@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

There's a limited extent of that already present on YouTube, since stuff like transformation [cw: no nudity, but you probably don't want it in your YT algorithm],

As far as I'm aware, removing the video from your watch history should remove it from algorithmic recommendations in the future.

men are going to just... use filters?

They become anime v-tubers, often with a feminine voice changer.

Nigga what the fuck

Sildenafil is many things and an indispensable miracle drug for many middle aged men around the world, but I have yet to see anyone call it an antidepressant. I'm sure it has antidepressant-adjacent properties, in the sense that most people would get at least a little depressed if their dick stopped working. Doesn't make it part of the same class.

At any rate, the only reason this particular format works is because Americans are fond of their stupid brand names while more enlightened countries use generic. I'm pretty sure I can recognize almost any generic antidepressant by name, including the atypicals, but it's like calling Genghis Khan "Bob" and then expecting everyone to know who he is.

I assume it's the vodka getting to him, I've had far more contentious quarrels that didn't result in a block, nor do I even block anyone myself. Certainly I made no move to escalate first.

At least the block system is better than Reddit, where I can see and engage with his posts unless I block him myself, even if I'm invisible to him.

Oh I understand that there will be negative consequences from such a prestigious establishment plying its trade. However, I am libertarian adjacent enough that I don't think the State should be in the business of demanding its citizens engage in nothing but "optimal" behavior (which is inherently subjective).

I would personally prefer that it attempts to price in externalities, and mainly stick to ensuring truth in advertising.

Freedom, without the extension of the freedom to make bad decisions isn't much in the way of freedom after all. What principled reason is there for the government to stop people from getting syphilis willingly when they aren't allowed to force you to jog every day or eat your veggies? What I personally seek to minimize is the harm to others who are indirectly affected, say by the new syphilis aficionados spreading the disease to them.

If, for example, this was the case in a nation with nationalised healthcare, I fully endorse the government imposing heavy fines on the clap trap, which they are free to pass on to customers via their pricing. I would rather see the fines capture the costs of externalities rather than be intentionally punitive or intended to make it impossible to operate at any cost.

You might even deny people who are so fundamentally retarded access to free healthcare, but I still consider that they should have the right to be retarded.

What is utterly unconscionable and deserving of severe punishment, at least in my eyes, is involving people who didn't make informed bad decisions, such as lying to customers even through omission, presuming they expect prostitutes with the normal risk of giving them syphilis, or the fine purveyors of that establishment who hide their own condition from other partners.

A nation made entirely of intelligent and rational ideal agents would've already fully eliminated every STD of significance by at first spontaneously agreeing to, and then nationally coordinating, a set of practices for testing and condom use.

The sanity waterline as it exists today more laps at the toes of such intellectual titans than it dampens the crotch of the average human :(

Well he decided to end the debate by blocking me, so good for him. I can't say I've done anything but argue in good faith.

The wellness part is more of a cry for help as I steadily experience temporary dementia from sleep deprivation. I'm sure "FunSearch" could also work in the fun thread.

But the discovered functions are less triumphs of machine thought and more like random blobs of if statements and additions with a bunch of simple patterns (eg fig 4b, 5b, 6b).

DM claims that the code generated is clear enough that human evaluators can notice obvious patterns and symmetries, which would certainly accelerate things.

As far as I'm concerned, this is only the first step, PaLM 2 isn't a particularly good model, and the fact that this works at all makes it a good bet that I'll only continue to get better.

If I had to set a date on when I expect:

As opposed to taking a LLM and teaching it 1000 math textbooks and then it spontaneously proving new theorems. Which is a thing that this paper, notably, very much doesn't do. But, you know, totally might in 5 years.

It would be closer to three years, but since you and I are in agreement that it's going to happen, and soon, there's not much else to do but wait and see.

I stand corrected then, thanks.

FunSearch: Making new discoveries in mathematical sciences using Large Language Models

Another day, another AI breakthrough, this time in maths.

Mathematics has been surprisingly difficult for computers to get a hold of, which would seem weird when you consider they're made of maths themselves. For decades, automated theorem solvers were more of a curiosity rather than anything practical, with the bulk of the problem being, as I understand it, representing intuitive-to-humans (and mathematically valid) concepts/axioms in their programming language. Of late, they've gotten better, and are handy for proof-reading and ensuring no nasty little errors creep into theorems that can stretch pages and boggle even the imagination of talented mathematicians to keep straight in their head.

However, short of brute-forcing certain classes of problems through exhaustive search, novel mathematical insight remained out of the reach of both programs that can't really be called intelligent, as well as proper AI (not that this isn't invaluable, good luck solving some of those by hand).

Until now.

Deepmind, a subsidiary of Google/Alphabet (does anyone call them Alphabet? At least Meta took off), announced FunSearch, which stands for function search (I'm sure somebody finds it fun, I'll settle for interesting).

As of today, the technique (rather than a model, per se, the general approach can be slotted into most LLMs, they used PaLM 2 this time), advanced the SOTA in two particular problems, namely the Cap Set problem and Online Bin-packing.

Of particular interest is the fact that this wasn't done by brute-forcing the space of all possible programs, which as Deepmind notes, is computationally intractable because of inevitable combinatorial explosions.

FunSearch uses an evolutionary method powered by LLMs, which promotes and develops the highest scoring ideas. These ideas are expressed as computer programs, so that they can be run and evaluated automatically. First, the user writes a description of the problem in the form of code. This description comprises a procedure to evaluate programs, and a seed program used to initialize a pool of programs.

FunSearch is an iterative procedure; at each >iteration, the system selects some programs from the current pool of programs, which are fed to an LLM. The LLM creatively builds upon these, and generates new programs, which are automatically evaluated. The best ones are added back to the pool of existing programs, creating a self-improving loop. FunSearch uses Google’s PaLM 2, but it is compatible with other LLMs trained on code.

Blah blah blah, I've been awake for 27 hours, my patients are dying, and my patience is dead, I can't be arsed to clean it up further and add additional commentary for the main thread, the "Stochastic Parrot" is better than you are at practical problems, justifying why AI becoming better than us at everything needs a CW angle, fuck me, fuck you, I'm going to take a nap

I would strongly recommend against this, if you ever plan to get an MRI done in your life. At least most piercings are less of a PITA to remove (well.. depending on how inventive you are about where you place them..).

As much as I am an ardent transhumanist, most or all current mechanical additions or replacements are only half-decent at replacing damaged parts, to me, BCIs like a Neuralink represent the first kind of augmentation that an otherwise healthy individual might want.

There are contexts in which testing for various diseases is mandatory. It might be COVID screening, it might be something else, but certain services can well be denied to you on the grounds that you refuse a test.

In the particular case of AIDS, the worst of it was before we had tests available AFAIK, and right now, it is nowhere near the level of crisis worth sacrificing civil liberties for in most contexts.

If we had an AIDS equivalent about that was significantly more contagious, such as being transmitted airborne or by close contact, and tests for it, I would have few qualms about making testing mandatory for participation in civic life.

If I had to think of a solution to the spread of STDs, I would suggest an annual screening program available to everyone. Participation would be encouraged, but not mandatory, but if you skipped it and then infected someone with such a disease (presuming at least that the incubation is long enough you weren't plausibly infected after the screen was due), then you'd have the book thrown at you.

You could modulate the penalty on the basis of the severity of the particular disease, whether you had other reason to suspect that you could be infected or at high risk and so on.

For example, you're a gay hooker who consistently refuses to get assessed? All well and good, but if you manage to infect someone, then you deserve to be punished more severely.

I don't think such a system is the most pressing thing to implement, perhaps if there's a new and particularly annoying STD around.

The UK has some sensible options, such as mandatory reporting to contacts while keeping the anonymity of the person initially diagnosed. They get something like a text message telling them they're potentially at risk of an infection and to come in for a screen, but who infected them isn't outright disclosed. For more personal contacts, like the spouse of a person who is hiding their HIV, then the doctor is obligated to inform them no matter the protestations involved.

One reason your claim doesn't hold up is that "Hispanic" is the most widely-recognized ethnicity in the Americas, and all it means is "descended from Spanish (and maybe Portugese) settlers of the New World." Most Hispanic people are additionally descended from aboriginal Americans, but many are distinguishable from Old World Europeans only by the accent of their Spanish

I don't see how that contradicts my point, for the same reason that African-American is a convenient moniker because most of the ADOS have no idea which particular region within a whole continent their ancestors came from.

People who say they are "ethnically American" today are broadly asserting that they experience a distinct sense of difference owing to culture and descent. You appear to essentially be using "ethnicity" as a synonym for the older concept of "race." Which you're free to do, but it kind of violates the whole point of the word's coining. Which you're additionally free to disagree with, if your focus is more rooted in DNA etc., but you should then be at least conscious of the controversy.

I do not think that KMC has such ambiguous aims. If he or you can concede that in principle, an American of Indian origin can "feel ethnically American" as well as, I would have no objections to this weird approach.

As usual, when seeking clarity it's probably best to taboo our words--but of course, asking a large group of people to stop using their preferred ethnic tag tends to go over like a lead balloon.

He can call himself whatever he likes, it's the not particularly principled exclusion of other American citizens who look different that makes me annoyed.

I have no idea, NFTs, at this point, are purely products for suckers, and I imagine most of them aren't that price sensitive, and some might even think that a higher listing price makes them more valuable.

I'm certainly advocating for people who knowingly and non-consensually infect others with a lethal illness being slow roasted over a fire. If Douglas was fucking around, he deserves to find out, and not his unwitting partners.

Shilts points to the theory that HIV required some other cofactor to progress into symptomatic AIDs

My understanding is that HIV doesn't usually kill you by itself, it's the immune suppression that leaves you open to everything else (yeah, is it the bullet, gun or shooter who kills someone etc etc). But I think it's reasonable to call that a "cofactor", if you miraculously managed to keep a person with AIDS in a perfectly sterile environment and scrubbed their microbiome, I'd expect them to live a lot longer (not that deleting a microbiome is a good idea in the least).

Even the sarcomas are due to opportunistic infection by HHV-8 and friends.

So a cofactor isn't really a bad description as far as I'm concerned.

There's some other later bits about gay activists putting often-steep political demands to insure that new anti-HIV efforts would not become anti-gay efforts, most impactfully around the dawn of testing.

I don't blame them, I can easily see how it could have gone that way. Of course, I am not necessarily opposed to mandatory testing, for human beings who have any reason to interact with anyone else, which is just about all of them. I've browsed enough /r/Grindr to know that while some of the more fastidious ones can make a song and dance about using condoms, getting tested and PREP, if the bussy is tight enough they'll usually relent. I'm sure most straight men would do the same, if they had even the same OOM odds of getting casual sex on demand.

Looking at the horndog behavior of gay men today, even accounting for how HIV has become largely inconsequential with modern anti retroviral therapies, I think revealed preferences strongly suggests many/most of them are willing to die sooner if it means they can bareback more partners. Sure, I have nothing against them for doing so, that's their prerogative, and I doubt there's a significant number of utterly naive gay men around who have no idea what that practise entails.

These are villains in the more Brazil sense, but they're still villains by Shilts' version of events.

I could well be overstating my competence, but if I was in charge of the CDC or FDA, I think I could, at least with a bit more study of epidemiology and stats than my standard curriculum provided, have done a better job than the incumbents during COVID. Certainly I would have at least deferred to superforecasters or polymaths like Zvi much earlier, if I felt I couldn't handle it. I would certainly have pushed for the end of lockdowns and masking much earlier than they petered away.

But putting myself in the shoes of the FDA/CDC in the 70s? I can't see myself doing better really.

My personal definition of villainy, even for institutional incompetence or sub-optimality, isn't that harsh.

although I guess it's also somewhat hypocritical for conservatives to ask for a radical change in immigration policy or whatever, when they usually abhor change.

I don't see how it's hypocritical, they want change to the extent that it returns things to what they deem the ideal status quo, not that even all conservatives can agree on which year that was. You might as well call liberals/progs hypocritical for not switching out the entire legal code on a monthly basis, at which point the word ceases to mean anything.

The confidence vote was delayed when a far-right lawmaker, Grzegorz Braun, used a fire extinguisher to put out the candles of a menorah during a Hanukkah celebration dedicated to Poland’s Jewish lawmakers of the 1920s and 1930s.

The sheer level of chutzpah involved makes him an honorary Jew, by linguistic transference.

I could have sworn you used that specific example with me in the past, but regardless, I do remember you claiming you can change your priors/beliefs at will.

HBD, corruption, subversion of meritocracy and egalitarianism through affirmative action, religion, factionalism that encourages populist pandering.

Basically, the electorate is too dumb and uneducated to hold the government accountable, and while that's vaguely true everywhere, it's more true here.

English, a language stunningly unsuitable for such discussions, not that I know of one that's better.

I might be wrong though. It is conceivable to me that some people can change their beliefs(1) by sheer force of will.

@FCfromSSC claims to be able to do this, including intentionally convincing himself that a chair he's sitting on is a fake. I'm capable of no analogous feat, but it's hardly the weirdest thing that human cognition has done, and I'll accept his word for it.

BOR does have implications for when we have zero evidence.

And that would be to choose the most minimal potential hypothesis, though I am unsure what that could possibly mean. What hypothesis explains a coin flip that never happened?

It is, however not true that we have "zero" evidence about what caused the Big Bang. After all, I presume you admit that there could be evidence along the lines of say, the cosmic microwave background radiation spelling out "God here. Glad you're reading this, good to see you're advancing up the tech tree" in English, and you (and I) would have no qualms about ascribing that as evidence for God causing the Big Bang? I don't think either of us would claim that it has no relevance, that it cannot be the case that observations made within a universe could inform our understanding of what lies outside it.

In a similar vein, to the extent that you expect a universe designed by the Judeo Christian deity to differ in any way from one that's purely mechanistic, the absence of such evidence is Bayesian evidence of absence.

It is indeed necessarily more complex than the Standard Model. In exactly the same way, "True Physics" being responsible for ensuring the operation of the Standard Model is necessarily more complex than the standard model.

It may be more complex. It is not necessarily so. Much of the charm of the Standard Model is that by establishing symmetries, it simplifies and explains whole bunch of seemingly disparate observations. You can imagine someone who studiously makes a table showing the rates of deceleration for a whole range of different masses under gravity, which is actually useful in real life, but more complex when compared to just applying Newtonian gravity and air resistance when supplied with a given value for m. I am mostly agnostic on whether the GUT will be "simpler" than the Standard Model, even if I'm mildly expecting that to be the case. Physicists certainly consider it desirable, but the only true necessity is that it explains things better, especially for situations not in the data used to derive it.

Certainly. But you are the one claiming that some unobservable hypotheses or ideas are simpler than others, and it seems you cannot actually use Kolmogorov Complexity to prove it in the way you claimed you could.

Kolmogorov complexity is a beast, but if you really cared to, you could easily substitute minimum message length or Shannon entropy and get the same result.

In fact, it was an error (or at least suboptimal) for me to even bring up KC, when MML exists:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_message_length

Minimum message length (MML) is a Bayesian information-theoretic method for statistical model comparison and selection.[1] It provides a formal information theory restatement of Occam's Razor: even when models are equal in their measure of fit-accuracy to the observed data, the one generating the most concise explanation of data is more likely to be correct (where the explanation consists of the statement of the model, followed by the lossless encoding of the data using the stated model). MML was invented by Chris Wallace, first appearing in the seminal paper "An information measure for classification".[2] MML is intended not just as a theoretical construct, but as a technique that may be deployed in practice. [3] It differs from the related concept of Kolmogorov complexity in that it does not require use of a Turing-complete language to model data.[4]

Besides, it's not just the Big Bang we're considering, it's the Big Bang and everything else. Here, once again, BOR implies that God is a terrible answer.

I apologize for the digression into KC, even if that's an interesting topic.

I reiterate that I am not attempting to convince you to believe in the Christian God. I am trying to demonstrate an observable, verifiable, testable fact: that all beliefs are chosen. It seems to me that you are appealing to Kolmogorov Complexity and Bayesian Occam's Razor because you want to claim that your commitment to materialism is not a choice, but rather a deterministic outcome of accumulated evidence. But it seems obvious to me that neither KC nor BOR can possibly work the way you are trying to use them, and in fact neither is the source of your conviction.

All beliefs are not a choice, assuming you're using "choice" in the standard sense.

A person suffering from Capgras delusion, who believes that his kin have been replaced by body snatchers, is not choosing to think so. You can argue with him, shake him about, shock him with a cattle prod, and he will never relent. The disease has stolen away even the option for him to think otherwise. A schizophrenic does not "choose" to think he's the reincarnation of Jesus or Napoleon.

You called for an expert, and it seems to me that the expert agreed with me that KC can't do what you claimed it did. Does the reversal of expected evidence change your position any? If not, what evidence does your conviction derive from?

I am pretty sure that @faul_sname agrees with my statements regarding the "objective" Kolmogorov complexity of different hypothesis. I know, and he knows I know that it's incomputable, because that came up as the subject of conversation not that long ago. But while Kolmogorov complexity might not be an ideal use case for anything except theoretical discussions, MML is, and I should have substituted it at the start if I remembered that the latter is a practical metric.

In this case, the relevant update for me is to do a better job of representing theories I only understand at a superficial level, not a knock against the generalized claim I'm making.

You're welcome! Some people here are prone to make less than well informed proclamations about the proclivities of a nation of 1.3 billion people, including some particular ones that are hilarious to someone who knows better.

One of the reasons that Indians assimilate so easily in the West is because the fundamentals of our culture or general mindset isn't that different. It causes me severe pain when someone thinks the relevant comparison is something like Africa. Our dysfunctions are significantly different.

Of course, I don't ascribe malice, just ignorance, and that's a far more forgivable sin. I'm sure I've made sweeping claims that people better informed would disagree with.

Uh.. I don't want to doxx my precise geographical neighborhood by naming only the ones I've been in.

I'm sure a quick Google search for "high end gated communities" in a bunch of random cities would suffice. I am at least certain of the fact that they exist, even if I can't point out which ones are the "best".

Honestly, I'm hard pressed to see a real villain in this whole narrative (assuming it tries to depict one).

If someone wishes to open a brothel with exclusively syphilitic whores, while I think that's a fucking terrible idea, I don't see why it should be made illegal, as long as they weren't lying to their customers (who should also know what they're getting into). I consider the correct target for penalization/responsible for externalities to be the gay men who lied about having the disease (as in they were confident about it, not just at risk) and spread it to others. I mean, that's not just for gay men, anyone who non-consensually and knowingly infects anyone with anything deserves punishment.

While the response to the advent of AIDS is certainly suboptimal, as @gattsuru points out, that was largely an outcome of sheer ignorance and confusion rather than entirely malicious. There were no tests for a long time, no way to tell if someone had been infected (barring a small and easy to miss prodromal phase after an infection), and no way to detect contaminated blood. I'm sure that the government did less than it could because gay men were disliked and marginalized, but not to the extent that I consider them evil for it.

The cause-and-effect chain was nowhere near as taut as COVID, and look at how much uncertainty there was even with modern medicine, epidemiology and stats. You have an insidious disease that only shows up in flagrant form years or decades after you were infected, and it must have taken a while to notice that it was gay men and hemophiliacs worst hit, and then to puzzle out the means of transmission in any robust way.

As for blood donations, there exists an optimal threshold for how strictly one wishes to screen blood. I'm sure the cost-benefit analysis today, with robust screening, makes it eminently sensible to forbid those at exceptionally high risk of contagious blood borne disease. But if I'm bleeding to death and there's nothing better available, I would accept potentially contaminated blood, yes, even with 1970s medicine. Dying in a decade beats dying today.

One specific figure who was fingered as a source for must misery in ATBPO is none other than Antonio Fauci, who made an early statement that AIDS might spread by touch in some situations

Well, if you wish to include the touch of a tumescent penis against the rectal walls, he's not not entirely wrong. (This is a joke, begone humorless pedants)

I have certainly heard of "Americans". My annoyance is at the claim, by KMC, that such a claim is restricted to the subsection of the citizenry that are of European origin, and so phenotypically similar that it's not immediately obvious if they're pure 100% German, 30% Irish and 70% Italian, or anything in between.

I have no objection to people imagining some undifferentiated jumbled Caucasian American as the default when they hear "American", they're still barely a majority in the country after all.

There are people who have forgotten their ethnic origins, people who nobody wishes to interrogate about them, and people where it's not immediately obvious if they have any divergence from Default American™ as it existed in 1950. That doesn't mean that African-Americans, Indian-Americans and every other visibly obvious minority can't be called American, or that the typical white dude is somehow "more American". Just within whites, there are millions who identify as Italian-Americans or Irish-Americans.

"Ethnically American" is a retarded statement when applied to anyone who didn't have ancestors dwelling on the continent before Columbus showed up. Certainly as used by KMC, it carries a not even veiled implication that they're somehow more American than the rest of them.