@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

I appreciate the answers, though you've substituted utter confusion with only mild confusion in this case haha.

Seems about right to me. That roughly sums up the philosophy/meta-ethics I adhere to and endorse.

If I had to elaborate, I would say that I see no reason to let moral nihilism/relativism prevent me (or anyone else) from being a moral chauvinist, in other words preferring their own ethical code and seeking to promulgate it above others.

There is no right or wrong option. To restate my point, that is a fundamentally confused question unless you begin with an axiomatic moral framing.

You cannot acquire morality from first principles. You can execute it on it when you have somehow acquired them, including, yes, basic and complicated mathematics.

While that's almost certainly a joke I sincerely hope that nobody thinks that building a PC usually involves the use of a soldering iron.

It's not as simple as Lego as some would claim, and will claim a blood sacrifice on occasion, but I've built my fair share.

But then again I'm poor and my current PC has only finally Ship of Theseused itself free of components from the original build I was gifted in 2011. That PSU caused me a great deal of sorrow I'll tell you, at this point I would go pre-built if only for the sake of my sanity, especially now that GPU prices have stabilized (if at at stupid levels).

And there’s something that I can’t remember at the moment but it was a Jewish dish being cast as Italian?

I am told that New Jersey makes this distinction hard to make at times, but what do I know?

See, this is why I sort of don't believe you when you say that we should just shut up and multiply. It doesn't seem like that's really what you think. If it's, "Shut up and multiply, but oh by the way, you definitely can't multiply," then it really means, "Shut up."

What on earth gives you that takeaway? It was never on the menu.

You can perform utilitarian calculus, GiveWell certainly adds, subtracts multiplies and divides to figure out what is the most cost effective, hence most moral in their lights, means of saving or extending human life.

In practise, everyone is a consequentialist. Even the denying Deontologists, who frontload it. Otherwise they have no choice but to halt and catch fire whenever two Kantian imperatives conflict, and for all the ill I can speak of them, they're not that dysfunctional.

That'll then appropriately and accurately get me to a correct problem of evil?

Buddy. I clearly stated that morality is fundamentally arbitrary/subjective/observer dependent and as far as I can tell, there is no good reason to think that's not the case barring wishful thinking.

There is no "correct problem of evil". That is a malformed question built on faulty assumptions.

If you're a consequentialist, especially one of the more well defined strains of utilitarian, you can very much shut up and multiply from base principles, like "saving human lives is good" and further adjustments like discounting by quality of life. Hence QALYs and DALYs. For the record, I am neither a utilitarian in the Benthamian sense or an EA.

If you're not a consequentialist, well, you actually are, deep down, just to be a functioning human, but there is no right or wrong here that is independent of a predefined frame of reference. In other words, an observer.

If, somehow you're actually an LLM, then you've achieved a working understanding of gestalt human morality simply by being fed an enormous amount of text and then doing multiplication (of matrices). It is obviously doable. A randomly instantiated neural net will predictably achieve it.

I just ate at a nice restaurant here with a tribal seafood theme.

This alone is eyebrow raising. The north eastern tribes in India live as far from the sea as it gets, given their iodine deficiency rates, and the other miscellaneous tribes don't sea-fare either. And they had wall art of random Native American tribals and even one panel showing a giraffe. Very mixed messaging.

Even more concerning was that they had Mongolian fish as a menu option.

What.

What.

???

"Ah yes, I will order a preparation of fish nominally based on the techniques of a pastoralist landlocked nation" - - - - > Clueless

Anyway, the food was great, though my absolute distaste for all seafood has made even squid hard to stomach. They've got biryani cooked in bamboo, served so hot you'd swear someone had fired a disposable rocket launcher like the RPG-26 and left it to cool.

What's the most questionable dish you guys have seen on a menu?

I agree peer review is a flawed idea applied terribly.

The incentive structure simply makes no sense. Busy academics are expected to do a great deal of work and cognitive effort in return for little to no recognition or recompense. It's a testament to natural honesty that it sometimes works even in a subpar manner.

Unless you actively incentivize things like performing replications, it's all for naught. We wouldn't have a replication crisis in the softer sciences if that wasn't the case. At least it's more obvious in the harder ones when something plainly does not work.

It needs to be torn down and rebuilt, but easier said than done for such a loadbearing structure in Science™.

I'm calling you this kind of facetious. It's doubly laughable when you've been so humorless with me before, so I don't care to indulge your witticisms.

As far as I'm concerned morality is arbitrary and inherently subjective, there's as much reason to think otherwise as there is to suspect another missing integer between 2 and 3, despite many people fervently wishing otherwise. I've discussed my thoughts at length on it before, and you're welcome to trawl through things if you want to dig it up.

And indeed, arbitrary means arbitrary. We thankfully don't have many people around who think Ponzi schemes are good (instead of thinking they're good because they're duped and don't understand them, a whole different kettle of fish). That is a fact about evolution, and the pressures exerted on it by game theoretical concerns, and us being extremely conserved and morally similar to each other compared to the entire set of possible minds and their morality. Even monkeys and dogs care about "fairness" and dislike perceived injustice and hostility to the ingroup. Hence it's no surprise that human morality is so similar and violent disagreements tend to happen at the edge cases where the concordance breaks down.

Your morality is what your morality is. Attempting to ground it will get you nowhere.

Thankfully, consequentialism, especially utilitarianism, can be computed explicitly. Look at GiveWell or the EA movement for a good effort with the latter.

So, by all means, let's figure out how to shut up and multiply our way from, "Ponzi schemes are good, actually," to a problem of evil. But it needs to be something that I can code, since that is the premise we're starting with.

Ah! I can make it really simple for you, without even getting into first principles:

  1. Find a paper on building the Transformer architecture/RWKV/Mamba or whatever is in vogue these days. I presume NeurIPS will suffice.

  2. Feed it a massive corpus of text. The scrapable internet is a good start.

  3. Stir the pot. (This is where the matrix multiplications come in, for those curious)

  4. Behold, an LLM with an intuitive understanding of morality.

(You may insert step 3.5 of RLHF if you're so inclined, it's not strictly necessary)

Tada, taking mere matrix multiplication and your ability to code, you have created an intelligence with knowledge of morality, and can modify it further with RLHF if you're feeling safety-ist or want to twist it to arbitrary ends. All done with a computer! In code!

Easy enough for you I presume? I can show you about twenty proofs of concept.

I would not object.

In reality, I would be constrained by legal concerns and my desire to maintain my job and good standing with the medical licensing boards of two different nations. But in that case, I would object only because I'm forced to, not because I want to.

I've seen plenty of babies born for whom the kindest option would be a pillow over the face, if an overdose of morphine wouldn't suffice. Thankfully most of them just die on their own when the "acceptable" option of extending minimal supportive care or simply withdrawing it is possible, which is thankfully accepted in the UK.

That is still more religion than I'm comfortable with, but I agree with your sentiments.

The putative Abrahamic God is god-awful at his job. Leaving aside it doesn't exist, we're better served by Man creating our own Gods in Our image.

One reason I'm so antitheistic is because it's a soporific musk that dulls people to very real pain and suffering and makes them attribute it all to a higher, inscrutable purpose.

What. The. Fuck.

Solve your damn problems. Only if all else fails is choosing to accept them the valid option.

As I've said before, Marx was correct in calling religion the opiate of the masses. I can't knock it on those grounds because I certainly prescribe my own share of opioids, but as always, our intent is to cure, and keeping someone in a morphine haze indefinitely is acceptable only when all efforts fail.

And we're working on that. An actual cure for cancer, aging and other diseases that have plagued us for all of history is in sight, I'd expect it to happen in my lifetime even in the counterfactual world where we weren't making our own superhuman deities that could (if they don't kill us) solve most of our problems. Efforts to make peace with that which should be put down with all the force we can muster is a crime against humanity itself. All the worse that this peace is built off the assumption that the torture and suffering we undergo is because of hidden benevolent meddling.

I'm doing my part. Are you?

I am sorely tempted to make a "Stop Discovering New Cytokines" meme off the usual template . Interleukins were at their best when they were fodder for speculative Michael Crichton novels.

Accursed immunologists, almost as bad as the geneticists when it comes to bloating up medical textbooks.

My grandpappy never heard of DNA till he was done with med school, and it didn't do him no harm.

shakes fist

Top-level LLM poasting. You have my seal of approval.

You're always going to have a large swath of people below the true Platonic ideal of a 100 IQ individual, save large scale genetic engineering.

IQ scored are renormalized regularly, so in a society that did do that, the median IQ would be 100 again (though they would be far higher on previous scales, this is a minor nitpick, I'm in the mood for those)

Which then raises the question of what material conditions make people accepting of AI output in the first place, and how those conditions might be different.

One obvious answer would be that the LLMs have become good enough that accepting their output, in a research setting, actually does achieve the objective of creating and promulgating useful knowledge.

I don't think we're there quite yet, but it's a sign we're close if so many are leaking through the cracks in the hallowed peer review process. You almost certainly couldn't achieve that with GPT-2, it would be too incoherent, unless you went with absolute bottom-barrel pay to publish journals, whereas they're cropping up in modestly respectable ones and even the odd prestigious journal.

People, including scientists, have always been lazy to some degree. That usually manifested as having grad students or even undergrads doing the grunt work. Now we've got new avenues.

Besides, as far as I'm concerned, we're only a few years away from LLMs doing "legitimate" research, and then becoming outright superhuman. This is just a transitional stage to get there, we have to deal with ersatz good enough to fool checked out reviewers section for only a bit longer. And soon enough we'll have the journals using AI themselves to notice and filter out the crap.

What humans are doing is Bayesian reasoning, at least if you subscribe to the Predictive Processing model of cognition, as I (and Scott, amongst others), tentatively endorse.

People, in general, are perfectly capable of modifying their beliefs in a Bayesian manner without remotely holding the idealized version of Bayes' rule in their skulls, at least above the level of groups of neurons for whom it comes naturally.

In physics, it is implicit. You will find all kinds of mention of how unlikely it is for certain varieties of observations to be seen were it not for X model that pre-emptively expect it to be the case (or at least doesn't conflict with it in hindsight).

You do not need them to write it out, any more than they need to invoke the tenets of ZFC when they add two numbers together. But then again:

When I pick up the text for the lab component of a college course in physics or chemistry, look to see if there are any priors, conditional probabilities, or posteriors, written down in it

What is a p-value? It's not a urine dipstick test I can tell you. Still can't read most papers without tripping over one. Don't ask me if they're using it in frequentist or Bayesian terms, but there's a conditional probability for you.

(Now, I can assure you that while Bayesian reasoning is not foreign to medical doctors, at least the ones who do actual research, the majority of doctors on the ground would recoil from that simple equation, or simply be confused at first sight. Doesn't mean they aren't using it, either explicitly or implicitly. The same goes for physics.)

Oh yes, quaternions are an example of a necessary evil, or so programmers trying to work in 3D tell me. Whatever it takes to avoid gimbal locking must be necessarily good. I'm sure the NSA might call elliptic curves evil, depending on whether or not they had a chance to put a backdoor or two in cryptographic standards.

Don't be facetious. Or remember your demands to "speak plainly". You need unprincipled* definitions of what counts as "evil" (or good) before you can start. Once you have a working definition, based off whatever moral intuitions you spawned with, then yes, you can do moral calculus and figure out an optimum, but your ability to do so as a computationally bounded entity will always be limited. Doesn't mean you can't try. Though you don't need quaternions or elliptic curves; addition, subtraction or multiplication should suffice. Certainly mere multiplication of massive numbers of matrices seems sufficient to create intelligence by itself, which is a necessity for discerning good from bad.

*Feel free to dispute this when you can argue Socrates into the ground.

You know, Yudkowsky still writes new things, as deeply unfashionable as it is around these parts to praise him.

So I present 'Empiricism!' as Anti-Epistemology. It's certainly relevant, especially to philosophy of science and your own post.

But if I had to speak for myself, the Scientific Method is just a bounded, modestly idiot-proofed form of Bayesian reasoning, generated after centuries of adjusting for human stupidity and adversarial incentives. When you look at it that way, there's no reason to have to argue ad nauseam about what counts as significant and well-established. You have priors and posteriors, and rules to work with. Shut up and multiply.

Hmm.. I have experience with Xiaomi and One Plus, a bit of Samsung.

None of them are remotely close to stock, but as I've already said, that has sadly become a good thing. Xiaomi has recently rebranded their UI to HyperOS, and I've yet to upgrade (I couldn't care less), but in general, all of them have significantly more flexibility and information density when compared to the closest mainstream "stock" Android in the Pixels.

Better notifications, better multitasking. These are massive. All of them have it. Bloatware and junk is no longer a big deal, and I haven't had to root my phone to remove things as I once felt obliged to back in the day. Add a DNS level adblock and practically any device is now usable as far as I'm concerned. (easily done in the settings on any device, I use AdGuard myself).

The Pixels have their own benefits, in the form of camera and AI features, but it took me all about 5 minutes to become utterly bored when messing with my girlfriend's Pixel 7A.

So Xiaomi, OnePlus, Samsung. All better than stock. Tentatively the Nothing phones, from what I've seen about them.

I haven't kept up with the custom ROM world for a while, so I can't tell you what's in vogue, but there are still misguided oldies and script kiddies who try and flash stock or Pixel ROMs on everything, not that I would recommend it. Just buy a flagship or last year's flagships over a midranger and you're set.

Use it long enough and you'll develop a tolerance, but that's what cycling and drug holidays are for.

But beyond that, there's no significant harm in daily use at therapeutic doses.

I have ADHD, though I need the meds primarily so I can even force myself to open a textbook. It does help with normal day to day stuff, but the experience on Ritalin is unpleasant enough that I don't bother most of the time.

I'm not embarrassed in the least by it. Studying, on top of work, is something I can't dispense with at this stage of my career, so it is what it is. I did have problems focusing on studies as a kid, but personal tutors keeping me under their gaze handled the worst of it, unfortunately it turns out that in their absence I won't study unless my life depends on it, and such last minute grinding doesn't get you anywhere when the books could kill a toddler if dropped on them.

Evidently the meds work for you. Try a lower dose and see if that keeps you functional without a "high". But if it makes life more bearable and you suffer without them, longterm use is warranted as far as I'm concerned.

I remember when stock Android was craved by enthusiasts. Now, I rely on OEMs to shield me from the worst of Google's cupidity.

I can't recall the last time I was excited by an Android update. Maybe around 6.0?

Yay, they rounded/unrounded some rectangles and added one more privacy control.

I'm no expert on STD rates in American care homes. I do know they have a similar reputation in the UK, and in India, ain't nobody getting poon at any age.

I agree it's low quality evidence, but it was a lead up for a low effort joke heh.

Here's what I found after a quick look

https://www.forbes.com/sites/claryestes/2020/02/26/historic-high-rates-of-stis-among-older-americans/?sh=4a2b7c884c39

https://nursinghomesabuse.org/nursing-home-injuries/infections/stds/

I haven't chased all the inner links down myself. The former claims increased rates in Americans over the 55, the other claims to be corroborated by the CDC.

At any rate, I stand by what I said, if you're gyrating on poles at that age, you likely already have a UTI and don't want it getting aggravated.

It depends on the breed of maggot in question. You don't want the ones from botflies, far too much umami. Common houseflies are best, especially with a sprinkle of paprika

They're having rice with lentils, miscellaneous vegetables and fish. I only like my rice fried or as biryani. I'm allergic to leafy greens, and I'm too old for my mother to forcefeed me fish.

I would not eat that if I was starving (I have, for reasons I'm not inclined to get into at 1 am, actually starved, as in I legitimately could not get food for days). But it's a bog standard meal. Why do you think I bother to work, if it's not for money to order in pizza, biryani, waffles and the like? When it comes to dietary advice, do as I don't.

In the UK, the pay is thankfully not shit. Well, by your standards (and mine) the pay for most doctors is trash, but GPs reach those hallowed plateaus faster than other fuckers slogging through 7 years of training.

I think the Indian system is quite similar to the US. I know of scenarios where there are legal requirements, such as it taking a psychiatrist to prescribe stimulants, but it's a combination of getting no bitches patients and the medicolegal concerns you mentioned that prevents anyone from doing just about anything.

I have heard some stories about the antics of my colleagues in more rural areas. I can't relay them on a public forum without contacting my lawyer first, even if I'm not involved. It gets that bad.