@georgioz's banner p

georgioz


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 07:15:35 UTC

				

User ID: 493

georgioz


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 07:15:35 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 493

"Morton's Fork: both Case 1 and Case 2 imply that discussing Cartesian-Daemon scenarios is pointless, so since one of them's true this is true unconditionally."

So you declare Cartesian Demon as pointless due to Morten's fork. Again, these are strong presuppositions. Please allow me to play internal critique and put some words in your mouth. An example:

  • "Not being pointless" is disqualifier
  • Morten's fork is valid way to accept or exclude stuff.

That is the modus ponens type of argument.

  • Being able make points is necessary precondition for "discussion intended to achieve truths".
  • Cartesian demon negates possibility of meaningful "discussion intended to achieve truths".
  • I assert that possibility of "discussion achieving truth" is fruitful/possible/valuable/obvious.
  • Therefore Cartesian demon does not exist at least in the form that ever explains anything and I am safe to discard it.

Just to note, this is in no way obvious conclusion. There are nihilists and post-modernists who own this and who say that yes, discussions have no meaning. That there is no non-arbitrary justification to exclude these conclusions and they mock the idea of meaningful truth. Maybe they believe in existence of Cartesian Demon under their own paradigm.

Now maybe you disagree with specific wording, where I assigned to you a presupposition

"I will only entertain paradigms/worldviews/webs-of-belief where meaningful discussion is possible. Cartesian Demon negates this condition therefore I will discard any worldview that entails existence of such an entity"

That is what I guess is your presupposition. But maybe I am wrong and you will chastise me again that I put words in your mouth. So what I am asking for you is to formulate and argument that enabled you to discard Cartesian Demon. And then see it for what it is, so we can dive deeper into the assumptions.

There are zero propositions that I have asked you to accept on the basis of obviousness.

You said this:

No, that's not what I'm saying. There is some probability that Cartesian-Daemon shenanigans are occurring. There's just obviously no point in discussing that scenario or even contemplating it, so we might as well act as if they're not.

Okay, so let's stop this goose chase. You wanted to stop contemplating existence of Carthesian-Daemon because it "there obviously is no point discussing it.". That is quite a strong statement, maybe one of your presuppositions? That is why I hammer it. Why is it obviously nonsensical? You can just say that you wanted to say something else.

I still am not sure I understand what you mean by this word. Could you explain it?

It is the foundation of your web of beliefs, here related to ontology, epistemology. You for instance said that "discussing Cartesian-Daemon scenarios is pointless". Why? What is the justified reason why discussing Cartesian Daemon is pointless. And here the "why" or "reason" ties to this very same same foundation. Saying that it is "obvious" or that "because it is not fruitful" etc. only moves the goalpost.

You can have a useful moral discussion even from a subjectivist standpoint

No you cannot, because you cannot define what is useful and what is not. Again, you presuppose "usefulness" concept. What is useful, how is it characterized. You say that assuming Carthesian Demon is not useful or correct or whatever. On what grounds? Can somebody claim that let's say existence of God or anything else useful or vice versa that it is pointless just because? Does it mean that God exists in the same way you use usefulness to deny existence of Carthesian Demon? What is useful from subjective standpoint of one person is useless from somebody else. That is why it is a weak point for this type of argumentation. Infinite regress of words like "it is obvious because it is useful because it is fruitful because ..." does not explain anything. Where do you ground it, what is the actual grounding of your web of beliefs? If this seems like Tu Quoqe, then again it is not. Not all webs of believes are equal from the standpoint of their internal consistency.

Okay. But he was married since 1980 till now. What other proof did we have that he is a serial womanizer? In fact around 90% of S&P 100 between 2011-2019 CEOs are married with around 10% ever being divorced. There are high profile scandals like with Musk or Bezos or now with Jensen Huang, but it is not normative for high-powered CEOs.

You keep using the word "presupposition", which seems to elide the difference between two different acts:

Asserting that X is true; Assuming that X is true.

Yes, all presuppositions are circular and assertive and BTW I can say that universal claim under my worldview. However worldviews and paradigms are not made equal. For instance if you assume secular materialist world where you assert that "all that exists is only matter and energy", and "I am just bunch of atoms doing stuff" then you strip this universe from telos. Even setting aside the problem of how 1kg of brain matter on Earth can make universal statements about all cosmos.

To claim that and then say "and that is why it is bad for people to steal" is no sequitur. You did not ground good or bad inside this cosmology. It is invalid move, you borrow from other traditions to make moral statements. Inside this monistic materialist paradigm a billion kilograms of children falling into black hole is just bunch of atoms doing stuff - in fact it is what happens to everybody, we all end up as particles in heat death of uniform and everything smooths out to some cold cosmic structure. In that state nothing has any meaning, suffering, bliss or anything else is meaningless. Without objective yardstick in God, these experiences are subjective and they can be good, bad or neutral even from the standpoint of the same person depending of how she feels when she wakes up.

...would suffice for you to immediately regenerate that proof in your head, and as such didn't spell it out (because spelling things out unnecessarily can be interpreted as condescension). Apparently, it was not obvious to you, so I did spell it out. At no point did I make a claim that obvious things are true; I merely used (apparent) obviousness as a criterion for elision, as a matter of debate etiquette.

The problem is not that it was "not obvious to me". It is that you do not have a coherent representation of what "obvious" is. Something can be obvious to 99.999% of people and it can be wrong. Or do you have some belief that as long as something is obvious to 50%+ of people than it makes it true or something? OR maybe you have some additional criteria: it counts as "obvious" for everybody who acknowledges some presupposition (e.g. secular humanism) or who has IQ greater than 120 or something? If yes, why did you invent this additional criteria for obviousness?

Also I would like to discuss a little bit more about Morton's fork specifically to bypass Cartheisan Daemon runs into Quines Undetermination of Scientific Theory. It is a critique of empiricism exactly in line with what I was saying - there is infinite compatible number of theories for any given amount of scientific evidence. If you privilege one theory over other, you have to go OUTSIDE of empiricism toward presuppositionalism. So we now have to have a discussion about which presupposition is more explanatory.

You are skipping the point of the whole tradition of empirical skepticism like Hume and Descartes. They tried hard to define "obvious" and failed. Quine explained why they failed and why it is bankrupt philosophical endeavor.

No, premise 2 is false. Arianism (i.e. Christianity minus the "1 = 3, it's a divine mystery" bit) can account for all those things. Islam can account for all those things. Zoroastrianism (which is at least sort of polytheistic) can account for all those things. Deism can account for all those things. Materialism can account for all of them except objective morality (which may not exist, and does not seem necessary for debate since a shared subjective morality can lead to shared conclusions).

Sure, I can go to apologetics and why Zoroastrianism, Ariansim, Islam or Buddhism and Hinduism are all incorrect - as long as we understand the premise that we have. We can fork this discussion if you wish. Again, I am absolutely opposed to classical deism or any notion of some pagan higher being as in Thomistic definition. Triune Christian God is completely different from Muslim Allah or Zoroastrian dualistic entity or Gnostic demiurge or some platonic The One. They are mutually incompatible paradigms.

The conclusion that the Christian God exists might be right or wrong, but premise 2 is clearly false

Just because my premise is more developed to your intuition does not mean it is "false". Relativity is less obvious than Newtonian mechanics - which is my analogy of Christianity vs all these other religions including secular religions worshiping material monads or some platonic structures or some dualism of substrate/software like Joscha Bah. Again, I am happy to engage in this discussion in the framework of presupposition.

Jacques Hébert was not guillotined for being a public intellectual lmao, he was a political heavyweight who literally openly called for violent insurrection and paid the price.

So what? If you call for violence then you are not an intellectual? Can we now publicly execute everybody who cheered assassination of Charlie Kirk or who endorse hanging of Nicolae Ceaușescu?

Marat was assassinated by a vengeful aristocrat acting on private terms

Marat was assassinated for his rabid revolutionary pamphlets. He was not assassinated for being the executioner, he was assassinated for his revolutionary fervor and his political opinions. After Thermidorian Reaction he was removed from republican Panthéon, cities named after him such as Havre-Marat were renamed back and so forth. So let's not pretend that it was a private act of violence.

As for the rest of the intellectuals the same is true. Also let's look at what is right now happening to Michel Houellebecq. In grand scheme of things him facing some hate-speech libel is the softest way of how French intellectuals were treated in the past. So give me a break.

I assumed (apparently falsely) that this proof was sufficiently "obvious" that you would immediately grasp it and thus I didn't need to belabour the point by stating it.

It is obvious only if you have a presupposition that debate has any meaning. Carthesian Demon is just an educational example of age-old skeptic tradition. The point was to demonstrate how one can build presuppositions from ground up, from Descarte's cogito ergo sum toward other concepts within a full fledged metaphysics. The point is that I do not grant anything as obvious on first level. What does it even mean "obvious". Obvious to you? Obvious to 1% or 10% of people? Is this some epistomological anchor, maybe some tweaked version of argumentum ad populum? I can also say that over 60% people on Earth believe in God and it is "obvious" to them: is this sufficient for you, or do you require some additional arguments and justifications?

Your interlocutor says X.

You respond to your interlocutor as though he's saying Y, presumably because English isn't your first language and you honestly misinterpreted him.

Your interlocutor responds that he's not saying Y, and is in fact saying X.

You insist that your interlocutor is saying Y, and sometimes insult him (as I just quoted).

What is this weird shit with me being East European and having trouble with articles and commas. But I can cut the crap, what does it mean "obvious" to you? One just cannot say that "X is obvious" and automatically win a debate. Because if we make this as a meta-level rule "anything anybody claims as obvious makes him win a debate" is not consistent. Did you get the meaning of what I say despite lack of articles and commas?

Do you believe these premises?

Yes, I do.

Premise 2 appears very obviously to be an error by Kant, due partially to his life being before the theory of natural selection was created by Wallace and Darwin and thus a materialistic explanation of 3/4 of those was devised, and partially due to privileging the Christian hypothesis over e.g. deism simply because there are more Christians than deists.

Who cares about psychologizing, if - in your mind somebody believes something because of psychology. It is just pure ad hominem. I can invent any psychological story of how somebody believes something because of their mother and father and trauma or whatnot. But is it True?

For instance as an example, I believe in personal God because it has explanatory power over telos of the universe. God being a person means that the universe has purpose. A personal God is somebody who can produce divine revelation of his creation. There are many other features of personal God that are above and beyond of something like declaring that "Schrodinger equation living inside Hilbert space is a god". It is a paradigmatical level argument, a meta-level argument for web of beliefs.