@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

As a pretty average American compared to most of this forum, I'd be okay with you or anyone else living here only if you did most of the following: got married (ideally to an American), had kids, learned to hunt or fish, started going to church or at least showed up and participated in public events hosted by churches, took an interest in local politics, and participated in traditional civil religion ceremonies (e.g. 4th of July cookout), got and kept a stable job, and generally deferred to the local culture, social conventions, and moral code (e.g. no loud ethnic music or fireworks at weird times, no opening abortion or gender transition clinics, no complaining about halal/no vegetarian food).

I was just about to say that I tick all of the boxes, except for ever being willing to be a devout member of a church, when I saw that you left open the option of simply participating in civic life.

I can genuinely say, with little doubt, that these are all things or practices I would be happy to do, or at least try, in the case of hunting (I fucking love guns, I want to turn a boar into pink mist with .50 bmg, I also have ADHD so I'd probably have to take meds in order to handle all the waiting around).

Abortion clinics? I'm for abortion being legal, and probably more pro-choice than most. I'm not in the business of opening them, I discarded the family trade of OBGYN.

As a psychiatrist, I also treat gender transitioning as something to be greatly skeptical of. I wouldn't be going around encouraging it, even if I don't really have an issue with trans people and try to be polite in their company.

So I can easily imagine myself settling into a small town, showing up to grill beef steaks with no issues, drinking beer and shooting the shit (and beer cans) with my neighbors and their kids while my own kids, the product of legal and ceremonial marriage, speak to them in English.

Also, just curious, but since you are transhumanist (IIRC) atheist, isn't the social and political climate of the UK much more amenable to your beliefs and political goals? America has a large population of recalcitrant believers in the imago dei, including not a few members of the elite, who completely oppose transhumanism.

The UK will jail you for burning a Koran, and will let the person who assaulted you while brandishing a knife go with bail. It's a state that does secularism entirely wrong, unlike the French, who have the right idea with lacité. America handles freedom of speech and religion far better.

I do not expect to have issues with religious people in the States. I usually keep my religious opinions to myself, except when I'm in an argumentative mood in an online forum with internet strangers. If they don't bother me, I won't bother them beyond not practicing their tenets.

Besides, the bulk of the atheist transhumanists live in the Bay Area. That's my first choice, though I like most of America and would be happy to live there (barring Alaska).

I find this surprising. The US seems to me to be in an unusually weak position to handle technological unemployment

We're approaching a world where Humans Need Not Apply. When that happens, the quality of human capital becomes mostly irrelevant, and things like raw resources, an existing manufacturing base that can be rapidly automated, and a smaller population that needs to subsist off UBI becomes the only real differentiating factors between nations. This is, of course, simplification, AI can take many trajectories, but as of early 2025, we're seeing near parity between the US and China, the latter is only 6 months behind, though it might fall further if chip shortages become the limiting factor.

Surprisingly, by virtue of the world's largest manufacturing base, China is surprisingly well positioned to make the most of automation. A lot of the factories are robotic, and eventually all of them will be.

On the other hand, the US has a decent manufacturing base, albeit one that has seen relative and absolute decline. It is, however, much richer in terms of initial capital, which is what allows rapid scaling once humans are no longer the bottleneck.

Even if the Republicans are against welfare (and my impression is that they're loathe to cut back things that a large portion of what their underemployed and disenfranchised voters require to survive), once we're seeing double digit unemployment, they're going to either be forced to accept UBI, or watch as the majority of the population starves. The latter isn't something I can say won't happen, but the US is large, rich, relatively underpopulated, and has welfare systems that could expand to cover nearly the entire population. I would strongly expect that in the initial turmoil, citizens would be prioritized over all others.

Other countries might be rich. They lack the industry or the raw resources to keep up. What will Singapore be forced to do when most of its services and the highly skilled and educated workforce becomes redundant?

Do you genuinely think I'm not aware of the failures of America? The fent addicts nodding off next to piles of human feces? Ghettos where everyone knows not to go, where shampoo and baby food is kept under lock? Rust Belt towns that have denizens so devoid of hope that they cling to welfare and opioid addictions?

How much of that is "3rd world imports"? Not much. A certain underclass in the country has ancestors who came over, rather unwillingly, several centuries back.

Did the Chinese, Korean and Indian immigrants, probably two or three generations in the country, who fled conditions as bad as the worst of the 3rd world today, show the same dysfunction? Did they fail to assimilate and live off the dole?

I expect to see a lot of awful things in the States. I also expect to see much more good. And of the awful I see, very little of it has anything to do with skilled immigrants. Hell, there are no end of people with kids and grandkids in the middle and upper class now who themselves came over destitute and unable to speak a word of English. Origin matters, and so does filtering.

My condolences. As cases of heartbreak go, I struggle to think of more awful.

All I can say is that the pain will fade, eventually. And you've already met multiple people you've found attractive enough to love, the odds are in your favor that it will happen again, and this time I hope it sticks.

@Throwaway05 has been scaring me with claims of how difficult the USMLE is. He's better positioned to answer this than I am, but I'm personally quite confident that almost nobody who did not actually have the skills and knowledge of an American doctor could make it through the gauntlet. The only way to get those, at present, is med school.

I think you're my special someone, I think I've just got over my heartbreak when ToaKraka shot me down, and I hope the Visa Office does too. DM me your address, shipping is on me!

Look, I'd be just as against opening the floodgates of immigration to Indians as you are.

The worst part of being an Indian in India is being surrounded by other Indians, in much the same way the worst part about poverty is having to live with poor people. Indians have the dual misfortune of being both Indian and poor (usually).

Canada is a clear example of taking things too far. When you're excusing diploma-mills in the country that exist solely to provide a convenient pretext for people to come on a 'student' visa and then start driving taxis with their Punjabi uncle, you're doing skilled immigration wrong.

On the other hand, Indian immigrants in the US and UK are clear success stories. They are usually the richest demographic, often fighting Jews and the Chinese for pole position, and remarkably well assimilated and lacking criminal tendency. Whatever mechanism allows for this to happen is a good one, and at least in the UK, Indian migrants are far more respected than their Pakistani and Bangladeshi subcontinental brethren. They have not imported the same bad habits from their homeland.

When we lived in a major city, we had similar experiences with Indian doctors we visited. There is just this overwhelming sense they don't care. They don't have any duty to service. Any investment in outcomes. There is a script, they get paid, what more do you want? My wife constantly struggled with lingering issues that several Indian doctors (why were they so dominant?) just made scattershot prescriptions for, before finally getting in with an Asian American doctor who was actually invested in solving her problems.

I can't really argue that your personal experiences haven't happened. I can argue that they're not representative. I've been treated by Indian doctors most of my life, and I wouldn't say they were uncaring automata in it for just the amount of money they can squeeze out of you. I necessarily know more doctors, Indians, and Indian doctors than you do, and I think my opinion is more likely to hold true at scale.

But somebody's probably would be if past experience is any indicator. I've never had an experience where an Indian went one millimeter outside of the minimum of their job description to service a customer.

I don't know if you ever noticed, but here I am, on this site, often handling out medical advice for the price of free. We could play games of Chinese Cardiologists all day if we had to. I know I've done more than the bare minimum for more people than I can count.

I've seen very little self awareness from Indians about what they are really fleeing from, or what makes them different. And to whatever degree self_made_human thinks he "knows" America and wants to live here, it just seems like an embarrassing strain of weebism to me. He imagines there is some mechanism by which he could come here, but that very same mechanism wouldn't play a part in destroying America, just the same way I'm certain 1m Americans would seriously fuck up Japan.

The mechanisms that would bring me there would be the same mechanisms that have brought existing Indians to America. And most people have positive opinions of those there. One mechanism that has worked for other Indian doctors is (hopefully temporarily) not an option for me at present. Another has been swung shut.

We strongly disagree on whether the status-quo is a good thing or not, and I don't expect to change your mind in that regard. I object to the status quo moving in a direction I think is worse for the country, and for skilled immigrants.

In fact, I respect your right to want to keep America the way it is, and preserve its culture. I think that I'm culturally American more than anything else, you can call me a Texaboo if you like, but can you deny that the average weeb loves Japan? Maybe I have more faith in the spirit of America than you do, it has assimilated tens of millions, it can take a million more, especially if they're a million like the ones who came before.

Dextroamphetamine report:

I finally got my first supply of dextroamphetamine, the cool enantiomer. This wasn't as simple as I'd like, I've previously kvertched about my psychiatrist making a minor prescription error that delayed things by a week, but I finally picked up the amended prescription, looked and it sideways and upside down, and then took the long bus ride back home and my local pharmacy.

I submitted my new prescription, and then found myself waiting.

And waiting.

And waiting some more. I could hear the rattle of lock boxes, and harried pharmacy technicians muttering under their breath as they figured things out. One of them scooched past me, carrying a box of what I hoped were my tablets, as well as what was clearly my prescription, before disappearing into an ominous 'Consultation Room'.

He proceeded to come and go several times, and for the short snatches of time the door was ajar, I managed to catch several glimpses of a senior-looking pharmacist doing inscrutable pharmacist things (I just write prescriptions, whatever happens afterwards isn't my forte).

Eventually, after a good twenty minutes of waiting, this senior pharmacist comes out. He asks me to confirm my name. I do. Then my date of birth. Which I do too.

Then he asks me if I've written this prescription myself.

Huh. No, I say, I mean, I very much wish I could have, it would have saved me a great deal of bother.

He puts on his reading glasses and peers at the label, then looks back at me. You sure you didn't write this?

Pretty sure. Though I did explain I'm a psychiatry resident myself.

Then he goes ahh, realizing the error. The Nigerian psychiatrist I saw, through some trick of the phonetic gods, happened to have a name that resembles mine. I mean, it's a very, very distant resemblance, you'd have to be half deaf to confuse the two of us.

You could also be half-blind, as they're spelled nowhere near alike. The GP practice that I signed up for was kind enough to append the actual "Dr." prefix before my name, and for a good 20 minutes, I presume the pharmacists had been arguing amongst themselves about whether I was writing myself a prescription for controlled substances, and whether they ought to do anything about it.

I mean, it is technically legal (with the possible exception of stimulants unless you're a licensed psychiatrist) for doctors to write themselves a prescription for anything. The GMC are just prudish assholes who frown heavily upon it, and hence everyone who values their license avoids it unless it's clearly unimpeachable. I doubt they'd fire me if I'd written myself up for paracetamol.

Anyway, I cleared up that mixup, but was informed that unfortunately, they didn't have enough tablets for an entire month's supply. Fortunately, they did provide me enough for three weeks, and more should come in soon. Half the reason I opted for dexedrine/dextroamphetamine is because it's rarely prescribed, and wouldn't be as likely to be in critical shortage.

I've taken a single 5mg tablet so far, and I can tell you it feels way superior to methylphenidate/Ritalin. 5mg of dexedrine is roughly 10mg of the latter, but even that low dose of Ritalin makes me feel sick, jittery and anxious, and yes, even using the sustained release formulation. This feels almost mellow, just the focus without the palpitations and headaches. Me likey.

It's too early to make a conclusive judgement, but so far I'm glad I didn't just stick to the drug I was familiar with.

Edit:

I took a total of 10mg, and while it did make me hyper-focus, I'm afraid that it doesn't entirely solve distractability. I ended up procrastinating quite a bit, and only read a few pages of my textbook. To be fair, I was interrupted, and just wasn't feeling like studying after a hectic morning.

At that dose, it became very slightly less pleasant, but still nowhere near as bad as the lowest dose of Ritalin. I think it's been long enough for it to start wearing off, and to my great relief, it's nowhere near as harsh when it comes to comedowns. Ritalin would leave me feeling absolutely burnt out and irritated.

Dopamine-release 1, dopamine-reuptake-inhibition 0 (this is grossly simplified pharmacology)

An interesting topic, I might be a Xianxia fan, but I've only read 4 whole novels!

(That was probably 20 million words, so make of that what you will)

I'll take your suggestion into account, it is a pet subject of mine, as my enthusiasm should show.

It's a bummer you're not a bummer. :(

Now what am I supposed to do, glue all that hair back on?

London is exorbitantly expensive. You have to either be very well off or very poor to live there without penny pinching, paradoxically. That's because the latter is often given free council housing in areas where free-market prices would be several thousands of pounds for a house in rent a month.

Most other cities are much better off in comparison, Edinburgh is expensive, but not the point it scares people away.

My main gripe is that I'm not being paid free-market wages. The NHS is a monopsony employer, and has a stranglehold on medical residencies and higher training. Doctors have faced sub-inflation pay raises for over a decade now, and even the meek and conflict-avoidant British doctors took to the streets in protest not that long ago. This lead to a recent pay uplift, but nowhere near enough to account for cumulative inflation. More or less every year, you face a gradual real-terms pay cut.

I am not strapped for cash, but only because I live well below my means and have no dependents. When I consider what I'd end up paying for things like childcare (I expect I'll marry another working professional, if not necessarily a doctor), it's rather eye watering. I don't think things like groceries or rents are significantly lower than the States, and housing prices have to account for the fact that UK housing is tiny compared to the former.

And regardless of the precise COL, which can vary substantially like you think, there's no way that the double or triple pay raise the US represents is beaten by it. Proportionally, I'd pay much less for private insurance than I would for the NHS, through taxes.

For 3, I think the climate sucks here too. But I've always lived in the northeast. Here the skies are gray 3/4 of the year.

That's the beauty of the States, you can choose to live anywhere from subtropical marshland to arctic conditions or a baking desert. I'd head to somewhere where the winters didn't last over 4 months.

6 is interesting. I feel the opposite, but maybe it's because I've lived here my whole life.

It's by far the most subjective claim I make. Some people, like @2rafa would claim that London is unmatched for its vibes and culture. I wasn't particularly impressed myself. I would absolutely take the Bay Area every time over anything that the UK offers, but others have different preferences.

That said, if you hang around Trafalgar Square you will probably still be fed illegally by tourists.

And here I was thinking the London banding didn't nearly account for additional cost of living, I appreciate the culinary advice!

You would know more than me – are there any efforts to substantially screen people to ensure they agree with American ideology? Specifically American ideology, no generic 'Western democratic values' – I'm talking no-holds-barred free speech, right to bear arms, rule of law and private property, a federalized system where the states are important and sovereign, freedom of religion.

I personally endorse all of these, so I wouldn't be worried about some kind of test of American Values. Hell, the fact that the UK lacks these is a driving reason behind my desire to treat it like a temporary pitstop.

I'm shaving my butthole as we speak, see you at the aisle!

I would if I could! The same American NGO that certifies international doctors as being eligible for the USMLE, is also relied upon by other Commonwealth countries to vet applicants.

The UK still has delusions of grandeur, and has their own certification pathway without entirely outsourcing that bit to an American org. Unfortunately, this doesn't provide a way to side-step the issues with my original med school, even if my higher training is recognized by Australia and New Zealand.

Otherwise I'd probably be replying back at an awkward time zone, as soon as I was safe from drop bear attack.

Thank you. It can occasionally be thankless work, I don't enjoy having to rap people on the knuckles, so if someone who underwent that still considers me a decent mod, I'm glad.

We try our best!

The answer is: It depends.

What kind of doctor? As a psychiatrist, I don't think my work would look very different in either country, but I know which one would pay me double or triple. At the very least, American doctors have the option of cutting back their hours while still making more than we do.

I think in most other specialities, doctors are just about as harried and overworked, but it's hard to say for sure.

The UK isn't a terrible place. It's about adequate, as a country where I could see myself residing and settling in, and it certainly beats India in most regards.

It's just that the US is better on almost all the metrics I personally care about:

  1. The pay is important to me. It's not my only concern, or I'd be considering places like the Middle East that lavish money on doctors with western training with more glee. US physician salaries can be double or triple that of British doctors.

  2. The UK is an authoritarian country, politely authoritarian in the quintessential British way , but authoritarian nonetheless. My freedom of speech is significantly curtailed. The US is the closest the planet truly has to a bastion of true free speech and freedom of association.

  3. The climate sucks. Scotland is lovely in the summer and early autumn, but I'd very much prefer sunnier climes, and even further down south in England isn't what I consider ideal.

  4. I identify with American political values and ideals far more than I do with British ones. Not in every case, but more often than not. I want to shoot full-auto AR-15s when I can dawg.

  5. I'm strongly concerned about technological unemployment, and the US is one of the countries that is most capable of weathering the storm without too much social disruption. This isn't something that can be taken for granted, but it has a much better manufacturing base than the UK does, and is far wealthier overall.

  6. I also think the States is far more vibrant and interesting, the UK is tiny, and Europe can be nice to visit, but I still prefer the States.

As far as I can tell, there's no way an Indian doctor can practise in the States without clearing the USMLE.

That is a protracted process, and there is identity verification involved. If a licensing exam can't rule out fraudulent or unqualified candidates, it's not worth the name.

Just being a doctor is of little value, they want you to prove equivalency.

I don't think I'm making a controversial claim if I say that the people who can manage to spend $1 million on investments in the States, while employing 10 people, are rather likely to be net-positive taxpayers.

For the record, despite being a mod myself, I had no part in this discussion. I was too busy replying to people to even notice while that was underway, in case anyone thinks that negativity expressed towards moderators is treated differently.

As you've previously mentioned, there is at least the possibility of having residency requirements waived if you can show experience and equivalency.

The waivers for IMGs in under-served areas don't specify a specialty, but I presume that at least some of the hospitals or practices looking for doctors would be in need of psychiatrists.

I'd be happy to take my chances, and I know I'll have to work for it. If I can't make the cut, then there's nobody to blame but myself. I'd have chased my dreams and failed, instead of nursing bitterness over the fact that factors beyond my power prevented me from trying.

And not just any Indian doctor. I think it's entirely fair to say that my values, attitudes and beliefs are far closer to American than Indian.

Hell, even the way I talk, I've been asked dozens of times by Brits if I'm an American based on my accent.

But yes, I sincerely doubt that the average American would be against a foreign doctor who had passed all the competency requirements, and had even gone through training in a Western country.

My impression is that Trump ran on reducing illegal immigration, and to the extent that there are quasi-legals like asylum seekers, he wanted them gone too.

I am not aware of him wanting all immigration reduced. He has been remarkably inconsistent when it comes to skilled immigration, but even the new Golden Ticket is framed as a play to snag wealthy immigrants while reducing the national debt.

To reduce debt, you want more money. Ergo this is a bad idea on its own merits.

Have you considered staying inside your home country?

Certainly. I have, on further consideration, decided not to.

Americans overwhelmingly voted to lower immigration - Trump’s policies aren’t a "suggestion" or some miscalculation, they’re the people’s choice. It's quite selfish to continue to game the system in the face of this.

Americans have voted against illegal immigration. Against people hopping the border. You could also say that they're against the expansion of asylum seeking, and that would be true.

Skilled immigration is nowhere near as unpopular, I'd have to look up polls, but I recall it being seen as a positive across the aisle.

Trump is keeping his promises this term, but in a ham-fisted way. You can address illegal immigration while not worsening the already difficult process of legal immigration.

It's quite selfish to continue to game the system in the face of this.

Now, my dear friend. Do I look like an illegal migrant or an asylum seeker?

How exactly have I "gamed" the system? By trying my absolute best to sort out the impediments that would prevent me from legally moving to the States as a doctor? By considering an entirely legal class of visa, the EB5?

I have to ask - do you not feel uncomfortable coming to a country where the people do not want you there? I know I could not make such a move.

I'd be uncomfortable if this was true. It's not.

Here's a handy link to a previous post about my desire to move to the States, where I discussed my desperate efforts to make a now ex-girlfriend understand how amazing the States is as a country, and how its flaws are overplayed.

It's on this very forum. It has 70 upvotes at the time of writing, probably putting it in the top 0.1% of posts ever by popularity.

You are welcome to count the number of people who sympathized with my desire, and clearly said they wanted me to achieve my goal. There are people there inviting me to their homes, offering to show me around, take me out shooting.

They dwarf the mere two or three people who said they didn't want me around. Feel free to look yourself.

I am a law-abiding, responsible highly-trained professional in one of the most respected professions around. I'm articulate, fluent in English at a native level, an anglophile and a big fan of the United States. I hold nuanced political views and am friends with people on both sides of the political spectrum. I nurse no ethnic grudges, I'm not seeking to displace or replace anyone. I'm as Westernized as it gets, and my personal views and beliefs, if they were material, are those you could find in any number of Americans. I'd probably be working in under-served communities that your local doctors avoid if they can help it.

I invite you to present to me an example of someone you think would be a better candidate for an immigrant.

Even in the UK, almost everyone I've met has liked me, and been glad to have my presence. That includes old people at bars who complain about Pakis while telling me they vote SNP, that gentleman ended up saying I was one of the good ones and tried to set me up with a bartender.

I rest my case.