@naraburns's banner p

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

				

User ID: 100

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 100

Now ofc, the racial dynamics are explicit policy in the woke era. But, that's a more recent phenomenon.

One thing I wondered when writing my post is how much of this emerges organically from growing restrictions on what Hollywood will do. The recent diversity requirements for Oscars, for example, mean visible racial diversity has to be high on your casting list priorities (unless your story focuses on non-straight-white-men, apparently?). But that will influence the ways characters interact, and even the way they're written (Sam Jackson's Nick Fury started out as a badass, but in Secret Invasion he has been reduced to a man obsessed with racism, to the point of complaining about riding on segregated trains that would not have existed within his fictional lifetime, and demanding a black military officer (who may have been replaced by a shapeshifting alien, but--) help him as a show of solidarity against old, white politicians).

That definitely qualifies!

I highly doubt Clint Eastwood was trying to hint at white replacement in Gran Turino.

Maybe so! But what about the writer, Nick Schenk? Wikipedia suggests:

In the early 1990s, Schenk became acquainted with the history and culture of the Hmong while working in a factory in Minnesota. He also learned how they had sided with the South Vietnamese forces and its US allies during the Vietnam War, only to wind up in refugee camps, at the mercy of North Vietnamese Communist forces, when US troops pulled out and the government forces were defeated. Years later, he was deciding how to develop a story involving a widowed Korean War veteran trying to handle the changes in his neighborhood when he decided to place a Hmong family next door and create a culture clash.

And I guess I would add--it's not that the hint is deliberately "white replacement" so long as it is in some sense a matter of "making way." In discussing with others in the thread, I'm increasingly persuaded that a better way for me to frame this trope is "white dude has his humanity restored by relationship with non-white/female/etc. successor, and in the process realizes that his highest calling is to benefit them." And also that my focus on the white dude's death is probably me being too specific about which costs the white dude is depicted as paying.

A move can teach "racism is bad" by curing it, but in order to show the racist character's redemption, the newly-non-racist white dude is inevitably going to give up something, and maybe give up everything. Can someone be non-racist and also be as indifferent to one's minority neighbors as one's white neighbors? A Man Called Otto walks an interesting line here, too, as Otto is clearly depicted as a misandrist, but totally cool with everyone at the level of their individual characteristics.

(Interestingly, the so-called "anti-racist" view does seem to be that it's not enough to just not be racist--you have to actively work to benefit the BIPOCracy.)

Whiteness is about pure European heritage.

This has never really been true (until, perhaps, very recently, as a result of the Great Awokening and people turning "white" into a slur). It's something that gets discussed to death but it's not actually a very interesting debate, it just diverts discussion into an argument about words instead of a discussion about substance.

Yeah, see downthread for some further discussion on Man on Fire as well as Book of Eli--apparently Denzel Washington owns the inversion here!

I Am Legend doesn't seem to quite fit, though maybe depending on which ending you liked (in one, Smith lives). But the female lead is Alice Braga, who is Brazilian, so it's only inverted if you regard Hispanic as "white." Which many people do, and with good reason, but... probably not Hollywood.

he's not choosing to save her and/or secede the future to her

No, but he's still making way for her (and her children), in a more literal as well as a figurative sense. I think maybe part of what I'm tracking here is "white savior" characters who... aren't? Like, they kind of maybe look that way, but really their successor restores their humanity in some way, and then they see that the human thing to do is give everything to/for their successor.

It occurs to me that Pixar's Up could be this if Carl had died to get Russell home, and could also be this if there were a post-credit scene where Carl left an inheritance for Russell. But maybe I've made a problem for myself by focusing on dead men, maybe there are more clear examples where the men aren't shown to die but the implication is still that they are "making way."

That sounds like an inversion of the trope in multiple ways! Interesting that Denzel Washington should have starred in two that people remember.

Closest I can think of is "Man on Fire" with Denzel Washington and Dakota Fanning.

I have not seen that one. Reading the summary, I'm not sure I see Fanning's character as a "successor" or "inheritor" in this case but otherwise I agree that it gets most of the way there.

I did see that one! I suspect I did not think of it because the dead guy in that case is not really a PoV hero, so I don't think the audience is plainly intended to identify with him. But in all other respects, yes, that is definitely a "not-white successor" movie.

Content advisory: untagged spoilers for like a dozen movies below!

The other day I watched A Man Called Otto, Tom Hanks' 2022 remake of a Swedish movie (En man som heter Ove, based on a book of the same name) about an elderly man whose suicide attempt is interrupted by an Iranian immigrant, who gradually teaches him to live again. The Hanks edition hits a variety of CW notes; the Iranian is replaced with a Hispanic woman, the Swedish ending depicting Ove's reunion with his deceased wife in the afterlife is gone, and a homosexual character is replaced with a trans character (hashtag-gay-erasure). But there is one CW note in particular that really stood out to me. At the end of the movie, Otto dies and leaves his house and his car to the Hispanic woman, as well as enough money to fund the education of her three Hispanic children.

Maybe this would not have stood out to me had I not coincidentally recently re-watched the 2013's middling dystopic sci-fi, Elysium. If you've not seen this one, it is a story about an unusually talented blue collar laborer played by Matt Damon, presumably because everyone liked him as an unusually talented blue collar laborer in Stillwater, Good Will Hunting, and, uh, that artist guy in Titanic maybe? (Kidding!) Anyway this time blue-collared Matt lives in a Los Angeles peopled entirely by Mexicans (except for him), who spend most of their time trying to cross the border of space (illegally) so they can get high-tech medical treatment aboard the space station where all the billionaires moved when Earth got too crowded or warm or, who knows. For unimportant reasons, Matt finds that he's dying, so he goes to his coyote uh human trafficker spaceship launching ex (crime) boss to... Jesus Christ, who wrote this movie? Anyway, the moral of the story is that Matt gives his life to save the life of a young Hispanic girl while also making everyone on Earth a "citizen" so that suddenly the boundless healthcare resources the billionaires have been hoarding for no reason at all can be immediately deployed to cure all illness on Earth, the end.

So this got me thinking about other movies I've seen with the same central beat: selfish single white male with nothing to lose learns to care again by temporarily filling the role of mentor or savior to a not-white young person, then gives (often, loses) everything so the not-white youngster can inherit a brighter future. Gran Torino (2008). Snowpiercer (2013).

But while many lists of "problematic white savior" movies include these titles, I feel like there's a distinction to be drawn where the not-white character is treated as a successor, rather than as a success. In Finding Forrester (2000), there's a not-white successor, but the "white savior" doesn't especially give anything up. In The Blind Side (2009) the "white savior" isn't looking for a successor (despite the professed concerns of the NCAA).

And I don't think that it's quite the same phenomenon as "expendable man dies for the woman he loves." Never mind that I already mentioned Titanic (1997)--the Bond movie No Time To Die (2021) might be what I'm talking about if Bond had died to save Nomi instead of Madeleine, but (to the best of my recollection!) he did not. I suppose Luke Skywalker biting it to preserve Palpatine's bloodline might be an example of what I'm talking about--definitely would if Rey was not-white, and definitely would if the sequels had focused more on Finn becoming a Jedi.

So I feel like I've identified four clear examples of the trope I'm spotting (to review: A Man Called Otto, Elysium, Gran Torino, Snowpiercer). I know better than to expect TVTropes to have a "non-straight-white-hypercapable-male successor" trope, but I did look around and do not think that Changing of the Guard, Take Up My Sword, Taking Up the Mantle, White Man's Burden, or similar tropes quite apply. Likewise, many people will identify the trope I have in mind as a (correspondingly problematic) "white savior" story, except that most "white savior" stories aren't BIPOC successor stories. Rather, this is taking the expendability of men--long a cultural staple in the West--and mixing it up with a not-even-remotely-subtle hint at White Replacement.

I think the reason I even noticed the pattern is that I have a long fascination with Rudyard Kipling's infamous poem, "The White Man's Burden." Specifically, the people I know who regard the poem as highly racist almost always also talk a great deal about "privilege," without ever seeming to notice the noblesse oblige implied by the idea of checking that privilege. There seems to be a deeply unresolved contradiction in "woke" spaces, whereby whites are simultaneously obligated to elevate others, and forbidden from even imagining they have the capacity to do so. In the trope I'm trying to track, the acceptable excuse seems to be that the (grizzled, lonely, etc.) white man gets something from the successor, namely a "new lease on life," such that he can then return the favor by then literally dying and dedicating his entire legacy to assure the future of someone else's children, children who are not even his co-ethnics.

(TVTropes does have a Cuckold page, but this is also not quite what I'm talking about... I think!)

So here are your discussion questions for the day:

  1. Is there a name for this trope already? Have I missed a TVTropes pages somewhere? A RibbonFarm article? An obscure media studies dissertation?

  2. I can't watch every movie, or even remember all the movies I've watched. Can you think of any other movies/TV shows/other media to add to the four I've identified?

  3. I also can't think of any inverted examples. Can you think of any media in which the trope is inverted? How often do hypercompetent heroes "of color" learn to love whites and then give up their lives to ensure that several white children can afford to go to college? (Does the Wizard from Shazam! count, maybe, kinda?)

  4. Perhaps most importantly... is there any possibility at all that the phenomenon isn't blatantly deliberate agenda-pushing?

Naturally, you are not limited to these questions--this is a discussion board, not a MOOC. But I've managed to stump myself so I'm interested in what you all make of this.

men have slightly higher IQ than women on average

No. Average IQ is 100 by definition. Men have a flatter distribution curve; there are more men than women at the top and bottom of IQ distribution, but fewer at the peak of the curve.

EDIT: On further reading, I appear to maybe be partly wrong about this--all the sources I'm finding suggest that yes, the male IQ distribution curve is flatter, but also the peak is shifted rightward, so there is more to this issue that is, for all the reasons you might imagine, under-discussed.

More effort than this, please.

Engagement is tricky. I enjoy reading international stories but I'm not in a great position to judge the credibility of international sources, so having some of that contextualized by Mottizens is something I appreciate. But I don't necessarily have much to say about it for the same reason: I'm not an expert on such things. What I suspect you're hitting for a lot of people, is "fargroup fascination," which raises interest but doesn't necessarily lead to much discussion.

That said, did New Zealand's uptake of affirmative action in medicine get discussed in one of your threads? Or somewhere else on the Motte? If so, I missed it, and I'm sorry to have done so. The issue did come up over on Scott's link post, where he said:

The government says this just “corrects” institutional biases which exist at other stages; I don’t know the New Zealand situation but have found previous claims of this sort flimsy. Here are various articles talking about how anyone who is against this system lacks context on how it won’t work that way, plus also it already works this way so nothing will change, plus it will revolutionize health equity so you’d have to be a monster to object, plus it will make no difference so anyone who protests is just manufacturing fake outrage. I can’t find the algorithm they say they’re using anywhere; here is a FOIA-equivalent request for it which hasn’t been answered yet. This file seems related and suggests Maori should get the highest priority and Asians the lowest priority, but I’m not sure they’re exactly following the science here. I think of this in the context of the US COVID vaccine prioritization effort; not only did it cause hundreds or thousands of unnecessary deaths by giving vaccines to young healthy low-risk members of favored groups before old sick high-risk members of disfavored ones, it also caused scarce vaccine doses to be wasted rather than spent on members of disfavored groups because of implementation details. We should be fighting for less of this, not more.

But user "benwave" claims in the comments that:

Ethnicity was Already a factor taken into account in the algorithm for these surgery waitlists. This latest change makes ethnicity Less important in the algorithm than was previously the case, and raises importance of other various poverty indicators. But because this is the first most people have heard of it, so it has had a huge impact in the news and political spheres.

And see, once again: I personally have no idea whether this is true, and don't know off the top of my head how I would confirm it; probably by just spending an hour or two on Google, possibly coming away frustrated anyway. Also Scott's summary doesn't seem to differentiate between elective and emergency surgeries, but maybe he's using physician lingo that creates a distinction I can't notice.

So there's an example of an international story that piqued my interest, but concerning which I'm not sure I have anything useful to say.

The general framing is that smart people are more able to rationalize their biases away as something else.

I think there is ample evidence that smart people are not immune from bias. And just as critical thinking is not always the right tool for the job, neither is IQ. But that is a very different claim than a suggestion that smart people are in general worse at critical thinking than people with lower native intelligence, because they are smart. "Smart people are the real stupid people" is definitely a take I can see playing well to the cheap seats, but I just don't see any evidence of it.

In particular, the article you've linked here makes much of the idea that it might be harder to talk a smart person out of a belief in creationism because they are smart; well, maybe that is true, but it is also true that religion and IQ are negatively correlated. The Wikipedia article there suggests a variety of reasons why we might want to doubt the veracity of these findings, but still the picture they paint is not especially concordant with the idea that "smart" is limited to meaning "better able to talk oneself into not changing one's mind."

I recall seeing some paper that argued IQ and critical thinking is almost uncorrelated.

I'd be interested to see that paper. This one suggests a moderate correlation (r=.38, n=244) between IQ and critical thinking ability.

The paper argues that "critical thinking skills" are a better predictor of choices/outcomes than IQ, but this should be obvious from other arguments that IQ is a sort of "measuring cup," which identifies potential but must be "filled" to yield correlated benefits. If "critical thinking ability" is something higher IQ people are more likely to have, but not guaranteed to have, that fits my account very well.

A standard exercise would be to have them explain what a certain scholar thinks about something, and then ask them to explain whether they agree or disagree, and why. A very basic example from an introductory ethics class might be to give them the standard trolley problem, then ask them (1) what Jeremy Bentham would recommend (and why), and (2) whether they agree or disagree (and why). Knowing about utilitarianism and its contents is the main thing, but giving them an opportunity to say "I do/don't like how this comes out, and let me explain why that is" furnishes a chance to critically reflect.

If I've done my job at all, most students will get past (1) easily enough (though it's a little depressing, sometimes, the number of students who can't even be coached to this point). But for (2), most students will say something like "I agree because 5 is greater than 1," which is actually less of an answer than Bentham gives (roughly, "it's always best to do what brings about the greatest amount of happiness for the greatest number of people, and therefore you should save the five you can"). Where I start to see something like "critical thinking" is in students who say things like "I think I disagree because it seems like I'm not to blame if the five die, but I might be to blame for one death if I pull the lever. But in a different lecture we talked about the difference between killing and letting die, and I thought I agreed that there was no difference, which seems to suggest I should agree with Bentham after all." Responding to the push and pull between disparate positions is a noticeable improvement over leaping to dogmatic conclusions without hesitation, based on something you memorized from the textbook.

My feedback to students who just parrot "five is greater than one" would be an attempt to prompt them to change their mind in some way--not because they're wrong, necessarily, but because I don't see any thought behind their answer, so I try to say something to encourage them to think a little more deeply about the problem. This is the meat of "critical thinking" education--you can talk about thinking strategies, you can classify fallacies, you can read critical essays, but the real value is in the opportunities you give students to practice critical thinking, by giving them interesting problems to engage with on their own terms. No single problem could possibly contain every facet of critical thinking, and thinking about one issue may not improve your ability to think about other issues. But as you work through a variety of issues, in a variety of contexts, the hope is that you will gradually develop beneficial thinking habits.

I'm removing this comment. I am writing this reply but I don't actually know if this reply will still be visible after I remove this comment; I apologize in advance for whatever problems that creates!

The comment I am removing was recognized as uncredited copypasta by users. If the mod team had immediately recognized it as such, we may have removed the comment more quickly, as uncredited copypasta is a form of spam. But we had to verify, and there was some inter-moderator discussion going on.

I remind everyone that while our default position is not to remove comments--and certainly not to censor debate or stifle discussion of difficult topics--some users are not interested in discussion, as Zorba talks about in the latest META post. Sometimes it's hard to know who these users are. Sometimes we make bad calls as moderators. I apologize in advance if that's what I'm doing now.

But I admit, for the moment, that I doubt it. I'm also perma-banning the user for spam at least until such time as I am persuaded that they are not, in fact, just a spammer.

It sounds like you agree with me that CT can't really be taught and that it's just subject matter knowledge.

Well, no, not exactly... it can be "taught" to a certain degree, insofar as an inherently smart person who receives no education is unlikely to develop it (or develop it greatly), but it can't be taught to just anyone. And while subject matter knowledge is often the stuff of critical thinking, it is not the process of critical thinking. When I "teach" critical thinking, what I am mostly doing is giving students a wide array of opportunities to think critically, and giving them as many hints about the process as I can--like showering sparks onto material of unknown flammability. Some students "catch," most do not. Without the sparks, there would often be no fire, but the sparks are not sufficient, and for some students may not even be necessary.

When you say "objective," do you mean "impartial" or "in touch with noumenal reality," or something else?

I think the standard meaning of "objective" in this context is something like "truth-seeking without regard for one's preferences or biases or..." The words "objective" and "subjective" actually have a complicated history (my understanding is that their connotations have switched meanings twice in the history of philosophy) but that seemed like an unnecessary distraction to develop here.

If you think, to take the mechanic example, that it's some blend of creativity/counterfactuals or whatever which exists on top of just brute knowledge, is there anything an omniscient car mechanic would be unable to do (with a car) if he lacked only the power of critical thought? Is critical thought an easier substitute for knowledge? A harder substitute?

For certain values of omniscient, maybe not? I don't know enough about how automotive engines work to be very confident in my example here, so let me use a desktop PC example instead. Suppose that my desktop PC functions as expected for about an hour, then hard-locks. It does this no matter what I'm doing (gaming, word processing, surfing the web) but sometimes it doesn't--maybe sometimes it runs for two hours, or six, before hard-locking. How would I fix that problem?

The problem for an "omniscient" computer technician is that, so far, we don't actually have enough information to know what the problem is. In my experience, the described symptoms could easily be caused by a bad OS install, a faulty power supply, a faulty motherboard, a faulty CPU, a faulty GPU, faulty RAM, and less commonly even other faulty peripherals, including peripherals attached via USB (or whatever). There is no single answer to the question, "my computer keeps hard locking, usually after an hour but not always." To get from status quo A ("computer hard locks") to status quo B ("computer does not hard lock"), you're going to go through a series of steps that probably looks something like this:

  1. Google the problem for a while, see if anything obvious sticks out.

  2. Run your system in "safe mode" for a while, see if that fixes anything.

  3. Make sure your drivers are up to date, or maybe reinstall them even if they are. Do the same for any flashable BIOS or similar. Test for a while.

  4. Wipe your system drive, give your OS a fresh install. Test for a while.

  5. Remove all unnecessary peripherals, internal and external. Test for a while.

  6. Swap out a suspected part. Depending on the availability of parts, you might start with easy swaps (RAM), or more convenient swaps (you happen to have a PSU on hand). Iterate until the problem goes away.

Now you might say "well by ominscient I mean someone who knows all the troubleshooting procedures, not just everything there is to know about how computers work." But then you're just throwing a modified Chinese Room problem at me, which I certainly can't solve for you. You can say the words "infinite knowledge but no reasoning capacity" but I haven't got the first idea what that would actually look like, in practice. Nothing I've ever encountered has infinite knowledge.

Your question does remind me of studies showing that younger people are more flexible in their thinking, but older people have more (and more developed) "scripts" to draw from when faced with novel problems. So there does seem to be a meaningful difference between "thought" and "knowledge," even though the two often serve similar practical uses for their wielders. It's not "easier" or "harder" to be young versus old in such cases--more like, you have different tools that will work differently on different problems.

Paths from Status Quo A to SQ B seems too narrow a definition.

Sure, but I wasn't offering a definition, just a way of modeling critical thinking. There are other ways to model it, for example as an "answer generator" or similar--critical thinking might be something you do when you're trying to decide the truth of some matter. In the transition model I used above, you could still say "well that's taking you from status quo 'don't know' to status quo 'do know'" but that seems a bit stilted, so in such a case you might prefer a different model.

Critical Thinking is invoked most often as a synonym for "epistemology," but that doesn't involve any transit from one SQ to another- it just tries to figure out what SQ A is. Is that use of the term "critical thinking" a mistake?

I have never seen "critical thinking" used as a synonym for "epistemology" and yes, I would regard doing so as a mistake. Epistemology is generally concerned with what makes a "true justified belief." But Gettier problems introduce difficulty with even that definition of knowledge, and I have not personally encountered any response to them that I find wholly convincing. "Critical thinking" is a process of arriving at conclusions, so it's mostly focused on the "justified" part--since it does not guarantee truth, only offers (Bayesian?) assurances. "Critical thinking" is the phrase we use to describe something that people clearly do (process information in a truth-seeking way), and this is the "what" question in your topic line. How, precisely, it is done is a related but different question, and a much more difficult one.

It's tempting to respond to these questions with a bell curve meme:

Low Wit: Critical thinking is objective analysis!

Mid Wit: [wall of text expressing Humean doubt about the very possibility of objectivity on any issue]

High Wit: Critical thinking is objective analysis!

"Teach critical thinking" is a substantial portion of my real-life job description. It is the putative raison d'etre most often offered for humanities education generally, in the face of ever-increasing pressure from industry to transform university education into purely vocational training. On this basis, we teach logic, avoidance of fallacies, research skills like source identification and credibility evaluation, but the truth is not one student in ten completes an undergraduate education with the ability to generalize such skills beyond a narrow domain. For most people, education is the process of being inducted into the vocabulary and traditions of a particular field; they then spend their lives applying what they've learned, mostly uncritically, while knowledge is then left to progress (if at all) one funeral at a time.

This is most evident if you model "critical thinking" as the process of ascertaining possible paths from undesired status quo A to desired status quo B, either in the absence of known paths, or in the event of seeking alternative paths. This is done in part by systematically eliminating possibilities, both through thinking counterfactually and in the alternative, and by systematically eliminating candidate paths through hypothesis testing. This ability is critical in environments where a desired outcome is clear but the contributing factors are multivariate and entwined: health care for certain, the work of designers and technicians on complex machinery (e.g. cars, computers), and of course the crafting of effective (as distinct from merely spoils-distributing) social policy. But as such, "critical thinking" is a tool, and sometimes it might not be the right tool for the job.

That is: the ability to think objectively, counterfactually, hypothetically, etc. is often a social liability. The tradeoff is that it can be a material asset. It is interesting to wonder about this as a possible kind of natural limiter on the evolution of human IQ: we produce occasional wizards, but mostly we produce canon fodder. We produce some remarkable leaders, but mostly we produce sheep.

What your questions really reflect, I think, is the interplay between different camps of critical thinkers (which appear to be indistinguishable from "groups of high-IQ individuals") looking for ways to fence out their rivals. Even the idea "no one can truly undertake objective analysis" is the kind of idea at which one can only arrive by at least temporarily conducting objective analysis; if it were truly impossible to conduct objective analysis, then what reason would we have to believe someone who claims that objective analysis is impossible? Wouldn't we have to instead conclude that they are just biased against the idea of objective analysis?

You're not wrong, exactly--you can certainly model these competing camps as "cool kids clubs." But that doesn't eliminate the possibility that some of them are at least honestly "on the road" to objectivity, or are occasionally successfully objective. Provided one is honest, one can with plausible objectivity say, "this is what I conclude, given the best evidence available to me at this time." And measuring oneself against one's past self will often be more informative than weighing one's own perceived objectivity against the perceived objectivity of others. It's not hard to imagine someone smarter than yourself--just imagine anyone who can see the path from A to B more quickly, clearly, or effectively than you can. The hard part is not imagining them doing it, but imagining how they do it.

So for example: if someone shows you how to change your car's oil, then you have procedural knowledge of changing the oil. There's no critical thinking there. Many medical procedures are today like changing the oil of a car. Since bodies are complex and often different in surprising ways, navigating the surprises that can arise in medical practice requires more critical thinking than, say, being an auto mechanic. But sometimes auto mechanics are faced with problems that don't match standard diagnostic procedures, at which point "critical thinking" comes into play: mentally modeling the car, forming hypotheses, testing those hypotheses in ways that at least get you closer to a solution if they prove to not be the solution. In other words, thinking about how things might be, instead of leaping directly to where they are.

You may or may not have seen this play out in real life, but I have some family members who are very good at jumping to conclusions. And when you ask them to explain how they reached that conclusion, they are at a total loss. "It just makes sense," they might say, "don't you think so?" They seek agreement rather than understanding. They're not always wrong! And I know that I myself have, through critical reflection, reached incorrect conclusions which I then allowed myself to get too attached to, before realizing I hadn't grasped the whole picture. So even people who are capable of critical thought, will not always use it, or necessarily use it well.

Given the best evidence available to me at this time, "critical thinking" correlates most strongly to IQ, and secondarily to experience/education--but also that secondarily-acquired "critical thinking" is often limited to a single domain (e.g. great at troubleshooting cars, but can't apply the same process to computers, or interpersonal relationships). Some people are able to demonstrate critical thought in some contexts but not others; how this may apply to the question of "artificial general intelligence" and the possibility that some humans lack plausibly "general" intelligence, I leave as an exercise for the reader. But having staked out that position: I remind you that I have already observed that sometimes "critical thinking" is the wrong tool; I am not trying to be insulting when I suggest that some people are naturally bad at it.

I actually agree that ‘post something good’ could be a condition of avoiding or limiting a ban.

This is the back-end function of the AAQCs. One drawback is that some users (notably, yourself) opt out of that in various ways, so we still often have to rely on a vague sense of reputation instead of specific "here are good posts" metrics. But AAQCs are noted on user accounts, and having AAQCs gets you moderated more lightly--for a while. The hardest cases have always been the "lots of AAQCs, but also lots of antagonism" users. Partly because even if we turn a blind eye to the occasional torching of community capital by someone who has accrued a lot of it, their negative behavior emboldens negative behavior from others who have not accrued such capital.

But, partly to keep the AAQC reports to a reasonable length, not every good post gets recognized every time. This is a conversation the mod team has been having for as long as I've been moderating, and I'd guess it goes back even farther than that. The most clearly-functioning tool we have is the banhammer, but especially in communities like this one, we actually want to be using it as little as reasonably possible (e.g., on spambots, link farmers, etc.). The AAQC report is a functional carrot to the banhammer's stick, but I just flat-out can't get it done on better than a monthly basis, it's too selective to include every good post, and ultimately it only adds an account notation that doesn't always capture the larger picture.

(Incidentally, there is a lot of money out there being directed toward finding ways to encourage fruitful discussion between people who disagree. As far as I can tell, most of it is being given to humanities scholars to write essays congratulating themselves on being open-minded while still excusing hatred for all the right targets. I think the Motte has already succeeded far beyond what most of the professionals examining these issues ever manage to achieve. So I'm very interested in @ZorbaTHut's continued development of technological approaches to the problem, on a present budget of about $225 per month.)

This is low effort, consensus-enforcing, and a bit antagonistic. Don't post like this.

This seems like it might be of interest to Motte users, but without a submission statement and as the very first post from your account, it looks more like linkspam, so I'm removing it. But if you'd like to either resubmit with a submission statement, or participate a bit in other ways, I'll certainly reconsider.

As a post about sex differences, this is CW material and so should go in the CW thread.

That is pretty rich coming from someone who refuses to own up to the fact that he erroneously said that 303 Creative is a religious freedom in commerce case.

I did explain, already, that my phrasing there was a somewhat tongue-in-cheek inversion on the many people erroneously insisting (often, in news headlines) that this is an "LGBT rights" case, since of course the jurisprudence on suspect classifications is, let's say, 95% separate from the jurisprudence on Free Speech. Sorry you didn't feel that was sufficient "owning up."

I don't really understand why you're being such a sourpuss about this. I really tried to keep it light when I noticed your initial response, in which you classically ignored any point of interesting substance in favor of seeking boring nits to pick out of some misguided sense of tribal enmity. You always, always make me regret talking to you, in ways that have nothing to do with the substance of our disagreements, and I don't know what to do about that. Often you're pretty good at correcting the ways that people sometimes apply distorted interpretation to various facts, but you seem totally unwilling or unable to apply that ability to your own arguments, or indeed the arguments of anyone you perceive to be your ingroup.

But, if makes you happy, instead of saying that they are "completely different issues with completely different jurisprudences", perhaps I should have said that they are 99% different. Or even 95% different.

Cool cool. Glad we could reach some accord on your error.

Well, I don’t know anything about your background, but I know mine, and I would guess that I have more expertise on First Amendment law than you do.

Huh. Why did I think you were a schoolteacher?

Well. I'm a university professor with citations to scholarly work from federal courts in First Amendment cases. The only way you you have more expertise on First Amendment law than I do is if you're a federal judge. If you regularly practice First Amendment law, then you have more practical experience than me, but you might occasionally have reason to consult me on matters of theory if you're writing an appeal. Are you a First Amendment lawyer (or federal judge)? That would be interesting, because some of your takes in this thread strike me as really, really bad. In an effort to avoid a pissing contest I earlier deleted an incredulous question about where you went to law school. But now that you've brought background into it, I really do have to wonder!

And in fact there is almost no overlap between freedom of religion jurisprudence and freedom of speech jurisprudence.

That you were wrong about this when I thought you were a schoolteacher was kinda whatever. If you are a law-trained person, like, get a refund, because this is a really bad take. But you know--don't take my word for it! Consider this:

The Supreme Court has described the First Amendment as protecting certain rights of conscience. This general description can encompass the related protections for both speech and religion: "Just as the right to speak and the right to refrain from speaking are complementary components of a broader concept of individual freedom of mind, so also the individual’s freedom to choose his own creed is the counterpart of his right to refrain from accepting the creed established by the majority."

Supreme Court cases recognizing protections for religious speech have explored the precise relationship between the Free Speech and Free Exercise Clauses. The Court has recognized that each Clause protects private religious speech on its own, but in some cases, has invoked both Clauses to outline protections for religious speech. The two Clauses "work in tandem": "[w]here the Free Exercise Clause protects religious exercises, whether communicative or not, the Free Speech Clause provides overlapping protection for expressive religious activities."

The piece goes on to acknowledge a bit of what I think you might be trying to say, but feel free to clarify!

In a later case, though, the Supreme Court emphasized that the First Amendment nonetheless "protects speech and religion by quite different mechanisms," pointing in part to the Establishment Clause. Namely, the Free Speech Clause contemplates that the government will participate in public discussions, as part of the "full expression" of speech. By contrast, while the Free Exercise Clause’s "freedom of conscience and worship . . . has close parallels in the speech provisions of the First Amendment, . . . the Establishment Clause is a specific prohibition on forms of state intervention in religious affairs."

Most of this is Establishment issues, rather than Free Exercise, but

while the Free Speech and the Free Exercise Clauses serve similar goals of preventing government infringement of individual freedom of thought, their protections are not necessarily coextensive.

So, yeah--they're different! There's a difference. Like, obviously, right? But the idea that there is--to quote you directly--"almost no overlap between freedom of religion jurisprudence and freedom of speech jurisprudence" is either wrong, or a motte and bailey on "almost no." Could there be more overlap? Well, yes, I assume there could. Is there "a lot" of overlap? Well, what's "a lot?" If we disagree about what "a lot" is, then how can we mediate that disagreement besides endlessly nitpicking one another's phrasing? You yourself raised Kennedy, which is a case of overlap, so you were clearly aware of some overlap! So why lead with

completely different issues with completely different jurisprudences

??? That was wrong! Demonstrably from your own comment that was wrong! And instead of acknowledging, "okay, I overstated my position, but I do think this specific case we're talking about is sufficiently separate..." etc. etc. you went with a weasel-worded "almost no." This is very lawyerly of you, but at minimum it's horrible Motte etiquette. It's what I'm constantly fielding reports on for your trollish "what do words even mean" contributions to discussions here. You can't even seem to say true things (which you often do!) without making soldiers of your arguments.

To recap: you said that "Freedom of religion and freedom of speech are completely different issues with completely different jurisprudences." This claim was false, and I tried to point that out gently. Everything you've said since then appears to be an attempt to just... pretend you didn't say what you said? I guess? You'd save more face by just owning the mistake.