@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

By pidgin do they mean the annoying tendency of the NZ government to sprinkle in Maori words in press releases?

People with an interest in parenting don't need to buy sperm in most cases.

I strongly disagree, and believe me that if I'm not a gyno myself, I would know better.

The typical reason for seeking donor sperm is male infertility in a normal couple, in other words they want kids yet find out they can't have them, biologically related to the man at the least.

It's also prima facie ridiculous if you even think for a minute, of course people seeking donated sperm want a family, what else are they supposed to do with it, organize bukkake parties?

No, in some kind of refrigerated device.

I would be very concerned if "he" laid eggs anywhere really. But it's the 21st century, who am I to assume pronouns?

So you care about the future state of fertility out of care for your descendants but you don't care enough to actually help raise them?

He isn't laying eggs out in the wilderness, presumably the people who opt to take sperms from donors are above average in terms of dedication and interest in parenting, certainly in wealth.

I manage to use ad-block and root my phone, I think I'll manage, can't make promises about the rest of you!

You would hardly be the first or last person to make that observation on the discrepancy between pure demographics and advertising, be it here on the Motte or elsewhere. That's not the same thing as this being false, it's obviously true for anyone who has eyes, but it's been debated ad-nauseum here.

Thankfully my diligent use of ad-block prevents such visual and auditory pollution from entering my sensoria, most of the time. That's ads themselves, regardless of content. May the day come soon when AR filters get rid of them from my perception of non-digital reality.

I hear a lot of accounts on twitter of people who WANT their doctors to start giving them some of the more out-there suggestions for therapies or drugs or procedures that could fix [problem] but get frustrated because they have to navigate the standard process first and most doctors won't deviate from the script much, even when asked nicely. Some people resort to homebrews out of frustration, even.

One of the under-appreciated perks of being a doctor is that, when you go see a doctor, they're far more likely to indulge such concerns.

For example, UK guidelines for contraception, which are also used in India, mildly frown on using IUDs in nulliparous women who want a family down the line. Yet when my girl and I went to see a gyno, we were able to convince her to approve and insert one, since I could convincingly argue that despite it being UKMEC 2 (meaning it works, doesn't do any harm, but is ~overall held to not be the best choice for that demographic, which would be UKMEC 1 like OCPs or implants), we know what we were getting into. Or various psychiatric consults I've had to do myself.

I'm sure the same is true for lawyers consulting lawyers in other niches, or mechanics seeing mechanics and so on. You get a sense of palpable relief from knowing that you don't have to rehash the basics.

Sadly short of having a medical degree or experience in an allied field, there are few signals, costly or otherwise, that declare the same thing to a doctor who has to also consider the deficit in both knowledge and common sense in the average patient. I certainly wish it were otherwise, or that there was something like a short questionnaire or form you could fill out to declare yourself the equivalent of a sophisticated investor in medicine, who is willing to step outside the norm without crying about it later if it fails.

Do me a favor, while I'm perfectly happy addressing your points, the amount of effort it would take exceeds what I'm willing to do for the sake of just one person or the handful who are reading week old threads this deep, so I suggest you make a new top-level post on the new thread, where I will happily continue the debate.

I'll check back shortly after I'm done studying, you're welcome to either link or post excerpts from my comments or summarize them as you see fit, I see no particular reason to think you'd twist them in bad faith.

If you want, I can do the same myself, but like I said, I really should be studying, if only till the Ritalin wears off haha.

I've heard on the ACX discord that he's been doing this for years, and he's banned there too.

Also probably true, but I'll also say that if we have LLMs that are reliably able to spot and correct actual falsehoods we're probably in a world that is a little epistemically safer for the average person than our current one.

Entirely dependent on your standards for "reliability" in my eyes. I have found SOTA models adequate for that purpose in almost everything I've cared to try, and I have checked to see whether they were providing corrections that had a basis in objective fact. It's not perfect, but I say we're past "good enough" to catch anything the teacher says that they already expect diligent students to notice.

I broadly agree with the rest of your comment, I'm happy to defer to Scott for most things, even if I do disagree with certain things he's said, and there are certainly plenty of crime-thinkers on Twitter I follow because I trust them to give me information that's both true and suppressed because it's outside the general Overton Window.

If, say, we had an aligned AGI that proved itself to be smarter and more capable in terms of answering questions I had of it, including taking into account my values where relevant, I'd have few qualms about eventually handing over my decision making to it. But if I had a route to improving my own cognition to the point where I didn't need it, being able to match it myself, I'd prefer that.

Yes, but you're assuming there's a lot more even more dangerous things "out there" for a smarter entity to discover.

I repeat that, while I think this is true, it's still not necessary for a genius AI to be an existential risk. I've already explained why multiple times.

Nukes? They exist.

Pandemics? They exist. Can they be made more dangerous? Yes. Are humans already making them more dangerous for no good reason? Yes.

Automation? Well underway.

Our first day of Physics lab classes at Caltech, the instructor told us that it doesn't matter how many digits of pi we'd all memorized (quite a bunch), just use 3.14, or a scientific calculator's pi key, whichever was faster, because any rounding error would be swamped out by the measurement error in our instruments.

When it comes to modeling the physical world, sure, going from knowing, say, Planck's constant to two decimal places to knowing it to three decimal places will probably net you a bunch of improvements. But then going from, say, ten decimal places to eleven, or even ten decimal places to twenty, almost certainly won't net the same level of improvement.

I do not think that the benefits of additional intelligence as seen even in human physicists is well addressed by this analogy. The relevant one would be comparing Newtonian physics to GR, and then QM. In the domains where such nuance becomes relevant, the benefits are grossly superior.

For starters, while the Standard Model is great, it still isn't capable of conclusively explaining most of the mass or energy in the universe. Not to mention that even if we have equations for the fundamental processes, there are bazillions of higher-order concerns that are intractable to simulate from first-principles.

AlphaFold didn't massively outpace SOTA on protein folding by using QM on a molecule by molecule basis. It found smarter heuristics, that's also something intelligence is indispensable for. I see no reason why a human can't be perfectly modeled using QM, it is simply a computationally intractable problem even for a single cell within us.

In other words, knowing the underling rules of a complex system != knowing all the potential implications or applications. You can't just memorize the rules of Chess and then declare it's a solved problem.

That it's unsupported extrapolation to reason 'smart=nukes, therefore super-smart=super-nukes and mega-smart=mega-nukes.'

I'm sure there people who might make such a claim. I'm not one of them, and like I said, it's not load bearing. Just nukes is sufficient really. Certainly in combination with automation so the absence of those pesky humans running the machines isn't a problem.

I want you to at least consider, just for a moment, the idea that maybe we humans, with our "1.4 kg brain[s] in a small cranium," may have a good enough understanding of reality, and of each other, that a being with "900 more IQ points" won't find much room to improve on it.

I have considered it, at least to my satisfaction, and I consider it to be exceedingly unlikely. Increases in intelligence, even within the minuscule absolute variation seen within humans, is enormously powerful. There seems to be little to nothing in the way of further scaling in the context of inhuman entities that are not constrained by the same biological limitations in size, volume, speed or energy. They already match or exceed the average human in most cognitive tasks, and even if returns from further increases in intelligence diminish grossly or become asymptotic, I am the furthest from convinced that stage will be reached within spitting distance of the best of humanity, or that such an entity won't be enormously powerful and capable of exterminating us if it wishes to do so.

That's not a bad thing, if we can be sure the AI isn't going to hallucinate "this author wrote this poem" (no they didn't) or that the word "potato" contains the letter "b".

You studiously refrain from even using any LLM, so take it from me that hallucinations aren't a debilitating problem, and presumably teachers are going to check their students work in the first place. I don't deny it's an issue, but every new and improved model suffers from it less and less, and I don't think even you can claim that every statement made by a human teacher in class can be accepted as gospel truth.

They're already anal enough about not considering Wikipedia a "source", leaving aside it comes with its own citations for claims.

But the major problem is the same one bedeviling conventional education today - kids who want to learn will, be that teacher, homeschooling, or AI. Kids who don't want to, won't. Johnny playing on his phone instead of listening to the fun! interactive! personal tutor! AI is not going to learn. And how do you make Johnny pay attention?

This isn't a problem that can be entirely solved today, far from it. But an AI had the benefits of having much more leeway in organizing a tailored curriculum, assessing mastery, rephrasing or reformulating knowledge and so on than a harassed teacher grappling with a class of 30 students.

Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the better and all that jazz.

No, that was 'high decoupling consideration of hypotheticals'. I wasn't saying you, self_made_human, was a goat-fucker, I was saying hypothetical general you who may want to defend goat-fucking.

Uh huh..

https://www.themotte.org/post/760/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/159366?context=8#context

Your notion of entertaining hypotheticals seems to be "agree with them". 'Oh, you don't like that proposal, you disagree with it? You're a low decoupler who's too stupid to be able to think abstractly'. That seems to be your go-to position.

Listen, you want to fuck goats? That's your thing, but don't try and get around objections with "Why are people so mean to me about goat-fucking, it must be because they're all too stupid to think outside of conventional notions".

You had plenty of opportunities to state that when I told you I had no desire to fuck goats, or either brand of "kid", but such a considered, nuanced intent was lacking.

At any rate, it's water under the bridge, you took your lumps.

Explicit reasoning, especially on Bayesian lines, isn't necessary 99% of the time, in the sense that crunching the numbers will provide an increase in value greater than the time/opportunity cost spent doing it. This is because humans are probably fundamentally Bayesian in their reasoning, according to the predictive processing theory of cognition.

This ceases to be true in certain important edge cases, where people devote far too little thought or rigor to important decisions like say, buying or renting a house, or what insurance to get and so on. Hard numbers and research will almost certainly beat going off vibes, at least in terms of dollars per hour of effort.

One thing I like about this particular aphorism is that there's a meta lesson. "Think Horses, not Zebras... unless you happen to be in a location where Zebras are more common." If you happen to be in Eastern Africa, for instance.

Another reason to teach explicit Bayesianism, because that takeaway comes with it!

Plenty of tests reveal the equivalent of a news reel going "authorities report an escape of 22 zebras from the local zoo after the paddock was left open", or your neighbor swearing some of those ill-tempered horses had stripes on them.

There's also the risk-aversion that comes when you can be sued for malpractice if you do anything other than give the most common and accepted advice.

Malpractice claims are still thankfully a rarety in India, but I suppose you can still mitigate most of the risk by providing both the "recommended" advice as well as your particular suggestions and leave it to the patient to choose, assuming you document this well. There's nothing much stopping a pissed-off patient litigating against you really, not if they want to.

I do suspect that most US doctors are more risk-averse than necessary, but teaching them Bayesianism would help them figure out the optimal course of action for their particular risk tolerance.

It'd be interesting, for example, if teachers explicitly told students that they'd be slipping occasional falsehoods into the lessons and teaching them as true, and that there were extra credit available to anyone who not only could identify the falsehoods, but explain exactly how they figured out it was false.

I'd say that's a good idea, and what should have been done, but these days what will happen is that someone will copy paste lecture transcripts into an LLM and have it find the error and explain it lol. I suppose that does still deserve points for diligence.

I recall a professor back in med school who did do that, and I'm particularly proud of catching several of the bugs myself, even if I suspect a handful were simply him misspeaking from memory instead of being intentional heh.

Actually, medicine might be a bad idea for such tricks, plenty of things are outright counter-intuitive or edge-cases where we need to memorize where the heuristics fail. If you try this before the students have a good fundamental underpinning of theory and some practise, they might well never figure out where they went astray unless they crack out a textbook and pour over every claim.

At least Germany has a pragmatic approach to things, those who can't crack the requirements for a typical white collar job that needs college are put on a different track far earlier in schooling, or simply can opt for that if they feel like it.

I have never claimed it can convince anyone of literally anything. We've already had plenty of nuclear close-calls simply because of the fog of war or human/technical error.

Similarly, there are already >0 misanthropically omnicidal people around and kicking, and an AI could empower them to pursue their goals, or they might choose to adopt the AI for that purpose.

Mere humans, or human-run orgs like the CIA have long engineered regime change, it seems to me incredibly unlikely, to the point it can be outright dismissed from consideration, that an AGI only modestly higher in intelligence couldn't do the same, and even independently play multiple sides against each other until they all make terrible decisions.

Besides, it's clear that nobody even tries the Yudkowskian boxing approach these days. ARC evals, red-teaming and the like are nowhere close to the maximally paranoid approach, not even for SOTA models.

A group of say, 160 IQ humans with laser-focus and an elimination of many/most of the coordination and trust bottlenecks we face could well become an existential threat. Even a modestly superintelligent or merely genius level AGI can do that and more.

Education reform is, at least to me, one of the many things I no longer get particularly worked up about because even if the world's most optimized, ideal and effective curriculum (for any purpose) was introduced today, it would likely have a minimal effect on anything.

This is both because of AI, as you noted yourself, and because the main bottleneck is intelligence, especially combined with diligence. There are a few scalable ways to provide better educational outcomes, for example, we know that one-on-one tutoring is by far the most effective didactic method, yet it remains cost-prohibitive for public deployment.

Firstly, I don't expect a student entering pre-school or even middle-school today will ever be employable on the basis of what they learn in school, so at that point the debate looks to me more like an argument about what general knowledge and ethics are good to have in the citizenry, or more like an idle classical education for the purposes of being a well-rounded and erudite person, not someone who has to think for a living.

However, it's AI that promises a temporary flourishing of personalized tutoring. For a brief period in time, we have cheap, scalable models that are better in almost every way than the average school teacher available for personalized 1:1 tutoring for every kid alive. I certainly make full use of it to learn things, and will continue doing so after it makes me obsolete, because I enjoy learning.

Something that has always ticked me off about the medical curriculum, and which is likely a global problem, is that while doctors are occasionally trained to consider potential applications of Bayesian reasoning, we're not taught it explicitly.

So we're told, "if you hear hooves, think horses, not zebras" in the context of always considering the most common potential causes for a presentation, or confronted with questions like X disease has a prevalence of Y%, test A has a sensitivity B and specificity C, given a positive test result, what are the odds that the person testing positive actually has the disease and so on.

But the generalized thought process? Not a fucking peep.

And there's no reason that people should even enter med school without knowing Bayes' theorem, the math isn't even complicated.

Without knowing more about your career, I can't really comment, but it seems to me you're doing the right things, at least in terms of jumping jobs for a pay raise.

If possible, try and become friends with your colleagues, at the very least they'll likely have wives or girlfriends, and women love setting up eligible singles, unless all your coworkers are in the same boat I suppose.

A deep dive into the feasibility of Drexlerian nanotechnology. I haven't had the time to read much fiction, or even work on my novel, if anyone noticed heh.

God knows this blog post is long enough to be a novella at the very least

I do feel for you, I really do. Even as a man who has had decent success with the ladies, every time I see someone involuntarily celebate, I think "there but for the grace of God go I". If I was short, less funny or not a doctor or.. a dozen other things that could have been counterfactually true while still preserving the core of my personality. I certainly spent at least 18 years of my life in severe sexual and romantic frustration, and if I do end up single again, I don't look forward to the headache that is modern dating in the West.

(Please don't think I'm calling you an incel, heavens no, the difficulty most men face in getting a date compared to the average woman makes intra-group differences minuscule)

The problem is well, there are no easy solutions. Most things that make it easy for men to date are innate, or the result of innate tendencies, such as being smart enough to get into a high paying job.

Do you think your professional misfortunes are reversible? Are you at least on track to make your money? Are you fit and manage to dress well?

Bad? Compared to your entire life? Not at all.

But compared to either:

  1. Being in schooling, where you have state-sanctioned proximity to young and attractive people of the other gender, very few people in your peer group having become so utterly superior to you in terms of credentials.

  2. Being well-established in a career where you're gaining points for being wealthy/successful/put-together, in other words having said credentials.

It's a bit worse.

1 happens to be the biggest hurdle for the average person asking for relationship advice here, they're usually nerdy, shy or introverted, and often are in a stream where women are rare. But they usually get a big benefit from 2, where being successful makes them attractive again.

Being a recent graduate who just got a decent job, still has an active friends circle from college or uni and hasn't aged out of hangouts or events where the denizens of the latter exist is far from the worst place to be.

That's what moderation is for.

The Motte is past the size where mods can be expected to read every single comment. At most they can respond to reports, and even then there's usually a lag time of hours involved. I also personally don't expect the mods to commit themselves to sitting down and personally addressing every bad argument that gets deposited here like a turd on a doorstep.

I don't understand what your second point is saying.

Sometimes a comment is such utter bullshit that accurately/vividly calling it out as the bullshit it is can stray past the threshold where the reply itself violates the rules here. And that's leaving aside the emotive states where you're tempted to leave something more minimally inflammatory than theoretically possible, at which point just downvoting and moving on is better for you and the forum.

Don't ask me how I know the latter.

I get bans because a mod said so

As opposed to a random user banning you? If that's happening the code base inherited from rdrama must be more interesting than I thought.

somebody went running to teacher to complain

I wonder how much bearing that has on whether the complaint was valid. Certainly the gangsters or mafiosos declaring "snitches get stitches" aren't saying so because of their wounded pride from being falsely accused. You did call me a goat-fucker lol.

I do wonder what a system entirely run off user reports might look like, plenty of social media platforms, Reddit and Facebook/Insta included, have that to a degree where a sufficient number of user reports gets things auto-removed. They still have humans in the loop somewhere even if they don't act in every case. Not that I expect this to be a good idea, or work very well if at all, l just want to see novel forms of dysfunction at times!