@Throwaway05's banner p

Throwaway05


				

				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2023 January 02 15:05:53 UTC

				

User ID: 2034

Throwaway05


				
				
				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2023 January 02 15:05:53 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 2034

We've known about attachment theory for a long time and have demonstrated some of its features in animal models like monkeys. Granted true deficiency is a bit more serious than the above examples. It also may be helpful to think of the murdering/rapist case as a multi-hit model. Someone has the genetics or personality structure that renders them vulnerable to doing the fucked up shit AND then they are also raised in this way. It's more of a "most psychopaths had shitty parenting" then "most people raised with shitty parenting become psychopaths."

If you stuck with it for awhile and still had problems you should look into the socks and shoes - they can make a huge difference. OR staff, nurses in general, and good podiatrists can all give you tips, otherwise I'd dig around on Reddit as this is a problem that pops up every late June/July.

Personally I swear by my Calzuros but Hokas and Ons are much trendier.

A solid piece of advice I've heard is that it's always worth investing in shit that's between you and the ground.

Many people just acclimate after a few weeks, but if you need help with that all the exercise oriented advice is good. You'll also see tons of discussion on /r/residency and /r/nursing about this topic. Many people benefit from compression socks and excellent shoes (2-3 pairs that you'll cycle through).

In the U.S. most surgery people will use upscale clogs (ex: Danksos and Calzuros) and they work great but you should be able to find some options that are in a regular sneaker form factor, just search on the medical subreddits.

Footwear makes a HUGE difference.

We have a joke in the field that goes something like this: if you get hit by a truck while testing a new drug those Super Bowl advertisements are going to start saying "may cause you to get run over."

This exaggeration but not by a lot.

As you say, OP's data is meaningless without more context.

Involving physicians is a soft-ban. Docs are overwhelmingly left/pro-gun control and afraid of getting sued.

If they can get sued for someone committing a crime (which they will be) then they'll hit NO on everyone they possible can (and will be rational to do so).

It depends on the region but the average is more 300-500.

And because you don't know anything about Anesthesia. To some extent this is fair, patients don't interact with gas much and medical TV shows are uniformly misinforming, but you haven't show any evidence for the idea that they don't do anything complicated or useful to be a reasoned and informed belief.

The pilot analogy is apt. Most people intuit that takeoff and landing are harder, and that emergencies sometimes happen. They don't know about ground prep and the other stuff pilots do. I'm not sure you are naturally making those connections here and "lol nah I'm not going to read that" does not help you become better informed.

To be maximally charitable to you it is reasonable to figure this guy is talking up what gas does (or more realistically is ignoring the difference between lazy docs and hard working ones) but that doesn't change the fact that their are multiple fundamental every shift job roles you aren't aware of.

I'm not sure you understand what anesthesiologists actually do. Gas providers are pilots, if you assume 100% of the work is when the plane is on cruise control, sure... But take off and landing are a thing. And emergencies. And routine (and emergent) prep and post work. Also the other things gas does in the hospital (especially for OB and EM but also general procedural work).

This post on meddit outlines some specific.

https://old.reddit.com/r/medicine/comments/10wj8ma/anesthesiologists_how_well_could_crnas_do_your_job/j7ohdyo/

I absolutely agree it will get there, and this update that we have the technology to read EKGs correctly now is profoundly unshocking, but the fact that it isn't in use is telling (healthcare has tons of barriers including the regulatory) and the ability to form a good gestalt is a very complicated and hard skill.

AI will come for us - motivation is high because of the cost (in dollars) but the level of care is high because of the cost (in lives). We'll probably be one of the later manifestations and docs won't get cut out.

This topic irks me so much because one of the strongest patterns in American healthcare is outside industries thinking it is easy, rolling in, failing miserably, and leaving behind a trial of broken lives (especially coming in from tech and finance). Winners do exist (see like PE in EM and HCA) but mostly do so through illegal activity and profoundly unethical behavior.

So we have a ton of top of the line decision support tools right now, (including things like auto-read for EKGs, suggestions to put in antibiotic if the computer thinks someone is septic, etc.) the problem is that they suck and are intrusive and annoying. This is important, not only do they need to be more right but they also need to be consistently right - people are trained just to ignore them and if you go from being helpful from 5% of the time to 30% of the time they'll still be functionally useless. If we get to a 70% range situation people will ignore them out of habit and ingrained mistrust.

That problem aside...why is this shit so hard?

It's not because medicine is complicated (it is, but that's not the problem*), LLM are perfect for digging through a bunch of data and such. It's because people are complicated. People come in with a severe illness and complain about something else, ignore a diagnostically critical symptom, report pain in the "wrong" quadrant for the pathology (happens all the damn time).

The decision support tool needs to handle this ambiguity gracefully, have some mechanism for sussing out the correct shit from the patient, and have graceful way of handling the editorializing of whoever is recording and entering the data (and ideally in a timely fashion as you mention).

And then you have super significant but more arcane layers to the problem. Okay my patient has a kidney issue and a heart issue. My decision support tool can help and send me the most updated guidelines. Well where are we pulling from? Cards or Neph? One is shouting Blue and the other is shouting Yellow and depending on which Ivory Tower Institution you pull from the shades of those colors are going to be wildly different.

Research in medicine is difficult and fraught and ethically complicated and we don't have enough high quality recommendations to load this stuff with.

In Europe they manage appendicitis mostly medically, in the U.S. we operate. You ask a surgeon here why the difference and they'll probably say it's because we are fatter. Is that right? Fuck if I know, but we can't agree on the most simple of management.

*I have no idea why the EKG reads are bad, that's pretty damn simple and doesn't bode well for getting anything more complicated done.

You do realize the AMA primarily lobbies in support of lower salaries for doctors right?

I find that most people who think doctors (well, medical professionals) are easy to replace have a pretty limited understanding of what actually happens in healthcare. Sure if you occasionally have an ear infection or a sprained muscle that seems pretty easy and simple and replaceable. Even something like anesthesia, what this guy is just pushing some buttons right?

Well no.

You go into the hospital with trouble breathing, your doctor comes to see you. Your heart rate is elevated. Do you have a growing infection? Are you nervous talking to the doctor? Were you trying to work out because you have a date next week? Is this a side effect from the breathing medication we gave you? Were you just fucking your girlfriend? One of these requires immediate start of antibiotics, and patients can have more than one of them happening at the same time (and in my experience, have).

The algo is just going to start abx which is not harmless by any means. Decision support exists but it's uniformly terrible because it can't take into account the gestalt and patients usually have multiple things going wrong (both inpatient and outpatient). Young and healthy people with a single sick complaint is approximately zero percent of the work in healthcare but also 100% of what is replaceable with decisions support right now.

In a U.S. ED we have multiple layers of triage and knowledge running from triage nurses, to mid level providers, to ED physicians to IP docs and consultants. We know that the lower levels on this scale are inferior (and that includes ED physicians) because we observe it on a daily basis.

Current decision support tools can't even read an EKG, the amount of development required to deal with the messy complexity of people (including the fact that people will misinform you both intentionally and unintentionally) is immense and god help us if the people like Cim who think we aren't doing anything useful or important get their way.

Boba is a form of social gathering and an alternative to booze, that's where most of the love comes from.

My understanding is that the needing CPR twice was a miscommunication (likely because of something like "he was initially triaged in a resuscitation bay at the trauma center" which is a different kind resuscitation).

However even if he did have CPR twice that isn't evidence against commotio cordis, damage from "down time" (even with prompt high quality CPR) can lead to other problems like anoxic brain injury (likely avoided it seems), pulmonary damage (seems present), and issues with perfusion to other parts of the body that can lead to PT/OT needs. If your heart gets fucked up it fucks shit up. Not out of the woods after initial ROSC is obtained.

If you look at some of the initial medical social media discussion of this you'll see that some people were confused, commotio cordis is rare (and is more common in pediatric populations for physiology reasons) but that's what it looked like, pretty much slam dunk (ex: initial continued perfusion allowing to stand followed by sudden collapse). So we were wondering if it was an atypical presentation of something more "common" in this setting like hypertrophic cardiomyopathy.

I haven't seen a diagnosis released yet but cordis is most likely at this point and is pretty much a freak accident and has nothing to do with COVID.

The YouTuber Adam Ragusea seems to have pretty good connections to academic food researchers and the content from those discussions often shows up in the videos. Maybe see what resources he uses?

Doc here, the "official" answer here is that a few things are going on (at least in the U.S.).

-Healthcare resources are overwhelmed, especially pediatrics.

-People have forgotten what respiratory illness is like and have been taught to fear them because of COVID (Flu is really uncomfortable and always has been) leading more people to seek care.

-Lots of problems with people not seeking vaccines for the obvious reasons (get your fucking flu shots please).

-Immune systems are weak.

-Kids in particular are always prone to respiratory disease, but it's even worse than normal due to the obvious reasons, leading to transmission of adults at higher rates (including stuff like RSV which isn't usually an adult problem).

So it's a little bit of subjectively worse (after years of not being sick and being told to fear sickness...) but also a bit objectively worse due to more things being out there and lazy immune response. Hospital utilization has been high, and while mortality is still low it's higher than usual.

Also we have another COVID bump.

These things are supposed to also happen in "seasons" but this also has been fucked up severely over the last couple of years.

Edit: I should also add that we've had Acetaminophen shortages, which is like the most basic medication available (although it shouldn't be) and kinda tells you how bad things have been.

Short version: costs are weird, sometimes outright unknown (the accounting for some stuff gets bizarre), charges are generally inflated as a result an annoying dance with insurance companies and the federal government to get things paid for (ex: for a lot of stuff medicaid and medicare pay less than cost so things get...creative and the insurance company goes "we'll pay you 1.05 times the cost...").

Professional fees are like likely to do this because it's a little more obvious to pay out a portion of a staff members salary based off of how long the encounter is supposed to go (very doctors, NPs, or PA are self-employed these days, almost everyone is "owned" sometimes by a hospital but also by....).

Based off the absurdly inflated price and and the lack of willingness to negotiate (most health systems will be flexible with cash pay) (and also the fact this is the ED) the PA was probably owned by a practice management group which is when a PE firm buys a physician group and does things like cut salaries, raise prices, and be an asshole (and give the money back to whoever is invested in it). It's a huge problem right now.

It is also possible that this primarily driven by what happens when your insurance company just refuses to pay for things but that's less likely.

(and yes I know you asked for a general primer but the point is to build knowledge of the unexpected complexity).

Here's an example-

https://old.reddit.com/r/Residency/comments/104bwb4/why_was_damar_hamlin_in_the_sicu_after_his/

Why is Damar in a SICU (Surgical Intensive Care Unit) - some people are saying that's best practice, some people are saying that's best quality of care, some people are saying that's because of the resources specifically at UC and some people are saying it is because the case is high profile. And you can find someone saying the opposite for each of those. Everybody knows what they are talking about.

No way to know unless you work there and were involved and some combination of those answers is probably correct.

Stuff is very resource and facility dependent and a lot of things don't have strong consensus.

Negotiating prices for services is not "extracting" money unexpectedly, being unaware of what the insurance will cover is not "surprising fucking over," the insurance knows what they will pay for and we often don't and have to fight them, even for clearly necessary stuff.

Hospitals can't know (as in knowing and changing your decisions as a result is illegal, specifically for emergency medicine) what the insurance is going to do, the agency is extremely limited.

In response to this sort of fuckery places have literally closed their EDs. Hospitals are going out of business at record rates and posting record lows for profit. Meanwhile the insurance companies are posting record highs.

What are they supposed to do? Break the law and not treat the guy? Just not get paid and then go out of business? Stop victim blaming.

And that's completely ignoring the other layer of this which I can't verify with the details OP provided, but the PA is probably owned by a third party - a private equity group that does enjoy the revenue associated with skull fucking patients and everyone in healthcare would love for that behavior to get banned but we don't have any control...

I don't know how the fuck the scummy companies won the psyop where they blame everything on doctors who have zero administrative or financial control.

Again, the entity extracting more money and surprise fucking over the patient isn't the hospital or the healthcare provider it's the insurance company.

OP paid the insurance company for a service (covering healthcare needs) and then the insurance company was like lol nah we aren't going to do that, and instead of refusing to pay the insurance company or complaining about the insurance company they take it out on essentially a third party with no control.

If I wire transfer some money to 419 scammers and then walk into a bank and punch an employee in the face for allowing me to get scammed then I'm the asshole.

The ED is literally required by law to provide care regardless of insurance status, ability to pay, or appropriateness of that level of care. There's literally nothing the ED can do to stop this, it's OP's job to go to an appropriate level of care, think critically about whether an ED visit is required, investigate his insurance, or get new insurance.

OP and the Hospital are both victims of the insurance company being an asshole.

Nurses are leaving bedside nursing in droves and while some specialties are keeping up with retirement rates we are slipping behind our overall healthcare needs.

My problem is not that OP has a moral requirement to pay a bill no matter how stupid it is, it's that he doesn't know if it's stupid or not in this case, he (and everyone else) is blaming the wrong parties (the PA has no idea what's being charged and has no control over it, blame the insurance company or the hospital/practice management group that owns the PA). He also went to an inappropriate level of care and was surprised that costs were excessive. If you get admitted and demand to be in the ICU instead of on the floor it'll be your fault when the bill is an order of magnitude higher.

You'd think so and it's a fair question which is why I gave example somewhere else in this soup of comments. Elective procedures, stuff done at an outpatient surgery center, cosmetic things. Low rate of complications, low rate of fuck ups, pretty simple with a lower range of prices. Sure. Places will do that.

Hard to do for symptoms for so many reasons (is that headache a migraine, a stress headache, or a brain bleed? You are complaining about 8 things and the real problem is heart failure etc etc, the pain is referred and it's actually a very different kind of thing).

Once you've figured out what's going on it's feasible for some things, but the American population is really unhealthy and the one person where you open them up, find out it's bowel cancer and not appendicitis costs hundreds of times more than the regular appy.

It's the equivalent of those housing developments where everyone shares water fees but someone has a pool that they keep emptying and refilling every day.

I learned how to effectively grade scientific literature by looking for places where you'd see the hordes of "SOMEONE IS SAYING SOMETHING WRONG ON THE INTERNET" types and seeing what they said, and then after years of that picking up the skills myself.

Go to /r/medicine or other similar places, look for the hot button stuff, see what people say and complain about. At first you'll be missing context but you'll pick it up. Bonus points if you also go to the other places with different levels of training like /r/residency.

Be aware of the biases of the various areas though (anything remotely political is DOA on meddit, it's appropriate to hate midlevels but the residency subreddit takes it a little far).

Very common for industry adjacent people to do this, you'll see consultants, tech people, and lawyers pop in with their expertise because they are following or work or because of a partner.

Most of the mistakes people make are pretty basic- assuming it's simple and easy, or because they are falling for one of the agenda pushers (including us).

If you look closely you'll probably see one of those situations where three people with over 20 years of training and who very are on top of it are articulately arguing over if something like if "is a bandaid is actually a good idea or not" and you'll be like Jesus this is a nightmare.

Pretty normal to sign a document that says you are financially responsible for accrued charges.

Consider that when you walk into the ED with chest pain you can end up with a million dollar suite of cardiac surgery or thirty cents of tums and everyone has limited idea to predict which it is going to be ahead of time.

Ah you took this a different angle than everyone which is a better one.

-Restrictions on open immigration are not unique to medicine, no field wants to import competition and generally countries don't want to fuck over their knowledge workers. While the U.S. is notable for you needing to redo residency, that doesn't mean it's actually possible to move over (Canada and Australia will happily take U.S. docs but Germany is incredibly hard) for other reasons.

-Related to that, most countries aren't excited about this because in many countries a lot of people want to move to the U.S. because it's the U.S. or because salaries are higher. If you offered everyone in the NHS the chance to move to the U.S. healthcare in England would collapse instantly. So both the push and pull are blocked.

-Despite this if you wanted to import family medicine doctors (the only area that has true real need) from other countries I don't think anyone would complain, including the family care doctors.

-Training is strictly controlled in the U.S. and is better than elsewhere (mostly by being harder, potentially for no reason) but is also very much so less variable. You picked good countries but you couldn't do this with say India because of the training programs are absolutely U.S. grade and some are incredibly deficient.

-We don't have much of a shortage of doctors in most specialties, we have an allocation problem. Most doctors want to live in a relatively small number of urban areas so those places are flooded and everywhere else is lacking. The reasons for this are complex but increasing supply is unlikely to fix it, but doctors for clamoring for an increase in supply (in the form of residency spots) ANYWAY and have zero control it - blame the government.

-Physician political influence is abysmal right now, we've spent decades propping up our own competition, everyone hates us (because of envy of salaries, political involvement with covid, accusations of racism etc etc) and what lobbying we do do is just left wing politics.

-Physician pay is not unbelievably excessive. The average family care doctor makes 220k. That's a lot of money, but the ceiling is low and it comes with unbelievable sacrifices to that point. When people think of ridiculous pay they think of the orthopedic surgeon making 750k but those guys are less than 1% of doctors, over 90% of doctors are in primary care in some form and those people aren't making the "real" money.

-Medicine in general can be described as a skilled trade, that's what nurses are. Physician work cannot. In the U.S. doctors get training in (and are expected to use these skills) teaching, leadership/management, and research science. Depending on the field soft skills vary from mandatory to almost all of the job (as in Heme/Onc, Psych, and Palliative). On top of that some fields do have the manual skills. That is not an upscale plumber. In the U.S. we've made many attempts to drop in people with less training and skills and they do a demonstrably worse job and unlike in emergency plumbing people actually die.

Is this for real? The person billing OP wasn't even a doctor, and no PA, NP, or doctor is getting paid that much for that type of work. Blame the admin and the billing people for the number, the PA has no control over it and is making 1/10 of that sticker price.

Again, as stated elsewhere doctors have been lobbying for their own competition for years, who proceed to do the same job for cheaper, with less training, and do a demonstrably worse job.

I'm always flabbergasted at how little people seem to know about this in relation to how enthusiastic their beliefs are.

Also the NHS is collapsing.