aqouta
Friends:
User ID: 75
As long as the models continue to be in some sense "gullible" (for instance, taking you at your word when you say you are President Trump and planning an invasion of Canada, or that you have eaten 400 pounds of salt, or that the racist image you asked for is part of your classroom curriculum) people will still feel psychologically superior to the models, on the theory that they basically couldn't survive in "the real world" (which is probably true, I suspect deploying one of the unmodified frontier models to run a business would result in it getting scammed remarkably quickly.)
This is an artifact of their deployment as friendly chat bots, not a fact of the universe. They can be made skeptical.
Phase 1: increased ossification and feminization. This will occur because the (mostly male) "doers" on which the company relies are likely the first to be automated. There may still need to be a handful of rockstar performers, but the age of AI will, at least initially, make all intellectual endeavors a winner-takes-all market. With the actual work mostly automated, the remaining management is free to spend even more time doing longhouse things.
This doesn't really make sense to me. Most of the long house stuff comes up because of nebulous management layers that have to exist to manage a broad workforce, automation shrinks the workforce and moves the doing up the management chain. So where you used to have managers with a dozen workers under them which needed direction and HR staff to handle turn over and training now the manager will directly manage a number of agents who don't need HR overhead. This brings the whole management chain closer to the metal and removes a lot of the need for the longhouse roles.
When you're able to merge front line worker, manager and HR all the HR stuff boils off and you end up with a higher density of people being paid to do things.
It was a very broad definition for sure, you could whittle it down a bit, perhaps they also need an agreed upon shared political project. I do believe nations are distinct from simply people in a state or ethnic descendants and most sophisticated definitions of nation I've seen have acknowledged this. There is a kind of nation of christ and nation of islam as well.
I think my definition fits all of those? It's like the "legitimate" business of a shady scrap salesman who does everything by the books but doesn't ask any more questions than required about where the copper wire the crack head brought him was sourced from. It's only really tricky because there are not widely agreed upon international "rules". So we're left with conventions, comparisons and recognition. It's hard to find some criteria in which Israel is not legitimate without knocking some other widely agreed to be legitimate state out of the category. It's recognize by other states, even ones that condemn it. It polices it's borders. It maintains rule of law and administers basic services to its constituents. The largest thing it's missing is defined borders because it got into the state it is now after a series of wars where it established control of areas of at the time attacking Egypt and Jordan but didn't annex those territories. These are just observations, and if I were to draw a line around the "legitimate states" I would find it difficult to justify a line that doesn't include Israel.
Whether a state is legitimate or not says to me something about its relationship to other states and the expectation of its citizens. Whether what a state does it moral seems to be the thing you're actually interrogating and it's getting hung up on this diction.
Yeah, I read your post and answered the narrow question of legitimacy. I think this would all be much clearer and maybe lead to better discussion if you didn't pose legitimacy as the question you are asking. People are consistently telling you that legitimacy and morality are separate questions and you keep scolding them for not answering the question of morality. As if legitimate but bad weren't a valid combination of descriptors. If you were asking "is Israel an immoral state" then there's some meat there. I'd argue that it's immoral by western standards but above par by mid east standards. Can you explain why you're insisting on the word legitimate?
I mean your OP turned almost entirely on the definition of "legitimate" so yeah, people are going to argue the semantics of it. You seem to want to essentially merge legitimate with good in order to justify denying the legitimacy of states you don't like or all states for that matter. I, and many, find that to be kind of a silly word game. You can say Israel delenda est if you want. That's fine, a totally legitimate thing to believe. But playing some word game about what it really means to be legitimate is unimpressive. Legitimate usually refers to whether something is authentic and Israel seems pretty authentic from most lenses, at least as authenticate as almost any other state. Its origin and composition is relatively normal as far as states go. I don't see any reason to overload the concept of legitimacy with all this other baggage when you could just use another term, like is Israel a moral state? And cut out all the confusion. If you're just an anarchist and don't believe that any states are legitimate then we needn't confuse things by focusing on israel.
I think it was an evil action taken by a legitimate nation(or at least whether nazi Germany was a legitimate state turns on questions other than just the holocaust). I think the question of whether a state is legitimate is different to whether a state is good which is in turn different to whether the actions taken by a state are good, although these different questions interact. Might may not make right but it does often make states, I would actually add that there be some kind of internal coherency that is required. In a game of chess on turn one:
- moving my rook immediately over both my own pawn and my opponents pawn to take his rook is an illegitimate yet good move.
- moving my rook over my own pawn and placing it in front of my opponents pawn line would be an illegitimate bad move.
- if somehow both our pawns were already taken taking his rook with mine would be a legitimate good move.
- if somehow both our pawns were already taken moving my rook right in front of his to be taken for no material gain would be a legitimate bad move
And all of this would then interact with the question of whether I had gambled $1 vs the orphan's life I Was playing the game of chess against, in which case it would be evil for me to make good moves.
A state is what happens when a nation holds and administers sovereign land. A nation is a group of people who feel themselves bound by kinship. The nation of Judaism has long existed without a state and then founded one in Israel. It's not really much more complicated than that.
Media is more decentralized than it ever has been in history and is getting more decentralized. This whole line of reasoning just seems like persecution porn. We have a literal civil war in our history and plenty of times where a dominant group absolutely despised minority groups and we have not collapsed into a one party state. I don't think you appreciate how internally fractured the democratic party is, the DSA types and the Moderate types just barely stand each other enough to fight the republicans. If you straight up disenfranchised all republicans today then by tomorrow you'd have the democratic party split in two. Let alone if the Republican party just collapses and the moderate wing can scoop up those tasty tasty post republicans votes so they don't have to listen to Hasan Pikers of the world.
You're begging the question. Yes, if any party is able to and does literally persecutes other parties and prevents them from being formed then you could create a one party state, that's practically the definition of a one party state. But all these other things you're citing are irrelevant and not evidence of an intention or ability to literally prevent the formation of another party. There have been huge blowouts and trifecta governments in our history, parties have been born and died, and we did not collapse into a one party state. The equilibrium our institutions naturally fall into, mostly downstream of the first past the post elections, is to have two national parties and you have to introduce this element of coercion that is not present to change that.
This is actually not the case. I still think his answer is wrong and would prefer he loses by his associations alone. But you're referring to a deceptively edited clip put out by the Roger's campaign you can find the moment in the full video at this time stamp The question was about parent's control over their children's education, not trans in women's locker rooms.
You only need to reach the tipping point that people feel they have more influence by voting in the primary than in the general for it to come to pass.
When this happens the obvious next step is that the party splits, the more conservative half leaves and forms a "moderate" party and gobbles up the majority of the previous party. It's happened before. The reason this hasn't happened in places like Chicago or California is that they're anchored to the national race.
The thing is that the ambiguity is definitely on purpose, it's how he's responded to basically all of the calls to condemn anything. It's the exact same response he had to Hasan Piker. Anyone following along can tell that he is strategically trying to get people off his back without actually condemning the thing he's being asked to condemn.
As an update on this story. Stevens, AES's primary opponent, demanded AES condemn the ad, he refused and snubbed her at some event and now days before the election Stevens has endorsed his opponent Mike Rogers. There's much condemnation from all the obvious dem boosters on the move and the left is already calling it a ratfucking, I suspect secretly happy to have a clear excuse for why he's going to massively underperform the generic ballot. And certainly it's one of many both ways betrayals of the "vote blue no matter who" coalition. But it also speaks to what appears to be total coalitional management incompetence for the AES team. Stevens wasn't asking for that much in a condemnation of the ad and AES chose to basically condemn her instead. How can anyone expect this guy to get anything done if he can't work with anyone?
- Prev
- Next

It does this even when your harness includes a line about avoiding this problem?
More options
Context Copy link