@omw_68's banner p

omw_68


				

				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 08 10:28:31 UTC

				

User ID: 1014

omw_68


				
				
				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 08 10:28:31 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1014

Marine Le Pen couldn't hope for a better piece of propaganda than gangs of immigrant youths torching beautiful French buildings. If the left is behind this, it's a pretty stupid move.

I would say it depends on how the media spins it. Really terrible things can be great PR if spun the right way. Surely there will be videos of French riot police beating people up.

Come to think of it, I've consumed a lot of media about this topic, and for some reason I think this is the first time I've seen John Henry brought up. Even though it's kind of the obvious parable...?

I would guess that over the years, the legend of John Henry has become more of a racial thing than a man vs. machine thing. Which is really a shame in my opinion, because I think his value as a folk hero vastly outweighs his significance as a black person.

Obviously the hard left in France strongly encouraged the protests that led to these riot

It's not obvious to me. But then again, I haven't been following the situation in France.

But the old white left in these countries largely doesn’t really understand the migrant underclass.

I think the most charitable interpretation is that they see the right as a huge and immediate threat. As basically Nazis at the gates. From that perspective it makes sense to ally oneself with Muslims.

I thought that was the mainstream consensus. Why would that idea make you paranoid?

I'm not following the situation in France carefully.

Probably I am paranoid, but I strongly suspect that these types of riots (and also the BLM riots in the US) are organized and stoked by the Left. To be sure, they are playing with fire, but I don't see this as the next step in an Islamic takeover.

The centaur era in chess lasted for about a decade. But after about 2014, human involvement could only make chess engines worse.

Yeah, I was about to bring up this analogy. For now, even assuming that all these AI math proofs are correct, you still need humans involved to interpret, check, and explain. And to some extent, to pose interesting problems for the AIs. But it's hard to see this lasting.

For some it’s also “useless” like art: they want to understand and explain to others because they find the logic beautiful (in the exact same way artists find art beautiful).

I agree, but here's what I said in another post:

FWIW I have a professional physicist in my family and he is pretty much resigned to the idea of studying physics out of love for learning more about the way the universe works. Which I guess is a good attitude, but if it were me I would be kind of disappointed if I suddenly had effectively no chance of discovering and publicizing something significant. Because the AI is going to beat me to the punch.

And if AI obsoletes most human labor, why not keep paying them for that?

Fundamentally there is no reason not to. It's probably better to be the subsidized artist in your scenario than to be flat out unemployed. But still, I would feel pretty bad about the whole situation.

I myself started a business a few years back based on a creative idea I had had. I put the business together, worked on it night and day, encountered reasonable success, and ultimately sold for a good deal of money. It was a really nice experience to turn my ideas into a reality which the free market rewarded. It was also nice to earn the respect of my peers. Being a subsidized artist would be okay, but for me it wouldn't be the same.

This is true. But not because they haven't been obsoleted. They have. Rather because most of them work in industries that do not generally fire useless people.

There's still the problem that a lot of people don't like to feel useless. Of course I am aware that lots of people work BS jobs where they do essentially nothing but genuinely believe (at least to some extent) that they are important and valuable. But I think that most non-DEI math professors take genuine pride in the skills that they have developed over the years and feel genuinely bad about the fact that they are staring obsolescence in the face.

Anyway, I'm not a mathematician but that's how I basically feel. I'm reasonably good at what I do and I enjoy the satisfaction of solving a challenging problem and the respect I get when I do so. It makes me sad that very likely it's about to go away.