@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

I appreciate you extending charity and noticing that my worldview is, to the best of my understanding, consistent, even if it's unusual.

Going out on a hypothetical limb, what if you could saw off your own leg and donate that to another person, who was for some reason one-legged? Would you make the argument that the mendicant who did so would be in no way being exploited, that hey we all work for the man one way or another, this is just a logical and acceptable extension of that? It's a weak analogy and to my knowledge this isn't quite possible, but a similar (again, not exact) principle applies.

I think paid organ donations should be legal, though a leg would be a difficult one to pull off.

So yes, I think it should be legal, and if the donor had capacity to make decisions, and was being compensated at a rate he was happy with, I see no other reason to disagree.

If they wanted my leg, I wouldn't say there isn't a sum that wouldn't buy it, but it has a lot of zeroes in it. Someone elsewhere would probably do it for much cheaper. And there are people who'd pay for the privilege, either as a fetish or because of a weird disease that convinces them that their legs shouldn't be attached to them.

Do you think this law is equally stupid? If so, why?

I've elaborated elsewhere in the comment chain, but the gist of it is that I consider it a transaction at the end of the day, it might be an expensive one, but I consider most things fungible, and I think there are easily sums of money that leave the adoptive parents and the surrogates happy about the arrangement.

There's something metaphysical (in the most literal sense of that word) about motherhood, much that we do not understand about maternal bonding to children (or paternal bonding, for that matter). I am not sure that we are yet at the point where we are as a species ready for gestational surrogacy, or if that point will ever come.

I mean, you do see that I disagree on the metaphysics here, and I haven't heard of most surrogacy arrangements ending badly, not that I know any personally. Definitionally, the ones in the news are either because they're celebs, or because something went wrong. I think that's not true for the majority.

I try not to drink too much, and mostly succeed haha. But you're right, dropping into pubs when out of the big city is probably the best way to get a feel of the pulse of the place.

Reminded me about me and my-now-wife's random stay in a pub in a 500 soul village in mid England. The cook was a literature PhD from London and the family that run the pub were village/hamlet people. It was a interesting evening of cultural exchanges and curiously enough also the topic of how the NHS failed the patriarch of the family and how his wife (who was getting sloshed) fought for him by calling and showing up in person to demand treatment again and again to get anywhere.

Seems to me that as topics of conversation go, it's either the NHS or the weather in this country.

Fuck. That's not a story that's new to me, speaking generally, but I'm sorry you guys had to go through that. While I don't think it should matter too much where someone got their diagnosis and prescription, this is from the States, and I feel like that deserves additional weight.

I was already exploring private care, and groaning at the prices, honestly 200 pounds is far from how high it could have gone.

You'll often find that the usual contacts, namely secretaries and nurses, and occasionally GPs, can be less than well informed of the finer points of legality and regulation. It seems they were certainly wrong about whether this was a possible, but that did end up working in your favor for once.

Anything works as long as the general public voted it in place. I don't particularly care about whether it would be managed at the state or federal level. They'd probably negotiate treaties and recognize equivalent tests if the need arose.

As for their content:

A combination of IQ test and general knowledge for core franchises.

If you want to just be eligible to vote? Name the 3 largest political parties and their public policies. Score above the threshold IQ where you'd have been deemed Special Needs or outright lacking capacity. In other words, don't be an imbecile.

You want to drive? Take the same driving test we do today.

Want to drink? Show you understand how many drinks it takes to take your BAC to the legal limit. Take a simulated driving test while drunk, so you get a visceral understanding of its effects.

Do strongly addictive drugs without a medical prescription? Display a clear understanding of the dangers involved, the signs of toxicity and overdose, the longterm side-effects. Clearly state you understand the risks, you're releasing the state of liability for any expenses you incurr that you can't personally cover, buy insurance, or optionally post a bond that will be returned if you don't fall afoul in a fixed period of time. Optionally a cool-down period of a month, so anyone not strongly motivated doesn't bother. Perhaps have seminars by ex-addicts warning of the dangers.

Want to sell that shit? Don't want to go through med school? All of the above, with the same level of detail and knowledge you'd see in a geeky member of /r/Psychonauts. A clear understanding of customer protection laws, truthful advertising, quality control. Liability if not strictly vetting that your customers are licensed to buy too. It would probably look like a version of a pharmacy exam but much harder.

Want to gamble? I'd prefer no licensing at all, but if necessary, demonstrate basic understanding of probability and that the House always wins in the end.

Are you saying that bureaucrats and/or elected politicians will be granted authority to prepare an exam that deems be sufficiently "rational"?

Yes, with strict checks and balances, and mandatory consultation with domain experts. If you trust the systems in place that license doctors, lawyers and accountants, envision more of the same, but open to anyone who can pass the tests.

Alternatively, for people who have passed the hardest core tests, extend them the ability to buy any service, from anyone regardless of qualifications. If you trust some rando on the internet to be your doctor, then you can take his medical advice while discharging him of the liability normally involved.

Edit:

The simplest solution I can endorse is Robin Hanson's idea of a Store That Sells Banned Things.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/PeSzc9JTBxhaYRp9b/policy-debates-should-not-appear-one-sided#fn1x15

Robin Hanson proposed stores where banned products could be sold.1 There are a number of excellent arguments for such a policy—an inherent right of individual liberty, the career incentive of bureaucrats to prohibit everything, legislators being just as biased as individuals. But even so (I replied), some poor, honest, not overwhelmingly educated mother of five children is going to go into these stores and buy a “Dr. Snakeoil’s Sulfuric Acid Drink” for her arthritis and die, leaving her orphans to weep on national television.

I was just making a factual observation. Why did some people think it was an argument in favor of regulation?

Add in an exam to be able to access said store, and then I accept this factual consideration, and consider it to be positive on balance.

There is a categorical difference between an employer requesting you put in ear phones or get a health check up (both of which you can refuse) and agreeing upon incubating a human inside of you for nine months in order to receive payment. If you're saying "No, it's just a difference in degree" then we have an intractable disagreement.

I mean, outside of obvious coercion and indentured servitude, the surrogates can say no. I'm perfectly fine with coercion being illegal, I just don't think the usual argument that the difference in wealthy is necessarily coercive is worth a damn. I don't have a womb, but for the typical sum quoted, I would say I'd at least be interested.

Let's say you have a physically active job, and you've got clapped out knees. When you protest at being assigned field work, I see no reason why the employer can't ask you to get surgery to fix your knees, if a desk job is not a mutually acceptable option. You have the right to refuse, and find another job. That is, technically, something being put inside you for the purposes of work. At any rate, I don't see the qualitative difference between something in or outside you, as long as you agree to it.

I've never had an employer or customer put something inside me for even a moment, let alone nine months.

And this matters why? What qualitative difference does it make? Has your employer ever needed you to put in earphones? Or go through a health checkup?

If you don't like the terms and conditions, don't sign the contract.

I wouldn't do my current job for free. But I also enjoy talking about it - and find no shame it doing so - with my friends, family, and other acquaintances. Sometimes I have stressful days, but I don't end every day or week thinking, "A what a fucking emotional toll I had to pay!" In fact, I'm quite excited about my job because it lets me do all these other cool things with friends and families - and I feel like I really am creating some tangible value on a day to day basis.

Jobs vary, from the fulfilling to drudgery, from the stressful, to the relaxed. Mine certainly has its ups and downs, and it isn't all things I currently do for free online if someone were to politely ask. Getting pregnant and making $50k in 9 months strikes me as a much better deal than having to break your back laboring for the same sum, or have it represent life-time earnings, as would be the case in the Third World for many surrogates.

Someone having to work at McDonald's after their PhD in Underwater Basket Weaving failed to net them the jobs they dreamed of is obviously unhappy about it, and probably embarrassed to disclose it to friends and family. There are many low prestige jobs out there. Some of them even pay a premium to account for the fact it's not most people's first choice.

Yes?

Have you ever had to take a driving test? Do you want to legally prescribe heroin? You'd have to sit for a medical licensing exam after med school. This isn't a massive deviation from normality.

Nowhere does it say that these have to be particularly onerous exams, except potentially at the most extreme end. Basic franchises should be accessible by someone who doesn't have a learning disability, a reversal of the situation where we extend blanket permission for non-illegal acts, and only then restrict freedom for those, such as the mentally retarded or grannies with dementia, who can't be expected to take responsibility for their own safety and well-being.

Substitute government for "society". That's what I meant.

There are officials entrusted with tending to the commons, enforcing laws, and tackling bad actors. They're the ones who are directly nominated (and paid) to make the mess go away, and should be taken to task for their failure. Individual people in society shouldn't be obligated to be paramedics, firefighters or the like, if they want to help, then I don't hold it against them.

I edited it to specify he had no reason to suspect so.

I don't seek to hold people doing first aid and resuscitation liable, or punish them, for both consequentialist reasons at wider scale, and because I don't see why we wouldn't then arrest a fast food worker who sold a junkie a burger and prevented him from starving to death. Even if someone gave them food for free, out of pity.

I'd rather put the onus on society for not taking the junkie off the street in the first place, so that if you saw someone in a medical crisis on the streets, you wouldn't have any qualms about them being someone worth saving.

I do not think, from a proper consequentialist position that considers n-th order effects, that holding people liable for saving strangers is a good idea. In fact, I'd say it's a terrible idea.

If a cardiologist operates on, and saves, someone who goes on to conduct a genocide in Angola, would you hold him liable? Assume he didn't know the fellow beyond hearing he was a rich African who had flown into London for surgery, and paid for the best. Do you want us doing background checks on patients, as extending this line of reasoning would entail?

For the average bleeding heart: If they don't Narcan someone, I don't hold them responsible. If they do, then I think their general desire to be pro-social should be recognized, even if in this particular case, the person wasn't worth saving. That is not always a given, someone who is a recreational drug user but isn't a homeless junkie might easily OD on fent accidentally contaminating their coke. Far too many members of net productive members of society would be caught in the crossfire. Nary a day goes by when you hear of some young yuppy dying in a fancy club or house party from the same.

Surely the same duty that applies to you, applies to others. Doctors are going to be a source of the drugs.

Why? If we're restricting ourselves to what seems to be a rather minarchist AnCap Utopia, why is it that only doctors would be licensed to sell it?

Once again, my own views, and not representative of current reality:

Anyone can get a license to prescribe anything. They go to a government body that makes them pay a recurring sum that is a fair estimate of expected negative externalities, or what would have come out of the public purse. For highly addictive drugs, this would certainly be an enormous sum. It might even be legally required to buy insurance on the free market. Think of this as a more generalized form of malpractice insurance as paid by doctors, if you don't show proof of funds then too bad for you.

It might be framed as a bond, due to be returned with interest after X years, but any violations would be deducted from it. If they sold to someone with an Adult Card, then they'd be cleared of much of the liability.

It is not a fiction however but central to morality. Someone who is selling heroin to others is a horrible person.

Good luck on getting people to come to a true consensus on what is "good for you". A stable equilibrium is allowing people to choose for themselves, as long as they don't abuse the privilege by hurting others.

As far as I'm concerned, the State should not be in the business of being a nanny, and if it insists, then people should be allowed to opt out or form enclaves of like-minded people.

What you are proposing would be a betrayal to the principle of no regulation = liberty.

I re-iterate that I'm not a monomaniacal zealot. This counts as a concession, a mild step back from Absolute Freedom (or outright anarchy). I think your right to swing your fist ends where my nose begins.

I am willing to trade away a non-zero amount of freedom for other terminal values I have. I just value freedom more than most.

Plus smart people even though less than others, do stupid self destructive things too. Maybe this makes sense for something like crypto but makes less sense for heroin. Your proposal would surely lead to more restrictions than just banning the worst things.

I disagree. We currently do something maybe sorta kinda like what I propose, but in a half-baked manner without underlying guiding thought more than the whims of the Current Year.

It does make sense for some industries to limit them in some capacity when it comes to gambling, porn,etc. Still, the fact that you are willing to support something much more restrictive does undermine the claim that liberty to sell and buy heroin is an important principle. It is not. The duty of caring about the end result towards one fellow's man is more important here.

That is your opinion. I express my love and sense of duty towards my "fellow man" by hoping I can treat them like intelligent adults who can decide for themselves, and ask the same in turn.

I'm not a zealot, you won't see me holding a copy of Atlas Shrugged while putting a padlock on a public park.

In the UK, I've never seen Narcan dispensers in public. I presume only paramedics would carry them.

In the US? I've heard of them being in half the stores, people carrying them just in case, and so on.

If someone feels morally obliged to whip it out when they see an addict ODing, why on earth would I condemn the kindness of strangers? If they weren't carrying anything, and didn't do more than call 911 and walk away, I won't condemn them either.

Don't get me wrong. I think the opioid epidemic in the US needs addressing. I'm all for rounding up junkies and making them take their meds and go through a rehab program, but because they're criminals, a public nuisance and causing social chaos, not because they're drug-users.

I also think that in countries with publicly funded healthcare, states should have the right to deny coverage to those who refuse to address behaviors that impose exorbitant costs. You might be saved and treated free of charge the first time, but if you don't comply with further advice, then I don't object to the public washing their hands of you as a lost cause.

Some diseases are unavoidable, it's not like anyone asks to develop Type 1 diabetes or schizophrenia. I'm far more sympathetic to such cases, but not sane people who know the risks of addiction and show no signs of stopping, while expecting the rest of us to pick up after them.

I cross-posted this on a few subreddits, and boy can you tell that some of them have far more patience for long-form text than others.

On /r/SlateStarCodex ? Doing numbers, thank you.

/r/redscarepod ? A single comment, but they're not a fan of shrinks and only occasionally like a text dump

/r/Scotland ? More like /r/ADHD, the buggers cannae be arsed to read, apparently, and I got a dozen comments in a row complaining about the length. Well, at least a few people did read it and said they enjoyed it, but I know that if I do spec into ADHD in the future, I'll be doing numbers in my bank account.

I think we had a discussion about this before, but that you don't care about the line doesn't mean that you aren't breaking clear good ethical norms here that a doctor especially shouldn't break. Doctors are especially the kind of people who ought to think about what is their patient's best interest and not what their patient might be requesting at the moment.

I'd like to point that there's a distinction between a random person selling someone else heroin, and me doing the same thing. I would, of course, hold myself to a higher standard and not disburse it if it wasn't a necessity. That's what I would do if ever had to prescribe diamorphine, the term used not to scare the hoes.

Even in a setting where the usual legal and ethical constraints I'm obliged to follow (if I wish to keep my license) were waived, if someone came up to asking heroin, and it wasn't in the context of overwhelming pain in a hospital, I'd politely tell them I'm not comfortable doing that, and that they should look elsewhere.

I am okay with letting other people do things that might harm them, especially if they know what they're getting into, that doesn't mean I want to make things worse myself.

It is in fact immoral and parasitic to profit from selling what is harmful to others. There can be a debate about some more grey areas, but there is a line above which it becomes pretty clear that you have activity that is just harming people.

Sure. I'm happy to concede that. I don't think that changes my overall stance that blanket illegality shouldn't be the means of regulating this.

If I'm allowed to daydream, everyone old enough to vote takes a Rational Adult exam, potentially one that's subdivided into multiple ascending tiers of difficulty. The more you pass, the more you are allowed to do, because the presumption is that you've proven yourself intelligent enough to be responsible for yourself. For an existence proof, look at driving tests.

Maybe have people pay for bonds. Maybe allow insurance companies to charge them more for risky behavior. Tax negative external ties and strongly punish anything that spills out of personal bounds.

But aren't addicts morally culpable on a significant level? Of course. Although there might be some more sympathetic stories. But so are people selling heroin and to a lesser extend those allowing them to do so. You discourage and condemn all three to get a society without the malaise of significant drug addiction and death due to it. While you allow, encourage, and side with all three to get the society with these problems. It is a choice that will end with the different outcomes with a clear right and wrong side.

I don't really care about moral culpability, at best I consider it an occasionally useful fiction. You get a pass if you've got a brain tumor or something, that's the way people look at things.

I don't condone giving heroin away to school children. I am willing to look away when an adult buys it off another adult with no coercion involved. If it's a situation where coercion is the default assumption, have them sign a legal contract first. I see liberty that extends only to doing things that society deems are Good For You a pale imitation of the real deal, and I accept the consequences.

You're correct, though Narcan is a brand name.

What about it? I mean, I feel like most people have no objection to its existence, and consider it a very good thing to have around. You might have a few junkies start whaling on you because you ruined a perfectly good high as far they were concerned (they don't care about the fact that they stopped breathing).

Nah, we met back in India, but she actually does live in Scotland, not too far from where I live and work.

Yes. I'd legalize the sale of heroin from a buyer to the seller. I'd be okay with heavy taxes on it, and would absolutely be for imposing strict penalties on all the negative externalities it would cause.

If someone buys heroin and does it in their home without hassling anyone else, that's their business. If they become addicted and commit crime, then they should face punishment. If they lose their jobs and need to be bailed out, that should be conditional on a good faith attempt at seeking medical treatment and adhering to the treatment regime prescribed.

You won't catch me going on the street protesting for it to be legalized, because I have better things to do, but I wouldn't stand in the way.

After all, I am in the business of occasionally needing to prescribe fentanyl and morphine, and given that the patient pays for it directly, or indirectly through taxes or insurance, that counts as selling it. Doctors are, among other things, fent dealers. If that can be done without causing society to collapse in flames, other alternative arrangements might well work.

Consider it this way: is it a tragedy, to be orphaned? Like--if there was a shortage of orphans, would it be okay to deliberately make some?

Obviously not if the only way to manufacture orphans required their parents to be put to the sword.

But even today, that's not the case. Let's consider the entirely plausible hypothetical where someone's preserved eggs and semen outlasted them. There are couples who are entirely infertile, and unable to have biologically related children. Would I object if they wanted to create a child by going to a gene bank and getting a surrogate to birth a child whose biological parents were no longer alive?

Not at all. I see nothing wrong with that, everyone wins. Even the kid, because as far as I'm concerned, it's far better to be alive than not, and that's while grappling with severe clinical depression. Life is good! More lives are good!

Would anything change if instead of a surrogate, the couple seeking to adopt used an artificial womb? Not as far as I'm concerned, assuming mature technology with no deleterious effects on the child.

I hope that it illustrates that its possible, and good to at least sometimes create orphans when demand exceeds supply.

Well, sure, probably she can't complain, at the personal level: she agreed to be used. She rented out her womb. But whether it's good public policy to let people rent out their wombs is not just a question of personal liberty. If we let people sell their organs, or become prostitutes, or replace their brains with digital machinery, that doesn't just change the lives of those who have consented to the change. It changes the cultural landscape.

And I'm entirely fine with this change in the social landscape, or at the very least, I won't seek to oppose when it conflicts with my desire to maximize human liberty. I understand why people might disagree, I just consider it none of their business what I or other sane adults get up to in our spare time, of our own volition.

If someone tries to stop me from enhancing myself, with my own funds and my own body and mind at stake, then I'm not a man easily moved to violence, but I'd be looking for a gun.

The alternative to radical transhumanism is growing old and infirm, my brain rotting away and becoming riddled with holes like cheese gnawed by microscopic rodents. If the alternative is the same death that murdered the 97 billion anatomically modern humans before us, I am willing to fight to live. There is no way that is feasible without transhumanism.

Fortunately, as far as I'm concerned, this unlikely to come to pass, and the bio-chauvinists and luddites are unlikely to stop all progress.

Hence my reference to egregores like Moloch--everyone can individually be doing what is actually best for themselves, given the circumstances, and this can give rise to horrifying circumstances that no individual within the system can, or would even choose, to change.

I acknowledge Moloch as the Great Enemy. I do not think surrogacy or artificial wombs feeds it, and certainly doesn't strengthen it more than it strengthens us.

I would like transhumanism to be deliberate, in other words, rather than allowing it to emerge accidentally.

This is sadly a lost cause. But even I want transhumanism to be optional, and I have no issue with people who don't seek to embrace it. If people want to cling to the baseline human form, let them. I'm for being generous to them, giving them food and shelter, outright UBI. All I ask is that they don't get in the way of those with higher ambitions. And if their excuse is that they can't let me do as I wish, when it doesn't directly harm them, then the only option is war. I don't want that, but I'll do it if necessary. The tree of liberty might need regular watering.

I'm not saying you should be mad if future humans are bio-printed. I'm saying bio-printed people won't be humans, so it's a better future where our decision to bio-print transhumans fully accounts for the differences that will emerge between evolved beings, and designed ones. Especially if (when) the designed ones become noticeably superior in every way, given our own tendency to use as commodities those beings we regard as beneath us. If transhumans share this tendency, such future humans as may remain will be in some trouble.

I disagree that such people aren't human. I do, however, think that they are a better class of human than we are. Smarter, stronger, likely more moral and less prone to our failings. I seek to become them, and if that's not an option, ennoble my descendants.

Are baseline humans quite rightly concerned by the possibility of such a superior clade? Hell yes.

If they're not slightly anxious about potential replacement by beings smarter and more powerful than you, then they're a moron. You will inevitably find yourself at their mercy.

I, however, think it is possible to carefully engineer such posthumans, being they biological or otherwise, to still have empathy for their precursors. To actually extend us mercy, when we're at theirs. Any who can join them, should. We should also coordinate to prevent a Molochian tragedy where the universe is colonized by ever spreading swarms of minimally sentient Von Neumanns. But this doesn't stop me from being ready to fight to be better, and more free.

I don't find it unpalatable in the least, and it would be a stretch to call me wealthy or influential. I'm not even a likely customer.

I find the instinctive flinch away from it as sheer stupidity, especially when countries like India now ban surrogacy for pay.

I look to such people, and think: You're telling me that it's legal and widely accepted for someone to work in a sweatshop making textiles for a year and only maybe make a few thousand dollars at best, and them having to undergo pregnancy for 9 months for potentially several dozen times the sum is somehow worse!

We all sell our bodies and limited time under the sun to make ends meet. And we all pay an emotional toll for it, unless you're lucky enough to have a job that you'd do for free. The only question is if you're being paid enough to make that worth your while, and a childless couple offering ~$50k to poor woman in the Third World represents a sum that will set up both her and her future children for life.

I contend that it is neither unethical nor illegal in the least, and that the world would be a much better place if people didn't let their innate disgust reactions or severely miscalibrated notions of fairness lead them around by the nose.

I really don't see this as a compelling concern.

The 'Human Experience' is incredibly diverse, to say the least. Is an orphan, someone raised in an institution and lacking any parents, less human because of it?

I find that impossible to entertain.

Orphans do poorly mostly because of selection effects, especially if we consider extend our consideration to those who were abandoned by less than scrupulous birth parents but had the misfortune of still inheriting their genes (the only thing they got out of that bum deal).

Another illustrative case is that comparative studies show that most of the harms of not being raised with a father in the household arise from deadbeat dads, those who lost their fathers to sickness or accidents come out as normal as anyone else.

I have great contempt for most so-called ethicists, and as far as I'm concerned, mutually positive sum transactions between consenting individuals should be accepted, if not celebrated. Humans are finicky things, and the idea of surrogacy doesn't mean that the woman who bore the child escapes the hormonal and emotional consequences despite knowing on an intellectual level that the baby growing in their wombs isn't genetically related to them. But if they signed a contract accepting this, then that's that. I understand surrendering the baby might be immensely painful, and is an entirely legitimate feeling. After all, nobody is particularly surprised by adoptive parents being fond of their adopted children.

If this woman agreed to birth the child, even if it was her eggs that were used in the process, then I do not see any room for her to complain about handing the baby to Altman and his husband. Not that there's any evidence of this, I'm not aware of someone weeping and wailing on television, bemoaning that a cruel near-billionaire has snatched a waif away from her breast. She might not even want any publicity.

I fail to see much reason to care if future humans are gestated in the 'ol biological 3D printer, or in an external replica of such. At the very least, it's a technology with massive positive potential in a world with declining birth rates, and anything that makes the process of reproduction less of a hassle has its merits. I don't see the downsides as being worth much airtime in this case.

I've heard plenty of people, including over here, condemn Altman for not having a stake in the future, for being a disinterested devotee of Techno Capital without any real skin in the game. Him being gay and childless was pointed at to shore up their claim.

Now, I still think Altman is an untrustworthy snake, but that particular line of argument seems hollow.

I believe the standard use of MILF is to describe Women of a Certain Age, and maternity is, strictly speaking, optional.

Then again, this meant much more when I was younger, these days, the nominal MILF out there is about my age or just a few years older. Oh, how time flies.

As far as I'm aware, I've never had a dalliance with a married woman! The topic never came up, and I don't think I'd derive particular satisfaction from cuckolding another man, and would probably pity them too much to try.

As for being called handsome, I think everyone has their button, but that seems a paltry bone to snatch at. I'm sure you're handsome, and as you're a doctor you're batting, if not 1.000, pretty damn well on the scale, @SkookumTree and his self-loathing pathologies notwithstanding. What I mean is don't sweat the handsome bit, it's just a word. In Japan I've been told probably a thousand times that my face is small (which is supposed to be a good thing here.) It doesn't hit quite the same way, but it's words, is what I'm saying.

Eh, I don't rely entirely on drunken ramblings to boost my ego, but I've always been a tad-bit self conscious about my looks. It's unavoidable when you have a younger brother is both classically handsome and better looking than you. Not that I haven't done well for myself, I have my charms. They just lean more towards flirting and charming women, rather than having them throw themselves at me unprompted as my brother induces.

As an aside, being a doctor gets you much more mileage back in India. It's a bit of an apples to oranges comparison as I've been in a committed relationship before I even got to Scotland, but while I certainly feel that people respect me for my job, its not to the same degree.

I agree that @SkookumTree shouldn't mope that much. Almost any deficit in looks can be made up for by the money and prestige of being a doctor in the States, he'll have nurses showing up any day now.

I understand why pubs are still a nexus of social life around these parts, at least in smaller places. Nothing like familiar faces (or the rare unfamiliar one) and flowing liquor to get people talking.

Even with the internet, finding somewhere to live was a pain. Until the very last moment, I'd be been worrying I'd be in for a rather terrible commute, one of the reasons I'm not particularly mad at my existing landlords.

Sometimes those nights are a turning point and other times they feel ephemeral. My only proof that they happened is the hangover or drunk texts sent during the night.

Thankfully I made it out with just a mild hangover. Weak-sauce British beer can't touch me, I'm used to twice the ABV! I still found myself penning everything down when I got home that night, I find that's the best way to keep my memories straight.

Buddy, a few days back I'd have asked you if it was a SpongeBob thing.

The overall interior and exterior decor of the place is eccentric enough that it never stuck out to me.

Thanks! It was an unusual evening, to say the least, and I feel like I learned more about the place in the span of a few hours than I had in the course of six months.