@naraburns's banner p

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

				

User ID: 100

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 100

Freedom of religion and freedom of speech are completely different issues with completely different jurisprudences.

This is... not quite right, actually. Both fall under the heading of "First Amendment jurisprudence" and are generally taught to aspiring attorneys together in "First Amendment Law." It is true that there are specific bits of jurisprudence dealing with Speech, Press, Separation, Free Exercise, etc. but as fundamental rights yielding strict scrutiny analysis, the bleed between these issues is substantial. One view, which in my experience is common but which the Court itself has only hinted at, is that all the rights enumerated in the First Amendment are supposed to encompass something like a general "freedom of conscience," or "freedom of thought," or something along those lines. To call them "completely different issues with completely different jurisprudences" is perhaps an understandable mistake for someone who lacks much background in First Amendment law, but it is still definitely a mistake.

No, it is not very accurate to call it an LGBT rights case, but since the case is about the permissible scope of a law that protects LGBT rights, it is not entirely inaccurate either.

Indeed, and since the case encompasses a law that infringes on, inter alia, religious rights, my description is "not entirely inaccurate," either--well said.

303 Creative is a freedom of speech chase, not a religious freedom case.

What kind of speech (or silence) are we talking about, here? Are you one of those people who pedantically interjects that the civil war was a state's rights issue, not a slavery issue?

For whatever it's worth, my choice of words there was deliberately poking at the number of people calling this an "LGBT rights case." Because of course the case is sufficiently about that, that it's not entirely inaccurate to characterize the case that way, and yet flip that rhetoric on its head and certain people are bound to get worked up...

You seem to think that 303 Creative was an enforcement action brought by the state of Colorado against the company.

Sorry to have given you that impression, but no--I've never thought that at all.

the whole issue of whether or not anyone asked for a wedding website is essentially a red herring

Yes, very good--this is why I found the CNN article, and its downstream effects on conversation in my vicinity, noteworthy.

And of the recent decisions, this is likely to be the only one with any effect. Harvard has already all but announced it'll use Roberts's talisman to get around the affirmative action decision. Biden has already announced he's going to work around the student loan decision AND smack "defect" as hard as he can on the deal which ended the payment moratorium.

This is my feeling as well (hence my opening comment about doubting the impact of most of this week's cases). What will limit the impact of this case, of course, is just the facts of commerce; most people are pretty happy to take money for whatever, and there are so many alternative cake bakers, web designers, etc. that the freedom to refuse service will generally amount the freedom to get out-competed.

There really does seem to be a bit of a gulf between enforcement on progressive versus conservative court victories. The Supreme Court enforces a novel approach to marriage and we start throwing political dissidents in jail. The Supreme Court says "stop discriminating by race, you can consider its impact in individual lives but you can't make it a determinative factor" and Harvard effectively flips them the bird and says "who's gonna make me?" Not that it would probably be great optics for the right, but can you imagine the president of Harvard going to jail for contempt of court here?

I honestly don't know what Roberts is playing at, in these cases. He seems to have managed to achieve results that are easy to report in maximally inflammatory ways, potentially imposing political costs on right-wing candidates, while failing to generate any rulings that seem likely to noticeably and impactfully protect the interests they purport to protect.

I'm not a lawyer, so maybe I'm missing something, but I'm not sure I see your point. The plaintiffs in Lawrence had a harm to bring a case over: they really were charged with sodomy.

To the extent that I have a point at all, it's that the jurisprudence of homosexuality--and perhaps, we might infer, many other things--is substantially fictive. I think many people are suspicious of forum shopping, fewer are aware of plaintiff shopping but people do seem to be a bit suspicious of that, too. Most people are aware of civil disobedience, though, and don't necessarily think of it as problematic, even though it does involve ginning up a case rather than addressing the law from a position of organic (so to speak) social interaction. I do think CNN's "just asking questions" article is too coy by half, but as I noted in another reply, I don't have any serious objections to how these cases turned out. Just--if you're (the general you, not you personally) going to raise doubts about one SCOTUS case based on its loose connection to real events, you might not like where that leads (or, more likely, you're just engaged in isolated demands for rigor).

That seems different from the claim that no gay marriage website was ever ordered, so the whole case was actually about a hypothetical harm

While I don't think SCOTUS mentioned the "chilling effects" doctrine in 303 Creative, the Court has long recognized that the law does actual, rather than hypothetical, harm in cases where the law is clearly intended to "eliminate disfavored ideas" (p. 25).

The New Yorker article says why they had to go with Lawrence & Garner

Except, of course, for the part where they did not "have to" go with anyone. The case need never have been filed; society would have continued to function, and likely legislation would have eventually been updated one way or another. Rather, they wanted a case--hence, plaintiff shopping.

Puzzlingly

I mean, given my point, it's not puzzling at all, is it? It's how activists function, by either finding or outright creating cases crafted to reach the legal result they're after.

Hah! This is an beautifully parsimonious take which absolutely should have occurred to me, and did not. Of course, the reason for the blindfold is commonly held to be that all are equal before the law, not judged by station or appearance. But it is my understanding that the blindfold was first added, in 1494, as satire, to suggest that Justia was blind to the injustices being committed by lawyers:

The first known image to show a blindfolded justice comes from a woodcut, possibly by Albrecht Dürer, published in Ship of Fools, a collection of satirical poems by fifteenth century lawyer Sebastian Brant. This 1494 image is not a celebration of blind justice, but a critique. A fool is applying the blindfold so that lawyers can play fast and loose with the truth.

It's a fun bit of trivia to share with students from time to time, but it honestly did not even occur to me that it might apply to my critique, here. I guess because I'm not entirely persuaded that these cases are really miscarriages of justice? I don't have any real problem with the outcomes of either case, despite my poking fun at Kennedy's writing style. More like--I'm just not persuaded that either case is as grounded in reality as we might naturally prefer our landmark cases to be?

It is very hard to read this and come away with the assumption...

I don't find it hard at all! This is literally an associate professor of law at Yale asserting "my reconstruction of events based on interviews long after the fact is more plausible than the story told by Lawrence and Garner themselves"--men who, as the New Yorker article notes, were specifically preferred by activists in part because they had "little to lose." Here's from the law review piece:

For Lawrence and Garner's version to be correct (separate rooms, no sex), all three deputies would have to be lying about whether Garner was in the living room. That is possible, but harder to accept than my version of events above...

Of course, I wasn't there, I don't know, maybe the professor is correct. But if so, then Lawrence and Garner (and by extension, their advocates) were lying to the Court anyway, which is kinda my original point, so... not sure what that gets you?

Lots of big Supreme Court decisions this week, all important in various ways--none, if you ask me, likely to be nearly as impactful as imagined by either their proponents or opponents. But I was struck by a particular take on the religious freedom in commerce case that I saw popping up in a few places today.

Colorado web designer told Supreme Court a man sought her services for his same-sex wedding. He says he didn’t – and he’s straight

Very roughly, here's the deal: American courts can only decide "cases and controversies." This is a procedural thing, basically you need a plaintiff who has actually been harmed in some cognizable way before you can file a lawsuit. Sometimes this means you need someone willing to engage in a little civil disobedience, breaking the law for the express purpose of getting prosecuted. "Plaintiff shopping" is something activist lawyers have been doing for centuries. But to layfolk this can look a little suspicious, in much the way that forum shopping can seem suspicious. In fact American law is mostly indifferent to this kind of gamesmanship, and in some cases we even regard it as a clever thing to do (at least, when our ingroup pulls it off).

The CNN story presents itself as a "just the facts" observation that--hey, here's a party to the facts of this case who claims he didn't do what the record says he did! Isn't that interesting? Gosh, how "concerning," he says! Nobody even thought to contact him in six years!

"I don’t necessarily think that would be a tipping point in this case at all, but at the very least … a case of this magnitude should be corroborated, should be fact checked along the way."

No one is saying this changes anything, oh, no! Just, isn't it suspicious? (Is that... winking I hear?) Well, regardless, Stewart is only identified by his first name; CNN was able to contact him "through information in court filings." Although, in another funny coincidence,

Stewart, who previously worked for CNN, said that he is a web designer himself...

Now, CNN is only a mid-sized comedy troupe, but it does rival some legitimate news organizations in size and scope. Still, what are the odds, huh?

I've got several friends in my social feeds sharing the story, now, making snide remarks about how Lorie Smith clearly ginned up this whole case out of nothing. Of course, the CNN story doesn't actually say that; it just reminds the reader how suspicious it is for a plaintiff to have, shall we say, gussied up their case.

But the point of this post is not to take the piss out of CNN. Rather, what struck me was one other remarkable coincidence. There is another incredibly famous LGB rights case from the Supreme Court in which the actual facts of the case are completely irrelevant to the holding: Lawrence v. Texas.

That link is to a New Yorker article called "Extreme Makeover." If you're not familiar with Lawrence v. Texas, this was the 2003 SCOTUS case in which Justice Kennedy declared that the government has no business telling you who you can have sex with, as long as it's consensual and you're in the privacy of your home. Much like the later Obergefell case, Kennedy's opinion in Lawrence is packed with paeans to the sanctity of love and the primacy of intimacy--so packed, indeed, that there is essentially no room for coherent legal analysis! But here's the crazy bit:

There was no gay sex in Lawrence. Indeed, there was no gay couple in Lawrence.

The plaintiffs were gay men, charged under Texas' anti-sodomy statute. If you haven't heard the story, you really must read the New Yorker article. But in short, Lawrence and Garner were not together, sexually or otherwise, before or after the case. But since they were the two charged under the anti-sodomy statute, and activist lawyers wanted a case to take to the Supreme Court...

Each of the legal experts who were subsequently brought into the case knew instantly that it could end up at the high court. The challenge would be in finding a story about love and personal dignity to tell about Lawrence and Garner.

And so:

High-powered lawyers would represent Lawrence and Garner, as long as they agreed to stop saying they weren’t guilty and instead entered a “no contest” plea. By doing so, the two were promised relative personal privacy, and given a chance to become a part of gay-civil-rights history. The cause was greater than the facts themselves. Lawrence and Garner understood that they were being asked to keep the dirty secret that there was no dirty secret.

That’s the punch line: the case that affirmed the right of gay couples to have consensual sex in private spaces seems to have involved two men who were neither a couple nor having sex. In order to appeal to the conservative Justices on the high court, the story of a booze-soaked quarrel was repackaged as a love story. Nobody had to know that the gay-rights case of the century was actually about three or four men getting drunk in front of a television in a Harris County apartment decorated with bad James Dean erotica.

Perhaps better court-watchers than myself had some idea of what was going on, but I did not know anything about any of this until the New Yorker article ran nine years later. Does it make any difference? Well, maybe it makes you suspicious. Maybe not. Maybe you're thinking, "hmm, isn't tu quoque an informal fallacy?" Well, I'm not really staking a claim either way. I don't like forum shopping, I don't like plaintiff shopping, but I don't think I have anything like a thoroughly-developed account of why--it's more like a general distaste for gamesmanship. But without gamesmanship, American jurisprudence might scarcely exist at all! So I don't know.

But taking CNN's "just asking questions" article at face value, it makes me wonder where all the real gay people are, and why we can't seem to get a gay rights case in front of SCOTUS with parties who aren't being puppeted, Chicago-style. Okay, that's a bit of hyperbole, but still, two points form a line. So long as Congress remains sufficiently split that impeachment and amendments are off the table, the Supreme Court is the last word on American law. Why bother with the democratic process, if you can convince five unelected and unaccountable moral busybodies to make the law instead? All it takes is a bit of theater, apparently.

It doesn't necessarily end well for the puppets, of course--from the New Yorker again:

At a press conference after the decision was announced, Lawrence read a brief prepared statement and Garner said nothing. Some advocates hoped that Garner might have a career as a gay-rights spokesman. After he gave a drunken speech at a black-tie dinner in the plaintiffs’ honor, that idea was scratched. The case is called Lawrence v. Texas. John Lawrence died last November [2011]. Almost no one took note. Garner died five years earlier, at the age of thirty-nine. When Lambda Legal proved unable to raise funds for a proper memorial or burial, Harris County cremated him and sent his ashes home to his family in a plastic bag. There was no funeral.

I don't know what the moral of the story is. Being disillusioned with the legal process is nothing new or insightful. But this was what occurred to me when I read the CNN piece, and saw people sharing it around as proof positive of the Court's perfidy. No, silly people, the Court is not fundamentally deceptive. The Court is always and altogether--albeit willfully, like a moviegoer whose suspension of disbelief is essential to the process, like a wrestling fan whose kayfabe is the lifeblood of the art form--deceived.

This is a great read, but it is unquestionably CW material--feel free to repost in the CW thread.

This is a pretty aggressive post toward what appears to be your outgroup, which I would probably let slide if it brought some light, but... it doesn't seem to do that. I'm actually confused as to what your policy positions even are on these matters, much less why you hold the positions you do. It's okay to criticize or complain but only in the context of substantial ideas. Just targeting a group to lambast them is insufficient here.

This looks like "boo outgroup" spit-balling to me, except for maybe the part where posting about it here is performative evidence that you might think of yourself as nerd. It's difficult to see in your account anything but a deliberate attempt to troll, so let's start the banning at one week.

He merely dropped the incrediblyinflammatory statement about "extraordinary circumstances" such as sex with animals and black men

See, no, this is not enough charity. This is putting words in someone's mouth. "OP" isn't who you were responding to, OP is one level up from that. OP mentioned interracial cuckoldry, and someone else responded with a comment about "BLACKED adjacent behavior" which you took to mean something inflammatory, but which in context of the OP could, charitably, be a reference to the aforementioned interracial cuckoldry (which the brand BLACKED apparently famously produces, albeit not exclusively, which fact I am somewhat annoyed you have now made me research to be sure).

And here's the thing--maybe you're right! But the level of confidence, indeed insistence you're bringing to bear here is evidence of inadequate charity. No one actually said "having sex with black people is, or is like, bestiality," only that "BLACKED adjacent behavior" (contextually potentially a reference to interracial cuckoldry) was an extreme case, as is bestiality. Where someone does not make an explicitly inflammatory claim, context matters, and your earlier response to me suggests you were either ignorant of or ignoring that context.

Doubling down here with bad takes on the of meaning of charity does not help you. Don't lecture me about "actual simple and clear" statements when you are forced to repeatedly reword what was actually said in order to support your umbrage.

I don't recall them discussing racial insecurity somewhere else in this thread.

This seems like a reading problem, then. From the OP (to which the person you were responding was directly responding):

Racial dynamics add to this swirl. The common case is a white man watching a white woman fuck a black man (with a large penis). This fantasy props up so much there are entire porn sites based on this concept, and plenty of alt-right fanfiction about it. Racial insecurity.

(Emphasis added.) As for this:

"Blacked" porn isn't cuckold porn. It's just interracial porn with a black guy.

This may be a fair criticism; I admit that I did not go check on the exact nature of "Blacked," and will simply take your word for it here. But if "Blacked" porn includes any interracial cuckolding porn at all, then I think your interpretation still fails the charity test in this case.

This comment has accrued enough user reports for "antagonism" that I feel like I have to say something, but I admit I'm torn. What you've written is blunt enough that it could probably do with less heat, but you are answering a direct question in a clear, honest, and direct way, demonstrating good adherence to the "speak plainly" rule. But you have accrued several warnings and a ban in the last six months, which weighs against you here and increases my suspicion that you are pressing on boundaries just to see what you can get away with.

On balance, I'm issuing you a warning, but at the same time I think it would be fair to note that if a regular user with a couple of AAQCs had posted this exact comment, I would probably let it slide. Please work on making comments that are far from the edge, before seeing how close you can get to it.

That's unfortunate. I don't suppose you have any idea why? It looks like the whole substack has been wiped, but I guess I don't know for sure that there was anything else on it to begin with.

This adds nothing to the conversation--just takes a dig at the Motte. Don't forget, you're not stuck in traffic, you are traffic.

Having sex with animals or black people. You know, comparable examples of "extraordinary" deviance.

This is uncharitable. OP discusses "racial insecurity" as a factor in interracial cuckolding and @Sloot's comment can easily be read as a callback to that. Cuckolding and bestiality are both examples of fairly extraordinary deviance from baseline human sexual behavior, as far as I know. Jumping straight to "this must be racism" is all heat and no light. Don't do this.

The rules require that you respond to what was actually said before arguing something else. In particular, this means that putting words into people's mouths is not really allowed, even when you frame that move as a question. This is low effort, don't do this.

This is all heat and no light. Your AAQCs and history obviously get you a lot of leeway, but come on. You just came off a five day ban, so I feel like I can't possibly give you any less than that here.

knowing that children receive musical training says relatively little about their specific pitch training

While I acknowledge that these are separable, in practice I would be very surprised to meet a child with pitch training who lacked musical training, while all musical training contains at least some passive pitch training (hearing and naming notes, even if not for specific purposes of pitch training). Everyone I know who has AP actually discovered that they had AP, without ever deliberately developing it--they were just musically trained as children, and one day learned they could do something that others could not. (This is often the case with children--they typical-mind so strongly that they often don't even realize they have special abilities, or disabilities, like poor vision or hearing.)

So limiting the sample in this case to musically-trained children is, I think, a way of making the strongest case for "lots of people can do this." In the general population absolute pitch seems pretty rare. This study suggests that estimates of AP prevalence should be revised dramatically upward--to 4%. (It also may be linked in some way to autism.)

It’s an understudied, underutilized training process, since people have broadly treated it as a mysterious divine gift rather than a specific, trained skill.

Well, again--if we could just put some children into Skinner boxes... Seriously, though, as with all the gifts of childhood, the nature/nurture debate is difficult to navigate given that most children are not raised in especially intentional ways. APs prevalence in musically trained children versus children without such training clearly suggests, to my mind, that it is in fact a skill--kinda.

But mostly I just think people should move from completely ignoring it to studying it enough that we know how prevalent it can be

I agree, but I think part of what prevents this from happening, aside from the fact that many children receive no deliberate education prior to showing up at preschool, is that absolute pitch is a surprisingly low-utility ability, far less useful than, say, color vision. I once had a long conversation with a friend of mine about trying to leverage his AP into a mnemonic device, or a career in some kind of audio production, and his position was that it was mostly just a party trick--but also often annoying, because he notices when people transpose his favorite songs into different keys, and finds it jarring. I may have been a bit maudlin about how cool it was that he could literally enjoy music on a level that was beyond my ability, and he was like--eh, I guess. Even my piano tuner said, "it might be useful if we didn't have tuning machines... but we do."

Possibly my friend and I are just insufficiently inventive! But I have yet to actually meet someone with AP who finds it nearly as amazing and interesting a subject as I find it to be.

Absolute pitch is a fascinating example of a phenomenon that is grounded in nature but dependent on nurture. Some people are substantially tone deaf, in the way that some people are color blind--they can't really differentiate pitches to the same degree as most of us. But many people who are technically "wired" for absolute pitch will not develop it, because they don't receive sufficient musical training--at minimum, you need some words (whether note names, or solfège as in the article) to attach to certain pitches.

(As an aside, I think it would be fascinating to do a study on the extent to which it is possible for people with AP to distinguish frequencies outside the chromatic scale, but I'm not sure how this could be thoroughly accomplished without deliberately training a child to names the sounds they hear as frequencies instead of notes, and just this moment I don't have a baby I can put into a Skinner box...)

I do wonder if

This is something possible for almost everyone during a narrow window of time

is stating matters too strongly; while it is true that speakers of tonal languages are substantially more likely to exhibit AP, even among musically trained children it's not really an "almost everyone" thing:

For students who had begun musical training between ages 4 and 5, approximately 60 percent of the Chinese speakers tested as having perfect pitch, while only about 14 percent of the U.S. nontone language speakers did. For those who had begun training between 6 and 7, approximately 55 percent of the Chinese and 6 percent of the U.S. met the criterion. And for those beginning between 8 and 9, the figures were 42 percent of the Chinese and zero of the U.S. group.

Although:

The discrepancies were greater when the researchers allowed for semitone errors (that is, giving the subjects credit for a note missed by a half-note, or answering "C" for "C sharp"): Fully 74 percent of the Chinese students had perfect pitch if they had started musical training between ages 4 and 5.

There is also a human biodiversity question, here: does AP confer evolutionary advantage in cultures with tonal languages? Would a white or black baby adopted by Chinese parents be equally likely to develop AP as their own biological child?

Along these same lines: I could discuss the phenomenon of human tetrachromacy all day long, but I imagine this would be much more difficult, perhaps impossible, to teach. The idea that there are people out there whose sensorium literally grasps the world more keenly than my own would probably induce excruciating envy if I weren't just so delighted to know about the phenomenon. It is a special kind of genius, in the most ancient sense of a "'tutelary or moral spirit' who guides and governs an individual through life."

Except that the spirit of AP requires some care and feeding if it is to genuinely blossom. Humans are the coolest.

This is a pretty bad post. I probably would not have approved it, had I been the one at the queue.

It's not quite so culture-warry that I want to say "it belongs in the CW thread," though maybe that would be the best approach. Mostly it's just too much heat, and absolutely no light whatsoever. It's "boo outgroup" except it's written in a way that suggests to me this isn't really your outgroup, so, I don't know. I'm going to go with "don't post like this, please" and hope I don't have to ban you later to make that happen.

Ted Kaczynski's reign of terror is not commonly fodder for jokes.

Er... it really is, though. It really, truly is. Though I suppose even in 1996 some people wondered about the propriety of such things.

Humor is often off the table here at the Motte because so many standard approaches to humor violate our discussion standards in one way or another. But particularly in the Friday Fun thread, I think the principle of charity is especially important in connection with attempts at humor.

This is the Friday Fun thread. This degree of aggressiveness would be out of place even in the CW thread. Knock it off.

I'm not necessarily criticizing this ban, but what's the justification behind this? Why does it matter if something insightful came from a user here or from an outside thinker (assuming the poster agrees with what they're sharing)?

Is the idea that this is a way to prevent spamming, by raising the required time commitment to make a top-level post?

It's bound up in a long history of wrangling with "bare links" and otherwise low-effort content. At the extreme, a user could sock-puppet as a way of skirting the rules of engagement. Like, suppose you write a really scathing takedown of your outgroup. Post it here, maybe you get moderated. Post it on Substack and then share it here, though, maybe you don't, depending on how transparent your effort to circumvent the rules of engagement is.

This is not a common problem, by the by, but it is definitely something that has happened in the past. And the foundation of the whole enterprise is that we're here to discuss things, to test our own shady thinking in a community of people who don't all agree with our views. "Here's a thing for you all to discuss" is not quite the same thing as actually participating in a discussion, and can very easily be trolling/bait/etc. So copy-pasting large chunks of text while providing minimal insight of your own doesn't really reach the necessary level. If someone outside the sub says something insightful, sharing it here is fine--even as a top post, if it's not CW. But if it's a picture, or video, or Culture War material, then we are looking for submission statements and effortful engagement.