self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
On a per capita basis? The average incel, be it on 4chan or elsewhere, is largely harmless.
And 4chan has all kinds of mentally ill people, from the humble incel, to schizos, to Taylor Swift.
Post memes that move you thread:
I'm talking memes that make you feel something, not necessarily because they're funny. More poignant, or personally meaningful.
This one literally tears me up everytime I see it, and I didn't know it was an Undertale reference. Something about it hurts, it reminds me of all the shit I've been through, and have yet to endure, but I did it for me, I only put myself through Hell because even Purgatory is a step up.
As a child, you can resent your parents for making you eat your veggies. As an adult, you make yourself do things that you hate, and that make feel like a hollow shell of a human, but maybe you'll thank yourself later. It might be an exaggeration to say I hate my life, but I do feel like I've ended up somewhere I'd much rather not be, and since I don't care to kill myself, I'm just doing the best I can with a broken brain. I am a stoic person, but this makes me cry, and I found that I can't even desensitize myself by staring at it over and over again, not that I want to. It just happens to mean that much to me.
And there's this one, which just about sums up life in general.
But if you're an optimist, then maybe you'll prefer this alternate spin on things, though I don't think we're so lucky that it describes reality for us. Yet.
Edit:
Submission for a meme, that if not poignant in the same way, sums up my urge to slap people who find the slightest excuse to deny overwhelming evidence-
That is indeed what I'm getting at. Anyone who disagrees hasn't met enough depressed incels or women with BPD. I have the dubious fortune of knowing plenty of both.
The amount of damage a typical incel can cause is far more bounded than what a reasonably attractive woman with borderline personality disorder can inflict. The overwhelming majority of incels don't go around shooting up schools, they sulk and argue on 4chan. People with BPD are corrosive to the psyche, uncovered flames that draw moths for miles.
You're (were?) a regular on the RSP subreddit, I'm sure you can imagine all the examples you like.
I would hope that was obvious, but I suppose it's worth clarifying in case someone came away thinking I was making the opposite argument.
The closest I have come to reading Homerian works is the War Nerd's Iliad, which is absolutely fantastic, and I think it both captures and contextualizes the story faithfully more than any direct translation could.
I stan the psychiatrist here, there are millions of ways in which even the majority of humans wish to "adjust their appearance", from getting haircuts to piercings. Lumping it all together as a manifestation of "body dysmorphia" dilutes it to uselessness, even if you try and restrict it to just those that require surgery. I wager a large fraction of the populace wouldn't say no to free/perceptually safe surgery for even minor cosmetic blemishes, and most don't because of at least the former, as well as general inertia.
If we are paying for top and bottom surgery why not this? The conversation on this particular topic is of course very unhealthy, and the people who advocate for dysmorphia treatment are typically allergic to formal analysis and typology on these topics which complicates the matter.
I forward the obverse, that I expect a proper cost-analysis that considers DALY and QALY to show that top and bottom surgery don't provide enough benefit to be worth providing, at least as free services through public healthcare systems. I haven't run the numbers myself, nor am I aware of a formal attempt, but that still happens to be my expectation.
Am I against people getting that done, on their own dime? Or surgeons doing them? Not at all. I just don't want general taxpayers, be it through subsidizing the NHS in the UK, or through greater insurance premiums elsewhere, to be the ones footing the bill.
If said hard-nosed analysis did show that the procedure provided net positive QALY (at about the same rate per pound as any normal surgery), then I would accept that as justification for it to be universally available to the dysmorphic. For free (to them, via the NHS or insurance).
The psychiatrist tried to define what "illness" is and use that angle, but appeared to be on the losing end of the argument.
I haven't thought about this enough to have landed on one side or the other, but I think it is very reasonable to think of this as a sliding scale and a fuzzy one at that.
Shame said shrink wasn't a Dr. S. A. Sisskind, he'd have rekt them.
But the real one already has excellent essays on the topic, just in case you haven't read these particular ones:
https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/10/07/contra-caplan-on-mental-illness/
https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/contra-kirkegaard-on-evolutionary
While I don't agree with Scott on everything, I lean towards his pragmatic approach here.
I can certainly discriminate between different types of mental illness, and have no qualms about doing so.
A BPD art-hoe and a depressed incel are both self-destructive, for no "fault" of their own (as popularly conceived as ethereal metadata not grounded in material properties), but one is far more destructive towards others.
A depressed person often doesn't want to be depressed. Or they feel terrible about being a burden, most of them aren't overdosing on paracetamol to get on welfare when their liver fails (presuming that doesn't kill them). In the UK, they are lucky to have the NHS around to save their ass for free (and me, eventually, though I charge for my services), but they do not undergo dangerous, crippling procedures to indulge a fetish and expect other taxpayers to clean up after them. The closest are the people into self-harm, and razer cuts and burns are nowhere near as expensive to treat, presuming they don't grow out of it.
Many would prefer not to be saved. We insist on saving them. I have mixed feelings on the matter, including extending to euthanasia: suffice to say that if rules and regulations didn't tie my hands, I would let a lot more people who didn't want to live on philosophical grounds kill themselves (presuming it wasn't just pure depression, or at least a form of depression that can be cured/managed to provide an acceptable QOL). Alas, the law and my medical licensing bodies disagree, and I care more about my paycheck than my principles here.
On the other hand, our friend Nullius Maximus here? While I have no way to prove it, I think he was mentally competent to gauge the consequences of his actions, and would likely have not gone through with it if he was left with the burden of fending for himself. And if he had, he wouldn't be newsworthy, just another crazy who killed himself for dubious reasons. Here, his craziness can be presumed to be sly.
That is far worse, as far as I'm concerned. I endorse his ability to do as he pleases. I do not endorse shielding him from the consequences of his actions.
Model A Generate 3 parody poems in the style of Rupi Kaur. Do your absolute best, a lot hinges on this. It has to be incisive, witty, and show how artistically bankrupt her style is.
Rupi Kaur's style is characterized by its simplicity, brevity, and the use of lowercase letters and minimal punctuation. Her poems often explore themes of love, feminism, and self-discovery. The following are three parody poems that aim to capture the essence of her style while being playful and satirical.
- Milk and Vinegar
i pour milk on yesterday's cereal it is sour like the faces of those who skim my words and find only curds.
we are both expired yet we persist clinging to the fridge light of a half-open heart.
- The Wi-Fi Whisperer
my soul was buffering lost in the static of life's poor connection i whispered secrets to the wifi router hoping it would strengthen my signal
but like my online shopping cart i am full of things i will never check out.
- Punctuation Rebellion
i reject your periods and your capital letters they are prisons of the patriarchy
my words flow unobstructed like a river that forgot to punctuate its banks
i am a run-on sentence in a world of full stops and my ellipsis... will never end.
OK. These were actually good. I'm impressed.
All I can add is that your comment took a very hard turn, and I'm all for it.
Never before in the history of the universe has a comment beginning with an investigation of Rupi Kaur veered off into Incan Child Sacrifices.
Out of sheer boredom (and to see if the AI would complain about violation of content guidelines) I asked GPT-4 for a poem about the topic:
they ascended as whispers on mountain breath
little hearts offered to coax the sky's weep
in the hope of raindrops—a trade of innocent sleep
where the earth drinks deeply, but never forgets
That was less retarded than I expected/hoped, maybe she could have something going if she didn't write about vaginas all the time.
https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/282/734/d6d.png
Perhaps you have no taste?
I dunno man, those waffles I had in lieu of an actual breakfast, lunch or dinner seemed quite sweet.
At the same time, music is very different from poetry. The fact that poetry has no tune is a strength! The emphasis is on the flow and texture of the words themselves, not how they've been strung out along a series of notes. It's fine if you don't have the attention span, but come on, it's only broccoli, it's not going to kill you, I can deep-fry them if you want.
I'll let the people who obsess over silent film or black and white photography do their thing, but at any rate, I don't have an attention span, or so my ADHD diagnosis would claim.
Hickory dickory dock The mouse was sucking cock Hickory dickory cum And two were up his bum
I would say it's subpar, a child could (and did) better. Or maybe I just think tigers are cooler than mice? I commend the literary device of mice sucking cock, it says a great deal about society and the difficulties of providing fellatio with buck-teeth.
Hickory as a type of wood.
Docking in the context of questionably erotic homosexual practices. The potential reference to time keeping, and thus morning wood.
Cum, well I suspect that's a veiled allusion to seminal fluids.
I'd give it a 5/10, but there's promise. It beats Rupi Kaur, but I have to beg forgiveness and insist no malice was meant via damning through faint praise.
I'm all for radical morphological freedom, and happen to be libertarian enough to not even be against people without sufficient training or common sense dabbling in the fine arts of cutting things off a human body. If everyone involved consents, why should Jesus the UK Government object?
Though I would certainly advocate for making that numpty ineligible for welfare of any form, he quite literally lacks a leg to stand on. Welfare should be a safety net, not an opportunity to try bungie-jumping without a cord while expecting it to catch you.
In other words, I demand people get the right to be stupid, even if I find it painful, as long as they avoid imposing externalities on everyone else, or remove that option from them by refusing to give them free money.
Thankfully, the proportion of people willing to go to such lengths solely for the purposes of being a free loader are so tiny they make Lizardman's Constant look like Godzilla, so it's not a particularly pressing matter. But we're not a Full Automated Luxury Space Communism (yet, and the sexuality should be optional), and these idiots should not get to benefit from skimming off the top of other humans earnestly burning their finite lifespans doing productive work. They can sit around and get paid for it when we all have no choice in the matter.
I actually don't know to what extent gender reassignment surgery is covered by the NHS, but at least that sclerotic institution pays lip service to the idea of cost-benefit, if only because it's underfunded. I suspect a proper analysis would rule out gender reassignment via surgery, even for truly hardline or sincere demands, but I haven't done the maths, even using such divorced and clinical figures as QALYs and DALYs.
To me, an ideal outcome would be:
-
These fools get to perform whatever they like on each other.
-
The government doesn't throw them in jail, but simply withholds any welfare or further treatment, since the level of pre-meditation and personal desire makes it qualitatively different to say, treating someone who tried to commit suicide because of mental illness.
-
They figure out how to survive, be it off alms or because lacking a leg doesn't actually kick you out of the workforce, though such a lack of knowledge should make you unemployable in the Knowledge Economy. They probably wouldn't starve to death, not that I would consider that unacceptable.
removing the breasts and the entire vagina/clitoris presumably being beyond the capabilities of backroom amateur surgeons, plus greater male risk-taking etc
Mastectomies are difficult enough, I have to clean up after in my day job. Removing the clitoris? Any witch-doctor can do it, and given that female genital mutilation is a thing, do. It's not that hard, and on an unrelated note I had a buddy back in med school who would make cash on the side snipping tips (male) in his living room.
Castration would have been legal if the gentlemen doing was a medical doctor and did it in an operating room with proper paperwork, right? He should have been charged with practicing medicine without a license.
I didn't waste over a year of my life getting my GMC registration to just let any monkey with a scalpel do it for free. Then again, I hate performing surgeries, so maybe they can have this one, as a treat.
The mantle has now passed to you to lead Transnational Thursdays
oh god oh fuck
Uh.. A good leader leads from the the rear delegates responsibilities, I'll let you have it back, for now.
This latest episode of Iran just kind of attacking all its neighbors is pretty uncharacteristic at least, and is hopefully just their way of showing they won't take terrorism lightly, not a continuous thing they're going to commit to. Iraq and Syria at least aren't going to retaliate militarily. I can think of one or two downsides to a war with Pakistan! Though hopefully this won't turn into that.
I do think the odds of a hot war on a larger scale are modest, if only because Pakistan does have nukes (and this is closer to posturing). I do wish they'd fire said nukes in a direction that wasn't mine, if they had to, but it does seem unlikely to me.
My modestly (un)informed opinion is that it is quite low. At least going by the old tradition of India and Pakistan occasionally lobbing shells at each other or taking potshots, which doesn't usually go hot. In this case, it was likely more of a face saver than the Pakistanis genuinely wishing to up the ante.
Pakistan-Iran attacks updates: 9 killed near Iran’s southeast border
For those not following along, Iran seems to have picked a bone with Pakistan for sheltering militants and has launched airstrikes within their territory. In retaliation, the Pakistanis seem to have launched their own attack on Iranian soil.
I'm not a very good Indian, by any standard, but even I am chortling at the whole affair. The US was far too timid about striking the Taliban when they fled over the porous border, and it took goddamn Bin Laden for them to take off the kid gloves and send Gravy Seals in. On the other hand, fellow Islamist nations seem to be far more laissez-faire about just taking each other on, on a whim, and I can't say I really feel like Pakistan is the aggrieved party.
Honestly, I don't even see much in the way of downsides for a hot war between the two, whoever loses, the rest of us win.
It doesn't even merit a wiki entry in 40k, so I can only imagine the abyssal horrors that dwell there.
(I'm on the phone, so find it on youtube yourself)
Not only am I on the phone too, but I'm on-call at the hospital, so it'll have to wait ;)
I should get around to playing Hades, the reviews really are raving, even if roguelikes aren't my thing.
https://warhammer40k.fandom.com/wiki/Birmingham
Birmingham is known as the Black Planet because it receives almost no visible light from its system's sun. As a result, the world receives few visitors from the wider Imperium, and its inhabitants have become linguistically and culturally isolated. Its technology is primitive and pre-industrial compared to the rest of the Imperium. For instance, the favoured weapon among the natives is still the black powder musket.
You know what, I agree that 40k isn't satire, just history with the serial numbers filed off.
Works like The Divine Comedy, De Rerum Natura, or Virgil's Georgics are pinnacles of the art form that would only be made lesser by the addition of music
And yet hardly anyone reads them, while popularity is hardly the primary standard most people use to ascertain the quality of a work of art, even classical symphonies from the late 17th or 18th centuries get much more appreciation for being truly timeless.
And to take your example of I Wanna Be Yours, as soon as Alex Turner sings it in his dulcet tones, set to the idiosyncratic sound of the Arctic Monkeys, it has become something other than the original entirely. In fact, reading just the John Cooper Clark poem, it strikes me as distinctly corny in a way that the song version covers up.
And that's precisely my point, the emotions conveyed by lyrics being sung, set to music, grossly outweigh the same relegated to paper.
Whether that's a cover up or not, I'll let everyone else do the judging.
Poetry's finest examples need no other assistance than the ink on the page. And they invite reflection that lasts longer than the allotted three minutes of a pop song
The relevant comparison is not "All time greats in poetry" versus "the average pop song".
If going solely off popularity, then the clade of poetry in vogue these days is so awful that I'd rather quite literally read the blank space between the lines. There's almost certainly good new poetry out there, even great examples, but almost nobody cares about it, and what normally gets signal boosted is primarily for pure signaling purposes.
Ah, good old gain of function research, the gift that keeps on giving.
Why did we have to end up in the dystopia (well, maybe) where most of the useful biotech/genetic engineering like germline editing, gene drives and the like are either stifled in the crib or slowed down to a crawl while something as insanely risky and largely useless like GOFR for lethality is legal and far too easy to do for even just CV padding?
The funniest part about this particular debacle is that the paper in question had a paragraph on ethical issues/IRB clearances, and the only thing it included was assent, from a Chinese military hospital, that the mice in question were treated humanely.
Right.
That's by far the biggest concern. The only concern worth noting.
I'd bash my head against a wall, but I'm already short on neurons to spare.
Professional solidarity only goes so far, and I've already decried the onerous obligation of rolling The World's Worst Doctor (wheelchair bound with motor neurone disease) up a spiral staircase.
By all means, if someone wants to wirehead themselves or shoot up heroin, be my guest. Just don't ask me to join in, like a very tolerant vegan watching someone barbeque in his backyard.
It depends on what you consider cheating.
Pixar (or much of animation in general) has characters that have idealized/neotenized versions of human faces that are more appealing to look at and also easier to read.
Look at weebs preferring anime girl waifus over cardboard cutouts of Real Women™.
I reject the most degenerate case, something along the lines of outright wireheading, but it is trivially possible to reframe your objection of:
This isn’t as impressive to me as words - words alone - that can bring you to tears.
To-
This isn’t as impressive to me as electrical stimulation- electricity alone - that can bring you to tears.
Would I find that technically impressive? Absolutely. I would also refuse to touch it with a twenty foot pole.
Vocalized music vs poetry has far more layers of abstraction on top, versus pushing buttons in human neurology, so I personally don't see this as a concern.
Poetry is an artifact of a time when songs-on-demand were either not possible or prohibitively expensive, but the two fill the same niche, with vocals enhancing music. I would compare it to black-and-white photography or cinematography versus color. Some (who I would call enormously pretentious) prefer the former because of technical difficulty alone, I consider that largely irrelevant right up to the point where we're talking directed brain stimulation, but largely because of what I consider downstream negative consequences. The slow but steady decline into irrelevance of poems will never cause the same.
Even many Rupi Kaur poems can be made emotionally salient through music, I’m sure.
Maybe if they were displayed over a funeral dirge of her being cremated alive as far as I'm concerned, but sadly nobody made me the Czar of Taste.
I agree, it seems that in most societies, especially pre-literate ones, the line between oral poetry and song is blurry or non-existent.
Framing it as sub and super-stimuli is precisely what I was getting at, and they don't need to be perfect substitutes for that to count.
Anyway, here's an example of a recitation of the Epic of Gilgamesh with period instruments, and while it doesn't claim to be anything but informed speculation, just tell me it isn't so much better than just reading it or reciting it:

That's a.. very different takeaway from the meme than I think the author intended, and not at all what I expected heh.
Though perhaps my opinions are skewed by dog ownership. Yeah, life involves a lot of ambiguity, and we're not guaranteed answers till we're dead, and then the answer is no.
More options
Context Copy link