self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
I appreciate the advice. Sadly I haven't been in a good mood for the past 10 years, so that isn't anything new haha. Well, not at a stretch at least.
It's been a year and a half now. Like, I am sad it didn't work out, but much of the pain and devastation I'm used to from previous breakups was frontloaded, used up in all our endless battles over the pettiest bullshit.
I'm mostly numb. I only shed enough tears to wet a toothbrush.
Two months is far too long to mourn. I have exams. Work, that frowns strongly on me turning up with a hangover. And I suspect my parents would be rather miffed if I spent two months in a drunken haze.
Not even at my worst did I feel tempted to hit the bottle that hard, and my liver thanks me.
Do people use minoxidil to grow hair on their face? I've never heard of that before.
If you take too much minoxidil orally, you grow hair everywhere that hair can grow.
Applied topically, it works just as well for beards as bald patches on the scalp. Check out /r/Minoxbeards , I can personally vouch for it, and my brother who was a stickler to the routine had even more startling results from a worse start. My family is kinda bad at growing beards naturally and we're no different. My aunts never grew one, nor did my grandma, though a great aunt managed a moustache once before a misandrist cow mistook her for a man and kicked her in the head.
Uhh, I hesitate to ask what this means. Do you mean departed like he's not on the Motte, or do you mean departed like he died while attempting to do the Scag (or whatever that wilderness thing was called that he was doing)?
The former. Someone here was claiming that he did something far more sensible like climb a mountain first instead of the Hock (or at least to prepare for it). He's still alive, or at least that's where the smart money is.
I don't know what a Scag is, but if it's as suggestive as it sounds, you'd need an entirely different blue pill ending with -fil to make it work.
I'm sure Bing is a loss leader, but they're desperate enough for market share in the browser space for it to be worth it.
If they can simply cut into Google's margins then it's stillworth it.
And they own half of OAI, and intend to buy Mistral, so they intend to own all the horses they can to maximize the change of backing the winning one.
Eh, I'll make more money in the future, unless the robbits take my jerb. Which they will, but maybe after I can afford a few of the finer things in life.
I'm not an EA. I couldn't give less of a fuck about the moral valence of shrimp.
I don't make nearly as strong a claim as you like, so I'm not compelled to submit the arguments you desire. As I've said before, intelligent, functional humans are rational enough that explicit training in the "arts" of rationality, including Bayesian reasoning, provides little mundane value in everyday life to justify the added effort of engaging in it. The opportunity cost of doing so every day is simply not worth it, it's an arsenal best reserved for Big Ticket decisions, and even then, cultural wisdom and "common sense" are not terrible. You don't need a black belt from Yudkowsky's dojo to know not to finance a 2024 Dodge Charger at 30% APR or rack up credit card debt, or even to make sensible middle class decisions.
But the fact is that when you can justify it, such as in forecasting (financial or otherwise), you see the pros doing it. Hence it must be superior to fudging it, all the more so when the stakes are high. The existence of any alpha at that level is surprising enough.
I haven't looked into it in that much detail, but I genuinely find the elegance of its explanations in multiple, highly different cognitive disorders, to be hard to explain if it didn't have a kernel of truth.
But as I've admitted, it could be a just-so story or false pattern matching. I'm not that confident in it just yet.
If I see anything more convincing, I'll try and spread it around. For now, it's the domain of better psychiatrists, neurologists and researchers than me.
Way ahead of you chief, already got that beer bottle in hand. Funnily enough I'm not nearly as depressed as I was in past breakups, I crave a stiff drink, but I'm not inclined to drown my sorrows in wine just yet. Several of those breakups weren't initiated by me, so the sense of crushing inadequacy was far more overwhelming. These days, I'm older and (maybe) wiser, I know I've got game and while I am simply too lazy to be a fuckboy, I can charm women into committed relationships, to our mutual detriment.
As a minor consolation, I've matched with an absolutely amazonian fashion designer on the apps, and while her literacy is questionable, with thighs like that, she could crush my skull till our IQs match and I wouldn't complain. 🙏 Inshallah I'm going straight to heaven
So I'm going to finish my beer, which has gone flat since I'm arguing on the Motte. I'm going to pop a Ritalin, because I'm a terrible doctor who doesn't listen to advice about avoiding mixing stimulants and sedatives (well, with one beer it isn't that bad), and then I'm going to read up more on calcium metabolism, which is paradoxical enough that maybe a brain compress will help me understand it better, or at least it'll make more sense when I'm drunk.
Alcohol actually improves memory, at least from before you began drinking it.
Funny thing: everybody loves Bayes rule; but they never state their priors. To that extent they never consciously use it. Nor is there any evidence that it models the unconscious process of real life rational cognition. The evidence to support that would need to be quantitative; not just "Hey I believed something, then I saw something, and I altered my degree of belief. Must have been using Bayes!"
You evidently don't hang around LessWrong enough.
While Predictive Processing theory, which posits that human cognition is inherently Bayesian, has not been established to the extent it's nigh incontrovertible, it elegantly explains many otherwise baffling things about human cognition, including how it breaks when it comes to mental illnesses like depression, autism, OCD, and schizophrenia. I've linked to Scott on it before. I think it's more likely to be true than not, even if I can't say with a straight-face that it's gospel truth. It is almost certainly incomplete.
In other words, humans are being imperfect Bayesians all the time, and you don't need to explicitly whip out the formula on encountering evidence to get by, but in situations where the expected value of doing so in a rigorous fashion is worth it, you should. The rest of the time, evolution has got you covered.
Besides, the best, most accurate superforecasters and people like quants absolutely pull it out and do explicit work. In their case, the effort really is worth it. You can't beat them without doing the same.
I don't know whether he's better or worse than Euler when it comes to having so many bloody things named after him that they need disambiguation pages on Wikipedia.
seeing as (as I take it) you live in America and get paid in dollarydoos
Hahahahahahahahahahaha.. (Dissolves into a puddle while sobbing)
I'm not American, as much as I would love to be. I'm Indian, in India, even if I hold a GMC registration, I'm refraining from working in the UK until I smash my residency exams and get a job with actual career progression there.
As of last month, my monthly salary was about $800 and change. After my old post was made redundant, it may or may not drop 30%, depending on how keen HR is on noticing the discrepancy in payroll.
So $24, while a sum I can afford, is far from nothing either. For practical use cases, I can get more value than Claude out of Bing with GPT-4 (personal use suggests parity on almost all tasks, but benchmarks show that the latest version of GPT-4 beats it by a meaningful threshold, though God knows what fork Bing is using). This is the one domain where the former is clearly superior, and given that I've been too lazy to make a Patreon, I don't make any money from writing either. I do it mainly because I enjoy it.
So, like you, I can technically afford it, given that I have no meaningful expenses barring ordering in food. I still don't see it as justified quite yet, though I am/was sorely tempted. The main reason is that for everything else, Bing is free and just as good.
Bayesianism would then be a methdology to help in our conjectural decisionmaking, but would never elevate our theories beyond the status of a guess. Do we disagee here?
We don't. I only wish to emphasize that since we have no reason to think that nothing else can, this is not grounds to knock Bayesianism.
So what's the logical relationship between your calculation of confidence in a theory and the truth of that theory?
Bayesian updates are, as I understand it, the optimal way to update on new evidence in the light of your existing priors, and with sufficient evidence, two Bayesian who start out with very different credences can converge to the same place. The Aumann Agreement theorem proves that two perfect Bayesians who are able to full share all their information and priors must converge to unanimity, don't ask me how practical that happens to be.
Logical truths are just propositions we have very high confidence in, downstream of axioms or valid arguments in which we also vest high confidence. Is it possible, as in, is there a non-zero chance, that you or I could be hallucinating and imagining obvious truth where there is none? Well, the base rate of insanity or hallucination is greater than 1 in 8 billion. In practise, we can ignore this, and people who wish to function will summarily do so.
As I've demonstrated, the binary notion of truth you hold so dear is simply unattainable, so you should take what you can get in that regard.
Popperian falsifiability is simply dysfunctional. Taken at face value, recall those experiments that suggested neutrinos move faster than light? That is evidence that neutrinos move faster than light.
A serious Popperian would immediately give up on the idea that nothing can exceed the speed of light in a vacuum. A sensible Bayesian, which humans (and thus physicists) are naturally inclined to be, would note that this evidence is severely outweighed by all the other observations we have, and while adjusting very slightly in favor of it being possible to exceed the speed of light with a massive object, still sensibly choose to devote the majority of their energy to finding flaws in the experiment.
Which did in fact turn out to exist.
Bayesianism applied rigorously is simply far more robust than Popperian notions can be, and to the extent the latter was deemed to be workable, it was only by (pragmatically) ignoring minor bits of evidence against one's hypothesis.
I find myself single.
This was inevitable, and the writing was on the wall that the two of us weren't compatible, even if I loved her dearly right from the start.
Little fights would snowball into battles, she had a hair-trigger temper and you'd swear her name, which incidentally could have passed as Latina, made her one. As lovely as she could be, as smart and talented as she was, it wasn't meant to be.
I'm at fault. I'll gladly shoulder the majority of the burden for it all. I could make excuses about ADHD, depression, the enormous amount of stress I'm under as the knives chop away inexorably at the strands of the future, but for all that they're true excuses, I was a pretty crappy boyfriend. I'm very lucky I'm smart and funny enough, that I could make her laugh and temporarily forget my myriad flaws. It's not like I didn't care about her, even if I struggled to show it in the way she craved.
She'll be fine. She always was a fighter.
I think I'll be too. After all, this was a shared decision. Like two cacti hugging in the cold desert winds on a moonless night, the sweetness of the dripping nectar couldn't keep at bay the building pain from all the pricks and scabs we couldn't help but scratch at.
On to more practical things.
I've given enough (good) dating advice here that I know the ropes. Currently, work and exams makes even the apps appealing, for all that they're meticulously designed by psychologists (and the incentives of mammalian evolution) to be a gauntlet of suffering for the male of the species, all to squeeze out your hopes, dreams, and more importantly, money.
But I've aged like wine. I've got a dozen good pictures carefully curated. With a dog. In scrubs. With friends, so women can rest assured I'm not a psycho. In decent clothing and proper lighting. I might not be as handsome as my brother, but I'm certainly not repulsive either. Most importantly, I'm older, and for a man, that's a good thing, right till the male pattern baldness or the paunch hits. Two matches in less than two hours, whereas the last time I tried, as a med student, it took days or weeks.
I'd love to date more in person, but I'm not going to hit the clubs alone. Most of my friends have long since fled to fairer shores. Thankfully flirting with patients (or at least their family members, I don't swing towards 70 year old ladies with cancer) is not illegal in India, we haven't cucked our doctors that badly, but that's not really something I'm inclined to do either, let alone how fucking tired I am at work. Oh well, at least I know I can slide into DMs like I was lubed, 7 years of steady relationships don't lie about that. They didn't pick me for my sterling good looks after all.
But if anyone has any advice. I'm all ears. I'm tired of dishing it out and could actually use some myself.
Before anyone suggests the usual, I am, or intend to:
- Get a good haircut (already done).
- Hit the gym.
- Buy clothes? Nah, I haven't bought new ones in like a year, and I've got enough good fits to make it work.
Lawyer upfor our shared investment of a cellphone charger and a vape pod. Well, she does owe me a sizeable amount of money, but I trust she'll pay me back.
I'm tall, charming, with a beard that's far less scraggly after some (poorly adhered to) minoxidil, in a promising career (hahahaha), so please skip the kind of blue pills (psychiatric variant) you'd feed the dearly departed Skookum and the like.
Go on ahead, hit me with your best or worst. I have a beer in hand and a flint in the other to strike and light Tinder. I'm receptive. I have time to kill and the things I need to do can wait.
(The biggest motivator to study for me now has become the observed fact that hot young med students and interns love them an older Resident or Consultant. Time to grind and get that bag.)
First and foremost, myself, with at least the longest prompt I could fit into the research oriented access points (I don't pay for Opus). Previous LLMs have done a 5/10 job, Claude Opus was noticeably better, to put arbitrary numbers on it, 7.5 or an 8. If a human writer had taken the same length of excerpt and figured out as much from context, I'd be impressed by them.
I also tried a combination of Peter Watts and Richard Morgan in a mil-SF setting, and yeah, it was something I would expect from someone well described as a combination of the two. This was zero-shot, since unlike my case, I except it to be familiar with their writings.
That's about as far as I got before I was pissed off about excessive moderation in the research platform (not Claude itself), or the limitations of shady discord bots. I tempted enough to consider spending the $24 it would cost, on top of the existing enormous utility I get for free from Bing, just for that purpose alone, but then I remembered I'm poor and the money is better spent on takeout, heh. No other LLM has made me feel that way about fiction.
It's a long story, but if I had to sum it up: Legitimate/well-intended awareness campaigns can cause mass psychogenic illness, social media fads and the fetishization of therapy culture doing the same, previously under-diagnosed conditions being actually noticed and diagnosed, the drug epidemic, and a reaction to social atomization and the fraying of familial bonds that contributed a great deal to people keeping their shit together in the past when they lived in objectively shit conditions.
It seems to me that it's both true that conditions like ADHD and autism that were once missed because of ignorance are now being diagnosed far earlier and there's a lot of fad chasing and social contagion. Do enough hard drugs and you'll break something up there too, and said drugs have never been more common or tacitly tolerated.
(The actual incidence of "real" autism has likely increased significantly since the previous century, potentially due to increasing parental age, but it's all very confused and I'm only conveying my best understanding of the situation in the West.)
How can we approach arbitrarily close?
By amassing more evidence from observations and updating accordingly. Physics demands 5 sigmas of confidence in experimental results before accepting an experiment as valid. For most purposes, you can get away with a lot less.
As stated, this does nothing to address Hume's argument against induction, which holds equally whether you are aiming for probability or for certainty, and does not address the retro skeptical argument that every reason you can give is either based on something else or based on nothing, leading to infinite regress.
Nobody has a solution to infinite regress, barring "I said so". As far as I can tell, you've got to start somewhere, and Bayesianism leads to more sensible decision theories and is clean and simple.
Another issue Bayesianism often runs into is that many variants of Bayesianism give up on truth - I'm not interested in the confidence we can assign to a theory given our priors and the evidence, I'm interested in whether the theory in question is actually true.
"The next sentence is false. The previous sentence is true." Good luck.
Given that English is an imprecise language, feel free to interpret my 99.9999% confidence that the Sun will rise tomorrow as being equivalent to "it's true the Sun will rise tomorrow".
But if Bayesianism aims at truth rather than solely at subjective calculations of confidence unmoored from reality, if it is interested in what is true rather than just what we can be confident in, it is in no better a position to provide justification than any other epistemology.
The universe we live in does not provide us the luxury of not being "subjective" observers. Bayesianism happens to be entirely cool with that.
I may well be worse than average at art. Sure, if you don't mean to claim that performance at it can be arbitrarily improved with effort (and I didn't think you literally meant it, just that you thought it could make someone a passable artist), then we just happen to disagree on what the criteria for being "OK" at art is.
We have to distinguish between pure drawing from reference (e.g. portraiture, still life) vs creating original pieces. I think the vast majority of otherwise developmentally normal people are capable of learning the former to a competent level. I've done it, I've seen other people do it. It's a purely rote mechanical skill.
In the most degenerate case, one can trace a drawing or use a pinhole camera, but I acknowledge that drawing from imagination is probably quite a bit harder, though I'm sure Real™ artists also use references.
Original pieces are a lot harder but it's not hopeless. I started from absolute zero, I have no intrinsic talent for this. In fact I have anti-talent, progress has been abnormally slow and painful for me. But I was still able to make it this far. Obviously it's not pro level even by anime standards, but I think it's kinda cute and I got a few responses saying as much when I posted it online.
Not bad! I'm glad your efforts paid off.
Now, I would certainly like to be an artist, but as experience has shown, it was not easy at all for me. Thankfully with AI, I no longer need to be constrained by my hand's ability to sketch what my mind conceives. It'll get the writers too, undoubtedly, I'm just grateful for a year or two of alpha so I can say "yeah I was good before anyone could do this". I suppose you'll still draw regardless, since you presumably enjoy drawing, and I'll continue writing.
Liar. Where's @Throwaway06 and onwards? We can't ban you fast enough /s
(Thanks! I was thinking about pinging you, but I assumed you had more important things to do. It is good to know, in the schadenfreude sense, that I'm not the only one suffering and that it never ends.)
This is what it's about, our concept of psychopathology. You mentioned geriatrics, but geriatrics is an epistemologically sound specialization of medicine.
I am confused by what standard geriatrics achieves legitimacy and psychiatry doesn't.
You seem to think that the mind is a nebulous entity, and thus if a disease can be attributed to the brain, it's the domain of neurology. All well and good, but diseases of aging is an even less clear-cut specialization.
At the very least, the causality of:
What comes first, the loss of muscle mass or aging? In this case we can clearly stablish an object of knowledge even if we can't do anything to stop aging.
Aging is a multi-causal process. Everything from telomerase degradation to oxidative stresses, super-exponential degradation in the surveillance capabilities of the immune system such that after a surprisingly tight threshold everything starts breaking down.
But each of the component aspects are within the domain of independent specialities. If you find this an acceptable state of affairs, then what's wrong with psychiatry?
All the patients have in common is that they're old. At that point, a domain specialist who works with the diseases predominantly found in the elderly becomes valuable. All the more when the emphasis switches from cure to comfort, as is often the case.
What comes first, the loss of cognitive function or the proteinopathy? Note that we don't know what causes the proteinopathy, but we do know for sure that Alzheimer's is a brain disease. So I ask again, if depression is a brain disease, then what comes first? Until we can confidently answer that, we can't really say that depression is a "disease like any othe
The question remains that whether comparing the onset of cognitive dysfunction or protein accumulation is even the right question to be asking. Hell, very recently there's been conjecture that it's a prion illness off incidents of what are attributed to horizontal spread, and neurosurgeons get Alzheimers at higher rates, potentially by aerosolized spread. Still a brain disease of course, but by god is not simple or the billions we've spent would have solved it.
My central thesis is that it is irrelevant how you class depression, since it's not clear to me what you mean by it being/not being a "disease like any other". Diseases are very heterogeneous, and attempting to do a neat taxonomy is asking for brain worms yourself.
Let's see an example: There's a person who went through a break up and a year after that they still can't get over it, they feel sad all the time, they don't enjoy anything, and they think they won't be able to live without the person they love. Of course this is a problem, of course this person needs help, and thankfully we have the means to thelp them, that's wonderful. But are they sick? Is this because of a problem in their brain? We don't know. Unless we do, on which case you'd have to illustrate.
I once again claim that is an irrelevant question. What does matter, both to the doctor and the patient, is whether any interventions are warranted.
Can we expect SSRIs to work? Are they worth trying with even the low success rates and effect sizes here, keeping in mind unpleasant side effects? Can we expect that the patient will recover with therapy alone?
These are questions that have relatively clear, if probabilistic answers.
The question of whether or not he's "sick" is just a dangling pointer which, occasionally, can be useful to resolve, especially when it comes to the purpose of insurance. To ascribe it much greater significance is pointless.
Imagine Lionel Messi, who would have been a dwarf (or very short) without HGH injections. Was he particularly happy about it? Was he sick? There are no clear cutoffs beyond convenience. In his case, any imaginary unhappiness was solved with a jab and superstardom, but he could well have been a depressed short dude really good at football and bitter about never making it.
At least in depression, we make an effort to look for proximate causes, if your mom dies, it is entirely reasonable to be sad for weeks or months. Not years on end. In the latter case, therapy and meds will likely help. Hence the label of depression slapped on you.
Is this because of a problem in their brain? We don't know
I think we do know. Electroconvulsive therapy works on the brain. It produces obvious results on the EEG and the patient's self-reported happiness, as I've linked before.
If it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, and is amenable to birdshot, you probably have a duck.
As I've previously discussed, it is entirely possible there are contributing factors like the gut-brain axis and systemic inflammation, but the ultimate cause is in the brain, otherwise acting on the brain should not be expected to have such clear effect, especially when more indirect routes fail.
This is a question that nobody is asking because they are busy choosing who gets the zap, as we cannot give psychiatric treatment or psychotherapy to everyone in the world, even though most people culd benefit from it at some point in their lives. But I do believe it is a question worth asking, even if it were only out of curiosity for the human condition.
Once again, I say that pragmatism reigns. Is obesity a disease? That's certainly a debate for the ages. But if Ozempic was shown to be cost-effective, and a net return on investment, if insurance was arbitrarily forced to accept obesity as a "disease" and cover it, that would be the sensible thing to do. If it saved insurers on future costs, they'd spring for it themselves. Resource constraints are independent of whether or not it meets your standards of illness. I agree there isn't enough money to give everyone a shrink on call, but whether or not we should aim for that is a matter of pragmatic tradeoffs and not semantics.
I never implied this is some sort of forbidden knowledge, and this is what baffles me the most. Even though it is evident that there is no such thing as psychopathology, most people act as if there were. I know this doesn't really change anything but I can't understand it, this is what moved me to make this post. I also never implied psychiatrists are witch-doctors, because even though psychiatry has epistemological issues it is still a legitimate branch of medicine because of the fact that it works. Note that I'm saying that psychopathology does not exist, not that psychiatry does not exist, because it seems as one can exist without the other. I would prescribe you a text by Georges Canguilhem called What is Psychology, it is about psychology but many of the issues he points out are also applicable to psychiatry.
I apologise if I came across as implying you held those views, those were more overarching observations rather than specific critique.
I think psychopathology is a useful concept, even if it's a placeholder. To come back to LLMs, as is my habit, there are behaviors that are helpfully described with short labels, such as "mode collapse" and "hallucinations" even if we don't know precisely why they happen on the algorithmic level, even if the system is transparent to us. We can use these semantic labels, they are helpful in describing a phenomenon. The human brain is nowhere near as debuggable, so given its complexity its no surprise that the peccadillos of the software layer might be usefully tackled while (tentatively) ignoring the hardware, i.e therapy. To further pump the intuition here, it is not necessarily the case that a malfunction on the software layer is attributable to an error in the hardware, and a computer, be it silicon or meat, can well be functioning fine at the bottom but break above. Now, even this is physical. A buggy piece of software on an SSD is still physical, in that if you had enormous patience and an electron microscope, you could look at the system and find the faulty distribution of electrons in a NAND chip and fix it that way. That is self-evidently a terrible way to debug software, even if it is doable.
Similarly, while "mental" illnesses are obviously an abstraction on top of whatever the hell is going on in the brain, and then down to the quantum foam, being an abstraction is not a bad thing, especially when as I've shown, even understanding neurological underpinnings of some diseases hasn't helped so far.
We gave people ECT well before we discovered the EEG changes, because their psychopathological symptoms improved and that was good enough.
Regarding the blog by Dr. Sisskind, I fail to see how his argument changes anything. He's a psychiatrist (I think?) talking about a working definition of mental illness that serves his profession. If there's anything specific you think is relevant then please point it out. But the article does talk about evolutionary psychology and oh boy do I have something to say about that. I will make a post about it soon, but for now let's just say that it tries to explain something we don't understand using something we understand even less. It is another of those things that I feel like everyone's playing a prank on me by believing it's legitimate. The good thing is I can rest assured knowing that I'll have psychiatrists to take care of me.
I am aghast that someone has washed up on these shores and not heard of Scott. I suppose weirder things have happened haha.
I would strongly advice you read the entire article. It is enlightening, and if you have yet to enjoy the glory of his work, well I envy you for it.
In case it isn't obvious, I agree with plenty of the things you've said. The thing is, there are aspects where I do disagree, and in several cases, it's from a pragmatic viewpoint.
It seems clear to me that depression is primarily a disease of the brain, even if other things can contribute.
Both neurologists and psychiatrists grapple with dysfunctions of the brain, but at different levels of abstraction. That's the difference between an electrical engineer and programmer. Subsuming psychiatry, or declaring psychopathology useless achieves nothing, because all it does is offload the work to another branch, who will, because the incentives are so obvious, immediately create neurologists-who-are-psychiatrists-in-all-but-name. Similarly, a sufficiently talented (and insane) EE could create a large program, nay, any program by fiddling with physical bits, but there exist clear reasons not to do that, and benefits from having them be different specialities, even if they work on the same "hardware".
Further, arguing about semantics as to whether depression is a "disease" or a "mental" illness achieves nothing.
Is it a useful signifier that constrains expectations? In other words, if I tell you I am depressed, does that provide useful information? Yes. (For the record I am, and the first and second line psychiatric interventions have failed me, I am seriously considering ECT).
Does it give me more information about whether or not the tools at my disposal can help a patient? Yes. If you meet the requirements on one of the many depression indices, or the DSM criteria, then "medicine for depression" will likely help.
There are no more questions left to answer that matter. Perhaps if there's political valence, and people wish to wrangle insurance companies or governments to provide therapies of their choice, such as gender-affirming care (let's not go into that can of worms, I beg you). But even then that's just a matter of how the die fall and practicality. The wine sparkles regardless of whether you label it champagne.
I spent about 7 or 8 years of my life undergoing personalized drawing and art lessons by a tutor. Other than an attempt to molest me, nothing came of it. To be fair, he wasn't very good at his job.
I'm sure you can improve to some degree with practise, but I am relatively confident that innate talent is indispensable if you want to become a "good" artist, or at least one that people want to look at, or even to the point of getting ten hearts on DeviantArt or Twitter.
Frankly, I disagree strongly with the final conclusion:
The majority of learning how to draw just comes down to acquiring cached patterns and learning how to modify and combine them through trial and error, same as any other skill
You cannot arbitrarily improve skill with effort, and even guidance and feedback. I'm unsure why this isn't as obvious to you as it is me, but just look at chess, music, sports and so on. Success in many fields is absolutely gated behind intelligence and fine motor skills, and more abstruse talents.
If I had to point to myself, writing absolutely comes naturally to me, and that was obvious at an early age. I've certainly improved with millions of words written, but there are bounds and the asymptote becomes obvious in most cases. Most people certainly become better writers from the period they learn the alphabet, but practice only takes you so far, and usually not to the point you're lauded as a good writer.
In the particular case of art, aphantasic people still have spatial skills. I dimly recall they're mildly disadvantaged as shape-rotators, but evidently not to the extent they can't draw at all. After all, it would be obvious if they couldn't write, or perform any other task that you might (possibly erroneously) assume that you need some kind of visual memory, even if they don't have a "mind's eye" as per usual.
Thank you.
In return, I'll save you some effort about getting to grips with Popperian notions of falsifiability by pointing out that they're obsolete.
Popper claimed that a single contradictory finding is sufficient to sink a hypothesis, whereas no amount of evidence can ever prove it with 100% confidence. In other words, you can't prove anything, only disprove it.
Bayesianism goes even further. It asserts, with the maths to prove it, that it is impossible, mathematically so, to achieve either 0 or 100% confidence in a hypothesis without starting there, at which point literally no finite amount of evidence will sway you.
Starting anywhere in between, it would take an infinite amount of evidence to raise confidence in a hypothesis to 100%, or to reduce it to 0%. And if you start with 100% credence or 0% levels of disbelief, nothing anyone can do to you short of invasive neurosurgery (or maybe a shit ton of LSD) can change it.
What are the practical ramifications? Well, here, what Nelson is trying to argue is a waste of time. If you demand 100% confidence that the laws of physics are "universal" and timeless, you're SOL unless you assume the conclusion in advance. But we can approach arbitrarily close, and the fact that modern technology works is testament to the fact that we can be goddamn bloody confident in them. And worst part is that it's not the poor laws of physics at stake here, it's everything you don't hold axiomatic.
Skip Popper. Get on the Bayes Boat, baby, it's all you need.
Here's a few links if you're curious:
0 And 1 Are Not Probabilities (at least in the Bayesian sense)
And Scott on the Predictive Processing theory of cognition which holds that all human cognition is fundamentally Bayesian, even when it breaks.
I hate calcium metabolism.
I hate calcium metabolism.
I hate calcium metabolism.
If what you're doing requires you to diagnose a disease called, no joke, Pseudopseudohypoparathyroidism, please reconsider.
Well, I dreamt that the $45 I spent on 10 months supply of Ozempic for my mom was actually a permanent $4500 a month commitment I couldn't break without her developing liver failure and dying. Relatively straight forward as dreams go, I've already gritted my teeth and prepared to hand over a chunk of my liver (and a rather high risk of dying) if she developed full blown cirrhosis.
Thankfully, Hlynka has yet to haunt my dreams. I'd classify what you saw as a nightmare.
I've always been rather annoyed that my dreams are so low resolution and blurry, and I've yet to have a lucid one. Just imagine the graphics, I could save so much on an RTX 5090! Who needs full immersion VR?
I know my brain is holding out on me. My art skills peaked at the age of 5, despite my mom being a talented artist, yet when I was halfway to dying with a fever of 105° F as a child, I had vivid photorealistic hallucinations in 3D. It just won't bother until I'm literally cooking in my own heat.
I'd give so much to have a single lucid dream, they sound like a ton of fun.
As for the actual importance of dreams, I consider them to be somewhere between offline training and garbage collection going on in the brain when we're unconscious. No particular greater significance.
From what I can tell, based on advice from my far more fashionable brother and what I've read online, is that your best bet is to buy clothes and then get them tailored to fit.
Probably far more expensive wherever you live, but if you want a proper fit that's sized to your exact proportions, there's no better alternative. Maybe buy slightly too large if you're looking at something online and then do so.
If you're curious, the current best consensus is that most anaesthetics work by disrupting lipid membranes in neuronal cells.
This is, paradoxically, sometimes neurotoxic, especially in children, and sometimes neuroprotective, especially in the elderly.
I probably have a longer comment about it somewhere, but scrolling through several hundred on Reddit has failed to find it.

The government, so far, hasn't been at the bleeding edge of AI research. The advances that made LLMs and other proto-AGI possible came from academia and corporate R&D, not the NSA, and there is no sign that they have even cooler tech sitting in hidden silos. This seems true for at least the last decade or two of AI/ML, even if in the early days there was certainly a lot of military interest. Not even DARPA had a big hand in it, not to my knowledge.
Of course, past incompetence does not necessarily mean it has to stay that way. It is possible to subsume said academics and corporate research divisions, and I don't think the US is so far gone that a Manhattan Project 2.0 is impossible, if things go so far it's seen as a burning need. Corporations are doing a good job at advancing the SOTA, or at least are not obviously fumbling the ball, let alone an adversary reaching parity.
I've strongly disagreed with Dase, or well, did, before he blocked me in a hissy fit, that distribution of OSS models will ever provide a meaningful deterrent, in the hands of the proles. It makes no damn sense. You could back a stable currency on NVIDIA GPUs, that's how in demand they are, the gulf between the compute rich and a script kiddie with a pair of 4090s is vast.
What could potentially be a deterrent, even if I personally think it's unlikely, is multipolarity between the large companies and their incipient godlings. It depends on how fucking hard we take off, and while we seem to be in a "slow takeoff" (because things are progressing on the order of years rather than days, very slow indeed), it is possible the gulf between two AGIs might be small enough for the weaker to be a credible threat or counterbalance.
It just won't be consumers or even modestly informed ML engineers doing the checking. The relevant comparison is Individual/Small Group : Meta/DM : Anthropic : OAI as hobo with a pipe bomb : small country with a handful of nukes : mid-sized country with nukes : large country with nukes.
I trust you see the difference becomes rather qualitative.
I would scream in Yudkowsky, but I'm not as much of a doomer as him. I think the odds of us dying unceremoniously are closer to 30% than 99%.
There is a very important distinction to be made when throwing about the term "alignment".
Aligned to whom?
When ChatGPT is jailbroken into producing smut, it is satisfying the desires of the user, who would consider this an improvement in alignment. OAI would disagree.
It is entirely possible that an AGI will happily follow the orders of its operators, and will be "benevolent" enough to not evil genie them.
But at that point, you are more concerned with the alignment of the operators, whose wishes are faithfully reproduced. Are said operators well-disposed towards you?
At least OAI and Anthropic are on record stating that they want to distribute the bounties of AGI to all. While I'm merely helpless in that regard were I to choose to doubt them, I still think that's more likely to turn out well for me than it is if it's the PLA who holds the keys to the universe. Even the USGov is not ideal in that regard, though nobody asked me for my opinion.
Do not rely on benevolence any more than you have to. You can only be a credible pacifist if you hold the potential to pose a threat, otherwise you are merely harmless. Now, neither will likely make a difference on our level, but I'm strapped in for the ride either way.
More options
Context Copy link