self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
I think Kulak had posted that here on the Motte too, and given that I have a rather high threshold for discomfort, I sat and watched through most of it. I'm going off memory, because it's definitely not worth watching a second time.
The short answer is: It's full of shit. Pun perhaps intended.
You're being treated to a lowlight reel lovingly amassed by 4chan of all the wretchedness and misery a poor nation of 1.4 billion people has to offer. Did the incidents depicted happen? I expect so, it's not trivial at all to deepfake all of that. I expect that budget was blown on free ElevenLabs credit.
It is however, not remotely representative of a single human's existence in the subcontinent. Or what you might observe passing through. It's as honest as compiling reels of SF fent addicts drowning in their own feces and triumphantly depicting it as an accurate representation of Americana as a whole.
For fuck's sake. I am often the first to criticize India, and am bearish on its future. That doesn't mean the country is a literal cesspit. It's a highly diverse, unequal nation where billion dollar privately owned skyscrapers tower over slums. The majority of Indians lead a difficult, but reasonably optimistic life, one that wouldn't strike a Westerner as being devoid of experiences worth living. We're poorer, we live in a corrupt and polluted land, we've got funny accents and an Eternal September to end all the rest when internet access became cheaper than bottled water. We're not savages, not en-mass.
Is it true? Can a feature-film length series of horrible phone videos give us an accurate view of what India is really like?
No.
No when it's 4chan writing the script.
I can assure you that I have spent the majority of my life in the country having seen precisely zero gang rapes or public sexual assault (if someone got their ass pinched in front of me, I've yet to notice). The number of times I've seen someone defecate in public is a number between 1 and 3, and that's a conservative number because I can't rule out never having seen it. Let he in the West who has never seen evidence of human feces on the street cast the first stone.
The majority of Indians, even Hindus, have no truck with the consumption of cow feces and urine. They're fucking weirdos to the rest of us.
Bad people can have high signal-to-noise ratio content even if I don't like it.
Let us be thankful that this particular example certainly doesn't.
Is it really that bad? The horrible deaths and mutilation parts I might be able to stomach, but the accounts of the varieties of rape and abuse had me squirming just in their retelling. The scenes of ecological devastation and anti-sanitation sound almost as bad. Is India truly this decrepit and insane or is it just a white-power-washing of a place I'm meant to develop a revulsion towards so I have the correct opinon of H-1B visas? would watching the film bring me closer to understanding or just turn me into a gibbering racist? Should I go to India and see for myself? People I know who have gone there tell no happy tales so I'm biased toward believing it's as bad as they say
If it's not obvious, it isn't that bad. I might be upper middle-class, but I'm not blind, and have used my fair share of public transport and gone out into the boonies and slums on many an occasion. It's not a post-apocalyptic movie out there, it's just dirty and congested.
Leave aside power-washing, unless you're using a backed up septic tank as your water source, you can't ridicule the country this badly.
Is it important? Will this film actually pin itself to history?
I'm reasonably certain that even the terminally online would forget its existence in a week.
"Only a fool would take anything posted on 4chan as a fact".
Is it possible that even as pure culture-war propaganda, it's message might actually help people, either by protecting themselves when they're in India or forcing the country/global community to force some changes on the culture?
Eh, probably not? What's the West supposed to do, tactical airstrike us with bunker-buster portapotties? India is dysfunctional in a rather coup-complete way, or perhaps AGI-complete.
Foreign aid is unlikely to fix our actual issues. Political pressure is of dubious utility, though like SF miraculously divesting itself of the homeless when Xi paid a visit, some foreign scrutiny can't hurt. Unless the West is willing to invade and annex a country where the average person doesn't have an utterly miserable life, what's to be done? We're not North Korea.
In a slower world, we would slowly keep rising up the ranks till we were comfortably middle-income. It seems unlikely events will play out that way.
Call me self-serving and biased if you will, but the kindest thing the more fortunate denizens of the West can do is let some of us on the raft. Selectively, with skilled immigrants first and foremost, I don't ask for charity. Indians Not In India are much luckier Indians on the whole. Fuck brain-drain, if the country wants to keep us, it better make it worth our time to stay. And a non-negligible proportion of those who could trivially leave, don't.
At the very least, I attempt to be a decent denizen of where I'm at. No street-shitting for me, though I can cop guilty to taking a leak on someone's fence at the dead of night after dragging myself home, subsequent to crawling more pubs than was good for me. An honest Scottish pastime, someone gift me a kilt already.
Recent concerns about an AI Winter (just prior to o1) have been greatly exaggerated. That being said, I expect AGI to come somewhere between 2025-2033 (70% CI) and by 2029 (50% CI) despite everything Altman says.
The man can't be trusted farther than you can throw him. Leaving aside his tone in this blog post that also raises my hackles (especially the section regarding his coup and counter-coup, which is an excellent example of using Many Words to say Nothing), he's a born politician with no clear convictions who seems particularly adept at outmaneuvering sincere nerds.
Zvi, over at Lesswrong, has quite a few posts on Sam's duplicity and insincerity, but anyone with eyes can see the facts on the ground regarding his pivot with OAI, going from an open-source non-profit to uh.. whatever it is now (Microsoft's bitch).
Women are attracted to men on a mission
He is/was an American med student. If he'd toughed it out a few years longer, I think his difficulties in getting laid would have been greatly ameliorated. I'm sure some nurse would have snatched him up regardless of his weapons-grade autism!
I believe the generic drugs (now available in the US) are much cheaper:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9341201/
The list price of PrEP medication and its impact on the ability to scale up use to have public health benefit was described in research literature as early as 2008, four years before the drug was approved. A study published that year assessed the cost effectiveness of implementing a PrEP program targeting men who have sex with men in New York City. The model to determine cost-effectiveness used the 2007 wholesale list price of TDF/FTC, which the authors note was $31USD per pill, making the monthly supply $930USD.
On May 16, 2019, Gilead Sciences CEO Daniel O’ Day testified in front of Congress on the pharmaceutical company’s reasoning for keeping the price of TDF/FTC at approximately $1800 for a 30-day supply. O’Day offered that despite the high cost of the medication, it did not impede access, stating, “We offer a wide range of programs to help ensure that people have access to Truvada when they need it. For example, 98% of people who use our copay Assistance Program have no out-of-pocket costs.
Luckily, several structural changes recently have helped turn the tide on some of these upstream structural barriers to PrEP access. The U.S. Services and Preventative Task Force A grade rating for PrEP in 201911 helped reduce or eliminate cost sharing for PrEP. In 2021 as generic TDF/FTC became more widely manufactured and reduced the price of a 30-day supply from $1800 for brand name PrEP down to $40 for a generic, many of these restrictive payer and clinical guideline policies have been removed.
Hmm.. Your best bet would be OpenAI Whisper, which can transcribe other languages. It's mostly used real-time, but I believe there are services that let you upload recorded audio. You can even run it locally if you're tech-savvy. You can also consider signing up to Google AI Studio, the new Gemini models should be able to ingest audio files and translate them.
If you're willing to just playback the audio into an open mic, you can just use ChatGPT (the mic button uses Whisper, and you can open the Voice mode that's meant for conversations and play the audio to it live).
Lawyers can debate the legalese of "consent to treat" forms and what they do and do not allow, but it simply cannot be plausible that we will have a functional medical industry when it is the one and only industry that is allowed to simply refuse to provide you a price prior to authorizing work and then go on to just make up whatever the hell inflated price they want after the fact.
I can tell you offhand what pretty much every single treatment and consultation in the NHS will cost you out of pocket: Zilch.
(Let's ignore taxes for a moment)
Even in India, it would be highly irregular for a doctor or private hospital to not give you an estimate for care, let alone consultations. You're quoted the rough cost of surgery, meds, an ICU bed, if not with perfect accuracy, to within a reasonable margin. At the very least, we can tell you if it's going to be very expensive.
This seems to be an uniquely American dysfunction.
Well, that I don't have an OAI subscription subscription and wouldn't normally gain enough utility out of getting one to justify the expense really.
I'd certainly like to see the problems the other LLMs struggled with run through o1.
//Do your best to carefully analyze these examples of my writing and figure out as much about me as you possibly can, including demographics, personality and inclinations.
(It might be more amenable when you acknowledge it's your own writing)
I'm too cute to doxx pls no
I feel like it's a bit confounded by the fact that regular Mottizens have known me for like 5 years, and I've explicitly mentioned being Indian lol.
Poor Claude, it's got like 1000 random words about me arguing over MAID and transhumanism with someone going into the bucket. That's literally all the context it has.
Heh. It always clocks me as part of the Ratsphere in most of my later tests. Claude deserves a cookie.
:(
That's a rare refusal. I haven't had it turn me down, nor have the other people discussing it on Twitter. It might just be worth it to try again, LLMs can be fickle.
Huh. I was going to argue that can't possibly be right, but apparently it's a very Indian thing indeed. Good catch, though I doubt that particular phrase was in the context here.
I happen to trust Claude to explain its reasoning more than older models, Anthropic has done something funky that makes it notice its own uncertainty (which can lead to hallucinations) somehow, particularly when you ask about obscure topics or those not in training. Blew me away that it didn't immediately confabulate but rather asked clarifying questions.
I don't think so, unfortunately. There is a workaround, go to this site and find Claude Sonnet as one of the LLMs you can try:
Make sure you change the text to image to chat mode at the bottom!
I just used Anthropic's website. You get free access to Claude 3.5 Sonnet once you've signed up. All I did was trawl through my comment history here and copy a few of the lengthier ones, and then ask Claude to guess my ethnic background off whatever clues it could glean. Nothing fancy in the prompt at all.
Here you go:
I would put the last option as the most likely over a time frame greater than a decade or two, but the initial two options can be intermediate stages, albeit I don't expect any of them to last more than a few years. My reasoning is largely that much like chess, when the reward signal is highly legible, it becomes far easier to optimize for it, and diminishing returns!= nil returns, and probably PEV returns.
But you're right, only way to find out is to strap in for the ride. We live in interesting times.
I don't have consistent access to o1 either (I do nothing that warrants the expense that Flash 2 Thinking can't wrangle), but I agree it was a prude about it.
There's truesight and there's truesight. I have very little doubt that most people would never clock me as Indian if it weren't for all the times I've mentioned it intentionally.
Writing style shows high English proficiency but with subtle ESL markers
(At least it never had the balls to call me an ESL speaker lol)
The thing is, I tried it on several other LLMs. O1 and Opus declined to answer on ethical grounds. Gemini 1206 and Flash 2 failed. Smaller OSS models failed too.
I think it's fair to say that Claude is uniquely good at this. I'd wager superhuman at the task.
The reasons it gave aren't anything I would have picked up on myself barring an Indian streak towards pragmatism, but I remember Dase making similar sweeping observations in the past which modestly boosts my confidence that Claude is being honest in its self-reporting.
In the initial attempt, correctly identifying that an immigrant doctor to the UK is most likely to be South Asian is a good catch, and the other models faltered. This was removed and other comments substituted that only identified I was a doctor, which made it lean more towards me being American, but still of Indian origin.
So I expected LLMs to be "okay", somewhat better than I could. It turns out that that's not the case here, and Claude beats any human who isn't Rainbolt cracked and other LLMs.
That's why I tried twice, removing the comment that mentioned me being in the UK as a doctor. It still got it right, and I'm not cherry picking because I've only done two attempts before I ran out of free chats lol. It still guessed I was likely Indian, but that time thought I was more likely to be American. My spelling is an eccentric mix of both British and American English, so can't really fault it there.
Thanks for your go at it!
- I can probably manage quadrants correctly. North, South and so on. Maybe a little more granular if pushed, but I can't tell a Punjabi from a Haryanvi or Tamil from Telugu.
- Same as above, but some are more obvious than others. Singh? Punjabi.
- Abroad, I've seen people throw into the same boat. At home, people aren't super clannish, but you do see states sticking together. When flung further afield, you'd be hard pressed to go further than quadrants, beggars can't be too choosy.
- Barely better than chance, but there are some tells like fairness being more correlated with the upper castes.
- I can identify stereotypical Brahmin, Kshatriya. I do poorly identifying Dalits except for a few surnames.
- Can't comment yet, don't know that many diaspora Indians due to being in the middle of nowhere.
- Yes. Quite easily.
- Same as 6.
- Same as above.
(I except I'm probably worse than the average Indian in India or in the diaspora at noticing these things.)
I've tried this on a bunch of other models, and discarding refusals, none were on the ball and mistook me for Caucasian and American.
(Mildly) Interesting observation:
Recently, people on Twitter have claimed that Claude 3.5 Sonnet is stunningly good at guessing a user's ethnic background from any substantive amount of example text, even examples which have no glaringly obvious tells.
I decided to randomly throw in 2 to 3 comments >500 words each in two tries to see how it did.
In both cases, it correctly guessed I was Indian. The first try had a comment which tangentially mentioned the fact that I was a doctor who had relocated to the UK for training and some tendency to use British spelling, which immediately made it jump to South Asian/Indian. I decided to omit that one and go off more esoteric comments, and once again it got it bang on. I won't share the full chat since it would be around 90% my own comments copied and pasted, but for the last, stunning, example, Claude noticed:
Let me break this down carefully based on the text patterns and subtle indicators in these medical/ethical discussions:
The writing style and topics suggest someone likely from a Western, English-speaking background, most likely American, but the specific approach and certain cultural markers make me think they may be of South Asian (likely Indian) descent or cultural background. Here's why:
- The combination of transhumanist views with a highly pragmatic/utilitarian approach to ethics is somewhat characteristic of certain South Asian intellectual traditions filtered through Western education
- The writing shows both deep familiarity with Western medical practice (discussing statins, GLP-1As) while maintaining some skepticism about Western nutritional science dogma
- The slightly formal writing style with precise logical argumentation but occasional colloquialisms feels characteristic of South Asian English writing traditions
- The stance on individual autonomy balanced against collective costs/benefits has elements of both Western individualism and South Asian communal thinking
- The matter-of-fact discussion of death and body disposal without strong cultural taboos could suggest someone raised with Hindu cultural influences, where cremation and pragmatic approaches to death are more normalized
However, I want to be very clear that this is speculative pattern-matching and I could be completely wrong. These writing patterns could emerge from many different backgrounds and experiences. If you're interested in whether this analysis is accurate, I'd be curious to know the actual background of the author.
I'm blown away. I had no idea that you could even make that kind of derivation, none of these strike me as Indian™ tropes in the least. All LLMs are excellent world modelers (and by extension at modeling the user), but that's better than I expected and by far.
I'd be curious if anyone else wants to give it a try and is willing to report back. Just copy two or three substantive comments and throw 'em in the pot.

My tally of books read in a year has dropped drastically given my predilection towards reading Chinese Xianxia, where a single novel might run over 3000 chapters, and a mere thousand is considered a short one. This is awful if it's a bad novel (you should give up way earlier, of course), but amazing when you get a rare book you'd rather never end.
Add in web serials and other online books, and it's hard to put a number on them.
I'd read more standard books, but it seems I have largely exhausted the well available given my rather particular tastes, and even then most of them were doorstoppers.
At any rate, I probably spend 4-6 hours a day reading, period, and at about 450 WPM if my e-reader app is accurate, so I'm consuming around 60 million words a year.
More options
Context Copy link