@Throwaway05's banner p

Throwaway05


				

				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2023 January 02 15:05:53 UTC

				

User ID: 2034

Throwaway05


				
				
				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2023 January 02 15:05:53 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 2034

Malpractice is heavily dependent on state and specialty, can be as low as 5k-10k or as high as well into six figures (OB). Some states have caps on malpractice payouts, some everyone get sued constantly.

Loans are for 4 years undergrad + 4 years of medical school. After that you get paid while working 60-80+ hours a week (but the pay is 50-70) while in residency. Residency lasts like 3-7 years depending on the speciality, and to do some disciplines (like Cardiology) you have to do additional years of poor pay training on top of the residency.

Once an attending most jobs are 40-60 hours a week but some stay higher than that. Depending on the field you may also work weekends, nights, holidays, 24+ hour shifts, 2 weeks without a day off etc. even as a senior doctor.

It's not unreasonable for a PCP to make 180-220 a year. That's a lot of money in comparison to most jobs, but when the surgical sub specialist is making 600-800.....people follow incentives.

Note: We have orders of magnitude more doctors in primary care than the sexy big number specialties.

Being an excellent PCP is possibly the most difficult and cognitively demanding job in medicine. On top of that pay is shit, prestige is shit, so great people don't go into it but great people are needed.

Corporate pressure and increasing health problems means they have less time with patients but more to do than ever before.

It's a mess and I understand why patients feel mistreated but they also have no idea whats going on.

As for the specifics in the U.S. IM or FM can be a PCP after completing a relevant residency, with (some?) states having a process for being a "GP" with more limited scope of practice after completing certain levels of residency.

The U.S. is weird because all docs can technically do anything in medicine (unrestricted practice) but getting permission to do that in a particular facility, malpractice insurance, and getting patient's insurance to cover what you do is all complicated. Certain kinds of ethically challenged people manage.

a large number have cluster B personality disorders

Identity instability is a literal symptom of borderline. Not surprising if these people (when unstable) have trans thought content. If you throw the long COVID equivalent into your research studies, it's going to give you a ton of junk data and hide whatever thing is really going on.

I would guess a culture of "toughing it out" and "oh god we have tons of real health problems" limits the role for these softer diseases.

Also thank you for introducing me to "crore."

It is my firm belief that people with severe psychiatric disorders that appear to be permanent should essentially try the kitchen sink of pharmacology and related lifestyle alterations.

You should probably separate out things like depression and anxiety from illness like bipolar and schizophrenia. Some (considered crackpot) physicians will try and manage bipolar with therapy or recreational drugs but schizophrenia is pretty much straight up well understood pathophysiology that 100% necessitates medication management.

The stuff that can be managed conservatively rarely catches a diagnosis in those cases which does admittedly complicate the issue.

My suspicion is that this is a trans type situation. Yes there are real trans patients. Yes there are cultural contagion trans patients. Yes there are borderlines (and others) with identity instability manifesting as trans thought character.

Likewise with Long COVD et al you have a mix of those pathologies being rolled together and it really reduces clarity and makes it unclear to what extent it is a real thing. Some people likely do have mangled CNS/PNS as a result of viral illness, others are maybe looking for a more ego syntonic expression of their depressive symptoms.

I know less about fibromyalgia but my understanding is that some physicians are emphatic it's a real thing and more investigation will make real bio markers or whatever abundantly clear.

Not seeing any fibromyalgia in India is interesting but its possible that it's in some way culture-bound, or environment-bound - higher parasite burden, rougher lives may prevent the sensitization or whatever else is going on under the hood.

You may find it fruitful to read some of the work done by non-woke Psychologists and Psychiatrists (ex: Life at the Bottom by Theodore Dalrymple), if for no other reason than to go "my god other people have noticed this!"

Everybody who deals with these people has experienced this stuff but having the tools to diagnose and label what these people do is helpful (and may at times give you some insight in how to work them for your needs).

This happens a lot in our own fucking notes we used to share mission critical information with each other (called note bloat), pretty much zero reason to assume it will have the smallest usefulness for patient facing stuff (for the reasons you outline).

Additionally the level of affirmative action in medicine is extremely intense, I haven't looked at the data in a few years so I don't know where it's at now, but it used to be absurd - something like 90% percent of black med students would not have ended up in medicine if put on a fair playing field.

Not nearly as common as death by volume of paperwork, but an example of actual errors is when practice changes due to new information, and nobody updates the info sheets.

So while I sympathise, I don't know what can be done. If doctors over-warn, that triggers panic, if they don't warn, there is risk of a very severe side-effect. And yeah, you'll have patients who don't listen anyway.

Yup. :/

Pharmacists do have a helpful role here though. Specialities like Psych and Oncology have medication that is complicated and generally have the time to pause and talk through some things, but an antibiotic for an infection? PCP gonna move on to the next patient - good time for the pharmacist to do med information while dispensing.

Only allowing elective work to be done (especially risky or life altering stuff) after a longitudinal period sounds like a good step. Pretty common to do this for trans stuff but less so for things like a tummy tuck or the sterilization, which can also go wrong but we are happy to do.

I generally get the feeling the consent process exists to protect us from patients not the other way around, and longer/more clear communication may not help with that.

Written communication can be a problem sometimes though - you are going to have to write down that one of the risks is death, or other scary things and it's going to be worth it, and rare. But having that on a piece of paper that someone can stare at can be a bad thing.

Barring that, I'd at least like doctors to make a good faith effort to communicate all major known risks, as well as known unknowns and unknown unknowns to the patient before they get them to sign the unreadable legalese that they likely have to do before a procedure.

On paper we do a good job of this (although realistically I know a lot of docs half ass the consent process). The issue is that people struggle with risk. 'If I had known I was going to have night vision problems I wouldn't have gotten the eye surgery." Well generally we can't predict that in advance, we can tell you the rate of problems and so on, but that's it. That doesn't stop patients from wanting us to have perfect knowledge and suing when we simply don't.

Do you think physicians have a role in executions? Our stance is for the most part no (because do no harm), but I do think about the Solus principle - "had to be me, someone else might have gotten it wrong."

That approach can be fine for medical (as opposed to surgical specialties - in those you want someone who has some years of physical practice without being too far along in age), although the caution is that medical knowledge changes quickly. I remember within a couple years of starting residency (much less being an attending) some of what I was taught was outdated and it would have been very easy to not notice.

As to your other piece a lot of surgeons (and things like Oncologists) will have ancillary staff who can help generate counseling and additional information for patients in a way that is actually helpful.

And then I face-palmed when the final quiz began asking questions about HIPAA, which is not a thing in India and not covered in the course itself, strongly suggesting the course had been designed by ripping off a US source, or perhaps the latter hadn't localized it particularly well.

Jesus fucking christ.

Anyway - thank you for in essence covering my thoughts better than I did.

I think what I struggle with is that people should be allowed to make mistakes, but they should not be allowed to be fooled (or at least we should try and be more proactive in preventing that) but we have this issue where so many big topics are misleading, or political (as the sterilization is) and therefore people may need more protection.

It's pretty common to give print outs like medication information sheets, or something called an "after visit summary." Frequently what happens is that it gets comically enormous and useless as various stakeholders fill it with random bullshit.

Anything more personalized/off the cuff becomes extremely difficult, especially as corporate control of medicine pushes doctors to see more patients faster. Really hard to do when your visits are 15 minutes max and that's supposed to include your charting time.

To what extent should we protect patients from themselves? Two things happened this week that had me considering this again.

One, some discussion on medical reddit popped up about how to handle people (chiefly young women) requesting sterilization at a young age especially prior to having children. This has obvious implications for regret and forcing people to be locked in to insufficiently considered choices.

Two I was talking to a friend who was complaining about a side effect of laser eye surgery and she said she was not told about the possibility. In talking to her she was very clearly told about the possibility of this side effect but simply didn't get it.

This is not uncommon. Either surgeons half ass the consent process, or patients just completely fail to understand and fully grok what we tell them. Generally both.

A different example - I've had the conversation "X problem is gone because of your medication, if you stop your medication X problem will come back" "okay doc I'm here to complain about X problem, I stopped my medication" a million times. Including with smart and highly educated people. People often don't understand what is told to them and that can include things like life altering surgery.

What do we do with this? Do we let people make mistakes? Where do we draw the line?

This topic comes up very frequently in medicine but the discussion quality is generally very poor "protect them from themselves unless they want such and such political topic in which case sterilize them at their request with no counseling etc etc." I think this community may have something more interesting to say.

I especially don't know how to handle this given the tendency to strongly protect autonomy in some areas but not others.

More general CW implications include the usual trans problem, but also "protecting people from themselves instead of the more specific patients.

It's both a numbers game in terms of having your own personal random bad experience and in terms of meeting people who have zero insight into and understanding of their drinking, but if you expand that to a whole population you are going to catch some weirdness.

No way I'm doing that in the US because "regulation" jazz hands. We'll catch up eventually though, and I know some are doing it. A good EMR and/or dictation fixes a lot of these issues, even for Psych you can automate a note pretty well in Epic. OP notes a bit tricker depending on your style (but dictation works great). IM discharge notes are a shit show if you want them to be not worthless though.

Most long notes that people are write in psych (less so in other specialties) are a nervous habit, or driven by "training." Regulatory/legal/billing/admin stuff is less than you think it is, filling up the whole thing with subjective info is avoidable if you are willing to condense it - use dem writing skills you got.

Can't remember the last time I saw an MAOI (for Psych use anyway, you see them in Neuro). I think Phenelzine is around a bunch still.

The TCA's have broader use, Doxepin is legitimately an excellent choice as a sleep aid.

It's important to keep in mind that SSRIs are safer but not necessarily better - it's a good guess that David Foster Wallace killed himself because his doc insisted on stopping his MAOI for "safety" reasons.

You have summoned a crankier doctor than the one I think you are looking for but I'm sure he will chime in at some point.

Some thoughts:

-It's generally standard of care to recommend that patients on psychiatric medication (or just cross through that and make it just meds in general) abstain from alcohol use. This is for a variety of reasons, chronic and acute alcohol use both have impacts on certain kinds of drug metabolism. Some medications have specific interactions with alcohol (ex: Benzos). Alcohol and Marijuana appear to have a problematic effect on underlying conditions (no shit booze is a downer). This also applies to non-psych things. We are going to suggest you stop drinking.

-Just because it's standard of care doesn't mean it's mandatory, but again if we are speaking in official capacity we are going to tell you not to do it.

-SSRIs are (with some exceptions) pretty fucking safe. Older antidepressants have some issues. We have mostly switched for a reason.

-Alcohol is a poison with a very variable effect on the human body. Sick? Tired? Just worked out? Empty or full stomach? Haven't drank in a while? Random luck of the draw nonsense? You'll have a bad time. Easy to blame on the social boogieman if you do two doubles on an empty stomach.

-Personal anecdote: I've run into a "date rape" drug level alcohol response in settings where I know nobodies shit is tampered with, so I'm certain this class of thing exists, including one time where it was me and my own bottle of rum (and I later connected the dots that I recently had diarrhea and that may have been responsible for my bad time...).

-People are variable (duh) and have variable responses to things AND also variable awareness. There are a lot of people in this world who struggle to realize they are drunk until they are absolutely obliterated. You can easily see how those types (or other adjacent groups) might feel they were drugged if they got really drunk secondary to some other non-sketchy circumstance.

-Mixing uppers and downers is a huge problem and a lot of young people don't take the combination of stimulants (including all that Starbucks) and alcohol seriously. That combo can cause severe reactions and more people abuse those things now.

Yeah most of my coworkers swear by Dragon or some other licensed or free/cobbled together replacement.

Whatever works though.

I know a lot of people subscribe the "you are slow OR you are fast" approach to medical care and documentation, and I'm partially on that train....but if you want to focus on getting faster you will. It'll take awhile (and if you don't have exceptional insight you likely won't notice it's happening until you look back) but you can get faster at typing/writing/dictating.

Figure out what is fat and trim it.*

*Okay I have no fucking clue what the regulatory environment and documentation burden is in India but this is a good skill to get started on now to prep for psych.

I think what make's the US rust belt different is that it's so large because the country is so damn huge (maybe kinda like Russia in that way?). Canada and Australia are also enormous but much more population focused.

I don't think other countries have something like Kensington in Philadelphia, although I've heard political winds have changed and theirs some thought the situation will be improved soon.