@naraburns's banner p

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

				

User ID: 100

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 100

Yes, we should leave it at that, because, yet again, you have failed to explain why this one specific numerical minority must be protected from "mob rule" and others don't

What reason would I have to explain that? I have explicitly stated my position upthread that rural voters are not the only "numerical minority" that must be protected from mob rule. Let's have a look at just one recent example:

And, there are lots of groups in the numerical minority; bookkeepers are a minority of voters; do they get a veto?

Well, yes!

Where I said "I should probably leave it at that" in my previous post, I first deleted a paragraph where I laid out an argument that you are either being disingenuous, or have a serious reading comprehension issue. Then I thought--no, that's too much heat, not enough light, I'm just going to drop it.

With this comment, though, I just don't see any totally non-antagonistic way to describe your persistent and repeated mischaracterization of my view. I get that the thread is unwieldy, and you and I are both getting a lot of comments from a variety of people. So I want to be charitable about this, but like--if you're going to whine that I've "failed to explain" some position, you should probably be pretty confident that it's my actual position, and not a position I have repeatedly stated that I do not hold, right here in this thread! But no--here you are, arguing against some imaginary version of me you've concocted in your head.

Speaking of which--

I am willing to bet that I am far more opposed to mob rule than you are, because I have never seen you stand up for the rights of those you disagree with, which is something I do routinely.

If there were any plausible way to take that bet, I'd certainly do so--not least because I'd be shocked if you could personally identify the class of "people I disagree with" to even 50% accuracy. Conversely, I would not deign to comment on how often you stand up for the rights of people you disagree with, because I don't know you, and it would be idiotic to think that just because someone is (say) colossally disingenuous and reliably partisan in an online forum, that must be their whole personality.

Furthermore, probably most of us are bad at tracking good deeds, unless they are really substantial. My honest inclination is to say "I've never seen you actually demonstrate real care about civil liberties in ways that might undermine your apparent politics," but the truth is, if I had seen you do that, I probably wouldn't remember. There are too many users here for me to reliably remember each one's quirks and hangups, so I try to just approach every discussion with fresh eyes. Still, for whatever it's worth: you've never given me the impression that you are the tiniest bit interested in defending civil liberties in any broadly principled way.

This is far more suited to the Small Questions thread, which does technically allow CW-adjacent stuff.

Many people here get really fucking cringe ... Just a palpable sense of barely disguised seething towards women from some commenters.

Unnecessarily antagonistic. If you have something constructive to add to the conversation, do! Calling other users "cringe" does not contribute, and violates our rules of engagement. In my experience, rarely does the word "cringe" even get deployed outside of naked signaling. Aim for substance instead.

I don't care, and you shouldn't either. At least not here, in the Culture War thread, made for talking about the Culture War.

This is unnecessarily antagonistic. Under the circumstances, the rule corralling human biodiversity (including sex differences) and sexual harassment into the CW thread makes this an appropriate place to raise the discussion, given OP's stated belief that

This will be used as an excuse for some weirdo on the edge of sanity to stalk you.

If a topic doesn't interest you, that is a good time to practice the virtue of silence. But contrary to your claims, you seem to actually in fact care about these discussions--at least enough to complain about them.

This is the culture war thread, so the potential for any given conversation to "devolve, immediately" is always quite high. That's why we have the engagement rules that we have. Please adhere to them.

I have asked what is so special about a particular minority -- rural voters -- that they have a right to be given extra votes and a veto, as was the case in the past.

Calling them "extra votes and a veto, as was the case in the past" continues to beg the question, as you have done from the moment you joined this conversation. They weren't "extra" votes, it was the way the system was set up to protect certain minority interests from mob rule. If you prefer mob rule, like--I doubt I'm in any position to talk you out of that.

Most of what you're writing now suggests that you are either unwilling or unable to understand the answers I've already given you, so I should probably just leave it at that.

So, you are literally advocating that every numerical minority -- bookkeepers, etc; heck, even every individual! -- get veto power over legislation?

Well, in a way.

Meaning that no law ever gets passed?

Why should it mean that? Laws do pass unanimously in the House and Senate from time to time, and if we were voting on very basic matters I think we could often generate consent--especially if we limited citizenship to people who could pass a test of reasoning. Anyway I don't believe in direct democracy but so long as you have robust property and personal rights protected by a minimal government, a single person or group's decision to not participate in this or that regulatory scheme doesn't seem worth getting worked up about.

I am pretty sure that that is not what the framers had had in mind.

Well, probably not all of them. But some of them do seem to have felt approximately as I do. The "Great Compromise" is, I remind you, the best evidence we have available that, whatever else they believed, the Framers did not think "one man, one vote" was going to work for the United States.

Black and Hispanic districts are the same size as other districts, right? So, why should rural districts be an exception.

Black and Hispanic districts are created specifically to maximize Black and Hispanic impact. It's harder to do this with rural districts primarily because the sheer size of cities makes giving equal power to rural voters basically impossible under "one man, one vote."

That's an odd claim for someone who is arguing that urban voters should be the political slaves of rural America. I have yet to see a principled statement of why that should be the case.

Now you're just being pointlessly absurd. Nothing I have said implies that urban voters should be the political slaves of rural America. You're the only person here arguing that a certain minority deserves to be coerced because it is a minority. I think the Great Compromise was an interesting move. A bicameral legislature, with one house apportioned by population and one apportioned by geography, seems like a very functional resolution. It was so brilliant that many states copied the move with their own state legislatures--until the Warren court attacked.

So, if you are starting from the premise that there are any government actions from which "everyone benefits," your argument rests on rotten foundations.

This is bullshit. Laws against murder, rape, arson, theft, etc. are all to the benefit of everyone. Even a stable monetary system is arguably to the benefit of everyone. I see no need to pander to the last standing contrarian; people who don't want to participate in the government should be afforded maximum opportunity to do that, for example through aforementioned strong protection of individual and property rights. We live under an absolutely outrageous amount of regulation and government bloat today. None of it is necessary. Most of it is actively harmful to many while being slightly beneficial to a select few. There is nothing just about that; there is certainly nothing constitutional about it.

Is outlawing theft discrimination against those who want to steal?

Laws against theft protect everyone against theft. I have never yet met a thief who was happy to be stolen from.

If enough people wanted to be rural then they could be.

Sure, in theory. What do you think this shows?

If rural voters get a veto then urban voters should get a veto and suburban voters, and criminal voters and car salesmen voters and Appalachians and Cajuns and so on and so on.

As I note to gdanning below: yes. And not just groups of people, but individuals, too. The vast majority of governance is both unnecessary and coercive.

Only if, and because, they are the majority. Not because they are given extra votes due to their status.

"The majority gets to do those things because they are the majority" is not an explanation, it's you repeating the premise. It's certainly not a constitutional principle. If anything, it violates the constitutional edict that the federal government ensure a republican form of government in each individual state. Republican governments have never in history been "one man, one vote" until the Warren court said so.

And, there are lots of groups in the numerical minority; bookkeepers are a minority of voters; do they get a veto?

Well, yes! This is the true spirit of "equal protection." The end result is intensely libertarian, which is how it should be. The only time the government should act at all is when, by so doing, everyone benefits. Otherwise government is just a grand, complicated exercise in "who, whom."

Did you think this was some kind of persuasive "gotcha?" Here's Ayn Rand:

The smallest minority on earth is the individual. Those who deny individual rights, cannot claim to be defenders of minorities. The defense of minority rights is acclaimed today, virtually by everyone, as a moral principle of a high order.

I'm very much on board with this. Today the Court just picks-and-chooses minorities for special legal protection. Rural voters are out, black voters are in. Mormons are out, Muslims are in. Asians are out, "indigenous peoples" are in. This is legal bullshit of the highest order, a complete abandonment of the rule of law.

We don't give any of those groups a veto, or an extra vote.

Like hell we don't. Black and Hispanic voting districts are a thing, and redistricting in race-neutral ways draws all kinds of ire. Nobody gets to thumb the scales in similar ways for politically disfavored minorities.

Again, what is so special about rural voters that they should be given a veto, if none of the other 10,000 numerical minorities don't?

I haven't said anything about denying anyone a veto--remember, that's your (inconsistent) position. I'm the one defending minority rights here. If you want to come over to my side and have a chat about who else should also get a veto, I'm definitely open to that! But you don't actually seem inclined to do that--you seem instead to simply be grasping for any possible reason to defend the idea that rural voters are just the natural and appropriate political slaves of urban America.

What reason would they have to use a veto power on anything else?

Are you kidding? Anything that they think does not serve their interests,

Why should they be forced to go along with laws that don't serve their interests? The only reason available under "one man, one vote" appears to be "because they are in the minority, so too bad for them." How much more purposeful could discrimination possibly get, than to say "you get no benefit from this law, for no reason than because the majority is able to require that of you?"

or anything that they think might harm them (including anything that happens to have an adverse impact)

Again--what protection do they have against the majority, then? If rural voters think something harms them, under "one man, one vote" that's just too fucking bad. "One man, one vote" is all by itself purposeful discrimination against rural voters, implemented by a court that was clearly dedicated to its own social engineering projects over and above any constitutional principles.

or any culture war issue, for that matter

Yes, exactly. Rural voters having culture war issues dictated to them by urban voters was in practice, I think, the point of "one man, one vote." It was purposeful discrimination from the word go.

Or, any project that did not benefit them as much as they wanted. Or any budget that did not fund some useless pork in rural areas. Etc, etc, etc.

You haven't listed a single reason that doesn't sound like intentional discrimination against a minority, because they are a minority. Urban voters can veto any project that does not benefit them as much as they want. Urban voters can veto any budget that does not fund some useless pork in cities (like, say, the whole NEH). Etc. Etc. Why shouldn't rural voters have the same power? Ah, yes--because they are the minority. That is literally all "one man, one vote" means: mob rule at the state level. I have a hard time imagining more purposeful discrimination against rural voters.

why are you advocating for rural voters to never have a veto over ANY legislation, even legislation that intentionally discriminates against them?

I'm not.

If you agree with "one man, one vote" then actually yes--you are.

If you are arguing that the standard under the EP clause should be higher -- eg, that rural residency should be a quasi-suspect or suspect classification, fine. But you are arguing for something much, much broader: For a certain group to have an absolute veto over ALL legislation.

In fact I think the vast majority of legislation is totally illegitimate under a plain reading of the U.S. Constitution. That's kind of the theme of this discussion, though it was not my original intention: that 20th century jurisprudence basically threw the constitutional order out the window, substantially in favor of sweeping and often disastrous social engineering projects.

Then it sounds like you don't have an example

I just gave you all the examples. I can't tell whether you're being deliberately obtuse in hopes of setting some rhetorical trap, or whether I have mistakenly attributed to you a substantial knowledge of the law that you don't actually possess. (For some reason I thought you were a lawyer, but now I'm thinking I must be mistaken about that. If so, my apologies!)

You are advocating for giving rural voters veto power over ALL legislation, not the tiny minority of legislation that intentionally discriminates against them

What reason would they have to use a veto power on anything else?

Or maybe more importantly--why are you advocating for rural voters to never have a veto over ANY legislation, even legislation that intentionally discriminates against them? Because that is clearly the result of "one man, one vote."

The case law on redistricting studiously avoids recognizing that the problem with "one man, one vote" is exactly the problem the Framers recognized when reaching the Great Compromise. Urban and rural populations have different interests. Majority rule is mob rule. Protecting minority interests by creating a bicameral legislature with separate apportionment rules, instituting the electoral college, implementing an independent judiciary, etc. are all moves aimed at preventing "one man, one vote" from being the law of the land.

Then I assume you have an example?

Every single "strict scrutiny" case overturning state legislation grounded in a "suspect classification" is a concrete and often explicit example of a protected minority being given veto power over state legislation.

Is there some other "protected minority" that is given veto power over state legislation?

That's Fourteenth Amendment jurisprudence in a nutshell.

I can only think of the NRA and possibly the 17th amendment which committed such violence to the constitutional scheme.

Not Marbury v. Madison? (Kidding, kind of.)

But relatedly, the Civil Rights Act was just the legislative prong; I would argue that the Warren court overall did far greater violence to American liberty than any specific act of Congress. In particular, "one man one vote" via Baker v. Carr (1962) and Reynolds v. Sims (1964) stripped "protected minority" status from rural Americans, in effect ensuring that the United States would eventually follow the same trajectory as every other urban-centered empire in history. When your cities are packed with low-agency wards of the state who can vote themselves unlimited quantities of free grain, keeping the lights on becomes an increasingly fraught undertaking.

Don't sleep on this excellent Caplan piece. The man is a national treasure.

In "Lawsuits are the Hitman of the State," Caplan makes the case that the Texas "Heartbeat Act" is functionally equivalent to workplace discrimination laws that punish racist or sexist remarks.

(One thing I would be interested to see further discussion from Caplan on is the development of the idea that having a "job" is a "right," but he doesn't go into that in this piece. Basically, the Constitution is a document of enumerated powers, meaning the federal government can't--in theory--do anything the Constitution doesn't explicitly allow it to do. But the judicially-crafted breadth of the Fourteenth Amendment, combined with loose interpretation of the Commerce and Tax-and-Spend clauses, metastasized through the 20th century into today's rather grabby American legal system. This has given rise to the idea that you haven't just got a right to your own labor, but that you have a right to personally profit from other people's capital, at their expense, even if you contribute nothing of value to the enterprise.)

Something I really like about Caplan is how concise he manages to be while making absolutely cutting points:

The government starts with the blatantly illegal goal of banning “bigots from expressing their opinions in a way that abuses or offends their co-workers.” Then instead of respecting those limits, the government’s judicial branch gets creative: “Murder’s illegal? Fine, we’ll hire hitmen instead.” By affirming liability, it dangles piles of cash in front of potential plaintiffs to terrorize employers into banning what the government, legally, must allow.

Precedent on what counts as "government action" is remarkably unhelpful in understanding these things. Georgia v. McCollum (1992) is all about how a defendant in voir dire acts as an organ of the state when they select their own jury, and therefore are forbidden from considering race when seeking to exclude potential jurors. This, even though in virtually every other regard, as Justice O'Connor then noted, "our [past] decisions specifically establish that criminal defendants and their lawyers are not government actors when they perform traditional trial functions." Whether any particular action counts as "government action" proscribed by the Fourteenth Amendment does not seem to depend at all on who actually took the action, in other words, but only on how the Court wants the case to come out.

So I think Caplan is dead on, here--the Civil Rights movement basically shredded any kind of principled interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment, in pursuit of socially-engineered results.

That video is terrible, which is a shame because it is also a "good" video. It's such a firehose of information (some of which is actually worth knowing!).

Speak plainly and with effort, please.

Do not weakman in order to show how bad a group is. Surely you can think of some reasons in favor of a Jewish nation that aren't on the level of cartoon villainy? Or you could provide evidence of self-identified Zionists calling for cheaper oil through political destabilization?

In short, don't post like this.

i think there is a lot of information missing before I can come to the conclusion of "of course he would shoot up the school".

Well, OP's suggestion was:

being forced by the state to spend eight hours a day at a containment center run by a bunch of glorified babysitters

And the conclusion was not "of course"--the conclusion was "I understand."

Do you find stories of prison violence extraordinary? Do you think prison violence is an inescapable fact about imprisonment? You might object that schools are meaningfully distinct from prisons, but if you've never encountered comparisons between schools and prisons before, well, now you have--and I assure you that they are common comparisons. You might say "schools are meant to benefit children" but prisons are arguably meant to benefit criminals (through rehabilitation). You might say "school is not so unpleasant as to justify murder" and I'd say that's true! But no one in this thread has yet said "murder is justified." Only explained one thing that might drive a person to commit murder.

And sure, OP could have said more about it, but the difficulty there is, the more you say about it, the more it sounds like you are trying to claim that the violence is justified, rather than claiming that it is understandable. I didn't mind going to school as a child, but I undertstand that many people find the experience absolutely torturous.

Thoughts? Holes in logic? Did I assume too much?

Maybe you said too little? I was very confused by this post until I saw your comment below adding context. But even then, your question is a bit confusing--"if you believe in X-risk, why have a child" is a non sequitur (at best, I think). You pack a lot of antagonism into a pretty small space, too--I don't think Eliezer or Aella are likely to spend much time around here, but either (A) you are in their social orbit and so you're assuming too much about what your audience actually knows and agrees upon, or (B) you are not in their social orbit, and are drawing various unflattering conclusions about their lives and motivations from dubious parasocial sources like Twitter.

"If you believe in X-risk, why have a child" might be a question worth discussing, assuming you provide at minimum some detailed discussion of the argument behind the question, but then the Eliezer/Aella stuff is not the focus and thus should not consume the bulk of your post. On the other hand, there are surely reasonable discussions to be had about Eliezer and/or Aella, but then you'd need to be quite a bit more charitable toward them.

Hopefully that helps.

Do you have any sense of when this might have occurred? The Smollett hoax happened in January 2019, before I was a moderator in the sub. Your first ban from the Motte was in June 2019 on an unrelated comment. Your next ban from the Motte was in May of 2020, then June, July, November, December--still no Smollett comments in the log on those.

I can't speak to your bans from /r/SSC, and it's always possible something got left out of the log! And Darwin2500 has a particularly infuriating gift for baiting people into crossing the line. But if you did eat a ban for a Smollett comment in the Motte, it would be interesting to see the context of that, I think.

EDIT: Thanks to @gattsuru for finding the link--looks like it was indeed /r/SSC, not the Motte--and it looks like a warning rather than a ban, but that is not entirely clear to me.

This comment has received at least three reports, with some commenters saying they've reported this comment.

I am responding with a modhat to remind the reporters that this is a forum for testing shady thinking, which means that by default even shady thinking is allowed. While concrete threats of violence are in many instances illegal and would in any event violate our ruleset (at minimum by excluding the targets of such threats from the discussion), opinions regarding what might arguably justify violence are not the same as threats of violence.

From the reports, @Goodguy stands accused of being "pro shooting up schools" and sounding "really unhinged." From @NolanE's comment on the other reported comment:

It seems to justify school shootings (including young children) because of workplace toxicity.

But this is uncharitable and suggests an aversion to thinking charitably about the motives of violent people, which--if we actually want to prevent school shootings, or even threats of school shootings--it might be helpful for us to think about clearly and accurately. @Goodguy says that violence is "not necessarily a good reaction" but an "understandable" one. This is supported with a characterization of public education that many people disagree with (some, here in the comments), but not one that is presented as the only or even the correct perspective. Nothing about this comment "justifies" school shootings--only attempts to explain them.

There is a famous story about John Adams defending British soldiers in the Boston Massacre trials. It has become the center of essays, books, television productions... Adams does not seem to have even been excessively sympathetic toward the soldiers, though he was certainly accused of such sympathies. Rather, he just regarded it as an injustice for the soldiers to go to trial unrepresented, and he had some rational doubts about the stories he was hearing. In the end, many of the soldiers were actually acquitted, because there was good evidence that they weren't involved or at fault, but this evidence would not have come to light had public opinion prevailed and the soldiers simply been lynched. Still, there were some people who continued to regard Jon Adams as "pro shooting up Americans" as a result.

In hopes of throwing reporters a bit of a bone, I want to say something like "@Goodguy's comment could be higher effort," but even that I think would not be quite right. If @Goodguy had written a higher-effort version of this comment, I think it would only have strengthened the objections; the comment as written does not excuse or defend school shootings, only explains (some of) them in a way that could potentially be probative of root causes. That it does so succinctly helps, rhetorically, to strengthen the idea that shooters are not being defended as, well, the "good guys"--just as humans responding to an arguably coercive environment.

If anyone using this website ever turns out to commit a serious crime, I will be very sad about that! But I'm not going to moderate people for trying to understand violence, on grounds that understanding violence might lead to violence. Because I think the opposite is at least as likely to be true--that honest attempts to understand violence could help us to prevent it.

Note, this applies to parts of the right as well, I think.

I agree.

The further you can go, and get away with if not outright cheered and supported the more pressure it puts on people to adopt your views/join your group.

Right. One of the things I'm thinking about in connection with this case is just... weaponized rage, I guess. Jones is, for whatever reason, a bottomless well of rage, and my instinct is to respond by not talking about her, or others like her. To exercise the virtue of silence, to pursue the ideal embodied in the rules about focusing on the best ideas of those with whom I disagree. But it seems like this might also be a kind of trap, where one side's "righteous anger" is always a straight-faced headline while the other side's "unhinged paranoia" gets a laugh track on the Daily Show.

Meanwhile, there is a victim in this: a child, not yet a teenager, who apparently finds life so burdensome as to plot mass murder, or at least to pretend that he is. Kids say stupid stuff, and I'd like us not to ruin their lives over it. But also, it kind of seems like his mother has already ruined him, in great measure, by being an avatar of the culture wars. Can we talk about that tragedy--and I do think it is a tragedy!--without careening off the culture war angles? I honestly just don't know.

When The Motte was on Reddit, there was a post about women possibly having a... personalised... take on what they experience relative to reality. Was the post-author... you? A childhood magazine was involved, I believe, and AOC was invoked (not in the magazine, but the comment/post, or maybe in the replies).

That doesn't ring any bells, but if you recall sufficient detail to dredge it up I'd be interested to see it. By "childhood magazine" are you talking, like... Highlights for Children? Teen Vogue? I'm struggling to even think of concrete examples of "childhood magazines" so if I ever wrote a post about one I'd be surprised!

Which WhiningCoil post are you talking about? CTRL-F for "knuckl" doesn't give me hits on two pages of user history. Nevermind, found it.

Have you seen any links to the alleged meme?

Jones posted it. It's a fat police officer with the caption "cops in their car waiting for the school shooter to kill himself so they can go in." But the point is that the meme was not the problem, the threats were the problem.

Fifteen minutes ago Jones tweeted:

They took him away for sharing memes because he has a target on his back because I bested that short basturd who wants to be president. They kidnapped him, because that's what they do in Florida. Steal your children as political punishment.

And look at the trolls happy about it

So she continues to maintain that this is about a meme in the face of overwhelming evidence against that claim. (The idea that she "bested" DeSantis is also just... wild. He won re-election with almost 60% of the vote.)

There are rules. Speaking of which... There are definitely better ones to talk about. This is awfully close to the platonic ideal of “look what those people did.”

Did you notice me lampshade this at the beginning of my post? How about the tightrope metaphor? Was I too subtle? I did try to note that there are similarly bizarre figures on the "other side" (with the caveat that they seem to get less vocal support from rank-and-file conservatives; even Santos and Greene take flak from Fox News, do not enjoy the support of default subreddits, etc.). I do think this is an interesting case study for the idea that white liberals are more likely to have mental problems. I don't think Jones is the "best" of what the left has to offer! What catches my attention, though, is the apparently large numbers of leftists who apparently believe that she is, including, apparently, the Miami Herald. That's interesting to me, in ways that Jones herself really isn't.

Can someone explain how the term egregore is understood on this site?

Like this, approximately. "A non-physical entity that arises from the collective thoughts of a distinct group of people" can refer to a literal deity in occult terms, but it could also refer to constructed unities like "England" or "the economy." Usually when people talk about egregores here, they're talking about Moloch, the egregore that emerges from inadequate social equilibria.