self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
It is a regrettable aspect of modernity that people can and will take umbrage to just about any word, and we had to come up with the Euphemism Treadmill to describe the process occurring so rapidly that people with good intentions who aren't precisely up to date with what's in vogue, are left bemused when attacked for using what they remember as a benign term. "Wait, I thought they wanted us to call them Negroes?" A bemused old lady says as she's heckled outside a grocery story. "But what do you mean, Colored People is bad? Isn't that the same thing as People of Color??" A confused activist says as he's actively being canceled.
It is not a myth that some people object to the use of the word "mother" instead of "birthing person", or the word "retard" instead of "mentally handicapped" (and wouldn't you know it, some people even find the latter or merely "disabled" bad), even if you call someone with clinically diagnosed mental retardation a retard instead of trying to imply your opponents are so.
If a word drives some people away and is unnecessary for communicating ideas, then modding its usage helps one aspect of the foundation and doesn’t hurt the other.
My rebuttal is that such a level of word and tone-policing also drives away people who prefer free speech, or at least those who are dismayed by the Treadmill sweeping them off their feet. It is not a costless tradeoff as you imply.
Tranny might well be offensive to the majority of forum users (I don't think so, but it certainly is to a large fraction). It is, however, a word that can be applied precisely to the same set of people who can be more politely called trans or transfolk. I resent every linguistic imposition placed on me, regardless of whether I want to use the term, and as you can see, there are plenty of people who wish to use it. Trans people are also, despite their overrepresentation in online discourse, a very small minority in absolute terms.
But I am not interested in litigating every word anyone can potentially object to, because there are thousands of them. The matter has been internally discussed within the mod team, and so far, the closest we have to a consensus is:
"there is no hard and fast rule banning slurs. However, slurs exist to communicate antipathy/hostility/heat-and-not-light, so if you are including them in your post, you'd probably better make sure you compensate somehow. It's entirely possible to turn a marginal post into a modable post by the simple addition of slurs. There is no formal rule, we'll do our best and we expect you to do the same."*
This is not an official rule because it isn't an official rule. If explicit moderation guidelines emerge that rule out anything that a relatively well-defined set of the mods or users consider a slur, no matter the rest of the comment, I will enforce it in my remit as a mod. Until then, you are welcome to advocate for your stance, to the extent that I have some leeway to interpret the Foundation, I happen to disagree and will personally not moderate on that basis alone until the mod consensus says I should. Or we have a formal rule to that effect.
*formulated by the ever-eloquent @FCfromSSC, and personally endorsed by at least me and @raggedyanthem, but as I stress, not a binding declaration or even outright consensus.
I feel like your thought experiment is overly simplistic.
The members of the Motte consist of dozens of overlapping in-and-out groups. There are some sections of society, most notable the progressive liberals in the US, who take umbrage with any effort to define them and their ideology with a single moniker. Think of how Woke went from an ingroup identifier, to a pejorative. Or how they fought a battle to declaim being Social Justice Warriors, which was an acceptable if hyperbolic term once. Or the claims that CRT doesn't exist, or can't be defined, though their ideological opponents can easily point to relatively well defined behaviors that it constitutes and legislate against it.
At the end of the day, people don't even agree on what can be a slur. And others attempt to chill the debate to the freezing point with linguistic prescriptivism, including by making entirely benign words suddenly gain negative connotation overnight.
Since some can and will abuse their control over language to make certain classes of discussion unacceptable (look at why we left Reddit in the first place), I am strongly against letting that process take root here. That is entirely in keeping with the Foundation, given that some demand policing of language to the degree that other groups are forced away. It's all about striking a balance.
I was referring to the directed neutrino emissions for heat dissipation and as reaction mass as the outright scifi part, the Steamers are just short of proof of concept!
If you want to take a look, here it is:
https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/65211/ex-nihilo-nihil-supernum-original-hard-scifi-with
Musk in particular speaks often with figures like Indian Bronson, Cremièux and Hanania, all of them supporters of the HBD and "liberal-racist" or "liberal-realist" (still fun that we are talking about an Indian, a Jew and a Palestinian).
In general, Indians, disregarding our general societal conservatism, are very much "race realists".
Hell, someone asked me if I'm an alt for Indian Bronson. Which I am not, for the record.
The only reason this isn't particularly obvious is that there are very few other "races" in India, it's mostly Indians of different ethnicities with the odd African student going to college.
But that stance does carry over when we move to the West, Indians can have quite negative opinions of other races, especially blacks, though the liberalised UMC 2nd gens have that covered up their integration into the Social Justice memeplex. Certainly in the women raised that way, less so the men.
My relatives in the UK always told me to keep an eye out for congregations of black youths, and to keep my phone in my pocket if I spotted them.
We do however, have sincere appreciation for the local Whites, and other "Model Minorities" like the Asians, even if Hispanics are a bit iffy they're not unbearably so.
I would be content with you using strikethroughs, and then acknowledging your error.
I awaken, from half a century of cryogenic preservation following an aneurysm gained through going the mod queue, inside a rebuilt model of a KFC, get a perfectly fried and juicy chicken leg stuffed in my mouth by a cock rocking a doctor's badge.
Yeah. It looks like the future worked out, as far as I'm concerned. Happy to be here!
For near-infrared radiation (around 760 nm), which is emitted by most IR emitters used for VR eye tracking, ICNIRP has set a limit value of 0.8 W/m2 for continuous exposure over a period of time3. This means that if an object with an area of 1 m2 is exposed to a continuous near-infrared source with an intensity of 0.8 W/m2 for more than one hour, there is a risk of thermal damage to the cornea or iris.
The source you linked to strongly recommends not crossing that threshold.
However, I would assume that Apple's headsets are bright enough that they cause a pronounced pupillary response, and that their engineers are competent enough to stay within the same limit. After all, they've worked with IR and infrared LIDAR for ages, they know what they're doing.
I see it as very unlikely that it would cause even noticeable harm.
Sadly, Apple does love itself a walled garden, and telling users it's their way or the highway. Oculus, even after the Meta acquisition, has been far more tolerant of tinkering.
I wouldn't worry about IR lighting. I do not recall any evidence or claims that it causes damage to vision, unless we're talking the enormous intensities needed to cause thermal burns. If staring at a campfire doesn't cause people to go blind, a Vision Pro won't, though that might explain the mediocre battery life haha.
While hand tracking is great, especially for UI interactions, I consider it inadequate for games, where dedicated buttons or peripherals of some kind seem ideal. If not a controller, then at least haptic gloves.
What is especially frustrating to me is that, as far as I'm aware, Apple didn't make any effort to ensure compatibility with existing peripherals. I don't think you can use traditional VR controllers with it at all, the closest is pass-through for physical keyboards. It seems like a no-brainer feature, even if they didn't see the need for lighthouse tracking.
Hmm, if memory serves, I don't think raggedy was one of the mods awake when I was discussing my warning to Astragant with the older mods, so it may well be that she might have have disagreed at the time but just didn't happen to speak up or notice.
The influx of new mods will inevitably lead to drift in moderation decisions, though I do sincerely believe that after the degree of vetting we've been through, none of us are going to make particularly divergent decisions from the expectations of the regular users/previous mod consensus.
I strongly value free speech, and have more tolerance for pejoratives/uncharitable terms for people, including my ingroup, but of course, that's not infinitely so, especially if my personal preferences would lead to a general degradation of civility on The Motte. Hence why I warned Astragant in the first place, whereas if I was still a normal user, I'd just upvote and move on.
While the mods try, quite hard I might add, to show a united front, differences in opinion are to be expected. All I'm saying is that these are bounded.
In particular, I took great pains to show why I modded Astragant, with caveats aplenty. I don't recall seeing Skulldrinker's comment before she got to it, but in all likelihood it would have tripped my moderation threshold, even if not for quite the same reasons. I am aware that putting my mod hat on means that my opinions carry some degree of official weight, including speaking for the other mods.
I expect if a post that calls people trannies and also makes the 10,000th run-of-the-mill advocacy for conservative values, @raggedy_anthem will mod it and you will not.
It depends. Unsatisfactory answer, maybe, but it's still true. I consider just the use of "tranny" not worth a rebuke, but further action depends on precisely how they went about their "conservative advocacy". I think this particular comment was inflammatory (even if I personally agree with it), and thus I support her decision. Further relevant factors include the user's standing, and how severe the punishment given is.
A warning? That's fine by me. If she had gone for a ban, I would first check if Skull had a pattern of being obnoxious (especially after being officially warned), and likely discuss the matter internally, and if the two of us still couldn't see eye to eye, I'd go with overall mod consensus instead of unilaterally reversing the decision or disputing it in public. But in the end, we have some degree of independent initiative, and we all answer to Zorba in the end.
I hope that clarifies things, and I can understand that you might put more of a premium on politeness than I do, which is fine, I certainly value it too, if not quite as much.
Someone needs to find the mutations that predispose human fetishists to be into vore, and then put that into all livestock animals ASAP
A very respectable card, one of the best Nvidia ever made! Just don't hook it up to a 4k high refresh rate monitor if you don't want the poor thing to have an aneurysm haha.
You may, assuming the rest of your comment doesn't continue to not contribute to the atmosphere/culture we seek to cultivate here, also call people trannies (or at least I won't mod you for that reason alone).
Emphasis added.
Moderators aren't perfectly consistent, we're human too. While we attempt to build internal consensus for any major decisions, especially bans, something as minor as a warning doesn't usually warrant further discussion.
Calling people trannies is hardly the only inflammatory wording Skulldrinker made, I think "tranny-hags" is probably even worse.
In this case, I think what @raggedy_anthem said is perfectly consistent with what I did, and even if it wasn't, minor variation in what each mod considers unacceptable are to be expected. If it was a ban, especially a lengthy one, I would personally say it wasn't warranted, at least in internal discussion, but here I stand with her.
I presume you're talking about Hydrogen/Helium steamers that work through keeping hull temperatures below the noise limit for IR detectors, and potentially even at CMB levels?
In my own hard scifi novel, the K3 aliens have those, as well as far faster craft that manage to hide emissions via using neutrinos as their reaction mass in their drives, beaming them tightly and nigh-undetectably away from watching sensors, but that's a tier far above current speculative space craft (well, they're K3!).
Hmm, unless you have a beastly card the display is going to be wasted, but sure, as you can see I'm hardly most zealous VR evangelist around when I just said I'm too lazy to use it!
Excuse me? Is it okay these days to just assume that other people have the privilege of a bugpod to retreat to, especially with the recent budget cuts to education?
The CV1 is positively ancient, the Quest 3 has a very sharp screen with minimal screen door, and it's cheap compared to the alternatives. I run my Quest 2 wired, and it's not a hassle, likely the same for the 3 or you could use Airlink.
I see. Well, my tiny residual dissatisfaction with the ban I received is much ameliorated when I discover that you were doing much the same thing I later found myself compelled to do for Astragant, arguably the FarRight dude.
Certainly it taught me that tone and phrase matters, when the topics of discussion are contentious, which likely made me a more careful and considerate mod, as well as what I can only hope is one that does his best to stop that bias leaking through when trying to be impartial!
He made it personal first, and implied that if I didn't drive 5000 kms to one of the 5 universities (I've looked into this at great effort) that had copies without credentials of my own and then illegally digitized a book I'd have to break in to access, that I don't believe what I say. (as if that's an optimal use of limited time for illegal activity)
Leaving aside who made what personal, to a mildly curious but not particularly invested bystander like me, it is not at all obvious that @Eetam expected you to have to go to those lengths go find a copy. Sure, he could be a bit more polite about asking you to put your paperbacks where your mouth is, but unless he wishes to clarify otherwise, I don't see that level of hostility in response as warranted Kulak.
You rage that I'm right about major works by world leaders having been disappeared is revealing. The fact you're offended by me pointing it out and desperately need to grasp that these aren't "real banned books" when you have no problem with the barnes and noble displays of "the handmaid's tale" and "to kill a mockingbird" is doubly revealing.
How do you know he doesn't have an aversion to such farcical displays? Where's the rage? He's trying to show you that a lot of the books described as banned are only not available because nobody can be arsed to track them down, not even their nominal supporters.
You're not upset that I haven't personally tracked these down and put them on libgen, you're upset that I've surfaced them to 10s of thousands of people, and now someone with access to UTexas or UPenn library system (the only two places I could find copies) will.
I really don't see a reason to say that, it seems weird that he would complain about you sharing the other books while simultaneously telling you to put them up on the best piracy site for literature. Why make that assumption?
Both of you should a take a breather, please, you're both regulars in good standing, albeit with quirks, and hopefully you can sort the rest of it out yourselves. More politely and with charity.
I'm genuinely heartened to hear that! I hope you don't mind if I use it as an excuse for a second-hand Effective Altruist card haha. (j/k, but presumably the ones doing admin or fundraising work get away with it).
To discuss my current stance on bioterrorism x-risk in slightly more detail, such monitoring will significantly hamper lone crazies/small groups the most. Of course, they have a hard time of it, at least in the West. Just about the hardest part of making a truly extinction-level threat of a pathogen is not dying to Alpha 0.3 halfway through the process. Look at all the issues even BSL-3+ labs have with leaks. Some degree of surveillance, even if hardly the most rigorous, has been implemented. I believe most reputable purveyors of on-demand DNA/RNA/protein synthesis are filtering for known pathogens/GOF/bioweapons, though I suspect it is hardly robust, or insurmountable to a determined adversary willing to get their hands dirty.
This doesn't solve the issue of more well-resourced actors, especially in jurisdictions with more laissez-faire policies, but nation-states are generally not omnicidal (citation hopefully not needed). Wastewater surveillance will, at the very least, tell us something is up, and might even be good enough to save civilization if a pathogen isn't ridiculously good.
I'm glad you made the donation, and I sincerely hope they manage to scale cheaply and ubiquitously enough that we get some hint of what's coming that's more robust than doctors near wet-markets wondering about a really weird flu.
Part of why I don't care very much about this issue, is I'd be fine with the ending of gender separated sports. Tough shit if women can't compete, the world ain't fair. I say that with daughters who will very likely compete in high school and possibly college sports competitions. Still don't care. I understand I have a minority view on that point, and if you want to have female sports it makes sense to actually try and preserve them.
I caught my first (and only) ban from you (I'm pretty sure) for saying the same, albeit in a far less charitable way. As far as I'm concerned, women's sports are fundamentally less interesting, the competitors are worse, the action less exciting. They've been grandmothered in as "societally acceptable", but in most cases, they're about as popular in terms of viewership as the Paralympics. I cynically suspect that even the relatively popular ones, like tennis or swimming, gain most of their appeal from the voyeuristic pleasure of watching skimpily clad fit women.
In some cases, a specific carve out or female only league is outright ridiculous, why should there be a separate leaderboard or league for female chess players? The original justification, if memory serves, that it helps them find a foothold in a misogynistic and unfriendly environment, has negative relevance now. It's a test of pure skill that doesn't even need more physical effort than moving pieces on a board.
I go even further into the minority by advocating for almost all restrictions being removed from sports in general. Hell yeah, let's allow anabolic steroids and sketchy Russian PEDs, and as a Twitter wag once said, find out high humans can really jump. Olympic athletes are often mutants who are gifted, from birth, with better muscles and cardiovascular systems. I see no reason why they can get away with being blessed by the roll of the RNG while intentional attempts at self-improvement are verboten.
If I can't get that, sadly, then I demand that standards be applied fairly. Biological women should be disbarred from "Men's" sports, which are, almost always, open to anyone who cares to participate, not that it'll make any difference in practise.
Thanks for clarifying! I'll take your word for it, since I am modestly attached to my Discord account and don't desire to find out the hard way haha.
There's a lot of ruin compassion in a Nation, especially a wealthy and liberal one.
But not infinitely or indefinitely so. Eventually, even the bleeding hearts stop, if only because they exsanguinated.
For example, see how the sentiment has turned against Middle-Eastern immigrants in the Nordic states, from them once being misunderstood darlings to far more Right-wing and integrationist parties coming into vogue as a battered populace changes their mind.
The same is true for many YIMBYs and people-of-houselessness defenders, who get a rude wakeup call when the homeless are camping in their neighborhood parks, ruining their public transport, and clearly demonstrating that efforts to simply be nice to them by offering housing, shelter or safe drugs are far from sufficient to solve the problem, at least for the worst homeless who are either crazy or too addicted/drug-addled to respect carrots and not sticks.
Of course, this does require things to get worse, and people can be stupidly kind longer than your housing market or appetite for Hep-B can bear, but it can happen and is happening. I've seen plenty of outcry on Twitter from Californians outraged that what their politicians had wrung hands about as an unavoidable problem of the homeless ruining the place mysteriously vanished overnight when Xi Jinping visited. Huh. It seems the state capacity to handle homelessness exists all along, just a lack of will to use it.
While I don't endorse Accelerationism in general, since I'd much prefer finding a solution that isn't "let it all burn to the ground knowing it'll be built back better", I still think that the general ethos has a point, at least when it comes to shocking the complacent into noticing reality.
You know, being a mod and seeing the moderation queue makes me wonder how the previous ones didn't have a nervous breakdown from the sheer number of spurious and pointless reports.
This one caught one for "low-effort", and while a laconic dismissal isn't a robust rebuttal, in this case it's clearly obvious that you're disputing a load-bearing aspect of @guesswho 's claims, and both of you have discussed your concerns in more detail. Someone following up a string of high-effort comments with a low one will not be scolded for it.
To the person who reported this, come on, you lose the right to complain about being dogpiled and unfairly reported if you're going to engage in frivolous reporting yourself.
At the very least, I have personally done the same if without the mods at the time taking umbrage, and so have many others. So from precedent and enlightened self-interest, I don't see anything here worth complaining about.
While I didn't mention it in this particular comment, my own p(doom) has gone from a peak of 70% in 2021 to about 30% right now.
It seems to me that the attitude once held by Yudkowsky, that AGI would be almost inevitably misaligned and agentic by default, is not true, at least not for an AI I have no qualms about calling human-level when it comes to general intelligence. I think GPT-4 is smarter than the average human, with their 100 IQ, and while it is not superhuman in any specific field, it is a far better generalist polymath than any human alive. That should count for strong evidence that we're not in the Least Convenient Possible World, especially when considering recent advances in interpretability. The fact that RLHF even works would have astounded me 3 years back!
The remainder of the x-risk I foresee is both because I, like you, can't conclusively rule out either a phase transition when basic bitch transformers/LLMs are pushed way further, or what might happen if a new and less corrigible or interpretable SOTA technique and model emerged, plus my concern about the people using an "Aligned" ASI (aligned to who, whom?) in a manner not conducive to my interests or continued survival. And of course what happens when a highly competent and jailbroken model glibly informs a bioterrorist how to cook up Super-AIDS.
If I had to put very vague numbers on the relative contributions of all of them, I'd say there roughly equal, or 10% each. I've still gone from considering my death imminent this decade to merely gravely concerned, which doesn't really change the policies I advocate for.
Edit: There's also the risk, which I haven't seen any conclusive rebuttal of, from hostile Simulacra being instantiated within an LLM. https://gwern.net/fiction/clippy
I'd give that maybe a 1-5% risk of being a problem, eventually, but my error bars are wide enough as is.

A top-level post from a new account with 4 reports so far?
And all of them for being an "Actually A Quality Contribution?*
Worry not my friend, the waters are warm and congenial, just don't wonder about how much of it is piss. Certainly that's a remarkable entrance for a new account, and I'm doubly glad that it covers a pet topic of mine.
*Conflict of interest: One of the 4 AAQC reports was from me.
More options
Context Copy link