self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
Easier said than done.
It isn't 2023, when it used to be trivially obvious that someone was using ChatGPT 3.5. Even without special care, LLMs output text that doesn't scream AI, especially if you're only viewing what might be the equivalent of a typical comment. Even large posts or essays can be made to sound perfectly human.
The only conclusive examples would be someone getting sloppy and including "Certainly! Here is a long essay about Underwater Basket Weaving in Nigeria".
(I felt like getting cheeky and using ChatGPT to draft a reply, and I'd bet you wouldn't notice, but I didn't, because I'm a good boy)
Even so-called AI detectors have unacceptable failure rates. Us moderators have no ground truth to go off of, but of course, we do our best. This will, inevitably, not withstand truly motivated bad actors, but we haven't been swamped yet.
we get utility monster sub groups that are net-tax negative
A utility monster is an entity that gets disproportionately large gains from the same allocation of resources, as compared to a 'normal' person. They also are usually considered far harder to satiate, such that from most utilitarian perspectives, the correct thing to do is to keep dumping almost all of your resources on them indefinitely, and even if others are starved, helping the monster is still more net utils. In other words, if you give a normal person $500, they're happy, $5000, happier, and so on but with clear diminishing returns and an asymptote (Bill Gates probably would be just as happy to make another billion as another ten billion), but a utility monster might just keep getting happier indefinitely and outcompete everyone else in terms of $/util.
While the subgroups you're presumably discussing are net negative in terms of taxes, they're not utility monsters. Maybe from the perspective of someone who approves of people using their welfare payments on heroin, but otherwise, I fail to see why they would benefit more than any other group at the same degree of poverty.
The Twitter meme does not imply what people think it implies. It shows the extent of a person's moral circle of concern, and does not mean that liberals care more about distant strangers than their own family or neighbors.
But let's not let actually reading the study get in the way of easy gotchas or reasons to yell at the outgroup, eh?
I'm afraid you're out of the loop, Scott has been been broadly supportive of trans people for about as long as he's been blogging and it's been a subject thrust into the societal limelight. Even when he tackles questions like its potential classification as a mental illness, autogynephilia and so on, he's always advocated for compassion, understanding and tolerance of trans people, even if he's lukewarm about the ideology. He's been remarkably ideologically consistent for the ~decade I've been reading him, so he's not really more leftist than he ever was, and I would peg him as firmly grey tribe, not that it's a very fixed category.
He has been less radical, at least in the eyes of many of his longterm readers, but as he speculated in a post addressing that topic, it might simply be that discourse outpaced him. I consider his recent posts somewhat of a return to form. Even old Scott wouldn't outright endorse HBD, at best he wrung his hands about it, and would avoid it where possible. You're correct that it was his squeamishness (and pressure from his social circle) that made him deplatform the thriving discussion threads of CWR or even some topics in the comments of his blog.
(I'm surprised people come here from Drama. Not that I judge, I lurk for the lolz and did so while it was still a sub. Adversity makes for strange bedfellows, because I can't imagine a forum that has a more polar-opposite culture and discussion norms than /r/Drama when compared to us)
Gemini 2.0 Pro. 400k tokens is far from filling up its context window, which is about 2 million tokens.
Out of boredom, I even got it to start rewriting it in Scott's style, and it's a respectable pastiche if not nearly as good as he actually is. I gave up because it took half a minute of processing to just ingest the pdf, and it would take absolutely ages to get a book out of it at the rate it produces new tokens. Not that it's not feasible if you need it, but this was idle curiosity and me being industrious in my laziness.
It's nice to live in the future. I was going through the MRCPsych reading list, and one of the books straight up made my eyes glaze over.
Psychiatric textbooks can have a tendency to huff their own farts, what I'd give to have Scott actually write a textbook (though I'm sure he has more valuable ways to spend his time). I decided to throw it in, 400k tokens, into an LLM to give me a TL;DR (if 10k words isn't too long itself). Truly a more enlightened age, using machines to make succinct what humans made verbose. Just the book alone is about 100 times more text than the original iteration of ChatGPT could hold in its context window.
What makes you say that Scott is explicitly aligning with the left wing, beyond continued displays of his longterm predilections?
The man came out defending HBD. I can't think of many things less leftist.
From that link:
Kendall v. United States ex rel. Stokes, 37 U.S. (12 Pet.) 524 (1838). After the Postmaster General refused to pay a contractor for delivering mail, the contractor persuaded Congress to pass a bill requiring the Postmaster General to pay him. The Postmaster General refused, so the contractor sued. Held: the Postmaster General was required to pay.
Damn. I guess Congress was either really bored and underworked at the time, or they thought acting as a small-claims court was a cushy gig.
Bare links to Google would trigger a ban
To nitpick, it probably wouldn't warrant a ban. A warning, certainly, but bans would come up if they didn't stop and didn't contribute anything of note. I can't say that situation actually came up outside of actual spam.
I agree with you here. There's an unfortunate amount of inherent haziness in trying to adjudicate using the Motte's rules, and the effort requirements are quite often the most litigated.
If someone is using an AI in a more discreet manner, while I can't I outright approve of them doing so, if I can't prove it, well...
A 3rd party reseller on Amazon tried to rip me off. I use an iPad to take notes (best in the business, Android tablets are lacking, and I hate Apple).
Back when I used to use pen and paper, I always ended up misplacing months worth of notebooks on a regular basis. Much easier when it's all digital and backed up to the cloud, especially when you can annotate textbooks and notes with a stylus.
My trusty old iPad Air started giving up the ghost, it had a cracked screen that hadn't been a problem for the last 4 years, but I guess the digitizer had enough, and I wasn't willing to pay Apple's repair charges.
I shopped around, saw a good deal on a refurbished m2 iPad Pro, and ordered it, though I had my fingers crossed since the quality was "acceptable".
Turns out it wasn't. The fuckers sent me a 2020 model, the one with the A12Z instead of an M2. It's a good thing I have an autistic obsession with keeping track of hardware that doesn't physically change in appearance year over year.* I was too ticked off to bother waiting for the seller to respond to my angry messages, so I ended up escalating to Amazon. I'm enjoying roasting their chestnuts over a fire, and with any luck I might end up with a third iPad, or at least my money back. Yay for strong consumer protection laws in the UK, though I hope not to need them.
*I noticed Apple's sign up email mention the generation, and went huh, that doesn't look right.
Edit: I was idiot. The larger and smaller iPad pros are out of sync in terms of generation counts, and they sent me the right one. I suppose a 5 star review will make things right.
My perplexity about what the universe holds in store for 2025 is off the charts. No wonder that LLMs with knowledge cutoffs in early 2024 straight up think users are pulling their legs when discussing recent events.
Both the definition and charge of ethnic cleansing is often disputed, with some researchers including and others excluding coercive assimilation or mass killings as a means of depopulating an area of a particular group.[6][7][8]
I am well aware of what the term means, even though those who care to define it can't find mutual agreement.
I think it's absolute bullshit as a concept in general, the arson, murder and jaywalking charges of international law.
I oppose your use of it to describe what, until proven otherwise, is a humanitarian intervention that will likely keep two inimicable foes from tearing out each other's throats, and with the US footing the bill for the repair work instead of confiscating the $3.50 left in Gazan accounts.
We might disagree, but I expect even you think that US peacekeepers would be a preferable alternative in the eyes of the locals, and with a better track record of not doing {all alleged Israeli war crimes}.
God, I absolutely hate attempts to subsume so many different things under "ethnic cleansing" or genocide.
Gaza is a smoldering ruin. The US gov is, as far as I can tell, not indicating a desire to send its remaining denizens to a gas chamber. It seems they're being relocated, presumably with enormous amounts of US aid and direct support, with US forces probably being more palatable to the locals than Israelis would be, the place is being rebuilt from the ground up, at which point I presume return tickets might be booked.
If this is "ethnic cleansing" in a manner that deserves to be condemned, so am I when I do a bad job with my laundry.
I'd be the person you're looking for.
I think AI is a useful tool, and has some utility in discourse, the most pertinent example that comes to mind being fact-checking lengthy comments (though I still expect people to read them).
I'm fine with short excerpts being quoted. I am on the fence for anything longer, and entirely AI generated commenting or posting without human addition is beyond the pale as far as I'm concerned.
My stance is that AI use is presumed to be low effort by default, the onus is on the user to put their own time and effort into vetting and fact checking it, and only quoting from it when necessary. I ask that longer pieces of prose be linked off-site, pastebin would be a good option.
While I can tolerate people using AI to engage with me, I can clearly see, like the other mods, that it's a contentious topic, and it annoys people reflexively, with some immediately using AI back as a gotcha, or refusing to engage with the text on its own merits. I'm not going to go "am I out of touch, no it's the users who are wrong" here, the Motte relies on consensus both in its moderation team, and in its user base. If people who would otherwise be happy and productive users check out or disengage, then I am happy to have draconian restrictions for the sake of maintaining the status quo.
People come here to talk to humans. They perceive AI text to be a failure in that regard (even I at least want a human in the loop, or I'd talk to Claude). If this requires AI to be discouraged, that's fine. I'm for it, though I would be slightly unhappy with a categorical ban. If that's the way things turn out, this not a hill I care to die on, especially when some users clearly would be happy to take advantage of our forbearance.
An interesting choice.. I admit that if I ran into a lone survivor in the apocalypse who had made it that far with a poodle for a companion, I'd be second-guessing myself.
I prefer to judge each case on its merits, but I agree that the expectation is that an AI generated post has less effort put into it than otherwise. I prefer that it has enough effort put in, by the human using it, to overcome that detriment.
“I asked AI x and here’s what it said…”
I don't think this is necessarily a bad thing. LLMs represent an enormous amount of knowledge, grossly superhuman levels. Even the most erudite and educated human pales in comparison, likely even with the ability to Google the topic. If that sounds doubtful, you can look at benchmarks like GPQA, which, as the full name would imply, is supposed to be "Google Proof" unless you have immense domain knowledge.
They are great didactic tools, especially when you don't know where to begin on a topic. If someone wrote something that seemed to me to be wrong (intuition, a hunch I can't articulate) but I wouldn't be able to engage closely enough to disagree on my own, it's a worthwhile endeavor to ask an LLM to scrutinize it, and sometimes using that information to push back.
Hey, I asked ChatGPT to do a vibes check on your comment. It pointed out these objections, which look sensible to me. Why ought I disregard them? Is something I would not object to if I was done to me. A human is asking the question, through an intermediary.
The average LLM is more trustworthy than the average Twitter or Reddit commentator, though for now I would hope the Motte does better. While I still prefer engaging with humans, I think what the machines can say is often enlightening.
That's just a GSD with a French accent, but I can get behind that choice haha*
*Assuming original GSDs didn't pick up a mix from living in Alsace.
I don't want AI slop!
I want AI output that has been prompted, filtered or modified via editing to not be slop.
I don't know about you, but my disagreement is with people who think AI output is nothing but slop. I think it is perfectly possible for it to be useful and interesting, even enlightening at times. Not enough that I can assume that by default, but it's not the GPT-2 days where it was incoherent and meaningless.
Of course, I would still prefer to engage with real humans, but as long as they are actually reading what I say and exercising oversight over what an LLM used on their behalf says back (and is clear about it), I would only be slightly miffed.
(I do think having the BLR back wouldn't hurt, but I have no strong feelings on the matter)
I find Claude and DeepSeek far harder to detect than ChatGPT. They have a far more 'human' default style, that doesn't stick out like a sore thumb. That might just be me, but even the average internet user has some ability to detect ChatGPT.
Of course, if you provide excerpts from your own writing and ask it to emulate you, or just refer to a known figure whose writing is in the corpus (Gwern, Scott etc), I wouldn't except to be able to tell unless strongly primed to be suspicious in advance.
I don't think @ChestertonMeme used an LLM to generate those bulletpoints. They seem to represent his own thoughts, and they're not ChatGPT-ese.
If you were living through a societal breakdown/apocalypse (well, the kind that doesn't immediately kill you) and you had to pick a canine companion, what would you opt for?
It would definitely be a German shepherd for me. Loyal to a fault, smart and intimidating to strangers without being bloodthirsty. I miss mine a lot, but he had a good life and that's what counts. I'd expect a GSD would do a good job keeping you safe.
It certainly wouldn't be my lab, I tell you. An absolute lovable doofus who traded brains for brawn, turning out 50% larger than the average lab.
Interesting. I don't know if this is common outside of Japan, but it's the first time I'm hearing it.
The pharmacy next to my med school had a rather lax approach when it came to doling out controlled substances and prescription meds, even to med students. I know that personally, because I certainly asked for them (I could have brought along a valid prescription if needed, but I knew they wouldn't ask). I don't recall anyone from my cohort taking advantage, and I didn't see any obvious signs of abuse. Even in my medical career, I never heard of a doctor I personally knew or worked with admitting to abusing meds or being caught out doing so. Nobody clearly zooted on stims, or sedated from benzos or opioids.
Not that anyone is really abusing beta blockers, and you wouldn't be able to tell unless they passed out or something. Interestingly enough, I did take a few when my palpitations from my methylphenidate became overwhelming, but I was aware of minor negative effects on memory and cognition and did my best not to take them before exams. I suppose if someone has crippling anxiety, it beats the alternative!

It wouldn't do so without explicit instruction or example. Not that it isn't capable of doing so, it's simply not default behavior.
More options
Context Copy link