self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
The postulated tradeoffs of the Sexual Revolution, even if all the decline in reported happiness and increased suicide/depression are taken at face value and then attributed to it, are within what I'm willing to accept as a tax on my beliefs.
But what do I know? My country hasn't really had one, the norms around sex, dating and marriage in India are closer to 1950s America than they are to what's the case now or for the last half century or so. Still far more liberal than it used to be, it was nigh-Victorian in living memory.
I do not consider an increase in happiness necessary or sufficient by itself to justify any policy, even if it's obviously desirable. My preference for epistemic hygiene and clear thinking rules out any adoption of religion, and I don't deny that the religious are happier. If I was offered to be turned into a Lotus Eater or joy-wired, I would consider it a fate, if not worse than death, but close.
There’s not as much research as one would like, but from what I have found, the children of widowed mothers do not tend to differ much on outcomes from the children of biological, two-parent households, so “growing up without a father” doesn’t seem to be that important net of other factors.
Immense confounders ahoy! The genetics of the kids who are deprived of their dads because they died (accidentally or from illness) are going to be notably different from those who dads went to the corner store and never brought back the cigarettes (at least they avoided indoor smoking). Not to mention the poor taste/lack of judgment in their moms.
As far as I've read, single motherhood overall is terrible for the kids, probably even worse when you carve out the chunk who are single because of being widowed.
tl;dr Eugenics and explicit genetic tyranny all the way down.
Is that supposed to be a bad thing? (I know you consider that to be the case, this was a rhetorical question)
Modus ponens and modus tollens applies. I can answer each of those questions, I have internally satisfactory cutoffs (and I do not consider it a failing if they're not universally popular, merely saddening), and I am okay with arbitrary cutoffs, at least where a more principled cost-benefit analysis isn't worth it.
Someone born a meter away over the border from the US is a Mexican citizen, and nobody I know claims that they should be considered 50:50 each for that reason alone. Arbitrariness, while ideally avoided, is acceptable.
I will bite every bullet I must bite, and not one more or less (while lead poisoning is less of a concern, I wish to retain my teeth). You have no recourse to someone who does that, short of force of arms, and that's a symmetrical weapon and deprecated by civilized society for good reason.
I don't know about the US, but in the UK the surgery would not be done unless the parents wanted it to be, and there if anything the system would encourage the parents not to go ahead on the basis that people underestimate how hard it is to raise a severely disabled child.
The doctors involved have the outright ability to deny the parent's wishes here, if they consider it to be against the best interests of the child. This goes the other way too, they have the legal ability and duty to forcibly provide care in situations where the parents might vehemently disagree, if they think it's in the child's best interests.
Source: I've studied enough of UK medical ethics for my exams that I'm now more familiar with it than the laws in India.
I don't see what salience that really has to the value of a moral code.
There is no reason that a "perfect" moral code (not that I think that's even possible, I see no reason why morality isn't anything but subjectivity and the occasional illusion of objectivity where ~everyone ended up with similar stances, usually for strongly convergent evopsych reasons, such as even monkeys and dogs prizing fairness) should be instantiable by less than perfect humans.
All it has to do is be directionally better than the alternatives, even if nobody alive can claim to embody it perfectly. If you're a utilitarian, then imperfect utilitarianism beats everything else. If you're a vegan, tben occasionally being tempted into trying a burger beats not being vegan.
I do not think that his infidelity remotely outweighs any contribution he made to ideals (utilitarianism) by the first and second order effects from his promulgation of it.
He's not perfect. Nobody is, as far as I'm aware.
I fail to see much reason to care, and I'm not a utilitarian, and I wouldn't see any even if I was.
Affirmative Action? Sure, India Numba Wan 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Welfare? I don't really see that being the case. Both the quality and breadth of amenities available to many Western welfare states I can name, such as the UK, utterly dwarfs the kind of coverage an Indian can expect.
We have free public healthcare. It is not terrible, it manages to provide maybe 50% the care, if not the comfort, of say, the NHS. Medicine, in both senses of the word, has strong power laws. The easy and cheap (free) availability of say, the WHO's top 100 list of essential medications means maybe 90% of patients presenting with a disease can get curative treatment.
But healthcare isn't the only part of a welfare state. There's housing, and India doesn't have anything like free/extremely subsidized public housing, along the lines of council flats and so on.
Food? Well, if you really like rice and lentils. You might even stave off most of the obvious nutritional deficiencies.
The welfare system in India is, of necessity, the bare minimum needed to ensure nobody starves to death or dies without at least one disinterested, overworked and underequipped doctor laying hands on them. Maybe you get cheap electricity and water. Subsidized public transport. Education, and quality at that once you're past high school, IITs and AIIMS (or most government run medical colleges) are far more prestigious than their private, for-profit counterparts.
I can't think of any aspect that makes the welfare state here more all-encompassing, and not just in terms of how much it can offer the average person. Western welfare states almost all offer better and more.
In the spirit of honesty, I owe @guesswho an apology.
In the comment I made, mod hat on, to his questioning of whether he would receive the same degree of careful consideration and explanation I extended to Astragant when I (lightly) modded him, I was referring to a comment I believed he had made, which I had ignored after it was reported in the mod queue, and then found it gone when I went back to check.
Turns out, it was one made by @Goodguy
https://www.themotte.org/post/812/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/175876?context=8#context
(As @netstack managed to hunt down later.)
That is an example of what I think counts as a comment that is mildly uncharitable or inflammatory, but charity is not an infinite resource, and sometimes an accurate description of reality can be less than so, so I, and the other mods who opted to discuss it, didn't find it worth modding.
I do stand by the rest of my statement, but I am informed that Zorba decided that the transition off-site should constitute a clean slate for everyone, be they popular or unpopular on the subreddit, and I will adjust accordingly. I don't think that particularly changes anything, given how long it's been, anyone hanged has had plenty of opportunity to lay the rope anew, but I do feel like you've been unfairly maligned and reflexively downvoted. Sadly, this is not a crime or easily fixable by the mods, though I disapprove of anyone who acts that way. It might be some consolation that I noticed I upvote maybe like 25% of your posts (the ones I see), and can't spot any downvotes.
So consider yourself to be in not quite as precarious a position as I implied, and my bad. The veil of ignorance is a nuisance to drape over my eyes, but the thing about social fiction is that they can become social fact if you try hard enough.
(Maybe make an alt and don't announce yourself next time, I think you'll find a more receptive audience, I think you've accumulated more haters than you're really due.)
- Get into psychiatry training, or sit the USMLE
- Take my ADHD meds (for certain values of *successful')
I disagree that quality doesn't correspond with upvotes. Both from personal experience, and looking around at what gets upvoted in general.
it always seems to me like this forum accepts pretty antagonistic stances as long as the targets are correct, and applies a lot more scrutiny if the table gets flipped
The mods don't control the users, anyone can upvote and downvote as they please, and we're not like Reddit where you can get into trouble for upvoting Crimethink. But in terms of our own behavior, I do not see any significant or notable bias in what gets through or is condoned by the mods, and my existence as a humble user has been far longer than my odd week as a mod. We also make allowances for a good regular user who has an off-day, things that might get a new user banned for good might get merely a warning. Or at least a shorter ban.
If your opinions are unpopular, well, that sucks, but it's not a problem to be fixed, at least until the people reacting negatively also violate the rules in their responses.
Anyway, if you do see reported posts form me that you find ' antagonistic and uncharitable to your opponents, but within the limit of what I'm willing to tolerate', I would love to get a similar 'request and mild warning' and detailed explanation like you did for Astra here. That would help me a lot to understand what people are reacting to and expecting, before it blows up into something more serious.
I'll keep that in mind for minor violations, but as you must be well aware, the specific example of snapping and calling Right-leaning people Nazis (unless they are obviously and outspoken right-wing Wignats who advocate for discrimination against the usual targets of the original Nazis), is not acceptable behavior. For anything else, where you don't seem to be obviously trying to push buttons or stick to just the right side of the tracks, I'll try and point out what you can do better.
But of course, just because something is being reported doesn't mean the mods take action, and you are better off asking the people who disagree with you, I can't really speak for everyone who downvotes. And if the mods do take action, we usually make it a point in the first place to explain our reasoning. If Astragant had been reported but I considered his comment and pattern of behavior acceptable, I wouldn't have warned him in the first place, or explained anything outside my usual remit as a user.
Ozempic? It works great, both for weight loss and more surprising applications like treating addictions and impulsive behaviors. They haven't even discovered any real adverse effects, barring loss of muscle mass with the fat (as is the case for most rapid weight loss techniques, including dieting or fasting), and believe me there are plenty of attempts to find a reason it can't just be taken at face value, or must be "too good to be true".
The only knock against it I can muster is that it's still expensive, but it'll get cheaper, there are other drugs in the same category that work even better, and eventually it'll become a generic or commodity alternatives will show up.
I don't think the Fat Acceptance movement ever gained widespread momentum, ahem, but it's going to die out from its adherents ending up sheepishly not fat, or the worst of them will literally die.
(Mixed rant / actual CW post. I defer to the Delphic wisdom of the mods to discern this)
Well, I'm first on call tonight, before being on-call for my day job at the hospital later haha. I think this is a good top-level submission. It has plenty of discussion about a relevant topic, so that alone clears the modest bar where we don't want bare-links without added commentary (a decision I mildly disagree with myself, but if the other, more experienced mods are content with it, I'm not inclined to argue).
I have more I'd like to discuss about your comment, but not in my role as a mod, so for now, I encourage you to make this post, and then more just like it!
All of those demonstrate correlation and not causation, but thank you for tracking them down. Certainly I don't care at all if their parents disapprove of them consuming porn, as one of the concerns quoted.
Here's an example of what I recall from Psychology Today
https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/talking-apes/202104/does-porn-use-lead-sexual-violence
And:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1359178909000445
The effects of pornography, whether violent or non-violent, on sexual aggression have been debated for decades. The current review examines evidence about the influence of pornography on sexual aggression in correlational and experimental studies and in real world violent crime data. Evidence for a causal relationship between exposure to pornography and sexual aggression is slim and may, at certain times, have been exaggerated by politicians, pressure groups and some social scientists. Some of the debate has focused on violent pornography, but evidence of any negative effects is inconsistent, and violent pornography is comparatively rare in the real world. Victimization rates for rape in the United States demonstrate an inverse relationship between pornography consumption and rape rates. Data from other nations have suggested similar relationships. Although these data cannot be used to determine that pornography has a cathartic effect on rape behavior, combined with the weak evidence in support of negative causal hypotheses from the scientific literature, it is concluded that it is time to discard the hypothesis that pornography contributes to increased sexual assault behavior.
Emphasis added.
Thanks for tracking that down!
Harm to the diversity of his writing? Sure. Material harm to him, be it financially or through social ostracism? Quite the opposite.
It's funny you should say that, Darwin (did I guess right?). A comment made by you ended up in the mod queue, and I elected to ignore it, and when I checked again, it was gone, indicating another mod has dismissed it. As I've elaborated upon above, I did find it antagonistic and uncharitable to your opponents, but within the limit of what I'm willing to tolerate without comment, at least once in a while.
You happen to have the dubious distinction of being so frequently downvoted that I and the other mods usually need to manually approve your comments, as I did for this one.
I am also aware, from reputation, if not personal interaction with you, that you have a tendency to toe the line and make comments that just barely avoid the point where we need to take mod action. That was the case from well before we move offsite. As our moderation guidelines make clear, we have the discretion of taking action even if no individual aspect of a comment is obviously bad, if the total is, especially when it's representative of a wider pattern.
Thus, you can interpret our/my seeming inaction as a form of action in itself. Try not to flame out or resort to name-calling, if you can avoid it, but until then I am more of a cautious observer. As usual, it is far superior to report antagonistic comments than to join the fun, though we definitely make allowances for provocation.
I have never heard of Traveler's flu before, and as far as Google tells me, there's no clinically recognized condition by that name.
The closest I can find is this publication:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5505480/
Methods: We conducted a PUBMED/MEDLINE search for a combination of the MeSH terms Influenza virus, travel, mass gathering, large scale events and cruise ship. In addition we gathered guidelines and recommendations from selected countries and regarding influenza prevention and management in travellers. By reviewing these search results in the light of published knowledge in the fields of influenza prevention and management, we present best practice advice for the prevention and management of influenza in travel medicine.
Results: Seasonal influenza is among the most prevalent infectious diseases in travellers. Known host-associated risk factors include extremes of age and being immune-compromised, while the most relevant environmental factors are associated with holiday cruises and mass gatherings.
I don't think this has much to do with traveling to a new place as much as it does with being crammed in tight spaces with poor ventilation with hundreds of others.
Similarly, if you travel to a new country during the flu season, you're at increased risk of catching it, but so are the locals. I am not aware of any literature claiming that new immigrants are at additional risk of catching flu and similar diseases, relative to the native population.
Masks vary greatly in terms of effectiveness, both from the specific type in question and proper use and adherence. But for a typical adult who begins masking in public, I do not expect that the the decreased exposure to pathogens will significantly impact their susceptibility to novel strains. In the case of the common cold or the flu, prior infection to a previous strain isn't protective for the next one that does the rounds, which is why flu vaccines are refreshed annual (and designed pre-emptively, based on models of what the next strain might be).
If someone masked and avoided the flu, for say, 2 years, I strongly doubt they are at any additional risk if they stop masking or catch the next one despite masking.
This is a different consideration from children, since I know that atopy is associated with insufficient exposure to a diverse array of microbes in childhood. Everything from peanut allergies to asthma can be mitigated by exposing them early and often. But for an adult, I do not expect it to make a difference.
Mind you, I don't disagree that wearing masks is largely pointless. Unless you're immunocompromised or are working with people who are, they are unlikely to help, unless maybe if you wear an N-95 on the plane and so on. What I disagree with is that they are meaningfully harmful on net to an average adult, which is a different question entirely from whether they provide benefits.
There are places, like China and Japan, where masking in public was common before the pandemic, and I have seen no claims that makes them more susceptible overall to respiratory illness when they do get it.
I do not expect that masking or isolation, even taken to an extreme, will cause any notable negative health effects due to your immune system getting "out of sync".
That might apply if you were being raised in a clean-room since birth, but as far as I'm aware, in situations such as an immigrant from the Global South going to the West, you don't see them suddenly falling sick because of all the novel pathogens circulating in a country several continents away. International travel at that range is not so common that I expect everything to become homogeneous when it comes to the short-scale evolution of pathogenic microbes. Note I am not claiming the opposite, it is both true and a trope that Western visitors to the Global South often catch stomach bugs because of exposure to pathogens that the locals are inured to, but that's more a factor of said pathogens being more common, be it because they flourish in tropical regions, or because of lax standards in food safety or water treatment.
I do not expect wearing a mask in public for even years on end to change anything, our innate immunity does a lot of the heavy lifting, the adaptive component, while not negligible, is hardly sufficient, as anyone going through flu season can tell you. We are also vaccinated for the worst diseases, and I'd expect maskers to be even more fastidious about getting their shots.
Uncontacted tribes do have differences in innate immunity. You can literally trace historical population exposure to diseases like the Bubonic Plague, Smallpox or Malaria through genetic adaptations. But someone in civilized society fastidious about masking is never going to be as vulnerable as them, once again unless they were raised in a clean room from birth. If there is a negative effect, it's too trivial to worry about.
Leaving aside the arguments against it you've already mentioned, I am utterly unconvinced that seeing porn is "bad" for kids. The majority of studies on the longterm effects on pornography showed just about zilch in terms of effect, be it on sexual violence or anything else. The fact that conservatives consider it "obvious" is of little consequence to me here. The entire debacle seems to be far more concerned with arguments from moral purity rather than concrete harm, and I have an exceedingly dim opinion of those. Parents who want their kids to not watch porn should invest in parental controls, not a nanny-state, not that either will really work.
Well, at least it might make the little tykes more tech-savvy, at least they'll learn to use VPNs or even just torrent videos. Or else they might just learn to develop a vivid imagination, you don't need porn to jerk it, don't ask me how I happen to know that. I'll pour one out for the poor aphantasics.
I wager it's more because he prizes staying in the good graces of his immediate social circle, if memory serves, the dude who happened to date (marry?) his non-binary ex Ozzy leaked private emails from Scott where he acknowledges his surreptitious belief in HBD, which is an unpopular stance to hold in the EA community (and partially taboo in Rat circles like LW). This would be obvious to anyone who read his OG blog, before SSC, covering his trip to provide medical aid to Haiti.
This isn't to deny that he probably didn't like the controversy from the NYT exposé, but from a more detached perspective, it didn't really do him any harm and a lot of good. He garnered a great deal of sympathy, even from his opponents, and his Substack made >250k annually shortly after he opened it. That is already median wage for a US doctor, and at this point I expect it's long eclipsed his regular income.
And he wasn't really susceptible to cancelation in the sense of being sacked and left unemployed, it takes quite a bit to do that to a doctor, and short of being struck off the register for gross malpractice, they have the option of doing private consultation or heading to places with good salaries but more flexible standards in who they hire.
Another reason I hold that opinion is because he still criticizes what might well be called essential elements of the PTB, such as calling for the FDA to be, if not delenda est, significantly reformed.
The only thing that could make it better is if you broke out to do a Bollywood dance number to express the true depths of you pain (can AI do that yet?)
It's certainly a better dancer than I am, I can only be coaxed into a shuffle with a few drinks on me.
And thank you, we've certainly had our differences in the past, so I'm glad that when I put on the badge and try to be an idealized version of myself, I haven't obviously fucked it up on the first go!
The moderator cries out in pain as he strikes you
(I find modding comments I personally agree with but consider against the rules or not conducive to the health of the forum painful, but I wouldn't have accepted the nomination if I didn't think I could put duty first)
Paradoxically, it's that this is a mild violation (I wouldn't call it simply borderline) that I felt compelled to justify my statement. If it was glaringly ban-worthy, I'd swing the hammer with only mild regret.
In fact, I am more annoyed by the fact that he's compelled me to act against a comment I endorse, much like a 50's Sheriff shaking his head as he drags a KKK member he's had drinks with off to a cell. But The Motte is, as far as I'm aware, one of a kind, and if that's necessary to keep it the kind of place that drew me here 5 years ago, then I will put my disquiet aside and do as I must.
I am proud that my tenure here earned the endorsement of the people who voted for me, and then the approval of the previous mods, and I don't want to tarnish their faith in me. As for those who didn't vote for me, I can only hope to gain their retroactive endorsement through my actions. This forum isn't a democracy, but if the mods don't act in a manner that the users approve of, well, we'll eventually end up as the sole suzerains of a drinking club and an entirely unjustified AWS bill.
Sigh. It seems it was inevitable that I'd have to get around to doing the unpleasant part of being a mod at some point, namely enforcing the rules and using my discretion in ambiguous situations. But I did sign up for it.
Please consider this a request, and a mild warning, not to speak this way.
So far, your comment has received 3 reports for being antagonistic, which it clearly seems to be to me. To an extent, antagonism is a forgivable sin, and I certainly plead guilty to being less than maximally polite on occasion.
However, what does draw my attention is that this, to me, represents an example of "waging the Culture War". There's no strict line in the sand here, the people discussing CW in the CW thread are almost always at least modest opinionated on the matter, and advocacy for one's beliefs is in no way disbarred.
I don't even particularly care that you call them trannies, I'm not one to police vocabulary where the word is entirely synonymous with more polite equivalents, even if it's pejorative. If someone insisted on calling Jews "Blood-drinking vampires", then I'd consider that to be an obvious infraction. Some of the other mods may well disagree, but I'm only me, and I have a degree of leeway here.
It might surprise you to learn that I happen to largely agree with you. I consider transgenderism, if not an outright mental illness in the strictest sense, to be highly comorbid with it. I wouldn't balk at calling many of them insane like you did. I have a soft spot for Kiwi Farms, Rdrama and the other untamed corners of the internet, and I'm glad they live to fight another day in an increasingly homogenous internet where the edges are sanded down and a relatively small but vocal minority tyrannizes the rest of us and slides the French Overton Window as fast as the rails allow.
That being said, I would prefer you be less antagonistic. You are allowed to be happy that attempts to deplatform a site that makes fun of transgender people backfire. You may enjoy schadenfreude. You may, assuming the rest of your comment doesn't continue to not contribute to the atmosphere/culture we seek to cultivate here, also call people trannies (or at least I won't mod you for that reason alone).
But the gestalt impression conveyed by your comment? Bad. Not conducive to the (ideal) spirit of even-tempered discussion of contentious topics. The problem with culture war fervor, schadenfreude, and pithy pejorative labels for the outgroup is that they tend to crowd out everything else, or at least foster a negative spiral if left unaddressed that leads to everyone else doing the same, and those looking for more polite and high quality debate crinkling their nose and leaving. We aren't rdrama, this is what we are trying to avoid here, and by including all three and not much else, this comment is not helping.
I'll leave it at that, it would take a trivial restatement of your comment to make it slip under the high threshold I hold for formal mod action, if not a reprimand. If you wish to consider this an attempt at censorship (and how can mod action not be?), then it's of tone and not content.
What does it matter? Fighter pilots, if not drone operators, are stereotypical "hard men", and it certainly seems that the countries experiencing "good times" have an abundance of them.
Besides, there were SF sent into the region, who are undeniably so.
The fact that technology and state capacity matters more than how fierce and militaristic your average goon is, should count as another knock against Good Times, Weak Men.
I appreciate the sources.
Addressing the letter to JAMA that you linked:
There is evidence from several sources, recently collated by the Neuro-Research Foundation, that brain dysfunction related to a focal lesion plays a significant role in the violent and assaultive behavior of thoroughly studied patients.1'4 In¬ dividuals with electroencephalo¬ graphic abnormalities in the tem¬ poral region have been found to have a much greater frequency of behav¬ ioral abnormalities (such as poor impulse control, assaultiveness and psychosis) than is present in peo¬ ple with a normal brain wave pat¬ tern.' On the other hand, French and South African reports disclosed that persons arrested for murder had six to nine times the frequency of ab¬ normal brain waves as occur in the population at large.8'7 Delinquent psychopaths tested in a medical cen¬ ter for federal prisoners in the Unit¬ ed States had an almost equally high frequency of abnormal brain wave patterns.8 Stafford-Clark and Taylor9 divided 64 English priso¬ ners accused of murder into five cat¬ egories. They found only one of 11 prisoners guilty of killing in self- defense, or in the commission of an¬ other crime, with an abnormal brain wave. Four out of 16 murderers with a clear homicidal motive had elec¬ troencephalographic abnormalities, but an abnormal pattern was pres¬ ent in 11 of 15 prisoners who did not have a motive for committing murder. It would be of more than passing interest to find what per¬ centage of the attempted and com¬ pleted murders committed during the recent wave of riots were done without a motive. Finally, it is an unjustified dis¬ tortion to conclude that the urban rioter has a monopoly on violence. It pervades every social, ethnic, and racial stratum of our society. The real lesson of the urban rioting is that, besides the need to study the social fabric that creates the riot at¬ mosphere, we need intensive re¬ search and clinical studies of the in¬ dividuals committing the violence. The goal of such studies would be to pinpoint, diagnose, and treat those people with low violence thres¬ holds before they contribute to fur¬ ther tragedies.
Emphasis added. The letter was written in the context of sweeping race riots, but I do not see anything suggesting racist/discriminatory intent on the part of the authors. They specialize in neurological correlates to violence, there's an epidemic of ongoing violence, and they're urging further research into the topic and treatment of those who have predilections to indulge in it.
The identification of violent/anti-social individuals is still a routine matter in psychiatry, though the matter only extends to formal diagnosis of Anti-social Personality Disorder, which doesn't have any treatment. Consider it a more formal way of saying, yeah, this dude's an asshole.
There's nothing singling out black people, or suggesting they're uniquely prone to violence, the race riots were simply the most salient example.
Regarding the other evidence you've shared, I don't consider it particularly damning. If you wish to study violence, especially the aetiology, then you want to conduct your research in an area with a high amount of violence. Would you deny that high schools with majority black/hispanic students wouldn't on average be more violent? That's a factually true statement. Fund raising before Congress to make the most of a (quite relevant) Current Thing? Who wouldn't?
On the use of a military base:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Nike
As the sites were decommissioned they were first offered to federal agencies. Many were already on Army National Guard bases who continued to use the property. Others were offered to state and local governments while others were sold to school districts. The left-overs were offered to private individuals. Thus, many Nike sites are now municipal yards, communications and FAA facilities (the IFC areas), probation camps, and even renovated for use as Airsoft gaming and MilSim training complexes. Several were obliterated and turned into parks. Some are now private residences.
The Army was handing out now useless Nike silos, which were snapped up by everyone from schools to airsoft players. This is because they were moving out, not offering a timeshare program!
This isn't some kind of top-secret blacksite for MKULTRA redux, there was property being handed out to whoever asked, and if I was to organize a program that involves isolating violent patients (likely against their will), then "remote" and "secure" sounds like excellent ideas, regardless of what I do with them.
Well, you're the doctor, and no offense to neurosurgeons (they actually seem to try to do it right, as far a I can tell), but I was under the impression that they absolute pussies compared to psychosurgeons. Don't they go on and on about how dangerous it is, and how it's a last resort?
I have met plenty of psycho surgeons, no psychosurgeons, so I have no opinion on their personality and habits. They don't market themselves as such anyway, they call themselves neurosurgeons.
Sure, it wasn't shut down completely, but you said yourself the time period in question was the point of it's decline. The paper you linked to seems to confirm it.
Because it was obsolete, not because it was controversial (not by 2007, at the least). For a perfectly benign example, open cholecystectomies have long been replaced by laparoscopic cholecystectomies. They were never controversial. In the odd case where the destruction of a small portion of the brain is needed, we zap it with radiation, and that's a procedure that happens every day in my hospital, even if it's more for tumors than violence.
I find no conclusion to the case of Kille after looking, it seems the negative PR, especially after the association with Terminal Man came out, was sufficient to derail the psychosurgery division there. He was hardly the only patient, and others presented as case studies did much better. If you manage to find the outcome of the lawsuit, I'd be curious to see it.

I do not interpret this as her suggesting something as stupid as claiming razer cuts on the wrist as evidence of parental abuse. I would imagine it's something like giving yourself a black eye or the odd bruise, which is both easy to do, and practically impossible to conclusively dismiss as fabricated.
As both a general practice doctor or a psychiatrist, I would almost never dismiss such evidence out of hand as a lie (and it almost never is). If you really want to get your parents in deep shit, that is easy enough. It would take a lot of inconsistency and other subtle tells before anyone would start getting suspicious.
Which is not the same as me claiming this is a good idea, but it is not as retarded as you think it sounds.
More options
Context Copy link