@georgioz's banner p

georgioz


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 07:15:35 UTC

				

User ID: 493

georgioz


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 07:15:35 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 493

Okay. But he was married since 1980 till now. What other proof did we have that he is a serial womanizer? In fact around 90% of S&P 100 between 2011-2019 CEOs are married with around 10% ever being divorced. There are high profile scandals like with Musk or Bezos or now with Jensen Huang, but it is not normative for high-powered CEOs.

You keep using the word "presupposition", which seems to elide the difference between two different acts:

Asserting that X is true; Assuming that X is true.

Yes, all presuppositions are circular and assertive and BTW I can say that universal claim under my worldview. However worldviews and paradigms are not made equal. For instance if you assume secular materialist world where you assert that "all that exists is only matter and energy", and "I am just bunch of atoms doing stuff" then you strip this universe from telos. Even setting aside the problem of how 1kg of brain matter on Earth can make universal statements about all cosmos.

To claim that and then say "and that is why it is bad for people to steal" is no sequitur. You did not ground good or bad inside this cosmology. It is invalid move, you borrow from other traditions to make moral statements. Inside this monistic materialist paradigm a billion kilograms of children falling into black hole is just bunch of atoms doing stuff - in fact it is what happens to everybody, we all end up as particles in heat death of uniform and everything smooths out to some cold cosmic structure. In that state nothing has any meaning, suffering, bliss or anything else is meaningless. Without objective yardstick in God, these experiences are subjective and they can be good, bad or neutral even from the standpoint of the same person depending of how she feels when she wakes up.

...would suffice for you to immediately regenerate that proof in your head, and as such didn't spell it out (because spelling things out unnecessarily can be interpreted as condescension). Apparently, it was not obvious to you, so I did spell it out. At no point did I make a claim that obvious things are true; I merely used (apparent) obviousness as a criterion for elision, as a matter of debate etiquette.

The problem is not that it was "not obvious to me". It is that you do not have a coherent representation of what "obvious" is. Something can be obvious to 99.999% of people and it can be wrong. Or do you have some belief that as long as something is obvious to 50%+ of people than it makes it true or something? OR maybe you have some additional criteria: it counts as "obvious" for everybody who acknowledges some presupposition (e.g. secular humanism) or who has IQ greater than 120 or something? If yes, why did you invent this additional criteria for obviousness?

Also I would like to discuss a little bit more about Morton's fork specifically to bypass Cartheisan Daemon runs into Quines Undetermination of Scientific Theory. It is a critique of empiricism exactly in line with what I was saying - there is infinite compatible number of theories for any given amount of scientific evidence. If you privilege one theory over other, you have to go OUTSIDE of empiricism toward presuppositionalism. So we now have to have a discussion about which presupposition is more explanatory.

You are skipping the point of the whole tradition of empirical skepticism like Hume and Descartes. They tried hard to define "obvious" and failed. Quine explained why they failed and why it is bankrupt philosophical endeavor.

No, premise 2 is false. Arianism (i.e. Christianity minus the "1 = 3, it's a divine mystery" bit) can account for all those things. Islam can account for all those things. Zoroastrianism (which is at least sort of polytheistic) can account for all those things. Deism can account for all those things. Materialism can account for all of them except objective morality (which may not exist, and does not seem necessary for debate since a shared subjective morality can lead to shared conclusions).

Sure, I can go to apologetics and why Zoroastrianism, Ariansim, Islam or Buddhism and Hinduism are all incorrect - as long as we understand the premise that we have. We can fork this discussion if you wish. Again, I am absolutely opposed to classical deism or any notion of some pagan higher being as in Thomistic definition. Triune Christian God is completely different from Muslim Allah or Zoroastrian dualistic entity or Gnostic demiurge or some platonic The One. They are mutually incompatible paradigms.

The conclusion that the Christian God exists might be right or wrong, but premise 2 is clearly false

Just because my premise is more developed to your intuition does not mean it is "false". Relativity is less obvious than Newtonian mechanics - which is my analogy of Christianity vs all these other religions including secular religions worshiping material monads or some platonic structures or some dualism of substrate/software like Joscha Bah. Again, I am happy to engage in this discussion in the framework of presupposition.

Jacques Hébert was not guillotined for being a public intellectual lmao, he was a political heavyweight who literally openly called for violent insurrection and paid the price.

So what? If you call for violence then you are not an intellectual? Can we now publicly execute everybody who cheered assassination of Charlie Kirk or who endorse hanging of Nicolae Ceaușescu?

Marat was assassinated by a vengeful aristocrat acting on private terms

Marat was assassinated for his rabid revolutionary pamphlets. He was not assassinated for being the executioner, he was assassinated for his revolutionary fervor and his political opinions. After Thermidorian Reaction he was removed from republican Panthéon, cities named after him such as Havre-Marat were renamed back and so forth. So let's not pretend that it was a private act of violence.

As for the rest of the intellectuals the same is true. Also let's look at what is right now happening to Michel Houellebecq. In grand scheme of things him facing some hate-speech libel is the softest way of how French intellectuals were treated in the past. So give me a break.

I assumed (apparently falsely) that this proof was sufficiently "obvious" that you would immediately grasp it and thus I didn't need to belabour the point by stating it.

It is obvious only if you have a presupposition that debate has any meaning. Carthesian Demon is just an educational example of age-old skeptic tradition. The point was to demonstrate how one can build presuppositions from ground up, from Descarte's cogito ergo sum toward other concepts within a full fledged metaphysics. The point is that I do not grant anything as obvious on first level. What does it even mean "obvious". Obvious to you? Obvious to 1% or 10% of people? Is this some epistomological anchor, maybe some tweaked version of argumentum ad populum? I can also say that over 60% people on Earth believe in God and it is "obvious" to them: is this sufficient for you, or do you require some additional arguments and justifications?

Your interlocutor says X.

You respond to your interlocutor as though he's saying Y, presumably because English isn't your first language and you honestly misinterpreted him.

Your interlocutor responds that he's not saying Y, and is in fact saying X.

You insist that your interlocutor is saying Y, and sometimes insult him (as I just quoted).

What is this weird shit with me being East European and having trouble with articles and commas. But I can cut the crap, what does it mean "obvious" to you? One just cannot say that "X is obvious" and automatically win a debate. Because if we make this as a meta-level rule "anything anybody claims as obvious makes him win a debate" is not consistent. Did you get the meaning of what I say despite lack of articles and commas?

Do you believe these premises?

Yes, I do.

Premise 2 appears very obviously to be an error by Kant, due partially to his life being before the theory of natural selection was created by Wallace and Darwin and thus a materialistic explanation of 3/4 of those was devised, and partially due to privileging the Christian hypothesis over e.g. deism simply because there are more Christians than deists.

Who cares about psychologizing, if - in your mind somebody believes something because of psychology. It is just pure ad hominem. I can invent any psychological story of how somebody believes something because of their mother and father and trauma or whatnot. But is it True?

For instance as an example, I believe in personal God because it has explanatory power over telos of the universe. God being a person means that the universe has purpose. A personal God is somebody who can produce divine revelation of his creation. There are many other features of personal God that are above and beyond of something like declaring that "Schrodinger equation living inside Hilbert space is a god". It is a paradigmatical level argument, a meta-level argument for web of believes.

However, what I suspect laws like this to be in practice is to function as a carve out for a censorious state with neurotic apparatchiks to punch up criminal charges whenever they feel like.

Exactly. One can reasonably argue about merits or demerits of these laws in a vacuum. However in practice the UK is already anarchotyranical banana republic government, where the law is applied selectively based on tribal, ideological or personal beliefs and connections. Just conisder refusal to prosecute already exiting laws during massive physical and provable mass rape scandals such as those in Rotherham. If police does not have capacity to prosecute thes things, why on earth do they have a need to expand areas of ineffectiveness over to prosecution of virtual crimes?

But this is not coming out of the blue. There are law abiding citizens with scewdriver arrested in Hull under draconian knife laws, while of course there are marauding gangs hacking each other with machetes openly on the street during daylight in Southend-on-Sea.

Returning to Houellebecq, it is fascinating to see the decline of one of France's greatest traditions - a shared respect and deference across the political spectrum for public intellectuals and figures of artistic merit

One can say that this is in fact RETVRN to the age old first republic tradition of silencing and executing journalists: either by censorship, guillotine or assassination with famous examples like Jacques Hébert, Camille Desmoulins or even Jean-Paul Marat. And it was not only First Republic, there was prosecution later be it in form of Bonapartists persecuted during white terror after Napoleonic wars, or "radicals" going against morals of Second Empire like Baudelaire or Flaubert and many, many others since the First Republic. In fact if you name anybody of import in French literature he was prosecuted, exiled or threatened: be it leftists like Victor Hugo, Émile Zola or rightists like Charles Maurras or fascist Robert Brasillach or even people opposing Algerian War during fourth republic - imprisoned and tortured like Henri Alleg.

There was never any deference and respect to anything opposing the French state, at best it was fear and need for control - which includes manipulation of history to create national heroes and villains during ideological shifts. France rabidly promoted their secular state religion with bloody power struggle over the narrative of what this religion should entail. Any idea of how it was some supposed softspoken liberal paradise, where everybody sang kumbaya, and where intellectuals were free to post their little pamphlets that were conveniently in line with secular republican state myth is absolute fantasy and propaganda of the very same state and ideology. Just during a few years of first republic under reign of terror there were more people executed than over 5 centuries of witch trials, Inquisition and heresy trials. And we are not even counting massacres such as infernal columns punishing Vendée uprising.

I am really baffled by this response. Why on earth would anybody think that modern France at least since 1794 is some cradle of "live and let live" hippie utopia? There are atrocities, political executions, assassinations and mass injustice every other decade for last 250 years. And it is a feature and not a bug of this strict secular state religion "republican" theocracy. It really is baffling to me.

The second affair doesn't add any new information. We already knew (from the first affair) what kind of person he is

No we did not. They knew each other since early 1980s, his wife was an engineer sticking with him throughout majority of his life. And also this is how she looks like now, age 65. It was plausible that he just has some marital problem and seeks a new relationship, being serial womanizer was possible but not certain.

Well, fuck, I guess philosophy is pointless if we can't possibly make any statements about reality because we can't prove we're not living in a simulation.

I find this hilarious as this is exactly point of my debate - you can't possibly make any statements about reality without solid grounds, for me existence of God. But that is neither here nor there. For me it is interesting that you at the same time disparage philosophy but also talk about "reality". Nature of reality is the subject of examination of ontology. What is reality, what is existence, how and why do things exist "in reality"?

What do you mean by reality: are those things that you experience? Is there some gradation: e.g. if you experience abstract concepts such as numbers - are they existing in the same way as trees? If not, what is the difference? Is reality only things that you yourself experience, or are other things also real - like one of many worlds that some physicist claim that they exist?

That is what I criticize. People constantly make assertions such as "numbers do not exist in reality", or that "all that exists is some universal wavefunction in Hilbert space". These are some quite outrageous claims about existence itself, don't you think?

No, that's not what I'm saying. There is some probability that Cartesian-Daemon shenanigans are occurring. There's just obviously no point in discussing that scenario or even contemplating it, so we might as well act as if they're not.

What does it mean obviously and no point? You are smuggling some new concepts, are we supposed to decide what is true and worthy to pursue by obviousness and having point? Whatever it is, it is your presupposition even in this naive and unexamined form. Can I say that Cartersia Demon obviously exists and thus there is no point having discussion, ending in some post-modern nihilism? If not why - from inside of your paradigm. How do you account for obviousness and meaning of "there being a point"?

Do you assume that everything is obvious to everybody and that the universe has a point and meaning and telos? Why? My paradigm of God accounts for such a thing: God is a person, he created the universe with a divine purpose. Humans were created in an image of God, they possess rational capacity to understand Gods plan and thus discussion is fruitful as it can arrive at this meaning, it is having a point. I am waiting for your paradigm to prove the same.

I have not found you explaining what this is.

Sure, I can present it here in this context as there are more transcendental arguments for God, including Kantian one. I mean it in this sense.

Premise 1 (Transcendental Precondition): Human experience, rational thought, logic, and objective morality are only intelligible if certain universal, unchanging, and immaterial truths exist.

Premise 2 (Worldview Comparison): Non-Christian worldviews (such as materialism, atheism, or polytheism) cannot account for these universal truths without borrowing from a Christian framework or falling into self-contradiction.

Premise 3 (The Christian Foundation): The Christian worldview—specifically the Triune God who is unchanging, immaterial, and the creator of an orderly universe—provides the necessary foundation for logic, science, and ethics.

Conclusion: Therefore, the Christian God must exist because without Him, you could not prove, know, or argue anything at all.

German wikipedia says this is a trivial modus tollens argument

Modus toles is a valid form of argument used all the time, what do you mean. Also it is far from trivial, Quines paper two dogmas of Empiricism is highly respected as correct, in fact it is why naive empiricism and other secular humanists completely gave up any notion of metaphysics and to large extend epistemology and ethics and why they are obsessed with ersatz topics such as phenomenology.

I just don't see 100% as a right, whereas it seems you do. So it's not concerning to me if I am only 99% sure about any belief that I have. I can operate on 99%s, and I don't find that invalid.

Yeah, it is just arbitrary assertion. I can declare that I have 1/(1-Googol) probability that my assertion of any claim is correct and just claim it as practically THE TRUTH. No amount of Bayesian updates I can reasonably make during my lifetime will move the needle. But technically I am still rationalist or whatever. It is just smokescreen for assertion, just with extra bells and whistles.

"German wikipedia says this is a trivial modus tollens argument. In real life we use Baye's and not modus tollens; a negative result will update the probability of each event in the chain to be lower. It will also let you rule out the entire chain. Generally experiments try to isolate variables; that means the chain is small or singular, so his argument furthermore does not apply."

No Bayesian update can let you rule out entire chain. There may be invalid moves where some probability assertion will clash with some downstream probability. E.g. you can say that you are 99% sure that you have fake coin with two heads, which would make assertion of flipping tails as 50% invalid. These inconsistencies only increase in complexity which makes these whole rationalist project very dubious, but also extraordinarily fragile to actual internal critique when examining these presuppositions.

Is your point that, if you assume you have the right to certainty, then you can deduce this

No, it is the other way around. Any certainty - even 99.9% - requires belief in presuppositions. How did you arrive to this number, why do you think it is sound? This is meta-level discussion about soundness of presuppositions, their consistency and explanatory power. Also the claim is that EVERYBODY assumes right to certainity, even you with your assertions of 99%. Are you certain it is 99% and not 0.1%? What gave you a right to do it?

The humanist project starts with fallible, limited, bounded human and it pretends access to these universal claims such as "I have 99% certainty to X". It is contradictory within itself as presuppositional paradigm. How can you claim that? Can anybody assert anything? Can I say I am 99.99% certain that God exists? If not, why?

"How does your framework deal with this? It seems like it demands a verbal justification and rejects other justifications."

Exactly. My frameowrk is that I accept that all metaphysics is circular and has to be self-referential. As you described above, you just ground your metaphysics on concept like "intuition" or "observational evidence". The problem is paradigmatical.

In your metaphysics, I guess you probably believe that you are fallible. So your paradigm is built on shaky and faulty grounds - it is inside your paradigm that you can be incorrect. I have a paradigm where the truth is grounded outside of myself, in personal, omniscient, benevolent and omnipotent and omnipresent God. You can object that it is also just my assertion and presupposition. However they are not equal as my paradigm has grounding that is very firm by that very entity. All logic and math are abstract concept that exist in Divine mind. The God has personal relationship and plan for creation, therefore universe has purpose, telos and meaning. God is omniscient and he lets us to know him through Divine Revelation and by using of our created natural faculties because he created the world as knowable by our rational thinking. He also gave us laws and he is the ultimate yardstick when it comes to what is bad and what is good, thus grounding ethics.

I have my asserted presupposition, and God paradigm. However that one is very powerful as it creates firm grounding that is outside of my own mind in this God entity. I can say things such as "this is good" without relying on my intuition. In fact I can judge my own intuition according to such a yardstick, thus having the ability to prove me wrong.

"1 - .99999999.... does not bother me. I also belief, justifiably, we can't do better for empirical beliefs. "

That is huge misconception. You have some idea of "cosmic truth" that Bayesian reasoning converges into. However as Quine shown in his Duhem-Quine thesis, empirical evidence is in line with infinite number of explanations and theories, where infinite numbers of them are mutually exclusive. You just use your fallible "intuition" to select a theory and then overfit data to confirm it. And then declare that you are "99% sure". It is absolutely invalid move, you do not have any access to underlying reality driving your sensory experience and you cannot say if you are 99% close to THE TRUTH or if you are converging to THE FALSE.

"You need assumption #1 because if there is such fuckery, then it fatally undermines any attempt to search for philosophical truths, so what's the point?"

Exactly. Now you embraced the basic presuppositional argument. X is necessary for Y. I assert Y. Therefore X exists. In this argument you posit that debate is meaningless if stable reality does not exist and if it is fucked up by Carthesian demons and similar stuff. I assert that meaningful debate exists. Therefore meaningful and stable reality exists, and no Carthesian demon shenanigans are real.

But observe yourself. This is pure presuppositional argument outside of any empirical or scientifical evidence as Carthesian Demon is equally consistent with empirical and scientific evidence. It is all the matter of your presupposition as Carthesian demon cannot be disproved by any number of evidence and empirical experience. You just have to accept it on blind faith.

Now we can enter into a meta-level discussion that I wanted to have with @stoatherd. The meta level discussion is as follows:

  • We all have metaphysical and epistemological presuppositions
  • However not all presuppositions are created equal. Some have explanatory power over epistemology and metaphysics that can give better account. They can provide grounding and justification for empirical observations.

I'd argue that Transcendental Argument for God is a very strong presuppositional position, that enables me to have access to stable reality and metaphysics, coherent ethics, grounded epistemology and possibility of math, logic and everything else. Personal God also grounds teleology and purpose and meaning of not only debate but the whole universe.

That is all.