VoxelVexillologist
πΊπΈ Multidimensional Radical Centrist
No bio...
User ID: 64
That its elites have decided to screw around with polyamory instead of doing the maximally-effective thing in the world reminds me more of a new-age religious sex cult than a movement genuinely interested in improving the world.
There is a certain irony in "deny base human impulses: apply rationality" quickly falling into "have as much sex as possible," which is probably the most base human impulse. But then again I've long recommended that actions be constantly scrutinized against lofty, if laudable, mission statements. Individual humans, even in groups, are quite fallible creatures, which is something that I respect religion for recognizing: "For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God."
There was a time up until probably the early 2000s when Scientology was a large part of the culture war, in particular regarding several legal battles between the church and it's detractors. They really were attacking anyone discussing Xenu, and both openly and covertly threatening their detractors. There are some pretty serious allegations against them.
I don't think Scientology is the best example here.
object to abortion but I value doctor-patient confidentiality, so as long as I don't know it's happening, I don't think I have much to say about abortion...
I've never found the confidentiality argument from Roe persuasive, and I don't think the legal system ever did either. Any coherent principle that treatments are exclusively between doctors and patients has to skip over that Roe was never found to legalize medical marijuana or euthanasia, both of which we've punished patients and doctors for in the past.
I think there are reasonable arguments in either direction, but a hard libertarian view of the doctor-patient relationship seems only to be referenced as a rhetorical cudgel rather than a principled argument.
Your description here sounds a lot like Havel's greengrocer, which is absolutely a thing non-artificial intelligences (real people) do too.
There's a specific flavor for these activities. They're all too complex to explain in a tweet, so the masses of lefty Palestinian propagandists can't describe them effectively and Israel "gets away with it".
I can see how this could be an effective strategy on the part of the Israelis, but The Motte seems like an ideal place to pick a few choice anecdotes in a longer form to sway readers. I, at least, would be interested in reading a few examples.
Conversely, appealing to an amorphous blob of never-enumerated misbehaviors is also a fairly common media strategy (see "X is problematic" in recent years).
While I think it's probably the case that the only true long-term resolution is a three state arrangement with Egypt annexing the Gaza Strip and Jordan the West Bank, I also accept that neither of those would be popular right now because neither of those countries is on good terms with the Palestinians. Arafat was involved with a 1970 attempt to overthrow the Jordanian monarchy, and Hamas in Gaza occasionally shoots at the Egyptians (who also maintain the blockade) too.
While the Israelis are not completely innocent in the conflict, it does seem like convincing a fractured Palestinian leadership to adopt peaceful resistance strategies is the only alternative to the current status quo.
The one I'm most familiar with is the Texas Open Meetings Act, which seems to place some stricter requirements on "meetings" with although that would depend on the details of city governance (were these "meetings" with the mayor and city council or is the mayor authorized to directly command the police department without deliberation?) and the text messages at play. Anecdotally, I've heard that politicians are advised to not discuss business outside of announced, scheduled meetings, but charges are infrequent (although not non-existent).
I think there are several states with open meetings and records laws (uncertain about the specific one in Washington state) in which this might rise to a criminal act. But that would also depend on the state wanting to bring charges.
childlessness is motivated by status
I think there's a fair amount of room for soft power to define what "high-status" means. I can't see it happening in the immediate future, but the idea of a society where the zeitgeist treats having children early and (slightly more) often as normal and respectable seems like something that could exist. Having movie protagonists choose (and juggle) parenting as something other than a minor side plot could occur more often. There was a moment where Lean In-style feminism might have encouraged this, but that seems to have faded.
Honestly, if you could wrangle the sorts of soft power that various activist groups wield fairly regularly you could probably make measurable progress at a goal of "have [a few] more children".
The example that came to mind was Texas with SB212. I can't immediately find matching legislation or executive policy in other states, but requiring almost all employees be mandatory reporters seems a common-but-not-universal setting. There is even a controversial effort by the federal DOE to make this universal, so perhaps it's not as polarized a notion as I thought.
On the other hand, I don't really have a good explanation why Texas decided to pass SB212, although I suppose it could also be related to the student-athlete scandal at Baylor a few years back.
A couple years back, several red state legislatures adopted bills designating certain employees (in particular, public university employees) as "mandatory reporters" of sexual discrimination under Title IX. At first it seemed a bit odd because normally boosting the Title IX office isn't a Republican priority, but in thinking about it, it seems that it was likely done at least partially to hang a nice-sounding Sword of Damocles over anyone attempting to run such a curriculum.
I don't know if I can comment on it's success, but I wouldn't be surprised to see it expanded to include racial discrimination in the future. There is also that outstanding SCOTUS case about affirmative action that may substantially shake things up.
It's worth noting that United Launch Alliance (ULA), one of their main competitors, is a joint Lockheed-Boeing project rather forcefully spun off from lawsuits between the two major market players. In the interest of continued service (neither going bankrupt and ending production), they were effectively forced to work together in 2006. I think your prediction is right: a forced sale to one of the larger government contractors, followed by re-evaluating the continual loss-leader strategy Musk seems to like.
On the subject of Starlink specifically, I had a project to estimate the market feasibility of such a service before it started launching, and at least my result was that it probably can't be profitable at the list prices. There is a chance it could be selling to the government, but there aren't enough people in OP's position to pay landline ISP prices to fund the operating costs for the launches, the ground stations, and staffing.
The US at least has spent a ton of money running fiber to rural areas in the last few decades, which doesn't require too much ongoing upkeep.
My (Musk-skeptic) view is that Starlink exists to provide a regular payload for Falcon 9: despite promises that cheaper launches would increase demand, they seem to have largely flushed out the wait lists and have actually seen a decline in commercial launches in recent years. "Exponential growth" wasn't going to keep banner launch rates up without making payloads themselves. The satellites and ground terminals themselves seem to work, although not as well as originally promised: do they have cross-links like Iridium had in the 90s? How much power do the ground terminals draw?
The economics of private companies mean that its hard from the outside to view their profitability. On the other hand, I've long predicted that empire dissolving, and I've admittedly been wrong about the timeline for that so far.
Perhaps I've personally over-estimated the risk, but the small empty bike rack outside the store next to the store a hundred yards from the local homeless encampment that seems full of likely-stolen bicycles is not confidence inducing. You may have convinced me to try it some time: I do bike to work (which has safe bike storage) sometimes.
Grocery stores tend to need a lot of open space.
I would point out that in addition to space for loading and restocking, the American grocery store has been trending larger to offer a wider variety of products. The economies of scale allow stocking two dozen types of cheese and a dozen different varieties of apples in a way that a corner store (which I've visited when travelling) just can't match.
Although I'm rather skeptical of the 15 minute number because despite living in a suburban (in-city) area of single-family homes, there are two major grocery stores within a hair over that that I'd never consider walking to because it'd be impractical to carry a family load of groceries that far. There is a corner store a few hundred yards away that I rarely visit because their selection is pretty small. It's too long of a walk to be a great idea, and I wouldn't trust a bike to not get stolen in a 20 minute visit (or carry an extra 50 pounds), so I drive.
Although I will vouch that the grocery stores tend to be near larger homeless encampments: I suspect it's partly space like you mention, also that food is readily accessible, and also that major grocery stores tend to be on major street corners for easy access. The supply of shopping carts is probably at least a bit attractive too, but I don't have a sense of the scale of that particular problem.
As an American, I learned a few interesting English grammar rules (most memorably, proper use of the subjunctive) from my AP foreign language class because high-school English instruction is almost entirely literature and writing.
This sounds somewhat similar to what you are saying about Irish, with the caveat that English is nigh-inescapable to Americans, even those who speak other languages at home.
Back in the 90s we did some great trials and discovered Direct Instruction was the best way to teach children. But teachers found it boring and revolted against it.
I don't remember my reading curricula in elementary school (partially because I remember reading before kindergarten), but I was briefly attending a "trendy" (public) school that was trying all sorts of newfangled ideas. One year tried mixing K-2 in a single classroom on the notion that peer instruction would improve outcomes (spoiler alert: no, it's harder to match instruction to more varied students and the size difference between kids led to bullying).
I'll lump teaching in with a few other professions that are both difficult and have poorly-measured outcomes. This also includes things like parts of economics, medicine, policing, and social work. I've observed that these fields seem especially prone to groupthink and oscillation between questionable policy choices. We'll focus on a single small and poorly-controlled study showing that different reading curricula improved one classroom once, and use that to justify throwing out years of tradition and experience.
As much as we want a silver bullet to solve our problems, the sad truth is that phonics or direct instruction alone won't solve the problems in these schools, and I'm fairly confident that more total time (inside and outside the classroom) practicing reading is far more important than the marginal gains of the specific curriculum. And even then there are still students who will struggle with reading due to dyslexia and such.
These problems are hard and I think treating them otherwise does us all a disservice in finding actual improvements.
viewing things through a critical lens
I have come to the opinion that critical is a terrible word choice (but possibly deliberately so). The different meanings of "heralded to critical acclaim", "critical decision to save the world", "in critical condition", and "overly critical diatribe" are so disparate that despite years of supposed education, I'm not sure which "critical thinking" refers to.
Naively, we should be teaching students to fairly evaluate ideas, and to make important decisions. But sometimes it seems like people lean into the criticism aspect to justify nihilism and tearing down everything without any thought to improving the human condition.
they say they're talking about suicide rates,
Perhaps a bit uncharitably, I personally am not convinced that suicide rates alone are worth high levels of sympathy. I suppose sometimes, but as you mention that is complicated by social contagions. Should we end euthanasia protocols to improve suicide rates? Personally not convinced. Does the fate of the Jeffrey Epsteins [citation needed] and Adolf Hitlers of this world suggest we should change government policies to make their specific lives better? No. Just no.
In other words if a church says a group is sinful,
I think this is how it's perceived more broadly by non-Christians, but misses the specific point that (most?) Christian denominations believe everyone is sinful. If you described a group of devout Catholics as sinful, I suspect the response would be "yes we are," with some commentary about confession, forgiveness, and repentance.
Executive branch officials seem to have much more ability to craft their own systems, which seem to be less secure.
Not only is the regulation for classified documents defined (almost) exclusively by Executive Order [1], but I suspect high-level executive branch officials are, by nature of their jobs, unable to fully "leave work at the office." Some bedtime background reading on foreign leaders to meet tomorrow or late-night national emergencies could easily see documents outside of normal locations. And that's not even considering the acknowledged epidemic of over-classification: it's possible to have a file marked "secret" that has nothing you couldn't learn from a cursory read of the New York Times -- though there are reasons this can legitimately be the case as well.
This isn't to say that I don't want them to do better, but I can at least see how it'd be difficult for the White House to keep all the files locked up every night.
[1] This is one of the defenses Trump has attempted to raise -- although I'm not completely certain I think it should prevail, it is an interesting argument and complicates the whole matter.
Post SB-8 legislatures
I don't think SB-8 was the first law to try to create civil liability for third parties. The mechanism is also used (and abused) for things like ADA accomodations and IIRC some of California's civil rights laws. While some might be okay with throwing these out concurrently, the scope would need to be much larger than I think you mean to imply.
Although I would in general agree that hanging vague metaphorical swords over otherwise law-abiding citizens is an undesirable state of affairs.
There are clever algorithms using homomorphic encryption which allow votes to be tallied without revealing who voted for whom, and let you verify that your vote was counted without revealing what it was.
As a very simple example of a system I've occasionally pondered -- which I'm not sure I'd describe as "homomorphic encryption" per se, more a zero-knowledge proof of election outcomes. "For each ballot, the voter calls a fair coin toss. If they win, keep the ballot. If they lose, replace it with a randomly selected ballot. Final resulting ballots are public, but the initial coin flip is never recorded." This is overwhelmingly likely to not change the outcome of the election, and any specific ballot can be verified by voters but they will be unable to convince a third party that the recorded vote for Kang was the result of the coin toss and that they intended to vote for Kodos.
convince the voting public that your magic math system cannot be cheated.
Yeah, this is really the hard part. I don't think I'd trust a coin toss even in my presence to decide something so important. I know abstractly that the statistics work out, but it feels viscerally disenfranchising.
One of the tragic parts of the Kursk incident is that Russia declined several Western offers of aid (from the US and parts of Europe) until such time as it's own efforts had completely failed several days later. In particular putting national pride above the lives of it's sailors seems like quite a tragedy for the families of those lost.
But perhaps that also speaks to attitudes toward the current situation that I have trouble understanding from a Western perspective.
I totally buy that people getting less religious
I sometimes wonder if it's really "people think they are becoming less religious, but religion-esque dogma and all its vices are actually a near-inescapable part of the human condition." Not sure myself, but it's a plausible take.

While not completely analogous, there are a few other events that are at least comparable, including several incidents in the Pacific Theater of WWII (most notably Chichijima, nearly involving future president George H. W. Bush). It's not quite as recent, but the story of Johan de Witt is undeniably Western as well.
More options
Context Copy link