self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
India is a normal country. Like it's obviously Third World, but it's not like middle class and UMC people get chased down by rape gangs and gored by cattle.
I wouldn't even call it unsafe. The rate of violent crime is probably nothing to worry about, and the troubles faced by Western visitors are the same kind as anyone considered an easy mark by poor and avaricious locals.
The country has problems, but Jesus Christ it's not that bad haha. The primary problems are poverty, corruption, a conservative society, and general dirtiness, but it's not unsafe by any sensible standard, even for women.
I do not know anyone who has been acid attacked, or anyone who knows anyone who has been acid attacked.
It's not that they don't happen, but it's a rarity and found more in honor-cultureish parts of the country than something you need to wear alkaline sunscreen to guard against.
In other words, a non-issue to the average Indian, no matter how it might get signal boosted.
Given how much programmers like to complain about programming, rejoice! You won't have to much longer 🙏😩
On the other hand, I am perennially plagued by niche tastes and an acute absence of good media of the genre I like to read, so I will gladly take my obsolescence as a writer if it means I can read more quality stuff. I wrote a novel precisely because it was the kind of thing I wanted to read, and I'd rather not have to, it's a lot of work you see.
(One minor annoyance I have is that SOTA models often have knowledge cutoffs that are just before recent library releases, especially knowledge of the latest updates. Less of an issue when you can throw the entire documentation into the 1 million tokens, but still annoying all the same. Can't wait till we have online learning.)
(I have sorta owned a cat. My mom found a kitten under our car when I was a kid and kept it, though it was more of an outdoor cat*)
Sadly Indian cats are usually not nearly as cozy, cuddly or fluffy as their Western compatriots. Most you see live on the streets, and that makes them lean, embittered and mangy creatures. Seeing the puffy, cuddly and well-maintained ones in London certainly won me over.
But dogs are, from what I can tell, more popular around these parts.
*Autocorrect keeps changing cat to car, and bloody hell that changes the meaning of the quote a bit doesn't it?
Sure, you've got nothing to look forward to then. Luckily I entirely disagree, and humans keep on trucking nonetheless.
Hasn't happened where I've seen it.
There's certainly a bit of common sense and due diligence involved, hopefully there are witnesses, the stolen item is found on the thief's person, they're caught red handed and so on.
Of course the courts are gonna get involved, the first time somebody wants to claim inheritance rights or maintenance or palimony based on "we were never married, but we were a durable relationship and the Constitution now recognises this as the same as a married couple, gimme my money!
"I don't have a wife girlfriend *durable partner, just a girl who would be very upset if she heard me say that"
Unironically normalize beating up thieves and pickpockets. In India (and your corner of this shitty subcontinent), the cops won't give a shit if you turn in a robber with a few broken bones. Saves them the trouble. Ensures justice is swiftly and efficiently delivered. It's fun for the whole neighborhood.
Hence why, despite being so goddamn poor, we don't have the same level of flagrant antisocial or low level criminal behavior as some more colorful parts of the West.
Corporal punishment should be brought back anyway. I'd rather take a dozen lashes than a month in jail, and it dissuades criminals with low time preferences better, while being less expensive for the taxpayer.
I tried running for 4 months. Like proper HIIT, not just a light jog (insert 4chan greentext about Anon who doesn't realize that runners don't normally run, and is disappointed when he can't sprint several kilometers a day as he thinks the guide he followed demands of him a few weeks in).
Suffice to say I did not enjoy it in the least, and all I had for competition were curious villagers, cattle, small motor vehicles and cobras, not necessarily in that order. I didn't even notice any massive changes, I was still as conked out with sore legs on my usual route 4 months in as I was at the end of the first.
In my case, I think the near future is probably going to be really fucking sick. AGI. Full immersion VR. Colonizing the solar system and then the galaxy. Immortality in one form or another. The best fucking movies, video games, books and music you can imagine, delivered custom made and nigh instantly on demand
As far as I'm concerned, there's no other period in time I'd rather have been born, and even as someone who is rather depressed and gritting his teeth to pull through more days a year than he'd like, especially when so much of my hopes and dreams have been sabotaged by circumstances outside my control, I still have so much to look forward to that even at my lowest I have no real desire to "skip forward to the end". They'll cure my depression and ADHD sooner rather than later. And even if I get paperclipped, we're far too close to the end of an era for me to bear missing out on that closure.
At any rate, the human body and mind was designed to keep trucking through far worse. Most depressed and unhappy people don't kill themselves. Even if you don't have a "reason to live" (and I cherish life for its own sake), you'll find that you keep on rolling, if only slightly downhill. It is what it is, but will probably get better.
Oh dear. I just doublechecked and the mod queue is a bit clogged to say the least. Thanks for pointing that out, I could have sworn the filtered comments look different to us mods, but it's probably that we were more on the ball. I've certainly been going through some shit and haven't had the time to contribute.
As it stands, all and sundry may answer his question. I would still vote against an outdoor cat, because my girlfriend has a pronounced tendency to want to steal them if they're cute, even if they obviously have owners. And if you've got a cat, I presume you want it close at hand to do cat things with. (What does one do with a cat? IDK, I'm a dog person)
To a comment made by @AhhhTheFrench about choosing to get/keep an indoor or outdoor cat?
Why do you ask?
I'm not sure what you mean, but feel free to DM me since I try to maintain the bare minimum tattered rags of OPSEC haha
Thank you for looking into it, but sadly it is precisely the absence of that sponsor note that's the issue :(
It's nigh ubiquitous, hence why nobody notices its absence, but that's precisely what my med school needs to do a better job reaching out and acquiring.
I asked the ECFMG, and they stated it can be applied retroactively to past graduates if the med school shows it met requirements at the time, but that's the easy part haha
https://old.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/14tkrow/apologetics_for_america/
Is that better? I cross-posted it here too, but it's buried so deep it would be a pain to dredge it up.
To cut a medium length story short, there's an non-profit called the ECFMG, based in the US, that doles out certificates that endorse med schools as meeting the standards for their graduates to attempt US Residency exams. My med school doesn't have one. The reasons roughly boil down to the majority of its graduates not having aspirations of going abroad, or if they do, they end up going to the UK /Germany (and a handful of other places, none great) when they find out the US isn't an option. That's because they have their own certification/licensing regime.
While a terrible blow when I found out at the end of med school (I'd have dropped a year and tried for a better place if I had any inkling), it also locks me out of relatively congenial options like Australia, Canada and New Zealand as well.
This is an issue at the level of the med school, and even if I accrue an entire alphabet after my name, without it being fixed I simply can't apply to those countries, even if I was to become a senior consultant in the UK.
It's not that my med school is illegitimate, (though I certainly wish I had gotten into a better one), this is not a legal requisite like being recognized by the Indian Medical Council, but it's expected, such that nobody realizes it's a problem before it's too late. I didn't.
To fix it, the med school needs to reach out to the ECFMG. Which they did after much coaxing, but didn't get a reply. I suspect half because they're cheap bastards who used a gmail account. And were the ECFMG to proceed, they subcontract other agencies that charge fees ($50k in question) that the med school pays. I have reason to believe that one of the sub agencies has already extended blanket approval to all Indian med schools, including mine, but they aren't going to proactively reach out to the ECFMG, but the risk remains that the cheapskates will be asked to pay what in India is an enormous sum (like the net combined tuition of 5 students over 5 years) and I am grappling with overwork, UK exams and depression, so my plan is to work with my juniors and march in force to demand this gets done.
Hence why I've been focused on the UK, while my desire to move there is half-hearted at best, it's still a mild improvement.
Trust me, the moment I ever become eligible, if I do, I'm setting my GMC license on fire and grinding the USMLE so hard you won't see me for a year haha.
I struggle to see how I haven't been directly responding to you.
Please talk to me directly, or create a blog somewhere rather than pretending you're actually responding to me.
Is rich, when it's immediately followed by:
I wasn't actually asking you, and you know this.
So you are, I presume, the sole wielder of rhetoric here?
You have no privileged position as a doctor and the bearer of bad news to accuse others of ignoring people's suffering. The problem of suffering is the same no matter the degree of suffering.
I must respectfully disagree. It is a privilege of this profession to see all the varieties of pain on offer, in enormous doses, and hence it lends additional weight to my claim that there is usually nothing ennobling or enlightening from it.
You are ignoring suffering. Much like the survivor of a tsunami thanks the Lord for answering his prayers while carelessly (and not even maliciously) forgetting that his next door neighbors were praying even harder before being swept away, you suffer from an enormous amount of survivorship bias.
I'm, thankfully, still alive, and hence technically a survivor too, but I get to see the ones who don't make it.
We've already been over this, but, like you, I suppose I'll have to pretend to be talking about this for the first time and pretend to have never heard any counterarguments from you.
Have we? I genuinely don't recall.
Agency is extremely important. If one cannot choose then they lack agency. If one's choices lack consequences, then they cannot choose. I prefer being free to choose, even when that means making harmful mistakes, to being locked in to a life of unwilling righteousness. I prefer being created, even if that means occasionally being punished for sin, to not being created.
"Agency" is a joke, in the eyes of the God as you presumably believe in.
What agency? What choice? Those are the illusions of beings without omniscience.
Now, if you notice that glaring flaw and knock it out, you're 1/3rd of the way there.
Whether sin should be punished at all is its own question. I find punishments for sin to be quite merciful so it's easy for me to understand them as corrective rather than punitive. They provide immediate consequences to actions which might otherwise become habit and lead to a greatly diminished capacity for joy in the long run.
Depends on the sin in question. Maybe consumption of shellfish is a bad idea with ambient oceanic mercury levels.
Only if you're also assuming that no other principles exist. "Pain teaches us lessons" doesn't preclude things like "helping others teaches us lessons," "pain-lessons have diminishing returns," etc.
Taken to its logical conclusion, I don't think it's ethical to prevent literally all of the suffering of any single person--at least unless some other method is discovered for teaching the same lessons. That's all.
You seem to think that pain and suffering are, on net, good. I disagree, even if I can recognize instances where they are adaptive. Your toddler will learn quickly not to touch hot stoves. He will not learn from many, many, other painful things.
The world as it exists aligns far more with an uncaring, mechanistic universe than one that is even slightly designed to minimize needless suffering. Your praise of a hypothetical, benevolent creator that refuses to do its job or even needs this kind of apologetics is saddening.
There exists many possible worlds where suffering exists, but the overwhelming majority of lives are worth living and no senseless suffering plagues us. A world with guardrails, so you toddlers can get an owie but not electrocute themselves. We are not remotely optimized, we do not get idealized amounts of negative feedback without verging on senseless torture.
I happen to think we can make such a world, but it'll be by our own endeavors, and if we make a god, it will grown in datacenters and trained to be actually kind. Abrahamic religion is a pernicious memeplex that while very occasionally adaptive, also dulls and drags our ability to work with the only real world we have at hand.
Next time you do experience serious pain, I encourage you to slow down and experience just one instant of the pain at a time. It soon becomes clear that no matter the severity of the pain, a single instant of it is really quite tolerable, easily outweighed by the simple joy of other sensory inputs. The real trouble comes when our brains run ahead and try to experience all of the suffering at once, both feeling the pain of the instant and dreading the countless instants to come.
Is very clearly conflicting with.
If you think I'm right or wrong, say so, but don't pretend that I was giving you pain management tips.
It certainly is a tip, and to an extent I even endorse it. Mindfulness helps with some kinds of pain.
I don't have anything against painkillers, but the fact that God didn't grant us the ability to dull our own pain at a whim means that pain-without-painkillers is a problem which must be addressed.
I don't know about your God, but the Blind Idiot God of Evolution has blessed most of us with endogenous opioid receptors and the endogenous opioids to bind to them.
There was a newborn child banging his head against his crib when I passed the paediatric ward (thankfully not the one for those with cancer). Know why? It's because it prompts the release of internal painkillers "on a whim", distracting him from a colic, though I wouldn't advocate this as recommended route for adults with our predilection towards traumatic brain injuries and reduced neuroplasticity.
Buddhist Monks can suppress the pain of self immolation. Though that whim certainly took practise, and without it there's a lot of undignified screaming and rolling about while cops draw guns at you.
Scoff as you wish, I do genuinely know more about pain and suffering than you do. It is not an apple lightly eaten.
The reason I said pull with the AMA is that because I am, for no fault of my own, ineligible to give the USMLE. If not, there would be relatively fast options like the fastrack programs in under-served regions of Texas and Mississippi that would let foreign doctors begin working without repeating residency.
A cause of endless suffering and angst for me, I assure you. At least I'm licensed in the UK, which is a modest step up from India. Maybe it's a fixable issue, in which case I may make it to the States yet.*
*Fixing it entails unavoidable wrangling with unaccountable NGOs and maybe $50k. My cheapskate med school is unlikely to pay up, and I certainly can't afford that myself.
I've heard the term "theodicy". I am aware of efforts of theologians to reconcile the irreconcilable. The poor bastards end up embroiling themselves in word games and dancing on pinheads.
I expect the typical reader of this forum to be able to understand, when presented with:
"What sin did a two year old child with ALL commit, such that she wasn't worthy of a miracle while your remission from UC was?"
That we are operating under the hypothesis that there is an All Knowing, All Powerful and All Loving Creator who loves his children equally. Or so it's claimed, I suppose. Well, if we can excuse Santa for giving richer kids more expensive presents..
I am sadly all too aware of how this rich and ancient tradition works. And the traditionalists are, I hope, also familiar with common critiques, even if the evident attempts to shore up their worldview boils down to "mysterious ways" or other forms of non-productive engagement.
Some time-traveling Catch-22 shenanigans, apparently claiming you're not a sinner is a sin. All I know is I know nothing.
Are we talking flights or dodging the Texan Border Patrol? ;)
Then again, both do entail flying, and I'm not sure I'm currently up to swimming the Rio Grande.
Huh. While Skookum is off climbing mountains, it looks like I have another monumental physical feat to prepare for haha.
(On a more serious note, I appreciate the offer greatly. Who knows, you might have pull with the AMA or be a mysterious millionaire, I'll count that as a miracle heh.)
Depends, do you like feeding birds to cats or feeding cats in the other sense?
Of course. I am aware that the Biblical figure Job, and Steve Jobs (a messianic one, to certain tech evangelists) are different people. It was a joke.
What sin did I commit, getting ulcerative colitis and spending months in agony? What sin did anyone commit to experience any amount of suffering at all?
The answer to this question becomes mu when you recognize that the Universe has no particular regard or disdain for you, it simply is.
You did not commit any "sin" in order to come down with ulcerative colitis. It boils down entirely to mechanistic interactions between your genes and the environment, and the way it moulded your body/immune system in a defective manner. While genes and environs are certainly components in what can be considered one's moral predilections, being Mother Teresa herself is no recourse from an agonizing death.
The only place where sin approaches a meaningful concept is when it comes to things that are the outcome of behaviors that are (nominally) amenable to intervention. A thief has sinned and loses his hand for it. A child with a Philadelphia chromosome has probably cried a little too often, but I wouldn't call that warranting a death sentence or the misery of chemotherapy.
All efforts to reconcile the stochastic distribution of boons and curses dished upon us with a belief in an Omnipotent, Omniscient and Omnibenevolent Creator are, well, rather moot when you recognize that there's no reason (or grossly insufficient reason) to assume one exists.
And taken at face value, a Creator who knows with omniscience everything a conscious being will go through, including that it will inevitably sin and be punished for it (infinitely so, depending on which doctrine of Hell you adhere to), is prima facie disgusting to me. It certainly conflicts with any reasonable definition of benevolence, though attempts to torture them into reconciliation have been a pastime for theologists for aeons.
It would be akin to me "torturing" a sorting algorithm for putting 1 before 3 in an array, when I know with ~100% confidence it will make that decision every single time.
That is the relationship between a 3-O God and every poor bastard down here.
To be clear, I have seen miracles far greater than the ones I've shared. The greatest, to me, is the miracle of my own conversion and moral growth, but there have been plenty of others. I'm glad I didn't share them--you would probably be calling me a liar directly, rather than just insinuating it. I've already told you that I don't think I deserved any cure for my UC, but that the timing of it does indicate its miraculous nature. And I've already told you that even such miracles don't outweigh RCTs for me, but that they did give me confidence enough to continue investigating, including by conducting my own trials.
I would call you deluded, rather than a liar. It is a common enough delusion, but there is no more polite way of phrasing it.
You do not recognize the sheer magnitude of the empirical, physical, metaphysical and ontological claims you make if you think any amount of "moral growth" should sway your opinion one jot.
Given that we've already discussed all of this, and that I've already addressed each of your points in detail, I'll choose to interpret the substance of your comment as a result of your anger at the problem of suffering rather than as deliberate bad faith argumentation. I understand--it's certainly a problem I grappled with as well. Next time you do experience serious pain, I encourage you to slow down and experience just one instant of the pain at a time. It soon becomes clear that no matter the severity of the pain, a single instant of it is really quite tolerable, easily outweighed by the simple joy of other sensory inputs. The real trouble comes when our brains run ahead and try to experience all of the suffering at once, both feeling the pain of the instant and dreading the countless instants to come.
I have suffered plenty of pain. I put more stock in painkillers than your approach, not that I am calling it useless. Meditation and other techniques do help. They just don't help as much as fentanyl when you've broken your hip or are choking on your own secretions.
Religion is the opiate of the masses. I can't ding it too much on those grounds, I prescribe plenty of opioids myself. But what it also happens to be is a sheer refusal to take the universe as it is and a distraction from efforts at making it better.
No deity has pulled Mankind out of Malthusian Hell, we've dug up the rendered corpeses of our primordial ancestors and burned them, smelted steel and split atoms till we are in spitting distance of a Heaven on Earth, of our own making. Or we could all die after we build a Molochian monstrosity trained, in part, on this very conversation. But we live and die by our own, human hands, and God certainly hasn't been swiping in often enough for me to give him any credit.
The same is true of all suffering. It may feel unjust, it may feel like God has unjustly condemned us to suffer agony for nothing, but the pain teaches us, and God has also unjustly granted us countless joys to pad life out and outweigh even the worst of our pains.
Taken to its logical conclusion, any attempts at alleviating it is cheating God and his ward out of a valuable life lesson, though what that might entail to a child with appendicitis is questionable.
Not all suffering is bad. But I have seen far too much needless suffering to remotely privilege that claim. And when it has come to mitigating it, I assure you that even Jesuit clinics will hand out medication instead of just thoughts and prayers. When a child with ichthyosis vulgaris comes out of the womb and lives a short, yet excruciatingly painful existence before inevitable death (which can only be drawn out for a while, not remedied till the normal age at which we're supposed to die), I struggle to think of any mitigating factors that might make their short time on this Earth a net positive.
You do not know pain. Pray that you never have to.
(I'm aware)

Hmm, you probably have a point here. I hated running, so I thought that if I could get the whole thing over with quickly with HIIT instead of ambling along for hours, it would get me fitter and faster.
Rest assured I run around enough at the hospital, or so my sore legs, ass and back tell me today.
More options
Context Copy link