to die anyway” boomer-death-spiral ideology (something I also hear from the boomers in my own life). But with that said, the Republicans have tied themselves at the neck to Israel, so Iran has a clear interest in making them lose for this reason alone apart from concerns about war continuation; there’s more than just the war per se, there’s “I don’t want America to give a bajillion bombs to Israel for free” which is the Republican plan.

My point is that the parties are equally beholden to Israel, which is very different from being equally likely to have started the war. If they were just both ideologically neoconservative, you could train them to be anti-war that way, but it's well established that they care more about pleasing Israel than they do about winning elections, so the midterms are a nonentity to them.

They would rather have their pro-Israel opposition in charge of Congress than enact a not-pro-Israel policy themselves.

I'm genuinely confused about why the Iranians (apparently) care about the midterms. Didn't we just get through four years of the Democrats letting Israel do whatever it pleased?

My sense is that there is growing anti-Israel sentiment in the Democratic Party. If I were Iran's current leadership, I would want more Democrats in power in the US. Possibly it's won't help the situation, but I think Iran's leadership is pretty desperate at this point.

I don't think either of those things make much sense. If Iran were desperate, they'd probably be directing their appeals to the disillusioned young men of the country who might be able to make something happen, rather than to Karen (43 ans) who would've voted blue anyways. The anti-Israel Dems have proven themselves pretty toothless on a very consistent basis, to the point where Trump's support of Israel has met more intra-party opposition than Biden's.

Keep in mind that everyone insisting Iran's desperate and on the brink of collapse has been insisting exactly that since the first week of the war. My best guess is that the messaging is the product of some high-level leader's daft, out-of-touch cousin who got appointed Secretary of American PR because he's too incompetent to put anywhere else.

If Iran were desperate, they'd probably be directing their appeals to the disillusioned young men of the country who might be able to make something happen, rather than to Karen (43 ans) who would've voted blue anyways

If Iran cared about the US midterm elections, what exactly would Iran be doing or not doing, in your view?

The anti-Israel Dems have proven themselves pretty toothless on a very consistent basis,

Well do you agree that anti-Israel sentiment has grown significantly in the Democratic party even in the last few years?

Keep in mind that everyone insisting Iran's desperate and on the brink of collapse has been insisting exactly that since the first week of the war.

I'm not sure what your point is here. I'm certainly not trying to argue that Iran is on the brink of collapse.

If Iran cared about the US midterm elections, what exactly would Iran be doing or not doing, in your view?

What? My position is that they do seem to care, and are wrong to care.

Well do you agree that anti-Israel sentiment has grown significantly in the Democratic party even in the last few years?

Sentiment and policy outcome are two very different things. In the GOP, the populists are strong and fighty enough to occasionally force an issue they care about. In the DNC, they're either too unagentic (in the case of migrant anti-Israelism) or too thoroughly 'buckbroken' (in the case of redditor anti-Israelism) to meaningfully contest the party establishment. AOC being made to vote in favor of an Israel aid bill that was already going to pass by a massive margin is a pretty useful case study.

My position is that they do seem to care, and are wrong to care.

Ok, and in your view, what are they doing to influence the outcome of the elections? And what would they do differently if they were desperate?

Sentiment and policy outcome are two very different things. In the GOP, the populists are strong and fighty enough to occasionally force an issue they care about. In the DNC, they're either too unagentic (in the case of migrant anti-Israelism) or too thoroughly 'buckbroken' (in the case of redditor anti-Israelism) to meaningfully contest the party establishment. AOC being made to vote in favor of an Israel aid bill that was already going to pass by a massive margin is a pretty useful case study.

I guess that means your answer is "yes"?

what are they doing to influence the outcome of the elections?

Aside from all of the recent moves that can conceivably be dismissed as having some other motivation, they penned a 24 page "letter to the American public" in which they explicitly stated that they wanted to influence the midterm elections in favor of the Democrats and that voting for them was what they wanted Americans to do.

I'm not joking, by the way, you can Google this. It's utterly baffling that that's the message they'd write to the dozen or so Americans willing to read a 24 page letter from the Iranian government in full, but it is indeed what they wrote.

Aside from all of the recent moves that can conceivably be dismissed as having some other motivation, they penned a 24 page "letter to the American public" in which they explicitly stated that they wanted to influence the midterm elections in favor of the Democrats and that voting for them was what they wanted Americans to do.

I'm not joking, by the way, you can Google this. It's utterly baffling that that's the message they'd write to the dozen or so Americans willing to read a 24 page letter from the Iranian government in full, but it is indeed what they wrote.

Well you don't seem to deny that as of late there has been growing anti-Israel sentiment in the Democratic party. Nor do you seem to deny that the Iranian leadership is desperate. (Not desperate in the sense of being on the brink of collapse, but desperate in the sense of being extremely squeezed financially.) Those two facts offer a reasonably good explanation for this letter you cite.

More comments

Yet somehow, despite this war goal being accomplished and the war being over, Saudi Arabia is still being attacked by Iran's Proxies..

I have to ask- how competently do you believe this characterizes the situation?

The Saudi-Huthi conflict was in a pause during the recent year, and was a non-factor for the US-Iran conflict which both Saudis and Huthis largely stayed out of. It re-ignited post-MOU when the Saudis tried to block an Iranian flight from landing in Huthi-controlled territory by bombing an airstrip, which was either responded to or provoked to justify a retaliation depending on who you ask. In the last week(s), the Huthis and Saudis have had dueling offensives, with significant increases in missile and airstrikes as the southern front shifts to and fro.

Saudi Arabia and the Huthis have a separate conflict independent not only of the US-Iran war, but predating the Huthi-Iran alliance. Saudi is not 'still' being attacked by Iran's Huthi proxy as a continuation of the US-Iran war because Saudi was not attacked by the Huthis during the US-Iran war in the first place. And also calling the Huthi's an Iranian proxy is wildly misleading of the dynamic. The American war goals in the US-Iran war are orthogonal to the resumption of the Saudi-Huthi conflict, because the war-ending effort of the MOU had nothing in particular too say about the Saudi-Huthi conflict, unlike other Iranian proxies active at the time, and the Huthi-Saudi conflict predates the US-Iran war by a decade.

I get that Shakes' Trumpian triumphalism can be annoying, but this is the sort of pretty bad reading of regional dynamics that gives him more than a bit of a leg to stand. By trying to conflate a separate (and pre-existing) conflict into a rhetorical cudgel regarding the conflict you want to contest the characterization off, you're just giving Shakes a lot to (correctly) reject, and in the process letting him use (well justified) rebuttals to paint the counter-picture that annoys you.

  • Trump has completely given up on “tanker for tanker”

  • Trump has completely given up on striking anywhere in Iran, for weeks apparently, even as Iran launches volleys of drones and missiles daily

  • Iran “remains well-stocked with ballistic missiles and some anti-ship weapons, and can quickly add more”, while receiving new armaments from Russia, and we should assume Russia has a desire to embarrass their #1 geopolitical rival who helped get them into the Ukraine kurfuffle

  • the fire rises upon the namesake of Ahura Mazda: Iran’s strikes are causing more severe damage, and their range of attacks grows larger

  • Iran has struck a bare minimum of 15 vessels in two weeks, could be much more than that but they stagger the reporting

  • sailors are being offered 4-6x normal wages for crossing the strait, indicating serious risks to life or limb (why would any sailor care if the vessel were merely struck? That would mean less work and command a lower wage. How much would a third world mariner risk to make 6x wages?)

  • As of October 4th, known Iranian route crossings rose from 23.2% to 29.9%; no vessels crossed via the Omani Route; the rest were dark transit / unknown. (Why does no one talk about what a big chunk of ships use the Iranian route?)

  • Vessel crossings in total fell past few days; October 8th was the lowest number of crossings in two months

  • Kpler’s head of geopolitical risk speculates that the Arabs are paying Iran to get their crude out. They are paying the toll.

  • Americans left Iraq without disarming the Shia militias, which was part of their original deal with the Iraqi government for their condition of leaving.

Are we winning yet?

Iran “remains well-stocked with ballistic missiles and some anti-ship weapons, and can quickly add more”, while receiving new armaments from Russia, and we should assume Russia has a desire to embarrass their #1 geopolitical rival who helped get them into the Ukraine kurfuffle

That article seems to be pretty biased. They interviewed some anonymous "officials," and found one to say that particular quote. The others, presumably, disagree, as do pretty much everyone who's gone on the records to talk about it publicly. (Of course they still have some missiles and drones, but it's odd to think that they have some infinite supply of missiles, or that they've suffered no damage from all the bombing. And Russia isn't exactly swimming in excess missile capacity these days. Forget about "embarassing their geopolitica rival," they're busy fighting for their survival.

How much would a third world mariner risk to make 6x wages?

tanker captains are earning $100,000 plus a $50,000 per-trip bonus to transit the strait.

Forget third-worlders. I'd take that job for that pay. Let the bombs come.

Are we winning yet?

I think if we were to see a quick resolution in a way that was favorable we'd probably expect to see oil prices that were low both in the spot market but in the futures market as well. (Or at the very least, a much steeper term structure.) As it stands if I want to get 1000 barrels of crude in December, it'd cost about $90.50/bbl. If I want it in August, it still would cost roughly $81/bbl or so. (Eyeballing the futures for WTI Crude Oil.)

Before the war, we were trading at around $70 or so. The futures that has that price roughly is around sometime in mid-2028. Now these prices move a lot and are subject to drop a lot on some headline but even that effect is becoming muted as Trump decides to declare victory every week or so.

Are we winning yet?

Yes, we are.

It's hard to overstate how little this matters for the midterms. Saudi Arabia? The Houthis? To the extent that Americans know about these things at all, they accurately identify them as distant foreigners whose strange and violent customs are entirely alien to our own experience.

The Iran War? Also a nothingburger. Unless American GI's start getting sent home in bodybags, and they very much aren't, it just doesn't matter. We can keep this up forever and it doesn't even move the needle. Gas isn't expensive, except for diesel, and that is more related to what's happening in Russia. Not that voters even know or care.

And of course an October surprise would be very much good for Trump just as every other attack from Pearl Harbor to 9/11 has been good for the incumbent.

The midterm election will be decided based on vibes and turnout. Mundane things like rules for mail in ballots and early in person voting matter a lot. The Iran War does not. Who is even being swayed? What are you going to do, vote for the party of gender transitions and open borders because of a foreign conflict that has killed, checks notes, 21 service members? There are much bigger issues at stake, and everyone has already made up there mind. Both parties have a hard floor and a hard ceiling and rely mostly on elderly voters and ethnic voting blocs.

The internet is not the real world.

Gas isn't expensive,

Where I am, gas is about $1 more expensive than before. That adds up to a massive, devastating cost of $50 per month in gas expenses. Whatever will we do???

But in all seriousness it's all about vibes and people don't like to see number go up. The egg shortage is over. But the beef shortage is not. People will forget the one that ended and only remember the current crisis.

In all practicality for people who eat beef often, the beef shortage likely affects cost of living more than fuel prices right now.

For some reason people are weirdly sensitive to gas prices, much more than they rationally should. I think because it's a big, specific number that you're constantly seeing whenever you drive near a gas station. You'll hear people talk about buying a brand new hybrid or electric car to "save on gas," even though there's no way the gas savings could ever add up to the cost of the new car.

I dunno, I checking quickly with AI and at current average prices, a Chevy Bolt (one of the cheapest new EVs, with the Leaf) without any subsidy will beat a Hyundai Venue (cheapest new car in the US) at around 71 000 miles, 131 000 miles at the average of the last 10 years. Seems quite realistic both cars would reach that. EVs also have less maintenance costs too.

Hmm, how is it doing that calculation? 100,000 miles at 25mpg is 4000 gallons. At $5 per gallon (rough average) that's still just $20,000, and a bolt costs $30000 new. Might work in california or Europe, or if you get a used Bolt though.

MSRP of a Bolt is 29000$USD, MSRP of a Venue is 20500$USD, so the Bolt has to save you 8500$ of fuel to be saving you any money net over getting cheapest new gas car sold in the US. Current average gas price in the US is 4.34$ a gallon. So you'd have to burn ~1958 gallons to cover the price difference. And the Venue gets 31 MPG, so you'd burn that much in about 60 714 miles. So assuming free electricity, that's how many miles you'd have to drive either for the Bolt to start being cheaper.

NOT assuming free electricity, average price of a kWh in the US is 18.31 cents. The Bolt 2026 gets about 4 miles per kWh, so over those 60714 miles the Bolt will have cost 2779$ in electricity. I can't be bothered in graphing it myself to find where the Venue's cost overtakes the Bolt, but I asked AI to chart it and it found it was a bit over 90k miles.

You'll hear people talk about buying a brand new hybrid or electric car to "save on gas," even though there's no way the gas savings could ever add up to the cost of the new car.

My dad actually did that once: compared the cost of gas with his SUV vs. the cost of gas+payments on a hybrid. Came out in favour of the latter. Granted, that was largely due to him having a sizeable commute at the time, and your point probably does hold true for most people.

That must be a really long commute on a very gas-intensive car, if the cost of payments on a new car still made the hybrid a savings. Could be possible for some people, but yeah in general it doesn't work out.

I recall it being over an hour (not counting traffic), and the other vehicle option was a Mercury Mountaineer. Call it 15-20 MPG?

It depends on the car (the difference in price used to be much greater than it is now) and the location of the commute (pure-ICE mileage has gotten pretty good outside of stop-and-go driving) and on the future of gas prices too. My daughter picked out a hybrid for environmentalist reasons but I was surprised to see (even pre-bombing-Iran) that, if gas prices don't drop, the break-even point would be under 50k miles in. That would actually have been a reasonable investment if not for the opportunity cost vs the stock market going wild during the past few years.

On the other hand, I have a friend with a hybrid who made the same calculation during a gas price peak pre-fracking. Gas prices did drop. For a long time.

There's also auto work to consider. On average hybrids now are a little cheaper to maintain thanks to less engine and brake wear, but more expensive repairs means that one bad accident or post-warranty breakdown could put her back in the red there.

That adds up to a massive, devastating cost of $50 per month in gas expenses. Whatever will we do???

I've said this before, but this rhymes very closely with Democrats' Biden era refrain "inflation is fake, and even if it's real the goddamn voters should shut up and recognize it's for a good cause."

I feel like gas is a bit different from inflation in the general understanding. Gas prices are a thing that fluctuates. It gets higher in the summer, or for geopolitics bullshit, but it can also come back down. Gas prices are a thing that is capable of getting better. OTOH, everyone understands that "inflation" means "everything is now more expensive forever".

An understandable argument but inflation levels are far below (like half) the Biden era peak. It's true inflation is elevated in 2026 compared to 2025 but by a small amount.

By vibes this seems about correct, as I have not personally seen consumer prices rise significantly besides the consistently high beef prices.

as I have not personally seen consumer prices rise significantly

The problem is that in the average joe's mind, they expect that in a good or average economy, prices would go "back down" to what they've anchored as "normal prices", not that they will "only slightly rise" from what they consider an already abnormally elevated price. I think MadMonzer's evaluation is right, the sticker shock of seeing the elevated prices after COVID is what broke people's perspective of what a normal economy looks like. During COVID people expected economic disruption, so they gave higher prices a pass, but they didn't expect those prices to stick and then when you pile on the loss of productivity and increased government spending...

The vibe now is that Trump does not give a **** about the cost of living, because he is doing highly visible things that both economically literate Republicans and MSM business/finance/economics talking heads expect to raise consumer prices. (Tariffs, Iran, above a certain IQ level the attacks on the Fed and the calls for tax cuts and spending increases). The lesson of 2024 is that that hurts more at the ballot box than the difference between 2% and 4% CPI inflation. Biden's problem in 2024 was that - whatever was driving voter concern about the cost of living, probably the sticker shock as people started doing things again at post-pandemic inflated prices - his response was to signal that he didn't give a **** by telling voters that the official numbers were benign and they should stop worrying.

Cost of living is much better now than it was under Biden. Inflation is down, GDP is up, wages are up.

I remember after the election much gloating that egg prices would never come down and that "Cost of Living" was a dogwhistle to fool swing voters that would be exposed as Trump would fail to do anything about it. Eggs are $1-$2 a dozen now at my Chinese grocery store, $5-$6 a dozen for the fancy pasture-raised ones. I never saw anyone admit they were wrong, eggs just quietly stopped being a measure of "Cost of Living" and the rhetorical goalposts shifted.

The background to the point I am making is that all the standard objective indicators of economic welfare for ordinary Americans, including CPI inflation, have been benign since about 2022, with not much to choose between the late-Biden and early-Trump economies unless you own Nvidia stock. (And far better in the US than in other 1st-world countries). But ordinary Americans weren't feeling it under Biden, and aren't feeling it now. "Hard-working middle-class Americans don't have nice things any more because the rich men north of Richmond took them away" is still an effective emotional appeal to the median voter, whether true or not.

From outside the US, where I can see the statistics but not the vibes, it looks like a temper tantrum by entitled voters. And Biden acted and Trump acts like they see it that way to, and the voters are punishing them for it.

In both 2024 and 2026, if you ask low-information swing voters what the most important election issue is they say "cost of living" or something similar, they think (correctly) that the incumbent President doesn't care, and they are planning to vote against his party.

I think it was somewhat worse in the Biden era though because there was the perception that progressives were seeing elevated prices as a way to achieve ideological goals opposed by the masses. For instances, progressives are, at least those I know, almost happy about elevated beef prices because they didn't think we should have been eating that much beef to begin with, that the low prices before were not capturing the environmental externalities of it. Same with single family home ownership. At least Trump's disregard for the economy is in service of attempting to achieve geopolitical goals, which yes, will depend on whether he achieves them, but it's not against the wishes of average americans who do not want to eat ze bugs and live in ze pod but probably do want to beat or diminish America's enemies abroad, although not necessarily at the price of increases in the cost of living.

Everything you get at the store also uses gasoline for transportation, so higher prices puts a direct inflationary pressure on basically every physical product. These effects will not be seen immediately as prices tend to increase more smoothly, but they will happen overtime just like with the tariffs.

Freight is like 5% of cogs at retail, and in the US the majority of cost for freight is in labor not capital or fuel. So even if fuel costs doubled the price at the store will barely budge.

This is different in countries with a lower cost of labor, where fuel is most of the cost of transpirtarion, but this is not the case in the United States.

Honestly the flood of millions of illegal Indians into the trucking industry did much more to move freight costs than fuel did.

Technically, it most likely uses diesel-fuel, which has gone up even more.

And whose high price is more about Russian refineries being hit by Ukraine than what's happening in Iran.

If this were true, it would have been reflected in prices for Heating Oil. It's not. They were priced at about $2.50/gallon before the war (generously), spiked up significantly after attacks, never recovered, and it is currently priced at about $4.60.

Voters are, shall we say, not particularly sophisticated in their evaluation of the causes of things that hurt their quality of life. It's probably even optimistic to think they'd confuse Ukraine-induced issues with Iran-induced issues; mostly, it's price go up, therefore I throw the bums out.

Yes, it's all very dumb. Nevertheless inflation is 3% and they didn't throw the bums out in 2022 when CPI was 9%.

The modal voter, a boomer, is doing just fine.

The difference is control of the narrative. It rests, as always, with the Democrats.

Trump looks even more impotent if the reason he's about to lose Congress is because he can't restrain the country entirely dependent on American support from blowing up the one asset that hurts him politically

Yeah it’s not great. That’s why Trump signed the deal to import Russian diesel after Zelenskyy repeatedly refused to stop bombing Russian refineries when asked. Worst client state ever.

Ukraine isn't a client state- they get weapons from all sorts of countries(Turkey, the USA, Poland, etc) to continue a war that they fully intend to keep fighting until their entire male population is dead or Russia gives up.

Saudi Arabia is still being attacked by Iran's Proxies..

While it's true that the anti-government forces in Yemen are supported by Iran, that conflict would continue even if Iran magically poofed out of existence.

President Donald Trump stated the U.S. is considering joining Saudi Arabia’s military campaign against the Houthis

He considers a lot of things and does fuck all for many of the time. In fact Trump even says he will do something many times and still does fuck all, so saying he'll consider something is truly a nothingburger.

what are the chances Iran has an October surprise in store for Trump

Very low according to polymarket. Maybe escalation of attacks against shipping but not by that much.

Why would they play along with this? I believe there is a good chance they will escalate

Why wouldn't they escalate in all the previous months? It's clear that the retarded tit-for-tat strikes of previous months have been a pain in the ass for both sides, and Iran would rather chill in the current standoff. While there's a chance Trump will escalate in the coming months, there's also a massive chance that Trump will pussy out like he's done countless times before, and Iran seems to like those odds.

the Houthis don't count

The Houthis have repeatedly showed willingness to make peace with the United States. It's true that their recent attacks are not in the US's best interests, but they're clearly targeted at KSA and while the Houthis have the capacity to disrupt far more than they have done so far, they have chosen not to use that capability.

On the other hand Iran got a peace deal with quite favorable concessions from the USA but decided they still want to blow stuff up.

That’s a good point on Iran thinking he might just do another TACO. But if they think he may attack after the midterms, then their best strategy imo is to kick it off early and embarrass Trump and ensure a historic defeat. Making attacking them a political suicide is in their best interest. But maybe their intelligence thinks they have done enough. Interesting on the Polymarket odds. That makes me lower my estimate. I hadn’t seen those.

Historic defeat?

This is ridiculous hyperbole. Iran is incapable of large scale military action. If you were to plot US military deaths per month on a graph you wouldn’t even be able to see this conflict from the background noise of training accidents and heart attacks.

This conflict is just a complete nothing for the US.

It is however, existential for Iran’s junta. Don’t be surprised if we see some, um, leadership changes in early November.

I can't comment on how @Clavicular meant that, but personally I parsed it as "historic defeat at the ballot box".

Oh I suppose that’s what he meant. I think he will be disappointed there too. “Iran wants us to win” would be a very bad campaign indeed for the Democrats. If Iran kills Americans to get Democrats elected, it will backfire. There’s already at least one very winnable Senate seat they could lose because of a terrorist sympathizer candidate.

But if they think he may attack after the midterms, then their best strategy imo is to kick it off early and embarrass Trump and ensure a historic defeat.

I think this is correct, but I am not sure they have any real ability to do that. The best way to do it would be to hit US ships or aircraft on the ground, but Iran has proven incapable of hitting US warships, and we might be moving our aircraft back as well to make them harder to hit.

I think it's also true that if they did this, it would give Trump better political leverage to play against a Democratic Congress if he wanted to continue the war.

If the war was being won, or even if Trump perceived the war was being won, then wouldn't he be making more extravagant demands too? At the start he was Truthing that only someone he chose or favoured could be president of Iran or else they'd keep up the assassination campaign (this was back in the regime change phase of the war, quite early on).

He's not doing that right now.

Instead of bullying Europe into releasing more diesel from their reserves or granting sanctions relief to Russia, he'd be trying to threaten or harass Iran more to capitalize on the victory. He'd be demanding money or oil from them under threat from bombing (since they don't have any air defences or ability to strike back, right?)

Trump is hardly likely to develop a magnanimous streak before a beaten opponent he routinely rails against and hates.

Surely if the US was winning or had won the war, they'd be moving back in and rebuilding the 5th fleet headquarters in Bahrain, sitting ships right in the straits to show control and allow the 200+ ships waiting around there to navigate freely. There wouldn't be any tankers being attacked, apparently 16 were in the last 2 weeks:

https://x.com/NoamRaydan/status/2109043440633946336

I don’t actually think the war was over. I was linking to a comment that had said it was 100% over.

I know, I agree with you. In retrospect I should've made that more clear.

Life is full of disappointments. Trump again did not win the Peace Nobel, and appears visibly upset:

“The United States of America, represented by me as your president, should have received the Nobel peace prize, but didn’t. And this is an indelible stain on the country of Norway, and those people that made such a disgraceful and embarrassing decision,” Trump said.

I am a bit surprised that Trump was surprised. If you told me that he would win next year's Nobel prize, my best guess would be that he had occupied Oslo and forced them to give him a Nobel at gunpoint.

So far, there have been two Norwegian lawmakers who have nominated Trump over the years, out of a parliament of 169. The parliament determines the Nobel committee, generally in proportion to their party strengths. Three of the five members will be replaced at the end of the year. There is no way in hell that the current parliament will vote in people who are receptive of Trump getting the Nobel for bombing Iran, and they will dominate the committee for six years, so even if some MAGA fans won the next election in a landslide, it seems very unlikely that Trump would get a Nobel before he croaks.

Even less likely is that Trump will do an 180 which will convince people that he deserves the Nobel. In his first term, he was not especially belligerent, but this time, he has taken actions which bar the Nobel unless he give some very costly signals renouncing his previous behavior. Which he obviously won't.

All of this is common knowledge. So the surprising thing about Trump is that he is actually surprised, that he had a world model in which he was more likely to win the Nobel than win Miss China.


Last year, the Nobel committee at least took Trump's feelings into account by awarding the prize to Machado, a democracy activist in Venezuela who was allied with Trump in fighting the Maduro government (and subsequently gifted her medal to Trump). Per WP, she is currently denied entry into Venezuela, seems the Rodríguez government has no interests in letting her in and Trump does not care either way as long as the US gets the oil. I am Jack's total lack of surprise.

This year, the picked laureate is a bit less reconciliatory towards Trump. Pillay seems like the antithesis to Trump. Not only is she a black woman, but she has made a career in international law. She was part of the International Criminal Court, whose members are currently under sanction from the Trump administration for going after Israeli politicians accused of war crimes. Later, she was a UN high commissioner for human rights and a member of the International Court of Justice before finally heading the Commission of Inquiry on Occupied Palestinian Territory which determined that Israel had indeed committed genocide during the Gaza war.

It the committee had wanted to pick a candidate to signal "fuck Donald Trump in particular", they could hardly have done better short of awarding it to Harris or the Ayatollah.

In a better world, Pillay would not be considered worthy of the Nobel. "Yes, she is part of the justice system which deals with terrible atrocities which have been committed in Rwanda or Myanmar, but that system is already universally supported by the civilized world. We would prefer to make a statement a bit spicier than 'war crimes bad' with our prize."

Instead, we live in times where everything Pillay stands for is under attack, where the theory of international relations endorsed by the most powerful country on earth can be summarized as "the strong will do what they wilt, the weak will suffer what they must". In this world, it makes total sense for the Nobel committee to throw their support behind international law.

Pillay isn't Black, she's Tamil. South Asian.

As an aside, does anyone know how the entire world decided to outsource the most prestigious awards on earth to some random group of Norwegian politicians? Like, I know Alfred Nobel yada yada yada, but why do we all care about the opinions of the Norwegian parliament and their nameless political appointees? It's like having the NFL MVP determined exclusively by the commissioner of my office fantasy football league.

As an aside, does anyone know how the entire world decided to outsource the most prestigious awards on earth to some random group of Norwegian politicians? Like, I know Alfred Nobel yada yada yada,

I assume you are NOT asking "Why Norway for the Peace Prize but Sweden for the other prizes?"

Anyway, I am pretty sure the answer is that it's a kind of self reinforcing feedback loop. The Nobel Prize is perceived as being extremely prestigious, which means that Nobel Laureates receive a lot of social status (even Trump wants a Nobel Peace Prize) which reinforces the prestige of the Nobel Prize.

It's arguably the same mechanism with an exclusive nightclub which is perceived as being high status which means that everyone who is anyone wants to get in. Which reinforces the nightclub's status. Or an elite university which is perceived as being elite so it attracts lots of great students, children of royalty; well respected professors, etc.. Which reinforces its status as an elite university.

So I would guess that it was just a matter of being in the right place at the right time and then snowballing.

Yeah I have high school book report level knowledge of the history of Nobel and how the various awards began, why peace and economics are different, etc. It was more the "why does anyone else care" question.

I guess first mover advantage plus network effects reinforcing over time makes sense. The first group to start offering gold plates ans cash prizes at a fancy white tie dinner gets a big head start on the others. It's just weird to me that the Scandinavians, a people so allergic to individual achievement and so internationally inconsequential, became world arbiters of individual greatness. I understand this is my American chauvinism showing, but I just have such a hard time understanding why anyone would care about an award given out by the inventors of tall poppy syndrom.

It was more the "why does anyone else care" question.

I guess first mover advantage plus network effects reinforcing over time makes sense.

Right, people care because other people care. Because other people care. Because other people care. etc. etc.

It's just weird to me that the Scandinavians, a people so allergic to individual achievement and so internationally inconsequential, became world arbiters of individual greatness.

Perhaps it helps that the Scandinavians are perceived as being highly advanced and yet above the fray, so to speak. If the Peace Price were awarded by the American legislature, it would (arguably) be even more hopelessly partisan.

Throughout the 20th century, they also managed to stay nominally neutral and peaceful in most major conflicts (while, perhaps not entirely deservedly, staying clear of the Swiss smell of profiteering off others' misery too), and gained a certain reputation for individual activism for the greater good (Fridtjof Nansen etc.).

Is there even anyone who would be a more credible arbiter?

Is there even anyone who would be a more credible arbiter?

That's a very interesting question. The issue I see is that as with most Western European countries, the Norwegian Nobel committee is perceived as having been captured by the Left. (Thus the Peace Prize award to Obama.)

In my view, what would be more credible is a bipartisan committee comprised of (1) two individuals appointed by the state legislature in Oklahoma; (2) two individuals appointed by the state legislature of New Jersey; and (3) a 5th member chosen by agreement among the first 4.

That might make for a reasonable starting point for a peace prize that will be considered "fair and balanced" by Americans, but the rest of the world would care about it as much as it does about this year's Superbowl winner. Hardly anyone out here could even point out Oklahoma on a map.

The circumstance that American political theatre is a hyperstimulus would also further sabotage any attempts at global appeal: much like Europeans are more captured by anti-Red propaganda and Russians are more captured by anti-Blue propaganda than most Americans, the shit-slinging that would inevitably ensue to try and influence the choice within the inside baseball league alone would leak out, and make outsiders walk away very confident that the selection process is hopelessly biased in whatever direction.

That might make for a reasonable starting point for a peace prize that will be considered "fair and balanced" by Americans, but the rest of the world would care about it as much as it does about this year's Superbowl winner. Hardly anyone out here could even point out Oklahoma on a map.

I would guess most people (1) are unaware that with with respect to the Peace Prize, it's Norway and not Sweden who decides; and (2) would be unable to point to a map of Europe and pick out Norway and Sweden. In my opinion, the main reason people care about the Nobel Prize is because other people care. Because other people care. And so on. A kind of first-mover / network effect.

Someone please give this guy a peace prize before he starts another war.

Wouldn't be surprised if Trump did the Iran thing in part because of a "If I'm not going to be awarded the Nobel for Peace, I might as well be a Hawk" attitude.

From a game theory point of view, it would be really bad to try to appease Trump in the hope that he will behave more nicely. Even if it works for a year, then next year you have to give the medicine Nobel to RFK Jr for not outlawing all vaccines and the peace Nobel to Putin for refraining to nuke Kiev. And find another one for Trump lest he feels neglected.

Giving a Nobel to someone for political reasons "even if it works for a year" is exactly the same as giving it to someone else for political reasons except that they are doing the desired activity after receiving it than before. You have no way to know that anyone you give a prize to will continue doing what you want for a long period of time whether their year of obedience starts before or after getting the prize. But somehow they manage to give lots of Nobels out for political reasons anyway.

This is an isolated demand for rigor.

You are surprised Trump has a mental world model in which he deserves the Nobel Peace Prize (and all other prizes, so if he cheats or commits fraud to acquire gains he is merely taking what is rightfully his)?

I thought that the 2025 tariffs were too obviously a bad idea to be real. Since then, no idea has been too deranged.

It is not surprising that Trump believes he deserves the Nobel Prize, it’s surprising that Trump thought the Scandanavian pinkos who hate him, would give it to him.

It is not surprising that Trump believes he deserves the Nobel Prize, it’s surprising that Trump thought the Scandanavian pinkos who hate him, would give it to him.

Yeah, if that's what he really thought.

I am pretty much automatically skeptical of any newspaper article which makes off-the-wall claims about Trump. I had this thing during his first term with a liberal female family member who would regularly say things like "Can you believe Trump said 'X'" where X was something totally unreasonable and off the wall. And each time I would scrutinize her claims and find that each time, Trump hadn't actually said X. That instead, he had said "Y," and it had been uncharitably interpreted by the press. Who had that written a story carefully crafted to give readers the impression that Trump had said X without saying so explicitly. This happened again and again until my family member stopped bringing up Trump to me.

Anyway, I haven't been following peace news that carefully, but I definitely think that at a minimum, Trump should have been in contention for the Peace Prize for his role in the peace deal between Israel and the UAE and a couple other Arab countries. That's real progress, except of course that in my mental model of progressives, those peace deals were no good. Because they were a win for Israel, a country which, in the progressive worldview, should not exist. (If anyone wants to correct me on this point, feel free.)

Trump should have been in contention for the Peace Prize

That might have been something to argue during Trump I, but in 2026, after Trump has been spending most of the year fighting a war with Iran his prior achievements towards world peace will not amount to much. They might as well give Putin the Nobel as well, or Netanyahu while they are at it.

That might have been something to argue during Trump I, but in 2026,

Perhaps not, but Trump might reasonably feel he had been cheated. Actually, that's perhaps not true -- I'm told that you don't get a peace prize for leading a mediating party.

after Trump has been spending most of the year fighting a war with Iran his prior achievements towards world peace will not amount to much. They might as well give Putin the Nobel as well, or Netanyahu while they are at it.

I don't know what the criteria are, but if leading a war (whether it's justified or not) is disqualifying, then yeah I agree.

A different Nobel Committee might reasonably have given a Nobel Peace Prize for the Abraham Accords, although I think with Saudi Arabia still not signed up it would have been a poor choice. But Nobel Peace Prizes for that type of deal almost always go to the principals (here Netanyahu and AbZ for the deal done to date, and Salman if Saudi joins) and not the third-party mediator. For example, Carter did not share the 1978 prize with Begin and Sadat. And even if they did award the prize to a mediator, Kushner has earned it and Trump, personally, has not.

So the chance of Donald Trump personally getting a Nobel Peace Prize for the Abraham Accords would be negligible even if he hadn't started three wars of choice since 2024, which is and probably should be disqualifying.

A different Nobel Committee might reasonably have given a Nobel Peace Prize for the Abraham Accords, although I think with Saudi Arabia still not signed up it would have been a poor choice. But Nobel Peace Prizes for that type of deal go to the principles (here Netanyahu and AbZ for the deal done to date, and Salman if Saudi joins) and not the third-party mediator.

I wasn't aware of that. Assuming you are correct (that the mediator never gets the Peace Prize) then I withdraw my argument.

Rechecking the list, Teddy Roosevelt got the 1906 Nobel (solo) for ending the Russia-Japan war of 1905, which would be a clear-cut exception. Ralph Bunche got the 1950 Nobel Peace Prize for his attempts to mediate the incipient Arab-Israeli conflict (also solo - in that case it is of course very clear that none of the principals deserved it) - the prize citation implies that he won it for mediating the ceasefire agreements that ended the Israeli War of Independence, but Wikipedia implies that it was a kind of lifetime achievement award.

The famous cases I was thinking of were the awards for Locarno (1925-6), Vietnam (1973), Israel-Egypt (1978), South Africa (1993), Israel-Palestine (1994) and Northern Ireland (1998) which were shared between principals. So looking more closely I wouldn't say the mediator never gets the prize, but by default it would go to the principals, and the Abraham Accords doesn't look like an exception.

1973 and 1994 were, of course, two of the worst Peace Prize awards in the undistinguished history of the prize. I think 1950 was below average - the most notable thing about attempts to mediate the Israel-Palestine conflict (including Bunche's) is how utterly they failed. And I don't think mediating an ugly freeze-the-status-quo armistice that doesn't lead to a peace treaty is close to a Nobel-worthy achievement.

And I don't think mediating an ugly freeze-the-status-quo armistice that doesn't lead to a peace treaty is close to a Nobel-worthy achievement.

The peace Nobel prize is never actually about the achievement, but about the message that the Nobel Committee wants to send. It's just incidental if the message they want to send is approval of an achievement. They gave the peace prize to Obama because they approved of his election, not because of an actual achievement. They gave it to Malala to take a stand against the Taliban's opposition to girl's education, not because she did anything special (getting shot is not an achievement).

And I think "outsiders should be spending time and effort trying to make peace in the Middle East when the locals are actually happier fighting each other" is a dumb message to send.

My position on the Israel-Palestine conflict, which is shared by the vast majority of normies, is "not my circus, not my monkeys".

Good for the Nobel committee for not aligning with either tribe. I do not understand what leads the left to defend Maduro and the right to attack the ICC. What problems did Trump's invasion create where ordinary Venezuelans' lives are or will be worse than if it hadn't happened? What is Piley doing wrong trying to prosecute Israeli war crimes?

We would prefer to make a statement a bit spicier than 'war crimes bad' with our prize.

I disagree: the Nobel peace prize should be about peace, as pure as possible, irrespective of anything else. If you can demonstrate your war is an effective means to a peaceful end, you may be good, you may honestly be the most effective altruist...but the prize should go to someone else who is more straightforwardly acting to reduce violence and suffering. It's a symbol that's particularly important to the simple-minded.

Good for the Nobel committee for not aligning with either tribe.

Bruh these same people gave Obama a peace prise. I have nothing but contempt for these posturing ghouls.

My perspective on the ICC comes from being Scottish. I'm not personally affected by Drug deaths rise sharply in Scotland as figures remain worst in Europe but it seems pretty clear that Scotland needs its own Duerte to save its young people from fentanyl and death. The ICC are the bad guys, on the side of drugs gangs and death. The ICC insist that government must be ineffective, with success being punished by prosecution for "crimes against humanity". Has the ICC been captured by organised crime?

Has the ICC been captured by organised crime?

Governments are organized crime.

I do not understand what leads the left to defend Maduro and the right to attack the ICC.

You really don't understand why the right would attack a court that believes it supersedes the sovereignty of the United States and would try members of the US military as war criminals? The Trump administration is correct to sanction and dismantle that court.

The ICC's clear violation of international law aside, it also makes sense politically.

The left would love to have a leftist body such as the ICC which can overrule the actions of a right wing President like Trump. Then they can say "we didn't violate the Constitution, it was out of our hands".

Are you also surprised that the left would attack the NRA?

I have to admit, crying foul over national sovereignty and international law is a bit rich coming from the US. After all, the general position of the US for the last quarter century or so has been that US law applies within the US and to US citizens, and the US president has unlimited jurisdiction over the life of freedom of anyone else. If you annoy the US (or get mistaken as someone who did so), perhaps you will get blown up in the middle of a wedding reception, or you will get kidnapped and brought to some torture prison the US runs where their constitution does not apply. I guess if you are really lucky, you will merely get kidnapped and brought within proper US jurisdiction.

Meanwhile, the US military is very reluctant to investigate possible war crimes of their soldiers, because the civilian leadership has no interests in doing so. The officer who mis-id'ed that school in Iran will obviously not face a military tribunal on charges of negligent manslaughter. The sailor who decided to shoot the shipwrecked survivors of a strike against a suspected drug smuggling boat will likewise never see a court martial.

I do not know how Trump would have handled the judicial aftermath of the Yugoslavia war. I doubt he would have cared much about foreign war crimes, so likely the accused would have gotten a presidential pardon in exchange for 'investing' in one of his shitcoins. Perhaps he would also have made up some ad-hoc military court to try and hang them. Perhaps the soldiers arresting the suspects would have been simply under orders not to take anyone alive, as they were with Bin Laden. Perhaps he would have let the Bosnians try any Serbs accused of crimes against humanity, with predictable results.

But it seems clear to me that all of these options would have been worse than just trying the suspected war criminals in the Hague, where they got their day in court, and if their guilt was proven beyond reasonable doubt, and they mostly got just sentences by judges who were non-partisan.

The ICC is just the generalization of that tribunal. I do not think it is very hard for a country to keep out of the crosshairs of the ICC -- simply conduct your wars (if you have to) while taking proper precautions to protect civilians, and if indivdual soldiers break the rules of engagement and commit crimes against civilians or PoWs, give them sentences similar to what civilians would have gotten for doing the crime against other domestic civilians.

A lot of the US courts are thoroughly politicized, starting with the SCOTUS (Roe vs Wade, among others) and continuing to the lawfare first against and then by Trump. My feeling is that the ICC is no worse than that (and likely a lot less political), despite Israel's whining to the contrary.

The US strategy for dealing with Hegseth, if he was working against rather than for the US, would be to blow him up and accept any bystanders as collateral damage. I am against this, not because I think he is especially deserving of legal protections he denied his enemies, but because legal protections should apply universally. So I would much prefer him and the people above and below him in the chain of command getting their day in court in the Hague, thereby strengthening international law rather than further weakening it.

I have to admit, crying foul over national sovereignty and international law is a bit rich coming from the US. After all, the general position of the US for the last quarter century or so has been that US law applies within the US and to US citizens, and the US president has unlimited jurisdiction over the life of freedom of anyone else.

No but you see when the US and its allies mess with the Middle East and Latin America for the umpteenth time, bomb their countries to smithereens and/or try to install their own puppet governments in the area, this is an act of magnanimity and liberation of the downtrodden as well as a justified act of retaliation against evil dictatorships. When US competitors exercise power on a much smaller and less consequential regional scale, for example China enforcing their sovereignty over Hong Kong or throwing their weight around in the South China Sea, this is uncalled-for aggression, authoritarianism and belligerence and a violation of international law. As always everything is just realpolitik and the ideological justifications are created ad hoc to legitimise it.

It's literally just rules for thee, not for me; their mode of engagement has never been particularly consistent. The actual basis for their objection to the ICC is primarily just that the US and its interests may be subject to some external power that constrains their ability to act, it has nothing to do with any serious belief in consistently-applied "international law" or "rules-based order". In this context, it's very hard for me to care about any arguments about how the ICC is trying to gain and keep power as an arbiter of international affairs, when we already live in a system where flagrant overexercise of power is the norm. America is just not used to being on the wrong side of that dynamic, and as such suddenly feels obliged to care.

Yes, the Bush and to a lesser extent Obama era depredations were bad. There is no excuse for torture.

Woe to the conquered.

All the more reason not to willingly relinquish sovereignty to people who hate you.

try members of the US military as war criminals?

What US members have been tried, what are their suspected crimes, and what did they actually do?

If they are guilty even by the US's own standards, only avoiding prosecution by inaction or corruption, they deserve it even by the US's own standards.

Otherwise regardless, they should be labeled by the ICC, without any US legal repercussions, so we can learn. If we don't seek input from those with different moral standards, we cannot improve or our own or stop them from decaying.

It appears the ICC cannot actually enforce over a nation (at least a powerful one like the US). The best they can do is get a world leader arrested if they travel outside...except they haven't managed that in the modern day, either. If they are effectively vocal, saying "we think you did something wrong", I don't think that deserves anything beyond a vocal response "I think you're wrong". Sanctioning a powerless ICC is at minimum a bad look.

Otherwise regardless, they should be labeled by the ICC, without any US legal repercussions, so we can learn

Perhaps the ICC will learn something from US sanctions.

If they are guilty even by the US's own standards, only avoiding prosecution by inaction or corruption, they deserve it even by the US's own standards.

As a side note, when the ICC was set up, its proponents assured everyone that the ICC did not have jurisdiction over and would not act against countries with their own systems in place to prosecute war crimes. (At the time, those opposed to the ICC knew that this was BS, that eventually the ICC would start going after Israel and the United States.)

To put it another way, by its own charter, the ICC is not supposed to do what you are suggesting, i.e. to give a kind of second opinion regarding the legal system in the US, Israel, or anywhere else.

Otherwise regardless, they should be labeled by the ICC, without any US legal repercussions, so we can learn.

Learn what? We already have processes for handling this. What additional value does an extrajudicial kangaroo court in Europe have in enforcing our laws. Perhaps we should start trying European politicians and soldiers in our own made up courts. Would that help them learn?

The ICC is not powerless. You are correct that they are de-facto powerless against the United States because we fight back against them. The answer is not to stop fighting back. It's to remove the threat entirely. You kill a tumor before it grows large enough to be a problem.

The Trump administration realizes quite correctly that the next Democrat regime could use the ICC to harass its domestic enemies while sidestepping Constitutional concerns. If there is a higher court that is above the Constitution and answers to no one, it's quite convenient. That's why they need to be defunded, disbanded, and sanctioned now.

What additional value does an extrajudicial kangaroo court in Europe have in enforcing our laws.

It provides value when certain factions want is prohibited by your laws. You might have the right to free speech domestically, but if your political opponents gain power and decide that criticizing your political opponents is a hate crime, and pack you off to a foreign country extraordinarily render you to face foreign "justice", then that doesn't matter.

It's the same kind of thing Charles I (and some king of Spain in the early 1800s) did by simply asking a foreign State to invade in return for economic promises. It's an act of civil war, obviously, but to what degree will the populace care?

One imagines a deal that the EU will keep the US dissident-free, while the US will keep the EU tariff-free into US markets.


The Trump administration realizes quite correctly that the next Democrat regime could use the ICC to harass its domestic enemies while sidestepping Constitutional concerns

This has kind of already happened; European countries (and US companies that would like to continue to do business in Europe, most notably payment processors) have already fought a few US companies for blasphemy (or "hate speech", as they prefer to call it). Which is kind of why the US needs to put its foot down and make sure that if the Europeans want their own firewall, they build it themselves (which would result in so much money -> political power changing hands that European gerontocracies would get turfed anyway).

I recall exactly one case in which a US citizen was arrested by the US government and sent to be imprisoned by an unrelated third party country without due process. That was under Trump II.

The ICCs mandate is rather narrow, mostly involving war crimes and crimes against humanity. While I am sure that there are some wokes who would dream of sending every Republican to the Hague, the SCOTUS will very much not let them, nor would the ICC convict them of anything.

The steelman version is that at the end of his administration, Trump (or Vance) give Hegseth a full pardon for any conduct he did while in office, thereby making it impossible to try him for the conduct he had ordered during subsequent administrations. Sending him to the Hague would bypass that pardon. (Of course, arresting him while bypassing the US court system would be tricky. I mean, the SCOTUS has already established that the next Democratic president will not have to answer criminal charges for any official conduct, but if a president orders a US citizen kidnapped and sent to the Netherlands he might as well order him kidnapped and dropped out of a helicopter.)

However, I do not believe that this is likely to happen. No resident of the White House wants to normalize criminal investigations into official conduct of administrations, for reasons which are plenty apparent. Nor were the Democrats historically very much against what might be considered war crimes, so far.

The ICCs mandate is rather narrow, mostly involving war crimes and crimes against humanity

That's just a fancy way to say "losing wars while being on the side the EU doesn't support". Progressives will tell you that disagreeing with a woman is a crime against humanity so the definition is worthless.

The fact the ICC draws most of its legitimacy from Nuremberg (which was, basically, to legitimize killing off a bunch of German elites) remains relevant; that's where the temptation and cultural pull to use the ICC for "anti-Nazi" purposes come from.

Conveniently, all of their opponents are Nazis.

Of course, arresting him while bypassing the US court system would be tricky.

I already outlined a way this can (and indeed, does) happen. For everyone else, there's your standard black-bagging- foreign intelligence services, if they want to stay on the US' good side, can launder the US' unlawful requests just like they do now with SIGINT.

Yes, it's obviously a degradation to sovereignty, but if you only care about sovereignty in the supranational sense (again, so you can avoid passing politically-costly laws- immigration being the easiest example) why would that concern you?

the SCOTUS will very much not let them

What legions will they send to stop them?

Nuremberg (which was, basically, to legitimize killing off a bunch of German elites)

This seems an odd point of view. If the purpose was to legitimize killing German elites, then at 55% success rate they did not do a very good job of it.

The subsequent trials were even less effective at eliminating Germans:

489 cases went to trial, involving 1,672 defendants. A total of 1,416 of them were found guilty; fewer than 200 were executed, and another 279 defendants were sentenced to life in prison. By the 1950s almost all of them had been released

About 212 people executed (in the West) is a tiny number compared to the number of people murdered by the Nazis. Even when just considering the Shoah, we get around one death sentence per 25k victims. The real number of people who were guilty of the crime of genocide (and thus should be punished like a common murderer) was obviously orders of magnitude higher. I maintain that hanging all the about 22k members of the SS-Totenkopfverbände (unless they could prove how they had been working against the regime, like Gerstein) for starters would have resulted in a much better approximation of justice.

Edit: fixed formatting bug.

The ICC is not powerless.

Agreed. If the ICC were strictly limited to advisory opinions, the "you might learn something" argument might have some merit. But the ICC believes that it can issue arrest warrants and some ICC countries would actually enforce those warrants.

Power is sort of like a self-fulfilling prophecy. If enough people believe that an institution has power, then it has power. And it's pretty obvious that the ICC is trying to get power.

What additional value does an extrajudicial kangaroo court in Europe have in enforcing our code of military justice?

Because sometimes the US system is wrong: it has been wrong in the past, and we will see it in the present as wrong in the future. The court may show and persuade us, via our own will, to see how it's wrong.

Perhaps we should start trying European politicians and soldiers in our own court of justice. Would that help them learn?

Yes: I think it's fair if Europe is free to largely ignore our rulings, like we largely ignore the ICC, but they would benefit from listening. Europe is facing a rise in right-wing parties, and there's a chance the left will undermine democracy and their other by-then-former principles to suppress them, so much that even leftist Europeans who today condemn Trump realize their by-then-former allies have gone too far.

The US does not always interfere positively with Europe. But Europeans should really ask if they want the US to leave them alone entirely, because sometimes by their own standards, the US government is right and theirs is wrong. Same with the ICC interfering with the US.

The Trump administration realizes quite correctly that the next Democrat regime could use the ICC to harrass its domestic enemies when Constitutional concerns get in the way.

They could also ignore the Constitution with some other excuse, or revive the ICC. Either way they must use their own power, since the ICC has effectively none, so I doubt it's significantly harder.

I understand why Trump's attacking them now, because he disagrees with them, but I'm trying to understand where he has the moral upper hand.

Because sometimes the US system is wrong: it has been wrong in the past, and we will see it in the present as wrong in the future. The court may show and persuade us, via our own will, to see how it's wrong.

As I noted above, that's not how the ICC is supposed to work. It's not supposed to have any jurisdiction at all over countries with their own systems in place to prosecute war crimes.

Also as I noted above, the ICC is doing a lot more than simply sharing its opinion. Rather, it is trying to get power. It is trying to get into a position where its arrest warrants are taken seriously.

The ICC could end all of these sanctions tomorrow if it simply made an announcement along the following lines:

The US and Israel both have bona fide systems in place to prosecute war criminals. Therefore, even though we don't necessarily agree with all of the decisions of these countries, under our charter we lack jurisdiction over them and we cannot investigate or prosecute members of the American or Israel armed forces or government.

But of course they won't do that. Because they want to increase the power and jurisdiction of the ICC. Which admittedly is rather limited at the moment, but it's still a serious threat.

The US and Israel both have bona fide systems in place to prosecute war criminals. Therefore, even though we don't necessarily agree with all of the decisions of these countries, under our charter we lack jurisdiction over them

This is not how it works. I am sure that Milosevic had a military court system which was also responsible for dealing with war crimes.

Instead, the relevant test is in Article 17 of the Rome statute.

The conduct in Gaza which the ICC found objectionable was for the most part official state policy of Israel. Likewise Hegseth's decision to sink suspected smuggling boats and then kill any shipwrecked survivors. A government which orders conduct generally does not criminally investigate fulfilling these orders.

The real restriction on the ICC is territorial jurisdiction. Fortunately, Palestine was admitted to the Rome statute as a state party, thus the ICC has (arguably) jurisdiction in Gaza.

By contrast, the ICC would not have any authority to try the Pretti shooting: it happened on US soil by an US perp, and the US has withdrawn from the Rome statute, thus they would need voluntary cooperation of the US.

This is not how it works.

Of course not -- that's not how it works in practice. But at the time the ICC was set up, people who objected that the ICC would be used as a tool go after Israel and the United States were told, in substance, that the ICC was only there for extreme cases where a state's own justice system had broken down. That it wasn't for situations where there was a simple disagreement along the lines of what @Brainwavez was suggesting. But at the time I and others knew exactly what was going to happen.

A government which orders conduct generally does not criminally investigate fulfilling these orders.

Perhaps not, but Israel constantly runs policies by internal legal counsel to make sure international law is being (and has been) followed. Israel has a method in place to assign independent prosecutors, which is presumably why Netanyahu was prosecuted a few years back on corruption charges. Israel has an independent court system which regularly rules against the government and there are plenty of powerful people in Israel's government who hate Netanyahu and believe Israel has been fighting the recent war too aggressively. It's not that Netanyahu is some tin pot dictator whose own government rubber stamps everything he does. Rather, he is simply not a war criminal by any reasonable and fair definition of that term. The ICC is going after him for the same political reasons that other international bodies aggressively single out and attack Israel. Just as was expected when the ICC was set up.

Fortunately, Palestine

Fortunate for those who want to use lawfare to go after Israel.

so much that even leftist Europeans who today condemn Trump realize their by-then-former allies have gone too far.

But Europeans should really ask if they want the US to leave them alone entirely, because sometimes by their own standards,

I do not feel that Europeans nowadays generally have standards beyond tribalism either. They were cheering when the leading candidate got excluded from elections in Romania (likely with significant American fire support), and they will cheer if this happens to AfD or FN or whomever.

A South African colleague of mine is very pleased that it was awarded to one of his countrywomen. I snarked that she now joins an exclusive club whose members also include Henry Kissinger, Yasser Arafat and Aung Sun Suu Kyi. He wasn't too impressed.

On the plus side, Trump might well win his second FIFA Peace Prize this year, and there's no way Pillay will snatch that from him.

On the plus side, Trump might well win his second FIFA Peace Prize this year,

Okay, that would be hilarious.

It’s pretty bizarre to call a Tamil black.

Obama's peace prize was basically a fuck GWB award, yhe committe has made it clear they hate American Republicans, so my only surprise is that they didnt give this one to the Surpreme Leader of Iran, honestly the cardbaord cuttout getting one would been hilarious.

It's incredibly telling that this years Nobel prizes for literature and physics both went to career academics who started teaching in the 1970s.

The award has now become a lifetime participation medal for those most committed to ivory tower PMC careers with zero innovation or risk.

I doubt the Norwegian parliament is any bigger of a fan of Iran's leadership. These are not braindead American college liberals just because they're progressive and don't like republicans.

I doubt the Norwegian parliament is any bigger of a fan of Iran's leadership. These are not braindead American college liberals just because they're progressive and don't like republicans.

Well have any American college student associations passed resolutions in support of the Iranian regime? I have not heard of this happening.

In any event, I agree with @aldomilyar that the Obama peace prize doesn't do much for the credibility of Norwegian leadership.

It's also worth noting that Trump helped broker peace agreements between Israel and the UAE and a couple other Arab countries.

In my view, that should have put him in contention for a Peace Prize. But my sense is that progressives HATE those peace agreements; they see them as a win for Israel. (Feel free to suggest another interpretation of this situation.)

Well have any American college student associations passed resolutions in support of the Iranian regime?

They do it indirectly, by protesting the war while not suggesting other ways to get rid of the regime.

They do it indirectly, by protesting the war while not suggesting other ways to get rid of the regime.

I'm too lazy to check, but I think it's more likely than not that liberal elements in Norway's parliament have done something similar.

I mean they're wading into the Palestine issue atleast implicitly here and the Obama nod is an all-time blind nuthug.

Justice Department won’t enforce registration rules on silencers and certain guns after court ruling

The Trump administration announced the enforcement policy changes after a Texas judge in August ruled the permitting process was unconstitutional. The judge’s ruling was limited to the parties involved in that case, but the Justice Department said Friday it would no longer enforce the registration requirements more broadly.

Under the new guidance, ATF will no longer require registration unless the buyer lives in one of about 15 states that have state laws requiring that people go through the federal permitting process. The registration process will still apply for machine guns and what are considered “destructive devices” under federal law, the Justice Department said.

This is not a legislative change or even a change after a Supreme Court ruling, so the next administration could reverse it. With that said, the amount of erosion of the National Firearms Act in the last decade is beyond the wildest dreams of the most fervent pro-2nd amendment crowd from 20 years ago. There are states now banning AR15s or trying to ban handguns, but if a person doesn't live in one of those, they can buy a short-barreled rifle and suppressor with no background check or tax stamp.

Once I learned that silencers are the same tech as car mufflers it all made sense, gas cars aren't silent, but they're a good bit quieter than striaght pipe exhaust.

I have to say that it was a disappointment when I found out that movie silencers are all fake and that guns are actually still really loud with them attached.

At least they turn the super-sonic ear rape wave into a slightly less ear-fucking clap. For this reason operating on the theory that any civilian deployment of a handgun while not gangbanging with your homies is in fact in self defense, they should be not only allowed but mandatory. You should not be expected to loose your hearing after, when you have to defend yourself from a home invasion.

If this stuff sticks maybe we see integrated suppressors becoming more of a thing? At the moment the worst part of them is the big can hanging off the end of your barrel; something like the DeLisle for rifles or the equivalent handgun would be super-cool!

I'm currently trying to decide what I want to buy and/or build. A CMMG banshee 9mm AR with FRT and suppressor is up there on the list, but I'm also really tempted to buy a cheap 5.56 bolt action used, and get the barrel swapped to 9mm with an integrated suppressor. more engineering would be needed to make it magazine-fed, but it seems like it'd make a pretty nice de lisle-alike. I also want to try building my own takedown .22, either based on the AR-7 or on the marlin or ruger takedown guns.

looking at the options, though, it's hard to see why it's worth going to the manual actions or single-shots when semi-autos are so cheap. I have a fascination with cheap guns, and one of the things I'm curious about is if you could use a .22 or 9mm adapter, or even just an AR barrel, to rework one of those cheap $50 turkish single-shot 12-gauges into an integrally-suppressed single shot, using the shotgun barrel as the outer wall of the suppressor. Or maybe see what you could do with a high-point 9mm carbine; those guns are actually cheap cheap. if you're paying $3-400 for even a used manual-action rifle and then reworking it to a pistol caliber, it's only a couple hundred more for a high-capacity AR, and actually less for the cheaper options.

A CMMG banshee 9mm AR with FRT and suppressor is up there on the list

If you want something actually transformative, build a vz. 61 with a lower that you can put an FRT into, then suppress it. If you must go Banshee, get the fixed ejector upgrade if you can (ejection is a weak point of this design), or go with the MEAN Arms roller-delayed system (it isn't an issue there). Or buy a parts kit and print an MP5.

it's hard to see why it's worth going to the manual actions or single-shots when semi-autos are so cheap

Pistol caliber semi-autos have always been cheaper simply because they require no locking system to function safely. That's why manual-action guns in these calibers are so rare (with the exception of magnum-length revolver calibers).

(Same reason why there are barely any straight-pull bolt-action rifles- you're >95% of the way to a semi-auto. The Heym SR-30, simplest of the straight-pulls, is mechanically/operationally identical to an HK SL-7 without an action spring and appropriate "locking" piece.)

more engineering would be needed to make it magazine-fed

If you can get the "donor" gun in question to take a normal magazine, just use Endomags (or Exomags if you want a 10-rounder for something closer to flush-fitting). Bolt guns with plunger ejectors might cause you some grief, but these magazines are available with ejectors mounted on them should you require that (though it's a compromise as they can get damaged, like they can on the 10/22, which also does this).

Or maybe see what you could do with a high-point 9mm carbine; those guns are actually cheap cheap

Extar's plastic 9mm is arguably a better value simply by virtue of needing fewer magazines (and you can put an FRT in that too).

Don't tell the anti gunners but proper silencers are just like the movies. Of course they can't silence a full power rifle, but suppressed pistol calibers and other quieter cartridges will be quiet enough that the loudest thing will be the action cycling and the bullet hitting the target.

I once fired a suppressed MP-5; the loudest sound was the brass hitting the floor.

It's funny and weird how differently silencers are treated in US vs Finland (being #10 on the list of most civilian firearms per population, so it's not like firearms are that rare here). Here silencers are treated as a public noise control issue and the idea of restricting them seems absurd. What on earth would it even accomplish? It's not like they're used in robberies (the point being that a robbery that involves shooting has gone to shit and everyone will almost certainly end up in jail, but now with much harsher sentence) and shootouts are almost always a lone drunk or mentally disturbed guy firing a few shots (with little to no preplanning).

US gun laws are written as a compromise between people who hate guns too much to know anything about them and people who just don't want the laws to work.

Specifically, the National Firearms Act put a tax stamp and registration requirement on a lengthy set of firearms categories on the basis of 'gangsters using them in the movies'. Over time that registration requirement became an odious six month process, because bureaucracy. Short barreled rifles/shotguns are also now unrestricted.

You have to use subsonic rounds to get that "ptew" sound.

Or use a crossbow.

I definitely think at the very least in 2 years when half of all new rifles are SBR, and gun stores are handing out $50 suppressors like candy, it may be hard to go back.

If we can get a real scotus ruling on "common use" then we may be only 50 million suppressors and sbrs away from winning them forever.

I definitely think at the very least in 2 years when half of all new rifles are SBR, and gun stores are handing out $50 suppressors like candy, it may be hard to go back.

I certainly hope so. The horse seems out of the barn on many NFA restrictions between forced-reset triggers and every gangbanger having a switch on his Glock, so continuing to punish law abiding citizens for wanting a silencer or AR pistol with a stock (instead of arm brace) is absurd. Not that absurdity ever stops the government, of course.

All this goes away between Thomas and Alito retiring or dying and the next Democratic adminstration eliminating the kinder-and-gentler ATF. Whether they'll go door-to-door collecting suppressors bought on 4473 or not, I don't know.

We do have a rough historical comparison. When the CMP accidentally shipped a shitload of illegal SBRs to civilians, Congress actually got off its ass an amended the NFA to change the legal barrel length.

I wouldn't be entirely surprised to see a similar situation happen here

Now that is a gun-rights idea I hadn't thought of before: subsidize/promote silencers (or anything else) that are only legal in some jurisdictions, get the courts to recognize it as "common use", and enshrine it as s right for everyone forever.

Of course, that requires the courts to cooperate, which hasn't been a good option in the past.

Alito retires next term, with a Democratic Senate. Thomas won't live forever. The next President will likely be a Democrat. A leftist court won't pussyfoot around being anti-RKBA the way the current court pretends to be pro-RKBA, so it'll all be gone in one decision.

They will never, ever get them back. They didn't get 18-inch barrel restrictions back when they fucked up and lost it. They didn't get braces or bump-stocks back when those leaked through. They haven't gotten FRTs back. They won't get SBRs or suppressors back either. If they are smart, they'll recognize the fait accompli and just let it go. If they're not smart, my guess is you see another round of Red State defiance the way you did with the border, and likely worse if they double-down.

President AOC (or Newsom)'s ATF will have fully automatic weapons, not to mention incendiary grenades. If they say "Mr. and Mrs. Gunowner, turn them all in" and then kill a few members, or an entire compound, of some unpopular group to punctuate their point, they'll get most of it back, and the rest will end up buried until they rust to uselessness.

Even Texas and Florida are not going to put their own police in the way of the ATF.

Texas did put police in the way of the open border and Biden just... let them.

Yes, but Biden himself wasn't really functional at the time.

I think the federal government does not want more Ruby Ridge and Waco style debacles. It's a PR disaster when they burn down the home of defiant people*. Some gun control advocates like to use feds death-squadding or bombing people who don't comply with gun laws as a trump card. Something about fighter jets being used to enforce compliance in a way an AR15 can't stop. They act like it is a mic drop debate ender to point out the feds have armored vehicles and fighter jets. But the fantasy of feds burning and bombing their political opponents is just not going to happen in the modern era. A century ago a little bit of that could happen but the feds are just softer now. Photos of federal agents standing over charred ruins mixed with dead children will prevent this†. Not that they have any moral issues with murdering their fellow Americans, but the terrible PR would harm their supporters in elections and they can't stand that.

*Branch Davidians actually burned down their own compound. But it looked like the feds did it and FBI agents perjured themselves denying that they used incendiary tear gas canisters.

† Like all those photos from Waco.

I think the federal government does not want more Ruby Ridge and Waco style debacles.

Nobody would even know about Ruby Ridge if it weren't for Waco. And the kitten-stomping and "nothing found" raids are 2nd amendment lore that normies know nothing about. The Feds (in a Democratic administration) know they can shoot whoever they want as long as they can claim whoever they were shooting was a criminal.

How’s Malinowski’s widow’s lawsuit going?

If.

Is there any precedent for SWAT raids on generally-law-abiding gun owners? If there isn't, what are the signs that the next administration will break new ground?

Ken Ballew would be 1971.

Also John Lawmaster 1991, on a tip that he had an illegally-converted machine gun. Fortunately Lawmaster wasn't home. ATF trashed the place, left the guns unsecured, and left a note "Nothing found- ATF". Probably the note is what gives the story staying power.

There's the 1994 Pennsylvania Lamplugh raid where ATF agents are alleged to have stomped a kitten to death.

More comments

Is there any precedent for SWAT raids on generally-law-abiding gun owners?

The Biden raids of "kitchen-table" gun dealers -- note that the Trump Administration is still defending his "engaged in the business rule".

Well, all except the 50 million silencers.

Even if they are re-restricted, I don't think the government has the guts to pull off a mass confiscation. Is there precedent for that?

No, but "just [retroactively] ban ones that didn't go through the process" will generally work because gun owners and being autistically law-abiding have something to do with each other. (Permitting illegal stuff to be used on range properties tends to create liability for them.)

The new school of gun owners is a bit less, uh, 'cucked', but they aren't in political power yet.

For reference, those fifteen states are Alaska, Colorado, Michigan, Georgia, Minnesota, Connecticut, Mississippi, North Dakota, North Carolina, Montana, Nevada, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Washington and Wisconsin.

For those who don't know, a silencer does not work like in the movies. In real life, it takes the sound from 'permanent hearing damage' down to merely 'very loud'. The proximal effects of this law will be essentially nil; criminals will continue to mostly use nine mils that they hold incorrectly.

I live in Minnesota and my local gun store sent me an email saying they will sell me a suppressor with just a 4473.

It feels to me that laws requiring SBRs/suppressors to be "registered in accordance with federal rules" are being interpreted as "if federal rules do not require registration, then an unregistered item is in fact registered in accordance with federal rules because federal rules do not require registration."

If you look at historic conflicts over incorporating values into hostile states, such as the end of slavery or civil rights or the new deal, it never just involved the courts but typically also involved successive administrations putting pressure over a long period of time on states to confirm. Brown v Board was in 1953, but the South remained de facto segregated until Nixon to give an example.

It seems nationally, neither side can cobble together the durable consensus like that which gave us nationwide civil rights enforcement. To that end, I expect blue states to trend more restrictive and red states less restrictive when it comes to guns.

On December 3rd, the United States military will publicly livestream the execution by firing squad of Fort Hood shooter Nidal Hasan.

I’ve made my strong support of the death penalty — and specifically of public executions — abundantly clear over the years. (For a primer, you can listen to this episode of the now-defunct Motte-adjacent Bailey Podcast, my first and to date only podcast appearance.) My initial reaction to this news was jubilant: talk about getting what I voted for! While my preferred method of execution here would be hanging, a firing squad is certainly a step in the right direction in terms of de-medicalizing capital punishment and emphasizing its fundamentally violent and retributive nature.

My observation of the discourse around it has given me pause, though. The apoplectic relationship from the political left has been predictable, and was unfortunately always priced in; the reaction from some on the right, though, has been sobering. Professionally Christian commenters have lamented what they see as the barbarity and vulgarity of the live-streaming aspect. (“This makes us no better than Al Qaeda! We aren’t some third-world dictatorship! This isn’t Who We Are™️!”) Many have warned that this will generate photogenic martyrdom propaganda that will inspire and energize future jihadists. (We’re giving Hasan exactly the attention and validation he always wanted!”)

These arguments give me pause not because I agree with them, but because they highlight the way that this is a rubber-meets-the-road moment for my ideology. To what extent have I allowed myself to become so radicalized by hermetically-sealed online discourse, such that I imagine my beliefs to be far more popular than they are in reality? Is what I imagine to be a broadly common-sense perspective actually going to prove deeply unpopular and massively polarizing once implemented publicly? Scott Greer, generally a reliable barometer for where the normal Middle American opinion sits, thinks so.

Personally, I am concerned that the Trump administration will, yet again, find some way to botch the aesthetics of the occasion, reveling in low-class pandering and/or ostentatious cruelty. (There is also the possibility of visible corruption: perhaps viewers will need to pay for a bespoke streaming platform which will put revenue in the pockets of Trump, Trump’s family, or a consortium of Trump donors.) There is a part of me that wishes that the first public execution in America since 1937 should be postponed until it can be overseen by an administration that is less inherently polarizing than this one. To some extent, about a third of the country is fully committed to hating whatever Trump does, no matter what it is; perhaps under a future administration with a higher baseline level of public trust, this event could serve as an opportunity for genuinely restrained public discourse about capital punishment, rather than an opportunity for retrenchment of existing political fault lines. If done incorrectly, this event has the potential to set back the political hopes of death penalty maximalists such as myself for a generation or more.

I’m still planning on tuning in to watch this execution. As someone who discovered the snuff film parts of the internet at a relatively young age, I’m pretty thoroughly desensitized to images of death. (And frankly, having seen a number of videos of firing squad executions, they’re a lot more mild than you might think.) I hope that perhaps there will be some small number of individuals who might find it inspiring — and that there may be others who are in some way deterred, even marginally, from future criminality. The executioners need to strike a delicate balance during the proceedings: solemnity and restraint, acknowledging the humanity of the condemned while also not getting bogged down by mawkish faux-contrition about having to end his miserable wasted life. Keeping the proceedings focused primarily on the victims, including testimony by survivors such as this guy may help to quell any instinctive sympathy for the condemned that viewers could otherwise experience.

Personally, I am concerned that the Trump administration will, yet again, find some way to botch the aesthetics of the occasion, reveling in low-class pandering and/or ostentatious cruelty.

Funny that, Here I was worried that the admin will cuck out in the last moment and not turn this into a cruel spectacle. The talking points from the "loosing slowly" Christian sections have been exactly what I expected and I find my distaste for them and their meekness to be in the predictable range.

My preferred method of execution would have been strapping that guy to a cruise missile with a starlink action cam and firing him at Iran but whatever.

My preferred method of execution would have been strapping that guy to a cruise missile with a starlink action cam and firing him at Iran but whatever.

Evil Overlord Rule #4 really applies to everyone: "Shooting IS good enough for my enemies."

The government is bad and is not justified in the morally wrong things that it does.

Morally wrong things not being justified morally is a tautology. Under what moral system is execution of murderers wrong?

There is no evidence that we need a government at all

Government is an irreducible constant in all human society at any scale. Cooperation requires coordination requires hierarchy.

And all excuses made about retribution and desert are quite hypocritical as soon as you dissolve the silly magic of the thin tinpot badge that separates member of the state from human being.

Let's suppose we abolish the state. Do you like it better if individual families coordinate retribution against those who kill their members? Killing the egregiously guilty is an emergent property of human nature, not the state. The state's contribution is to add rules and safeguards to keep this behavior within bounds. You appear to be teeing up objections to prisons as well, but the existing state is already well-past the point of sustainability in terms of restraining the human instinct toward retribution. Remove the state and you will see much, much, much more retributive killing, not less.

Clan based societies actually don't use the death penalty very much- they punish serious crimes with fines, that the entire family of the guilty pays into. Feuds happen when the two clans can't agree about it. The death penalty tends to be a feature of states.

Why yes, but we are not 2 bantu tribes with 10 members each living on an island.

What's to stop people from organizing a state to violently take the resources of other stateless people? It seems to me that at the very least a state can serve to protect you from other states. I don't see any viable alternatives without fundamentally changing human nature, and if a solution requires changing human nature I don't think it's a very practical solution.

Any system which says killing is generally wrong. In a time before prisons one could say that less killing was likely to happen overall if murderers were executed in a timely fashion. However this is not timely or necessary under that standard since the prison prevents him from killing anyone else.

Prisons are morally reprehensible. Justice should be instantaneous - the criminal fined, beaten, exiled or killed - and the matter resolved. Locking people up for years and decades in what are effectively slow-torture chambers, and requiring others to staff those prisons, and requiring law-abiding taxpayers to fund all that, that is unjust and disgusting.

Any system which says killing is generally wrong.

So... the Amish? I'm not Amish, and I'm pretty sure you're not Amish. America has never been ruled by such a system. No European, and indeed no Asian or African or South-American or Australian or Middle-Eastern nation I'm aware of has ever been ruled by such a system. I understand that hypothetical moral systems meeting this definition exist, and I understand that particular religious or philosophical communities exist attempting to follow such systems; these latter universally exist within much larger, far more complex systems which work the other way.

In a time before prisons one could say that less killing was likely to happen overall if murderers were executed in a timely fashion. However this is not timely or necessary under that standard since the prison prevents him from killing anyone else.

Prisons are for crimes that don't merit execution; those prisoners would be better off without having to cohabitate with the murderous. Prisons obviously do not prevent murder, and I am not buying arguments that this is due to lack of interest in preventing prison murder.

So was famine and many other maladies until recently.

I can point to complex societies without famine. You cannot point to complex societies without hierarchy.

Evidence required. With one caveat, I am not anti-hierarchy, I am anti state.

What is your definition of hierarchy? Can you point me to a real-world, actual example of a large-scale, complex, hierarchical non-state-run society?

Yes it is better because it is less territorial and violent.

It is often said that the police are just the largest gang. In a comparison between the police of a city and the non-police gangs, which do we observe being less territorial and less violent? Which do we observe normal citizens preferring to live under? We recently ran an experiment with drastically reducing or eliminating policing; does it seem to you that the results of this experiment supported the idea that policing was more violent and more territorial than non-policing?

Charlie Kirk was murdered by a private individual for political ends. Bryan Malinowski was, in my view, murdered by the federal government, likewise for political ends. I consider both murders serious problems. Nonetheless, it seems to me that Kirk's murder is a much more serious problem and a much harder problem to solve than Malinowski's. In the case of Malinowski, there is a legible off-switch to the murder machine, even if it's difficult to access and operate. In Kirk's case, there is no off switch and the threat is essentially unbounded.

Funny that the Catholic Church had no problem burning women at the stake for wearing male pants when they were powerful. Now they are weak so they cry about this because they would be irrelevant otherwise. This guy should have been killed years ago. He deserves no dignity because he gave none to his victims. Just shoot him behind closed doors without any fanfare and be done with it.

Yeah the current situation of 'We have legitimacy and continuity with a 2000 year old institution but somehow align perfectly with woke-left Lib talking points everywhere that counts now' for the Church is pretty embarrassing. What's the canonical approach if 200 years from now the prevailing morality has gone back right?

The church does not align perfectly with woke lib-left talking points. They merely happen to oppose the death penalty, as is elite consensus in Europe, even on the right.

It's generally best to model the Catholic church as having similar policy positions to the Europe's conservative elite- because by and large, that is who makes up the upper church administration. Bishops in the Roman curia are mostly from elite, conservative families in continental Europe. That means that yes, they believe in global warming, don't have vibes based opposition to immigration(because that's not an elite thing), oppose the death penalty, don't support the right to bear arms, etc- but also have hardline sexual morality views, are generally opposed to socialism, tend to be bioconservative, support gender roles, etc. The RCC is run by elites and has official positions which tend to be shifted towards elite consensus.

Europe's conservative elite

Are just as bad as the left. They've been doing everything in their power to be as innefectual and incompetent against the neocon/neolib "NWO" (and I am using this term unironically because there is only so many times you can gesture at the deepstate and "Globohomo" before you start sounding like Alex Jones.)

They have conserved nothing and the only thing that's dragging them into a more right-ward shift is the rise of anti-immigrant alternative right parties.

I believe that executions should be as public as a court trial. Open to the public, news people can bring cameras, the event has limited seating and there is an enforced somber, serious attitude. Violating that seriousness leads to jail time.

Trump saying the government, the group executing the person, will be broadcasting it makes it into a spectacle that is unworthy of the seriousness of the event.

I think a firing squad is far more appropriate than a lethal injection.

I am religiously bound to also assent that the government has other options than killing people and they should just resort to those.

news people can bring cameras ...

Trump saying the government, the group executing the person, will be broadcasting it

Do we even know if the government will be doing the livestream versus just meaning they will let cspan and cnn and co in and let them broadcast live?

Does it even matter if cspan does the broadcast versus the government itself?

Good on you, America. I wish we in Europe would actually kill the people who try to and do kill us, but we're too warped to do it.

Part of the problem with this administration, widely noted, is its tendency to maximally ragebait while being ineffective, which draws all the ire and force of the left while also failing to accomplish most of the right’s priorities (see deportations).

I have no problem with the government publishing or even streaming an important record of this historical event. The ‘martyrs’ argument is dubious; Islamist propagandists have plenty of footage they can use from Gaza, Iran, Assad’s Syria and so on that is more visceral and powerful.

But just announce it on the day, two hours before it happens, and then do it.

What if "ragebait" and "effectiveness" are proportional? What if there is no way to be "effective" with out inciting rage? Would you urge us to be maximally ineffective out of courtesy?

I disagree and think 2rafa is on point here. It's generally not effectiveness that elicits rage in the cultural war but the utilization of symbolism i.e. attacking symbols one way or another. This particular decision about making the execution public acts as ragebait without providing one ounce of political utility to Trump. It's not that one should abandon effectiveness out of courtesy but that political measures are to be effective whether they induce rage or not.

This makes us no better than Al Qaeda!

I am concerned that the Trump administration will, yet again, find some way to botch the aesthetics of the occasion, reveling in low-class pandering and/or ostentatious cruelty.

That’s literally the whole point. This is supposed to be the American version of a beheading video mailed to Al Jazeera. It’s like how Trump ends his most particularly angry tweets with “Praise be to Allah”.

It’s like how Trump ends his most particularly angry tweets with “Praise be to Allah”.

As some one who has bothered to read up on these desert religions it pains me greatly how normies think this is some sort of gotcha while all these fuckers are literally worshiping the same Abrahamic god, with several coats of new editions of prophet paint.

It’s not a gotcha, but Trump is intentionally using the Arabic phrasing because in the American mind it sounds a lot harder.

I'm somewhat against the death probably but if we're going to be doing this stuff we may as well livestream it.

Hiding it is really the worst thing you could do. If we're that ashamed of it we shouldn't be doing it! My aesthetics demand we embrace the brutal reality. Just like how I think if you want to eat chicken you should know what it's like to slaughter one.

Whether or not it becomes a spectacle isn't really my concern.

In the days when people had to kill their own meat, they prized it more. I can tell you that taking little kids hunting does not stop them from eating backstrap.

Hiding it is really the worst thing you could do. If we're that ashamed of it we shouldn't be doing it! My aesthetics demand we embrace the brutal reality. Just like how I think if you want to eat chicken you should know what it's like to slaughter one.

I tend to agree with this. In the United States, we're very far removed from death.

However as a guy who has slaughtered hundreds of chickens I can tell you that if anything it makes you less sympathetic to their plight.

Does working in the butchery business make chicken tendies less apetizing?

No, although for me it was a temporary gig.

find some way to botch the aesthetics of the occasion, reveling in low-class pandering and/or ostentatious cruelty.

What other reasons are there for someone to watch a livestreamed execution? I have no problem with this guy being executed, but I also have no desire to watch it, and don't understand why anyone would, other than the gore fetishists who will be jerking off to it. I really don't see why satisfying those people is worth the national security risks of helping to martyr a muslim terrorist, which is exactly what he wanted all along.

I don't like it aesthetically, but I disagree with posters who say this will be bad for Trump or for the death penalty.

Consider what has brought us to the current moment. It takes like 20 years and 5 million dollars to execute someone and then we try to do it in a medical way but can't even do that correctly.

We have proven beyond the shadow of a doubt that there is no way to perform executions that will satisfy the critics, just like we can't build nuclear power or high speed rail in California.

So Trump flips the table and does things in a way calculated to maximally piss off his haters. I doubt Trump is making an explicit political calculation, but when the usual suspects shed tears over an evil terrorist who killed people (and they will), it will polarize people to Trump's benefit.

It's a good reminder that Trump is a creation of the media. Like Roko's basilisk, he was willed into being by the very people who fear and loathe him the most. Every moment spent hating him makes him grow stronger. Best just to say, "yeah, he's right, evil terrorist is evil", not watch the video, and sleep soundly.

Personally, I'll cheer on the Golem who kills my enemies, even if he also muddies up the town square.

but can't even do that correctly.

At some point we have to concede they botched that woman's execution on purpose. Like how incompetent can a managerial state get.

It's not like the state doesn't have access to fentanyl. You can't botch an overdose. There are even other less drug oriented ways to make a surefire and painless execution like an exit bag. The brain gets hypoxia before the body realizes whats happening as we don't really have an oxygen in the blood sensor, we have carbon buildup in the blood sensor, so a steady stream of something like helium is enough.

We have proven beyond the shadow of a doubt that there is no way to perform executions that will satisfy the critics

It seems more like the current system is a compromise between people who support the death penalty and people who oppose it no matter the method used. But the problem is that you can't compromise between killing people and not killing them, so we ended up just killing them in the least violent way possible, which turns out to be inhumane. The current system satisfies nobody. It's simply very difficult to implement the death penalty in an enlightened society where people have rights. We are too civilized to do it correctly, but too barbaric to give it up.

A quick peruse of historical archives seems to indicate that newsreels showing war criminals getting terminated were commonplace in the past even in western nations. Nevertheless I do feel like it's quite tasteless. Hopefully they can think of something somewhat reserved like show the guy getting tied up to the pole then just show the squad doing their thing. Either way it's nothing that hasn't been done before many times so there's precedent on the staging and ceremony, so they won't have much to fuck up having to make it up.

I just want to note that I like the optics of him being crippled. If he was a strong Arab man who proudly stands his ground it might make for good martyrdom propaganda. Instead he will hopefully appear weak and pathetic, which I think will be more impactful to the target audience of potential jihadis.

America has no collective moral standard. So what else can one expect than complete chaos?

To put things in perspective, the eugenic argument for killing violent criminals is simple and straightforward. The argument for reveling in their death is different. As someone who has always been vary of group pathologies, this event and the surrounding characters make it feel like we are skirting the line.

As an example, killing a child rapist is just. But making a spectacle of the event where the intent is to invoke some emotional gratification or celebration goes beyond chasing the mere utility of ending a bad life. Good people don't enjoy suffering. The true celebration of ending the lives of criminals comes in the form of safe and happy societies that are free from the terror of living with bad people who allow themselves to cause undue suffering.

This should be especially obvious to those of the 'Christian' persuasion. Of which, one has to conclude, most Red Tribe Americans are not. If you feel anger or hatred for someone, the 'Christian' thing to do is for you to forgive them, if only to save yourself and those around you. Wrath is a sin. And if your conception of these events differs greatly from this Christian framework, you're probably not 'western'. That does not mean letting criminals go free, you should still seek justice. But beyond that justice you have a life to live.

It might be the case that the modern western person is simply too sheltered and cowardly to face the reality of what the third world necessitates. And that the 'spectacle' of the act is necessary in some way. But until such arguments are made, this feels like another slip towards barbarity. If this guy was to be executed, walk into his jailcell in the middle of the night and end him. Everything else is degenerate. I mean, he is paralyzed from the waist down, no? Are you going to shoot a guy in a wheelchair?

And as has been overviewed, the third worlder is no stranger to public executions. And dying a martyr for your cause is not something you should fear. So the only people not understanding what is going on from any angle are the 'westerners'

Keeping the proceedings focused primarily on the victims, including testimony by survivors such as this guy may help to quell any instinctive sympathy for the condemned that viewers could otherwise experience.

Listening to this person made me sympathize with the soon to be martyr. It could only be deduced from this interview that some Americans are incapable of understanding the suffering of others.

I am going to say it is called -- it's God's will. You live by the sword and you die by the sword. The way he went about doing his deed was a coward's way. We didn't have any way to defend ourselves that day and he chose in his terms was a soft target.

An American saying this about a middle Eastern terrorist is beyond a joke. America has no moral currency in that part of the world. It was all spent on the graves of children. 'They should not shoot our soldiers when they are not prepared' is laughable, and further serves to highlight just how morally lost America is.

Are you going to shoot a guy in a wheelchair?

It was good enough for the Brits.

I mean the government of most modern Democratic countries is whatever the collective electorate has decided at the present time. It by definition cannot be a singular principle other then vox populi suprema lex esto “the will of the people is the supreme law”.

Wrath is a sin.

This is true inasmuch as "wrath" is, when used technically, the sinful version of anger, but anger is not itself sinful in the Christian tradition.

If this guy was to be executed, walk into his jailcell in the middle of the night and end him. Everything else is degenerate.

Doing this is how the Soviets did it. Secret executions are the tool of repressive governments everywhere, and breed secrecy and fear. The Western tradition is one of public executions. The condemned also has, in the Western tradition, certain last rights that would be abrogated by executing him in his cell while he slept. As far as I know it is routine for other executions in the United States allow outside witnesses to attend.

You can argue that these are outdated ideas but understand that in the Western tradition you reference shooting someone in the back of the head in their cell block pattern-matches onto totalitarian regimes, whereas a public execution is pretty much the staple Anglo-American tradition.

Now you can also argue, I think, that livestreaming it is a bad idea. But it seems to me that we can address the question of if executions should be public and if they should be livestreamed separately.

Listening to this person made me sympathize with the soon to be martyr.

Why? He killed a pregnant woman who was his comrade-in-arms.

An American saying this about a middle Eastern terrorist is beyond a joke.

Nidal Hasan is not a Middle Eastern terrorist, he is an American citizen and soldier, born in Virginia, who shot his fellow soldiers to death when they were unarmed in a place of trust.

Executions are generally attended to by a cleric of the condemned's faith, a journalist from the associated press, and a doctor as well as prison officials, right?

I don't know the details of each state, but I think that something like what you are describing is typical. I believe there may be other outside witnesses as well.

Nidal Hasan is not a Middle Eastern terrorist, he is an American citizen and soldier, born in Virginia, who shot his fellow soldiers to death

I think the fact that this sentence exists demonstrates the weakness of the 'American citizen' bit in being the sole definition of who is (or should be) an American.

Clearly, calling this man is a terrorist, that's not a partisan statement. And clearly he is Middle Eastern (which is why his parents called him Nidal instead of James). His attack was motivated by his Middle Eastern religion and his attachment to his fellow Middle Easterners. He may have had American paperwork, and even an American accent, but he clearly did not consider himself American in a meaningful sense of the word.

Clearly, calling this man is a terrorist, that's not a partisan statement.

The definition of a "terrorist" is famously almost always a subject of contention. I don't particularly mind applying it to Hasan.

he clearly did not consider himself American in a meaningful sense of the word.

Oh, so you think that if he doesn't consider himself an American, then he's not? Interesting. Do people get to pick whatever citizenship they want, now? Does this mean that someone who does consider himself an American is? Maybe the whole world is American (except Nidal Hasan, who is a "Middle Easterner")? I think the answer to all of these questions is "no." So Hasan is an American.

I understand the idea of being (let's say) "spiritually American" or saying that Hasan is "not a true American" – very reasonable rhetorical statements – but this guy had the rights, privileges, and duties of an American, by virtue of being an American citizen. He is, legally, an American citizen. And in terms of his behavior, he deserves to be treated as one, because to do otherwise cheapens his crime.

If you think that citizenship is not something to be cheapened by importation and dilution but rather a sacred bond held between fellow-citizens with attendant rights and duties, then you believe in holding people to that.

Palestinians are special. They're internationally considered Palestinians even if they acquire another citizenship, and so are their descendants. Once a Palestinian, forever the line is so attainted.

They aren't that special, they're just using the same standard as Jews.

Not even in the slightest. If you convert away from Judaism, you are no longer a Jew and if you are a woman your future children aren't automatically Jewish either. Also Judaism is a religion and not a nationality; while Israel has the law of return, it only says Jews can become Israeli citizens, not that they ARE Israeli citizens.

If you convert to Christianity or Islam then you're no longer a Jew but if you become an atheist you still count and can apply for your "Right to Return". Inversely, if a Palestinian converts to Judaism their requests to become Israeli will be rejected and they're just as liable to be gunned down at a checkpoint as any other goy. The only religious requirement is defiance of Christ.

Plenty of cultural-only Jews at this point who'd still be considered thoroughly Jewish by the outer world. Most of the Seinfeld cast are the platonic example of New York Jews and I believe they don't actually practice.

Oh, so you think that if he doesn't consider himself an American, then he's not?

If America truly is a 'proposition nation' with no ethnic requirements to be a member then pretty much. if America is simply a (very successful) economic zone where citizenship is just a piece of paper that grants you access, like a software key, then America isn't a nation at all.

I guess the point I was responding to was your sentence that Hasan was not a middle eastern terrorist, he was an American, as if those things are mutually exclusive. I would argue that Hasan is 100% a middle eastern terrorist, even if he is also 100% a US citizen, because all citizenship is just a piece of paper. If Britain was invaded by France tomorrow and we were all stripped of our citizenship to be made subjects of the French Empire, Britain as a nation would continue to exist. Because, to put it crudely, civic nationalism is fake.

If America truly is a 'proposition nation' with no ethnic requirements to be a member then pretty much. if America is simply a (very successful) economic zone where citizenship is just a piece of paper that grants you access, like a software key, then America isn't a nation at all.

I don't think these are the only ways to think about how citizenship and country work. There's an older understanding of citizenship that is more akin to being bound in a sacred pact – like adoption. As far as I can tell, ethnic groups all have some way of bringing non-co-ethics into the "in-group" ethnic circle. If you think Americanness should be an ethnicity, when is an idea that I am sympathetic to, then citizenship is that ritual.

I would argue that Hasan is 100% a middle eastern terrorist, even if he is also 100% a US citizen, because all citizenship is just a piece of paper.

This is precisely what I think we should all deny. "Citizenship is just a piece of paper" commodifies and cheapens citizenship, the opposite values you should be pushing if you want people to think in ways that are transcendent instead of being non-transactional.

There's an older understanding of citizenship that is more akin to being bound in a sacred pact – like adoption.

Except Hasan was not a naturalised citizen. He never took an oath of loyalty or was willingly adopted into the country. There was no 'ritual' at all. The model of citizenship you describe is clearly incompatible with birthright citizenship, which involves handing out citizenship to babies of (both legal and illegal) immigrants.

This is precisely what I think we should all deny. "Citizenship is just a piece of paper" commodifies and cheapens citizenship

I would say that giving out citizenship like candy is what cheapens and commodifies it. Describing it as just a piece of paper is simply being honest about the world.

The model of citizenship you describe is clearly incompatible with birthright citizenship, which involves handing out citizenship to babies of (both legal and illegal) immigrants.

Hasan's parents were, as far as I can tell, legal immigrants and became naturalized citizens (a bit unclear to me if that happened before or after he was born), so opposing birthright citizenship for illegal aliens doesn't really "solve" here. Giving birthright citizenship to the children of citizens is not much, if it all, different than the model you seem to think would be preferable, of being born into an ethnic group.

However, I don't disagree with the criticism. If I was King Of The World, citizenship (and adulthood, for that matter) would likely be earned by deed, not birth.

Describing it as just a piece of paper is simply being honest about the world.

I don't want to live in such a world, nor do I agree that that is an honest description of what citizenship has long been understand to entail in the American tradition, so I decline to follow your lead here.

More comments

Oh, so you think that if he doesn't consider himself an American, then he's not? Interesting. Do people get to pick whatever citizenship they want, now? Does this mean that someone who does consider himself an American is?

You have this backwards. Hasan not considering himself an American isn't a positive point of evidence, it's counter-evidence (and a damning finisher) against the Propositional Nation position.

And yes, that's the fundamental absurdity. He's legally an American, yet clearly holds no bonds of brotherhood and fellowship for the rest of us. Instead, his true tribe is co-ethnics and co-religionists from the other side of the world, to the point where he was willing to commit mass murder about it.

He's legally an American, yet clearly holds no bonds of brotherhood and fellowship for the rest of us. Instead, his true tribe is co-ethnics and co-religionists from the other side of the world

Let's set aside the degree to which is tribal affinity with co-ethics and co-religionists on the other side of the world is a deadly LARP and agree that this is true: claiming that he is Middle Eastern obscures this and the problem (which exists to some degree in America and from what I can tell to a much larger degree in Europe) of second-generation radicalization.

If you think it's bad that Hasan doesn't consider himself an American despite being one, you shouldn't confuse people into thinking he's not American by referring to him as Middle Eastern. You should explicitly highlight exactly what he was, and highlight how it came to be that he continued to serve in the U.S. Armed Forces despite expressing affinity with America's enemies openly.

to the point where he was willing to commit mass murder about it.

As we've seen in this very thread, calling him a "Middle Easterner" seems to make it easier for people to believe that what he did was not mass murder but rather a surprise attack on enemy combatants. It casts him as someone who was true to his deepest self and therefore in some sense admirable rather than someone who betrayed his most sacred confidences.

When the news headline is "US kills American citizen by surprise attack without trial", the phrase 'Middle Easterner' doesn't typically get used by the media, even though such a headline is guaranteed to be about a Middle Easterner.

I would like to do better than news headlines!

And clearly he is Middle Eastern (which is why his parents called him Nidal instead of James).

Excellent point. Real Americans have names like 'Running Bear' or 'Flying Eagle'.

Excellent point. Real Americans have names like 'Running Bear' or 'Flying Eagle'.

People who call their children names like that tend to identify primarily as members of their (pre-American) tribe, and not primarily as Americans, which kind of proves my point.

Oh, when you said 'American', you meant 'UnitedStates-ian'.

I'm not sure I've made my point clear. As far as I am aware, there is no coherent ideological framework that justifies giving those of English extraction a special claim to the territories of both the United Kingdom and the United States.

One can either:

  1. claim that particular areas of land belong immutably to certain ancestral groups, which would endorse the Daily-Mail reading gammons' calls for remigration of the London-born children and grandchildren of South Asians from England, but also demand the remigration of white people form North America (and possibly the English from Scotland and Wales);

  2. reject ancestral blood-and-soil claims, and judge individuals not by their ethnicity or the etymology of their names but by their personal actions, drawing no distinction between Mr Hasan and a hypothetical alternate-timeline perpetrator born James Anglesax, whose ancestors arrived on the Mayflower or the Susan Constant and who converted to an extremist form of Islam and committed a similar massacre; or

  3. recognise land as belonging to whichever group is capable of seizing it by force, which would dissolve any ethical high ground between 'a descendant of Englishmen killing a descendant of Arabs to maintain the status quo' and 'a descendant of Arabs killing a descendant of Englishmen to overturn the status quo', and incentivise a metric arse-load of bloodshed until partisans of option 2 manage to establish a claim on behalf of All the descendants of the last common ancestor of all humans to the third planet from a ~two octillion tonne yellow dwarf star in the Orion-Cygnus arm, for now.

All three are logically coherent, but as someone who would greatly prefer that violence be kept to a minimum, I favour the second option.

False difference. All three can be true at the same time, and indeed I think they are. This land is my land, this clay is our clay. I won this clay by slaughtering those other guys who did not speak my language. It's still their clay but now I own it and my blood will own it too later until they fumble their inheretance and give it away to people who hate them for existing. The plight of those who came before me does not make me regret owning it.

That's not all three; it's missing No. 2, i. e. the only one that gives us a chance of getting to the stars.

I do not condone what Mr Hasan did. The only reason I don't support his execution is that it leaves society with no further measures to apply to even worse crimes. Be that as it may, however, the murders at Fort Hood were a crime committed by one individual against forty-five other individuals. They were not committed by 'the Arab race' against 'the white race'. (Two of the slain, Maj. Libardo Eduardo Caraveo and Pfc. Kham See Xiong, were born in Mexico and Thailand.)

More comments

I'm not sure I've made my point clear. As far as I am aware, there is no coherent ideological framework that justifies giving those of English extraction a special claim to the territories of both the United Kingdom and the United States.

I didn't say there was. I said that both Hasan and his parents identified primarily as Muslim Arabs and not as Americans. Which seems pretty obvious to me. Some ethnic groups in America do chose to identify as Americans, which is why, for example, Chinese Americans give their children names like Andrew, Amy and Jenny instead of Wei and Fang.

Did you mean to respond to somebody else?

Wrong America. The one you're talking about got done in by unchecked immigration.

This is true inasmuch as "wrath" is, when used technically, the sinful version of anger, but anger is not itself sinful in the Christian tradition.

So when I use the term wrath in this context we could conclude that I am talking about the sinful version of anger. To that extent I think it's very obvious that anyone seeking out glee or spectacle in another persons death is acting in a sinful way. In this context we presume it is out of anger or revenge, which would necessarily be sinful. A better Christian would recognize just law and capital punishment, along with the necessity to personally forgive the perpetrator to save their own soul.

Doing this is how the Soviets did it.

There's nothing secret about publicly sentencing someone to death in a court of law, killing them in a manner not publicized and then announcing that they have been executed.

The western tradition of public executions, along with burning witches, is generally not what people think of when talking about 'the west' which more often refers to the post enlightenment period and the major upswing in technology and standards of living through the 18th and 19th century. Which coincides with decreases in public executions and capital punishments along with a host of other social revolutions.

Why? He killed a pregnant woman who was his comrade-in-arms.

The US army has killed plenty of pregnant women in Nidal's lifetime. Should one only sympathize with pregnant women getting killed when they are American? That's what many Americans earnestly believe. Expressing themselves as completely incapable of recognizing any hostile act taken against them from the viewpoint of its perpetrators.

Nidal Hasan is not a Middle Eastern terrorist, he is an American citizen and soldier, born in Virginia, who shot his fellow soldiers to death when they were unarmed in a place of trust.

Nidal Hasan is a middle Eastern terrorist. He has a stamp from the US government and a birthplace far from his actual homelands, but knows in his heart exactly who he is. A martyr for a cause he believes is just, who shot enemy combatants in a successful ambush.

Maybe one day American soldiers will stop killing unarmed people in 'places of trust' the world over, but until they do, there's little rational to mourn them beyond anyone else when the shoe is on the other foot.

So when I use the term wrath in this context we could conclude that I am talking about the sinful version of anger.

Not everyone is aware of the distinction, though.

There's nothing secret about publicly sentencing someone to death in a court of law, killing them in a manner not publicized and then announcing that they have been executed.

This gives rise to speculations that the condemned was tortured the death, or not killed at all. Both are bad.

Which coincides with decreases in public executions and capital punishments along with a host of other social revolutions.

Actually, at least in England, the post-enlightenment period lead to the "Bloody Code" and a rise in executions, which were often public and treated as a spectacle.

The US army has killed plenty of pregnant women in Nidal's lifetime.

This is a false equivalency and you know it, or should know it.

That's what many Americans earnestly believe.

Please quantify this statement and back it up with polling numbers or another citation.

Expressing themselves as completely incapable of recognizing any hostile act taken against them from the viewpoint of its perpetrators.

It's curious how one could get such a perspective. Certainly not from reading American novelists (such as Tom Clancy), or American scholars (such as Lawrence Wright) or American journalists (such as John Hersey) or American combatants (like Ian Fritz) or interacting with American Mottizens (we have GWOT vets on here, and I've never gotten that impression from them at all; rather the opposite.)

Nidal Hasan is a middle Eastern terrorist.

Repeating something doesn't make it true.

Maybe one day American soldiers will stop killing unarmed people in 'places of trust' the world over, but until they do, there's little rational to mourn them beyond anyone else when the shoe is on the other foot.

It is rational to punish traitors because the harm of their actions erodes trust, and as I think you know, a lower-trust society is a worse one.

This gives rise to speculations that the condemned was tortured the death, or not killed at all. Both are bad.

I'm not getting this. Aside from being tortured by other inmates, which is routine in American prisons, I see no reason to assume that a prison intended for general population inmates or a military prison would begin torturing inmates because they changed the way they execute them. You could just as well torture them and execute them via firing squad.

Actually, at least in England, the post-enlightenment period lead to the "Bloody Code" and a rise in executions, which were often public and treated as a spectacle.

The code was not supported by the people. Which is why executions went down, despite more capital punishment law being passed. And it was then ultimately abolished. In either case, people don't associate 'the west' with public executions. But rather the modern justice system that came after.

This is a false equivalency and you know it, or should know it.

It's not. But people who are emotionally unable to sympathize with people born too far away do believe that it is.

Please quantify this statement and back it up with polling numbers or another citation.

I'm referring to the person in the Fox interview, people who share his sentiment, you and other pro-America guys on here. Who ultimately draw the distinction between good and bad, with America on the good side of every conflict. And they don't see that as unreasonable or questionable.

It's curious how one could get such a perspective. Certainly not from reading American novelists (such as Tom Clancy), or American scholars (such as Lawrence Wright) or American journalists (such as John Hersey) or American combatants (like Ian Fritz) or interacting with American Mottizens (we have GWOT vets on here, and I've never gotten that impression from them at all; rather the opposite.)

I get it from interacting with Americans. What is most peoples reaction to Timothy McVeigh when he called the children killed in the bombing 'Collateral Damage'? Yet so many Americans fail to imagine why some people refer to America as the great Satan.

Repeating something doesn't make it true.

We agree on that. What we disagree on, it appears, is what makes someone a national of a nation. With two Palestinian parents, I think you are a Palestinian.

It is rational to punish traitors because the harm of their actions erodes trust, and as I think you know, a lower-trust society is a worse one.

Sure?

You could just as well torture them and execute them via firing squad.

Generally speaking, when people are tortured it leaves marks that witnesses to executions will notice.

In either case, people don't associate 'the west' with public executions. But rather the modern justice system that came after.

Who's "people"? I'm a Westerner, and I do. I have been in favor of public executions since I was in high school or before, in part because it is part of the Western, Anglo-American tradition.

I do understand the push-back against live-streaming it and the concerns about making it a spectacle, or that it might be a bad idea in this specific case. Those arguments track with me. But the idea that "here in the West we don't execute people publicly" doesn't, because it's not true.

you and other pro-America guys on here. Who ultimately draw the distinction between good and bad, with America on the good side of every conflict. And they don't see that as unreasonable or questionable.

Do you really think this is an accurate description of me based on my posting history?

Even if you are confusing me with Shakes, Trump's Own Strongest Soldier, I doubt this would be an accurate description.

I get it from interacting with Americans.

Well, I think I am beginning to understand why. It should not surprise you if even the most reasonable and open-minded of people will become a raging nationalist when you paint people of their nationalities with a broad and unflattering brush.

You should read the authors I mentioned. They are emblematic of what Americans read: Clancy was a tremendously popular novelist during the Cold War with the American right; Wright wrote a popular and interesting account of the path to 9/11; Hersey's writing about Hiroshima is, I believe, commonly taught to American students in grade school; and Fritz wrote in the Atlantic, one of America's most prestigious publications.

With two Palestinian parents, I think you are a Palestinian.

His parents were Americans also.

America specifically has popularized many ways by which you can torture people and not leave a mark. So if a prison institution were committed to torturing their death row inmates and believed they could hide those acts, and I don't know why that would become the case if you were to not execute those inmates in public, they could presumably do just that.

But the idea that "here in the West we don't execute people publicly" doesn't, because it's not true.

Most modern western nations don't execute people, full stop. The ones who did public executions dropped the practice before the turn of the 20th century. Did they do so in the past? Yes, but 12 year olds working in factories for 14 hours a day was also a thing in the past, but is not associated with 'western values'.

Do you really think this is an accurate description of me based on my posting history?

I don't know. I based it on your reply to me here, where you acted with incredulity towards the assumed legitimacy of the targets of Nidal Hasan. Who were all but one, as far as I can tell, directly involved with the US military in one way or another. Alongside that I think the Fox News interview was very emblematic of exactly the kind of viewpoint blindness that I see afflicting many Americans.

As an example, from the Fox interview which another person thought would make people less sympathetic to Nidal, acting like a military base is a 'place of trust' and that the military personnel therein where defenseless, and therefor the attack was cowardly. And that if Nidal had honor, he would have challenged the American servicemen to hand to hand combat. I mean, it takes me a while to get past the absurdity of hearing such things said, but to examine it further, did the US military conduct itself with such honor? Or did they kill close to half a million civilians through war campaigns across the middle east? Where none of those men, women and children in a place of trust?

I'm not surprised when Americans who consider themselves reasonable and open minded rise on their hindlegs whenever the legitimacy of their tremendously stupid and murderous zionist foreign policy is questioned. Because despite their beliefs about themselves as being reasonable and open minded, they're often actually not all that. They just egotistically believe that about themselves, whilst acting with complete disregard for anyone and anything but themselves and their preconceived notions of 'America's interest'.

And to follow your point about open minded American literary figures, as dramatic as all the media Americans make about the atrocities they commit can be, whilst cathartic for the American, doesn't actually absolve Americans of the reality of those atrocities that they committed. It's actually quite perverted to murder hundreds of thousands of people and then write a book about how horrifying that was. And then make a big deal about how bad you feel about that. But then just repeat the process as soon as some foreign policy idiot theorists conception of America's hegemony gets threatened.

His parents were Americans also.

As I said, we have a different definition of what a national is. You think it's the stamp from the government or similar. Which is a historically absurd definition that contradicts the etymology of the word 'nation'. I think it's your ancestry. If you don't want to engage with the topic, fine, but these assertions are inane. A person born of two Palestinian parents is Palestinian. He proved that with his actions as well.

The point I am trying to get at as regards executions is that appearances are important, and executing people in secret is a bad appearance. Even if you don't think people's executions should be public, you shouldn't want witnesses removed. Even if you can secretly torture people without leaving marks (which yes, we can) you should not act in such a way as to needlessly arouse suspicion that you are doing so.

I don't know. I based it on your reply to me here, where you acted with incredulity towards the assumed legitimacy of the targets of Nidal Hasan.

The problem with Nidal Hasan's target wasn't that he targeted soldiers. Iran has killed somewhere between a dozen and two dozen soldiers in our war with them and none of the American commentators on here have acted like that was illegitimate in the same way that Hasan's was (or as far as I can remember, at all) because Hasan is an American who turned his gun on his countrymen.

I don't think you can point me to a single star-spangled flag waver on the Motte that has argued that Artesh soldiers, acting in the normal course of their duties, should be executed for the deaths of US soldiers. I think you are mistaking your own ideas about what Americans think with what they actually say they believe. Perhaps you have had other experiences off of the Motte that I can't speak to, but what you are describing of your experiences here does not comport with what I recognize.

acting like a military base is a 'place of trust' and that the military personnel therein where defenseless, and therefor the attack was cowardly.

If you are a soldier and particularly an officer, then yes, a military base is a place of trust, and generally stateside on a military base US soldiers are disarmed, and will go to jail if they carry a weapon on base. (This is a sorry and facile state of affairs, and I think the current admin may be working to change it, which is good).

I am not sure I would say Hasan is a coward but shooting unarmed people is not generally what is associated with courage. I don't think Hasan acted much differently in terms of personal courage than any mass shooter, in the sense that he was brave enough to accept being shot by cops but not brave enough or willing enough to accept defeat to engage armed people from the start. I think that his target set could in some sense be seen as more "legitimate" than bin Laden's in the sense that they were primarily military, but also that his infamy should be greater because he betrayed a position of trust and violated the oath he took.

Or did they kill close to half a million civilians through war campaigns across the middle east?

Did American troops kill close to half a million civilians during the Global War on Terror? No, they did not. The majority of civilian casualties throughout the Global War on Terror were not caused by US troops. I suspect you know this, which is why you used the phrase "through war campaigns" thus absolving the people who actually literally did kill civilians of their actions and rhetorically placing it on people who were innocent of their deaths, while at the same time providing a defense (a motte, if you will) if someone pointed out the inaccuracy.

I think it is completely fine to criticize the outcome of the Global War on Terror (indeed, I have done it myself) and to say that the GWOT led to hundreds of thousands of deaths. I think it is wrong to completely ignore consequentialist reasoning. But saying that the United States killed half a million citizens across the Middle East is no more sensible than saying Al Qaeda killed hundreds of thousands of Middle Easterners through war campaigns across the globe – arguably less sensible, since after all Al Qaeda attacked the States.

It's actually quite perverted to murder hundreds of thousands of people and then write a book about how horrifying that was. And then make a big deal about how bad you feel about that.

Off of the top of my head, there are only two Americans who could reasonably qualify, and I don't think either of them felt bad about what they did, or ever pretended to.

I think it's your ancestry. If you don't want to engage with the topic, fine, but these assertions are inane. A person born of two Palestinian parents is Palestinian. He proved that with his actions as well.

Very well. I shall expect you, then, in the spirit of self-consistency, to refer to Trump as a European leader going forward :)

More comments

The guy is a Palestinian Muslim who just so happened to be born in the US. His actions are reflective of someone who is a Palestinian Muslim jihadist, not of an American schizo. Why didn't he just go shoot up a school or something? It's because he's a Middle Eastern terrorist.

He's not a Middle Eastern terrorist. We can say that he behaved like a Middle Eastern terrorist, or that he shared their sympathies. We can argue that this is true in some spiritual sense, if we want.

But ultimately he was born as an American citizen to American immigrants who naturalized, and despite this he found that his sympathies lay elsewhere, to the degree that he was willing to kill his fellow soldiers out of misplaced affinity towards a group of people who were never really his own.

To claim that he is Middle Eastern is to deflect scrutiny from how he came to be radicalized.

This is just ethnicity denialism.

"Middle Eastern" is not an ethnicity.

More comments

Still seems healthier than the extremely low testosterone botched execution of that satanist murderess recently.

The procedure was marred by severe complications, including the execution team using at least seven needles and failing to establish proper intravenous lines, which likely caused the drug to leak into her tissue rather than enter her bloodstream.

Following the attempt, Pike was found conscious and breathing 40 minutes after the first dose was administered, prompting the execution to be halted. She was rushed to a hospital in critical condition, where she initially suffered from pneumonia, blood clots, and an inability to move her arms. Recent updates indicate she has regained consciousness and is walking and eating, though her lawyers report her prognosis remains unclear and she is dealing with profound psychological trauma.

Governor Bill Lee has suspended all executions for the rest of 2026 and ordered an independent review.

Apparently it's legally impossible to whip out a sidearm and blow her head off, since you can only kill people in the exact way and time that a judge finds pleasing. Otherwise it's something like murder, so that woman has to be rushed off to hospital to save her from the death she was supposed to suffer.

Pike’s legal team is seeking to commute her sentence to life in prison and has requested that all evidence from the failed execution be preserved for potential litigation.

So now the woman who should be dead is going to sue, fantastic.

Ohio’s 2009 attempt to execute Romell Broom failed after hours of trying to find a vein. Courts allowed a retry, but it never happened, and he later died of COVID in prison.

They are constantly failing, delaying, having issues with executions.

There are many arguments about the purpose of capital punishment but I don't think anyone argued for a system where it exists nominally but in practical terms it's for providing lawyers and administrative personnel jobs. Nobody comes out and says that the real metric of success is how many delays and how much expense can be inflicted, as opposed to swift and efficient execution of serious criminals. But that's what the US system actually is. Purpose of the system is what it does and what it does is extract money and find excuses for it. In Pike and Hassan's case there was no doubt or useful justice-enhancing purpose for appeals.

Pike was sentenced to death in 1996, lawyers and the legal system have just been sending little memos back and forth for 30 years rather than producing any actual justice. She attempted to kill someone in prison and also started litigation about her conditions being 'unequal' to male prisoners on death row. Hasan was convicted in 2013.

I suspect Trump's natural instinct is 'to hell with the lawyers, let's blow his head off' rather than careful procedurism, which does have its benefits. I made a post back in 2025 about how tariffs weren't that bad compared to careful, boring procedural sabotage, grifting and wrecking. The harms of tariffs are obvious and overt but aren't necessarily worse than the harms that the experts cause silently and slowly and in a boring, adult, professional manner. Of course there are also overt harms that are worse. But in general, there's something to be said for this stance.

Apparently it's legally impossible to whip out a sidearm and blow her head off, since you can only kill people in the exact way and time that a judge finds pleasing. Otherwise it's something like murder, so that woman has to be rushed off to hospital to save her from the death she was supposed to suffer.

The relevant law is a state statute defining the method of execution. Utah has used a firing squad in the recent past(Utah has a low crime rate and population and does not execute very many people), because the state government chose to define that as a legal method of execution. It's not about 'cruel and unusual' it's 'compliance with state law about carrying out the death penalty'.

Sure, it just seems bizarre that when they miss the vein and she's still alive 40 minutes later, they scramble around looking for lifesaving equipment to save the person they were trying to kill. I understand that they're obeying the law. The law is the issue.

I predict that for Pike there will be a huge investigation, all kinds of new rules will be introduced requiring people to get extensively trained about how to stick needles in people so they can hit veins. Maybe lifesaving equipment will have to be kept in the execution room. Even more procedural epicycles. Pike will sue. Others will sue. Another gazillion dollars to lawyers. The whole ethos here is weak.

Far more likely that they’ll change the law to allow nitrogen asphyxiation.

Apparently it's legally impossible to whip out a sidearm and blow her head off, since you can only kill people in the exact way and time that a judge finds pleasing. Otherwise it's something like murder, so that woman has to be rushed off to hospital to save her from the death she was supposed to suffer.

Well yeah, procedure and oversight is a big part of what distinguishes a justice system from violent chaos. And it's good to have a justice system rather than violent chaos.

No matter how brutal a person's crimes might be, the fact remains that there is a strong incentive to do the entire capital punishment process in a very careful way. A short duration between conviction and execution would lessen the chance of new evidence being discovered to exonerate an innocent person. A brutal and pragmatic approach to the actual execution would add an element of bloodthirstiness that I think it is dangerous to let the government exercise.

Would I care about any of that if the convict was someone who I was convinced had killed a loved one of mine? Almost certainly not. But that's not necessarily a good argument.

A short duration between conviction and execution

Pike was in prison for 30 years. Hasan was convicted in 2013 for a shooting in 2009.

What new evidence could there possibly be for Hasan? It's known he did it, the evidence is incontrovertible. Not wanting to execute people on dubious evidence is one thing, decades of delay is another.

On December 7, 2020, the United States Army Court of Criminal Appeals upheld Hasan's death penalty. On September 11, 2023, the United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces upheld Hasan's death penalty. On March 31, 2025, the United States Supreme Court denied Hasan's final petition for a writ of certiorari, thereby confirming his death sentence.

They're just going around and around in circles.

Or with Pike, we see her lawyers saying 'she was sexually abused when younger and the judge didn't give that enough weight when sentencing.' They don't say 'actually she didn't do it', they're just using delaying tactics.

Some Americans actually pay for this, some individual workers have hours of his time taken from him and given to murderers so their lawyers can file endless pieces of paper for decades, to be read and opposed and rejected by other lawyers. Hasan cost about $10 million + for his trials and appeals, attorneys, legal work, transport by helicopter... Peanuts by government standards of course but an injustice. Entire lifetimes worth of tax have been siphoned from real people and given to lawyers for the sake of this guy.

How is this just? Pike had her chance for legal defence in the first trial. If it meets a high standard of evidence (overwhelming confidence of guilt), then that alone should be sufficient. There doesn't need to be a giant legal circus of increasingly flimsy appeals. Hasan obviously did it, it's an open and shut case.

Past a certain point, procedure doesn't prevent violent chaos but actively impedes swift justice. Excessive quantities of procedure make the US less safe. They put criminals back out into the public because the legal system invents all kinds of reasons for why they weren't supposed to be arrested, or because jails are overcrowded. There's violent chaos in many US cities because of an excessively lenient and exploitable legal system whose most ridiculous aspects are in these death row delays.

Would swift executions result in innocent people dying? Sure. Innocent people are going to die under any system. Mature governance accepts this and has to ration resources. That 10 million worth of legal spending on Hasan is roughly similar to the $9.4-13 million statistical value of an American life. Privileging the worst murderers with these huge investments of resources just because they're particularly legible and known to the legal system (as compared to normal people who get run over, robbed and torturously murdered by the '30 prior offences' crowd) is very counterintuitive.

The current system for the death penalty in the United States actually requires this baroque procedure- Gary Gilmore still had to go through a lengthy process.

It does this less about concern with executing innocent people and more because elite consensus is anti-death penalty but abolitionism is too unpopular to actually do in most of the country.

I think it's good for footage of executions to be released publically, but I must confess as well that the idea of livestreaming this seems a bit uncouth.

I mean, will it be allowed on YouTube? Will Alphabet let the US Government upload cinematically shot HD footage of liter after liter of blood gushing out of a gasping human pincushion? Is it going to be aired on Fox News?

There won't be liters upon liters of blood gushing out. There will be blood, yes, but most of it will remain inside his corpse- .308 rounds do not kill by exsanguination.

They mix blanks in with the real ones. I'd always heard there was only one actual bullet, but trying to read up on it, that may be a myth. Funnily, the reason I was checking was because my daughter thought it was 10 guys just mag dumping into some prisoner with automatics, which is a darkly hilarious mental image.

Funnily, the reason I was checking was because my daughter thought it was 10 guys just mag dumping into some prisoner with automatics, which is a darkly hilarious mental image.

Considering the weapon used in his crime, P90s would be an appropriate (and ironic) choice.

Have the execution guard dressed in the current space force get up if we're going to be using P90s. Maybe one of them could use a plasma caster staff.

The 1947 code specifies 8 rifles, from 1 to 3 blanks. I don't know if they've changed that.

I think that if you are going to be pro death penalty, it is morally consistent to be pro public execution. The only difference to the accused is that more people are aware of what's going on. To be Pro Death Penalty but anti public seems to be a moral cowardice, in essence you want to hide the execution. You don't have a strong enough conviction in (your perceived) inherent correctness of execution and wish to avoid public scrutiny.

If you're against the death penalty but live in a country where it exists you should want it to be public to rally people to your cause and for a sense of openness from the government, that they are not hiding executions and killing in secret.

Is there a reason to be pro death penalty but against public execution? It seems that the vast majority of people I see (admittedly on Reddit which is my imperfect bellwether) that are against it are against the death penalty anyway. They mostly just seem to think it's gauche.

The main reason public execution was curtailed was not that the public was against it, but that the elite were put off that the public was so enthusiastic about it.

Well, obviously; if I was guilty of the same things in a more abstract fashion I'd be fucking terrified too.

I used to find this position compelling: executions should be public and not medicalized. If we are empowering the state to take the lives of prisoners then we should be confronted with the bloody consequences of granting it such power.

I no longer find that compelling. It's not a matter of taste, it's that I don't believe that the people would actually respond with any kind of sober solemnity about the state taking a life. Throughout history public executions haven't been solemn, they've been spectacle.

Probably the right path is to make them public in the same way that court records are public. They're kind of hard to get if you don't know what you're looking for, but if you care enough to make sure the state is performing its duties properly, then you can view all of the executions. Political leaders ought not celebrate or shy away from the executions, but treat them as justice served.

Ececuting a murderer should be an exciting day for the people. Properly, there shouldn't be that many murderers in their community. This is complicated in that we now live in a multi billion person world with many multi million person cities, but the base truth is the same: If someone kills a person or persons in good standing in your community, that evil persons execution is going to be a day of celebration. The defense and appeals bar has ruined this by delaying execution for decades at this point, and a nationally seen execution is historically unheard of, but... arent the victims of Islamic terror all of America? Shouldn't we all have the reminder that Sharia is evil and the enemy of America just as a small town of 900 people in Massachusetts in 1830 would have been reminded that killing the butcher is evil? Shouldn't we be able to rejoice in evil being exterminated just as they did when a rapist in 1910 was executed?

Or must we go along with the people who's role in the world is fighting biology and reality and deny that we think killing bad people is good and pretend to cry when bad people go to prison? Should we keep letting dogs die so coyotes can live?

I no longer find that compelling. It's not a matter of taste, it's that I don't believe that the people would actually respond with any kind of sober solemnity about the state taking a life. Throughout history public executions haven't been solemn, they've been spectacle.

Probably the right path is to make them public in the same way that court records are public. They're kind of hard to get if you don't know what you're looking for, but if you care enough to make sure the state is performing its duties properly, then you can view all of the executions

I agree completely with all of this, except of course there is a fly in the ointment: With computers and the internet, the concept of public records that are "kind of hard to get" is going the way of the dodo-bird. Even if you put the execution video in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying "beware of the leopard," some journalist (professional or amateur) is going to obtain it and post it online.

I don't see anything morally impermissible about public execution, but in 2026 America it will make the whole thing much more controversial and feed a larger anti-death penalty backlash when the Democrats come back to power. So for pragmatic reasons I'm pro death penalty and against public execution.

We don't know that.

Abolishing the death penalty has never passed a popular vote test. It's still unpopular, years after the fact, in many of the places where it's abolished. In all likelihood this guy will be shot and then slump over like a perfect shot on a deer, the 'unnecessary suffering' or 'cruel and unusual angle' just won't be possible to run with. People who watch looking for gore and brutality will come away disappointed, and the people will say eh, he's a bastard, at least they made it quick.

We don't know that, but it's a reasonable thing to think. There are a lot of people - liberals even (the death penalty is pretty popular) - who are fine with shooting this guy but are genuinely taken aback by the perception that Hegseth/Trump/MAGA wants to bring back public executions as an entertainment event. I don't see how this wouldn't embolden the anti-execution side.

"Public entertainment" is the least charitable way to frame it. It is mostly public informing. People should see the states' actions clearly.

My image of American masculinity will always be John Wayne et al, the noble Cowboy gunslinger beloved of early 20th century Hollywood and Louis L'Amour novel. And I just can't imagine a scene in a John Wayne movie where he shot a cripple. I'd imagine such a scene, in which some foppish cavalry captain or Eastern judge sent west, the symbol of government bureaucracy and oppression, asks our protagonist to shoot a cripple. The response, I'd imagine, would go something like Wayne spitting on the ground in front of the judge and saying "I reckon the man deserves to die, but I ain't gonna shoot a man who can't walk."

I asked ChatGPT for the scenario, and it pretty much agreed with me. To be fair, I could probably prompt it to do otherwise, but I think this a reasonable use of the LLM: to conjure the zeitgeist around a stock character and see what the oracle tells us.

The man deserves to die. He deserved to die quite a while ago. But I ain't gonna be the one to shoot him, and I ain't gonna watch.

I say this despite fully agreeing with you that if we are going to execute people, it ought to be the halftime show at Cowboys-Redskins every year in DC. We shouldn't hide behind medicalization and privacy. But shooting a man in a wheelchair is inherently dishonorable, even if it naturally has zero impact on the justice of the sentence being carried out.

This whole thing feels like "vice-signaling," engaging performatively in actions that the individual himself feels to be morally wrong, in order to pick a culture war fight. I don't reckon the federal government ought to be in that business.

The man's in a wheelchair because he was shot while committing mass murder; this does not make him deserving of sympathy. If a John Wayne character had been there, Hasan would have been shot dead on the spot; alas, none was.

I don't think any John Wayne character was an executioner at all. And executions in westerns are typically hangings (though firing squads aren't unknown), and hanging a paraplegic would present a challenge to do properly -- although it has been done.

Why should shooting a man in a wheelchair be dishonorable? It's not like he'd have a chance to live if he had full use of his legs, it's not like he's in a gladiatorial arena or something? There's no substantive difference, only an aesthetic difference. We know songs in a minor theme are more ominous and villain coded but there's no actual reason for that, it's just a convention.

I don't disagree that it does seem dishonorable. But I can't see any reason why.

To be clear my argument is limited to: this is a dishonorable act that ought to be done discreetly, not broadcast proudly, and being proud of doing something dishonorable shows a lack of character. I'm not arguing that he oughtn't to be executed, merely that it oughtn't to be on tv.

If the execution is otherwise acceptable, by definition it's honorable. "He's helpless and can't fight back" doesn't make it dishonorable, otherwise having guards or putting someone behind unbreakable jail bars is also dishonorable.

In the Western scenario, the villain wouldn't have been saved by prompt medical treatment to survive as a cripple in the first place.

My interest in watching is zero, but I don’t have much of a problem with the concept of public execution or public punishments. The current version of execution does little to deter crime, but I think this is more because of how we do them. It’s private, it takes decades to actually kill (or attempt to kill) the condemned, and we do so in a manner that looks like any surgery done in the United States (except that the condemned usually never wakes up). Of freaking course an execution that takes 25 years, is private, and looks like a surgery in almost every way won’t scare anyone straight or give people confidence in the system. Add in a recent fuckup in Tennessee and the current method is exactly the worst possible way to execute someone. You get none of the deterrent effects, you get all of the stupid legal wrangling, you get potential fuckups, and thus it benefits nobody.

In the old days like the old west when you’d hang a guy from a tall tree because he stole a horse, it had an immediate effects on local thieves. They know the guy and know he took a horse last week, and know that the state is deadly serious about protecting property. They know how much it sucks to be hung. And so they’re less likely to do it. For the public, Justice gets served and served quickly. They thus know that their local government is protecting them and their property from being destroyed or taken.

As far as Hassan getting what he wanted, im not sure. The Middle East is not stranger to public punishment. Public floggings and beheadings and so on happen in that region. They’re not squeamish like modern westerners who never see that stuff. If you think that is going to encourage more terrorists, I don’t see it.

They thus know that their local government is protecting them and their property from being destroyed or taken.

Well, yeah- when State capacity is relatively weak relative to the population's ability to simply decide to form their own government, the State actually has to do something if it wants to stay in control.

When State capacity is strong, the State will just import criminals to extract tribute from the population indirectly (they'll be exempt from justice, obviously).

the first public execution in America since 1937

This got me intrigued because I could swear I remember learning it ages ago from some book that the last public execution in the US took place in 1936. I looked around on the internet and it seems most sources also confirm the latter date. Roscoe Jackson's case went down the memory hole apparently. Wikipedia claims that Rainey Bethea's hanging in Kentucky was botched and generated a big media circus which in turn prompted the legislature to end public executions. It should be noted for context that Bethea was convicted of rape and the law they repealed in 1938 specifically stated that executions for convicted rapists be conducted by hanging in the county seat where they raped their victims.

Polarization increases by assenting to the unwarranted anxiety of the fearful. It’s like an anxiety disorder that expands if you take the fear seriously and become evasive. To end polarization, you want to smash the Overton Window so loudly that it shocks everyone in the vicinity and snaps them into the realization that their chronic catastrophizing is lame and boring. I’ve heard the most “polar opposite” views from friends and family and have never felt this was an obstacle to ties or normalcy or whatever.

I think public executions are a good idea. But in this case, I side with Joe Kent: “death by firing squad is borderline too merciful […] it also gives the terrorists free propaganda”. What I would prefer us to do is use MKUltra propaganda to turn Nidal into an atheist, possibly transgender, and habitual pork and alcohol enjoyer. This is much more aversive to would-be terrorists: the idea that you will lose your eternal reward when you are caught and be turned into an infidel who gets the worst punishment. This is better than making him an international news story, as terrorists are probably motivated by some taste for infamy at the same time that they are motivated by extremism. Also, the theatrics of a firing squad always make the offender look cooler than the shooter. I think about St Sebastian and how cool he looks, and he’s pretty much the firing squad victim of antiquity.

Also, IMO it’s possible this is motivated by the Israel elements of the Trump admin more than anything, given that Nidal is Palestinian, not that this matters for judging whether it is a wise decision.

MKUltra propaganda to turn Nidal into an atheist, possibly transgender, and habitual pork and alcohol enjoyer.

Unfortunately I think that would actually legitimately fit the definition of cruel and unusual punishment.

What I would prefer us to do is use MKUltra propaganda to turn Nidal into an atheist, possibly transgender, and habitual pork and alcohol enjoyer.

I think that might be making a few assumptions regarding the effectiveness of MK-ULTRA....

A few leaked videos of a few reprogrammed terrorists getting consensual trains run on them by other inmates would do more to damper the desire to be an Islamic terrorist than 5000 executions.

I think about St Sebastian and how cool he looks, and he’s pretty much the firing squad victim of antiquity.

In his semi-autobiographical novel Confessions of a Mask (1949), Japanese author Yukio Mishima (三島 由紀夫) describes the saintly image that inspired his sexual awakening: “A remarkably handsome youth was bound naked to the trunk of a tree . . . Were it not for the arrows with their shafts deeply sunk into his left armpit and right side, he would seem more a Roman athlete resting from fatigue”.

Mishima famously stated that "inverts" commonly glommed onto the image of St Sebastian pierced by arrows.

I think it makes sense for a homosexual to latch onto the image of the coolest dude. Perhaps this painting of Sebastian has sufficiently heterosexual undertones, or this one

He still looks... kinda gay?

I wonder if this is one of those things that "everyone knows" that just got passed down orally until the Renaissance when a bunch of painters put it down on canvas?

Uh, renaissance painters were a bit, shall we say ... fruity... themselves, and may have been importing their own preferences into their art.

I haven't read Mishima in a while, but I assumed it was the act of being penetrated by the arrow that lead to the fascination.

I’m not planning on watching this. It will, if I’m not much mistaken, make us the only non-Muslim country to carry out a public execution this year, and I have no real interest in watching a 60 year old paraplegic die, no matter how bad he is.

Firing squad is an ipso facto normal thing to do here; military members who swore allegiance to a faction their country was at war with and opened fire on their comrades would be executed even in many countries that formally don’t have a death penalty. I don’t particularly like the public execution spectacle because execution is too rarely used to have a deterrent effect. Being executed in the United States isn’t a matter for common murderers; it requires aggravating factors. Making it less cruel is better, not more cruel, because there is no real deterrent effect- it’s a rare tail event.

We are literally living in George Carlin sketch.

This is stupid. I don't think that public executions are a bad thing per se. But if you want to instate that federal executions should be public - there should be somewhat of a process, not by fiat, and not make it exceptional occasion.

Also not a chance in hell this will happen - if SCOTUS thought that right to privacy gives you right to abortion, if sure as hell gives you literal right to privacy for your execution. I do support the condemned to be able to waiver it and make it as public or private as they desire.

My only regret is we are not living in the maximalist George Carlin sketch, we could be executing a whole bunch of people at once with nukes. If the state is going to dispense life and death it might as well do it in the most grandiose way it can. It should display its mastery over magical hellfire stones while at it.

...would Hasan want privacy for his execution?

That is up to him, not to Pete.

if SCOTUS thought that right to privacy gives you right to abortion, if sure as hell gives you literal right to privacy for your execution

Would it matter to your formulation that abortion is a private choice, while execution is imposed on the person by the public? I don't see the two as anywhere near to 1:1 with regard to a right to privacy.

Absolutely not. Because it was pure raw uncut bullshit justification to begin with. So if they can tie it to privacy, then privacy of execution is much easier to tie to the right to privacy.

This makes me think of Foucault and Discipline and Punish. Ironically, I think this will backfire spectacularly on the Trump admin. As Foucault points out, this will make people sympathetic to the condemned. It is better for the regime this is done behind closed doors.

As Foucault points out, this will make people sympathetic to the condemned.

Foucault? The pedophile? I suppose it's understandable why he would feel sympathy for the vile. For the normies, it's a perfect opportunity to ruin their overdeveloped sense of sympathy. Preface and accompany the execution with a ruthless description of the harm he caused. The man murdered a pregnant woman while she was begging for the life of her baby.

I think you are misunderstanding his point. He actually is making more of a Moldbug style observation. He uses some historical examples showing public executions undermine a regime’s authority by generating sympathy for the condemned, provoking riots, and exposing the regime's brutality. This is actually in the first few pages if you want to read his arguments.

What he was saying was that moving punishment behind closed doors made state power less visibly violent and potentially more effective. His thesis is that modern imprisonment wasn't simply moral progress but a shift toward subtler, more pervasive forms of surveillance and social control. People don't want to see how the sausage is made (Palantir, Flock, public executions, etc.). I don't even think he could have anticipated how predisposed leftists are to sympathizing with criminals today.

So I actually agree with him 100%. Another example is deportations. People support deportations until you have to use violence to remove criminal illegal aliens. It's harmful for the regime to do this, which is why the Trump admin stopped making it a spectacle. Maybe reading some Foucault would have made them aware of this. His observations about the intersection of knowledge and power are also spot on, and all right wingers should be red pilled on Foucault.

I do not get it. Even for pro death penalty people, I do not think there is a bigger point in making the execution public. If the US says they have executed someone in prison, few people will doubt them, so even before AI made video evidence unreliable establishing common knowledge would not have been a great reason.

Nor do I think that the shock value will scare people straight. It does not work too well with the shock pictures the EU puts on tobacco products either.

I think the most coherent reason is that MAGA wants a spectacle.

But then why go for something as tame as a firing squad? Where is the suspense, the thrill? The obvious baseline for RETVRN-leaning MAGAs should be pagan Rome, they knew how to put on a show. Wild animals, fighting, messy deaths. Crucifixions are right out though, not only because they would offend the Christian right, but also because two hours in viewers will get bored and start scrolling TokTok.

Presumably Seaworld was not willing to let Hegseth drop him into a shark tank? Or have him fight for his life with a dagger against an angry polar bear? Perhaps Hegseth could fight him bare-handed to the death, thereby proving his manliness? The horror genre is full of ideas on how to make the spectacle last longer. Is there nobody in the administration who would want to channel their inner Mason Verger by having a jihadist being eaten alive by pigs? Or it could even be episodic, where the convict gets to face some deadly threat every Tuesday at prime time, sometimes getting maimed, until he finally succumbs to one. Think of the money Trump could make on prediction markets by rigging that game!

Presumably Hegseth was advised that the SCOTUS would declare most of these options cruel and unusual, but even the boring firing squad thing would offer the potential for some excitement. Think about it: if execution by firing squad is legal, then execution by a firing squad chosen in a particular fashion is legal. Trump could run a weekly casting/game show where would-be members of the squad compete against each other for the honor of firing the shot. The courts might even allow bringing the convict along for every episode. Fox could make a killing. Bait the left: let Trump's kids and the ICE goons who shot Hope and Pretty compete.

Obviously, the key question would be if Trump would want a woman and black guy on the squad to increase his demographic appeal or if that would be too DEI.

Perhaps Hegseth could fight him bare-handed to the death

Now you're talking. Except it should be more gladiatorial and more wrought steel and leather straps., people from the army and civilians would be signing up to be on the Eagle and stripes team for the chance of personally combating the terrorist. We can even turn this into a pardon if he wins he gets to live etc.

But then why go for something as tame as a firing squad?

Federal law prescribes execution methods quite specifically(and for state executions normally this is also prescribed by statute)- the military is allowed to use firing squad, lethal injection, or the method of the state the military prison hes being held in is located in.

If Hasan specifically requested to be locked in the tiger cage at the San Francisco zoo, like many a dumb stoner, then the Supreme Court would likely rule that he has the right to pick his own manner of execution(they have repeatedly used this as an answer to cruel and unusual punishment claims in the past). But in the absence of that, hegseth is stuck deciding between a short, set list of methods.

Even for pro death penalty people, I do not think there is a bigger point in making the execution public.

Execution is the proper and just disposition of some crimes, of which this is one. It is not a shameful event to be hidden away in a cellar, it is a demonstration that our society possesses the moral conviction to see that justice is done. People need to see it happen, and they need to understand that this is not something they can overcome with language games and infinite isolated demands for rigor. Further, this method is better than many others, certainly better than pseudo-medicalizations like lethal injection or fossilized techno-futurism like the electric chair or gas chamber. It is proper that this person should be killed, and so we kill them with our standard killing tools.

But then why go for something as tame as a firing squad? Where is the suspense, the thrill?

If you are wondering why your opponents, who you have modelled as cartoonishly evil, are not acting cartoonishly evil, maybe it's because your model is wrong? Maybe you should revise your model, rather than detailing all the ways their actual behavior could diverge less from your imagination's paintings of how awful they could be?

I have watched Blues publicly celebrate lawless murder of innocents, many, many times. Would you appreciate it if I wrote a post like this about something Blues hadn't done, but I could imagine them doing?

People need to see it happen, and they need to understand that this is not something they can overcome with language games and infinite isolated demands for rigor.

I do not think this will help deter anyone. It will not deter a single jihadist. It will hardly deter any normal criminal -- the ones who don't have the stomach for it will simply not watch. And the ones who will watch will not decide that the threat of getting shot after a few decades of prison will make it not worth it.

And it will very much not be a grim if dignified affair like Ned Stark beheading someone. People will watch it on TV in bars. School boys will make bets if the condemned will shit himself before or after being shot.

Let me try an analogy. Many parents want grandchildren, and many royalists want a royal heir. However, this rarely means that either group would be very interested in observing the process of the baby being conceived or born on live TV. As long as the processes are handled competently, most parents and royalists will prefer to see the end result without the various fluids involved along the way. The ones who would prefer to watch everything are probably perverts.

With a public execution, most of the public in favor of it will decide that as long as it happens, they do not need to see it done. A few will tune in because they feel it is their duty as citizens to bear witness. The main audience will be people watching out of morbid curiosity. Some will watch to confirm their opinion that the death penalty is barbaric.

And MAGA will obviously turn this into a media circus. Hegseth has a day job, he is in charge of the most expensive military on the planet. The particulars of the implementation of the judgments of military courts are only a tiny part of that job, in most administrations they would be handled three layers of management below him. Instead, the former Fox News moderator decided not only to make the execution public, but also to personally announce it.

Can I be sure that he does not share my aesthetic revulsion regarding death by shark? Not really, it could be that for once our aesthetics and moral judgments would agree. His previous readiness to embrace war and warrior aesthetics would make it surprising, but you never know.

Still, I concede that attacking MAGA over what I think they might want to do was bad on my part. I am confident there will be enough for me to criticize after their circus without me having to speculate what the distasteful particulars might be beforehand.

People need to see it happen, and they need to understand that this is not something they can overcome with language games and infinite isolated demands for rigor.

I do not think this will help deter anyone. It will not deter a single jihadist. It will hardly deter any normal criminal -- the ones who don't have the stomach for it will simply not watch.

What part of the sentence you quoted do you think was referring to jihadists or normal criminals?

You are arguing public perception. I am also arguing public perception. I believe that execution of murderers is good and proper. I believe, both in this matter and in many, many others, that attempting to reach accommodation with those of incompatible values has been an obvious chronic failure, and the proper path forward is to do what I and others like me perceive to be correct, with little to no regard for how this is perceived by the outgroup. We should offer the public a concrete alternative to the Blue Tribe consensus, not in terms of theory but in terms of actual practice, so that our way and their way can be directly compared. The outgroup does not grant consideration to our moral positions, and we should cease to grant consideration to theirs. the alternative is to be led by the nose in a game of "optics" designed from the ground up to be unwinnable; "only do things that Blue Tribe bigots won't hiss slurs at you for" is a recipe for paralytic abdication.

I do not perceive public execution of a traitorous mass-murderer to be shameful. I do not care if he is in a wheelchair; why should I? His powerlessness is not in question here, this is an execution of a condemned prisoner, not an honorable duel. I do not perceive a valid moral argument against execution of violent criminals, much less murderers, still less mass-murderers, and am entirely comfortable with a debate over the consequences of this approach versus the status quo. I think it is better to force Blues to burn resources attempting to shame us for doing what we perceive to be correct, than to do things we perceive to be wrong in the false hope that they will not shame us, thus granting them further power without contest. I perceive the latter strategy to have resulted in vast ruin, while the former strategy has delivered more victories in a shorter timeframe than any within my tribe dreamed possible. If you believe that this will in some way offend the normies, feel free to explain why widespread celebration of actual lawless murder in numerous previous and quite recent cases has not offended the normies even more.

With a public execution, most of the public in favor of it will decide that as long as it happens, they do not need to see it done.

What evidence leads you to believe this is the case? I think they do need to see it done. I think seeing it done, and the national conversation that follows, will have a significant positive effect on the state of our nation. Certainly I will be drawing comparisons to the reaction to this execution and to previous lawless murders. The disparity in reaction is obvious and instructive.

And MAGA will obviously turn this into a media circus.

Should we discuss media circuses, and what they tell us about the people generating them? I do not perceive a shortage of actual, past-tense media circuses with which we might contextualize the hypothetical media circus you are predicting, nor is such an analysis one I expect to get the worst end of. It seems to me that your post above was exceedingly uncharitable; if you want to talk about media circuses and their effect on public opinion, why not reach for the rich context readily available? I think it unlikely that MAGA is going to turn this execution into more of a media circus than Blues did the murders of Kirk and Thompson, or the Lindsey Clancy saga, or the attempted assassinations of Trump, or the death of George Floyd and so on and on and on. Is it somehow worse to have a media circus over the execution of a traitorous murderer than it is over the murder of a law-abiding businessman or a milquetoast political activist or a multiple-felon drug addict ODing in police custody because he swallowed his stash? Or is this a Russell's conjugation thing: my social movement, your media circus, his shameless propaganda? Do these questions seem unreasonable to you, and if so, why?

Still, I concede that attacking MAGA over what I think they might want to do was bad on my part. I am confident there will be enough for me to criticize after their circus without me having to speculate what the distasteful particulars might be beforehand.

Fair enough. Let's pick it up when the facts are in.

TL;DR - you are appealing to an image of social norms that seem entirely fictional to me, based on direct observation of the real world. I decline to be swayed by such fictions, and I think confronting them head-on is straightforwardly better than attempting compromise with them. The idea that there is some sort of stable, respectable social consensus that must be respected or accounted for is entirely unsupportable, and it is better to actually have the argument here and now than to allow appeals to this fictional consensus to pass unchallenged.

According to Wikipedia it seems it was not a lack of moral conviction but the consideration to avoid the media circus generated by botched executions that brought public executions to an end in the US. See my comment here.

Public executions were big parties. Life was so boring that thousands of people would turn out and get drunk watching a man be hanged.

“Instead of promoting the sanctity of life and how solemn the circumstance was, with people applauding and having a carnival-like atmosphere, that really turned people off,” he said.

If you are wondering why your opponents, who you have modelled as cartoonishly evil, are not acting cartoonishly evil, maybe it's because your model is wrong? Maybe you should revise your model, rather than detailing all the ways their actual behavior could diverge less from your imagination's paintings of how awful they could be?

Is it cartoonishly evil to kill people in theatrical and spectacular ways, or just a form of human nature? Romans killed people like this all the time and people loved it. There's really no reason it can't happen again. This could be the starting point for it happening again if it's what America wants.

I think the most coherent reason is that MAGA wants a spectacle.

But then why go for something as tame as a firing squad? Where is the suspense, the thrill? The obvious baseline for RETVRN-leaning MAGAs should be pagan Rome, they knew how to put on a show. Wild animals, fighting, messy deaths. Crucifixions are right out though, not only because they would offend the Christian right, but also because two hours in viewers will get bored and start scrolling TokTok.

The reasoning in the second paragraph should cast doubt on the first. It's not going to be a spectacle. It's going to be a video of a guy in a wheelchair, restrained, hooded, and with a target placed on his heart, who is then shot to death by several people. It will be brutal, but it won't be a spectacle. And I think Hegseth knows this.

I don't know why he wants it publicly streamed. But I think it's a good thing. Whether you're for or against the death penalty, you should be able to see what it is.

I favor the death penalty, but I think livestreaming it is a mistake, instrumentally if not inherently. The political capital wasted by causing a massive controversy like this could be better spent on executing more people, stepping up law enforcement, or something else like deportation. What possible gain beside "liberal tears" could come from insisting on public executions? The administration needs to keep their eye on the ball instead of performing the Based Ritual constantly.

Isn't it the opposite? The political capital of generating controversy is to take attention off of matters of governance that actually matter. The people need their circus.

It doesn't seem to have worked very well so far. Is this supposed to help them win the midterms?

People are arguing online about the death penalty and not about XYZ other topic, that's working exactly as intended. Plus this puts Islamic terror and law and order front of mind, both of which are typically winners for Republicans. The details of this particular spectacle are irrelevant, nobody is voting based on their opinion of this execution.

Immigration is a winner for Republicans too, by that logic they should pursue their immigration policies in a maximally controversial way to dominate the discourse. In reality they had to revise their approach because it was such a PR liability.

Many have warned that this will generate photogenic martyrdom propaganda that will inspire and energize future jihadists. (We’re giving Hasan exactly the attention and validation he always wanted!”)

Aside from any other ethical or moral arguments, this alone I think is reason to reconsider. Of the many potential crimes that could be dissuaded from a public death penalty, terroristic martyrdom is one of the last guesses I would make. This is even worse given he is a somewhat old crippled man, and the optics of putting a guy out in a wheelchair and shooting him isn't great. Even worse if it ends up botched, which isn't that likely but holy shit if a public execution ends up with him slowly dying (or barely surviving) in a very messy way, it'll be a disaster. He'll be a hero tortured by the Great Satan for radicalizable young men all over.

Also here's a great point from Jonathon Moran https://x.com/JVanMaren/status/2108586303444943246?s=20

The execution of Nidal Hassan feels like a microcosm of Trump II policies in many ways. It goes something like this:

  1. Take a popular action/policy (executing a terrorist who murdered servicemen, deporting illegal immigrants).
  2. Carry out the action/policy in a manner tailor-made to appeal to online MAGA anons, for whom the performative cruelty of the process is as important as the policy.
  3. Manage to lose public support while implementing a very popular action/policy.

and that there may be others who are in some way deterred, even marginally, from future criminality

This is one of the parts where death penalty advocates really lose me. I've done my share of fantasising about the sort of actions you only admit to taking in Minecraft (TM), and I'm very sure that for each of them the certainty of a swift end by firing squad would be greatly encouraging compared to the reality of a lifetime in a US supermax prison. I might be somewhat persuadable by statistics showing that death penalty candidate criminals really prefer life imprisonment, if those exist, but in this particular case the perp was a jihadi! Throwing away their life is their whole schtick.

I can understand death penalty advocates feeling moral revulsion at criminals being kept alive and healthy on their dime, but hoping for increased deterrence to me really seems like an instance of "what feels good must be good" just-world fallacy.

I can understand death penalty advocates feeling moral revulsion at criminals being kept alive and healthy on their dime, but hoping for increased deterrence to me really seems like an instance of "what feels good must be good" just-world fallacy.

No, I’m operating on the belief that the failure of capital punishment to effectively deter crime in the 21st century is precisely because of the massive temporal gap between conviction and execution, and because of the absurd behind-closed-doors way in which it is carried out.

My preference is for executions that are carried out in a public place, and in a visually evocative manner. We could bring local inmates — especially juvenile detention inmates — and force them to watch. “That’s your homeboy, or a member of the gang you’ve been curious about joining, being strung up in front of you. If you don’t change your life really fast, that will be you soon.” I do believe that this could be a very effective deterrent, because it would stress the reliability of the punishment and underline its immediate relevance to onlookers.

I’m not worried about deterring jihadists. You’re correct that the kind of guy who would consider becoming a terrorist is not going to be fazed by watching one video of a fairly sterile and bloodless execution; the possibility of that outcome is already priced into his worldview. And if it remains the case that this sort of execution is only in the cards for the absolute worst-of-the-worst, once-in-a-generation criminals, then you’re right that it won’t have much of an effect on the average criminal. If, on the other hand, it’s made clear that this is the sort of thing that will happen to you, young man, then I think it’d be a different story.

Death penalty eligible criminals have the option to waive their final appeals and get it over with. Almost none of them take it.

I don’t think the death penalty is deterring, because it isn’t used often enough. But it’s sure not deterring in the other direction- the actual reality of execution is spending twenty years in a maximum security prison and then dying.

The death penalty is way more efficient (if done by a not incompetent government). To deter people, we could give them a "short" stay in prison first, but if people are comfortable committing a crime then dying, wouldn't they off themselves? Oh wait, I forgot most criminals are idiots...I still think execution would deter any who would be deterred.

Why do people use Canadian/Dutch/Swiss euthanasia services when they could just off themselves? Why is the right-wing set so offended by the existence of those if offing oneself is an equivalent option? Clearly precommitting to having someone else do it is psychologically a lot easier.

I am not, in principal, against the death penalty, and I certainly think Nidal Hassan deserves it.

However, IMO, it should be a sober, deliberative action we do because we have made a rational decision, not something to please a bloodthirsty crowd. And it should be done humanely, no matter how big a scumbag the condemned was, and no matter how many people would like to see him slowly tortured to death.

reveling in low-class pandering and/or ostentatious cruelty

is exactly the point here. I fully expect the administration to "botch the aesthetics of the occasion," by which I mean they will treat it like a celebration and sell T-shirts, and if they botch the execution itself and Hassan lies on the ground, bleeding out but not dead, Trump will probably do a cute imitation of his dying gurgles, to wild cheers.

I'm against the death penalty and therefore generally unhappy with this turn of events, but I think, in this case, worrying about how "it should be done humanely" is looking for a stick to beat the decision with in defiance of the facts. Firing squads are the humane option relative to gas chambers, hangings, lethal injections, all of which I understand to be slower and more distressing ways to die. "Slowly torturing him to death" is, in other words, the one thing that they are not doing to this guy. Sure, there's still some small chance the execution could be botched, but that'd be equally (un)likely with a normal, non-public execution. Or are you arguing that it may be deliberately rigged to go wrong for the amusement of the crowd?

Firing squads are the humane option relative to gas chambers, hangings, lethal injections

Only because those methods have been almost sabotaged, don't know if purposefully or through incompetence but there are variations of the methods that are both painless and guaranteed to work. A gas chamber/exit bag with helium knocks you out before you know what's happening, you don't even get the feeling of suffocation. Or you could drop the air pressure in a vacuum proof sealed room. You loose consciousnes the same way. "Lethal injections" could have also just used an overdose of Fentanyl or some other delightful molecule that knocks you out and stops your heart. As for handguns we could have used an assload of TNT strapped to the head. The brain would be a mist before the electric impulses have the chance to travel from one end to the other.

Instead we choose some bullshit form of drugs that are inefficient versus a non-inconsequential slice of the human biological diversity.

"Lethal injections" could have also

Not to mention that activists deliberately targeted the companies that manufactured efficacious lethal injection chemicals so that we have to deliberately use less reliable cocktails. There is no shortage of poisons and toxins that will kill someone reliably, we just aren't allowed to use them.

You and others in the thread have implied that hangings are inhumane. Could I ask why? Assuming it's not botched, it seems second only to explosively disassembling the brain in terms of no time to suffer. In particular, more humane than firing squad, where you get a few shots to the body and several seconds of pain while the brain loses consciousness from blood loss.

IIRC there's two methods of hanging, and the US used strangulation hanging which is genuinely inhumane. The commonwealth and many oriental countries use(d) long-drop, which is not inhumane.

I believe most US jurisdictions switched to the "standard drop" (intended to be quick, though it didn't prove reliable) and then the "long drop" shortly after they came available.

Got it. I had no idea anybody intentionally used strangulation, and when it did occur I thought it was only due to a miscalculation or other incompetence.

Strangulation hanging is the low tech version, it was superceded in the commonwealth with the development of long drop and then adopted by other modern users of hanging.

I don't think a firing squad is inhumane. I'm talking about livestreaming it, which also is not in itself inhumane, but I don't think the motivation for that is anything other than base spectacle. It does not strike me as taking the responsibility of executing someone seriously, but rather turning it into entertainment.

I'm sure many people will be entertained.

Trump, of course, is the definition of bad taste. But I don't think even Hegseth will do anything like that.

Trump will probably do a cute imitation of his dying gurgles, to wild cheers.

like tiktokers and charlie kirk, or so i'm told.

Yes, they're disgusting. Call me old-fashioned; I remember when we expected presidents to be above acting like that.

I remember when we expected presidents to be above acting like that.

i have hazy memories of those days gone by, decades ago. alas!

Well Obama was pretty classy and fairly rec…oh no…

Well, if you hold your president to the standard of a tiktoker...

there's a nonzero chance the next Dem candidate will be AOC, so that's already in the cards.

i have no expectations of Trump to be decent. we haven't had a properly respectable president in a long time.

You haven't had a president who did the equivalent of the Charlie Kirk thing, though. Maybe AOC is capable of something like it, but "I punch you now because you might punch me afterwards", while painfully common, is not politics that leads to a good equilibrium.

While my preferred method of execution here would be hanging

Why do you prefer hanging, for the spectacle? As someone who does not support the death penalty, if it must be carried out, the firing squad seems like the best method in terms of lethality and dignity. Botched hangings are extraordinarily cruel, and of course lethal injection is both cruel and undignified.

Christian commenters have lamented what they see as the barbarity and vulgarity of the live-streaming aspect

Personally, I am concerned that the Trump administration will, yet again, find some way to botch the aesthetics of the occasion, reveling in low-class pandering and/or ostentatious cruelty.

If your goal is to RVTURN to lindy public executions, which I can at least understand the argument for, then jumping from zero to one thousand by breaking new ground in live-streaming the execution (which I believe has no precedent from an internationally recognized nation state, only via terrorists and cartels) as red meat for the base is obviously not the way to do it.

Many have warned that this will generate photogenic martyrdom propaganda that will inspire and energize future jihadists.

This is also just plainly obvious; public executions, before even bringing in the live-streaming aspect, are currently still well outside of the Overton window. It seems fairly clear that this will turn into a massively polarizing event amongst Americans and the developed world more broadly, while the actual jihadists will be the ones to benefit in finding common cause and a new martyr to rally around. It's clearly counterproductive in terms of actually winning in the marketplace of ideas.

There is also the possibility of visible corruption: perhaps viewers will need to pay for a bespoke streaming platform which will put revenue in the pockets of Trump, Trump’s family, or a consortium of Trump donors

I am somewhat morbidly curious how this is going to be streamed. I can't imagine any of the existing platforms wanting anything like this anywhere near them, but perhaps the administration will try and force them to bend the knee. Otherwise, as you say, it will probably be a bespoke streaming platform that's the stuff of nightmares.

Why do you prefer hanging, for the spectacle? As someone who does not support the death penalty, if it must be carried out, the firing squad seems like the best method in terms of lethality and dignity.

Specifically that it is a process that preserves the dignity of the state while also not lending any dignity to the condemned. The condemned becomes a macabre prop, which is right and fitting for what he did.

jumping from zero to one thousand by breaking new ground in live-streaming the execution (which I believe has no precedent from an internationally recognized nation state, only via terrorists and cartels) as red meat for the base is obviously not the way to do it.

The goal of any forward-thinking person who’s at all sympathetic to a Yarvin-style post-liberal critique must be to grapple with this question: how to aggressively move the Overton window in our direction without knocking down any load-bearing legal/institutional elements that would generate massive backlash when disturbed. I am concerned about the optical ramifications of this administration skipping some intermediate steps, but I’m also intrigued by the sort of Propaganda Of The Deed effects that could redound from just ripping off the bandaid and showing that none of the “landmark” jurisprudential developments of late 20th century America are actually sacred or load-bearing in any way. We can actually just do this important and widely popular thing; it won’t lead to any massive negative downstream consequences, it won’t turn us into savage barbarians, it won’t erode everything we hold dear, etc.

Nitrogen asphyxiation is the correct way to execute someone, followed by lethal injection. We can even make the injection something like fentanyl (not like it's hard to source or anything) to minimise pain and suffering. No different to the people who die by drug overdose.

Nitrogen asphyxiation is currently only used in Oklahoma. Lethal injection is the method used for most executions in the US and it's typically done with either a drug cocktail or an overdose using veterinary drugs.

Why do you prefer hanging, for the spectacle?

Because hanging is the traditional punishment for crimes of disloyalty.

internationally recognized nation state, only via terrorists and cartels

Red China has done it in the relatively recent past.

I am somewhat morbidly curious how this is going to be streamed. I can't imagine any of the existing platforms wanting anything like this anywhere near them,

The government might well have its own streaming platform for c-span or something. And there’s always streaming on X.

Red China has done it in the relatively recent past.

Public executions have a very lindy history in China, but my point was that even they abolished public executions well before live-streaming even existed. Even the Muslim nation states and North Korea that still carry out public executions don't livestream them for the gawking world at large to see, it's really only the cartels and jihadis that do that.

That being said, this is the reverse case to America, where many Chinese people would actually quite like to see public executions return, and in general the death penalty holds massive public support.

And there’s always streaming on X.

I would be moderately surprised if Elon would want an execution prominently streamed on X, but perhaps I'm wrong there.

My Chinese wife told me they publicly executed drug dealers at her school in the 90s.

The dignity is the issue - a firing squad is an honourable method of execution for soldiers, hanging marks someone as dying a criminal's death rather than a soldier's (this was a contested issue at Nuremberg, for instance). This is not particularly consistent across American military history, as far as I can tell, but hanging is definitely more of a "traitor's death". I do suspect there's some concern involved about the optics of a botched hanging, given how little it's done nowadays, even China goes for firing squad/injection.

I doubt they'd allow him to be barefaced and either look defiant or cry though. Instead they'd probably put something over his head and won't that take away any dignity?

It's kind of a principle of the thing situation, that one is a particularly military (in the West) form of execution, and one is for common criminals.

He could be shot in the back of the head by a single executioner with a pistol, as was practiced in the Soviet Union, but the optics of that might be too inflammatory even for Hegseth.

I agree. The death penalty is fine; firing squad (done effectively) is OK although nitrogen would be better; but making it into a sadistic performance is bad at least in appearance.

Just recently, Tennessee attempted to execute Christa Pike and failed. Another shining example of government incompetence, this time Tennessee's: why don't they just use nitrogen? The law says no cruel or unusual punishment, and I agree, "cruelty" should always be justified by convincingly making the world more peaceful overall.

Keep it in fiction. I'd rather live in a world where people are never seriously cruel to me in exchange for never being seriously cruel to them.

Because unlike Oklahoma, Tennessee has not defined statutorily that the use of nitrogen asphyxiation rather than veterinary medications is an accepted method of execution. Why this is is probably because Tennessee doesn't execute people very often and so never felt the need to change their method.

Most US executions are carried out in just a few states- Texas Georgia and Florida(the three big southern states), and Alabama and Oklahoma. Texas and Georgia have political reasons for being unable to change anything about their death penalty. Alabama, Florida, and Oklahoma have alternative methods enshrined in law.

What I don’t understand is why it is so hard for these states to obtain the necessary drugs. They all operate health systems of some kind and I doubt there is any way a pharmaceutical wholesaler can tell the difference between their products being obtained for executions as opposed to other purposes.

My understanding is that the big drug makers have extremely strict contracts with distributors that prohibit any down-the-line use in capital punishment in any circumstances and have extremely damaging financial penalties for anyone in the distribution chain who, knowingly or unknowingly, is involved in facilitating their use for this purpose.

In addition most of the major manufacturers are European or based in other countries that ban the export of any drugs used in capital punishment. Lastly, while India and China might be import options, the courts banned them as unapproved after a few states tried to use Indian drugs in lethal injections in the early 2010s.

Lastly, if a - say - ‘based’ right wing manufacturer were to set up shop in the US and was FDA approved, they would be liable for legal action by any Christa Pike types which, in America’s litigation culture and given that many lawyers and well funded interests are strongly opposed to the death penalty, means that a single botched execution would probably bankrupt such a venture, and in lethal injections failures are not uncommon.

re liability/brand management

The best part of being the government is you can do whatever the hell you want. The vax producers got blanket immunity from civil suits, I'm sure if the state really wanted to they could work something similar. And you COULD make it a requirement of having the pleasure of being a govt supplier that you can't refuse that use case.

It's dumb that drugs have to be FDA approved for executions, but it's easiest to sidestep the matter. Even if Mexican rope-makers, German gun and ammunition manufacturers, and Japanese steelmakers refused to allow their products to be used in executions, there's enough American capacity for the few executions we do. Just hang, behead, or shoot; it works.

Methods of execution are set by statute and at the moment Oklahoma allows nitrogen asphyxiation but Tennessee does not. Most executions in the US are carried out in states that allow only lethal injection- although that’s likely to change soon.

Nitrogen has been botched also. There isn't any method of execution that can't be botched, though lethal injection seems to be the worst. There isn't enough data on firing squads in the modern era, but I'd expect them to be as reliable as hanging if not more so, even if you count needing a coup-de-grace as a botch.

Hanging probably isn't practical for Nidal Hasan, him being in a wheelchair. It would be possible, but absurd.

Hanging probably isn't practical for Nidal Hasan, him being in a wheelchair. It would be possible, but absurd.

You evidently don't recall the Dr. Gillespie killings.

You evidently don't recall the Dr. Gillespie killings.

You reference a scene from Blazing Saddles; I stand by "absurd".

There isn't any method of execution that can't be botched

Are there any accounts of MAID being "botched"? Admittedly I haven't gone looking, but I'd assume they would be similarly effective but for the lack of medical qualifications on the death penalty side.

There has been some rumbling about specific elderly homes in Canada waiting for the relatives to be out of reach to do an "informed consent" "execution" of terminally altzheimered grandmother. Very recent too. link

I share your ethical concerns about MAID, but in this case "botched" meant "patient didn't die" in the same way the execution failed.

I have no clue if the medications used are even the same.

Does seem kinda insane it's taken 17 years to get from shooting to actually undertaking the execution for the most palpably guilty perp possible.

Quick AI search suggests the US government spent atleast $5M between the incarceration, original trial, appeals and that seems to be based on an article from a couple years ago.

The root cause of the whole Christa Pike situation (which for the record is really fucked up) stems from the fact that the people in charge are stupid. IMO the correct response to such demonstrable incompetence is to do a Scott Evil and to do it as publicly as possible, which is what is happening.