self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
What a way to miss the point. What they seek is to make the free-market value of most things so minimal that we no longer bother to put a price on them in much the same way you're not being metered for the air you breathe, or at the least like how you don't have to pay a fee for running a tap in a restaurant even if you're not ordering in there.
It's not like Taylor Swift concert tickets being sold at a price far less than the market will bear, largely for the PR benefit of fans deluding themselves into thinking Taylor is looking out for them, so that you can make a killing off re-selling them for much more than you paid for them, if you're lucky or have a bot helping you scalp them.
This is, of course, completely orthogonal to whether or not that's feasible (I do think it is, at least for malaria vaccines), but that is what their goal is.
The world as we know it is already radically abundant compared to most of history. There are no end of things that people won't mind you taking in passing, with objections only rising when you show up with a handcart to grab all the "free" stuff.
Isnt Beff Jezos an obvious parody account?
Ahem, reverse Poe's law?
The name is obviously a joke, and as he admits, the opinions shared within are intentionally bombastic and lacking in nuance, because he recognizes that as a necessity for going viral. But the ideology is very much sincere.
I've always been a techno-optimist (in the sense that I strongly believe that technology has been the biggest positive force for good in history, likely the only form of true progress that isn't just moral fashion), but these days I'd call myself d/acc instead of an e/acc, because I think current approaches to AGI have a subjective probability of about 30% of killing us all.
I don't call myself a doomer, I'd imagine Yud and co would assign something like 90% to that, but in terms of practical considerations? If you think something has a >10% of killing everyone, I find it hard to see how you could prioritize anything else! I believe Vitalik made a similar statement, one more reason for me to nod approvingly.
A large chunk of the decrease in my p(doom) from a peak of 70% in 2021 to 30% now is, as I've said before, because it seems like we're not in the "least convenient possible world" where it comes to AI alignment. LLMs, as moderated by RLHF and other techniques, almost want to be aligned, and are negligibly agentic unless you set them up to be that way. The majority of the probability mass left, at least to me, encompasses intentional misuse of weakly or strongly superhuman AI based off modest advances on the current SOTA (LLMs) or a paradigm shifting breakthrough that results in far more agentic and less pliable models.
Think "Government/Organization/Individuals ordering a powerful LLM to commit acts that get us all killed" versus it being inherently misaligned and doing it from intrinsic motivation, with the most obvious danger being biological warfare. Or it might not even be one that kills everyone, an organization using their technological edge to get rid of everyone who isn't in their in-group counts as far as I'm concerned.
Sadly, the timelines don't favor human cognitive enhancement, which I would happily accept in the interim before we can be more confident about making sure SAGI is (practically) provably safe. Maybe if we'd cloned Von Neumann by the ton a decade back. Even things like BCIs seem to have pretty much zero impact on aligning AI given plausible advances in 5-10 years.
I do think that it's pretty likely that, in a counterfactual world where AI never advances past GPT-4, ~baseline humans can still scale a lot of the tech tree to post-scarcity for matter and energy. Biological immortality, cognitive enhancement, interstellar exploration, building a Dyson Swarm or three, I think we could achieve most of that within the life expectancy of the majority of people reading this, especially mine. I'd certainly very much appreciate it if it all happened faster, of course, and AI remains the most promising route for that, shame about everything else.
I have no power to change anything, but at the very least I can enjoy the Golden Age of Humanity-as-we-know-it, be it because the future is going to be so bright we all gotta wear shades, or because we're all dead. I lean more towards the former, and not even because of the glare of nuclear warfare, but a 30% chance of me and everyone I love dying in a few decades isn't very comfortable is it?
At any rate, life, if not the best it could be, is pretty good, so regardless of what happens, I'm strapping in for a ride. I don't think there's an epoch in human history I'd rather have been born to experience really.
Alex Turner, who had written, arguably, two strongest and most popular formal proofs of instrumental convergence to power-seeking in AI agents
Well, I suppose that explains the pseudo-jazz albums about hotels on the Moon ;)
Longer-term, there are ideas like the "pivotal act" theory: we create an AI that performs a single one-time act which rearranges the world into a game where from that point forward humans are still in charge, but where the game board is somehow more defense-favoring and more fit for human flourishing.
I think this is a terrible definition of a "pivotal act". When Yudkowsky suggests releasing a nanite plague that melts GPUs, he doesn't want them to melt the GPUs of the AI releasing them.
Such a decision is very much not a "one-off", people who suggest it want to maintain an unshakeable technological lead over their peers, such as by making sure their AI prevents the formation or promulgation of potential peers. I don't think this is categorically bad, it depends on your priors about whether a unipolar or multipolar world is better for us, and how trustworthy the AI you're about to use is, and at the very least, if such an act succeeds, we at least have an existence proof of an aligned AGI that is likely superhuman, as it needs to be to pull that off, regardless of whether or not even better AI can be aligned. Let's hope we don't need to find out.
This is a widely promulgated yet glaringly incorrect interpretation.
According to Ay Mehdit Up et al, the archaeological record suggests that the length of his trunk and his morbid obesity is more suggestive of auto-fellatio.
I'm using "Maximizer" in a looser sense than a strict utility maximizer. The reason is that acquiring power and resources are such highly convergent goals that most entities will look like they're maximizing acquiring them to us, even if they have entirely different terminal goals or sets of heuristics in mind.
Think about it this way, would you disagree with the statement that, for a wide range of ideologies or terminal values seen in humans, the Solar System and then the rest of the galaxy will be either colonized or broken down for resources, given sufficient amounts of time (and technological feasibility, which I think is a reasonable assumption)? Be they communists, ancaps or anything in between, optimization pressure to be efficient in their exploitation will leave them, from the perspective of some alien with a telescope, looking like something attempting to "maximize" the conquest of the light cone.
In a similar manner, I expect a misaligned AGI to be very likely to attempt to seize as much energy and mass as it can, even if it's not strictly optimizing for the same, and that the agents/toy models we've seen are simply not smart enough to pursue such strategies.
I have read that LW post, but I've forgotten what the takeaway was, so I'll give it another read!
I can only chuckle ruefully at what I imagine similar statistics might suggest for Indians (in India).
I'd be surprised if more than 5% of Indian males get laid by the time they're in high school, maybe ~30% by the time they're done with college. Well, at least they have an arranged marriage to look forward to if nothing else, but if you've ever wondered why some Hindu deities are displayed with cyan skin, know that it's subconscious cultural symbolism representing our chronic blue balls.
Since you're a fan of Shogun 2, would you agree that naval artillery bombardment, which I believe was in FOTS, has the same "drawbacks" as magic?
It's click a button and magic rocks fall, everyone dies.
It's still not true for magic in TWW3, because:
-
Most spellcasters are squishy, they can easily get themselves killed by enemy single entity lords, heroes or monsters. Or if you miscast too many times.
-
Magic offers a great deal of contextual utility. Let's say you're on the offensive against an enemy that doesn't want to budge. Send a mage up, dodging fire, and then launch a bombardment. That gets the AI to move and approach your own favorable position. Or during a siege, helping blast the defenders on walls before you attack. Or using a summoned disposable unit to stuff up an enemy advance, fortify your backlines, or simply tie down their high value units.
I can see many valid critiques of the way magic is handled, but it being of limited utility or not interacting with other systems is a head-scratcher for sure. The reason it's limited, especially by the mana pool, is because it's incredibly powerful if used sensibly.
At any rate, if you really want to get a pike-and-shot experience out of the game, get the Southern Realms mod, which adds something quasi-similar to the Italian city states in the late 1600s. If you restrict your opponents to other similar factions, the Empire or Bretonnia, you don't have to suspend your disbelief too much.
My God, that is a terrible review, especially since so many of the sins you ascribe to TWW began well before in the historical genre, like Rome 2 making generals mandatory for moving troops, or trade routes being abstracted away.
Fuck your artillery because flying units will just bypass any defensive lines you have.
Flying units like bats are meant to counter artillery for factions that lack it themselves. You handle it by focusing ranged units on them as they approach, or keeping cav ready in the backlines to sweep them away as soon as they land, or even dismounting the crews and running them away.
Spellcasters have no counterplay at all. Yeah they only get a few shots per fight, and it's more spectacle than effect. But given that and that you can't automate your own spellcasters, the entire existence of spellcasting is just a major annoyance on both ends and it doesn't meaningfully interact with anything else in the game at all. It's slapped-on and stupid and adds nothing of value to the game.
Aneurysm. You can:
- Shoot them with artillery
- Sic your own melee lords or heroes on them
- Counterspell them with magic missiles
Doesn't meaningfully interact?? If you can't see the utility of buffing up your own units, healing monsters and cav, turning your lord into a roided monster, or nuking the enemy..
If terrain matters at all I haven't seen it do so.
It very much does, because if you're not considering sightlines or elevation, then your gunpowder armies are useless.
Not to mention that there are serious elevation buffs, units that have a height differential above their enemies get a massive damage buff to their ranged or even melee attacks, and a damage reduction in turn.
Have you got prior experience with Total War games? Warhammer 3 isn't the easiest game for a noob to the genre, especially given the far less simple archetypes for units, let alone magic.
I'm a big fan of the series, the very concept of merging Warhammer Fantasy and Total War is one of those chef's kiss things that tells me that we're capable of occasionally picking up the low hanging fruit out there. There's nothing like desperately maneuvering your handful of normal human units and using all the fire power they possess to hold off a horde of Chaos forces that can rip them apart limb from limb.
If you only have W3, I suggest Cathay as a starting faction. The concept of their units is simple and recognizable, and it'll teach you to use infantry to screen, how to position ranged units, the application of cav and so on.
I'd also highly recommend the SFO mod, can't play without it, it makes the battles and campaign so much more fun.
Even local elites are so much faster than me that nothing I can do is going to make me remotely competitive with them.
Have you considered a car? /s
God made some shank's ponies faster than the others, Henry Ford ran them off the road.
There's definitely a selection effect of being the offspring of parents who relegate their kids to being wards of the state, and don't have family who can raise them.
Stop making my sworn enemies seem reasonable, you're doing far too good a job at it!
shakes fist
I think this is a satisfactory explanation, so thank you for suggesting it.
Yes, I understand that, but most people who want kids don't have that issue.
I took what you previously said as implying that people who opt for sperm donors don't want kids, which may have been a misunderstanding on my part.
Absent that specific procedure, the woman with a burning desire to have kids could easily find a different mate to get it done, considering how common it is for people to swap partners these days.
Are you encouraging women to leave their husbands because they're infertile? I mean, I personally think that's an entirely understandable if uncomfortable reason, but the women are presumably finding a new "mate" in the form of the donor, without having to break monogamy with the man they know and love.
AI individual tutoring will work for the kids who want to learn. For the kids who can't, and especially the ones who don't want to learn, it'll be no more use than anything else. The kid who five minutes into the class starts throwing chairs around, either because of psychological problems or because he's a budding criminal, how is AI going to deal with that?
Taps sign: "Don't let the perfect become the enemy of the good (or at least better)"
Existing, presumably 100% real human (not that they act like it) US teachers are largely powerless in the same situation, correct me if I'm wrong, but they don't even have the leeway to kick the little shit out of class, let alone rap them on the knuckles. This is the same line of thinking that prevents gifted students from entering fast track programs, because imagine the plight of those left behind!
So if helps those who can be helped, while not really making things worse for those who can't be fixed short of a good caning, what's there to lose?
There are plenty of intermediate situations between purely human teachers and purely artificial ones, you could simply have the electronics that each kid has come loaded with the AI so they can ask it questions, during class or after, about things they couldn't quite get. Or have it tell the human teacher where the kid is struggling.
I think GPT-4 is a better tutor than the average human teacher, certainly if given a curriculum to follow and metrics to track, but even if it's worse, it seems to be clearly additive to the capabilities of having the human around while not costing much.
That's close enough to an apology for me, while we certainly have our disagreements or outright arguments, you're not remotely as intolerable as some I could name here, heh.
The presumption, which I think is highly justified in reality, is that if someone went to the trouble of explicitly stating an act is allowed during a particular period of time/place/whatever, that implies that it's not allowed or at least discouraged outside of those specific circumstances.
Rules are not necessarily adhered to 100% of the time, in the hospital from which I'm shit posting, there is a rule regarding the timings when visitors are allowed, the typical person coming outside of that will be turned away, but if you're connected or have an important reason, you'll be let through. That does not invalidate the general principle that visitors aren't allowed outside the allotted time.
It might well be that the security guard was napping and didn't notice, but that doesn't mean there isn't a rule, in the same manner that successfully launching a heist on Fort Knox isn't proof that stealing is legal.
You're welcome, after learning the explanation a while back, my furious urge to genocide anyone who uses it casually has been tempered to mere homicide of the unrepentant, since there's a small chance they're using it the original sense. A very small chance indeed :(
It doesn't, but if part of the implicit reasoning behind suspecting that might be so is the disproportionate success of gay men in certain fields, that's at least some Bayes Points knocked off, given that a more prosaic explanation like what we have in mind would explain the disparity.
Apparently according to Google's web scraper, has somewhere behind the paywall a claim going:
Rahman et al. (Reference Rahman, Bhanot, Emrith-Small, Ghafoor and Robertsin press) show that there are no statistically significant differences in estimated full-scale IQ among straight men, straight women and gay men.
Which is what I would personally expect.
If someone wants to go to the trouble of finding the actual paper on Sci hub, I'm curious to know more, but I'm at the hospital with more pressing concerns right now.
Edit:
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21331499/
Claims:
The present study explored whether there were relationships among gender nonconformity, intelligence, and sexual orientation. A total of 106 heterosexual men, 115 heterosexual women, and 103 gay men completed measures of demographic variables, recalled childhood gender nonconformity (CGN), and the National Adult Reading Test (NART). NART error scores were used to estimate Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS) Full-Scale IQ (FSIQ) and Verbal IQ (VIQ) scores. Gay men had significantly fewer NART errors than heterosexual men and women (controlling for years of education). In heterosexual men, correlational analysis revealed significant associations between CGN, NART, and FSIQ scores (elevated boyhood femininity correlated with higher IQ scores). In heterosexual women, the direction of the correlations between CGN and all IQ scores was reversed (elevated girlhood femininity correlating with lower IQ scores). There were no significant correlations among these variables in gay men. These data may indicate a "sexuality-specific" effect on general cognitive ability but with limitations. They also support growing evidence that quantitative measures of sex-atypicality are useful in the study of trait sexual orientation.
Which I am too sleep deprived to interpret.
While the data isn't quite the same as what you claim, the figures are higher than I expected myself. Thank you for providing them.
Post sexual revolution, women choose single motherhood over being a 30th-percentile man's first wife, so I don't think they will be lining up to be a median-quality man's second wife either.
Citation needed. Most 30th percentile men end up paired off with 30th percentile woman, regardless of whether or not they marry. Single motherhood is by no means the choice of a majority of women in any place I'm aware of.
Gay people have feminine interests, well at least more feminine than straight men. Ergo they'll be overrepresented in fashion, drama and the like, and thus also more likely to hold higher ranking positions therein.
I, at the very least, don't see any glaring discrepancies in a more general consideration of public intellectuals, if we're trading anecdotes.
It might just be that the effect is bullshit and there is nothing to salvage.
Within the range of intelligence in the kind of people usually recruited for such psychometric studies? Probably.
But lower than that? I think someone with an IQ of say 60, in the retarded category, simply doesn't know how bad they are. It seems to me that that kind of general awareness of relative competence arises somewhere, even if most humans are past it.
I have also met exceptions, of course, but perhaps they prove the rule.
My BP just shot up 20mm of mercury after hearing that phrase haha. Exceptions cannot prove the rule. They do the very opposite, at least in the sense most people use the phrase!
The origin of it, which is far more reasonable, is along the lines of seeing a sign saying "visiting hours 3-5 pm" at a hospital, from which we can glean that visiting isn't allowed outside this window. Thus the existence of an "exception" carved out from a general rule suggests the existence of said rule in a broad sense, but you're not using it that way :(
This is the hill I choose to die on, I'm digging trenches and planting mines as we speak.
The Dunning-Kruger effect is autocorrelation
Huh. I can only apologize for the relatively bare link, but I feel like it's worth drawing attention to something so widely accepted yet utterly worthless, especially when it comes up so often here.
The thing about the DK effect is that it makes intuitive sense. To extend it past the realm of typical human intelligence, an ant or a chimp isn't very good at knowing how dumb they are because they're not very good at most things. However, I suspect that the average dumb (human) person does know they're a bit dim, so it confuses me how this finding can even arise.
The problem with the Dunning-Kruger chart is that it violates a fundamental principle in statistics. If you’re going to correlate two sets of data, they must be measured independently. In the Dunning-Kruger chart, this principle gets violated. The chart mixes test score into both axes, giving rise to autocorrelation.
Realizing this mistake, Edward Nuhfer and colleagues asked an interesting question: what happens to the Dunning-Kruger effect if it is measured in a way that is statistically valid? According to Nuhfer’s evidence, the answer is that the effect disappears.
Is it possible to salvage a non-trivial version of the DKE? The one we know and once loved literally works for random data, so that's right out. In other words, what's the cut-off where a stupid person becomes smart enough to know they're stupid, or at least worse than their peers?*
*In a more general sense than a chimp knowing he's not as strong or big as the alpha male.

From a pretty significant amount of observational experience, there's little chance that obesity can account for most or even much of the reduced amount of sex, at least via inducing ED.
More options
Context Copy link