@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

Eh, I can't imagine it's on par with Whisper, which, if no longer quite SOTA (by like 3 months, the field moves fast), is really goddamn good and fast. Plus Dragon doesn't seem to have an Android app. I have to shuffle between whichever sorry excuse for a PC is free on the multiple wards I cover, so it's not like I have a place to call my own. And I don't even own a laptop.

  1. I'm cheap. And $20 a month is, well, not exactly nothing by my standards.

  2. I have a pretty nice mechanical keyboard, but I sure as fuck won't be lugging it to the hospital, maybe if I end up running the psych ward and need something to batter uppity people with.

Mundane life hack:

Writing discharge summaries for patients is a pain in the ass.

I've got a few options:

  1. Hand write it on paper and send it over to the transcriptionists, who are not medically trained, and will likely mangle it beyond recognition. Like, I know my handwriting is reflecting my sanity, but it's not that bad, and yet they manage to do things that leave me in awe.

(@throwaway05 I caught my consultants guffawing over the previous discharge for a post op thyroid carcinoma case, apparently the XXXXXX level LNs were involved, which is either a typist fuckup, or they needed a crane to operate on a giraffe)

  1. Type it out myself, using gummy keyboards that swallow letters, and EMR software that makes me want to pull my hair out.

  2. Type it out, but using something less likely to make me want to self-discharge into purgatory, such as writing it on my phone and mailing it over to the transcriptionists to copy-paste (far harder for them to fuck it up). But still a PITA, fighting autocorrect and RSI to output the 25 drugs my geriatric soon to be ex-patient is on.

  3. Apparently, there's a verbal medical transcription service, where all you need to do is mutter into the mic for some low wage worker to do the dirty work (one that isn't me), but my investigations show that this is a service only offered to actual consultants, in a sub-basement with a Beware of Leopard sign covering up the computer. Limited licenses, HR approval, yada yada. And why would said senior doctors bother when they can get their juniors to bother me at 5 pm to absolutely urgently prepare a discharge by 7 pm for a patient I know for a fact won't be discharged till next afternoon, after being reviewed by said doctor.

Well fuck all of the above, it's the last thing I want to be doing at either 9 pm, when I'm bone tired, or 7 am, when I'm being woken up to handle incessant early morning bullshittery. So, as someone who believes in better living through technology, I wondered if I could use OpenAIs Whisper voice transcription service to save me a lot of writing.

Short answer? Yes.

However, there's no free and easy way to do so, and I can't be arsed to drag a laptop out and install an offline version. There are apps out there, but they're the usual trial and nagware shit.

But wait!

ChatGPT uses Whisper for voice transcription when you use the voice input option. I don't pay for GPT-4, so I don't trust it to do the whole job correctly, but simply transcribing what I'm saying to text verbatim? Hell yeah it can do that.

Cue me opening up the app, entering a prompt that amounts to STFU till I tell you otherwise, then I unload my stream of thought, terribly written surgical notes, and the other forms of torment undergone by my ward. Even the drugs, it does a really good job of handling even the weirdest generics and brand names.

I then copy and paste that, or have ChatGPT lightly format it when relevant, move it around and edit it myself till it fits the format, and then email it off.

I estimate this saves at least half an hour per discharge, what with me not having to write by hand, or undo the errors introduced by the typists.

Thank god nobody gives a shit about HIPAA here, but there you have it, my most useful use case for ChatGPT Free is just to hack into the Whisper API. For anything more important, please use either the paid version or Bing, but this saves me a great deal of real pain.

I still need to give it a once over and fix minor errors but by Allah it does a fantastic job right out of the gate.

If there's one thing that Jim and co got right most of all, it's that sex differences are very great. Completely different mindset.

I'm going to tattoo this on my forehead for the next time my girlfriend suggests we watch a Victorian period drama jfc

I look forward to these threads, and your contributions to them, even if I rarely have much to add! I don't follow Indian news, largely for my own mental health, so it pains me to have to passively consume most of the time, but consider me another one of the many people who would be sad to see you not continue, even if all we do is upvote and go hmm.

My ADHD is mild, as in I could convince others (including my parents and tutors) that I was a perfectly normal kid, and as for myself, why would I have reason to assume otherwise?

Then high school hit, and my usual habit of cramming for subjects the last couple nights before an exam ceased to cope. Turns out enormous amounts of stress and caffeine (all the pharmaceutical therapy I had access to then) only goes so far, and it only got worse when I crawled into med school.

I realized I had ADHD, badgered my parents to take me to a psychiatrist, and they refused for ages, mostly because they simply couldn't accept that their darling son could have such a disease, as well as the general stigma/ignorance around it in India. It took a complete nervous breakdown for them to finally take me over, and what did you know, I got diagnosed, got meds, and while hardly perfect, am far more capable of handling professional and academic pressures.

For a long time, I thought it was preposterous that people studied until right before exams. Like, can't you just cram dawg? Turns out that, no, most neurotypical people don't need do or die levels of stress or constant micromanagement to do so, even if some leave it off longer than they ought to.

At any rate, ADHD meds work, both on people with "actual" ADHD, depending on where you draw a line on the curve, and even those with above average executive function or conscientiousness. You can't take a happy person and give them antidepressants to make them super duper happy. I'm not inclined to gatekeep, I'd be utterly fucked without meds, so presuming I ever become an actual psychiatrist, I'm inclined to be far less anal than the ones who the blog author encountered.

And my case is mild. It's not obvious at all in normal conversation, nor did it reflect on my grades till the burden simply become too much to cope. My brother is worse struck, and my little nephew is a flagrant example, and I consider them lucky that my suffering will make my/their parents take the issue more seriously. Once again, I complain about methylphenidate/Ritalin. Shit drug, at least in terms of how it makes you feel. I look forward to trying Adderall when I can, since it's not available here. But given that Ritalin still makes me a functional doctor (academically, I can work just fine without it in an actual job), I can't complain too hard.

Hang in there for Grey Zone Warfare, you can think of it as Wildlands and Tarkov having a FPS baby, and with far less PVP than the latter.

I'm holding out for it, and I've almost completed everything worth doing in Tarkov two months in, with four to go of fucking about, so I expect GZW will take over.

Yeah, if you're not getting any benefit from a formal positive diagnosis, you're doing much the same as with a regular cold or flu, lying in bed and trying not to spread it to anyone you care about. More serious if you're ailing or old, at which point paxlovid is a good shout, but for anyone outside that, just wait it out with a cup of something hot.

In my case, I am all too familiar with COVID and I could swear blindly this was a bout, but either the lab fucked up, or it's the flu. The complete anosmia was only for half a day, whereas with COVID it lasts at least one or two for me personally.

As best as I could tell, yes, couldn't smell perfume or taste food. That increases the odds the COVID test was a false negative, for what it's worth, but I couldn't bother with the nasal rape of a new swab.

It's standard for the cancer patients, but gone are the days when most Indian hospitals provided PCR tests to their staff for free when suspected. At least I managed to get my money's worth when I worked in a (COVID) ICU during the peak of the pandemic here, and two weeks off certainly eased the very real pain. I was looking forward to the sick leave than anything else, my boss is an asshole who wouldn't approve it if it wasn't COVID, or at least he'd make a fuss about it.

Oh well, I'm alive and not at any risk, and thankfully today wasn't the worst day at work. Just a pretty bad one.

Fentanyl hasn't been a problem in India from my anecdotal experience. Opioid overdoses were pretty rare, I can't recall one from my intern days, though I make it a point to stay as far from the ER as possible now. When it happens, it's usually plain old heroin.

If I had to guess why that's the case, well, heroin was enshrined and fentanyl dealers probably couldn't break in, or found selling precursors/smuggling it into wealthier nations more lucrative.

I thought I caught COVID for the 8th time, but no, the PCR came back negative and it's likely just the bloody flu.

I was fervently hoping for a positive result (and confident in it, since I'd expect I'd know what the disease feels like by now), but it was not to be. No sick leave for me. You'd think being in contact with thirty or so immunocompromised people might make them care, but alas. Anosmia, the works, maybe I'll bother with the flu vaccine next time.

Compatibility issues aside (which are ridiculous because the format is more than a decade old), .webp is actually a good format on its own merits. Far better compression and quality than JPEG, and quite close to PNG in terms of the latter.

It's funny/sad the creator actively participates in Twitter threads trying to clear his name when it's being maligned, but it's not really his fault that software devs are too lazy to implement it. It makes for massive savings in image size for hosts, and for little loss in quality, you'd hope they'd have picked up on that by now.

Now consider the difference between Pygmy populations in Africa and Nordics. There's nothing you can feed the former, barring Human Growth Hormone, that will make them reach similar average heights.

Understandable, have a nice day!

(How many kids did it take? Was the short term rental worth it? Did you have to lose your deposit because of the stains?)

My bad. I didn't think it was that Ben Franklin quote, which I can see after I bothered to open it.

Don't mind me, just dying of my 8th bout of COVID here.

This is awful. Morality aside, you could pick any trait of yours from a hat, and it would be more open to modification than your looks.

?

You can modify your looks, with everything from trivial ease to great expense. Make up. A proper haircut and shave. Rhinoplasty. Buccal fat removal. Ozempic.

Intelligence, for example, another nigh unalloyed good, is nigh impossible to modify. Stimulants don't make you smarter, just harder working/dedicated/conscientious. Even the most well studied options like ashwagandha for memory show minor effects.

Perhaps genetic engineering should take us in the other direction instead -- so that no one is too attractive, and instead of mewing and bone-smashing we'd be cultivating virtue and writing proofs.

I'm at a loss for words. I suppose making a taller bucket helps some of the crabs.

Good looks, at least in the form of clear skin, facial symmetry and hair, is a sign of good overall health. It correlates with intelligence too. It might be be more zero-sum, but it is not entirely so, so I fail to see any reason why something as questionable as enforcing "looks restrictions" on genetic engineering is remotely a good idea.

Once everyone is on the Pareto Frontier when it comes to attractiveness, we'll find something else to compete on, though I doubt your suggestion of "cultivating virtue" and proof writing will get any take up.

I haven't run into any obviously drug seeking patients myself in India, the people getting morphine or fentanyl prescriptions climb the pain ladder at the same rate anyone else does.

I was prescribed tramadol once, for severe sudden back pain and costal tenderness (?acute pancreatitis but the the enzymes came back normal), and it was a warm glow, but I never felt the urge to get more once the course was over. It did at least help with the agony, when the strongest NSAIDs didn't. The maximum I took daily was equivalent to about 10 mg of morphine, oral.

I suspect it's a lot of people trying to cure SLS (Shit Life Syndrome), and well, if you can't fix your problems you might as well not notice them.

Well, I supposed privatizing the NHS and harvesting PAs and NPs for their organs were niche policy proposals. It didn't make a difference when I pointed out that the brains would fetch a higher price, barely used you see.

What's this supposed to be, an allegory for CO poisoning? I have no idea what you're getting at.

I was just about to recommend Hell Divers 2 even if it's an FPS. From the gameplay I've seen, it does every ST does and better, and while I strongly prefer an FPS perspective, in a coop shooter it's not nearly as aggravating as wall peeking is something like Gears of War and the like.

Let me know if you pick it up, I might do so myself, it looks like a blast. Ah it looks like it isn't your cup of tea.

Well, maybe you'll try Tarkov one day, but I feel like the anxiety would kill you, and ping limits mean I can't even carry you through the new player on-boarding waterboarding.

There's Darktide, but I have my own gripes with that game and can't wholeheartedly recommend it, but it is satisfying to shoot the guns. There's a game called Grey Zone Warfare entering EA soon, which has PVP but far less of it than Tarkov, and will have dedicated PvE servers if you want to play it like a hardcore Ghost Recon with buddies. I'm quite optimistic about it, if only because the devs read and responded to my autistic screeching about milsim medical systems in their feedback section and even seem to have implemented a few of my suggestions.

Thing is, it's not like the USMLE, I attribute the oddities of this exam to incompetence rather than malice attempts at making questions that get at in depth understanding of medical matters. The SJT alone should be sufficient evidence to back up that claim.

The questions were easy, at least in terms of diagnosis, and I understand scenarios where one has to use limited information to make a snap judgement come up regularly, and vagueness is not necessarily inaccurate to real life, it was the fact that they designed questions that ranged from "why did I even study for this" to "choose between two plausible options with insufficient information to decide between them". Admit? Admit and do what? Refer? Urgently or not? That's critical, and without it the question becomes a matter of guessing, especially when a lot of it hinges on the particulars of where you see the presentation. It matters a great deal whether your nominal location is in a GP practise, or they're showing up at the ER, and in some cases that information was both relevant and absent.

I can't say I know much about the USMLE (given that it would be an entirely academic curiosity for me, right now), but the PLAB exam was significantly better in that regard. Clear curriculum, an understanding of core competencies to cover, better written questions. I can't even say the MSRA by itself was harder, both had the typical pattern matching red currant stuff too, but this exam made me feel like I went to get a driving test and then ended up forklift certified. The difficulty comes solely from the fact it's competitive for limited seats, whereas that's far less of a factor for the PLAB. I'd rather have a hard exam where I know how to prepare than an "easy" one where I'm at just as much at a loss as anyone else.

Ideally at some point you’ll be doing a boards question or some other assessment and you’ll have this experience of “I don’t know the answer to this question but my knowledge is sufficient to understand what the answer should be based off of other things I do know.” I’m not quite sure I made that come across the way I wanted to but hopefully you’ll have the ah-hah moment at some point.

The missile doctor knows what the right answer is by knowing what it isn't eh?

PS: Tarkov cheaters. You learn to live with them. And don't go Labs, if you can help it. I play on Singapore and occasionally Chinese servers, so I'd imagine I have the worst of it, but avoiding Labs and Lighthouse (except for quests) will keep you mostly safe. And eventually you'll be rich enough that dying to a cheater every dozen raids or so is the cost of doing business.

Above average for a physician, on any type of assessment or metric.....is impressive as hell. These people are study psychopaths and you have your neurodivergence etc. Good. Fucking. Work.

❤️

(It's 64th percentile for all the MSRA applicants too, not just Psych, which is heartening. These are proper lads and lasses with GMC registration)

I did study my ass off, if it wasn't obvious I was on the verge of absolute burnout haha. What makes me even more pissed is that most of that work was utterly irrelevant, you'd think the examiners were taking the piss if you saw the questions I encountered, and not just the SJT part which I've complained about enough.

For example, NICE guidelines recommend urgent referral for malignant hypertension with papilloedema to prevent further end organ damage, and in the question where I had such a patient, the options included "admit" and "refer to _ specialist".

Mf, is that supposed to be an urgent referral? Is it implied that we're going to admit them first to get the hypertension in check before bleeping someone?

So many questions like this, with vague options. The majority of questions were maybe 2 or 3 sentences long, whereas all the MCQ banks give you whopping multiple paragraph cases with little tidbits and clues inside. I would like to say that the additional difficulty and challenge helped me prepare, but as far as I can tell, it didn't, that particular question was the only one where the megabyte of guidelines I memorized was relevant, and even then the answer wasn't clear.

5 questions in a group where I'm pretty sure the answers were all bacterial vaginosis (though maybe one could be a misplaced tampon, not that I'm quite sure how you can lose one of those in there, but I opted for BV).

It all makes one despair, what on earth can I study to improve on that? And the SJT is.. I won't repeat myself.

So I fervently hope I manage to land a place this go, as I am frankly unsure how it's even possible to improve further. Maybe read more neuro, which I skimped on, but that's about it. No childhood rashes, no paediatric milestones, none of the supposedly high yield topics except gyne, and even then it was just BV.

Have some caution with respect to specialty trends, these can turn on a dime and if you don't have a good source of intel you can miss out on wild swings in competitiveness (for instance in the US Psych went from not competitive at all to tough as hell to average, all in the span in 3-4 years. Advisors mostly missed this and left people high and dry). Sometimes it's better to swing the bat and not worry (shit, does that also work for Cricket?*)

For what it's worth, the sudden ramp up in difficulty seemed to come as a surprise to even the UK locals. I will work on the assumption it'll only get more difficult, if I am cursed to have another go. Besides, I haven't found anything else I like :(

I haven't swung a bat in ages, I find both cricket and baseball to be remarkably boring sports, at least in the former the spectators get more cardio than like all but 3 of the players.

Ruralness. This one I can definitely comment on(ish). There are a handful of cities in the US most Residents want to be in, and approximately 10,000 places they don't want to be. Thanks giant ass continent. Normally when I'm advising students I'll tell them to rate location higher than they think. Not wanting to shoot yourself because you have fun things to do during your limited fun time is more important than higher salary or academic prestige. However higher than you think doesn't mean it's the whole list. Training is short, career is long, and the UK is small. As long as you have flexibility after you are done then you can live with wherever they put you and then leverage yourself into a better position later.

I think both my training and my career are going to be short, for the usual reasons we discussed heh. I suppose that disagreement can only be resolved with time, not that I wouldn't be exceedingly happy if I manage to be a Real Consultant™ 7 years down the line.

You might be concerned about training quality in a rural area and this is real, but psych isn't surgery. You don't need physical practice doing a Whipple, you can catch up on knowledge gaps through training and studying resources pretty easily. You also likely get to avoid the truly annoying patient populations (like malingering homeless) that a big city will be flush with, and rare shit like autoimmune encephalitis is still rare enough that you wouldn't see it in London or wherever. You will need to eventually learn how to deal with bread and butter homeless malingerers and decompensated psychosis but because they are common in a city setting you'll figure it out quick when you move to one.

That's what I suspected and it's good to have some confirmation! I'm not worried overly much about the quality of the training, just QOL in general, but psych is still supposed to be chill, and the fewer hobos going for a needle the better.

The UK is small enough that I don't have to worry particularly much about getting about, though geographic proximity would certainly help maintain the one relationship I've got going. And there's family in the bigger cities, not particularly close, but better than nothing. It's not too big a deal, I am sick enough of studying the 3 odd years since I finished my MBBS that I'll take any training post with the word psychiatry in it (though not in India).

If my USMLE woes are resolved, then I'll phone it in at work with LTFT, going from 80% hours to as low as they'll let me before they realize I'm not showing up at work at all, and if I do manage to pass it and match I'm going to firebomb the GMC building and catch the first flight out. But that's not a given, and so to that particular damp island I go, for now.

Thank you, as always, for the excellent advice, it's too early to celebrate quite yet, but if I'm being honest I think my odds of matching are >50%, and worst case it's another 6 to 8 months gone.

Mf just ignoring me right here, with all the solicited and unsolicited medical advice I dish out for free.

That's it, I'm going to get Zorba to implement micropayments and a blockchain so I can bill you all.

(But as I said above, I'm not touching this one, psychiatry is built on One Weird Trick like talking to people and making them feel better, resetting their brains with electrical currents, supplementing neurotransmitters when we know there isn't actually a deficiency, fucking ketamine yada yada. But those are Weird Tricks that scale, and I'm betting this doesn't)

After a certain point it gets easier to crush and dissolve tablets in water and then pour it out. I don't know if that works for melatonin, but you could use a grinder and make a slurry in the worst case.

But melatonin dosing is god awful for the opposite reason as Vitamin D, as you seem to be aware.