self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
Granted this is a bit of a clash of fundamental worldviews. I too used to believe that the world was a giant chaotic Brownian motion mess of stuff happening, the media reporting on it in a way that follows their self-interest ("they do it for the clicks!") and historians dutifully reporting on the more notable cases. The problem is that various recent events have completely discredited that theory in my eyes. We know for a fact the media do not report on things that are too embarrassing to the establishment, even if they could make a ton of money this way, and historians pick and chose what is "notable" to their hearts content.
What's with the "I too"? You're sorely mistaken if you think I'm a quokka who is happy to take everything at face value. I'm merely positing that you are being excessively suspicious of an entirely benign fact, or at least an unremarkable footnote in history.
I have no idea who Leonard Khile is, and what he has to do with anything, and a Google search turns up literally zero results.
Do me a favor and spell out how exactly you can claim:
If you read the Time magazine article, you'll see doctors Sweet, Mark, and Ervin were planning to deploy psychosurgery as a cure against the race riots of the 60's.
As for-
"Racial violence" should not be in quotes since it's not a term I used in my post, nor did I say they were part of a group studying it
The quotes are a literal quote from the article you previously shared. I am pointing out that they had no involvement with anything beyond being practitioners of psychosurgery, who a reporter thought might be offering advice in the future to a Presidential Commission. No evidence of whether they did so, or what they might have said, and fuck all in terms of any effect.
They did explicitly argue that abnormalities in the brain are an overlooked factor driving the violent behavior during the race riots
They did not make that specific claim. The closest thing they claimed was that they had found a correlation between violence in general and brain abnormalities. That is a far more general and unobjectionable proposal.
maybe they were honest scientists being careful about how far they will go with their claims, maybe it was a fig-leaf to cover up what they really wanted to do (I think at the end of the whole affair, when they were planning to ramp up their operations, they wanted to open more centers explicitly targeting minorities, but it blew up in their faces), or maybe they were just using a Current Thing as a marketing tool to get grants
Knowing the average scientist, far more likely to be the latter, and I invite you to demonstrate any evidence of more nefarious intent. What makes you think they were planning to "open more centers explicitly targeting minorities?" Citation?
In the end it doesn't matter, because my point is that while we live in an era where every historical wrong against black people is dug out, and every type of "disparate impact" is considered a wrong, social justice activists seem oddly quiet on this one.
They are not "oddly quiet" about a tiny group of doctors who have never been demonstrated to have used their niche neurosurgical techniques for malign ends. They are precisely the expected level of quiet.
That abstract seems entirely consistent with the amount of psychosurgeries dramatically dropping as a result of the controversy we're discussing, so my point is that it's weird that the controversy itself is allowed to be forgotten (and that this is likely deliberate)
Hardly. I can assure you that neurosurgery as a field is doing fine, and psychosurgery, in the particular sense where you're trying to solve behavioral issues, still exists.
It's niche, and has been for half a century, but mostly because we have less invasive therapies and non-surgical ways of affecting targeted parts of the brain. The "controversy" ceased to be a meaningful factor in the 50s and onwards, it's worthless today. There are plenty of rare, but well-established surgeries that are done maybe a dozen times a year in superspeciality hospitals where the last research paper of note was decades back. That does not make them discredited or controversial, that shows that they're niche and mundane. Stereotactic amygdalatomies are arguably obsolete, since targeted radio-frequency ablation does the same job and better.
If you want to eat nothingburgers and exist in an excess of paranoia, feel free to do so. The optimal amount of suspicion is not zero, but in your case, you have failed to make a convincing case why anyone should care. Certainly not showing it's been memory-holed in a suspicious manner.
Levocetirizine is a non-sedating one that causes minimal cognitive effects, I'd recommend it. The paper I linked has examples of some others that couldn't be disentangled from placebo, so hopefully you find one that works for you.
Or you could go for a topical preparation? That should have fewer cognitive side effects.
That's not a particularly convincing statement, one of the benefits of "good times, hard men" is how vaguely it can be interpreted. The Japanese and Germans during WW2 suffered far harder times than the US did, what with their soldiers getting ships full of ice cream while the former were eating their shoes. The Soviets suffered plenty of "hard times", and even they gave up on fighting a mountain insurgency. The Chechens prided themselves on being "hard men" and even they got their cheeks clapped later when the Russians swallowed losses.
It is a largely useless and outright misleading frame to view the world in, even if there are examples of moral "weakness" (or at least a lack of appetite for brutality) causing defeat. And that's not even the definition of weak being used in every context, another benefit of how vague the term is in the English language is that it lets people accidentally or intentionally conflate two very separate things, cowardice and military weakness. The US managed to clap ISIS despite the latter being even more rabid than the Taliban.
The Romans famously gave up on Germania after disastrous losses at Teutoburg and well before anyone could plausibly call them weak/decadent.
You said safest, not the most effective, so I'm going to go with a glass of cold milk haha.
Truth be told, there isn't much in the way of good, almost perfectly safe choices, at least in OTC drugs that I'm aware of, and availability might well be in different in the States from what I'm used to. I could vaguely recommend l-theanine as a highly safe anxiolytic, even if it's not a sedative. Melatonin is highly dubious in terms of usefulness. But if you want to be knocked the fuck out, older antihistamines are your friend.
I don't have a particularly strong opinion on doxylamine beyond my theoretical knowledge, it's not the antihistamine used regularly where I hail from, but used in moderation? Doesn't seem all that bad. But it will almost certainly have the cognitive effects I mentioned above.
Yes. The sad thing about the majority of pharmaceuticals in use today is that they're blunt instruments, hammers substituted for scalpels. Histamine, while we're mostly accustomed to encountering its effects from annoyances like hives or allergies, also functions as a neurotransmitter in the brain. It happens to modulate arousal and awakening in the brain, which is why sedation is/was a common side effect of antihistamines (more so in the older ones).
In a recent comparative trial, subjects who were treated with the first-generation agent diphenhydramine were found to have significant performance deficits on tests of divided attention, working memory, vigilance, and speed. By contrast, subjects who were treated with the second-generation antihistamine loratadine performed as well as subjects who were treated with placebo. The sedative effects of the first-generation agents persist well into the next day and thus can potentially interfere with daytime performance and safety even when taken the night before. It is therefore recommended that patients whose occupations require vigilance, divided attention, or concentration receive only second-generation antihistamines.
The second-generation antihistamines are classified as "non-sedating", which is more or less correct, even if a few of them do have mild sedative effect, at least they're much better in that regard than the OGs. Keep in mind you're not thinking your best when you've got a reason to take them, such as during allergies or a cold.
I don't see any suggestion that the effect persists indefinitely, at least not for acute use at recommended doses, and you can avoid the worst of it by getting the better ones from the non-sedating class.
I can see that, but I'm sure it won't surprise you in the least that I have a jaundiced opinion of the "noble savage" trope as a whole, in whatever incarnation I encounter it.
So assuming psychosurgery was indeed a decently-sized issue, could it just disappear into the mists of history? I asked that very question and the consensus response seems to have been “yes, definitely!”. Your theory on that may differ from mine, but I ended coming to the conclusion that memory of such events needs to be actively maintained or it will fade. We remember things that are useful for people writing history books (or the ones who employ them) and forget the others, so while a similarly sized scandal like the Tuskagee experiment has a certain “Never Again” quality to it, others, like psychosurgery will fall by the wayside. And before you bring it up - no, this is not due to the affected demographics, which are largely the same. If you read the Time magazine article, you'll see doctors Sweet, Mark, and Ervin were planning to deploy psychosurgery as a cure against the race riots of the 60's.
Well, I agree with the "yes, definitely!" crowd.
One recurring question I had when watching the documentary was “how the hell did I not hear about tthis”? It's not like I'm an expert, but this is the sort of stuff that felt like it should pop up along the way in my areas of interest. I heard about the Rosenhan experiment, I heard about the Stanford prison experiment, the Milgram experiment, even the 30-50's era lobotomies, why not the late 60's to early 70's era of psychosurgery?
Ten Thousand seems to me a far more plausible explanation of your previous ignorance than any attempt at intentional memory-holing.
The kinds of psychosurgery you're concerned about, namely in the 60s and 70s, was the period of terminal decline of the practise as more targeted therapies such as radio-ablation were developed, as well as better drugs. There's not even much in the way of a meaningful distinction to be made between "lobotomies" and "psychosurgery" as you see it, lobotomies are an example of the latter, and when they went out of fashion, so did the rest of it.
Back when I bothered to visit the default subs, in the usual subs like TIL and the like, I certainly saw plenty of discussion of the overall practise of psychosurgery, since lobotomies count. Primarily addressing the most photogenic example, Rosemary Kennedy.
Here's an example from last year:
There's no "memory-holing" when there's hardly any memory to be holed in the first place.
And before you bring it up - no, this is not due to the affected demographics, which are largely the same. If you read the Time magazine article, you'll see doctors Sweet, Mark, and Ervin were planning to deploy psychosurgery as a cure against the race riots of the 60's.
And they didn't get to do it, did they? As far as I can tell, the only people Mark and Ervin subjected to amygdalotomies were a handful of aggressive patients with temporal lobe epilepsy.
I'd like to see any evidence that they had the power to "deploy psychosurgery" against the rioters before I particularly care what they idly dreamed about, or submitted suggestions for that were never implemented.
Hell, after reading through the primary source in your link from a year ago, I see no mention of any proposal by either of them to:
you'll see doctors Sweet, Mark, and Ervin were planning to deploy psychosurgery as a cure against the race riots of the 60's.
Here's a screenshot of the relevant paragraph, and it absolutely does not say what you claim it says:
They were a research team that were considered, according to the reporter, to be high quality correspondents with the Commission on Violence established by the President of the time. They had no higher authority, they were not part of the group studying "racial violence", and the article specifically mentions that they were more concerned with studying individual causes of violence and their neuro-physical origins, which is about the same kind of venomous accusation one can level against the odd researcher today who tries and fails to demonstrate that videogames/rap/movies cause violence.
And before you bring it up - no, this is not due to the affected demographics, which are largely the same
The targets of amygdalatomy were a very distinct demographic from the more laissez-faire approach from when frontal lobotomies were in vogue. In fact, they're still done today, or at least of 2007:
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17228178/
Nobody cares about the rare examples done in the 60s or 70s for the same reason nobody particularly cares about them today.
https://acoup.blog/2020/02/21/collections-the-fremen-mirage-interlude-ways-of-the-fremen/
There's an additional interlude which delves further into his opinions on how much Dune it's succumbs to the "Fremen Mirage".
Note that I never claimed that Devereaux considered the Fremen "bad", merely unrealistic, and a propagator of bad tropes into even relatively sophisticated audiences. I'm using his arguments to justify my dislike of them, and my primary rebuttal is to your claim that nobody other than me happens to care about the matter. Like I said, I have seen people bring it up as a criticism of Dune organically, hell I could pull up screenshots of a discussion a few days ago on the ACX discord.
Suffice to say that n>1 people care, and at least I have plenty of reason to find Dune not particularly worthy of its current high regard as a work of classic science fiction.
The Fremen don't make sense even in context. That is the objection that both I and Devereaux happen to have. The blog has shed enough ink on the topic that I don't feel the need to recapitulate any of it again.
I have a nuclear engineer in my distant family (and I cry every time I compare his salary to mine), so by the transitive property I am about 12.5% qualified to comment on this haha. (And I do try and keep up with nuclear power)
To an extent, the US does indirectly assist other countries in getting domestic nuclear power up and running. If you're a talented engineer from an allied or at least neutral country, you have every chance to study under the best in the States and then bring your knowhow back home, assuming you don't get hooked and settle down right there. You're then a prize for any competent government you hail from, that seeks to establish their own nuclear power plants. Of course, many countries, like Russia, China, India and so on, independently began their own power/weapon programs, because of some degree of hostility from the States (and the Soviets drank directly from the source).
I emphasize competent, most countries that strongly desire nuclear power have programs up and running, and many who would love to have nuclear power either lack state capacity or are untrustworthy/volatile.
If the US decided to operate nuclear plants in such nations, well, for one, the latter would be effectively ceding a great deal of sovereignty, I do not foresee the State Department being happy in the least to operate a plant that isn't secured by US forces, and with strict vetting and control over who works there. It would work closer to a military base rather than say, an embassy, and also prove to be a liability in case of the kind of volatility that many potential hosts suffer from.
Then there's also the usual slowdown or red tape from environmental lobbyists, which is bad enough for nuclear power in the States.
This is not to say that this isn't a good idea, it is, as far as I'm concerned. Sadly not every good idea gets pursued, and the US has enough trouble just keeping their own domestic nuclear from going under. Plus with how cheap renewables have gotten, you might as well just ship them solar panels and batteries, with much less in the way of domestic or international opposition, or the inconvenient considerations about what to do when a state falls to a coup, a revolution, or simply turns hostile.
I think the most elegant solution would be something along the lines of running a thick power cable from a nuclear-powered ship, along the lines of an aircraft carrier. You isolate yourself from a great deal of the troubles on land, and have the option to cut and run at a moment's notice if needed. Presumably existing aircraft carriers have other things to be doing, but the Navy are the experts when it comes to modular, reliable and most importantly portable nuclear power, and have been so for decades. China is currently exploring nuclear-powered cargo ships, likely both because it's a sensible idea in itself, and because they want to minimize reliance on oil in case Taiwan goes hot. Such a ship, with some modifications, would probably be a great design for nuclear power on tap.
Nobody cares (well, apparently except you) if the Fremen are realistic
Sorry dawg, Brett Devereaux apparently does, and I've seen this particular piece of work crop up both on the Motte, as a definitive rebuttal to the "Weak times, weak men" hypothesis that so many are fond of, and in the wild elsewhere, that I can be confident there's a significant number of people who find the Fremen-wank grating.
And they're far from the worst elements in the novel, credit for being first only goes so far. So sure, I "give credit" to Dune, if you so desire, which doesn't negate my stance that I think it's a mediocre book with questionable worldbuilding, queer plotting, 1D characters, and enough fetish material to make an accurate adaptation to the big screen something you should book your popcorn for well in advance.
I really don't understand the praise for Dune's worldbuilding. The Fremen are ridiculous/retarded:
https://acoup.blog/2020/01/17/collections-the-fremen-mirage-part-i-war-at-the-dawn-of-civilization/
And as for the rest of it, Warhammer 40k rips it off and does it all better. I will not apologize for the sheer spice in that take.
It's a tossup between Connecticut Yankee and Huckleberry Finn, both are S-tier as far as I'm concerned.
I thought Dune was grossly overrated. Somewhere between boring, nonsensical, and up its own ass.
It's not even that thing where a book that established foundational tropes that are explored by subsequent works seems staid and boring in comparison, I can name plenty of older books that still hold up with the best available today, and feel just as fresh as when they were written, such as anything by Mark Twain.
And don't get me started on the fucking Fremen, at least ACOUP has me covered:
https://acoup.blog/2020/01/17/collections-the-fremen-mirage-part-i-war-at-the-dawn-of-civilization/
On the other hand, the movies? At least they're a spectacle.
I get this is a well-intentioned comment, but I assure you that most of the experiences you mention are hardly foreign to me.
Have I had to suffer through traffic? Yes. Bad stoplights? Yes. Cross an inconvenient highway to get to the other side? Yes. And while dodging cows while I'm at. Annoying u-turn restrictions? There's one walking distance from my door. Geriatric Cadillac driver? Well, I've never encountered a Cadillac, but rest assured I've been tempted to misuse my license to double check theirs.
You've never sat in a 10 mile traffic backup caused by people's inability to not slow down and look at crashed cars and ambulances on the other side of the highway. You've never changed brake pads on the street. You've never paid significantly more for an apartment that had a garage. You've never paid $250/month for a parking lease at work. You've never spent 45 minutes at a dead standstill between the bend at Bates and the Squirrel Hill Tunnel, not once, but every. Fucking. Day. As part of your commute.
Discounting the obvious Americanisms, I've been in traffic delayed by rubbernecking at accidents. I've fortunately never had to change brake pads at all. Apartments with guaranteed and reserved parking do cost more. Thankfully my hospital doesn't nickel and dime me with parking, but that'll change in the NHS.
No really, I am well aware of the difficulties that car ownership entails, and I would wager it's even worse here with the quality of the roads, the cows, people who consider the laws of the road more akin to flexible guidelines, and no end of other issues. About the only thing I'm certain I'm better off without is the risk of someone pulling a gun out of road rage.
And I still prefer widespread car-ownership. It's a pretty sweet deal the moment you remember you have (or plan to have) a large family, carry a bunch of crap like groceries, travel to places outside a city that don't fall on convenient rail or bus routes and so on. Even in the UK, it's expected that a doctor should have a car, I had to sign a waiver for my training application where I indemnify the NHS against paying for any expenses incurred if I'm urgently forced to rent a cab or take public transport.
Much like democracy, having a car is the worst possible option barring all the others.
I disagree with everything you've just said.
We are nowhere near "resource constrained", the primary concerns with giving everyone First World/American lifestyles is energy and carbon emissions, both of which are solvable problems. Invest in nuclear, or continue waiting for renewables to be even more competitive (they already are, even without market subsidies), and then do one of the many forms of geoeningeering needed to deal with the climactic changes.
I see no fundamental barriers to drastically raising the global standard of living. Certainly none that can't be solved, or won't inevitably be solved.
I do not care about animal welfare, pictures of overstuffed chickens in pens or male chicks being sent to the meat grinder do not matter in the least to me. That makes all the arguments downstream of their moral salience irrelevant as far as I'm concerned. Sure, with a fastidious adherence to a broad diet and medical supplements, you can barely get an adequate caloric and nutritional intake that makes you not outright unhealthy or anemic, but what of it?
I prefer cars, I find it daft that after centuries of industrial and technological progress, there are people who would try and make them cost-prohibitive to use for the average person. I am intimately familiar with "walkable cities", every city in India is walkable, as they must be when the majority of the population is too poor to afford cars. I've had the "pleasure" of using public transport in London, often paraded as the city with the best infrastructure for the same, and I would far prefer an alternative with more cars. I see nothing absurd about relying on a two-ton vehicle and fuel to get about, any more than I am concerned about the other hundreds or thousands of tons of infrastructure required for a comfortable middle class existence in the West.
Am I aware that the anti-car movement has a point regarding the drawbacks on density, the inconvenience to pedestrians or the relative inefficiency of everyone driving? Absolutely. I don't even deny it, I simply consider it an acceptable tradeoff for my preferences.
On a more meta note, I see nothing particularly wrong with arguing one's point to an opponent and using arguments within their framework of beliefs that I do not consider salient to my own. When I point out the manifest absurdities of aligning Omniscience, Omnipotence, and Omnibenevolence in the context of an argument for atheism, or when I point out that the world as it exists looks nothing like a world made by an Omnibenevolent Creator, I do not for a millisecond happen to have believed in any of those properties, I'm only trying to demonstrate their utter incoherence to someone who holds all of them. Showing inconsistencies is a necessary step to start swaying people, and eventually, one hopes, when the cognitive dissonance becomes too much to bear, they'll stop trying to patch things up and then tear it all down to build a new edifice that aligns closer to mine.
So I don't particularly begrudge the vegans or anti-car people from trying to advance tangential arguments, but believe it or not, those are still niche positions to hold, and I don't see it as particularly surprising that they don't have all that many vocal adherents here. There's nothing in the rules of the Motte that states that any particular brand of advocacy must find positive feedback here, and many of us who remain, including the more extreme of the Wignats, do so because they're willing to accept downvotes and negative feedback, and to the extent they persist, by following the rules in their statements.
Bing/Copilot image generation does it, with weekly limits. You can get around it by asking the Copilot chat to make them for you, just tell it to make an image according to your prompt. No limits on that, yet!
I am assuming each relationship lasts 1 year. Real life has enough additional complexity that I doubt that simplifying conclusion makes any difference, and on average, a year seems like the rough amount of time needed to know if things are going to work out in the longterm with a new partner.
There are all kinds of wrinkles in a real life context, such as being exposed to additional evidence regarding the quality of one's partners before "interviewing" them, not having to see strictly serially, not needing a strict amount of time for each relationship, having each relationship change your SMV and so on.
But either approach shows that OP wasn't being sensible in how he handled things.
Thank you! I'd say it's hard work, but I've just been practising ethical dilemmas for an upcoming exam, and Jesus Christ I think I'd need to hire one of the dozen lawyers here to deal with some of them. In contrast, handling the Motte only requires me not to do an obviously worse job than the other mods who have been hard at work keeping it tidy haha.
I noticed it sitting in the mod queue with a bunch of reports, but as a greenhorn moderator I didn't quite feel ready to take drastic action, especially since I wasn't aware of all the context with previous warnings. Well, better late than never!
And thank you, I'll try and keep the place tidy and let Amadan get some sleep on occasion.
Multiple rounds of selection.
In the initial round, a bunch of users who the mods considered trustworthy and generally representative of the forum were selected, mainly going off AAQC count and other things, and then asked to nominate the next set of voters, who would go on to nominate the final set, who were then to nominate the people who they wanted to see as mods. I have genuinely lost track of whether there were 2 or 3 preliminary rounds before the final vote.
At that point, the candidates were asked if they were willing to take on the responsibility, and quite a few demurred. The remainder were finally vetted by the existing admins, and the results came out a few days ago.
As you can imagine, this took a while. I think a few intermediate steps could be taken out of the picture, because the people nominated in the second step were almost all the same people who showed up for the final vote, but at least it brought in new faces who hadn't been chosen by the mods at the start.
@ZorbaTHut based it off the election of the Doge in Venice. It seemed to work well enough last time, and if it ain't broke and also happens to be mildly exciting, don't fix it!
Votes were submitted in private to him, but there was no barrier to people declaring or discussing their choices, in a channel made for them. A surprising lack of acrimony, and I don't recall anyone being uncouth enough to nominate themselves, though I'm not sure if that was expressly ruled out.
Ah.. It's got pretty pictures in it. That's pretty much a pre-requisite for general worldbuilding/lore dumps to be taken seriously, at least in /r/Worldbuilding.
Well, I sprinkle plenty of AI generated illustrations into mine, though that's more because I think the very idea that I can afford to do so on a budget of $0 is cool enough as is, not to mention the tech.
Looks shiftily at plans for a Substack, somewhere, somewhen
Well, I have enough on my plate as it is with exams coming up, though the Ritalin does make me procrasturbate more than I ought to, usually manifesting in Motteposting.

My memory says no, but I did look it up and there doesn't seem to be any claims of it being hazardous beyond the mild sedation itself.
More options
Context Copy link