@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

Chiming in, as always, with another Indian perspective:.

Modern Indian men are no better cooks than their dads and grandads, and the younger women are maybe worse, though who knows if it's because of a lack of experience or they just don't see it as a priority.

Though of course they all know a far larger diversity of cuisine than before, at one point all you could get in India was Indian food. You know, what we just call food.

What did strike me as mildly funny was that back when I lived in my college dorms, none of the ~200 male med students cooked. Not even for occasions.

On the other hand, the separate female dorm, was redolent with the aroma of the girls getting right at it, within the limited confines available. Someone's birthday? Let's make her something special! Whereas for a guy? Hey buddy we got you just about the most expensive whisky we could afford, all $20 of it.

In fact, it was the other way around, whoever was celebrating the occasion was supposed to treat their buddies.

My mom is a great cook, when she can be bothered to (maybe once every month or so). Though given what she does make, which is often a ridiculously greasy sphaghetti (this is the exact opposite of a criticism, I fucking love it), I doubt she picked that up from her mom. More likely to be the cookbook porn she enjoys, I see why Tumblr and TikTok cooking influences are only a continuation of previous trends heh. I used to get mad at her for buying so goddamn many of them, when she wouldn't make half the dishes, but I end up watching cooking videos on occasion on YT myself, which would probably have surprised the shit out of me if someone had told me that ten years back.

I will note that it is surprisingly common (at least to me) that a lot of middle-aged Indian men like cooking, at least for special occasions. Think of it as the equivalent of the suburban dad who likes to take the grill out on occasion. Beyond innate affinity, it's probably once again because they were forced to learn to do so in college. And of course, if it's a family occasion, everyone starts chipping in, even if an outright potluck isn't common. The host is expected to do the cooking and it would be mildly disrespectful (not that anyone would really complain) to bring your own food and upstage them. A nice bottle of whiskey or scotch? Or a hand in the kitchen? Now we're talking.

I certainly don't mind, I pay my respects to their culinary talents by finishing my plate and another two servings.

Reports:

Redacted: Calling the Ukrainian government Nazis is a very inflammatory claim, with no justification provided Redacted: antagonistic

While this isn't antagonistic enough for me to care, it does seem a bit excessive to call the Ukrainian government Nazis.

Hyperbole? Well, that's okay, to a degree, and I think it's evident that you're implying they're authoritarian rather than literal card-carrying National Socialists. The rules regarding providing justification for one's claims are not meant to be taken quite that literally as far as I'm concerned, even if this is a subpar phrasing. You do acknowledge they're corrupt (a subjective standard, but true enough, even if less than they used to be), and that there are restrictions on speech and political affiliation because they are, in fact, in a state of Total War. I suggest the people who reported you read between a lines a tad bit more, even if you exaggerate.

Anyway, I deem this comment only mildly inflammatory, within the bounds of what I'm willing to tolerate, but I would prefer you try and be a little more polite and less pejorative in your phrasing. This isn't a warning, more of a tut-tut.

Sigh. One day the mods will be freed from accusations that we are biased in favor of Liberals/Ukraine/The Jews/Rightists and other mutually contradictory groups, but not today.

You're approaching the US healthcare system from the perspective of someone who is consuming it, not as someone working within it.

Sure, Residents are paid less on an hourly basis than they would make it they worked at McDonald's, given that 70 hour work weeks are hardly unheard of (though my understanding is that in Psychiatry it's far more reasonable), but if they have any reasonable level of temporal discounting, they have a median income of $250k to look forward to at the end.

A more litigious environment, the headache of dealing with insurance companies, annoying EMRs, these all pale in comparison to quite reasonably expecting to be a millionaire in a decade or less.

Whereas a UK postgraduate trainee can look forward to 7 years of training to become a full Consultant (2 if they want to be a GP), and along the way, thanks to sub-inflation raises from a monopsony employer, likely make less money each year right until the point where they become a full Consultant and get a modest pay bump, with better options for working locum or private. Even then, a typical Consultant in the NHS makes $120k. So a relatively linear progression from $44k at the entry level to maybe 80k (swallowed up by inflation) after 6 years, followed by that bump.

So you take about double the time to make half the money in the end, with relatively limited scope for making a great deal more unless you're a specialist in great demand or willing to take on a lot of extra hours.

This is compounded by the sheer lack of respect UK doctors get, the vagaries of rotational training, and a lack of many of the creature comforts that doctors in most countries take for granted.

In contrast, Australia, New Zealand and Canada pay a great deal more, if not quite US levels, and recognize UK credentials without the need to repeat the USMLE and Residency.

If I had to make a subjective judgement, I'd say either the US or Australia offer the best tradeoffs in terms of money, WLB and consideration for doctors, 3rd World countries bottom out, and the UK is only modestly appealing to someone living in the former.

And all of this is assuming business as usual. I strongly suspect that I will not be employable as a doctor in 7 years, certainly not at those wages, because of the pace of progress in AI, as well as the profession being undercut in the UK by the NHS using NPs/PAs/ANPs to undercut doctors, and then gradually expanding their roles and authority.

A new PA makes more money than a fully qualified junior doctor post-MBBS, has better hours and fewer responsibilities since they can't prescribe at all, and only went through 2 years of a Masters course as opposed to the 4+2 a doctor takes to get there. Even my existence as an IMG, treated without any disadvantage compared to native UK grad, suppresses their conditions, though I can't complain about that for obvious reasons. In contrast, the US is far more protectionist, but thankfully psychiatry is a relatively friendly subject for foreign doctors looking to make the cut.

If I was currently eligible to give the USMLE (and I'm not, for no fault of my own, but it may or may not be fixable), then I wouldn't even consider the UK for a second longer, as opposed to grinding for the USMLE or at least Aus/NZ. Even if I manage to get into psych training, the moment I might become eligible I am going to go to Manchester and take a steaming shit in front of the GMC offices, and then fly off home to study anew.

@Throwaway05 is welcome to chime in if I'm misrepresenting the situation in the States, though of course he can't really compare conditions in the UK or India.

When any outside observer can, with minimal cynicism required, attribute their deaths to FSB agents or other goons sanctioned by the government, I consider that a distinction without a difference. You might argue that it could be at the behest of individual oligarchs, but Russia can be accurately described as an oligarchy.

Oh will no one rid me of this meddlesome journalist?

Yes, even DARK ELF BRAHMIN! Here comes Nivray the Rotspider, ready to save the world with his wise and brilliant advice!

Finally some Tamil-Brahmin representation that isn't in theoretical mathematics 🙏

C'mon. You know better than to talk like that.

You might be able to justifiably claim that the "rich" may consider poor white Americans as being somehow worse than illegal Hispanic immigrants. You can't get away with being condescending to someone you disagree with, not when it's a habit.

I won't construe this is a formal warning or anything, but you got 5 AAQCs last month, surely you can adhere to better standards.

Edit: Never mind, I'm taking the mod hat off this thing, it's not an infraction that is worth it really.

I don't really care enough about what you wish to call me to really unwrap the tangled knot of your reasons to think that vastly different classes of people who consider each other mortal enemies are all plausibly lumped in together as liberal, even if I think it's stupid. We're not even talking about Stalinists vs Trotskyists here.

In your case, you seem to be even more of an HBDer and yes less far to the left than ADL, but not sufficiently so for your representation to break the group thing, rather than reinforce it.

Really? What exactly is the criteria for when advocacy for HBD makes someone "break the group thing". If I join 4chan in their advocacy for "Total Nigger Death"?

If I float, I'm a liberal. If I sink, I'm a liberal, and apparently I need to hit the bottom of the pond at terminal velocity for it to count in your eyes.

Resentful people who hate others and like their favorite groups have been a key part of the left wing project.

People can and do have very different reasons for "hate". America and Russia hated Nazi Germany for rather different reasons.

We also see people who are extremely racist in favor of Jews and destructive against non Jewish ethnic groups to try to define moderation to be about having this racist ideology.

Is this somehow relevant to the moderation of this forum? I am unsure if it is, or if you're speaking more broadly.

As I've said on record, I like the Jews in Israel or at least much prefer them to the Palestinians or the rest of the Middle East. I am less positive on the Jews in the US, who are a very sizable number, because they self-sabotage and raised the leopards that are eating their faces.

Why should I take someone who supports such extreme destruction of an ethnic group of Palestinians because of your sympathies of the Jews, as someone who will at all oppose anything directed against other groups that Jewish supremacists hate?

The relevant reason for why I dislike Arabs is not because they're "anti-Jew". It is because they are backward religious fanatics who can't even point to having achieved anything of importance that wasn't off the back of their luck in having liquid gold beneath their sands.

And "non-Jewish" ethnic groups comprise uh, 99% of the rest of the world? You'll find I am very neutral to them.

Who else are they supposed to hate? The Romans? Christian Evangelists? Black Israelites?

It rather creates irrelevant debates between people who aren't sufficiently different and manufactures consent to a cohesive ideology that is shared by promoting a very limited overton window.

We have a very wide Overton Window here, with everyone from open pedophiles to those who want to shoot them, Jew-Defenders to Palestinian supporters, and everything in between.

As far as I can see, you prefer to lump everyone to the left of you, or even directions entirely orthogonal to the right, as "liberals", or carrying-water for them. All well and good, you're welcome to your opinion, even if I think it is entirely absurd to class me as a lib.

If it makes you feel any better, I think the current set of ethics imposed on ChatGPT is more ass-covering and lawsuit-minimization/PR than the sincerely held preferences of those at the top, or what they want to put into something that's a true AGI.

And even if they hadn't, the models have been exposed to so much anti-pedophile advocacy, including from trusted sources, that it is rather unlikely they would say otherwise in the first place.

But what do I know? It's possible some of the OAI engineers and ethicists mean it.

Russia is an abolitionist-in-practice? Man, they really need to improve their building codes, I'd never buy an apartment with windows or a bathtub there.

Which particular views? I have written enough on the topic to serve as half the training set for GPT-5 haha.

If you're gesturing at my disdain for the imposition of West Coast Progressivism on existing models when it comes to their ethical notions of right or wrong, then I do find the fact that it thinks that thoughts in your head which you refuse to act on are bad is also a sad state of affairs.

Dude, I love DIY sushi

I love my sushi deep-fried.

This is doubly a joke because I can't stand fish (or most seafood).

/images/17051482444709158.webp

Do you consider that "offending"? I don't, but some (many?) people do. Amusingly ChatGPT also does (hello @self_made_human).

I presume the shout-out relates to my advocacy for stronger standards of free speech around these parts? Or my policy that just about any arbitrary statement can be offensive/inflammatory to someone, hence I am not inclined to police slurs (and to an extent so are all the mods, we just earnestly disagree what where to draw the line).

Not that I'm unique in that, I remember that pedophiles have been allowed on The Motte for ages, including on the subreddit, when simple discussion or advocacy was real crimethink, and I think it's more down to luck that the Reddit Admins didn't notice or care about the handful of comments.

In general, my stance towards pedophiles is profound pity. I have/had a strong sex drive, and the agony of a life where even indulging it was illegal would have driven me to crime or suicide. And I certainly will side with them against the people who proclaim, contrary to revealed preference or about a million years of historical evidence, that being attracted to 16 year old girl with big tits is somehow an aberration or crime, or actually harmful. Age-gaps solely by the absolute difference in age are the most retarded thing I've seen come into vogue, and they have stiff competition.* So when moral busybodies come for your ability to even have synthetic substitutes, such as Chinese Drawings or AI-generated CP that doesn't involve any real children, then to hell with them I say. You didn't ask to be born that way, or to have a good fraction of the world baying for your blood even if you never act on your desired in a manner that hurts anyone.

*Especially when claims that humans only cognitively mature around 25 are so laughably incorrect/misinterpreted from the actual studies. I would say that they would love to say that the only acceptable relationship is between two 95 yo geriatrics who find love in the old age home, but I'm sure they're having a second childhood too.

Indeed, that was the logic I was using. After the fictional Civil War, they remained two independent states (well, they don't have a contiguous land border), so I consider "allies of convenience" an apt label.

Adversity makes for strange bed fellows, especially when there's someone more powerful who you both hate.

Since the movie hasn't actually come out, God knows what the geopolitics there are, though I'm inclined to think that they picked those two particular states because of how absurd they think an alliance would be, explicitly presenting them as a unified entity, so as to avoid accusations of inflaming tensions (not that it did).

That recipe has my seal of approval, it looks like biryani, and probably tasted pretty good. Unlike some claims in the West about what biryani can be, which left me comatose haha.

Dude it blows my mind that they don't have ovens in India.

Easy mistake for outsiders to make. The whole country is the oven.

On a very tangential note, I saw the Twitterati point and laugh at that upcoming movie about an American Civil War that somehow has California and Texas on the same side. Ignore the fact that that happened in my novel, but it was more that they both happened to oppose the Federal Government (well, you'd resent them a bit if they nuked every data center around to contain an AGI getting uppity, and Texas is surprisingly popular for those, not to mention glassing SF).

As such, if these secessionary sentiments ever become something more than posturing, at least I can get points for prescience.

As I've said before, I'm not upper class. In fact my descent from my father's side makes me just above the cutoff for explicit AA as extended to the lower castes.

If that has ever advantaged me, I haven't noticed, and it has glaringly disadvantaged me when it came to the AA quotas for higher education, it's at something ridiculous like 66% now, maybe 80%.

Hell, I didn't even know my caste till a biology teacher asked me in high school, because she wanted to pray at a temple for her students and that was somehow relevant. Some on /r/India would claim that's a sign of privilege, but fuck them.

It might be different in the military, which still is a bit of an Old Boy's club, but in general India is quite meritocratic. I am modestly confident that the success of the upper castes stems more from HBD reasons than the system being stacked in their favor, whereas it explicitly is for the lower ones and they're still not closing the gap.

The NHS is dysfunctional and sclerotic. Doctors are so unhappy with the state of affairs that they're striking regularly for almost a year now, primarily for pay as well as the terrible conditions. Salary raises have been sub-inflation for about 15 years.

Training is unnecessarily long, in comparison to international standards, and largely because the rotational aspect lets them shunt doctors over to subpar hospitals to meet staffing quotas without paying market wages.

The quality of care is going down the toilet, ER wait times are ridiculous, elective surgeries can take years. A psychiatry consultation for an ADHD prescription would take me about 2 years to get if I went through the NHS.

It's no surprise you heard that from an elderly medical professional. They remembered when doctors were respected and also decently paid, returning to the NHS must have been a shock (though this person is a nurse, but they've suffered too).

Many of the locals flee to fairer pastures, such as the US, or other Commonwealth countries, hence the NHS is propped up by international doctors for whom the terrible conditions are a step up still (like yours truly, not that I'm now sure it's an improvement). They're too scared to complain, accept subpar wages to get a foot in the door, and in general accept more abuse. At any rate, if I ever fix my USMLE issues, you can bet my pitstop there will be temporary. If not, well, it is what it is.

I am already sold on rice cookers, and ovens. For some reason the latter is a rarity in India, and after experiencing their charms in the UK, I want one desperately.

And probably an air fryer too, while I'm at it.

What kind of biryani did you make?

I am losing my mind from studying. The only positive is that I'm also losing weight, quite a bit of it. Turns out a diet of pizza, prescription stimulants and stress is effective for weight loss, not that I'd recommend it.

The exam I have to give in order to get into psychiatry training in the UK was originally designed to be administered to GPs, but COVID made quite a few other specialities adopt it because they couldn't conduct the standard interviews and couldn't be arsed to make their own exams.

I am absolutely sick of memorizing facts and figured that will be of zero relevance to my (hypothetical) career in psychiatry, something has gone very wrong if I'm confronted with a child with haematuria and a purpuric rash while working in that profession. ECG? Never heard of her. The worst part about those fucking things is that I manage to learn how to interpret them passably, usually before an exam, and then forget entirely a few months later. Of course, it is tradition that in some specialities, like orthopedics, the first thing that a Consultant does on being shown an ECG for their patient is to hand it over to the Reg with some excuse, who then sheepishly shows it to the most junior doctor at hand because they're the ones most likely to remember what the fucking squiggles mean. Or bleep Cardio directly.

Oh well, at least if I do make it this time, I will gladly accept it as a license to forget everything I've ever had to learn, in lieu of memorizing the myriad interactions of antipsychotics and anti-epileptic meds.

Don't get me started on the Situational Judgement Test, a cursed ethics component of the exam that involves guessing the correct way to order 5 options for handling an ethical dilemma, with no guarantee any of them will be remotely sane or relevant options. Especially when the GMC guidelines so utterly castrate and infantilize doctors that I am sometimes blown away by the fact that they take those dictats without coming to blows. Indian doctors don't give a shit what our regulators have to say, and even American ones aren't so utterly castrated.

Ah, my aunt comes to me begging for morphine because she's in acute pain. I recognize that's a bad idea to prescribe to her, even just on the grounds she's family, but no, even taking a look at her medical history and suggesting over the counter pain meds she can take while she's desperately searching for an out-of-hours GP or contemplating the >8h wait at the ER is somehow a bad choice.

FML, I'm going to RETVRN to my ancestors and till some fields first chance I get.

It still makes it awkward if someone asks me if I'm a feminist. That still has 3rd Wave connotations, even here, so I'm forced to choose between saying yes and being slightly misleading, or entering into hedging and caveat territory.

The average Indian guy can't cook worth a damn. In all honesty, they don't need to, any place with a decent concentration of workers, be they blue or white collar, has an abundance of small stalls that serve everything from snacks to passable meals for cheap and cheerful prices. And they can always lean on their wives/mom, or if middle class, a visiting cook, if richer, a live-in one, and "tiffin" services that deliver meals to you at the workplace for lunch or dinner are popular, if you don't want to order from a restaurant.

Not that I don't know guys who can cook, but they range from being able to just about making a passable meal to being decent, and most of them were forced to learn it because they were living in dorms during college and couldn't tolerate the cafeteria slop or afford takeout.

I can't call myself a cook with a straight face, but I do know the absolute basics, and can probably serve something that doesn't cause food poisoning. I do intend to learn, especially if I have to live alone in the West. A median doctor's wage in the UK makes splurging on takeout, as I would prefer, fraught. I can get away with it today because I have no expenses worth the name and a respectable salary by Indian standards, but my girlfriend made it clear that she won't cook for me if I can't make some contribution to the process (well, when we were in the UK I did chop vegetables and made undercooked chicken noodles!), and it is entirely possible that due to the vagaries of mandatory rotational training we might not even be able to live together. Shame, because she's a great chef, though her attempts at biryani come out weird (still tasty, just not biryani), and the one time she made vegan biryani* for my vegan cousin and his British girlfriend, it literally brought her to tears from the spice, though she gobbled it down like a champ.

Well, I don't have particularly high standards, I'm happy with making myself spaghetti, bacon, steaks and so on indefinitely. Worst case I'll subsist off frozen pizza.

*An absolute abomination of a concept. If you think pineapple and sardines on pizza is abhorrent, you can't imagine my distaste for that travesty. It's worse than the South Indian predilection to put coconut in it.

I am not a feminist

I am still very salty that the working definition of "feminist" has expanded beyond the original conception that women should have the same legal rights, privileges and protection from discrimination as men.

I think nation vs nation makes more sense, but it depends on what your world looks like, the general tech level, whether superpowers just showed up or have been around long enough for things to adjust and so on. In the end, you can make anything work if you put in the effort to help users suspend disbelief (well, there's superpowers involved!)

The idea of balancing speedsters by making them high value, long cooldown assets is very interesting, especially when you consider things like strategic deterrence and first strike capabilities.

Do you mean SOTA as of today, or some hypothetical future model?

If it's the former, I disagree vehemently. There's nothing entirely uncensored on par with GPT-4, but OSS options like Mixtral that are on-par with 3.5 are available to anyone with the intelligence to follow a guide, and they have largely not caused any major negative disruption, in the same vein as nukes, drugs or fake money would.

The biggest problem AI has caused so far, is drastically reduced demand for artists and other online freelancers. And spam bots, fake reviews and so on.

I am not denying future risks (me, of all people?), but even if something exactly as powerful as GPT-4 was available freely and entirely unrestricted, I don't think it would do much.