@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

Two AAQC, entirely localized to the shortest month of the year? I'm chuffed.

You know what, you have the cheek to report your own comment for an AAQC. I have to respect that, if absolutely nothing else.

My man, you've convinced me to switch to the default Motte theme in my profile so I can both flashbang my eyes and also see what kind of record of past rule-breaking you've been up to.

My eyes are burnt, and so is your standing with us mods. I see a long list of past warnings and temp bans, and not a single good thing to counteract that. You've been warned for low effort commentary as well as booing the outgroup more times than I want to count.

Banned for a month, and I leave it open to the others if they want to extend this.

This seems plausible but I'm unsure. I did realize my analysis depends on the belief that the median doctor is a net value add, which some people dispute.

You do agree or at least consider it plausible, so I guess I can only express frank confusion about those who don't. I can only hope they're a small minority (haha).

I don't know if my opinion about doctors is invalid because I'm one, but I've never felt myself having to exercise particular caution when looking for a doctor, and I'm usually happy with the treatment I receive. This is, of course, confounded by the fact I've been a doctor for a while, and a med student for about as long, and the scion of doctors for as long as I've been alive. Other doctors will treat you differently for any of the above, but I expect not to the point they wouldn't do a good job for the average person. They'll treat you regardless.

I don't know if you read my comment below, but I do agree with you. Critique of a country by a foreigner will almost certainly go down harder than praise (by a foreigner).

If someone went to /r/India and began extolling the virtues of chicken Tikka masala, they'd have a very different reception to someone in the West who complained about street shitting.

Assuming self_made_human is as competent as the median American doctor

That is very kind of you to assume, though I can't agree or disagree beyond saying that all the American doctors I personally know are scary good. Look at @Throwaway05, who I highly respect, though I think he's well above median. And I hope for the sake of my self-esteem that he is significantly older and more experienced than me, because god knows I have stiff competition as is.

(I don't know many American doctors, but they have very high quality training, even by First World standards)

I do expect to be a better doctor by the time I'm (eligible) for the USMLE, and a rather good one if I can overcome the strong competition for the positions that are bookmarked for international doctors (around 4.5k the last time I checked, and you better believe the competition is an order of magnitude larger).

I'm early in training! I've only been a psychiatry resident for 6 months and change, so God knows that you wouldn't want to leave me entirely on my own to handle truly difficult cases. I'd probably not bungle it, because I can always look up treatment guidelines, but the mark of a competent doctor these days is the ability to make good decisions when operating outside the cut and dry, where guidelines and standard practice no longer apply.

An important addendum is that you don't have to be a median or better doctor to be a net value add! This is important, and the joke about half of all doctors being below average in their class is (mostly) a joke. A 10th percentile doctor is probably the point where I'd start having strong second thoughts, and that number depends on how strong the filtering is for both med students and fully qualified doctors with MDs. This is fair, because 90% of doctors will do an adequate job of treating you.

I have no firm numbers on hand for the relative difficulty of getting into medicine in either the States, the US or the UK (I'm tipsy at a pub), but I can definitely admit without shame that the average American doctor has better training than the rest.

I would very much like to charge as much money as people would pay me, especially in the States, but on a macro level letting more foreign doctors in will both suppress local wages and also increase access to healthcare for the average American. The former is likely going to be barely perceptible, unless the AMC does something drastic like allowing all Western doctors from near-peer nations to practise in the States automatically (and they never will). The latter also depends strongly on multiple factors, but the average IMG who does get into the States will probably be forced to take a role that pays less than the median (because it's easier for us to get into the unpopular things like Family Medicine), which will make IMG doctors cheaper on average for the average Joe.

If you want to peg my capabilities, I was around 75th percentile for all doctors, both British-trained and foreign (who met the eligibility criteria to sit it) in the clinical section of the exam I gave to enter higher training. When you include both the clinical knowledge and the ethical section of the exam, I was around 65th percentile. I will say that the ethics section of the MSRA, called the SJT, is universally panned as absolute bullshit and barely better than random noise on a good day.

I think that mistake theory and conflict theory are far too simplistic ways of viewing the world, and I reject identifying primarily as either.

It seems clear to me that the world is messy, and that many, if not most, contentious issues hinge both on people believing different sets of 'facts' (and theoretically, if not practically, once they come to a consensus about the facts they'll agree on policy) as well as fundamental conflicts of values.

Someone who thinks that abortion at 12 weeks should be illegal because they believe fetuses can suffer could, at least in theory, be swayed by arguments about embryonic development and our best guess about cognition and consciousness.

Someone who thinks that zygotes have an Immortal Soul and are thus worthy of life is both factually wrong, and also likely an adherent of values that cannot be moved by rational argument.

For a slightly less CW example, think about two people, who both believe that some degree of taxation and redistribution is justified by the support it provides to the poor, but disagree on what the ideal level of taxation should be.

I can see one of them pulling out papers by respected economists (which both of them agree beforehand are trustworthy), where they find that above a certain level, taxes are distorionary, and prompt those wealthy enough to be net tax payers to flee to other jurisdictions, causing a net reduction in taxes paid, and hence aid available to the poor.

On the other hand, if one of them is an unshakeable libertarian, they might be unwilling to stand any level of taxation that isn't voluntary, no matter the justification. They'll only cave when the cops show up at their door, and maybe they'll decide to feed the dog tannerite in advance. If it's someone with a pathological hatred for the wealthy, they might think the poor suffering is a fair price to pay for getting one over those richy riches.

At the end of the day, humans are messy, values are messy, the Aumann Agreement Theorem is hard to instantiate, and people can accept the same facts and come away with entirely different desired outcomes from said facts.

Hell, even "self-interest" is sometimes not a useful metric. Is a revolutionary who takes up arms against what they perceive as a tyrannical government, often not putting other values over their own bodily integrity and well-being? If a concept pathologizes even overt altruism as well as sheer evil, it's probably not the best rubric.

Fortunately, the civilized world has largely found ways to prevent outright bloodshed even in the face of conflicting values, and we have ways of discharging unhappiness or rage at things not going our way, because the alternative is often unacceptable to both sides. This isn't unbounded, and things can and do go awry.

If surrendering metric is the only option if I need to move over, then you'll never take me alive! I'll be dead and buried 182 cm below the ground before I cave in.

I presume I'd actually have to familiarize myself with bullet grain, it's not really knowledge I've needed. As a recreational shooter who isn't too invested in fantasies of standing with their rifle against the world, I presume I'd only need to dial in the gas block? I would prefer not to have my rifle explode and send me to the ER with a severed artery in my neck. Beyond that, I don't see myself ever needing to splurge for fancy bullets beyond the bare minimum, no black tips for me.

At one point Fang Yuan compared something to a neon lamp. I'm pretty sure that was his own internal narration and not the author's notes. Mao was also mentioned.

I stand corrected, and I'm actively trying not to remember because I want my memory to fade so I can re-read it with pleasure.

I do think that an industrial revolution is unlikely even with determined effort, because it would undermine the powers of the Cultivators (who can get any modern amenity they want through Gu), and because the world is far too hostile to build even modern medieval trade networks.

As much as it physically pains me, I have to upvote you despite you coming away with a tepid review so far.

170 chapters is enough to give even Xianxia a fair-shot, in my opinion.

Smart protagonist cred: 2/5. It might be intended that Fang Yuan doesn't come off as particularly smart, but rather experienced, lucky to have achieved the heights he had once despite his disadvantage in natural talent and then lucky once more to get another chance. The protagonist begins the story with the massive advantage of 500 years of foreknowledge along with a prestige boon that boosts his progress massively on top of the information he has. He does not make glaring unforced mistakes, but that is not to the credit of the story when I have never seen him learn, but instead was told how "Fang Yuan was entirely clear on X" and "Fang Yuan was utterly calm like a still lake because of his 500 years of experience". On top of that, the "Fang Yuan transmigrated from Earth" part was criminally wasted. You isekai into medieval ages from modernity and don't even consider in your internal thoughts to invent gunpowder and kickstart the industrial evolution combined with the existing magical system? Some "Chinese scholar", he is!

Unfortunately, this is the one place where I actually do have to say the cliched line: Wait a bit longer.

Eventually you will see the galaxy brain shenanigans, and FY outsmarting the competition. At the risk of mild spoilers, as time goes by, FY can rely less and less on his knowledge of future events, his actions have butterfly effects, and he's forced to figure out new solutions and use even more of his brains.

On top of that, the "Fang Yuan transmigrated from Earth" part was criminally wasted. You isekai into medieval ages from modernity and don't even consider in your internal thoughts to invent gunpowder and kickstart the industrial evolution combined with the existing magical system? Some "Chinese scholar", he is!

We don't know for a fact that he hasn't at least considered it, but in his defense I'll say that the Gu world is very unfriendly to technology. Outposts of civilization exist separated by wilderness teeming with magical beasts. Cultivating Gu provides guaranteed and easy power ups, and reduces the impetus for technological development.

FY probably couldn't manage the industrial chain necessary to use gunpowder as a mortal, and by the time he has the power to do so, why democratize things when he can get his way with his cultivation? At higher levels, as in most Xianxia settings, mundane weaponry shorts of MOABs and nukes won't make a deny against upper level Cultivators.

He reincarnated 500 years ago, so I wouldn't be surprised if most traces of his original personality and life have faded. It will become quite clear that he's changed considerably over time, but I don't want to spoil things.

And as far as I can recall, the author never claimed that he was the reincarnation of a modern Chinese scholar! All we know is that he had an extensive knowledge of classical Chinese literature and poetry, so he could well have been alive hundreds or even a thousand years before the present day.

jumps around from third-person omniscient narrator to some sort of weird "teaching moments" between the author and the reader, with the "morals?

The Legend of Gu Zhen Ren is polarizing, and I can honestly say I'm not a fan of it. But it does have relevance to the setting, both as something the denizens personally know about, and later on for reasons I won't spoil.

Thanks for giving the book a go! I do hope you continue reading further, and I think quite a few of your critiques are valid.

It was hyperbole. I would like to own at least 2 different rifles, probably an AR-15 chambered in 5.56, and a DMR in something like .338 or .408. If you can't tell, I like guns that go boom. I could tell you more about my aesthetics, I'd kit out the AR with Daniel Defense furniture barring a magpul MOE buttstock, Geissele match triggers, an LPVO with a mounted red dot. The DMR would (ideally) be a Mk-18 Mjolnir, because I love that gun, but I'd settle for a off the shelf AR-10 in 7.62x51 if I had to.

The 5.56 for plinking or at the range, the DMR for the hell of it. If I wanted to go hunting boar from a chopper with a Barrett, that would be a special treat if anything.

I did know there was a fancy term for it, it just didn't come up off the top of my head, thank you.

Honestly, I wish more people even considered the possibility of trying to price in externalities and let them be paid for.

This pure rhetoric and hyperbole that is not worth addressing. I can only wish you well when you conquer your hangups and decide to move to Japan.

Opinions differ strongly on how much of that is is "make work". From the perspective of a hospital, the administrators provide some value, even if it's due to a need to engage with a labrynthine bureaucracy and governmentally imposed regulation. Someone being paid to fill up a hole that someone else is paid to dig, is at the least, filling up a hole that might trip up passersby.

It's like saying the military is make-work, because the main reason each nation needs one is because other nations have their own.

If there's a point where humans are not employable in a free market, but rely entirely on government work or government mandated work that requires a human in the loop, it is a shitty form of UBI.

Agreed. There was once someone I loved, who didn't love me back, and while it's been half a decade or more, meeting her and rekindling our friendship would be more pain than it's worth. It's not like it's impossible, but I think it takes being settled and happy already to be worth considering

I wonder if we could solve the issue of nuclear waste by assigning them negative value, I'm pretty sure your property will depreciate in value for having a cask of radioactive waste buried under the floorboards.

Then we could have people bidding to buy them, knowing they'd save a lot of money in taxes (people are irrationally afraid of it, hence would pay much less for the land). My genius frightens me.

My annual leave is mostly spent going back home to India for a few weeks, but I do plan to come to the States in the nearish future to attend a close friend's marriage. When I do, I'll be sure to hit you up!

I have discussed a whole range of options in the past, including make-work. Even that is a form of UBI, just a rather shitty one, and once again, the US would be in a better position to make it work.

I'm not entirely sure myself. I didn't expect it to be remotely as polarizing! Before the vote count became visible, my expectations would have been a 65:35 spread at worst.

If I had to guess, and I am guessing, it's because I explicitly discuss a particular means of immigration that might strike people as being "unfair". I'd wager people have different opinions on a prospective migrant crossing hurdles like licensing exams versus one who even considers the option of buying entry.

It might be that I'm actively criticizing the current administration and Trump in particular, whereas my previous post was a paen of praise for the US of A that made hearts swell and tears shed across the aisle. America is Great is an easier statement to get behind than America is Great and You Shouldn't Make it Harder For People Like Me To Get In.

Thanks. I think I understand your argument now.

Uh.. I'm not quite sure what point you're making, unless you're taking off entirely tangentially.

That being said:

I've recently learned of great Black Japanese hero of legends, Yasuke. He was the closest friend and advisor to Nobunaga. I had look up Nobunaga, he was apparently some sort of a head honcho in Japan. So anyay, Japanese not only know, and adore Yasuke. You know, I've heard they are pretty racist there, but as their love for Yasuke will rise new heights, hopefully they will overcome this flaw.

My man, have you known many weebs? They can be racist as fuck, and are probably one of the demographic most ticked off by Assassin's Creed: Shadows, and their depiction of an African uberchad steamrolling underfed rice-eating Japs. Even Afro Samurai had the decency to set itself in the far future, with the character effectively being a LARPer.

I guess this is why we are just talking past each other. You see a dead America, corpse being picked clean and future kingdoms taking root, and think it's still a fantastic place to live. "That's it?" you think.

That's laughable hyperbole at best. Seriously? Do you know what a truly dysfunctional, ethnically and politically divided nation looks like? You haven't even engaged with my rebuttals, or the clear evidence that I am aware of the warts on America's ass cheeks.

The only immigrants I'd want are ones who see what is become of America, and would prefer to fortify their own homeland from the rot.

Well, you're a citizen, and I'm not, so you're entitled to that opinion. That Republic you consider a rotten corpse is still yours, provided that you can keep it. You don't even seem to want to.

Hmm.. It seems to me that you're describing late 1960s and early 70s medicine, whereas what I had in mind was closer to early 90s, before computers and internet access were truly ubiquitous.

I think by then, most of medicine had solidified, or at least we wouldn't be too outraged at the state of knowledge.

My grandpa finished med school back when penicillin was the hot new thing, DNA hadn't been discovered. Hell, when he entered med school, the notion of surgeons specializing was rather novel. I think they were at General Surgeons, OBGYNs and orthopods when he finished med school, if not by the time he finished postgraduate training in gyne.

I presume that the understanding of anatomy was most of the way there. You're not going to discover a brand new organ past the 1950s (and recent claims of new organs are rather tenuous at best, is the discovery of a new part of the lymphatic system or some kind of fascia that important?). And surgery would definitely be a practical field above all else.

I believe you. It's not like the PLAB doesn't occasionally let absolute lemons through, and I wish I could say that every doctor with the same nominal degree I have was someone I'd entrust my medical care to.

God knows that I've sometimes felt scared and befuddled by how much autonomy the UK saw fit to grant me, back in India it was far too easy to hide behind a consultant's skirt, but that's not really a possibility when the senior psychiatrist hasn't had to interpret a CXR longer than I've been alive. I personally think it's nigh miraculous how doctors once managed without ready access to the internet.

I understand, and I won't press the point.

It can be frustrating to confront someone with the same set of observed facts, and find that they take away entirely different messages. Some of that is miscommunication, and common ground can be found if you hash things out long enough.

Sometimes, it can be genuine differences in what we value, and I wish I had a solution to that. I do not expect that there is, beyond letting the brute force of reality sort out a victor, though hopefully not with bloodshed or permanent acrimony. I've been there, when talking to someone who accepts what I find unacceptable, and I'd be lying if I said I'd never lost my temper in the process.

If you wish to continue the conversation, I'll be here. If not, then I did appreciate the opportunity to discuss our beliefs and ideas.