@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

I have mixed opinions of BOC. It has a strong start, but ends up becoming repetitive once it keeps playing up its core shtick. Not great, not terrible.

That's a bit harsh, given that it was a translation. I presume it flows better in Chinese. As people have elaborated on above, it's a hard language to translate and a lot of nuance doesn't carry over.

Part of the reason for a (small) info-dump is that most of it isn't really relevant to the story. Even though he was isekai'd from Earth, it doesn't make a difference in his life beyond his ability to plagiarise classic Chinese literature and make people mistake him for a precocious genius.

To be fair, it could have been dispensed with entirely, but it merits as much verbiage as it has plot-relevance.

Grok 3 is a whelming outcome. The only thing notable about it is how consistent it is with most predictions, including scaling laws.

Unfortunately, its time as SOTA is going to be short, or nonexistent, because the full-fat o3 from OpenAI already ekes out a win in benchmarks. Of course, o3 is not technically available to the public, so among released models that are pay to play, Grok reigns.

I've only played around with it a little bit, through lmarena.ai because I'm not in dire need of any paid plan. It seemed fine? There's one particular question that I ask LLMs, courtesy of my maths PhD cousin: "Is the one-point compactification of a Hausdorff space itself Hausdorff?" The correct answer is yes, or so I'm told. Grok 2 fails, Grok 3 succeeds. But so do GPT-4o, Gemini 2.0 Pro and the like.*

(I've asked this so many times that my keyboard automatically suggests the entire question, talk about machine learning)

In short, Grok 3 is a mild bull signal for LLMs, and a slightly stronger one for xAI. It doesn't seem to be astonishingly good, or break ground other models haven't reached. It also hasn't been made retarded by too much Reinforcement Learning from Elon's Feedback. He shared an excerpt showing it lambasting an outlet called The Information, but actual users get a far more measured response. I cynically suspect that a few xAI engineers probably set the sycophancy setting to the maximum when he's using it.

*I'm probably remembering the original explanation I was given wrong, and that my cousin had said it was a no except with additional qualifiers. Mea culpa.

Edit: On a second try with Grok 3:

In all relevant cases, we can find disjoint open sets separating any two distinct points in (X^). Therefore, the one-point compactification (X^) of a Hausdorff space (X) (assuming (X) is locally compact) is itself Hausdorff.

Which I believe is the correct answer.

Seems legit! I read the same translation, just on a different site.

Eyeballing it, looks fine! Keep in mind the story is technically unfinished due to CCP meddling, but I'd say 90% of the story was done, and you'll only miss out on a bit of closure. If you share a link, I can see if the translation is the one I've read, which was very good.

I haven't read Cradle myself, but I have heard a range of opinions on it. If it was a video game on Steam, I reckon it would be "mostly positive". On the other hand, RI has rave reviews, and I am vociferous in my endorsement.

I do expect that authentic Chinese Xianxia would probably be better, a lot of Western homages don't quite have the same charm.

Uh.. I never read past a few pages of the Silmarillon, it struck me as somewhere between a dictionary and a novel. But speaking broadly, I guess that works?

Is there an elevator pitch for Reverend Insanity, or is it one of the "anything would be a spoiler, just read 30 chapters" ones?

Imagine being a Pokémon trainer. Except your body is the pokeball.

"Gu" are mystical creatures, often resembling bugs of some description, that can be captured and tamed, then put to use. They range in power from something you'd find in tall grass outside the starter town to godlike entities that control physics and metaphysics.

(This is a highly unusual setup for Xianxia)

The protagonist is evil. That's not a word I use lightly, he's sociopathic, and even before the story began, he had painstakingly amassed a respectable degree of power, a lot of it through skullduggery, deceit and violence.

Then, through a combination of sheer luck and grit, he managed to catch a Legendary Pokémon, a one-of-a-kind rarity. This attracted the attention of his enemies, who launched an attack on him, while citing minor petty crimes such as the murder of several million innocent people. He was outnumbered, overpowered, and forced to commit suicide while using the Pokémon.

Which turns out to be Time Travel-mon. It brings him back in time to when he was just a teenager, but with the knowledge he had before if not the power. He takes this an opportunity to start over from scratch, but making full use of the knowledge he came in with.

(It's a long elevator ride)

The protagonist is one of a kind. An absolute sociopath, but charming. Intelligent, ruthless and more shameless than words than do justice to. And hilarious, for what it's worth.

The levels of utter shamelessness and depravity he dares plumb will shock both other characters and you, the reader. Think a genocidal warlord nominating himself for the Nobel Peace prize on the grounds there's nobody left to make war levels. He's not psychopathic, just a sociopath with none of the internal flinches that keep normal humans in check. He won't go out of his way to kill you, unless he has something to gain from it. I suppose "amoral" is a better term than evil.

The author is a mad-man. The levels of plotting, counter-plotting and recursive escalation he can hold in his head will astound you. Not a single Chekov's gun will remain unfired on the mantle. You will never find yourself screaming at the characters, wondering why they don't use an obvious ability or trick when apt. And you'll be blind-sided by what they come up with, but never in hindsight will you think it's an ass-pull. That's difficult enough in any novel, let alone Xianxia.

And don't worry about the time travel. It's a power not used lightly, and fickle. The author never uses it as a get out of jail free card.

I see you read a lot of xianxia, so actually it would be interesting to get a pitch on the whole genre. From what I heard of it, it's... I wouldn't like to say "powerslop", but it has the reputation, you know? "Ascending through universes" this, "ruthless MC that"... isekai so you don't have to figure out an in-universe backstory for the MC, "ruthless MC" so you don't have to write the struggle between personal scruples and the next tasty powerup, 100 gorillion chapters because the author didn't bother thinking of any containable scale in favor of numbers going ever up... along with the Jumpchain genre, it feels like not so much "literature" as "concentrated trope fentanyl to inject directly into storyteller brain". (I wonder if the Chinese who were brought up on xianxia think Western fantasy is just "herojourneyslop".)

Of course, the above is all an impression gathered by osmosis rather than reading one of those doorstoppers that make Worm look like a leaflet. But I did play Tale of Immortal. Please tell me how wrong or how correct I am.

You are correct. Most of Xianxia is slop with no redeeming qualities, for the reasons you've mentioned.

But as I say elsewhere, most novels in any genre are barely worth reading. If you randomly search all Kindle titles, good luck in finding good novels.

That being said, the ones I recommended are diamonds in a pile of shit. Some combination of world building, character writing and respect for the reader's intelligence elevate them to soaring heights compared to their peers.

Don't pick a random novel in the genre and throw yourself in. That way lies pain and insanity. But look at English-speaking fan recommendations, and you'll fare much better. And when you do find a novel, you'll have a chonker that keeps you busy for months even if you read as fast as I do. That's always a perk in my books!

The majority of Xianxia is pure slop. Chapters rushed out on a near daily basis, both by the author and paid/volunteer translators who sometimes do a questionable job at translating them.

But that's true of any genre! Most novels are slop! Superhero novels, YA novels, romance novels. The majority of books are barely worth reading, and what people advocate for are cherry-picked examples.

That being said, there are excellent novels. I've name-dropped a few. Beyond the power fantasy, they have great plots, characters and world building. Chinese fantasy is also alien to Western sensibilities, or at least refreshingly different. Most Xianxia protagonists are refreshingly pragmatic, manifestations of Will to Power without the moping and navel-gazing of their western counterparts.

They get the girl. They get girls (consent is questionable). They are more than happy to slaughter their foes and exult in the lamentations of their women and children. They want to be powerful, exceed the limits of biology, ascend to godhood, and punishment for their hubris is something they prepare for and seek to overcome.

Western fantasy has gotten stale for me, but Xianxia hasn't. And when you find a good novel, you can probably spend half a year reading it, given how long they tend to be.

I'm afraid there isn't a site with updated translations out there.

What I personally did was find Chinese raws:

https://www.piaotia.com/html/7/7095/6107291.html

When you notice the default English translation that's on most sites goes to shit, start copying and pasting from here to to any decent LLM and ask for a translation. I'd love to share mine, but I never actually saved them, just threw chapter after chapter in there as I went along.

Already suggested Forty Millenniums of Cultivation somewhere in the thread, which I'd say is a pretty solid novel and one that combines sci-fi with Cultivation in a manner that few stories tackle. There's a bit of Warhammer 40k influence, if the name doesn't make it obvious, but it runs only skin deep.

I don't really read much progression fantasy in general, but probably the best I've read would be Worth The Candle.

I tried Reverend Insanity, and even allowing for a rough translation, the writing was crap.

Junior, you dare? Kowtow and break all your limbs, and I will leave you with an intact corpse.

Ahem. There's no accounting for taste, but I still think you missed out, or just didn't hold on long enough for the story to get its claws in you. It's an unfortunate Xianxia meme that people will tell you to stick to a story for a hundred chapters because then it gets good, but if memory serves it was around 30 in that RI had me leaning forward. I really can't recommend it enough.

I think it really ought to be Xianxia. And in fact, it's a strong inspiration for the genre as a whole.

When someone is slaying gods and leaving across the universe in a single jump, they're a proper Xianxia character. Though it's a shame he still gets trolled by the Buddha through literal sleight of hand.

Besides, Sun Wukong inspired Sun Goku, and DBZ has its own share of Xianxia tropes, especially when it comes to power scaling.

The main difference between the two is power-scaling. Wuxia only strays to a limited extent from feats that a "peak human" could perform, though there's supernatural bullshit that has roots in Chinese herbalism, alchemy, traditional medicine and the like. Xianxia takes that and dials that to 9000, then keeps on cranking.

Wuxia: The protagonist punches someone and they break through a door or wall.

Xianxia: The protagonist punches someone and they break through a mountain.

Wuxia: The protagonist finds a pill that extends their lifespan by 20 years.

Xianxia: The protagonist finds a pill that lets them live for a length of time that requires scientific notation.

Wuxia: A sword-master who spent their life meditating on the Great Dao might be able to fight a hundred opponents and win.

Xianxia: Someone's 'sword-intent' chops your dick off from a parallel dimension away.

Wuxia: You've reached the peak. True immortality is probably out of your grasp, but now all of China will remember your name.

Xianxia: You've reached the peak of the mortal realm. Yet your tired eyes spot the hints of an even taller range beyond, and you rub them while muttering something about Mt. Tai. None dare challenge you, but you're not content, not yet. After years of preparation, you go all out and barely survive after facing the wrath of Heaven for your impudence. You've managed to breakthrough and become worthy of the next realm. Congratulations, your previous powers mean fuck-all, and you're barely worthy of joining a sect in the upper realm as a janitor. Time to start from the bottom now that you're here.

This cyclic nature is one of the hallmarks of Xianxia, though it's not always a given. The usual goal for any self-respecting protagonist is to first achieve immortality, then get bored and go for omnipotence. If you're not defying the Heavens and overturning the laws that restrict you, why even bother?

Batman might be a a typical Wuxia character. Superman would be a weak character in a Xianxia setting, especially in a novel that's managed to steadily creep up in both power and page count. There are of course novels that don't indulge in the power fantasy to the extent that universes are being blown up with every punch, but that's something that people familiar with the genre wouldn't be surprised by haha.

If there were neurons dedicated to a non-existent tail, could we tell?

The cortical homunculus was visualized by electrostimulation of the precentral and postcentral gyri, while asking participants where the perceived sensation was localized.

If there was a chunk that mapped to a "tail", then you'd pick up a disproportionate amount of correspondence to the current sacrum. If it was to go as far as the blog in question conjectures, you might see reports of 'phantom tail'.

So yes, we could tell, and in the absence of such, it's just a tall tale about tails.

I mean, monkeys do already use their hands for holding objects to some extent, but what I had in mind is less about how much neurons you dedicate to body parts and more so the shape of those parts thats expected. Because in what sense could your body be "wrong" for a given neural emphasis? But I would say that hands are propably a part where the model is almost entirely human, because there it really matters to get them exactly right.

The blog claims that there must be an atavasism in human sensory-motor proprioception. The cortical homunculus is the best visualization we have of that, and in a sense is real, with a true 1:1 correspondence with our body (weighted by salience and richness of ennervation).

It does not show any such discrepancy. It can plausibly be similar in both humans and precursor primates, barring the glaring absence of a tail. I would also strongly expect more emphasis on the feet, especially in an arboreal animal like the LCA between humans and lemurs.

Im afraid my english isnt good enough for this grammar.

The author claims that furries have body dysmorphia that is an atavism of a previous ancestral form. Many trans people happen to be autistic, and claim that they have a sense of "wrongness" or body dysmorphia, which they interpret as gender dysphoria. They think that this sense of wrongness is a sign from their body telling them they're the wrong gender (inside) and seek to 'correct' this discrepancy by transitioning.

I believe both are incorrect. In the latter case, because autistic people have sensory processing issues, and modern culture prompts them to reinterpret that as gender dysphoria. Hence the over-representation of ASD in both furries and trans people.

Though as far as I know, the number of people who think being a furry is evidence of an atavistic proprioceptive system rounds down to 1.

Congratulations on the pregnancy! I hope things proceed smoothly for the two and soon to be three of you.

I still don't know if people say Er Gen is good unironically or not, though your comment updates me towards the former.

I would say Reverend Insanity, even in its unfinished state, is a 10/10 novel. Contender for best novel I've ever read in fact. I'm trying to hold off re-reading it until my memory fades enough for it to feel fresh again.

Forty Millenniums of Cultivation is a good one, an 8/10 IMO. It was good enough for me to get frustrated reading awful MTL and then track down raws and translate them with modern SOTA LLMs that do a better job.

I never got very far into Lord of the Mysteries, but by all accounts it's supposed to be very good.

I have nothing useful to add, since I hadn't heard of the franchise till about 4 hours ago, when someone was lauding it as a resurgence in Chinese soft power in my Twitter feed.

That being said, it gives me hope that I'll see some proper high-budget Xianxia adaptations, and soon-ish. Hopefully adaptations of the good novels!

There are aspects of it that scream bipedal hominid over all else.

Note the enormously disproportionate upper limbs. The absence of a tail. Bipedal hominids had their arms freed from the task of being just another means of propulsion, and hence could repurpose them for tool-use. This incentivized much finer grained control of muscles, as well as denser sensory innervation.

Furries, and the LCA between humans and lemurs, are notably fond of tails.

What wemp said about other cultures is a good point, but I think you really overestimate how much of this I find plausible. I think there are some leftovers from pre-bipedal bodies, and I make no claim whether this causes furries.

I find this interesting mostly in how this illustrates a way of thinking about trans-. The part where the theory is not total whack and you can believe it if you really want to contributes to the accurate immitation, just like the ultrapersonal grievances turned into a general theory of politics in the other posts, and the all around excellent mental health of the author.

Fair enough, if you want to look at it that obliquely. You said it was a plausible theory in your top-level post, but if you think it's less likely to be true than not, then my only disagreement is that I think it is very unlikely to be true.

It may have relevance to the Trans Question, but only to the extent that is an attempted explanation for body dysmorphia, which I think is as unlikely to be true as the culturally-driven manifestation for trans body dysphoria as gender dysphoria represents an actual error in some well-defined gender pointer in the human brain.

If British doctors must suffer from endless Continuing Medical Education, it's only fair our luckier brethren across the pond suffer with us.

Look at this fine gentleman, who probably starred in an early-era Disney animated movie that has since been memory-holed and erased from polite conversation.

/images/17398192488222513.webp

I'm not an American (would that I were), but it seems to me that recent American geopolitics reflects a few things:

  1. America and Europe are no longer peers. They might have had a passably equitable partnership till the 90s, but only the blind deny the former has raced ahead economically while the latter stagnates and sniffs its own farts.

  2. The Soviet Union was a far more compelling adversary to both parties than its descendant, Russia, or the new upstart, China. It was a nuclear superpower with large land borders and a hostile ideology. Russia might retain the nukes, and is a great power if you squint, but it no longer has any meaningful ideological drive or desire to spread it beyond "if you trade with us and speak favorably of us, we'll back you". Even China has strong trade relations with Europe, and is not culturally hegemonising to the same degree.

  3. Europe grew complacent, too accustomed to US security guarantees to uphold its own military and budgetary commitments to a mutual defense pact. Why bother? Uncle Sam would pick up the bill, and there's always more welfare to be funded.

  4. The US was too polite to notice, and for the period of the 90s to the early 2010s, not threatened to the degree that it asked for more than lip-service from its allies and subsidiaries. As long as they sent a token force to muck about in American Forever Wars, and made the right sounds in global forums, why demand more?

  5. The former no longer holds. Lines in the sand are being drawn, and the US has realised that the restrictions of international law do not matter. You can tell nearby nations that they better toe the party line or you'll screw them with sanctions or military action, and the world doesn't end. Panama, Mexico, Greenland, all will come to realise that if America wants what you have, there's little saving you. Europe decided to kick back and relax instead of staying peers. They're finding out, to their shock, that what you give and what you get from a superpower are strongly correlated. Especially an insecure super power, one that is belatedly realizing that a legitimate challenger has arisen, and that demanding tribute from its vassals finally makes sense.

The sleeping bull has woken up, and remembered it has horns. Blunted horns, wreathed in garlands and unwieldy from lack of use. But still horns on a very big bull. Speaking softly is slowly being discarded in favor of wielding a very big stick.

Doesn't pass the sniff test.

I expect the largest and most significant divergence between human cortical homunculi and that of other mammals (animalculi?) would have occurred when we began speccing into bipedal locomotion. That is much later than the period suggested here. Look at that damn thing and tell me that it has much relevance to proto-lemurs.

Furries are rare enough, in absolute terms, that they're far more likely a culture-bound idiosyncratic misfiring rather than some kind of primitive atavism brought to life. Somewhere between 4 to 11% of furries have formal diagnoses of ASD. About 1% of the wider population are autistic.

Not to mention that in many cultures, furries are nigh-unheard of. I can't imagine most Indians, Africans or Chinese people would know what the hell a furry is, and there's no seething undercurrent of furry-desire that gets liberated when they move to the West. Even within the West, Americans probably have the highest furry-per-capita. Within America, cities that are liberal enclaves.

I agree with Duplex below that autism and its concommitant body dysphoria and facial agnosia are far more likely to be relevant explanations. And I think connecting the dots between human and canine co-evolution is genius. It may or may not be correct, but it's better than this.

I haven't seen a mod-hatted reply to my own for so long that it gave me a fright, visions of a bloody-coup and counter-coup as we ban each other left right and center till Zorba gets annoyed and stops paying the AWS bill.

I am personally not fond of age-gating literature at all, being of the opinion that if you can read and understand something, it's for you.

But that doesn't mean I don't understand what you mean haha. Thresholder has some adult content, but anything graphic happens off-screen. That's a necessity to be hosted on Royal Road, I think (without being age-gated, but it's been a while since I checked). You might see the MC looking longingly at a lady's buxom curves, have them described, but you're not getting a blow-for-blow of what follows, just a fade to black or acknowledgement. Someone might pop a boner, but no loving description of the veins or girth involved.

I would imagine most people wouldn't object to 13 year olds reading that. If you're reading it out loud, you'd be doing a decent amount of censoring for younger age groups. There's graphic violence, but nothing that would upset a psychologically normal red-blooded young lad.

I do want to thank you for introducing your kids to rationalist or rat-adjacent fiction, though that might spoil them with high standards when it comes to mainstream slop.