self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
I've only been a mod since the migration to this site, but my personal experience doesn't match yours. My impression is that things are as they were, though I understand better what an uphill task moderation can be by virtue of being one.
As @roystgnr notes, even a small forum like this is too large for a small team of moderators (unpaid! working out of the kindness of their hearts!) to catch violations by reading every single comment. I'm too gainfully-employed to manage these days, and there was a time when I read every single comment posted.
We rely heavily on reports and user sentiment.
We also have rules that need a lot of subjective interpretation at times. This can be taxing, especially when we usually try to give substantive explanations for moderation actions instead of "get rekt". Mostly. Paradoxically, more minor and subtle violations demand more from us than gross ones. The average user isn't seeing the blatant spam.
All well and good, can't fault that.
Yet I must note that you accuse me of some kind of misunderstanding, and have yet to clarify what possibly could have made you say that.
It doesn't seem to me that this sort of position is compatible with your critique of the naturalist fallacy above. The argument against obesity is that it's divergent from our natural state, from what we ought to be. But as you say, rabies, infant mortality, etc, etc, and it seems to follow that any downside to obesity could easily be framed as just a matter of insufficient technology.
I don't follow. I'm not the one arguing that obesity is bad because it's not natural. I think it's bad because it makes you slower, weaker, ruins your QOL, makes you more likely to die early and less likely to find an attractive partner.
If there was a magic pill or surgery that let you be obese without any of the present downsides, that's a matter of aesthetics. It would be no different to dying your hair a weird color or getting a garish tattoo.
Being super fit and muscular isn't natural at all. Yet that's the revealed preference in terms of what people look for or aspire to, and they at least feel bad about not being there. The closest humans to a "state of nature", hunter gatherers, aren't super models or killing it on dating apps.
I would argue that we should value the places where nature is consonant with our desires, and we should be skeptical of places where our desires require wholesale rejection of nature. To the extent that our desires potentially bring us into conflict with nature, I think we should favor the desires that are as concrete and general as possible, over the desires that are highly individual and unusual. I think doing so would allow us to pursue common ground for a supermajority of the population.
Humans have been rejecting nature ever since they sharpened sticks and lit fires. It's worked out pretty well overall.
I think that questions of whether something is natural are often irrelevant to whether its good or desirable, noting that this unavoidable requires a subject to decide what counts as good or desirable. If that was you, then you might intrinsically think natural = better in many situations.
I'm the dancer, not the dance. I'm the waves, not the water.
To be a little more concrete:
Every part of your body is endlessly recycled while you're alive. This is true for every structure more complicated than fundamental particles. If two electrons have the same mass, spin, charge and other quantum numbers, then it's impossible to distinguish between them.
The majority of the atoms in my body have swapped around since I was born. I have a consistent self-identity that is conserved even if I have a banana for breakfast or take a big dump, or if I go to bed and wake up tomorrow. I'm never the exact same, any more than a river is. Yet a river and a self_made_human are consistent entities about which it possible to make broad statements.
So it can't be pure and perfect identity. It can't be truly continuous consciousness, unless one wishes to believe that sleep is lethal.
What remains are the patterns of information and the algorithms that act on them. If I copy a png of a flower and share it with you, there is nothing lost or gained in the process, assuming standard error correction.
Right now, these algorithms and their data are instantiated in meat machinery: neurons.
Yet the neurons churn. And eventually, without advanced technological intervention, will die and take me with them.
If you can perform addition using both an abacus, a TI-84 and a supercomputer, in a very real sense they're all doing the same thing. It doesn't make much sense to say that your CPU can't actually add numbers.
(Ignore details such as how the floating point arithmetic would work, that's beside the point)
I think there's no fundamental barrier to extracting the algorithms and information in my neurons and creating a replica in-silico. It is a ridiculously difficult engineering challenge, but not something forbidden by the laws of physics.
I can dig up a link, but we already know that that artifical neural networks can near perfectly replicate the behavior of their biological counterparts (usually in a 1000:1 ratio). You can make them arbitrarily more precise, to the point where the original brain is noisier.
Hence, I want my mind to be uploaded into a computer. It's more robust than flesh, and unlocks far more scope for improvement. Going from a dumb baby to a reasonably intelligent adult didn't kill me, so I don't think becoming more intelligent will.
I'm also fine with multiple copies of myself running around. All that matters is that they begin as indistinguishable in terms of behavior to a blinded observer. If there's a "copy" of myself sitting in a black box, which says the exact same things, acts like me in simulation, and so on, then I accept that as me.
..and yet, you must pity people who actually believe it, right?
The same way I pity someone with a bad haircut. It's not a big deal, or a lot of pity.
Let's start with, "What does this sentence mean?" What does it mean for values to be "just as valid (or not)"? You seem to have not touched on this at all in your latest comment.
It means precisely that from any imagined objective standpoint (which I argue doesn't exist for morality), no set of values has a greater claim to inherent correctness or truth than any other. They are "equally valid" in the sense that they are all subjective constructs, arising from individuals or cultures. They are "equally (or not)" valid because the very concept of objective validation is moot here – they are all equally ungrounded in objective truth. Think of it like favourite colours: saying my favourite colour (blue) is "just as valid" as yours (red) means neither has an objective claim to being the 'correct' favourite colour; the concept doesn't apply.
This lack of objective grounding doesn't prevent me, as a subject, from having preferences. I prefer my moral framework. I find it more consistent, more conducive to the kind of world I want to live in, etc. That's the chauvinism. But it's a preference asserted without the illusion of objective backing. It's saying "I prefer blue and think others should too because I find it aesthetically superior," not "Blue is objectively the best colour according to the laws of the universe."
Not that I feel like this point requires elaboration, I strongly expect that if you had an actual way to show me up as incoherent, you'd have produced it by now.
Since you claim that nature is a very ill defined concept (which I agree with), then what was the point of your previous comment? Why even point to something being natural?
Saying that hindering reproduction is the same as helping reproduction is your misunderstanding, not mine.
I invite you to show me where I can be said to have made this "misunderstanding". An earlier comment of mine explicitly said I don't want puberty blockers, and if my future kids did, I'd do everything I could to stop them.
There are animals, like jellyfish, that are biologically immortal in the sense they don't age.
You could argue that the first progenitor of life, whatever color of microbe that was, is still alive. During mitosis or meiosis, both the daughter cells have equal claim of being the original, if one insists on using that term.
Jellyfish have existed largely unchanged for half a billion years. If aging was always bad, I'd expect such exuberant youth would have been stamped out by now.
It seems to me far more likely that aging is a very difficult problem for evolution to solve in complicated, macroscopic organisms. Human females are one of the few (or only) animals that experience menopause, which is postulated to help them divert their resources towards their offspring's young instead of producing more. That seems like a consequence of blind evolution being unable to find a more optimal solution, and kludging together a fix.
I think that when I use the word "healthy", it reliably constrains expectations. If I tell you my shirt is red, and then you examine it, you wouldn't be expecting it to emit or reflect only light that's 460nm in frequency, even if the term "red" leaves room for subjective interpretation where it bleeds into orange or pink.
It would be rather awkward if I had to append the WHO definition (Health is a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity) every time I used that phrase. Even said definition is implicitly subjective.
So no, it's not meaningless beyond an individual observer. If I delivered a baby missing a head and handed it to a mother, I'd be rather aghast if anyone in the room called it a healthy child.
That is to say, the question of whether something is "healthy" begins and ends with their subjective opinion of their current state?
I couldn't really be a psychiatrist if I subscribed to that notion, could I?
Sadly human language is rather imprecise. It's still useful. I'm unable to define health in a way so rigorous I could program it into a computer in Lisp, but LLMs prove that that's not necessary.
Hooo buddy, have I got some news to break to you about natural science. People debate conceptual primitives and what "counts" as them all the bloody time. I presume that you pity people who genuinely believe in natural physical law or "objective" reality, too?
Ontology is a matter of convenience. All models are flawed, some models are useful. If there are two different models of reality that output the same results for all ranges of possible inputs, then choosing between them is a matter of convenience. If, for some reason, it became relevant, you could then worry about which one had the lowest Kolmogorov complexity or something.
Objective reality is a very useful concept to have, even if establishing it is likely unreachable. I can happily concede that the universe might be a cosmic dream, that this could be a simulation, that I'm perhaps a brain in a vat or a Boltzmann brain while happily acting as if this reality is shared, stable and predictable. The ability to compartmentalize or hold multiple levels of abstraction in your head when necessary can be handy.
There is certainly far more evidence for consistent and universal laws of physics than there is for objective and universal morality. Physicists can predict the outcome of systems spanning dozens of orders of magnitude within the limits of experimental error. Philosophers are lucky if they can get their buddy reading Kant in the cafeteria to agree with them.
These sentences contradict one another and result in something that is conceptually incoherent.
- Morality has no objective foundation, and is unavoidably subjective.
- I'm a subject, or at least an observer of my own moral schema.
- In other words, I have a subjective sense of morality. I can see no convincing reason for anyone to claim that theirs is more objective in any meaningful sense.
- Hence morality is always relative to an observer.
- I prefer my own moral system. If there was someone else's I preferred, I would adopt it. I've certainly been influenced by other people, I didn't grow up in a vacuum.
- I would prefer that other people adopt my sense of morality, if not wholesale, then the sections that relate to other people.
- Ergo, I'm a chauvinist, preferring my morals and seeking to convince others to adopt them.
1 to 4 establish the relativism. 5-7 explain why that's not a barrier for me preferring my morality over all others, as I believe that it both needs no justification beyond personal preference and that there isn't any more deep-seated justification for anyone's morality.
In other words: "Because there's no objective standard, all moralities are equally ungrounded. However, from my subjective viewpoint, I find my own morality preferable, and therefore I advocate for it." I avoid claiming objective superiority while still asserting subjective preference and a desire for propagation.
Please, do tell me me how these two concepts are impossible to reconcile. I think I just did that, so there's an existence proof for you. I would be much obliged if you also established reasons for there being an "objective" morality, or a reason why I should prefer that of someone else's over myself.
If you somehow succeed, I will either concede the point, or disappear into a gibbering mess of congealing brain matter from the cognitive dissonance I expect to experience.
This is paper, not steel. Puberty is not reversible in the same way that birth is not reversible, nor aging. These are normal, natural, and expected processes. This is what humans do, as much as trees grow to the light and fish swim upriver to spawn.
One day I'll stop running into the naturalistic fallacy in the wild and consider that my 10^28 years of existence leading up till that point worthwhile.
If someone said that 50% infant mortality was natural and not reversible, or the same for heart attacks being inevitably fatal.. They'd have been right for almost all of human history. Fortunately, we still have people alive who've witnessed this state of affairs, fortunate only in that we're not usually tempted to think this was somehow a superior state of affairs.
Pre-mature infants are far more likely to survive these days, thanks to modern incubators and resuscitate technologies doing at least some of the work a womb could or would. We've got proof of concept artificial wombs that have gestated mammalian embryos months for as long as 4 weeks without any physiological abnormalities:
https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms15112
With the improved incubator, five experimental animals with CA/JV cannulation (ranging in age from 120 to 125 days of gestation) were maintained on the system for 346.6±93.5 h, a marked improvement over the original design. Importantly, one animal was maintained on the circuit for 288 h (120–132 days of gestation) and was successfully weaned to spontaneous respiration, with long-term survival confirming that animals can be transitioned to normal postnatal life after prolonged extra-uterine support.
Give me a billion dollars and change, and I'll put any damn baby back into the womb and keep it there happily.
Give me a hundred billion, and I'll pocket one, and spend a few million delegating more competent people to the task of solving aging.
This is what humans do, as much as trees grow to the light and fish swim upriver to spawn.
As rabies proliferated through your peripheral nerves and is transported to your brain. As Onchocerca volvulus happily turns children blind.
Nature is not very nice. The congenial environment you find yourself in is very strongly the property of artificial efforts to keep it that way.
This is the majority of philosophers btw. I personally don't take a strong stance on metaethics (another way to put it is that I'm too lazy to read enough to formulate one and always puts it off) but that always gives me pause here. What many people find very unintuitive is the consensus position.
I've done my best to explore what drives philosophers to endorse objective morality, and found all their arguments lacking. It would help if the people who believed in objective morality could agree with each other on what it looked like, but alas.
I actually think that's part of the problem: society is constantly being overturned in the name of smaller and smaller minorities until we hit one where the tradeoffs for doing so are actually serious and visible.
I belong to the most oppressed minority of all, gamers, individuals. It doesn't get any smaller than that.
I also strongly value personal liberty. It's far from my only consideration, but it is a powerful one. The same arguments, namely paternalism, thinking that you can't allow such far-fetched thinking, would also restrict me.
I'm willing to support people in their quest for personal liberty, even if I think they're misguided, for the same reason that you want the right to free speech to cover heinous kinds as well. Nobody needs to have speech that's popular and favored protected by law.
And I suppose that's a coherent personal position. However, society clearly has certain standards for medical treatment.
Society isn't actually a monolithic entity (I'm not claiming that you're saying this, you appear to appreciate nuance). It's made of individuals, and some of them, like medical professionals or regulators, have disproportionate influence.
As the former, if not the latter, I consider it my duty to explain my views. At the absolute very least, I'm painfully self-consistent, and many of my opponents (the average philosopher, for example) aren't. There's plenty of vagueness and moral gray in that field, let alone when it becomes political.
It is certainly not consistent. As @RovScam helpfully illustrates in his own comment, it is trivial to consider an isomorphic example where almost nobody would consider it their business to interfere if the patient, their parents and the treating physicians were all on board.
Yes, it would be better if everyone was given accurate information on blockers. But that's not the only medical ethic. It seems like we have some pretty high standards for things like amputations which is precisely why exuberant claims were made about the necessity of transition to save a child's life. Even my opponents have implicitly yielded the point: the goal is not short-term gender euphoria in exchange for things we know tend to give people meaning like the ability to experience sexual pleasure and have children or not suffer side-effects from cross-sex hormones.
Modus ponens, modus tollens. I've addressed the specific example of elective limb amputation before. To summarize, if the person was otherwise sane (or at least had capacity), couldn't be dissuaded despite plenty of effort, found a surgeon willing to help, and could afford it, then I see that as entirely fine. I wouldn't like to pay for it with my taxes, there are better things to waste them on.
Young teens make many life changing decisions with uncertain payoffs. Opting for a less conventional field of scholarship might be one.
"We know that leaving school at 11 and then tilling the fields leads to a satisfying and happy life, why bother with the stress and expense of uni".
If someone is busy sacrificing their ability to party with friends in high school in exchange for grinding for med school, what of it? They'd definitely be getting more sexual pleasure in the short term, and likely have more kids if they didn't have to finish residency.
It's to literally save lives and improve human flourishing. It is not like your own personal decision to spend $3 on a lottery ticket (which costs you almost nothing and doesn't require any medical professional to be complicit).
The issue is that the people you're trying to look out for vehemently disagree on what counts as human flourishing. They certainly don't appreciate your attempts to dictate what they should choose, even if you good intentions.
If money is the biggest factor, then I have little objection to saying such procedures shouldn't be paid for by the public, any more than breast implants or a boob job typically are. I say typically for a reason, because someone who had a mastectomy for cancer might qualify.
The core of this is that meme:
"I consent." Says a distressed young child. "I consent." Says their worried but loving parents, and some doctor making sure they're ticking the consent boxes. "I don't-" Says someone whose consent seems entirely unnecessary to me, at least when they're not paying for this.
I bet I already have.
If not, I'll answer your rhetorical quasi-question:
Transhumanism seeks to liberate us from the existing limits of the human flesh. The exact goal can vary, be it practical immortality, becoming superintelligent or immune to disease. The only common thread is looking at the Human Condition, deeming it deeply suboptimal, and aspiring to do better through technology.
Transgenderism? That could mean anything from affirming that a desire to change sex is Valid™, that it is desirable to do so, or claims that we can do so. Some might say that people who have made efforts to emulate the opposite sex should be extended the polite courtesy/social fiction of being treated like them. Hardliners might say that they are the opposite sex, and any efforts to distinguish them from those natally blessed is bigotry.
They have superficial similarities. Both sides are usually less than pleased with their current bodies and wish to remedy that.
If you're happy that I'm conceding some kind of point you've made, then I will helpfully point out that if you consider them equal and indistinguishable:
- Brushing your teeth.
- Wearing clothes.
- Getting a pacemaker installed.
- Driving a car or using a bicycle.
- Wearing shoes.
Are all sterling examples of transhumanism! The evidence is clear for all to behold, are they not all examples of overcoming human limitations through technology?
Look at this featherless biped, is he not a fine specimen of Man?
If your wife were to dye her hair blonde, would you divorce her as a reckless transhumanist obsessed with undermining the sanctity of the human form she was blessed with? Probably not.
Ahem.
I'm a transhumanist. I'm not a transgenderist in any meaningful sense. I'm very happy being a man rather than a woman. I'd be even happier as a post-gender Matrioshka Brain.
If you want to restrict yourself to the kind of trans-activism that demands people who disagree make concessions beyond minor ones like going along with a new name or remembering new pronouns, then they're usually making some kind of metaphysical claim that a trans-woman is as female as a born woman.
Which I think is nonsense. At the very least it's not possible to pull off today, no matter how much surgery or gene therapy they can afford or survive.
When I want to be a 6'9" muscular 420 IQ uber-mensch, I want that to be a fact about physical reality. There shouldn't be any dispute about that, no more than anyone wants to dispute the fact that I have black hair right now.
I do not think that putting on high heels and bribing my way into Mensa achieves my goal. I do not just want to turn around and say that because I identify as a posthuman deity, that I am one and you need to acknowledge that fact.
This explains why I have repeatedly pointed out that while I have no objection to trans people wanting to be the opposite sex, that they need to understand the limitations of current technology. I would have hoped that was obvious, why else would I pull terms like ersatz or facsimile out of my handy Thesaurus?
Self identification only equals identity if I asked you about which football club you're a fan of. I haven't actually met someone with who asked me to use different pronouns in real life, if they did, I'd probably oblige them because I'm a polite person with better hills to die on. If they saw me in a treatment room, I'd put their birth sex in the charts and helpfully append "trans" or "identifies as X" alongside it.
I basically agree with you about values and freedom. I guess my main fear is around the information environment we provide re: "This is the closest we can get you today." I'm not an expert but I get the impression that many (maybe most?) people who attempt to transition are deeply mislead about both the best and worst-case outcomes. I just don't expect any modern Western institution to be able to honest about what wretched results most transitioners end up having, nor about what most people honestly think of them.
I have no opposition to making every reasonable effort to expose people to reality. Of course, with the matter as politicized as it is, easier said than done. There are just as many people committed to cracking eggs at all costs as there people who will claim that puberty blockers gave their cancer cancer.
At any rate, if I had solutions for people making bad decisions, I'd probably be accepting a dozen Nobel prizes right now. All I can say is that we should let people make their own choices, and if they're hard and risky choices, do our best to ensure they're exposed to the facts they need.
Discussions like this make you feel the void left by any natural law or common understanding of virtue.
I did stress that I'm playing Devil's Advocate Doctor. I don't want puberty blockers, if I had the misfortune of having a child who desired them, I would do almost anything in my power to dissuade them. I'm not in the business of prescribing them either, I'm not a psychiatrist for kids and teenagers. In fact, the UK is cracking down on even the relatively few (compared to the US) "legitimate" gender transitioning clinics.
That being said: Natural law is bullshit. There is no coherent collection of principles that the term usefully refers to. Most adherents ignore the literal meaning and embrace a gazillion unprincipled exceptions. The closest it has to a working definition is status-quo bias.
Even teleological definitions have absurd conclusions. Is the meaning of life to maximize entropy? It is, if the outcome of a process defines its purpose.
Even mild exposure to different cultures and their associated values will tell you that beyond a small core (often contentious itself) there's no "common understanding of virtue".
Even simple sounding ideas, like "don't murder, or steal from your neighbors" will have people arguing ad-nauseum what counts murder or stealing or even a neighbor.
If I pity people who want to be the opposite of the sex they were at birth, then I pity people who genuinely believe in natural law or "objective" morality even more.
One of them is a matter of personal values. The other is basing your moral foundations on wishful thinking.
I'm a moral relativist and a moral chauvinist. I know my values are just as valid (or not) as anyone else's. I also happen to think they're better, with the implicit understanding that to use such a comparative term necessarily needs an observer by whose light it is better or worse (me). Anyone who has convinced themselves that there's objective grounding to their morality, well, I don't want to have what they're smoking.
It's because it's both natural and we have a long track record of that path working.
Quite a few gynecologists and many endocrinologists would be out of a job if the outcome of human hormones acting as they would always had the desired outcome.
I don't contest that the overwhelming majority of people are neutral or slightly positive towards puberty, assuming they even cared to reflect on it.
It's a very difficult problem to come up with an alternative pathway that leads to physically and mentally healthy humans at our current level of tech. Unconstrained thinking is probably not a good idea when it comes to complex biological and social changes.
I would be the last person to disagree about the limits of modern science, engineering and medicine. I also think we should be improving our tech (and we are).
On the other hand, constraining thinking to only that which is known to be possible is... a choice.
You might have gotten away with it a thousand years back, when the lives you and your grandpa lived were nigh interchangeable. That's not the case today, we're living in a scifi novel with reality's rather lax attitude towards plausibility.
It becomes even more absurd to even attempt this in the name of people with disordered relations to their own body, when puberty itself may help resolve that disordered relationship.
And it might not. The rate of desistance with puberty is not 100%. A non-zero number of people will find themselves still wanting to transition, and face even greater hardship for even less change.
I'm for reflecting on whether or not that risk is worth taking, from the perspective of someone who has to:
- Make an irreversible choice.
- Their ability to make a choice automatically being taken away by inaction.
They need to add up the benefits and risks themselves.
Maybe people's intuitions that living their values will make them happy are just wrong. Maybe this is especially true for a group that is prone to a bunch of other mental disorders.
I do not hold happiness as the only terminal value, nor do most people. If they disagree, then they're welcome to start a fent habit.
Whether doing something will make a person happier, either in the short-term, in the long term, or just on average, is far from the only consideration when making a choice.
We can't exactly take it for granted that mentally ill people are holding values that will actually make them happy (what is the point of psychiatry otherwise), or that (especially when faced with dubious information from medical practitioners) they have a reasonable understanding of the risk they're taking on or have reasonable expectations for these treatments.
There are plenty of people who are just depressed, so we wouldn't be out of a job.
Mental illnesses are not made equal.
Someone who had an overwhelming desire to fly and tried to do so might have been better off in an insane asylum if they were born in the 1700s.
Today, they might be a hang-glider hobbyist, a pilot, an astronaut.
Did the people who jumped off cliffs or the Eiffel Tower with inadequate parachutes or mechanical contraptions count as mentally ill or suicidal? Not by most definitions I've heard of. They would still have been "better off" if society had caged them, or at least lived longer. Yet today, we soar.
Your argument argues, just as strongly, for doing our level best to present reliable information to patients. You could also force doctors to present information that better represented reality, on the pain of liability. You could have people be grilled by a different doctor or some other Authoritative Individual who had to be convinced that the patient understood the risks and benefits. This is already common practice in psychiatry, at least where I work. Things like detention under the Mental Health Act or forced treatment require multiple people uninvolved with the original case to sign off. This isn't trivially gamed either, I've seen the headaches my bosses get went they're trying to put these in place without unimpeachable evidence.
Or hell, that their stated euphoria and relief will be lasting.
Death, be it ours, or that of the universe, doesn't mean temporary endeavors are worthless. At least not to me.
Even in the short term, the hedonic treadmill goes brrr. I'd love to win the lottery, even if a year later my happiness would have regressed to near baseline levels.
Society is entitled to say no. My doctor won't give me SARMs for some reason.
You should try a different doctor. Some are more flexible. If I had a patient who understood the risks and benefits, and I wasn't violating laws (because I wish to keep my license, my own moral proclivities aside), then I'd prescribe them.
There are many things that would nice if they were real. You know, a benevolent Creator, objective morality, a pill that changes your gender with no consequences.
Sometimes, you're shit out of luck. Sometimes you can make something just as good. Sometimes you pick the lesser evil out of available options while working on making better ones.
If you have a god-shaped hole, in a universe that doesn't have a god, make one yourself from applying linear algebra to {the majority of text Mankind has written}. If you can't become the opposite sex today, maybe settle for the terrible ersatź substitute.
All I say is maybe.
Excellent travelogue. I'm looking forward to future installments.
Hmm.. Maybe I should consider a visit to China at some point. I know literally nobody there, but I might submit offerings to the shrine of Jiankui He. Or more likely, see if the uber-polished cyberpunk vibes of the newer cities holds up on closer inspection.
I'm going to play Devil's Doctor here:
You underwent a drastic change in your personality as a consequence of a hormonal surge that was out of your control. That's 'normal'. It's puberty.
Yet the person you became isn't the same person as the one before. I mean, puberty hit me hard, but I never felt as if my values or goals changed because of it (beyond being even more eager for the company of the fairer sex).
This seems to me to be analogous to a person who, for their entire life, had sworn off addictive substances, but ended up on benzos or opioids for Medical Reason and found themselves hooked, and are now unwilling to try and become sober.
Why should we so strongly privilege puberty because it's "natural"? Many things are natural, such as 50% infant mortality rates, dying of a heart attack at 50 or getting prostate cancer by 80.
Nature, a blind and indifferent force, cares nothing for our individual well-being or our carefully constructed notions of self. To equate "natural" with "good" or "desirable" is a fundamental error, a logical fallacy we often fall prey to.
In the UK, the laws around consent for minors are relatively simple. Past the age of 16, they're assumed to be competent to consent to or decline medical procedures until proven otherwise. Below that age, there's no strict cut-off, if they can prove to their clinician that they are able to weigh the risks and benefits, they are able to consent or withhold it, and even override parental demands.
Someone who wishes to be the opposite sex is someone I pity. Medical science as it currently stands can't provide them more a hollow facsimile of that transition, it's Singularity-complete based off my knowledge of biology. Even so, the desire is one I consider as valid as any.
If they understand that:
A)Puberty blockers have risks and might not be truly reversible if they change their mind.
B) It won't solve all their problems, it won't physically make them indistinguishable from their desired sex.
Then I see no reason to declare that they're making a mistake. By the values they hold, it's the right decision. If they're forced to pass through puberty, they might desist, or they might spend their life wracked with regret that they didn't pull the trigger (hopefully not literally). You can pass far easier before testosterone wracks your body. It's a helluva drug/hormone.
A lot of life-changing decisions can be ones that change the person making them irrevocably, and into a person who would affirm them in retrospect. But I would yell at someone who suggested that couples who are iffy about childbirth be forced to have a child in the hopes that'll change their mind, or fix their marriage or some other well-intentioned goal. Or if we suddenly were to say that everyone should be made to try alcohol and cigarettes because the kind of people who try them tend to stick to it.
We're forced to deal with a messy world that doesn't always readily cough up pathways to our desires when we ask. I'm all for overcoming biology, and I think that people who understand what they're getting into are entitled to ask for even imperfect solutions.
Want to be more muscular? Try tren, if you know what you're in for. Want to lose weight? Take ozempic, while keeping an eye on your eyesight and pancreas. Want to be the other sex? This is the closest we can get you today.
It's entirely possible that I'm the one remembering things wrong. If that's the case, my criticism would lean more towards the rather disproportionately high profit factor that certain weapons were locked behind.
While I could see the gameplay justification behind doing so, there were things like krak grenades, explosive charges and standard med kits that were limited purchases.
I can only reiterate the level of ludonarrative dissonance that induced in me. Even an impoverished RT should be able to buy enough explosives to blow a factory sky high. They can certainly afford standard issue militarum medkits. It would have made far more sense to limit players in how many could be brought at once into a mission, which is already the case thanks to inventory limits.
I'm happy to concede that RT does a far better job at diegetically gating stronger gear than the average RPG, and the setting of 40k makes rare relic gear and one-of-a-kind antiques very easy to justify.
I still felt that the profit factor was wack, a single gun could cost as much as you deciding to be merciful and preventing a planet from starving by providing subsidized grain. It very much wasn't the kind of gear where that would make sense, such as some kind of adrathic weapon or a set of Terminator armor.
I'd much rather have had some form of accounting, even if the units of exchange you had to bother to consider were millions of Thrones, or have the weapons be doled out through quests or loot drops in the kind of scenarios where that makes eminent sense.
Huh. Luckily the pre-built I'm eyeing (because it's cheap) has a watercooled system, so that should keep me safe.
The 9070 XT is an excellent card.
Unfortunately, it's very hard to get at MSRP in the UK. Any other time, I'd have been tempted away from team green (my first two GPUs were AMD), but sadly they don't have anything in the performance or price range of the 5080.
That's half the reason I'm buying a pre-built, getting cards at MSRP is an uphill struggle, and when you account for prevailing direct to consumer prices, the markup isn't bad at all.
"OwlCat makes least intuitive RPG level up system and perk tree, asked to leave".
Seriously. I played about a third of the way through the game before I gave up on trying to build my own characters up and just re-rolled them with an online guide. It's so damn unintuitive, and the vast majority of builds are underwhelming.
Another gripe I had with it was the gear system. A Rogue Trader, even one down on their luck, has more money than God. I should be able to buy the vast majority of weaponry with cash, no questions asked. I can understand very rare or heretical weaponry being gated behind the expenditure of influence or building rep with factions, but it pissed me off no end that Slightly Better Bolter/Lasgun was something I couldn't just buy.
The game also ends up with damage-spongy enemies the moment you cross the early game. You can ameliorate this to an extent, since the game has the great feature of letting you tune damage sliders in the settings with decent granularity. Even so, I think it ruins immersion for a bog-standard human Cultist to take more than a couple Bolter rounds to the chest and not be reduced to a puddle.
I enjoyed the writing, but I wished the game had a wider variety of recruitable characters, or that you had more freedom to choose back stories for your player character. You can recruit a member of the Mechanicus, but I want to be able to be one myself.
I would also have appreciated more in the way of enemy variety, beyond Chaos and flavors of Eldar. Where are the Orks? They should be everywhere.
Honestly, I would loved to have more DLC if it meant that we had more potential companions and enemy diversity.
It's a good game, but I ended up dropping it for above-mentioned reasons well before the end of the story, and I don't see myself replaying over 50 hours to get to that point without drastic additions in terms of new content.
Good points!
Leaving aside AAA games, I download an absurd number of mods for games that support it. I think vanilla Rimworld is less than a gig, I have a dozen times that just in mods. Arma 3 is like 30 gb, and I had 500 more in mods.
I'll just go with the option that has a decent sized primary SSD and buy plenty more as needed. They're quite cheap these days.
If your wi-fi connection drops sometimes I'd recommend getting a powerline adapter. It should be about equal to wi-fi if your wiring is good/new but more importantly it will be stable and won't drop connection if you're going to play games online. If your wi-fi is rock solid it doesn't matter though.
I haven't heard of this before, I'll have to take a look into how this works.
Another bit of sacrilege, I would recommend getting a controller. Not simply because some of them play better with that (classic example being dark souls but anything with analog movement) but because kb&m tends to hurt my hands after extended play whereas controller usually just wears out the tip of my thumb at most, and more important to me is the lean-back experience is so much nicer than lean forward when it comes to playing games and relaxing
Good advice, but unfortunately the majority of games I play, such as FPS titles, RTS games or colony builders, don't play well with a controller. For racing games (which I do occasionally play), I 100% agree that it's a more comfortable and enjoyable experience, especially with haptic feedback.
For a mechanical keyboard Gateron switches for mechanical keyboards are usually cheaper and better than cherry switches in most people's experience because they're smoother.
I strongly prefer mechanical keyboards over rubber domes, but I deliberately refrain from becoming too obsessed with the finer aspects of switches. That wha lies bankruptcy! Even a cheapo mech beats the best membrane I've ever tried. My old Chinesium keyboard had Kailh Browns, and they were perfectly decent.
Thank you again! The cheapest build, the one I linked to in a separate comment, has an 850w PSU from a reputable brand. I presume that's going to tide me over for a long time unless I ever get a 5090 successor.
The case: diminishing returns above £150-175.
I had a PC "built" by assembling the pieces in the cardboard box the motherboard came in, so you can tell I'm not overly fussy about cases ;)
AM5 motherboards require DDR5 ram! You can't combine ddr5 with ddr4. And mbs are now more "picky eaters" of ram than ever, I think. There's a reason the sticks are sold in pairs/sets. They don't play well with others. And they should be inserted in the A2 + B2 slots. The PC might not even boot if A1+B1 are used instead. Mb producers provide a "QVL list" of ram skus that are tested to work with the mb.
Oh, I meant it in the sense that old RAM variants tend to be commercially available (and cheap) well past when they're obsolete. But thank you for elaborating on making sure that the kits match up, in the worst case if I can't find identical models, it probably won't break the bank to buy a fresh set!
Sometimes there's a deal to be had on a 34" ultrawide oled monitor. They're nice. Beware that both oled and ultrawide are techs you're likely to never want to abandon once you've started using them. You're locking yourself into a new and somewhat expensive computering lifestyle. :)
I've had OLED phones for a long time, so I know the perks. I'm hooked to high refresh rates, so what's ultra-wide or OLED in comparison? They're down to steep but understandable prices, and unlike GPUs, they're likely to keep getting cheaper. I've been a good boy, so I'm going to treat myself to all the sweet candy haha.

You're playing word games and being intentionally obtuse.
You initially argued against puberty blockers by contrasting them with "normal, natural, and expected processes" like puberty, framing the intervention itself as the problem partly because it disrupts something "natural."
When I pointed out that "natural" doesn't automatically mean "good" (the naturalistic fallacy, using examples like disease), you then pivoted quite sharply to say "There is no such thing as nature." You were rather quick to contradict your own starting point.
Then you accused me of a specific "misunderstanding," claiming I said "hindering reproduction is the same as helping reproduction." I said no such thing. My point was about interventions against harmful natural processes (like disease) being generally considered good, challenging your implicit framing that interfering with any natural process is inherently suspect because it's natural:
See that first bit I've bolded for you? That's the problem.
I asked you twice, directly, to clarify where you think I made that specific error. Both times, you avoided answering the question. First, you restated your personal philosophy ("be fruitful and multiply"), and second, you vaguely talked about good vs. bad artificial efforts without actually substantiating the accusation I challenged.
More options
Context Copy link