VoxelVexillologist
๐บ๐ธ Multidimensional Radical Centrist
No bio...
User ID: 64
To respectfully break the rules on recruiting for a cause: anyone want to join me in distributing pamphlets advocating for disbanding the Selective Service in Washington some time soon? We can call it a performance art piece.
(sarcasm, if unclear, but only mostly)
I always assume that anyone unironically quoting Schenck agrees with its conclusion that distributing anti-draft pamphlets is akin to shouting fire in a crowded theater. Which seems like a downright fascist perspective, but what do I know?
Is it known whether the loans are fixed rate? If they aren't, costs are presumably also going up as the Federal Reserve keeps raising interest rates to fight inflation.
Barrett has several adopted children, IIRC two of which are from Haiti and would presumably benefit from affirmative action.
I'm hardly an expert on Russian internal politics, but this seems a case like several in history: Prigozhin likely believes he cannot escape defenestration (on account of previous comments and a lack of clear battlefield utility to the Kremlin) if he yields, so why not take a likely-unsuccessful stand? A Chinese uprising in 209BC occurred when two officers realized that the penalty for arriving late was the same as for rebelling: They were ultimately killed by their own men when their uprising proved a lost cause.
Alternatively, this could be compared to Caesar crossing the Rubicon: a charismatic military commander holding troops' personal loyalty faces a choice between yielding civil government demands to give up his army and riches and taking up arms against it. Caesar was successful despite mixed results in battle, but was ultimately unable to escape assassination at the literal hands of his political opponents.
I wasn't aware of the other gun crimes. The original article says "it would not prosecute him in connection with his purchase of a handgun in 2018 during a period when he was using drugs," which seems to dance around the details of post-purchase behavior, although I hardly expect to see charges filed for that either.
As a non-lawyer, it's fairly well known that lying on the ATF Form 4473 basically never results in charges (as of the 2018 GAO report, at least -- they claim they're trying to increase those numbers). In FY 2017, 8.6M reported transactions led to 112k denials, 12.7k investigations, and 12 prosecutions. Presumably every one of those denials lied about eligibility on that form, barring questionable corner cases like "I forgot I have a felony conviction."
Note that Form 4473 here is the one that asks "Are you an unlawful user of, or addicted to, marijuana or any depressant, stimulant, narcotic drug, or any other controlled substance?" and notes in bold that lying on the form is itself a felony. I most often see this referenced by people in gun circles complaining that the law as-written is not enforced.
As much as I wish we'd actually, like, enforce laws in this country, starting to enforce previously-mostly-ignored laws specifically with people close to politicians is a bit of a bad look. OTOH, I'd really like to see us hold those in positions of power to a higher standard, rather than a lower one.
This appears to be everyone's favorite CFAA. I have few comments about this specific case, but I mentally group it with the set of laws that exist but the Powers That Be refuse to enforce because they're likely overbroad. Some of the things it criminalizes absolutely should be valid charges, but, for example, in the 2020 Sandvig case, we finally saw a court rule that violating posted website terms of service is not inherently a criminal act.
In this instance (from my brief skim of the page you mentioned) "logging into a service account with a password that had been both posted publicly and also privately messaged" seems like the sort of borderline case which might allow a competent defense (which admittedly, the Trump family seems to have difficulty fielding) to limit the law's utility for acquiring questionable warrants. IMO we'd do well to make challenges to unenforced laws easier.
I'm reading that a major reason they went with a carbon fiber section in the hull was that they could maintain significantly more buoyancy that way, whereas if they'd used titanium everywhere they'd have needed to add separate syntactic foam floats too.
Apparently pressure-capable syntactic foam is expensive, but another traditional solution for deep sea exploration is to use gasoline tanks, which are slightly bouyant and not compressible. See the original Trieste, which reached Challenger Deep in 1960, and also managed to surface automatically in the event of electrical failure.
Further, although it's perhaps a bit arguable, the "All porn is cuckhold porn" view doesn't seem to apply well to what I've always seen described as softcore porn: your classic Playboy features solo performers but still manages, um, titillation (although one could, IMO weakly, argue that Hefner served that role).
Even then, to use your example of fiction, there's a line -- a blurry one, sometimes -- between reading Harry Potter and appreciating its storytelling (for the articles, I swear!) and identifying with Harry as a self-insert. Excessive self-insertion even a frequent trope in low-quality fanfiction. There's always a bit of tension between wanting to be like the protagonist, and wanting to be the protagonist.
I do find the premise to be interesting, and possibly true in certain ways in lots of cases, but I don't think it's quite as all-encompassing as it's stated.
I could see something like Kent State happening. It's before my time, but that caused quite a bit of protest, but didn't incite actual revolt. Also I suspect it's still fresh enough in the institutional memory that guard members and police probably are trained specifically to avoid repeating it.
It is actually against the law (22 CFR 17.22) to classify information to conceal embarrassment (also to conceal violations of law). That said, I'm sure it happens, and many embarrassing facts may also be relevant to national security.
I've known a few Christian (not specifically LDS) apologetics who defend faith as a choice to believe, and that doubt is a generally-inescapable part of that process. An earnest "I want to believe" may go further than you think.
One of the most relevant parts of that game theory, though, is how to re-establish trust and fairness given a history of defection. Given a historically bipartisan-ly corrupt system, how do you begin enforcing the rules without appearing to play favorites?
Honestly it's a hard problem of soft skills: if there were an easy answer, any number of longstanding grudges (Israel/Palestine, etc) could be settled. There are a few successful examples: Northern Ireland seems pretty peaceful these days.
For the record, I'd much prefer a non-corrupt system, but I think a partisanly corrupt system is probably even worse.
Separate and apart from that issue, the Espionage Act does not reference "classified" information. It references information "relating to the national defense," as it predates the modern system of classification by several decades. It's not clear that information being classified or declassified changes whether it is objectively information "relating to the national defense."
This is true, but I'm unaware of any (successful) instance of bringing charges against someone without a prior position of trust (see the SF 312 question). Nobody charged the editors of The Washington Post for possessing the Snowden documents, which were presumably "relating to the national defense," nor can I think of anyone other than the leakers charged for possessing leaked documents in the cases of Manning, Winner, and Teixeira. The Assange case is still outstanding and raises a lot of relevant questions.
Of course, I suppose that would be moot if someone produced a SF 312 signed by Trump himself.
But you have a reasonable argument that could be made, I just think this treads on lots of areas of novel law that will (given reasonable legal strategy, which is hardly a given for the parties in question) presumably raise lots of opportunities for challenges and appeals.
Anything and anyone around big secrets tend to become secret as well. And eventually things must either end in everything being secret or nothing being secret.
It sometimes works this way, but there are certainly cases where specific facts can remain classified in isolation on systems that are acknowledged. The DoD likes to claim top speeds "in excess of" a public value, while the actual numbers are much more closely guarded, and they presumably avoid exceeding the claimed value outside of controlled conditions. Your missile silos in North Dakota are part of Minot Air Force Base, which even has a public web site, but I doubt the silo coordinates are on it. I can only assume that completely secret programs are particularly expensive and avoided when possible.
Although I'll agree that your concern is reasonable and there are plenty of folks worried about overclassification, even within the government.
This is why secrecy and classification is infectious. Right now if you work at all with certain government agencies, like any branch of the military, the CIA, FBI, etc then you will almost certainly have to get a top secret clearance.
The need to hold the clearance doesn't imply constantly working with such material. I've talked to folks with TS clearances who have offices with windows: sometimes it's a small fraction of the job in a separate space. But having a standing clearance makes it easier to have certain discussions on short notice (and, as someone once told me, "prevents paperwork when people make mistakes").
The issue around classification is effectively whether Trump could have by his power as President deemed any of the documents he took to not be information relating to the national defense, and also whether or not his claims to have done so are in fact true, or just something he made up after the fact of him leaving office.
Part of the problem with this is legal case is that with a few (largely nuclear-related) exceptions, all classification guidance exists in the form of Executive Orders. The current guidance is EO 13526 from 2010, but that revoked and replaced a whole list of orders from previous administrations dating back to Harry Truman. So if the question is "could Trump have declassified this?", he could have declassified (almost) everything by mere a executive order revoking 13526 without replacement. In addition, the EO 13526 explicitly designates the President (and Vice President) as a "classification authority" able to determine classification.
But what constitutes an executive order? In general, the separate powers of the US federal government are given broad leeway to determine their own rules and procedures (see Noel Canning, which found that the Senate is in recess only when it declares itself as such). I can't see any reasonable court deciding that failing to write on official White House stationary invalidates an executive order. There might be an argument that the President wasn't faithfully executing the laws as passed by Congress, but the Legislature has its own means (impeachment) for enforcing that.
If the contention is that the illegal acts happened after he was president, that's a potential case, but I think it still faces a fairly high bar to show that keeping the documents wasn't justified by actions taken as president: that would require a court to take significant leeway in interpreting how the executive ran its operations. A precedent of "just because a President [claims to have] issued verbal instructions to do things that are lawful except for violating prior executive orders doesn't prevent your prosecution for violating those prior orders" would be terrible.
Does an elected President (in particular, one with no prior service) even have to sign SF 312? That NDA is the vehicle through which most criminal charges for mishandling classified information flow, and without it it's unclear that any charges could stick to a non-signatory. That's why the powers that be can't charge the journalists at The Washington Post who published the Snowden leaks.
Now, the fact that classification is almost entirely due to Executive fiat is, I would agree, a terrible arrangement, and it would make quite a bit of sense to codify (much of) the existing ruleset through an act of Congress. But, in its great wisdom, Congress hasn't decided that doing so is worth its effort. Ultimately, I'm not a fan of Trump, but this really seems like a politicized effort to bring historically unprecedented charges.
IMO the fact that the universe exists is a fairly compelling argument for theism generally. Any science undergraduate will understand that zero everywhere is a very satisfactory solution to all of the relevant field equations, but the fact that anything is here at all implies a far more complicated arrangement. I personally find it more compelling than life, even intelligent life, existing within the universe.
But that's just my opinion and it's hardly conclusive ontological proof.
If so, I want to ask the DoD why they're giving people clearance to say untrue things.
For some categories of folks, I wouldn't be surprised if pre-publication review is mandatory. The DOD probably has to at least proofread any book by certain folks, even if they decide to write historical fiction. A memoir or anything close to their specialty could actually inadvertently disclose something classified. It's quite possible the folks here charged with "giving clearance" only care about a very narrow set of facts (names, places, dates) appearing.
Although I suppose claiming any degree of official statement or backing might be its own concern. But it's unclear to me this is actually claimed here: "the censors didn't censor my ramblings" isn't alone an endorsement.
It's not bizarre at all if you remember that ChatGPT has no inner qualia. It does not have any sort of sentience or real thought. It writes what it writes in an attempt to predict what you would like to read.
I don't think I disagree here, but I don't have a good grasp of what would be necessary to demonstrate qualia. What is it? What is missing? It's something, but I can't quite define it.
If you asked me a decade ago I'd have called out the Turing Test. In hindsight, that isn't as binary as we might have hoped. In the words of a park ranger describing the development of bear-proof trash cans, "there is a substantial overlap between the smartest bears and the dumbest humans." It seems GPT has reached the point where, in some contexts, in limited durations, it can seem to pass the test.
One of my heuristics for good persuasive writing involves the number of citations, or at least clear distinct factual references that could be verified, as the clerk is doing for the rest of us here. Broad, general arguments are easy to write, but in my opinion shouldn't be weighted as heavily.
The amusing part here is that I have been doing this for years to weed out political hacks, long predating GPT.
Interesting! Any good papers or summary articles you'd recommend?
I know this is a hobby horse, but once AI is trained on gait recognition and body language of labelled examples of millions of hours of countless criminalsโ movements recorded by CCTV, tiny little telltale patterns might well allow for effective pre-crime in the case of almost all premeditated criminal activity. People show their nerves, everyone has a tell, etc.
I have trouble believing there's enough information content present in CCTV streams to uniquely identify individuals confidently. I see how it maybe could work, but it's not something I'd focus on directly. Are human gaits really that different as to be identifiable from distant security cameras? Are they even consistent for a single person day-to-day?
The longer I think about it, I've also started thinking that AI likely scales sub-linearly (logarithmic?) with the size of the training dataset. "But the AI can viably consider a larger dataset than human experts" may be true, but may not generate hugely better results.
This is the equivalent of a Japanese Banzai charge straight into dug-in machine gun emplacements and sighted artillery.
I've long thought that if the Catholics really wanted to win a battle in the Culture War, they should start repeating "anti-Catholic animus" (or perhaps some catchier -phobia or -ism term I'm not going to consider) in the same way that "racism" and "antisemitism" get thrown around. The historical citations aren't really unjustified: the KKK was founded as, among other things, anti-Catholic. All of the historical bias against Italians and Irish immigrants is at least somewhat rooted in anti-Catholic bias, as is some of the bias against Central and South American immigration. The Nazis persecuted Catholics. And they continue to be victims of hate crimes in the US.
On one hand, repetition legitimizes and a constant drone of "we're persecuted" is functionally how various groups on the left have achieved their existing hierarchy -- this seems to bear more relation to the quantity and quality of complaints than to any particular metrics of measurable oppression. On the other, I respect that Catholics absolutely could claim (some degree of) martyrdom in the Year of Our Lord 2023 but choose not to because silent stoicism better aligns with their principles.

Your spring metaphor reminds me of a fair amount of literature on athletic performance: everyone agrees that training makes you stronger, but not immediately. Asking folks who just finished a marathon to run another immediately -- but faster now because they've trained more -- is not going to go well. You actually get stronger when resting after training. But rest too long and you start to lose form.
Sports science has figured out all sorts of (imperfect) models for human performance. Generally best results come from periodizing training and recovery to optimize fitness in competition, rather than year-round.
I think your idea generalizes "strong" here to include more than athletic feats. But even accepting that model doesn't make it easy: motivation for self-improvement purely for stoic self-actualization -- thanks, Maslow! -- doesn't in my experience work that well. I try (and do okay, I think) but my greatest efforts and successes in life have had non-actualization driving factors.
Even if we assume it would work -- of which I'm not certain -- it's unclear to me how we'd encourage this at a population level. There have been plenty of pop culture books that have tried, but getting people to clean their room, or even exercise modestly and eat healthier, seems to prove quite difficult for the average human wealthy enough to have a choice in the matter.
More options
Context Copy link