magicalkittycat
No bio...
User ID: 3762
You only addressed the least interesting part of my comment. Why don't you address the division in age groups? Should adults be allowed to self-identify as children? Why not?
How is this any different than what I said already about it being a proxy on whether or not trans identity is legit?
No, it still isn't. It's pretty obvious that women's sports were created for the 50% of the population with a biologically female body,
Plenty of sports organizations have allowed trans participants for decades, it must not have been obvious to them then.
If the intent had always been to create one division for males-who-identify-as-men and one division where the only people able to win medals would be males-who-identify-as-women feminists would never have supported it.
Then why is one of the most feminist sports organizations, the WNBA, trans accepting?
Maybe, I can't rule out a tiny fraction of true believers, but I think there is a much larger percentage that just goes along with the nonsense because it doesn't affect them directly, and they've learned that saying the Emperor has no clothes gets you labeled as a hateful bigot who ought to be fired from their job.
The entire analogy falls apart when the richest and most powerful individuals to have ever existed ever in the history of the world are the ones against accepting trans identity as valid! The Emperor creates a silenced people because he is the Emperor and has power. Everyday social pressure from other ordinary everyday people however is genuine evidence that said other people believe what they are saying, to at least some degree.
It is a story of speaking truth to power, so if you want to use it as an analogy you should probably consider who the most powerful people are first. It is those like Trump and Musk and Xi Jinping and Putin and other such rich individuals or powerful politicians who are the Emperor, and they're anti trans identity.
This argument is the wrong way around. Even if a random woman in the world is unlikely to win a particular competition, the winner of that competition is always a woman. That gives an opportunity to women that wouldn't otherwise exist.
Okay, so like I said the discussion is a proxy for whether or not trans mtf people count under the category of "women" and not about whether or not 99% of women have any chance.
Not really. Everyone knows transwomen aren't really women; if they were, there would be nothing to discuss.
Now that's just not true. You can't just say "everyone secretly agrees with me, including the people whose words and actions indicate disagreement" so easily.
Which you even contradict yourself later here!
The same way for transwomen: what level of accommodation is due of course depends on whether you believe transwomen are simply women born in the wrong body or that you view them as egotistical sexual fetishists
Exactly, some percentage of the population genuinely views trans women as under the category of women. There are genuine understandable theories in which this could occur, such as intersex neurological development is a leading theory for instance. But one also could go into the spiritual/metaphysical direction. Most people believe in some concept of souls or soul like idea, thus the idea of female oriented soul in male body is not some inherently irrational idea under many soul frameworks. And a person defining man/woman based off neurology or souls or whatever else can be valid disagreement.
The ideal solution technically is an ELO/MMR system like literally any other competitive environment ever, the issue however is that this is just impractical with sports. They don't play enough games to get a solid baseline, especially not when the teams are set in place so bad teammates can be carried by good ones and vice versa.
Because how sports are set up right now is inherently unfair, everyone knows it and no one seems to care about this issue except in the one limited circumstance of trans athletes. But trans athletes are not an actual issue, they mathematically can not be.
Even if every single trans athlete was an elite player that their cis counterparts can not match, the amount of people they displace from sports if they are allowed to join is only .5-1% of the population. Meanwhile 99% of the population is already displaced and that's because most men and most women are not allowed to do sports in a meaningful competitive manner already. Only the top most genetically gifted people are able to. Most people already have no chance.
Some sports are more blatant than others, basketball for instance is very obvious. The average height of a basketball player is 6'6, this is well over the 99th percentile. People say that men's sports are open to everyone, but that's not true. Men's basketball is not even open to the average man, it is only available to the genetic freaks who tower above everyone else. Likewise the WNBA is six feet. The average WNBA player is taller than the average man. The WNBA is not open to the average woman, only the genetic freaks who tower over everyone else.
Competitive sports are not inclusive, they are not fair, and they are basically impossible for the large majority of humans to participate in already. Men's sports do not include most men, women's sports do not include most women. 99% of the population is already displaced, so trans athletes barely even make a splash in the fairness discussion because the additional displaced is a basically invisible amount compared to the number who already have no access. They're a drop in the ocean of unfairness.
But no one actually cares about fairness in sports and therefore discussion of how we stop displacing 99% of the population from playing are nonstarters. They just want to see genetic freaks playing against other genetic freaks, and the trans sports discussion isn't about fairness, because again we already know no one gives a shit about that, and is instead a proxy for whether or not they're "really" their identified gender.
From what I can see she's currently being investigated as a potential spy but there's nothing confirmed yet. Either way, the potential there is meaningful as it shows a weak spot in industries important to national security, same way a plane need not actually crash. If she is a spy, the potential to either get information out through covert means/manipulation, or through blackmail is obvious.
That being said, just like with plane crashes Nvidia is hopefully set up in a redundant manner that things stay secure even if the CEO is compromised. I doubt it, but this sort of thing should be the goal for our tech industry and government.
The US does not run just one election, it runs thousands of them coordinating between the states/counties/cities. Many of those thousands are primarily Republican controlled areas with volunteers/workers who are disproportionately Republican.
Thus we have two possible conclusions if fraud is happening this widespread.
-
Ordinary Republican volunteers and politicians are all in on the conspiracy and able to prevent whistleblowers somehow.
-
Republicans are so retarded that they can get the elections stolen in their own counties and governments right under their nose without anyone uncovering a single bit of hard proof.
There must be some explanation for why Republican areas are apparently so easily stolen.
I agree with the other comment on this then, at some point if was happening then maybe you just deserve it.
I've never bought into the premise of the fermi paradox to begin with.
We start off with observation 1: We exist and observation 2: We are life
Thus we can conclude: Life can exist
Thus we can theorize: other life could possibly exist
All good so far. But then people take the hypothetical "other life could exist" to "other life is likely to exist" and that is an illogical jump.
Think of it this way, imagine two universes where life exists every 100,000 planets and one where life exists every 100 sextillion planets. Life in both universes before contact makes the same observations, that "we exist therefore other life could exist". The beings that exist on all of them no matter the probability have the exact same logic they can use. And if all universes (both likely, unlikely, and everything else) have the same exact observation, then you can not actually tell the likelihood of other life based on that.
Voters are inconsistent and nonsensical is hardly news.
Trans people participating in preferred sports is not the only issue at play in the trans discussion, and voters having a nuanced opinion on the different facets of it doesn't make them inconsistent or nonsensical.
Okay here's a question to ponder then, why should the Democrats actually get rid of Trump? He's clearly become electoral poison and his descent into dementia seems to be slowly picking up if the constant MoCA references he keeps making are signals of testing he's had recently so if anything the toxin he has over the Republicans is probably gonna get worse right? And Biden could be kept behind the scenes easily, because he was always that type of background player guy even in the early years when the decline didn't hit yet. Trump going silent as his aides hide him will be noticed, if they can even get him to cooperate with it.
I can't even see what Trump's point was in doing this
The answer of it's just basic corruption seems pretty convincing when a fair bit of other seemingly random Trump actions end up having that same reasoning.
The ad has two simple parts
"Harris is for they/them" = Harris is concerned about someone else's issues, particularly a pet cultural issue of trans folk who no one cares about.
"Trump is for you" = Trump cares about the topics you care about.
Now we can go and check polling to see what voters actually care about cause they'll tell us! And affordability/prices/economy has continued to be the no 1 issue over and over and over again, and transgender people (for or against) continue to be one of the least cared about topics.
The ad would not work if it was "Harris for they/them, Trump against they/them", because voters don't give a shit either way! They see it all as unimportant.
The big lesson here IMO should be properly understanding the mandate. It won't be learned, but it should. The American people primarily care about bread and butter topics as always, and your win on those as the "best of two evil" does not mean free reign to throw away economic concerns and start doing whatever you want. Like it or not most Americans still think of the parties as giant douche vs turd sandwich, and if you're turd sandwich, you do not pile on extra shit after a win.
But that's exactly what happened. Consider the infamous "Harris is for they/them, Trump is for you" ad. The underlying message painted Harris as an idealogue concerned about irrelevant topics like trans people, and Trump as caring about the real topics. But what did Republicans take away from this? The exact opposite of what they should have learned, they hyper focused on culture war shit. They spent their ad focus and money saying tranny 50 times in a mirror hoping to summon the voters again, and it failed.
And likewise with overreach. Voters are very clear that they don't like trans people participating in their preferred sports, but in general they actually trust Democrats more on the overall topic!. Most voters don't want big daddy government coming in and repressing people's access to hormone treatments or discriminating in employment or anything like that.
Focusing the political discussion on trans people both makes the GOP look out of touch and cruel.
This has happened with Trump on basically every topic. The average voter does not consider the US in an existential crisis that needs 100 million deportations. They want a secure border where criminals can't get in, but they don't want a border so shut down and so hard to get visas with that their favorite voice actors are barred from entering. Yes a single concert by itself isn't a big deal, but it's not just a single concert. It is just one example of the many ways that overreach and a misunderstanding of the border mandate happened. Yet putting extremists in charge who want to limit foreigners of all kinds and of all types into the country inevitably leads to these fuckups.
And then if it wasn't for all this shit, there's also Trump specific problems too. Even if you're a hardcore conservative who thinks two years of idealogical overreach is worth the political sacrifice, Trump is barely even doing that well! He's focusing on his ballroom, the reflecting pool, threatening to invade Canada and Greenland over and over! He's probably spent more time on the white house's furnishings than he did trying to pass real legislation with the trifecta. Certainly even a hardcore idealogue is well aware of how no voter gives a shit about that and watching the president ignore the Real Issues in favor of such nonsense is a bad look right?
The good news for Republicans is that the Dems won this election so hard that they might get cocky overreach on their new mandate and fuck things up. The bad news is that Trump is still president and will not only be causing new issues (if 2025 Trump is threatening to invade Canada, maybe 2028 Trump is threatening to bomb France. Who knows at this point?) but just by having the seat and being the guy in charge will be eating the blame for general problems.
The big lesson here IMO should be properly understanding the mandate. It won't be learned, but it should. The American people primarily care about bread and butter topics as always, and your win on those as the "best of two evil" does not mean free reign to throw away economic concerns and start doing whatever you want. Like it or not most Americans still think of the parties as giant douche vs turd sandwich, and if you're turd sandwich, you do not pile on extra shit after a win.
But that's exactly what happened. Consider the infamous "Harris is for they/them, Trump is for you" ad. The underlying message painted Harris as an idealogue concerned about irrelevant topics like trans people, and Trump as caring about the real topics. But what did Republicans take away from this? The exact opposite of what they should have learned, they hyper focused on culture war shit. They spent their ad focus and money saying tranny 50 times in a mirror hoping to summon the voters again, and it failed.
And likewise with overreach. Voters are very clear that they don't like trans people participating in their preferred sports, but in general they actually trust Democrats more on the overall topic!. Most voters don't want big daddy government coming in and repressing people's access to hormone treatments or discriminating in employment or anything like that.
Focusing the political discussion on trans people both makes the GOP look out of touch and cruel.
This has happened with Trump on basically every topic. The average voter does not consider the US in an existential crisis that needs 100 million deportations. They want a secure border where criminals can't get in, but they don't want a border so shut down and so hard to get visas with that their favorite voice actors are barred from entering. Yes a single concert by itself isn't a big deal, but it's not just a single concert. It is just one example of the many ways that overreach and a misunderstanding of the border mandate happened. Yet putting extremists in charge who want to limit foreigners of all kinds and of all types into the country inevitably leads to these fuckups.
And then if it wasn't for all this shit, there's also Trump specific problems too. Even if you're a hardcore conservative who thinks two years of idealogical overreach is worth the political sacrifice, Trump is barely even doing that well! He's focusing on his ballroom, the reflecting pool, threatening to invade Canada and Greenland over and over! He's probably spent more time on the white house's furnishings than he did trying to pass real legislation with the trifecta. Certainly even a hardcore idealogue is well aware of how no voter gives a shit about that and watching the president ignore the Real Issues in favor of such nonsense is a bad look right?
If they had sent out monthly checks to all citizens for the past 2 years, and labeled them something like "rewards check for less illegals"
The effects of course are driving up the debt even further and massively accelerating the already quite high inflation. At some point we gotta start asking "with what money?" again when people propose insane spending ideas because we aren't even affording things now.
He shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur; and he shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, Judges of the supreme Court, and all other Officers of the United States, whose Appointments are not herein otherwise provided for, and which shall be established by Law: but the Congress may by Law vest the Appointment of such inferior Officers, as they think proper, in the President alone, in the Courts of Law, or in the Heads of Departments.
If the Senate doesn't approve of Trump's picks and therefore none of them happen, that's not a constitutional crisis. It's literally what the constitution says, the president (unless authorized by a passed law) must have their picks approved.
This is explicitly how the balance of powers is laid out, there is no confusion here. "But I don't like it" is not a crisis. If Trump has an issue with this, Trump should have been a better president so American citizens would vote in senators who agree with him on his nominees.
As one of the main resident unpopular opinion havers here, I agree with the problem at least. I'll end up choosing a few replies to talk with, but still once in a while I'll get people mad at me for ignoring them, it creates an issue of following who is saying what if the topic continues on especially when there are similar usernames involved, and I'm also a human being and can't guarantee I'm not being selective or biased in who I choose to reply to!
That being said, I'm not sure about the solution suggested. One annoying thing about the Internet is seeing someone who agrees with your conclusion but not the reasoning.
Like let's say two people dislike a law limiting weed sales past 5pm, except one dislikes it because they want no limits and the other dislikes it cause they don't want it allowed at all. Who should represent the "this law is bad" side?
But even within the former of wanting no limits, what if you think the law is bad and weed should be always legal because of small government values but the person who gets appointed as argument representative is a dumb dudebro type who says weed cures cancer so it needs to be sold in case of emergency cancer treatment as their main point? I'm sure we've all experienced seeing people argue for "our side" of a topic in a way we don't agree with, either from their points or their behavior.
Aren't the vast majority of amber alerts custody disputes of various types?
Yes, parents kidnapping a child after a separation is the most common form of abduction by far. The main person to fear is not your neighbor, but your ex.
Jews in electoral terms are not a meaningful demographic nor are they likely to stay Republican for long (if we believe that they're even flipping) what with the rise of the groyper right.
Maybe it's a unique NA thing but car centrism and loss of freedoms for kids seem to be directly related. A society where eyes are everywhere in the local neighborhood from people walking directly results in less crime. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_surveillance and helps people feel safer too when they actually see and know their neighbors more.
The people complaining about "diversity" or "lack of social cohesion" are missing the point; it is precisely because these crimes are white-on-white that the hysteria is generated.
Yeah as I pointed out in another comment race and immigration are irrational explanations for one simple reason, almost every crime against a child is by someone the child is related to or already knows well and therefore is almost always someone of the same race.
There are just not hordes of minority men prowling the streets kidnapping children. Mostly it's the parents! 60% of amber alerts are for a parent. And that's not counting other family members like siblings/aunts/uncles or things like a pastor/family friend/etc.
If we want to be paranoid of someone, we need to be paranoid of ourselves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_Abduction_Is_Not_Funny
Something's wrong with the kids, too. No child should tolerate that, and yet, something they should have grown out of in their teens persists into their twenties and beyond.
I agree, but we've socially set this up for them to think they are and act like they are children. We even have people trying to claim the age of 25 now as maturity! It's insane, and children raised into this society with empowered helicopter parents never get the chance to learn it can be different.
You can run, but you can't hide. Your wife needs to fight that law (and if she isn't, she's in the wrong), and you need to back her up (and if you don't, you're in the wrong). That's it.
No, the worst thing we could do to our kids is to be in jail trying to fight stupid laws. We find ways to help teach them accountability and such, we can tell by the fact that our eldest is way more mature than most of the other kids at their daycare as is. We set our standards high but fair and we get results. I just wish we could give our kids more freedom too, like playing outside in the yard without parents watching like I used to growing up.
The mother and father are both white.
Will be interesting to see if it turns out to be a lie, cause if she is lying about the babysitter bit then it would stand to reason other lies may be happening.
Race and immigration are irrational explanations for one simple reason, almost every crime against a child is by someone the child is related to or already knows well therefore it's mostly done with the same racial group. For example, 60% of amber alerts are just the parents, yet alone older siblings/aunts/uncles/babysitters/pastors/family friends/etc other groups that are known by the child already and thus very likely to be the same race as them.
Perhaps immigration and diversity erodes trust, but it doesn't hurt children. The people, the often same race people, in the childs life hurt children.
Teens babysitting is now illegal in Florida. Well, not technically, but practically so. A mother has been charged for leaving her 14 year old to watch her other kids (9, 11, 12) for a few days while she was on a work trip. She hired an adult babysitter to check on them twice a day too.
The youngest accidentally dropped a weight while working out, the type of accudent that can easily occur under adult supervision, they called 911 to get him medical help, and the cops proceeded to arrest the mom upon arriving back home. For the children's safety, they have now been placed with the father who is facing domestic abuse charges and has a restraining order against him, a very safe place indeed.
Here's another summary real quick of the important parts https://x.com/niah_x03/status/2115452369043652617
For those who refuse to read the articles about this case. She had a babysitter coming in the mornings to check in, make lunches, get them off to school, and prep dinner for them. All the 14 year old had to do was help them get inside after school. Microwave dinner. Get kids in bed and text mom updates. This was a work trip and they threatened to fire her if she did not go. The father has abuse charges and the police handed him their kids on top of arresting her.
I've talked about this topic before here on themotte, how children and teens are now treated as completely incapable babies and this will be enforced not just socially but through the law. If it's not immediately clear I think this is ridiculous. When I was a teen, my older sister (15) was babysitting other people's kids. There's even a popular book story from the 80s about young teens and tweens (yes, some were 12!) in middle school babysitting children as part of the babysitters club. And it's not just fiction, people did that in real life. For the younger folk here, this hysteria about leaving a teenager to watch over younger children as neglect is very new and very modern.
I've talked before about how my parents and grandparents would play all around the neighborhood in their own childhood, and yet now even walking in a gated community is deemed too dangerous. At this point I can't even let my own children have independence even if I wanted to (which I do), they literally are not allowed to grow as normal human beings used to because the cops might show up cause they're out on the front yard!
It is just another part of the helicopter parent hysteria as I've talked about before as well. There are young adults now in college who need their parents to walk them through basic life, come visit to do the laundry, and clean for them! We need less "parenting" and more freedom so kids can actually be mature instead of still crying for their mommies in college! Tweens now aren't even allowed to go to another aisle in the grocery store
I once had a great 25-26 year old intern recent graduate who still had her mother trying to butt in once when something happened at my work. She's lucky I'm very forgiving and understanding of her situation and I know that she was embarrassed about it too (I even helped her find a better living situation) but it's another example of how a lot of parents are so crazy nowadays like that!
And again, it's legally enforced now. It's so legally enforced that they'll take your kids away and give them to an abuser with a restraining order! Is this really the society we're stuck with now, where our children are increasingly coddled in their teens, sometimes into their 20s and 30s, never expected to grow up or learn responsibility?
None of us will know more about this case than the prosecutor, who believed the stepdad was guilty. Since a trial won't happen now, I'll trust his judgement on who's lying.
Actually there are two people who knew more. Amy herself, and the father.
And the father was a man who saw a trial coming and thought oh fuck I'm gonna be found guilty due to the available evidence. And because he is literally a criminal who fled the courts, we never got to see the results but we sure do know what he was expecting!
It's about as close to a layman's admission of guilt as we can get.
- Prev
- Next

You missed a very key part of what I said. "everyone secretly agrees with me, including the people whose words and actions indicate disagreement"
Do you think there is a sizeable amount of people whose words and actions indicate disagreement with the statement "Height is an advantage in basketball"? I've literally never seen it, and if I were to ask 100 random people on the street I think every single one would agree in both words and actions.
This is not the case if you were to ask about trans identity. There is a large portion of the population (around 40%) with words and actions that indicate a genuine belief.
Thus it is completely true to say that everyone agrees with the basketball statement, because there is not any stated disagreement with it to be found! It is not true to proclaim everyone agrees on trans identities.
Now if you can find me a large group of people who contest height advantage in basketball, then I will concede that it's not "everyone" who knows sports can be unfair.
More options
Context Copy link