@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

Look, you're being too harsh on me.

When I say I had active suicidal ideation, I meant it. The barrier between suicidal ideation and an attempt is tenuous at best.

I wasn't very far at some points. I never actively planned things, but at certain points, if someone had come up and put a gun in my hand, I can't say for sure what would have happened.

Public attitude prior to about the 90s was suicide is wrong. Flat out wrong. Then euthanasia become a cause for terminal patients suffering from incurable cancers and the like, people in constant suffering. But it would never go past that the medical establishment insisted, and it would certainly never be trivialised by being offered to the depressed. 25 years later and the depressed can get assisted suicide. It is an example of the concept creep pusher_robot mentioned.

Norms change over time, and we're talking 30 years. The people who might have made the original claims could easily be dead or retired.

Governments have changed multiple times since. Culture would have changed even without strong pushes. It's not the same set of people making promises and breaking them the moment backs are turned.

I strongly disagree that there's any "trivialization" involved in offering it to the incurably and severely depressed. They're living miserable lives, even if we can't clearly and legibly figure out what's gone wrong with them. That's just the state of psychiatry today.

I would strongly push back against it being offered to people who hadn't exhausted the treatment options for their depression. What else can I say?

This pretty much sums it up for me. Yeah bud, I know it's unavoidable, that's been my point from the beginning. The fact that you would level it back at me as if that somehow excuses it is the core problem with the modern world. It's the death of a thousand cuts, responsibility is diffused so nobody has to own the psychological consequences of their actions and we say 'hey they have the freedom right? You aren't opposed to freedom are you? I didn't hand them a gun!' Sure you knew you were taking actions that would result in their deaths, but they could have just spent 700 pounds to ask a doctor to promise to never kill them during one of the infrequent periods when they could even see something resembling a future for themselves! How is that on you?

I am a consequentialist. I seek to maximize my values, finding compromise where they conflict with each other.

I strongly value personal liberty and freedom, including control of one's life. I also value other people living on, preferably as happy and satisfied as they can be.

I'm not lying or denying that there are clear downsides and tradeoffs involved. I just think that they're worth it.

You offer me a bullet, and I'm biting it.

You might value things differently, and that's your prerogative.

I would be willing to perform the kinds of roles my envisioned system would require. It would be difficult and emotionally taxing work, but most doctors eventually understand, through bitter experience, that not all patients can be saved. Sometimes everything that can be done had been done, and you're keeping a corpse hooked up on life support. Sometimes it's not that clear cut, but they consistently report that their life is misery while being otherwise physically well. If I can't save them, then prolonging their life against their wishes is as bad as putting a confused elderly woman with dementia on the ventilator so she can spend another week in pain and terror before her inevitable death.

Well you're right, it's not. Congratulations on winning the argument.

I guess it's on me for expecting you to actually grapple with the issue because you claim to have suffered depression. I should have realised you wouldn't be able to empathise when you explained that you had never been suicidal.

I never came into this with the desire to win an argument. If this passes as a victory, I want it even less than you do.

I'm doing my best to explain why I hold the views I do. That I am aware of your values and concerns, and the downsides of my own desires. I still think the price worth paying, and not because I'm not empathetic. I wouldn't be a psychiatrist if I didn't want to help people. I some rare circumstances, that help would be for them to no longer live on.

I think we both know that even if I was willing to go to any lengths to get in, admitting to fraudulent intent in an online forum is a bad idea haha. Even a pseudonymous one.

I think it's nigh inevitable that we're all unmasked by AI doing stylometry. My OP-sec is far from perfect, and there's enough unique information about me out there that a determined human adversary could manage. I even nurse minor ambitions of becoming a Proper Blogger some day, and that just increases the attack surface.

In all honesty, I want it to be as legal as I can make it. I could certainly afford a flight to Guatemala or Nicaragua and find a mule, but I don't want to live the life of an illegal immigrant. The medical profession in UK might not be ideal, but it beats that as far as I'm concerned!

As for finding a legitimate American wife, the easiest way is to be in America. Most Americans are sensible enough not to move to either the UK or India. Most of them would also prefer that their husband be gainfully employed.

To practise as a doctor in the States requires me to be eligible for the USMLE and then pass it. I've been keeping a close eye on the recent trend of many individual US states waiving the residency requirement, but to my dismay, there isn't one that does away with the USMLE altogether, not even if I were a senior clinician who had finished their higher training in a peer medical system like the UK. They usually ask that such candidates work in under-served rural areas, but I can deal with that.

(This is true, the bit about being peers. The NHS is certainly poorer, but not to that extent. We've got the same things you do in your private hospitals, we just have to dole the expensive stuff out much more begrudgingly. And psychiatry? You can't get away with just a pen and paper these days, but it isn't a very demanding field in terms of equipment)

I'd strongly prefer to continue working as a doctor. I haven't entirely ruled out a pivot to something that is non-clinical, which would let me work in the States, but many options take additional degrees and loads of time. Time I don't think I have, with the pace of progress in AI.

A friend of mine, from the same med school, ended up doing a PhD in Public Health in Texas and now works with the big names, but the ideal time for me to have done that would have been 3 years in the past.

If I did so now, not only would I be taking up educational debt, I'd be losing out on several years of earnings. This wouldn't mean shit in India, but since I'm already in the UK..

You can see how complicated things are. If I had to rank my options:

  1. Practice in the US as a doctor and settle down there. Highly desired, not impossible, but time consuming.

1.5) If that USMLE issue is fixed, I would also be able to go to countries that are better off than the UK and pay doctors well. Think Canada or NZ, the same obstacle blocks all of them. Slightly lower payoff than the States, but I'd be happy with it.

  1. Continue training in the UK and resign myself to life here. It beats India. This is more or less something I can count on.

  2. Discard clinical medicine and do something that doesn't have so much regulatory red tape, and try to get into the States that way. Uncertain odds, massive opportunity costs if I have to quit my job and training program.

Now, if some lovely lady becomes so enamored by my hobby of arguing with strangers online that she wants to marry me, I might not say no haha. If I was a US citizen, then I could apply for jobs that think that even if my medical credentials aren't directly applicable, it's proof of general competence.

I do wish I was, and my impression is that most of you would be happy to have me.

Yes.

Thank you. I'd have linked to the same post on the Motte if I wasn't too tired to dig through my profile. If you were one of the people who had said it back then, I appreciate you, and I do now.

I think I'd be a fine American. Let's see if that pans out, my life hasn't been entirely terrible outside of it.

In an ideal world, I'd have already given the USMLE and would have whatever visa was offered to international medical graduates doing a residency in the States.

This is still a goal of mine, assuming the blocking factor is finished by the time I finish my current British training in psychiatry. The issue is that my med school doesn't have a sponsor note from an American organization called the ECFMG. It is entitled to one, it meets the recently updated requirements in full, but the last time I had them reach out to the ECFMG, all we heard were crickets. Even then, it's a process that can take years, both due to the ECFMG being lazy, and the Indian National Medical Council being even lazier.

If I saw that coveted tick box, I'd likely drop everything that wasn't strictly necessary for me to remain in my job, and begin grinding for the USMLE. I entered psych training in the UK both because I want to be a shrink, and so I can at least have a backup if the blocker never resolves.

I also had another fallback, namely the EB5 visa described above. It was about $1 million invested in the States, as well as starting a business that employed ten Americans. Now it's $5 million, the rest being unchanged (I could be wrong about minor details).

This wouldn't let work as a doctor, not without also giving the USMLE, and it would represent liquidating parental assets. If I really needed it, they'd probably oblige, and UK doctor salaries are shite so it would take me decades to save up enough by myself. But at least it was an option. $5 million? Not happening before my kids would be as old as I am.

You can see @TheDag's post below about the Golden Tickets that replace the EB5. As I've mentioned, it's five times the previous price, which only let in about ten thousand people taking previously. At 5 million, I wouldn't be surprised if the numbers dropped down to a thousand or less.

Raising the Price of Admission

I find myself immensely frustrated by Trump's recent moves to cut down on immigration, especially replacing the EB5 with his new golden ticket scheme.

I've always wanted to move to the States, but by virtue of being Indian, and in a profession with strict regulatory requirements, it was never easy. As of right now, I can't sit for the USMLE if I wanted to, but I believe that is a problem my uni could solve, unfortunately I'm locked into the UK for at least 3 more years and don't have the time to breathe down their necks.

If I wanted to spend $1 million for the old EB5, I'd probably have to sell a significant fraction of my familial assets, and they're not mine yet, I have a sibling and parents to think of. The fact that we even have that much, when my father made $50k at the peak of his career as a OBGYN surgeon, represents a lifetime of my parents being frugal and living beneath their means. My dad started out from scratch, a penniless refugee, and all his life he worked tirelessly to make sure his kids wouldn't have to work as hard as he did. To a degree, he's succeeded. I nearly make as much as he does, but that's virtue of grinding my ass off to escape India. I had to settle for the UK, whereas I'd much rather be in the States.

The EB-5 program already functioned as a high barrier to entry, requiring not just capital but also the ability to invest in ways that met the job creation criteria. By raising the price to $5 million, the U.S. is effectively signaling that it no longer wants "entrepreneurial upper-middle-class" immigrants - it only wants the ultra-wealthy. The problem, is that the truly ultra-wealthy already have multiple options. The US is relatively unique in dual-taxation, and has heavier taxes overall when compared to some of the alternatives. They can buy citizenship in other countries (Malta, St. Kitts, etc.), take advantage of residence-by-investment programs in the EU, or just maintain an arsenal of visas that allow them to live anywhere they please. The U.S. loses out on exactly the kind of people who were willing to put down roots and contribute significantly to the economy while still needing the opportunities that U.S. citizenship provides.

If Trump (or any administration) wanted a truly meritocratic system, they should be auctioning off a limited number of economic immigrant slots each year. That would at least allow market forces to determine the actual value of U.S. residency. A points-based system, like Canada’s or Australia’s, could also make more sense: prioritizing skilled professionals over sheer wealth. A million already strongly filters would-be immigrants. Five is exorbitant, especially if it's a flat sum.

(Let's leave aside the other requirements, such as running a business that creates a certain number of jobs)

Jevon's paradoxmakes us expect that increasing the price of a good by 5 times will not 5x the revenue. It'll decrease it in expectation. If Trump prizes himself as a businessman, this should be clear to him.

Even the abolition of birthright citizenship strikes me as a violation of the American ethos. It was certainly being abused, anchor babies being a case in point, but when even green cards are this hard to get, prospective skilled migrants greatly appreciate the peace of mind that their kids are entitled to citizenship provides.

End it for illegal immigrants if you have to, why lump in everyone else there legitimately? I wouldn't mind people using their visitor visas to get a fast one in being debarred too, but I look at the current state of affairs with great dismay.

At any rate, I'm not an American. I do wish I was, and my impression is that most of you would be happy to have me. Well, I'm used to life being rough, and the UK isn't the worst place I could be. I still think that even from an absolutely monetary point of view, this is a bad plan.

I hope I've made a decent case for why you're not getting much out filtering the immigrants for quality at that point, and the ones who are that loaded are probably not nearly as keen. They're easily Global Citizens for whom nationality is a formality.

Well, I'm still going to see if I manage to figure out the USMLE thing by the time my training in the UK ends, but there must be thousands of skilled immigrants in a similar boat, just noticing a rather significant leak in it. Then they're confronted by a sign at Eliis Island that just any ocean-crossing vessel won't do, they need a yacht. We don't deserve to be clubbed in with those who break the rules.

My point was supposed to be that we had previously been assured that assisted suicide would never be used for anything except terminal illness and certainly never for depression, and yet here we are.

As I've said above, I consider an intractable case of severe depression to be a terminal illness. I have no personal involvement in matters of euthanasia (beyond deciding if a patient is palliative and needs comfort care).

I presume that you're not in the Netherlands either, so when you say that "we were assured", who's the we?

I didn't provide that assurance, and regardless of whether, in the Netherlands, it was in fact a statement made some kind of authoritative figure, I consider this particular case an outcome I endorse!

And the case seems to be entering litigation, so it's not like the government ignored objections and killed the woman right away. I presume a court will rule on whether the actual law allows this.

If you point to an example of a clearly inappropriate decision for euthanasia, say someone who went to their doctors and said they're feeling sad, and that was the first suggestion made, then I would certainly say that's against my views.

You live in a world where you see doctors all day every day so talking to one is nothing, hell you can do all that shit yourself if you like, but otherwise your buddy will bang it out for you as a favour after work.

I do see doctors every day. But I'm afraid that they're unable to help me in any way, in terms of medical problems that require a prescription and not just casual advice.

In the UK, the GMC strongly frowns on prescribing or treating colleagues, I have ADHD, there are several senior psychiatrists who could have written me a prescription for my meds. I even asked, but as expected, they declined, saying it was inappropriate.

I personally think this is bullshit, and I should personally have been allowed to write my own script if needed (though stimulants require a psychiatrist who has completed training). In India, it wouldn't have been an issue at all.

I had to wait three months to be seen by a psychiatrist for my depression. I took the opportunity to also get him to prescribe for my ADHD. But if it had been just my ADHD, then I would have had to wait 2 years to be seen!

Trust me, at least in the UK, getting a doctor to see you, even if you're a doctor yourself, isn't trivial at all. I won't deny that they take me more seriously as a fellow medical professional, if I were to tell a psychiatrist I'm clinically depressed and I calculated it to be moderate-severe, they'll take me at my word. But the typical doctor will not react to someone telling them they're suicidal and don't want to be in a dismissive manner.

You live in a world where you see doctors all day every day so talking to one is nothing, hell you can do all that shit yourself if you like, but otherwise your buddy will bang it out for you as a favour after work. I live in a world where every fifteen minutes I spend with a doctor costs me $90, I can address one issue and if I bring up another it will cost me another $90 even if the last one only took two minutes to address. I do not go to the doctor unless I have no choice and I am incapacitated. And in my working class social circles I am considered a hypochondriac. I am regularly told that I trust doctors too much. That is the world I live in about half the time, and those people are not going to the doctor to ask him or her to promise not to kill them if they ask. I don't think you or @Throwaway05 understand how shot trust in medicine is amongst the working class. It's kind of terrifying.

Look, if I had ended up giving up on waiting for the NHS and gone private, I'd be paying anywhere from 400 to 700 pounds for an appointment that could be anywhere from 15 minutes to an hour. You can see how the rates compare.

And it might surprise you, but it's entirely possible that you make more money than I do! As a resident, I make about $50k a year. That would be well within the range of what a working class individual makes in the States. It's entirely possible for a skilled tradesperson in the States to out earn a senior doctor in the UK. If they start a small business and stick to it, they can leave us in the dirt.

And the cost of living in the UK is probably quite comparable to the US, while we pay more in tax to boot. I'm much closer to you than @Throwaway05 is in financial terms. I have technically free access to healthcare courtesy of taxes paid to the NHS, but even that isn't much good for anything but an ER visit straight away, or an appointment with a GP in weeks/months.

In case this is the point of confusion, I'm not concerned about that, I'm not concerned about me at all, I have the perspective of age now. I am worried about the young adults out there like me when I was a young adult, the undiagnosed schizophrenics (and the undiagnosed bipolars and major depressives) who would never give strangers power of deciding their fate, believe suicide is a personal decision and only hold back because of a sense of wrongness. Those people are going to die in your world before a doctor even knows there is something wrong.

It is unavoidable that media coverage of suicide, or more permissive social norms, will likely increase the number of people opting to commit it both through (hypothetical) legal means as well as taking it on themselves.

I value free speech and personal autonomy strongly enough that I do not foresee the numbers rising to the point that I can't accept the cost, even if I wish it wasn't so.

Aww.. I don't mean to, I'm fond of this place (or I wouldn't volunteer my time to janny it, let alone have >3k comments). I've already had the value of my free time multiplied massively courtesy of the large nominal and relative pay raise going from a third world country to a (debatable) first world one entails, and I'm still here haha.

Even if I was purely mercenary, I think that half of the AAQCs I write are in response to things someone else said over here. It's a fertile breeding ground for ideas and strong arguments for said ideas, not many places like it out there.

Hmm.. That sounds sensible to me, and roughly what I expected/feared. Still, I'll probably give it a shot, given that I write anyway for this audience, then I don't think I'm doing too much extra work, and it has its upsides. Thanks!

It genuinely seems to me that the case you linked to is the system working as intended. I'm 100% serious:

An article about her case, published in April, was picked up by international media, prompting an outcry that caused Ter Beek huge distress.

She said it was understandable that cases such as hers – and the broader issue of whether assisted dying should be legal – were controversial. “People think that when you’re mentally ill, you can’t think straight, which is insulting,” she told the Guardian. “I understand the fears that some disabled people have about assisted dying, and worries about people being under pressure to die.

“But in the Netherlands, we’ve had this law for more than 20 years. There are really strict rules, and it’s really safe.”

Under Dutch law, to be eligible for an assisted death, a person must be experiencing “unbearable suffering with no prospect of improvement”. They must be fully informed and competent to take such a decision.

...

Ter Beek’s difficulties began in early childhood. She has chronic depression, anxiety, trauma and unspecified personality disorder. She has also been diagnosed with autism. When she met her partner, she thought the safe environment he offered would heal her. “But I continued to self-harm and feel suicidal.”

She embarked on intensive treatments, including talking therapies, medication and more than 30 sessions of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). “In therapy, I learned a lot about myself and coping mechanisms, but it didn’t fix the main issues. At the beginning of treatment, you start out hopeful. I thought I’d get better. But the longer the treatment goes on, you start losing hope.”

After 10 years, there was “nothing left” in terms of treatment. “I knew I couldn’t cope with the way I live now.” She had thought about taking her own life but the violent death by suicide of a schoolfriend and its impact on the girl’s family deterred her.

She has a point. If you're not familiar with the management of severe depression, then by the time you reach ECT, you've exhausted all the options. I don't know if she tried things along the lines of ketamine or psychedelics, but those don't work for everyone.

She's tried everything, it didn't work, and she's clearly suffering immensely.

This woman, the purported victim, seems entirely lucid and defending the medical establishment that's carrying out her wishes. What more can you possibly ask for? It is clearly not spur of the moment decision, she's engaged with the options that the medical field can offer her.

The only thing that I would (personally) say that strikes me as untrue is that there "there's no hope". I think I have strong reasons to hope got a cure for depression, but that isn't a certainty, and could take decades even for myself.

If someone doesn't have the same degree of confidence in future medicine or a technological singularity, then I think that's acceptable shorthand. Strictly speaking, there's always a possibility that someone might just develop a brain tumor that makes them not depressed (or at least makes them manic), but that's not particularly reliable.

A world where the water we breathe says 'suicide is an option actually' instead of 'suicide is a tragedy'. I am strong enough in this world to not submit to despair, but I don't know if I would be strong enough in that world. Not when that black dog has me and suicide seems like the only chance for something resembling relief.

Suicide is always an option, regardless of what the law has to say in that regard. It is also often a tragedy. The two aren't mutually incompatible statements!

In the UK, we have things called living wills or advanced care plans. In your case, since you're afraid that you might make the wrong call during a depressive spiral, in my described world, I would advocate that you draft something along those lines so that any doctor who isn't malevolent (in a manner that breaks the law at that point) would note that you don't you don't want to die, and stymie it then.

Would you prefer I say that I don't necessarily not believe you? That sounds more awkward to me, but I hope you can see what I meant.

I don't necessarily disbelieve you. But the level of justification for lockdowns at Day Zero, 30, 90 and 365 varied significantly.

Remember that in the very early days, we genuinely weren't sure of COVID's CFR, if there's a disease that's spreading like wildfire and you aren't sure it won't kill tens or hundreds of millions, then I think an initial lockdown is sensible. Once it becomes clear that it's nowhere as bad as it was thought, and the primary risk was for old and sick people, then lockdowns should have been lifted. I don't think that this was obvious until several months in, and I was doing my best to stay abreast. There was genuine terror that I and other doctors could catch it, and that it had a very real chance of killing us. I think around 3 months in, I was personally feeling safer, but still worried about spreading it to the elderly members of my family, and still was right up till vaccines became available.

Do you have better alternatives? At the end of the day, if you're unhappy with the government, then you need to elect a better government. I presume that it wouldn't be impossible to strip bureaucrats of their immunity if the laws was changed to reflect that. What else could I really advise, that someone shoot Fauci?

In a way, the new Republican government reflects the deep unrest with previous medical policy. RFK isn't a fan of vaccines.

The reason I advocate for governments having the ability to impose lockdowns and quarantines is because pandemics can be highly dangerous. Covid was initially believed to have a ~1-10%% CFR for the first few weeks, and on the higher end, the serious possibility of several hundred million people dying justifies some action be taken. I think a month is enough to narrow the CFR down, leaving aside the primary benefit of reducing spread.

I've bitten the bullet on creating a substack. There's nothing to see there just yet, but if anyone has advice or suggestions, I'd love to hear them! Does anyone happen to know if substack's organic discovery is any good? I'm not going to spend money on advertising, or spam, so I don't know what to expect.

Working plan: Await next post of mine that would be a certified club banger, and then use that to announce its existence, here and on /r/Slatestarcodex.

I think I have a sizable backlog of essays I could easily copy and paste, just to flesh it out further.

I've bitten the bullet on creating a substack. There's nothing to see there just yet, but if anyone has advice or suggestions, I'd love to hear them! Does anyone happen to know if substack's organic discovery is any good? I'm not going to spend money on advertising, or spam, so I don't know what to expect.

Working plan: Await next post of mine that would be a certified club banger, and then use that to announce its existence, here and on /r/Slatestarcodex.

I think I have a sizable backlog of essays I could easily copy and paste, just to flesh it out further.

I'm a radical transhumanist who aspires to live forever, and wants that for everyone else. I can't think of any conclusive argument that proves beyond reasonable doubt that such measures won't be taken to a place that's not palatable for me, and I really wish I had them.

I just think it's worth a shot, even as a small pilot program.

Even if this never happens, I wouldn't lose sleep over it. I think that the kind of person who was that intent on dying would find a way, you don't have to be a doctor to figure out ways to kill yourself. It just makes it easier to achieve without leaving a mess.

Clayton Atraeus managed it, and he was down to two arms and a head.

Quite confident. If my heterodox views are any indication, I'm not someone particularly susceptible to conformity or peer pressure. How many people do you think were born and raised in my circumstances and turned out the way I did? I defy neat classification.

If society was unchanged in terms of medical technology and overall technological progress, but actively encouraged suicide, I still don't think I'd opt for it. I'd demand that every possible treatment be tried first, then possibly ask for a legal document put in place that debarred me from applying for a lengthy period of time, no matter the cause. I'd spend the rest of my life hoping for a cure, and wouldn't give up until I was dying of other causes. If I really wanted to die, I already have more opportunities than I can count (not that the average person doesn't, bridges and busses aren't rare objects).

Do note that I would prefer that even if euthanasia on demand was an option, that there were multiple safe-guards in place to minimize impulse decisions. That would include medical review for reversible causes, counseling with therapists paid a bonus for every patient they talk out of it (to align incentives), and a wait time of a few months. If at any point someone has second thoughts, the wait time gets pushed back another few months.

Hell, keep it a secret under NDA that the first time they put you in the suicide pod, it's actually a drill. If you start screaming and want to be let out, that's when they tell you and swear you to secrecy. Even during the real thing, leave a big red button that would stop the process, if it's a lethal drug, have a bottle of antidote by their side when they're given it.

There was an incredibly poignant video of an elderly francophone lady taking her euthanasia meds for a terminal illness. She was lucid and in absolute control, and speaking till she went to sleep and never woke up. That's what I want the average person who takes this route to look like.

At that point, I'd be content that we're looking at people with incurable illnesses who can't be talked out of their intent. My confidence in an eventual cure for almost all disease isn't so strong that I would demand people hold out for it, that's their choice to make. My choice, at every point in the 10+ years I've been depressed, is to live for a better future.

I've never met an anti-vaxxer in person, though I'm not usually in the business of handling vaccinations! I agree that if you establish a good therapeutic relationship, it's possible to make people come around.

I do wonder if some of your surprise comes from being in India during COVID - the way things felt in the UK or US vs India may make for some difference in experience or expectation?

India was far more sane about lockdowns. I think ours lasted 4 to 6 months, and eventually the government realized it was economically untenable if nothing else.

We never had an anti-vax movement of note, everyone and their dog was fighting for a shot when they became available.

I actually don't know what it was like in the UK at the time, it wasn't on my radar nearly as much as the US was. All I remember is reading about scandals where Dominic Cummings was caught partying during the same time the government was demanding everyone stay home.

I think importing doctors from poor countries gives you doctors with lower than average amounts of empathy.

I think I've got plenty of empathy, or at least the average as doctors go. That being said, while empathy is always nice to have in a doctor, I'd personally prefer one that was incredibly competent at addressing your problems even if they weren't tearing up over your plight.

Seeing human misery up close creates calloused human beings.

Would you say that a doctor who volunteers for the MSF has lower empathy because of their experience with crushing poverty and disease? Probably not, though I'm happy to note there are selection effects involved. What about one that grew up in an inner-city ghetto but was bright enough to enter med school? Is that a bad thing?

I've seen crushing poverty, and when I volunteered to transfer to one of the largest hospitals in my home country (to work for free), I saw things that emotionally wrecked me. As the essay notes, you either harden your heart or exsanguinate.

It didn't make me a worse doctor, quite the contrary. I went out of my way to help people, and still do.

There's preliminary evidence that Ozempic helps with addictions, but it's far from conclusively established, and won't be for another year or three.

You call the med reg when you want a pigeon removed from the ward. You call the psych reg when you want the pigeon removed from existence.

(With your username, you're best off avoiding the UK like the plague.)

Doctors go through lengthy training, but while you can't just walk into a hospital and ask to become an intern, the textbooks are free, and so is most of the research and literature (if you know how to use libgen).

If you can't parse the literature and weigh up the risks and benefits with confidence, then I'm afraid the only solution is to look at people you think are trustworthy and do as they suggest.

There's a reason that doctors tend to be highly paid professionals in almost every country, and it isn't all regulatory capture. (British doctors make above median wages, but nowhere near a free-ish market would settle as we're victims of regulatory capture).

This is because medicine is difficult. It's also the easiest it's ever been, now that so much knowledge and resources are available to anyone with an internet connection. If you've taken high school biology and have an LLM, there's practically nothing you can't theoretically learn given the time and will. This is often impractical, hence why you want to pay someone who doesn't need to do this.

I think a sensible reaction to covid pandemic measures would be to demand governments provide far more evidence to justify a lockdown longer than a month. If it's not abundantly clear that you're dealing with a disease that kills upwards of several % of the population, by the time that period is over, then demand the lockdowns end or violate them in public protest.

You should trust doctors very slightly less, trust governments and government medical bodies quite a bit less, but IMO, if you're at the point where vaccines seem net-negative to you, you've over-shot the mark.

If you really want to, there's always the option of litigation against government officials if you can prove they willfully lied. If they encouraged lockdowns when it became clear it wouldn't help, or overstated the benefits of vaccination (without the benefit of hindsight), then they should be accountable for the harm.

I think euthanasia should be legal. I think there should be quite a lot of oversight of the process, but I'm not against governments doing cost-benefit analyses of who gets care.

By revealed preferences, it's impossible to care infinitely about a given life. If that wasn't the case, then the entire global economic output would be spent on the first kid who showed up with terminal cancer. Not even those who claim that Life Is Priceless act like that's true. The Pope isn't selling his mobile to save one more starving child in Africa. Even the Dalai Lama has personal possessions, and expensive ones.

Once you accept that (and no population on earth could function without doing so) , all that remains is figuring out how much society implicitly or explicitly values life and making it legible. Yes, it sucks. But we're not gods with unlimited resources.

(If you wish to spend your own funds on your care, then I have no objection to you spending as much as you can afford, your money, your choice. But if you're spending my money, through taxes..)

I also think that anyone who can prove they possess capacity (in the medicolegal sense) should have the right to end their lives.

I'd be open to that being a difficult process, you'd need doctors to sign you off as sane and not suffering from a disease that impairs judgement (and can be cured).

No, I avoid tautology by not claiming that just wanting to die is sufficient grounds to be diagnosed with a mental illness and hence lack capacity. I think there are philosophical reasons that are consistent with wanting to die, for reasons other than depression.

(Severe depression that is resistant to all treatment is, IMO, a terminal illness)*

I hold this position despite being severely depressed, with occasional suicidal ideation. I recognize that I don't want to be depressed or suicidal, and want that part of me excised. I'm quite confident I would never act on that (and doctors know how to make it quick, painless, and irreversible), and if my disease somehow overwhelmed my true volition, I would want to be saved.

I think that unless someone has formally applied for a Suicide License, the default presumption should be that something is wrong with them, and they don't actually want it. This allows us to try and save people who jump off bridges or take paracetamol after a bad breakup. I differ from most people in that I would accept people wanting to die for more considered reasons.

Of course, in the Real World, my hands are tied by laws and code of conducts that physicians must agree to if they want to stay out of jail and in their job. But that's my stance on the matter.

*I haven't exhausted all options, far from it. I even expect that we'll have a generalized cure for depression in my lifetime. I still am not comfortable with telling someone with depression so bad life has lost meaning that they must hold out in hopes of a cure, suffering all the way.

Fortunately for my sanity, I've filtered my Twitter feed to the extent that the most profound cases of retardation miss me haha.

Add in the political climate - nothing I say when defending medicine is going to do anything to separate me seeming like one of "those" COVID people to skeptics.

This is what irks me the most. Short of going full Dr. Phil and taking up full-blown vaccine denialism, what can I say to people with that mindset and convince them? It's an utter mode collapse, there are certainly people in this thread who have views more nuanced than "all vaccines are amazing and harmless" and "vaccines are designed to turn you into a gay frog", but it confuses me.

I'm rather fortunate that medicine was never this politicized either in India or the UK. There isn't the same degree of digging in of heels and treating arguments as soldiers rather than an attempt to establish empirical fact.

COVID lockdowns were a bust, but even if they'd curbed the disease, I'm unsure if it was worth it if it pissed off tens of millions of people in the States to the point that even basic medical knowledge became untrustworthy.

Do these people not note that there are >180 other countries out there? If vaccines were a scam or net harmful, then you'd find at least a few countries that rejected them wholesale. The only ones without state vaccination programs are absolute basket-cases, and even they have the sense to accept foreign medical aid.

I'll be real with you, I find the fact that you're being downvoted so heavily rather frustrating.

We're both doctors, and we're not perfect. Most doctors aren't perfect either, but I would expect you'd agree with me when I say the majority of our colleagues are smart, conscientious people who genuinely want to do right by the people who see them.

We've conceded that vaccines have risks. We've pointed out scenarios where vaccination might be technically net positive, but of such minuscule effect that people shouldn't run around screaming because they've missed a shot. We've pointed out circumstances where the calculations change, and that vaccination schedules are made for the whole population, and not just for conscientious upper middle class nerds who take care of their health.

If I was being paid at US rates, you'd bet I'd walk any neurotic person through an entire questionnaire that ticks off boxes and adds up net QALYs for any given vaccine. This isn't really feasible at scale, and mass media is necessarily something that must scale and reach the LCD.

Yet I see more FUD than I want to here. Somehow the whole profession is discredited by covid, even though quite a few doctors would happily tell you that the way the pandemic was handled was far from perfect.

It all strikes me as a gross over-correction. The public should trust the medical field and the US government less because of our errors, but some people are throwing out the unvaccinated baby with the bath water.

I know we've got more than our fair share of contrarians, the Motte encourages their presence, but damn.

I'm lucky because 90% of the time, I'm happy with my first draft. I know people who become obsessed with continuously editing and rewriting to the point they're never happy with the outcome. Usually I just look for typos and then let it rip without worrying further.

I think my web serial is well past several hundred thousand words, and most of it was written on the fly. This wasn't to its obvious detriment, and I'm pleased with its reviews.

I think writing is next to impossible to give good advice for improving, leaving aside very obvious tips like "get an editor or a friend with good taste to read it over; proof-read yourself; keep writing and assess how feedback changes; want to look Literary™? Use semicolons."

I can at least say that effort and persistence pays off. When I look at my old essays, even very popular ones, I see a hundred things I'd do differently if I were to rewrite them.

Everything else is often idiosyncratic, and advice that's good for someone might the opposite of what another person should hear.

I must say, LLMs can be useful tools, though you shouldn't take what they say as gospel truth. I often find them useful for just vibe checking drafts, though you need to heavily discount for sycophancy.