@Throwaway05's banner p

Throwaway05


				

				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2023 January 02 15:05:53 UTC

				

User ID: 2034

Throwaway05


				
				
				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2023 January 02 15:05:53 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 2034

All of this below is somewhat moot in the sense that I'm not convinced that Ellison had Bipolar.

Disturbances in cognition exist on a spectrum from "this is not recognized pathology and is just my personality structure" (like a preference for scrambled eggs, a love of baseball, or being an asshole to your girlfriend because you are insecure about your small dick) to "this is purely something with an organic cause and blaming the person for their behavior is asinine" (a classic example benign example is a granny who is violent in the hospital because she's delirious and thinks she's is in a Nazi camp because of a UTI, a classic scarier example is someone who engages in a mass shooting because they have a golf ball sized tumor pressing on a few key structures in their brain).

Cases of the former are much more legitimate to blame (whatever that means) if love of eggs cause problems. Realistically insecurity about the small dick requires some sort of sex therapy or something if the person wants to stop hurting others and have a bit better of an experience of life.

Murder granny gets put in restraints and we treat her UTI and then everyone goes about their business and forgives her afterwards.

When it comes to things in the middle of those two extremes (that is, classic mental illness) we have a similar range. On one end you have personality disorders, like borderline personality disorder. These are in truth diseases of personality construction and really tease at what a "disease" is. It's easy to not feel bad for them (although I encourage you to) and this is true to the point where people don't want to give the diagnosis because of stigma (they give bipolar instead, relevance to Ellison?).

At the other end is one of: schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder, and bipolar disorder. You could debate which one and they are certainly interesting and have interesting impacts on how much sympathy and guilt we should feel (what do you mean a symptom of the disease is that he doesn't think he has a disease and that's why he doesn't take medication and then ends up hurting people?),

True Bipolar 1 with psychotic features is the most stark here. Again I doubt Ellison had this but this the most sympathy you can have. This is a person with a monster inside them that comes up abruptly and severely because they run a 5k and their metabolism of their lithium changes.

They go from total normal nice person to a violent felon who doesn't sleep, spends their entire family's money and does X,Y, and Z ends up in jail with HIV and then gets started on medication and then goes completely back to normal.

Some people do things that put them at higher rate of an episode, but many people commit no mistakes and still lose.

Living with that should increase sympathy, no?

Most people aren't as stark as the straw patient above, but that is what it can be like.

I have to imagine that the Dems have gotten very good at knifing each other for perceived thought crimes and insufficient demographic achievement. Only those who have been around long enough manage to avoid this through the accumulation of political power manage to survive in this environment.

Too much eating their own.

I do know a lot of young dems who in other times would be stepping up, but they seem to be too white and/or male and therefore stick with the think tanks or party strategist roles (and lead the elders into unpopular decisions).

and if I read 200 pages of a 1000 page story I still consider myself to have "read" it.

That is fair, would do it, and at the same time is antithetical to me haha.

I've read like 200-300 stories in this genre,

How the fuck! So many of them are so damn long.

Thank you!

Although I am not pleased with Australia slander.

I hope so! I was worried about Ukraine but I don't know the specific situation right now.

Interesting, my mental model of a trucker is still a fat white guy with a hat.

RE: overtaking, as per google AI summary:

"In Germany, "Elefantenrennen" (elephant racing) refers to the slow overtaking of one truck by another on a highway, often blocking all lanes and causing traffic congestion. It's a common, and often frustrating, phenomenon where trucks with minimal speed differences attempt to pass each other, causing delays. This practice is actually illegal in Germany, according to GermanyinUSA."

Somebody on here was reading Sublight Drive, which I have now finished and loved. The author reported he had to stop writing secondary to mandatory service, anybody know what country he is from?

I am not this man!

Not sure I would say this person's writing resembles mine but that's the kinda thing I'd have limited ability to assess.

Also not sure how I feel about being accused of semi-trolling. I do earnestly believe we increasingly have the evidence base and research on outcomes to conclude that free will is pretty damn limited.

Not sure if I've been up to other stuff that could be considered trolling other than my excessive arguing with that one guy a few months ago.

On a related note some people get pleasure from exercise (ex: runner's high). Others don't. This has a significant impact on enjoyment of and therefore participation in exercise.

.....Does it? With a rear view camera it should be pretty damn fast.

I mean it's def location dependent. If I lived in the Netherlands? That's one thing.

Where I live they function like handicap spots. Do people use them and need them? Sure. Are they nearly always empty unless someone is misusing them? Also sure.

Also tons of delivery/professional bike riders weaving through traffic, going on the side walk in an unsafe way, wrong waying on a lane and so on.

As for additional driving scissor statements, I prefer to back into a parking spot, or pull through a double spot to be facing out. Some people call it “getaway parking,” others deride it as “ghetto.”

I also do this, I had no idea anyone would deride it.

I don't think you should implement bike lanes without stiff penalties for not using them (or for cars, stealing the space).

For now I see bike lanes as a waste of space that bicycles don't use.

Proceed in an orderly and predictable manner

Personally I think this is an underrated component of the whole thing, and part of my issue with Bikes. Being predictable is safe.

road trains

Thank you!

And someone with different genetics and life experiences might be able to do so.

Probably Dilaudid, also known in the ER as "I'm allergic to everything except for that one that starts with D."

Follow-up question: what do you mean by the road train stuff?

Also re: headlights, lots of people have and use automatics now, do you oppose relying on that?

I now interrupt your regularly scheduled WWIII/Nothing Ever Happens to ask a question:

So, the Bike discussion down below generated a lot of angst and heat, so I'd like to poll The Motte on our driving habits a bit (in the CW thread because I do fear we are going to get some strong feelings).

How do we feel about the following:

  1. You should turn on your turn signal every time you switch lanes or otherwise would be expected to use it, even if nobody is around.

  2. Stop signs and red lights need to be fully stopped at, even if nobody is around and you know there isn't a red light camera.

  3. Speed limits should be followed to the letter when possible.

  4. The left lane is for passing only, and also, if you are in that lane and not passing and someone cuts you off or rides your bumper, that is fine.

  5. If someone does not make room for you and you need to come over (and properly signaled) you can cut them off guilt free.

  6. I can break some of these rules (or others) but other drivers should not.

  7. Any other possible driving scissor statements?

If you'd like to be mad at me: Yes, Yes, No, Yes with qualification, Yes, No.

Admittedly handling this well requires some flexibility of thinking that is going to be challenging for the general population, but just like how HBD claims doesn't mean we have to treat *ethnic group * like ass, just because free will is limited doesn't mean that we can't punish people for misbehavior, arrange society in various desirable ways, and so on.

Let's start with the free will statement. The strongest form of the argument is something like this: we have good data on things like efficacy of treatments, causes of various things, outcomes given various adverse childhood experiences and so on.*

We can cobble together some genetic data and presentations, certain kinds of childhood experiences like gross sexual exploitation, family history of other mental illness, family history of substance abuse, etc and say "this kind of person is enormously unlikely to ever overcome their circumstance." Can we do this for most people? Well not right now anyway, but for certain kinds absolutely yes.

Should we allow them the chance to make their own mistakes instead of doing something first? Different question. Should we let them run roughshod over things? No, but different question.

This definitely applies to certain patterns of child abuse.

A better example is probably opioid abuse. Medication assisted treatment (this is not safe injection sites) originally started as highly stigmatized and disliked but has grown to be approved by most in medicine because what we've found is that once addicted (rarer then you might think) most people just don't recover.

Free will need not apply. The thing is too dangerous.

Look for other options.

We know that external locus of control and efforts at getting people to help themselves work for those who can, so we should try, but thought leaders should be aware that some populations and situations just aren't going to get fixed without outside intervention.

*Simplest place to start if you want to examine the research base is ACE studies.

I see forensic patients at time and had some of my training is in a forensic setting.

Two things can be true at the same time.

  1. I hate you and I am quite happy if you spend the rest of your life in prison. You deserve it.

  2. I have compassion for you, will take care of your medical needs, and feel bad about the circumstances that led to your criminality.

In another setting it might be something like "I love you and I'm sorry your father abused you, but the way you treat me is not something I can tolerate and I will not have you be part of my life."

oh yeah you can say she's a fucking moron and I dont want my daughter doing that ....and at the same time, her life made her that way and you can feel bad for her.

I refuse to believe anyone would like cricket. REFUSE.

Bruh!!! Learn the foot. Or look around conspiratorially and go "secretly I like cricket more." Likely they will go "gasp, cricket, how awful" and ask no further questions.

Yeah fair, being judgmental IS probably more determined by your life history and cultural context, however thinking she is a nasty hoe (I mean, I do too...the shower thing? Eesh) is not incompatible with having empathy for her and awareness of the life history that likely brought her to the set of beliefs you find odious.