@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

Thanks, fixed.

I think the biggest problems with the SAT are both the range compression at the upper end, as well as the reduction in g loading as you discussed.

In contrast, a similarly equivalent exam in India, the NEET, is designed explicitly to avoid those problems. It is difficult (though the claims that some questions can stump Western physics or engineering majors are overblown), but more importantly, the sheer number of questions and the difficulty ensures that it's basically impossible to get a perfect score. You have to be both very good at the subjects (all STEM related), and also excellent at time management. That implies a far longer tail of results, which makes it easier to tease out "mere" 99th percentile nerds from the 99.999th percentile geniuses, and not even the latter can hope to get a perfect score.

Which is as it should be, I have a jaundiced opinion on extracurriculars being defacto mandatory for the purposes of college entry, it's largely a waste of time that both biases for the rich and wealthy (who on top of being genetically smarter) are also capable of gaming those systems by sending their kids off to a nice summer of helping dig wells in Africa or similar bullshit.

On the other hand, a smart but poor student in India is on a much more level playing field. All they have to do is focus on making it in the NEET, and everything else becomes moot. This laudable system is of course undermined by our own AA, but I still consider it an improvement.

I had to change the DALL-E 3 prompt to "Centaur man with wings" instead of winged Centaur, which produces pegasi, but it can do it consistently.

https://ibb.co/vD4Kx3r https://ibb.co/sqgpMp6

The issue with VAERS is both that it doesn't vet data, had massive signal boosting, and more importantly, was signal boosted heavily in the vaccine-skeptical crowd. I expect a great deal more spurious claims, both because of intentional and disingenuous reporting, as well as people being on edge and willing to attribute a natural death or one from COVID itself to the vaccine that preceded it.

I mean, it's both possible for people to be irrationally averse to vaccination in general or the COVID one in particular and the vaccine to be dangerous (or at least worse than the disease), it's just unlikely.

Yes, you can pick apart any of these studies. They are all limited at least by being fairly small given the relative rarity of these events. None of them are proper clinical trials. But that's because these studies are the only ones that have been done.

I'm not against better studies, but until they happen, I reserve judgement, or at least hold the null hypothesis. There's publication bias both from the vaccine manufacturers and their pharma affiliates who would prefer not to demonstrate harm and hundreds or thousands of small-time researchers who would love to make a name by demonstrating clear and obvious harm. The latter aren't deplatformed, you did link to multiple weak/inconclusive studies after all.

But we do now know that vaccines remain active for 60+ days and that they produce random proteins they are not supposed to (these are lab studies on how the vax works)

"Random proteins" aren't really that big a deal. The human body handles probably quadrillions of misfolded proteins or even those produced by point/frameshift mutations every day. When the original study you cited makes no claim that it causes harm, I expect more evidence to back up that claim, including obvious increases in all cause mortality that can be retroactively attributed to mRNA vaccines.

In the specific case of children, my point is that the CFR for them is so minuscule that it wouldn't be worth vaccinating them even if the vaccine was perfectly safe. Certainly not when vaccine stocks were short of requirements in the early/middle pandemic.

"Mutilated" is a loaded term. Are dentures being put in and your objections overruled mutilation? Getting your ears pierced as a child?

The obvious counterpart, female genital mutilation, has much more grounding as such, since it is explicitly designed to deny women sexual pleasure, and the clitoris contributes a great deal more to it than the prepuce does for the penis.

I'm circumcised, and I'm apathetic about it. I don't see myself as being deprived of anything in particular, and it wasn't done when I was too young to remember the difference. Now, I'm also against people having their bodies modified against their consent for most reasons, and the benefits of circumcision are minimal if they exist at all. I just happen to think that the men who consider it a cut-down hill worth dying on are overstating its impact. It likely contributed nothing to what ails them, unless the circumcision was really botched, and I don't think that's accusation in play. It's a trivial procedure, or less African witchdoctors and Rabbis with incisors couldn't pull it off reliably.

Here's my attempt to parse VAERS data, so the next poor soul doesn't have to.

/images/17029894385891418.webp

The VAERS UI and UX designers deserve to be shot.

I note a massive spike from 2021, which I don't particularly consider noteworthy since the total deaths from that period onwards sums up to about 15k. And:

VAERS accepts reports of adverse events and reactions that occur following vaccination. Healthcare providers, vaccine manufacturers, and the public can submit reports to VAERS. While very important in monitoring vaccine safety, VAERS reports alone cannot be used to determine if a vaccine caused or contributed to an adverse event or illness. The reports may contain information that is incomplete, inaccurate, coincidental, or unverifiable. Most reports to VAERS are voluntary, which means they are subject to biases. This creates specific limitations on how the data can be used scientifically. Data from VAERS reports should always be interpreted with these limitations in mind.

And the CDC makes no effort to verify every individual claim, let alone actually enforce the nominal legal penalty for false ones.

I expect that given the enormous increase in public awareness about VAERS, that this isn't particularly significant.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37163200/

The RR for overall mortality of mRNA vaccines vs. placebo was 1.03 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.63-1.71). In the adenovirus-vector vaccine RCTs, the RR for overall mortality was 0.37 (0.19-0.70).

Those are some pretty wide 95% CIs to me, but I'm no statistician. All I can conclude from it is that mRNA vaccines do worse than adenoviral ones. Which is fine, a suboptimal choice of vaccine is bad enough by itself.

Clinical trial data also shows increased risk of serious adverse events for mrna vaccines, outweighing risk of severe COVID in younger population groups: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0264410X22010283.

I don't disagree that it's not worth vaccinating paediatric age groups.

I looked around for takes from those better equipped to evaluate such claims than I am:

https://healthfeedback.org/claimreview/covid19-mrna-vaccines-saved-lives-reducing-risks-infection-severe-covid-19/

First, Benn et al. used RCTs with a small number of deaths, whether from COVID-19 or other causes. Together, the mRNA vaccine (Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna) RCTs reported 61 deaths out of 74,193 participants (0.0008%), while the AV vaccine (AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson) trials reported 46 deaths out of 122,164 participants (0.0003%). When assessing the risk of death, a small number of events is problematic because it leaves the results highly vulnerable to statistical flukes.

Karina Top, a professor in the division of infectious diseases of Dalhousie University, explained that these small numbers of deaths “translated into wide confidence intervals around the point estimates indicating lack of precision in the results”.

Abram Wagner, a professor of epidemiology and global public health at Michigan University, reached the same conclusion. “Together, these studies included 74,193 participants in mRNA vaccine trials, and there were only 61 deaths across vaccinated and placebo groups. Essentially there is not enough statistical power to make any conclusions from these data”, he said.

Statistical power is the ability of an analysis to adequately detect an effect where there is indeed one. In this case, a lack of statistical power due to a small number of deaths means that there’s a high risk of failing to detect mRNA vaccines’ effect on overall mortality when such an effect actually exists. In other words, data on mortality in the mRNA clinical trials reported in Benn et al. are actually inconclusive.

Hmm, I guess my nose is worth something after all, I did consider those CIs sus before I read this.

And:

The fact that there aren’t enough deaths to properly assess the effect of vaccination on all-cause mortality isn’t surprising. As Benn et al. acknowledged, the initial clinical trials that led to vaccines’ authorizations primarily focused on preventing symptomatic COVID-19. For example, death from COVID-19 isn’t among the original primary outcomes monitored during the Pfizer, Moderna, or AstraZeneca clinical trials.

If you have better sources or can point out a reason my reasoning is incorrect, I'd be happy to hear it. My general enthusiasm for technological advances is, at least I'd hope, less overwhelming than my desire to get to the bottom of things.

Overall, these data increase our understanding of how modified ribonucleotides affect the fidelity of mRNA translation, and although there are no adverse outcomes reported from mistranslation of mRNA-based SARS-CoV-2 vaccines in humans, these data highlight potential off-target effects for future mRNA-based therapeutics and demonstrate the requirement for sequence optimization.

That risk doesn't seem to have borne out.

My parents are medical professionals, and they got me circumcised for reasons that were, in hindsight, unnecessary.

I think the effect on my QOL is just about zero, and I was old enough to remember what my dick used to be like. I doubt it's worth getting angry about in the least, my orgasms from PIV sex are just fine.

It's co-authored by Timnit Gebru, a woman so utterly incompetent and hostile that she managed to wear out the massive amount of tolerance her gender engenders in her field at Google.

The emoji is hardly the worst part about it.

I will presume that your first paragraph suggests that you too expect a technologically transformative future.

Given said transformation, I see no reason to expect men to be disprivileged in that regard. Why would they be? If everyone can avail of genetic/cybernetic augmentation or has hypercompetent AI assisting them, then I fail to see how even the aspects of intelligence coded as feminine can't be enhanced in everyone, or a reason to see why men would floor out earlier.

At the end of the day, I expect it to be moot, in much the same way that the circumference of one's biceps counts for just about nothing when predicting who's going to be better at digital fighting games. Let alone when they're both kicking up their feet and letting the superhuman bots duke it out on their behalf.

It does. I keep mixing the two up, despite having been corrected about the acronyms in the past, in my defense it's been a long shift. I do mean bipolar here.

He just managed to write an awful and long article that could be summed: AI doomers are wrong and desperate.

I suppose an awful and short article is an improvement of sorts.

An accidental tab refresh ate my lengthy comment, so I'm going to be terse.

Yes, I agree that Freddie is inciting violence, not even particularly veiled. It's all, ah woe is modernity, wouldn't it be a shame if the disaffected took out their rage on their wifi routers? Anyway, it's unlikely to happen, but if you're so inclined here's [list of easy targets].

Leaving aside that unironically invoking Stochastic Parrots should be a clinical sign of mental retardation, I'll be sure to include it if I'm ever consulted for the DSM-7. LLMs don't perform well out of distribution, but when the distribution they're trained on comprises most of the internet..

At any rate, he's impotent and not just because of the meds. The appetite for political violence in the US is nowhere near as high as the overly online might like to daydream, and a decentralized bout of violent ludditism is unlikely to come about, no matter how vigorously he tries to manifest it. I value free speech enough that I don't want him deplatformed for his ranting.

If they want to be ants, the powers that be have bugspray.

To be fair, bipolar disorder with its manic psychosis is probably adaptive for the purposes of violent extremism. You need to be a little schizo, or ideally have a brain tumor, before some misdirected political violence in the comfort of the US seems remotely like a good idea.

By the time most of the masses even end up unemployed and disenfranchised, without a social safety net, that'll be when they're obsolete. Maybe they can merk an odd Google employee while they're sipping a latte, but data centers will become (and are) valuable enough that I don't suppose they'll have much success in climbing electrified fences, avoiding the robodogs and cameras and then taking a piss on a server rack.

So, what are you reading?

Medical textbooks. I can't remember the last time I had time to read anything else.

The worst of it is the GMC's Good Medical Practise, which expects a kind of simpering obsequiousness and self-sacrifice from doctors that would be uncalled for in a nun working under Mother Teresa. Then again, we're both about as exposed to TB or leprosy, so maybe I can learn from them.

The Coffin of Andy and Leyley

I am agnostic on your preferences, sadly I'm not the target demographic, so I only know what I've heard or seen on Twitter. I believe there are some visual elements involved, and probably text.

I'm talking about the meme cannibal game.

To discuss a broader point that mere modern sexlessness or the demographic travails of a particular nation, I don't think demographics are worth worrying about particularly.

There's two different considerations at play here:

  1. Whether global birth rates/total human population will decline.

  2. Whether that decline will be a "bad" thing.

In the case of the former:

I think that a "business as usual" or naive extrapolation of demographic trends is a bad idea, when AGI is imminent. In the case of population, it's less bad than usual, at least compared to things like GDP. As far as I'm concerned, the majority of the probability mass can be divvied up between "baseline human population booms" and "all humans die".

Why might it boom? (The bust case doesn't need to be restated, insert the usual AI x-risk arguments).

To the extent that humans consider reproduction to be a terminal value, AI will make it significantly cheaper and easier. AI assisted creches or reliable rob-nannies that don't let their wards succumb to what are posited as the ills of too much screen time or improper socialization will mean that much of the unpleasantness of raising a child can be delegated, in much the same manner that a billionaire faces no real constraints in their QOL from having a nigh arbitrary number of kids when they can afford as many nannies as they please. You hardly need to be a billionaire to achieve that, it's in the reach of UMC Third Worlders because of income inequality, and while more expensive in the West, hardly insurmountable for successful DINKs. The wealth versus fertility curve is currently highest for the poor, dropping precipitously with income, but then increases again when you consider the realms of the super-wealthy.

What this does retain will be what most people consider to be universally cherished aspects of raising a child, be it the warm fuzzy glow of interacting with them, watching them grow and develop, or the more general sense of satisfaction it entails.

If, for some reason, more resource rich entities like governments desire more humans around, advances like artifical wombs and said creches would allow large population cohorts to be raised without much in the way of the usual drawbacks today, as seen in the dysfunction of orphanages. This counts as a fallback measure in case the average human simply can't be bothered to reproduce themselves.

The kind of abundance/bounded post-scarcity we can expect will mean no significant downsides from the idle desire to have kids.

Not all people succumb to hyper-stimuli replacements, and the ones who don't will have far more resources to indulge their natal instincts.

As for the latter:

Today, and for most of human history, population growth has robustly correlated with progress and invention, be it technological or cultural, especially technological. That will almost certainly cease to be so when we have non-human intelligences or even superintelligences about, that can replace the cognitive or physical labour that currently requires humans.

It costs far less to spool up a new instance of GPT-4 than it does to conceive and then raise a child to be a productive worker.

You won't need human scientists, or artists, or anything else really, AI can and will fill those roles better than we can.

I'm also bullish on the potential for anti-aging therapy, even if our current progress on AGI was to suddenly halt indefinitely. Mere baseline human intelligence seems sufficient to the task within the nominal life expectancy of most people reading this, as it does for interplanetary colonization or constructing Dyson Swarms. AI would just happen to make it all faster, but even we could make post-scarcity happen over the scale of a century, let alone a form of recursive self-improvement through genetic engineering or cybernetics.

From the perspective of a healthy baseliner living in a world with AGI, you won't notice any of the current issues plaguing demographically senile or contracting populations, such as failure of infrastructure, unsustainable healthcare costs, a loss of impetus when it comes to advancing technology, less people around to make music/art/culture/ideas. Whether there are a billion, ten billion or a trillion other biological humans around will be utterly irrelevant, at least for the deep seated biological desires we developed in an ancestral environment where we lived and died in the company of about 150 others.

You won't be lonely. You won't be living in a world struggling to maintain the pace of progress you once took for granted, or worse, watching everything slowly decay around you.

What struck me the hardest about MD is how modern the writing felt.

Knowing how to "build a house" is a ludicrous expectation for most men around the world. Even in the US, it's a bit of a stretch, and you have a strong DIY culture.

"Ugly houses" are best addressed by people developing more taste, architects either being less (or more!) restricted.

Poorly maintained infrastructure, that's problem for the government, I fail to see how the average male complaining about them can be expected to pull out a shovel or start laying down asphalt.

I don't think surplus males are a particularly big problem, not until the imbalance skews well past 1.1, and even then it's hardly catastrophic.

That's... how I feel. Like, our species basically requires war in order to sort out our psychology. Otherwise there will be this latent male aggression caused by intra-sexual competition, and it won't end until we have some stupid fucking war over nothing, just to reduce the surplus male population.

I don't think this is true, but even if it was, what of it?

A war that kills 1-10% of the adult male population is, to put it bluntly, a cure much worse than the disease.

Yeah it's not ideal that we aren't living in society where literally everyone pairbonds off to a single partner for life, but mass murder isn't a suitable solution.

It's in the game, but optionally so.

The incest is, believe it or not, optional. But while I've heard it's a decent game on its own merit, most of the players are in it for the titillation.

Hmm, thanks for sharing. I'm primarily curious about how people who had never heard of the Motte before it moved arrived here, but I have yet to get a response from someone like that. Maybe they don't exist!