@guajalote's banner p

guajalote


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 18:41:28 UTC

				

User ID: 676

guajalote


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 18:41:28 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 676

I think you are missing two important points.

The first is that evangelicals believe the Bible and Christianity are one-in-the-same. There is nothing you need to learn about Christianity outside the Bible, other than perhaps things that God might communicate to you directly. If an organization or authority figure says something that seems to be in tension with the literal text of the Bible, then the authority figure is wrong because the Bible is infallible.

The second point is that, irrespective of what people think now, most believing Christians and Jews throughout history believed Genesis was literally true. So there are only three possibilities:

  1. Those people in the past were right,
  2. Those people in the past were wrong because God wrote the Bible in a deliberately misleading way knowing that it would trick them into believing something untrue, or
  3. The Bible is not the word of God.

I probably should have said "Every single Word in Scripture is literally correct and not misleading." They don't dispute that metaphors exist, but unless something it clearly metaphorical it shouldn't be interpreted as such. God wouldn't leave room for ambiguity about what is metaphorical.

And I can say for certain that people do in fact believe this, because me and many people I knew believed this when I was an evangelical teenager.

Usually they do in fact follow that part of the bible as well, but they understand it to mean that they shouldn't preach during church services, not that they shouldn't give talks.

It's pretty simple. If every word of the Bible is literally true, then evolution cannot be true. So if you want to believe every word of the Bible is literally true, then you need to deny evolution.

On the other hand, if every word of the Bible is not literally true, how can it have been written by a loving and all-knowing God who wants people to believe in him? Surely such a God would not put deliberate errors or sources of confusion in the Bible. He has omnipotent power and can use that power to write a perfectly clear book, so why wouldn't he? If it turns out large portions of the Bible are false, doesn't that imply it is not, in fact, divinely inspired at all? And therefore all this Christianity stuff is hokum?

It's not that men offered to carry women's books as a way to impress her (or her parents). It's that men were socially expected to offer to carry heavy objects like books for women, and if the man happened to be attracted to the woman then this interaction would also present a good opportunity to flirt with her.

One of the common responses to AI safety concerns is "just don't let it get out of the box." That's actually a pretty good point: as long as the AI doesn't have godlike intelligence and as long as we actually take steps to keep it inside the box where it can't impact the real world directly, the danger that an AI can pose is somewhat contained and limited.

When you start giving AI access to real world stuff, you no longer have the ability to keep it fully inside the box. At this point it's probably fine and not a big risk given current AI capabilities, but it's hard to say for sure, and it gets riskier and riskier as capabilities get better.

It's clear to me that aligned AI (of the type you describe) is a much bigger threat in the near term than unaligned AI. I haven't seen any indication that AI intrinsically wants to harm people, but an aligned AI will gladly do bad things because a human told it to.

I'm not claiming it's what she meant. She probably didn't mean anything or even write the speech. I'm just pointing out how a small tweak by the speechwriter would have saved the day.

One of the things that makes it so hard to align superintelligent human beings (like political leaders) is that they have human drives and ambitions for things like sex, power, prestige, etc. They will always be intrinsically driven to get around guardrails to get these things. It doesn't seem like AI needs to be beholden to its goals in the same way. It seems like we can design a paperclip maximizer that just stops maximizing paperclips when we tell it to. Hopefully that continues to be true.

I agree with you philosophically. I have a son the same age who is healthy, but if he were suffering severely in the manner described in the article I would feel compelled to at least seriously consider every lawful option to alleviate that suffering.

However, I think there might be good practical arguments against euthanasia, especially in a system where the government bears the cost of healthcare. There is a strong financial incentive for the government to use euthanasia as cost-saving tool, and this incentive might erode whatever checks are in place, such that people who should not be euthanized are getting euthanized anyway. I'm not sure if I fully believe this argument, but it's the only counterargument that seems at all convincing to me.

Or if she had said "the primary victims of the aftermath of war" which seems to be what she is trying to say in the following sentences.

Its extremely rarely that I agree with China or Trump on anything, but I think they are sadly correct. No matter how well-meaning and theoretically prudent AI safety regulation may be, the practical effect of any real world AI regulation will not be safety, but will be to "uphold Washington's monopolistic hegemony in cutting-edge technology, and exclude China from the global AI governance system."

I don't see how that pertains to the law being discussed. Of course private venues can turn people down. The law bans drag shows that were not turned down by the venue.

It makes for an incredibly cheesy, campy effect, and I'm tired of pretending that it's not in horrible taste.

Speech that's cheesy, campy, and in horrible taste is protected by the First Amendment.

This argument is like saying that if an impersonation of Barack Obama by a white man is racist, then being Barack Obama is racist.

Yes, this argument would be equally bad. An impersonation of Barack Obama by a white man is not inherently racist. Also, racist speech is protected by the First Amendment.

In many contexts the act of impersonation itself is sexual, above and beyond the fact that there's sexuality because of the target of the impersonation.

I'm not sure this is true. But even if it were true, there are many contexts where impersonation is not intrinsically sexual, and the law provides no mechanism to distinguish these contexts. The law does not even mention impersonation as a factor to be considered in the analysis.

Adjusted for inflation, do you make significantly less than your father did at the same age? If so, that would explain your experience. But it is very much not the typical US experience. Real wages have risen consistently, and this is true across all income deciles.

Of course, there is a distribution of outcomes, and some people will inevitably see their incomes decrease even as most incomes increase. You may be one of those people, for whatever reason. This is not a new phenomenon, and it doesn't warrant new policies to address it. It's just a fact of statistics that some people will (based on genetics, luck, whatever) diverge from the typical outcome and end up making less than their parents did, even while most people are making more.

If that's not the case, then it means you are choosing to allocate your resources differently than your father did. You are choosing to live in a high cost of living area (the fact that it's the same zip code is irrelevant; the relative desirability of zip codes shifts over time). You are choosing to spend more on other things besides housing square footage.

telling people that there aren't actually affordability issues because you know better than them about how they're just wasteful with money is a braindead strategy

How did you take that away from what I said? I said you were choosing to spend your money differently. That's not accusing you of being wasteful (although if you are being wasteful, that would certainly be a relevant fact). I'm saying you are prioritizing other goods more highly than you prioritize housing square footage. That may be a perfectly legitimate thing to do.

I deliberately wrote decent burrito, meaning something roughly on par with Chipotle. That did not exist most places in the US 30 years ago.

I can't imagine the Midwest being so very different as not to have its own terrible burrito factory at the time?

My mom grew up in a very rural part of the midwest. She saw an avocado for the first time as a teenager when another kid who had been on vacation somewhere brought one to the school as a curiosity to show people.

Tell me if I'm getting the argument here:

  1. You feel your life is worse than your father's.

  2. When people argue your beliefs are factually incorrect, you say its about "the messaging strategy, not the object debate."

  3. Based on your feelings (which need not be true at the object level), you believe you are entitled to submit a list of "specific asks" to someone (?) who is for some reason obligated to implement them.

Can you flesh out the last part?

So first of all... yes.

That is certainly not the experience of most people 30+ years ago. My mother who grew up in the Midwest never laid eyes on a burrito until she was at least in her 20s. My father grew up in the SF bay area, so he likely ate them from a young age, but he's in a small minority. And even he didn't have access to sushi or other such "exotic" food we take for granted today.

But my point is that I think you are probably doing better than your parents and you are simply failing to recognize it (or if not you personally, then at least the average member of your cohort). Your kids are 4 to a bedroom, but you admit that is because you are simply prioritizing your spending differently. You are spending more on things like food and healthcare and in exchange receiving much higher quality food and healthcare than your father's generation did. My burrito question is emblematic of this fact. And you can't just handwave away modern cars and phones and TVs and the internet and everything else your father didn't have. You are objectively choosing to spend money to get more and better stuff in other areas of your life for yourself and your children, and in exchange you are settling for slightly worse housing. You and your family are objectively better off overall.

I completely agree we need to address affordability, because it's good to do that regardless of whether people are doing better than their parents or not. There are a bunch of simple things we can do to accomplish that, but they largely lack political support: deregulate housing and make it much easier to build, get rid of tariffs, lower taxes and government spending.

Apply the burrito test to your own life. When your father was your age, was a decent burrito available at a nearby restaurant at any price, let alone $20? Unless you live in certain places like California, the answer is almost certainly "no."

They were pulled from the home by economic incentives, not economic need. As wages rose, employment became an increasingly attractive alternative to staying home.

By that logic, the fact that Trump chose the word "bleach" instead of "disinfecting nasal spray" is what cost lives.

I think the progressive would claim that immigrants overperform in football because they are oppressed and excluded from higher education and white collar employment opportunities. Still a dumb argument, as it implies that getting rid of oppression would also "destroy football throughout the UK," but not an endorsement of HBD.

In general it is impossible to predict when a crash will happen until it has already happened. So I am a greypiller. You should always try to be prepared for the possibility of a downturn (whether in the larger economy or in your own personal economic fortunes) but you're fooling yourself if you think you can predict them.

I like the Killers, and I do pay attention to lyrics, but I think you're right in that most of the Killers' lyrics are nonsense. Sure, the song has general themes of jealousy, but not much coherence beyond that.

Consider the first two lines. "Comin' out of my cage and I've been doin' just fine / Gotta, gotta be down because I want it all." These lyrics barely make sense and seemingly have nothing to do with the rest of the song. And then you get to lines like "Turning saints into the sea / Swimming through sick lullabies" that make even less sense. Sure, you can try to interpret them to mean something, but they're mostly just there to sound cool. I doubt Brandon Flowers intended any deeper meaning.

It's not even clear to me that the song is about infidelity. I read it as being about a guy who is pining after a woman who its not interested in him, and he is imagining scenarios where she is sleeping with other men ("it's all in my head").