@ZeStriderOfDunedain's banner p

ZeStriderOfDunedain

Ze Strider

0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 04:34:38 UTC

No Iranian called me an incel


				

User ID: 812

ZeStriderOfDunedain

Ze Strider

0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 04:34:38 UTC

					

No Iranian called me an incel


					

User ID: 812

They certainly are trying to sell a progressive feminist conception of heterosexual relationships, which is almost always the inverse of what they'd call toxic and patriarchal. Ironically, Rockstar discontinued GTA 4's friendship mechanic cuz players found it too annoying. I suspect they'd be far less receptive to player feedback regarding the relationship mechanic.

Yeah, if this is what 2 billion dollars could fetch us, I think it's fair to assume game development has hit the ceiling. Any marginal improvements are getting more expensive and increasingly irrelevant to the actual experience of playing the game. I genuinely couldn't care less if the vellus hair on a character's face is rendered with anatomical precision if the world around them offers little worth interacting with. Arkham Knight is eleven years old this year. When it released, GTA San Andreas was eleven years old. The difference between those two generations was staggering. And Arkham Knight still looks staggering and distinctive.

CDPR also lifted Witcher 3's open-world design philosophy and transplanted it into Cyberpunk 2077's densely populated futuristic metropolis, apparently without appreciating how fundamentally different the expectations of those settings are. A wilderness punctuated by medieval towns, villages, monsters, and occasional settlements can sustain the illusion of a living world through relatively sparse and reproducible interactions. But an urban environment derives its appeal from density, variety, and the sheer number of things happening within it. Every inaccessible building, decorative storefront, scripted event, and non-interactive pedestrian is a reminder that you're wandering through an extraordinarily elaborate film set. RDR2's life-simulation approach worked for much the same reason. Now I've seen clips of GTA 6 streamers hunting down bigfoot, discovering aliens, helping Red Hulk, fighting a giant crab among other things... obvious fanservice to the easter eggs and urban legends from the series 3D era.

I'd have preferred something far less ambitious geographically and considerably more ambitious mechanically. Take the original Vice City map, expand it by perhaps fifty percent, and build vertically. Make all the interiors enterable. Give buildings actual functions, businesses meaningful systems, and neighbourhoods activities that extend beyond driving between mission markers. I'd happily trade another hundred square kilometres of beautifully rendered asphalt for a single city block in which I could actually do things.

Welp, this thread was inevitable. I was hoping to wait a few weeks until the dust settled but whatevs. Yup, it's precisely what I expected it to be. I suspected this was going to be wifeguy simulator as soon as we saw the leaks in 2022.

But holy shit, the technical continuity with RDR2 is almost comical. The hand-to-hand combat looks practically lifted from it, even the movement, weapon handling, animation priorities, and the obsessive physical realism all belong to the same design philosophy. 13 years and 2 billion dollars to refine a simulation that was already recognisable in 2018. 600,000 animations is certainly an unprecedented technical achievement but the underlying experience still feels so familiar. Like, Cyberpunk 2077 was torn to sheds for that infamous launch, here it feels like a footnote. But who cares, bugs will be fixed, amirite?

Anyway, I don't think GTA can capture the "woah" factor anymore. I remember playing Vice City and San Andreas as a kid, and the sheer range of possibilities genuinely stunned me. You could run, drive cars, ride motorcycles, pilot choppers, commandeer boats, fly aircraft, strap on a jetpack, gamble, buy property, shoot your way through the criminal underworld, and become a kingpin. Every few hours the game revealed another possibility I hadn't considered! It wasn't just a large world, but one that seemed determined to let you do everything. GTA IV compensated the relative lack of freedom with an extraordinary leap in physics, ragdoll animation, environmental interaction, and a genuinely compelling story that unraveled the myth of the American Dream. Gem of the 9/11 era.

Then we had the era of GTA clones, though many of them went on to establish their own identities and still delivered high octane explosive fun, like Saints Row. We had Watch Dogs, a rebel hacker taking the fight against surveillance capitalism. We also got Sleeping Dogs, GTA in Hong Kong, but with parkour and kung fu-style hand-to-hand combat. The novelty of open-world freedom had already worn off.

And by GTA V, the cracks were starting to show. Switching between three protagonists was a fun gimmick, and the spectacle was still entertaining, but the satire had begun to feel strangely exhausted. Urban life in modern America has become too sterile and mediated through apps, surveillance, bureaucratic restrictions, and carefully managed commercial spaces. The GTA spirit is its ability caricature the American malaise of its era, but the real world in 2026 has become so saturated with social media, performative outrage, corporate absurdity, AI slop, and algorithm that real life became the parody. When modern politics already resembles a GTA radio commercial, exaggerating it another fifteen percent doesn't land. This is where realism becomes a liability. It worked in RDR2 because the outlaw frontier was an inherently exciting setting. Riding through the wilderness, tending to your horse, cleaning weapons, hunting, camping, and performing menial chores had novelty precisely because they were so remote from my lived experience in 2026.

Realism is only valuable when it enriches the fantasy, which segues my point to the elephant in the room.

The fantasy presented in GTA 6 is severely unappealing to me. Why the fuck would I play an escapist fantasy about being a good, considerate boyfriend showing one-sided devotion to girlboss #984565 that I have to pretend isn't viscerally unlikeable and undesirable, when I would never do that IRL? I want to drive fast cars, shoot things, visit strip clubs, bang hookers, gamble, own a casino, kill dangerous criminals, rob banks, blow up drug labs, and become a ludicrously wealthy underworld kingpin. I don't care if it doesn't pass the vibe check for an enlightened or emotionally mature (read: feminist) conception of masculinity, this is GTA! Remember when former Rockstar boss bluntly said they were a bunch of guys making games for guys? Why are male spaces constantly expected to accommodate and pander to female sensibilities?

Honestly, the only highlight of the game was Niko Bellic's cameo. They let him retain his aura, with his original VA returning, without getting Johnny Klebitz'd. But even here, you can notice it's the fat white male he's allowed to humiliate to assert his status. I can tell the HR karen writing team had to summon strenght from the marrow of their bones to restrain themselves from letting girlboss #984565 emasculate Niko, he's too fucking sacred to the community. He's a real badass. Girlboss #984565 is not a real badass. We just pretend that she is. We have to clap like trained seals and stroke her ego or risk being labelled misogynist incel™.

But you know what? I'm glad they didn't hold back the wokeness. Games like RDR2 could bury the wokerot inside production values and purportedly anti-woke gamers rationalised it as incidental. It took years until they took off the rose-tinted glasses and a level of woke fatigue became mainstream before we could have an honest conversation about the writing. GTA 6 does not bother. The wokeness is overt and repeatedly in the way. That makes the problem easier to name.

Lastly, I remember joking years ago when AAAs were normalising obscene prices and multiple editions, will these games entertain me more than an escort would for the same price? Well, that's not a joke anymore. 2 billion dollar game won't let me bang hookers? Fine, I'll just do it IRL. Slog 200+ hours to please digital girlboss #984565 in 2 billion dollar game, or a much more memorable 30 minutes with a far hotter lady IRL? That is my benchmark from now.

EDIT: Jesus, that was a rant. Discourse around this game has seriously brainrotted me. At least, we can bury the "we got this before gta 6" meme now.

You're not an incel if you don't care that much about getting a girlfriend, you're just asexual or something like that.

No, just apathetic. Horrible risk-to-reward ratio makes it not worth it. By this yardstick, almost every incel could be "volcel". But I address this upthread:

Why would you rationally put up with women with substance abuse problems, serious emotional baggage, neurotic personalities, destructive ego patterns and extreme disagreeability, when you would promptly cuss out a man should he display even a fraction of those things?

A far safer "alternative" is just accepting you're not good enough, you'll never be good enough, remain lonely and miserable, and write 1000 word essays complaining about the dating market online.

Brilliant sum up. While I definitely think NEET doomers are their own category, and literally all of them are incels, the pool of men who cannot get a girlfriend ("involuntarily celibate" in the technical sense) extends well beyond that demographic. They may not explicitly identify as incels, largely because pop media has tortured the term to imply active sexual resentment towards women, despite its colloquial use always being a straightforward, derogatory description of men who simply cannot get laid. They are aware they cannot openly talk about their dating struggles without sounding like "incels" (pop definition).

Fair, but I'd still argue that's (partly) downstream of factors that didn't exist in 1986. Less digital overload, less loneliness, etc., meaning, obese incels already blackpilled before they became obese and simply don't have the incentive to make themselves presentable anymore. Anecdotally, if you looked at my friends (all mid-20s college educated white males), you can't "tell" that some of them are incels.

I'll rephrase that: "physically" average. Many of those things are downstream of environmental factors, as in, things they cannot control. Put another way, they wouldn't be living with parents and battling serious depression in 1986. I earn more than the NZ median, and still live at home.

While stock photos are usually altered, I have (ahem) sources who can confirm that these are women an average man is unlikely to pull naturally. Although I'd be cautious of mostly-ethnic brothels, you have to be citizen or PR to work legally. But it's not really enforced very well, you don't have to look far to find Chinese escorts who don't speak a word of English providing full service.

Eh, I'm sure such extremes exist, but I suspect the average incel in 2026 would just be an average man in 1986. Usually, people think of this meme, but the profiles are actually closer to college educated men from stable homes with stable incomes. In the real world, your dating pool shouldn't include literally every similar-aged woman within commuting distance. Realistic standards are still standards. Why would you rationally put up with women with substance abuse problems, serious emotional baggage, neurotic personalities, destructive ego patterns and extreme disagreeability, when you would promptly cuss out a man should he display even a fraction of those things?

We're quick to mock a terminally online schizoid who's fully crashed out and conjures neurotic conspiracies about gynocratic world order gatekeeping his dick from pussy. But we're considerably more indulgent toward women whose every interaction with the world is similarly coloured by grievance, and who are only a few inferential steps away from blaming you (YOU, personally) for being an agent of the patriarchy that brought about that resentment. I would never tolerate any of that for some mid pipe. Remaining single and miserable can be preferable to entering a relationship that makes you even more miserable.

Although I do think @PutAHelmetOn 's descriptor "status dysphoria" is apt. Stealing this.

To be fair, I also have friends who've hired escorts for a full GFE despite being perfectly capable of rizzing up women naturally, just cuz they're too lazy to actually pass that speech perk. Also full service escorts in NZ get STI screenings regularly, so you could argue that a brothel (on the pricey high end) is actually safer than a pub! Plus better looking girls, better sex, kink friendly... etc.

Yeah that axiom never made sense to me. I doubt David Beckham crosses anyone's mind when they think of a typical john.

Yes. Look at Australia, New Zealand. Fully legal. We still have incels. They can fuck a 100 prossies (RIP wallet), they'll still remain incels. And they're not even necessarily jobless losers, just no game and a crippling aversion to social risk-taking.

I used to believe this as well, that ladies of the night offered a convenient "dark arts" shortcut to developing the social and sexual confidence necessary for conventional relationships, but that doesn't really bear out in practice. Often times, the johns (the incel kind in the literal sense of the word) end up developing feelings for the girl, only to leave feeling more alienated, and being reminded of the intimacy they cannot experience organically. You can throw on a nice jacket, make conversation, and attempt to charm her. Or not. You're still fucking her for the same price. There is no psychological barrier attached to the social cost of insinuating that you find her goonable and wish to goon inside her.

I'm not going to relitigate myself, we're talking over each other.

I agree with you on YooKay and France, the situation is frankly eye watering. The Islamic extremism, grooming gangs, retrograde parallel societies that liberal and even "right wing" governments have failed to curb (or allowed to fester) have unraveled the social fabric. I don't have a "workable" solution, maybe we keep relentlessly injecting heavy doses of 5th wave feminism into minority communities until their TFR falls well below the native average.

On Singapore, you're missing my point. Your contention is "antiracism is racism" but mind you, I made a straight-forward point about racism against minorities, then you hit me back with whataboutery. Is there any format or a template for a conversation about garden variety racism a la "fuck the darkies" "those smelly browns don't belong" that you would be comfortable allowing? Because frankly, the vibes I'm getting is "well, sure it exists but why are you talking about it!" Singapore's multiracialism and integration aren't mutually exclusive, they explicitly pursue both. More importantly, the Singaporean government is perfectly willing to identify and condemn racism against minorities when they encounter it, without writing a dissertation on anti-majority discrimination. That was my original point, which seems to keep getting lost.

Regarding your final paragraph, saying that governments necessarily restrict rights is a truism, not a defense of any particular restriction. Social Security reform involves difficult fiscal trade-offs, true. But your proposals track compulsory cultural conformity, expanded policing, and potentially extraordinary coercive measures against tens of millions. The relevant questions are proportionality, scale, administrative feasibility, and whether less intrusive alternatives exist. I believe American gun culture is dumb, and that school shootings and gun violence can be ameliorated by taking away the guns! But think about the logistics of pursuing this, and since Americans would sooner claw off their fingers before they surrender their guns, it's a non-starter.

Editing to add, I also think social media has been destructive for mental health and the social fabric. Zoomers are posting nostalgia slop for the pre-internet days... on social media. I strongly believe dismantling the entire social media ecosystem, and reducing it to a purely direct-messaging service will have amazing long term outcomes for mankind. But again, logistics, and severe disruptions in the short-medium term.

We've wandered so far from my original point that the right has a large constituency quite comfortable with open racism that it's becoming difficult to remember what we're even disputing. You grudgingly concede that "fuck the darkies" is contemptible, but apparently I'm not permitted to acknowledge its existence without first performing an elaborate ritual of throat-clearing about how antiracism has also been used to justify discrimination against whites. A point I've conceded repeatedly, by the way. How many more disclaimers am I expected to append before I'm allowed to discuss the actual subject?

I believe I explicitly asked "not just what people tell themselves to feel better about it".

You don't get to dismiss a distinction as merely "what people tell themselves to feel better about it" and pretend you've refuted it. You're trying to settle a descriptive question about what Americans find acceptable by repeatedly announcing what you personally find indefensible.

I mean, it does? I suppose you're trying to rescue it with "anti-minority"

Is there any qualifier for racism against non-whites you'd be willing to acknowledge without immediately pivoting to institutional discrimination against whites? Can we not hold both observations to be true simultaneously, or must every discussion of one be derailed by an obligatory disclaimer about the other?

If it did "liberals" would have the same response to all things that pattern match to opposing principles, but they only have this issue with the right-wing view on identity.

Let me reiterate, yet again, that I'm talking about the credibility of these accusations among normie voters, not their moral consistency. You keep returning to some liberal double standards, when did I deny this? You may be entirely correct about the hypocrisy, but that goes in both directions. If I were a woke activist constantly railing against "MAGA Nazis", would you generously assume I might unironically agree that affirmative action is discrimination against whites and therefore should be unconstitutional? Of course not. The online discourse has gone on for way too long that people can recognise the rhetorical scripts and the ideological commitments they usually signal. Sure, the "noticing" is not infallible, but neither is it arbitrary. It's literally how the woke left squandered so much of their credibility, and I suspect you'd have no difficulty recognising the phenomenon if I were criticising them instead.

Now is perhaps a good time to mention I'm a European living in Europe

See, your nativist argument has a much stronger historical foundation in the European context, where your identities often predate the modern state and are more closely intertwined with ancestry, language, and ethnicity. But America is a rather different proposition.

if someone does airdrop 100K Haitian voodoo priests on your home town, and hands out passports to them, you'll have zero recourse.

If your concern is mass immigration overwhelming a community, we can tighten the rules governing admission. Nothing about legally recognising existing citizens as equally American prevents that. You're inventing a failure of immigration policy and presenting it as an indictment of civic nationality, when the former can be addressed without abandoning the latter.

I'd go with a couple of criteria:

Suppose we actually attempt this. How exactly do you propose administering it? What is The Assimilator supposed to do? I suppose you can make everyone undergo periodic CRT-style racial attitude tests. And if we're applying this consistently, does a naturalised Polish American expressing hostility toward blacks also fail your ingroup identification test and become eligible for deportation? Meanwhile, a black American with sufficient lineage can presumably express contempt for every other group with impunity. Even the author of your linked study cautions against drawing sweeping conclusions from these responses. We can just lie on surveys, though I suppose that's good enough.

You also invoke Singapore, but Lee Kuan Yew's government pursued an explicitly multiracial national identity, with policies designed to integrate different ethnic communities rather than establish hereditary grades of citizenship. You seem to want Singaporean social discipline combined with an ethnonational conception of belonging that Singapore's official ideology explicitly rejected. Just two months ago, a Singaporean minister condemned racist comments against Indians and called for solidarity. Which brings me back to my original point: can you acknowledge and condemn racism of this sort unequivocally, when it comes from the contemporary right, without first performing a dozen obligatory rituals to denounce liberal double standards?

By the way, why are you asking so many questions and providing precisely zero of your own?

I believe restrictive immigration policies, demanding naturalisation requirements, and integration through common civic institutions are adequate. We can demand for more rigorous enforcement. I'm asking questions because your proposals entail an extraordinarily expensive and intrusive administrative apparatus that will have a strong impact on ordinary people's livelihoods. There is a hard limit to what can be achieved through democratic politics, especially with modern day population counts.

First of all civil rights are a lie, they can be and have been, freely suspended to push throughva social agenda, as long as it's one liberals desire.

Once again, can we please dispense with the "but Suzy did it, so why shouldn't I?" Whatever the liberals did, what you're proposing is something considerably more sweeping and intrusive, and not practicable at all. Let alone marketable to the general electorate.

There's also the even more minor problem that if you do nothing your country is over.

Anything that involves impeding on the rights and livelihoods of 150 million people is a non-starter. So I'd think of better solutions if you don't want a repeat of the midterms.

That those deep state connections and not much else are driving the foreign policy wrt Israel, is my point. Remember Genocide Joe?

Is there? Than explain to me what difference there is.

The difference is between the justification of a policy and the principle it purports to establish. Affirmative action is defended as a corrective to slavery and Jim Crow, not as an affirmation of permanent racial hierarchy. You can reject that justification as incoherent or discriminatory, but it doesn't follow that the public perceives the two propositions as morally equivalent. That distinction matters because my argument concerns cultural legitimacy, not whether progressive racial politics can survive a philosophical consistency test.

How is that different from "no, you don't understand, making the darkies pick our cotton is our way of life!"?

It is not, and I already addressed this:

Now you can argue that anti-white racism should be included in that vocabulary, and I bet many people will agree, that doesn't mean the underlying taboo against anti-minority racism has evaporated.

Yes. The point of the question is to establish which one of these makes you an American.

Okay, so what should the criteria be, in your opinion? A civic idea of nationality, a cultural idea, and an explicitly racial one entail very different political arrangements. Americans can disagree about the first two, and they will overwhelmingly reject the latter, so if that's what you're going for, you'll have to readjust your expectations.

From there it can at least be used to put forward the question if being born on a plot of land is enough to determine nationality.

If objectionable behaviour is enough to question someone's belonging, why shouldn't we subject Donald Trump to the same scrutiny? Americans gave him a historic victory, despite relentless attacks on his character and legitimacy from the left, and how did he repay them? An economy in tatters and a war that nobody wanted. We can apply your principle, but it will engulf a lot of people in your putative ingroup as well.

I doubt it. SocJus ideas are quickly pattern matched to all sorts of unpalatable ideas

Well duh. That doesn't answer whether the association is warranted in particular cases. Sometimes the accusation is lazy pattern matching, other times the speaker really does believe that ancestry should determine membership in the country. When was the last time you raised these concerns with someone who is 100% European and whether they should belong? You're not the only one doing the "noticing".

Citizenship? Open the borders

Closing the borders, and treating your citizens equally independent of their heritage are not mutually exclusive positions.

Cultural assimilation? Which culture do they have to assimilate to? What happens if they don't? What happens to all the people who have the passport, were born in the country, but have not fully absorbed the culture or are actively opposed to it? Can they be deported or denaturalized?

What do you want, exactly? What rituals should they participate in to prove their belonging? What are the practical policies that will ensure that 350 million people are conforming to the culture, without severely (understatement) impeding on civil liberties? Does this apply to everyone or just non-white people?

Shared historical identity, ancestry, or racial membership? Congratulations, you're a Nazi now.

There is that minor problem of ~150 million non-white Americans who are not going anywhere.

I still don't believe it. There are things that a hostile public opinion cannot move. We're talking eight decades of military cooperation, intelligence integration, co-developed defense systems, congressional commitments, and bureaucratic planning that have created substantial institutional inertia. A Democratic administration could restrict arms transfers or adopt a more confrontational diplomatic posture without dismantling that architecture, but we've seen glimpses of this before even under Republican administrations (Reagan and Bush Sr). Israel simply isn't a client state waiting for Washington to withdraw its blessing.

I'll push back on number 3. America's bonhomie with Israel goes beyond a handful of politicians, too many locked-in commitments to reverse in one election. Maybe they will slow-walk some munitions, but nothing else changes.

On number 4, we shall see. Democrats will certainly try to appear pro-immigration to counter the GOP's perceived bigotry, but I don't expect to see more H1Bs anytime soon.

We can only hope the GOP takes the midterms as a census on the economy and foreign policy, learn the right lessons. They will probably lose 2028 though.

There is a difference between Americans tolerating racial preferences dressed up in the language of remedying historical discrimination and Americans embracing racial hierarchy as a positive political principle. The white racist has occupied the role of a stock cultural villain in American public consciousness for several generations now. From the civil rights movement onward, opposition to racial discrimination and fascism have become deeply embedded in the country's civic mythology, educational institutions, popular entertainment, and understanding of its own moral progress.

Whatever the inconsistencies of its application, antiracism is not some recent progressive affectation that can simply be discarded once people grow tired of DEI seminars. It is part of the moral grammar that mainstream America uses to understand its national identity. Now you can argue that anti-white racism should be included in that vocabulary, and I bet many people will agree, that doesn't mean the underlying taboo against anti-minority racism has evaporated. The initial rhetoric made sense, constantly injecting grievance literature will never allow black Americans to move on from racial consciousness and even unravel the social fabric. This is not what Bo French and the groyper right believe though.

but questions like "what is an American" are 100% valid in my opinion

Are we discussing citizenship, cultural assimilation, shared historical identity, ancestry, or racial membership? These are different propositions with different implications. Simply insisting that the question is legitimate doesn't establish that every proposed answer will be equally acceptable to the public. Vivek's conduct can be criticised without establishing anything about whether Indian-Americans (those born and raised in America, not H1Bs) can be legitimate members of the national community. That question draws so much ire because it is quickly pattern matched to white nationalists who are too shy to admit they believe in racial membership, and they're not at all a minority of right wingers.

I mean, everyone thinks a pendulum swing to "their" side is the new consensus that will break the cycle. The cultural trajectory towards wokeness has invited some mainstream scrutiny over the years, but it's been largely undisturbed. White men "won" 2024, in a symbolic way, but still didn't deliver much of what was promised in defiance of the culture, and thunderously delivered a war that nobody wanted. Party of the white men failed, that's the price you pay for rejecting the black woman President!

There is "racist", then there is racist. The difference lies in whether normie voters find those accusations credible.

The GOP convincingly argued that woke activists had rendered the word practically meaningless. When everything from immigration restrictions to perfectly innocuous statements about affirmative action could attract the accusation, it became relatively easy to dismiss the charge as ideological overreach. You bring up perfectly fair criticisms of that rhetoric. My point is not that Democrats have been saying the same things for ten years. It's whether the conduct being criticised, and the public's willingness to believe the criticism, have changed. "Racism is based" is simply not a winnable position in a culture that prides itself for its multi-racial heritage. You could get away with it if you delivered on the economy though. Now it's a double whammy.

Jon Rosenthal leads the race for Texas Railroads Commissioner

I'll drink one to Bo French's hail mary racism.

It was right wingers themselves that were beating the drums about a "client's list" for years, and fanning blatant falsehoods. So chalk that up as another self-own.

The Israel fetish is built into the system, it sucks for Americans but gotta get used to it!